Timing and mechanisms of mesodermal and neural determination revealed by secondary embryo formation in Cynops and Xenopus

We examined the timing and mechanisms of mesodermal and neural determination in Cynops , using the secondary embryo induced by transplantation of the prechordal endomesoderm. Two unique approaches were used: one was to observe gastrulation movements induced by the graft, and the other to measure the volumes of formed tissues. Transplanted graft pulled host animal cap cells inside to form a new notochord and other mesoderm of the secondary embryo, showing determination of mesoderm during gastrulation. The graft attained a certain width beneath the host ectoderm and moved near to the animal pole of the host by late gastrula, and a neural plate, which had a similar width to the graft, was formed covering the graft. The volume of neural tissues of the secondary embryo at tail-bud stages was about half that of the normal embryo, while the volumes of notochord were comparable in each case. These data suggest that prechordal endomesoderm, rather than notochord, determines the limit of neural plate in the overlying ectoderm. Similar dorsal grafts were transplanted at early gastrula in Xenopus but did not form well developed secondary embryos, demonstrating that the timing and mechanisms of mesoderm formation in Xenopus are different from those in Cynops .     

Early neurogenesis in Amniote vertebrates

Labelling of Hensen's node in a 6-somite stage chick embryo by the quail/chick chimera method has revealed that, while moving caudalwards as the embryo elongates, the node leaves in its wake not only the notochord but also the floor plate and a longitudinal strand of dorsal endoderm. The node itself contains cells endowed with the capacity to yield midline cells (i.e. notochord and floor plate) along the whole length of the neural axis. Caudal node cells function as stem cells. They are responsible for the apical growth of the cord of cells that are at the origin of the midline structures since, if removed, neither the notochord nor the floor plate, are formed caudally to the ablation. The embryo extends however in the absence of midline cells and a neural tube develops posterior to the excision. Only dorsal molecular markers are detectable on this neural tube (e.g. Pax3 and Slug). The posterior region of the embryo in which the structures secreting Shh are missing undergo cell death within the 24 to 48 hours following its formation. Unpublished results indicate that rescue of the posterior region of the embryo can be obtained by implantation of Shh secreting cells. One of the critical roles of floor plate and notochord is therefore to inhibit the cell death programme in the axial and paraxial structures of the embryo at gastrulation and neurulation stages.     

Impact of node ablation on the morphogenesis of the body axis and the lateral asymmetry of the mouse embryo during early organogenesis.

The node of the mouse gastrula is the major source of the progenitor cells of the notochord, the floor plate, and the gut endoderm. The node may also play a morphogenetic role since it can induce a partial body axis following heterotopic transplantation. The impact of losing these progenitor cells and the morphogenetic activity on the development of the body axes was studied by the ablation of the node at late gastrulation. In the ablated embryo, an apparently intact anterior-posterior body axis with morphologically normal head folds, neural tube, and primitive streak developed during early organogenesis. Cell fate analysis revealed that the loss of the node elicits de novo recruitment of neural ectoderm and somitic mesoderm from the surrounding germ-layer tissues. This leads to the restoration of the neural tube and the paraxial mesoderm. However, the body axis of the embryo was foreshortened and somite formation was retarded. Histological and gene expression studies reveal that in most of the node-ablated embryos, the notochord in the trunk was either absent or interrupted, and the floor plate was absent in the ventral region of the reconstituted neural tube. The loss of the node did not affect the differentiation of the gut endoderm or the formation of the mid- and hindgut. In the node-ablated embryo, expression of the Pitx2 gene in the lateral plate mesoderm was no longer restricted to the left side but was found on both sides of the body or was completely absent from the lateral plate mesoderm. Therefore, the loss of the node results in the failure to delineate the laterality of the body axis. The node and its derivatives therefore play a critical role in the patterning of the ventral neural tube and lateral body axis but not of the anterior-posterior axis during early organogenesis.     

