Rubus host range of rubus yellow net virus and its involvement with other aphid-borne latent viruses in inducing raspberry veinbanding mosaic disease

After graft inoculation with rubus yellow net virus (RYNV), 12 of 34 Rubus species and cultivars developed noticeable symptoms. R. macraei developed the most conspicuous symptoms and is recommended as an improved indicator plant. In attempts to determine the cause of raspberry veinbanding mosaic, a disease in which RYNV is involved, several European and North American red raspberry cvs were graft-inoculated with RYNV and three other aphid-borne viruses, black raspberry necrosis (BRNV), raspberry leaf mottle (RLMV) and raspberry leaf spot, singly and in all combinations. In periods of up to 4 yr, classical veinbanding mosaic symptoms developed in sensitive cvs only when they contained both RYNV and RLMV. These symptoms were intensified in plants co-infected with additional viruses. Veinbanding mosaic disease did not develop in any of 11 cvs infected with RYNV + BRNV, the combination of viruses previously assumed to be responsible for this disease in Britain and North America.     

Rubus host range, symptomatology and ultrastructural effects of a British isolate of black raspberry necrosis virus

Scions from red raspberry (Rubus idaeus) plants naturally infected with an aphid- and sap-transmissible virus, code-named 52V, always induced apical necrosis in R. occidentals signifying the presence of black raspberry necrosis virus (BRNV), whereas plants free from 52V did not. These and other findings provide strong circumstantial evidence that 52V is an isolate of BRNV, the heat-labile member of the pair of viruses that together cause raspberry veinbanding mosaic disease. On grafting with R. idaeus scions containing a 52V culture of BRNV free from other detectable viruses, all of twenty-two red raspberry cultivars and four other Rubus species were infected symptomlessly but apical necrosis developed in R. henryi and R. molaccanus. Electron microscopy of thin sections of 52V-infected Chenopodium quinoa, R. henryii and R. occidentalis showed areas of dead cells in the vascular tissue and leaf blade. Some of the cells adjacent to these areas had cell wall outgrowths and many of the plasmodesmata contained virus-like particles c. 25 nm in diameter arranged in a single file.     

Association of different kinds of bacilliform particle with vein chlorosis and mosaic diseases of raspberry (Rubus idaeus)

Thin sections of diseased raspberry (Rubus idaeus) were examined by electron microscopy. Plants of the cv. Baumforth's B and of an aphid (Amphorophora rubi)-resistant breeding selection (6820/54), both infected with raspberry vein chlorosis virus (RVCV) but not with other detectable viruses, contained large bacilliform particles c. 430 × 65 nm. Particles occurred in the cytoplasm and perinuclear space of a small proportion of xylem parenchyma cells. They had an inner core c. 25–30 nm in diameter with cross-banding of periodicity 4·5 nm, and were bounded by an outer membrane. They are probably the particles of RVCV. Plants of cv. Mailing Jewel and of a selection (M14) both showing symptoms of raspberry mosaic (veinbanding) disease contained smaller bacilliform particles c. 125 × 30 nm, which occurred singly or in clusters in the cytoplasm of a small proportion of vascular parenchyma cells. It is not known which, if any, of the viruses associated with raspberry mosaic are represented by the particles.     

Identification of Rubus yellow net virus as a distinct badnavirus and its detection by PCR in Rubus species and in aphids

Rubus yellow net virus (RYNV) infects Rubus species and cultivars worldwide and is an essential component of raspberry veinbanding mosaic (RVBMD), a virus disease complex that causes serious decline in plant vigour and productivity. The virus is transmitted, probably in a semi‐persistent manner, by the large raspberry aphid, Amphorophora idaei in Europe, and A. agathonica in North America. The particles of RYNV are bacilliform in shape and measure 80–150 × 25–30 nm, similar to those of badnaviruses. A1.7 kb fragment of the viral DNA was amplified by PCR and then directly sequenced. Analysis of this sequence suggests that RYNV is possibly a distinct species in the genus Badnavirus and is most closely related to Gooseberry vein banding associated virus (GVBAV) and Spiraea yellow leaf spot virus, two other badnaviruses described recently. Using the sequence derived from the PCR‐amplified viral DNA fragment, RYNV‐specific primers were designed and used in PCR to assay for RYNV in a range of Rubus germplasm infected with RYNV, with other unrelated viruses and virus‐like diseases found in Rubus, and in healthy plants. RYNV was detected in all glasshouse cultures of RYNV‐infected plants, whether alone or in complex infections with other viruses, but not from healthy Rubus plants, nor from plants infected with other viruses. It was also detected in field‐grown raspberry plants with and without symptoms of RVBMD and in raspberry plants infected with RYNV by viruliferous A. idaei. RYNV was also detected by PCR in A. idaei following access feeds on RYNV‐infected plants of 1 h or more. PCR failed to amplify DNA from gooseberry infected with GVBAV confirming the specificity of the RYNV analysis. PCR detection of RYNV in dormant raspberry buds allows assays to be made outside the natural growing season, providing a useful application for plant introduction and quarantine programmes.     

Unusual filamentous virus-like particles in symptomless blackberry associated with severe leaf curling in the virus indicator Rubus macraei, and anomalous data using a degenerate badnavirus primer in PCR of Rubus species

Electron microscopy of ultrathin sections of leaves of symptomless Himalaya Giant blackberry and of the virus indicator species, Rubus macraei, showing severe leaf curl symptoms following graft inoculation with scions from this blackberry, detected highly flexuous virus‐like particles with an unusual ‘beaded’ structure. Such particles were restricted to a few vascular cells and were distinct from P‐protein common in some such cells. This virus, provisionally named Hawaiian rubus leaf curl virus (HRLCV), symptomlessly infected a wide range of Rubus species and cultivars. Badnavirus‐like bacilliform particles were observed in some cells of a single R. macraei plant showing leaf curl symptoms following graft inoculation with the causal agent of this disease symptom from Himalaya Giant blackberry after passage through red raspberry, but not in any other material. PCR with primer sets for the badnaviruses Rubus yellow net virus and Gooseberry veinbanding associated virus, showed that no Rubus sources studied contained these viruses. However, using a sequence‐specific primer set designed from the sequence of the product generated with a badnavirus degenerate primer set, a specific product was amplified from healthy plants of all of 16 raspberry cultivars and two Rubus species, but not from 16 blackberry cultivars (including cv. Himalaya Giant). All of these sources were free from viruses known to occur in Rubus. Sequence analysis of this product showed no homology with any known badnavirus, or with any other published sequences. It seems most likely therefore that a region of the raspberry genome has been amplified using the degenerate badnavirus primer set and that it is absent from the blackberry genome.     

Ultrastructural changes and small bacilliform particles associated with infection by rubus yellow net virus

A culture of rubus yellow net virus (RYNV) was obtained free from other detectable viruses by heat treatment of red raspberry (Rubus idaeus) cv. Mailing Jewel showing veinbanding mosaic symptoms. Graft inoculated black raspberry (JR. occidentalis) plants showed three kinds of ultrastructural abnormality: (1) cell wall outgrowths in many kinds of cells in the leaf blade and vascular bundles, (2) tubular structures c. 30 nm in diameter and up to 1100 nm long, in groups in the cytoplasm close to the nucleus and (3) small bacilliform virus-like particles c. 80–150 × 25 nm in size randomly distributed in the cytoplasm of many kinds of leaf cells, but especially in the phloem. The bacilliform particles, which in some cells were in large groups associated with lightly staining amorphous material, are considered to be those of RYNV.     

STUDIES IN RUBUS VIRUS DISEASES I. A LATENT VIRUS OF NORFOLK GIANT RASPBERRY

A selection of Norfolk Giant raspberry is infected with a virus transmissible by Amphorophora rubi Kalt. after short feeding periods on infected plants and persisting for at least 18 1/2 hr. in the aphid. This virus is identified with one which is carried without symptoms by Norfolk Giant and Baumforth's Seedling B, and causes necrosis on Rubus henryi and mosaic symptoms on R. saxatilis , American black raspberry R. occidentalis (var. Cumberland) and the red raspberry varieties Chartham, Mailing Landmark and St Walfried. The virus is present in some commercial stocks of Baumforth's Seedling B, Burnetholm Seedling, and the Mailing varieties Enterprise, Notable and Promise. The name raspberry leaf mottle is proposed.     

Biology of the European large raspberry aphid (Amphorophora idaei): its role in virus transmission and resistance breakdown in red raspberry

1 The European large raspberry aphid Amphorophora idaei Börner is the most important vector of viral diseases afflicting commercially grown red raspberry ( Rubus idaeus L.) in Northern Europe, with European raspberry production amounting to 416 000 tonnes per annum. This review synthesizes existing knowledge on its biology and interactions with other organisms, including its host plant and the viral pathogens it vectors.
2 Information about trophic interactions with other insect herbivores and natural enemies is reviewed. Vine weevils Otiorhynchus sulcatus compromise aphid resistance in some raspberry cultivars, increasing A.   idaei abundance by 80%. Parasitoids show mixed success in parasitizing A.   idaei , although Aphidius ervi attack rates more than doubled when A.   idaei fed on a partially susceptible raspberry cultivar, compared with a resistant variety. These findings are discussed in the context of potential biological control as part of an integrated pest and disease management framework.
3  Amphorophora idaei transmits four known viruses: Black raspberry necrosis virus, Raspberry leaf mottle virus, Raspberry leaf spot virus and Rubus yellow net virus , with A.   idaei taking as little as 2 min to transmit some viruses.
4 Existing control strategies, including resistant cultivars, insecticides and eradication of disease from parent plants, are described. In particular, strong selection pressures have resulted in A .  idaei overcoming genetic resistance in many raspberry cultivars and most insecticides are now ineffective.
5 Future directions for the sustained control of A.   idaei are suggested, taking into consideration the possible effects of climate change and also changes in agronomic practices in U.K. agriculture.     