Development of chick axial mesoderm: specification of prechordal mesoderm by anterior endoderm-derived TGFbeta family signalling

Two populations of axial mesoderm cells can be recognised in the chick embryo, posterior notochord and anterior prechordal mesoderm. We have examined the cellular and molecular events that govern the specification of prechordal mesoderm. We report that notochord and prechordal mesoderm cells are intermingled and share expression of many markers as they initially extend out of Hensen's node. In vitro culture studies, together with in vivo grafting experiments, reveal that early extending axial mesoderm cells are labile and that their character may be defined subsequently through signals that derive from anterior endodermal tissues. Anterior endoderm elicits aspects of prechordal mesoderm identity in extending axial mesoderm by repressing notochord characteristics, briefly maintaining gsc expression and inducing BMP7 expression. Together these experiments suggest that, in vivo, signalling by anterior endoderm may determine the extent of prechordal mesoderm. The transforming growth factor (beta) (TGFbeta) superfamily members BMP2, BMP4, BMP7 and activin, all of which are transiently expressed in anterior endoderm mimic distinct aspects of its patterning actions. Together our results suggest that anterior endoderm-derived TGFbetas may specify prechordal mesoderm character in chick axial mesoderm.     

INTER AND INTRATISSUE COMMUNICATION DURING AMPHIBIAN DEVELOPMENT*

The changes of electrical communication between various tissues of the newt (Cynops pyrrhogaster) embryo during development have been investigated by measuring electrotonic potentials at various interelectrode distances. In general, cells of the same tissue are electrically coupled from gastrulation up to closure of the neural tube. Notochordal cells, however, are an exception in that cell coupling decreases during stages 22–23 in comparison to earlier stages. Neuroectoderm cells are coupled to adjacent chorda-mesoderm cells during the initial stages of gastrulation (st. 12c). Subsequently coupling of these tissues diminishes (st. 15–16) and finally disappears (st. 22–23). The similar decrease of coupling was observed in inter-tissues of the chorda-mesoderm cells and the somitic mesoderm cells during the mesodermal differentiation. In contrast, coupling values of less than 0.1 recorded between somite cells and cells of the neural tube or epidermis still remain at st. 22–23. The neural plate cells remain coupled to the lateral ectoderm cells at st. 18 and then become insulated from the epidermis by st. 22–23, even though a coupling ratio of 0.1 remains between these tissues. These developmental patterns of coupling are discussed with respect to cellular movements of neuroectoderm and mesoderm during gastrulation, and with special reference to neural competence.     

Asymmetric expression of antivin/lefty1 in the early chick embryo

Mammalian lefty and zebrafish antivin, highly related to lefty, are shown to be expressed asymmetrically and involved in the specification of the left body side of early embryos. We isolated a chick homologue of the antivin/lefty1 cDNA and studied its expression pattern during early chick development. We found that antivin/lefty1 is expressed asymmetrically on the left side of the prospective floorplate, notochord and lateral plate mesoderm of the chick embryo.     

Distinct modes of floor plate induction in the chick embryo

To begin to reconcile models of floor plate formation in the vertebrate neural tube, we have performed experiments aimed at understanding the development of the early floor plate in the chick embryo. Using real-time analyses of cell behaviour, we provide evidence that the principal contributor to the early neural midline, the future anterior floor plate, exists as a separate population of floor plate precursor cells in the epiblast of the gastrula stage embryo, and does not share a lineage with axial mesoderm. Analysis of the tissue interactions associated with differentiation of these cells to a floor plate fate reveals a role for the nascent prechordal mesoderm, indicating that more than one inductive event is associated with floor plate formation along the length of the neuraxis. We show that Nr1, a chick nodal homologue, is expressed in the nascent prechordal mesoderm and we provide evidence that Nodal signalling can cooperate with Shh to induce the epiblast precursors to a floor-plate fate. These results indicate that a shared lineage with axial mesoderm cells is not a pre-requisite for floor plate differentiation and suggest parallels between the development of the floor plate in amniote and anamniote embryos.     

Role of morphogens in brain growth

During the last century, experiments on the chick embryo established that the ballooning expansion of the early forebrain and midbrain vesicles is dependent on the underlying axial (notochordal) mesoderm. Transient separation of the early midbrain primordium from the notochord causes subsequent collapse of both midbrain and forebrain (telencephalic) vesicles, accompanied by pronounced folding of the neural epithelium. More recent experiments have shown that vesicle collapse is caused by defective Sonic Hedgehog (Shh) signaling from the notochord and floor plate. Separation of the notochord from the brain causes loss of ventral Shh expression, resulting in reduced cell proliferation and increased cell death in the expanding neural epithelium, and culminating in vesicle collapse. These experiments are reviewed here, and set in the context of other studies illustrating the wide range of molecular and cellular processes that cause abnormal brain morphogenesis when perturbed. We also speculate that variation in the regulation of signaling pathways such as Hedgehog may have played a significant part in generating rapid morphogenetic changes during the evolution of the vertebrate brain.     

Positive and Negative Regulation of the Differentiation of Ventral Mesoderm for Erythrocytes in Xenopus laevis

To elucidate the mechanism of determination and regulation of hemopoiesis in the early Xenopus embryo, explants of dorsal and ventral mesoderm from various stage embryos were cultured alone or combined with various tissues derived from the same stage embryo. Western blot analysis of larvae-specific globin expression using monoclonal antibody L5.41 revealed that extensive erythropoiesis occurred in the explants of ventral mesoderm from st. 22 tailbud embryo, but not in those of dorsal mesoderm. Experiments using combined explants at this stage demonstrated that the in vitro differentiation of erythrocytes in the ventral mesoderm could be completely inhibited by the dorsal tissue, including neural tube, notochord, and somite mesoderm, but not by other mesoderms, gut endoderm, or forebrain. Subsequent explant studies showed that the notochord alone is sufficient for this inhibition. Furthermore, the ventral mesoderm explant from the st. 10⁺ early gastrula embryo was not able to differentiate into erythroid cells. However, small amounts of globin were expressed if ventral mesoderm of this stage was combined with animal pole cells which were mainly differentiated to epidermis. This stimulation was enhanced when both tissues were excised together without separation, while none of the other parts of st. 10⁺ embryo had this stimulatory effect. These observations found in the combined explants suggest that in vivo interactions between the ventral mesoderm and adjacent tissues are important for normal development of erythroid precursor cells.     

Anti-apoptotic role of Sonic hedgehog protein at the early stages of nervous system organogenesis

In vertebrates the neural tube, like most of the embryonic organs, shows discreet areas of programmed cell death at several stages during development. In the chick embryo, cell death is dramatically increased in the developing nervous system and other tissues when the midline cells, notochord and floor plate, are prevented from forming by excision of the axial-paraxial hinge (APH), i.e. caudal Hensen's node and rostral primitive streak, at the 6-somite stage ( Charrier, J. B., Teillet, M.-A., Lapointe, F. and Le Douarin, N. M. (1999). Development 126, 4771-4783). In this paper we demonstrate that one day after APH excision, when dramatic apoptosis is already present in the neural tube, the latter can be rescued from death by grafting a notochord or a floor plate fragment in its vicinity. The neural tube can also be recovered by transplanting it into a stage-matched chick embryo having one of these structures. In addition, cells engineered to produce Sonic hedgehog protein (SHH) can mimic the effect of the notochord and floor plate cells in in situ grafts and transplantation experiments. SHH can thus counteract a built-in cell death program and thereby contribute to organ morphogenesis, in particular in the central nervous system.     

Apoptosis regulates notochord development in Xenopus

The notochord is the defining characteristic of the chordate embryo and plays critical roles as a signaling center and as the primitive skeleton. In this study we show that early notochord development in Xenopus embryos is regulated by apoptosis. We find apoptotic cells in the notochord beginning at the neural groove stage and increasing in number as the embryo develops. These dying cells are distributed in an anterior to posterior pattern that is correlated with notochord extension through vacuolization. In axial mesoderm explants, inhibition of this apoptosis causes the length of the notochord to approximately double compared to controls. In embryos, however, inhibition of apoptosis decreases the length of the notochord and it is severely kinked. This kinking also spreads from the anterior with developmental stage such that, by the tadpole stage, the notochord lacks any recognizable structure, although notochord markers are expressed in a normal temporal pattern. Extension of the somites and neural plate mirrors that of the notochord in these embryos, and the somites are severely disorganized. These data indicate that apoptosis is required for normal notochord development during the formation of the anterior-posterior axis, and its role in this process is discussed.     

An early marker of axial pattern in the chick embryo and its respecification by retinoic acid.

Chick Ghox 2.9 protein, a homeodomain-containing polypeptide, is first detected in the mid-gastrula stage embryo and its levels increase rapidly in the late gastrula. At this time, the initially narrow band of expression along the primitive streak expands laterally to form a shield-like domain that encompasses almost the entire posterior region of the embryo and extends anteriorly as far as Hensen's node. We have found that this expression domain co-localizes with a morphological feature that consists of a stratum of refractile, thickened mesoderm. Antibody-staining indicates that Ghox 2.9 protein is present in all cells of this mesodermal region. In contrast, expression within the ectoderm overlying the region of refractile mesoderm varies considerably. The highest levels of expression are found in ectoderm near the streak and surrounding Hensen's node, regions that recent fate mapping studies suggest that primarily destined to give rise to neurectoderm. At the definitive streak stage (Hamburger and Hamilton stage 4) the chick embryo is especially sensitive to the induction of axial malformations by retinoic acid. Four hours after the treatment of definitive streak embryos with a pulse of retinoic acid the expression of Ghox 2.9 protein is greatly elevated. This ectopic expression occurs in tissues anterior to Hensen's node, including floor plate, notochord, presumptive neural plate and lateral plate mesoderm, but does not occur in the anteriormost region of the embryo. The ectopic induction of Ghox 2.9 is strongest in ectoderm, and weaker in the underlying mesoderm. Endoderm throughout the embryo is unresponsive. At stage 11, Ghox 2.9 is normally expressed at high levels within rhombomere 4 of the developing hindbrain. In retinoic-acid-treated embryos which have developed to this stage, typical rhombomere boundaries are largely absent. Nevertheless, Ghox 2.9 is still expressed as a discrete band, but one that is widened and displaced to a more anterior position.     

Induction of an additional floor plate in the neural tube

The role of the notochord in the morphogenesis of the neural tube was investigated by implanting a notochord fragment laterally to the neural wall of a 1.5 day chick embryo. Embryos were sacrificed at 4 days. In the basal part of the neural tube an additional floor plate was induced in the vicinity of the implant. This floor plate was characterized by a low proliferative activity, a thin wall, spindle-like nuclei crowded peripherally and some neuroblast-like cells. It was either blending with the natural floor plate or separated from it, depending on the exact position of the implant. In the latter case neuroblasts were observed in between both floor plates. The additional floor plate was present only when the implanted notochord was less than 25 micron apart from the neural tube; at larger distance an increase of the ventral horn neuroblast area could be seen. It is concluded that the implanted notochord is able to induce a floor plate at 1.5 days of incubation. The specific influence of the notochord on the morphogenesis of the neural tube, its inductive period as well as the presence of the neuroblast-like cells in the additional floor plate are discussed.     

Cells remain competent to respond to mesoderm-inducing signals present during gastrulation in Xenopus laevis

During gastrulation, the vertebrate embryo is patterned and shaped by complex signaling pathways and morphogenetic movements. One of the first regions defined during gastrulation is the prospective notochord, which exhibits specific cell behaviors that drive the extension of the embryonic axis. To examine the signals involved in notochord formation in Xenopus laevis and the competence of cells to respond to these signals, we performed cell transplantation experiments during gastrulation. Labeled cells from the prospective notochord, somitic mesoderm, ventrolateral mesoderm, neural ectoderm, and epidermis, between stages 9 (pregastrulation) and 12 (late gastrulation), were grafted into the prospective notochord region of the early gastrula. We show that cells from each region are competent to respond to notochord-inducing signals and differentiate into notochordal tissue. Cells from the prospective neural ectoderm are the most responsive to notochord-inducing signals, whereas cells from the ventrolateral and epidermal regions are the least responsive. We show that at the end of gastrulation, while transplanted cells lose their competence to form notochord, they remain competent to form somites. These results demonstrate that at the end of gastrulation cell fates are not restricted within germ layers. To determine whether notochord-inducing signals are present throughout gastrulation, grafts were made into progressively older host embryos. We found that regardless of the age of the host, grafted cells from each region give rise to notochordal tissue. This indicates that notochord-inducing signals are present throughout gastrulation and that these signals overlap with somite-inducing signals at the end of gastrulation. We conclude that it is the change of competence that restricts cells to specific tissues rather than the regulation of the inducing signals.     

The organizer of the mouse gastrula is composed of a dynamic population of progenitor cells for the axial mesoderm

An organizer population has been identified in the anterior end of the primitive streak of the mid-streak stage embryo, by the expression of Hnf3beta, Gsc(lacZ) and Chrd, and the ability of these cells to induce a second neural axis in the host embryo. This cell population can therefore be regarded as the mid-gastrula organizer and, together with the early-gastrula organizer and the node, constitute the organizer of the mouse embryo at successive stages of development. The profile of genetic activity and the tissue contribution by cells in the organizer change during gastrulation, suggesting that the organizer may be populated by a succession of cell populations with different fates. Fine mapping of the epiblast in the posterior region of the early-streak stage embryo reveals that although the early-gastrula organizer contains cells that give rise to the axial mesoderm, the bulk of the progenitors of the head process and the notochord are localized outside the early gastrula organizer. In the mid-gastrula organizer, early gastrula organizer derived cells that are fated for the prechordal mesoderm are joined by the progenitors of the head process that are recruited from the epiblast previously anterior to the early gastrula organizer. Cells that are fated for the head process move anteriorly from the mid-gastrula organizer in a tight column along the midline of the embryo. Other mid-gastrula organizer cells join the expanding mesodermal layer and colonize the cranial and heart mesoderm. Progenitors of the trunk notochord that are localized in the anterior primitive streak of the mid-streak stage embryo are later incorporated into the node. The gastrula organizer is therefore composed of a constantly changing population of cells that are allocated to different parts of the axial mesoderm.     

Appearance and distribution of entactin in the early chick embryo

Abstract. Entactin is a sulfated glycoprotein of basement membranes and recent data indicate that it may play a major role in extracellular matrix (ECM) assembly and in modulating the activities of the other molecular components. We investigated the time of appearance and subsequent distribution of entactin during the earliest stages of morphogenesis and its involvement in the first major cellular migrations and interactions in the chick embryo. Entactin is first detected in the epiblast and in the hypoblast at the blastula stage. The accumulating ECM displays intense presence of entactin in the space between the epiblast and the hypoblast at late blastula. Entactin is increasingly abundant in the neural plate and in the ECM and also at least transiently in many mesodermal tissues such as the notochord, the developing heart and somites in the early chick embryo. Immunogold labeling revealed a punctate pattern of entactin distribution in the ECM during the gastrula, neurula and at later stages and at all levels within the embryo. Because of its early appearance in more than one germ layer, entactin may be important in the formation of most embryonic structures. Entactin is detected at the same developmental time and co-localizes with laminin. Antibodies to entactin do not interfere with triggering of the first major cell movements but perturb directional migration of these cells. It would seem that entactin plays a functional role in the directed migration of cells and does not seem to affect cell adhesion during the period of the first morphogenetic events in the early chick embryo.     

Pattern and morphogenesis of presumptive superficial mesoderm in two closely related species, Xenopus laevis and Xenopus tropicalis

The mesoderm, comprising the tissues that come to lie entirely in the deep layer, originates in both the superficial epithelial and the deep mesenchymal layers of the early amphibian embryo. Here, we characterize the mechanisms by which the superficial component of the presumptive mesoderm ingresses into the underlying deep mesenchymal layer in Xenopus tropicalis and extend our previous findings for Xenopus laevis. Fate mapping the superficial epithelium of pregastrula stage embryos demonstrates ingression of surface cells into both paraxial and axial mesoderm (including hypochord), in similar patterns and amounts in both species. Superficial presumptive notochord lies medially, flanked by presumptive hypochord and both overlie the deep region of the presumptive notochord. These tissues are flanked laterally by superficial presumptive somitic mesoderm, the anterior tip of which also appears to overlay the presumptive deep notochord. Time-lapse recordings show that presumptive somitic and notochordal cells move out of the roof of the gastrocoel and into the deep region during neurulation, whereas hypochordal cells ingress after neurulation. Scanning electron microscopy at the stage and position where ingression occurs suggests that superficial presumptive somitic cells in X. laevis ingress into the deep region as bottle cells whereas those in X. tropicalis ingress by "relamination" (e.g., [Dev. Biol. 174 (1996) 92]). In both species, the superficially derived presumptive somitic cells come to lie in the medial region of the presumptive somites during neurulation. By the early tailbud stages, these cells lie at the horizontal myoseptum of the somites. The morphogenic pathway of these cells strongly resembles that of the primary slow muscle pioneer cells of the zebrafish. We present a revised fate map of Xenopus, and we discuss the conservation of superficial mesoderm within amphibians and across the chordates and its implications for the role of this tissue in patterning the mesoderm.