Association of raspberry bushy dwarf virus with raspberry yellows disease; reaction of Rubus species and cultivars, and the inheritance of resistance.

The agent of raspberry yellows disease is transmitted by grafting but not by aphids and is resistant to thermotherapy. Further studies showed that it is transmitted by inoculation of sap through seed; it is probably transmitted to plants by pollination. Raspberry bushy dwarf virus (RBDV) shares all these attributes and is known to infect all yellows-sensitive raspberry cultivars except Puyallup and Sumner; however, neither of these cultivars has been tested by graft inoculation with RBDV. RBDV commonly infects plants symptomiessly, even those of yellows-sensitive cultivars, but it induced yellows when inoculated either manually to Norfolk Giant raspberry or by grafting to a yellows-sensitive raspberry selection. The evidence suggests that RBDV is the causal agent of yellows disease but that symptom expression is greatiy dependent on genetic and environmental factors. Many red raspberry cultivars are resistant, probably immune, to the type culture of RBDV and this character was shown to be conferred by a single dominant gene designated Bu.     

RASPBERRY YELLOW DWARF, A SOIL-BORNE VIRUS

An apparently undescribed virus, provisionally named raspberry yellow dwarf virus (RYDV), was isolated from naturally infected raspberry, strawberry, blackberry and several weed species by mechanical inoculation of sap to Chenopodium amaranticolor. The severe disease it caused in Malling Exploit raspberry usually occurred patchily in otherwise normal plantations: these patches increased in size from year to year. RYDV was differentiated from raspberry ringspot and tomato black ring viruses by the symptoms produced in C. amaranticolor , tobacco and Petunia hybrida. RYDV lost infectivity when sap was heated for 10 min. at 61° C., diluted 10^-5or kept for 15 days at 18° C. RYDV was precipitated without inactivation by acetone and by ammonium sulphate.
Isolates of RYDV from different plants and localities, and of different virulence, were identified by plant-protection and serological tests. Such tests gave no evidence that RYDV was related to raspberry ringspot, tobacco ringspot, tomato black ring or cucumber mosaic viruses.
Raspberry and sugar-beet plants became systemically infected with RYDV when grown under glass in soil from a field where the disease had occurred in raspberry plants, and where the virus persisted in the soil for 3 years after the raspberry plants were removed. RYDV seems to be widely disseminated in England but recently introduced and rare in eastern Scotland.
Like raspberry ringspot and tomato black ring viruses, RYDV causes symptoms of the ringspot type in tobacco, has a wide natural and experimental host range, is soil-borne and of local importance. Such features seem characteristic of ringspot viruses as a group.     

Isolates of raspberry bushy dwarf virus differing in Rubus host range

Isolates of raspberry bushy dwarf virus (RBDV) occurring in the field at East Mailing Research Station (EMRS), and an isolate from raspberry seed imported from the USSR, were found to differ from the Scottish type isolate (D200) of RBDV in that they infected red raspberry cultivars that are resistant, possibly immune, to isolate D200. Of several red raspberry, blackberry and hybrid berry cultivars and EMRS raspberry selections graft-inoculated with these recently discovered RBDV isolates only two raspberry cvs (Haida and Rannaya Sladkaya) and one EMRS selection did not become infected. Differences in the conclusions reached in two previous studies on the inheritance of resistance to RBDV in raspberry can be explained by the use of virus isolates that differed in Rubus host range.     

The effect of resistance to Amphorophora rubi in raspberry (Rubus idaeus) on the spread of aphid-borne viruses

The effectiveness of resistance to the aphid Amphorophora rubi in restricting the spread of aphid-borne viruses was assessed in a field experiment using six genotypes of red raspberry. In one block of the experiment, the genotypes alternated with rows of virus-infected Mailing Jewel raspberry, and in the other they alternated with virus-free Mailing Jewel. During 4 years, the numbers of A. rubi and the amount of 52V virus spread in the two blocks were similar, suggesting that this virus was mostly introduced from outside the plots. Lloyd George and Mailing Jewel raspberry became heavily infested with A. rubi and were rapidly infected with raspberry leaf mottle, raspberry leaf spot and 52V viruses. Glen Clova and Norfolk Giant raspberry, which contain minor genes for resistance to A. rubi, were infested with fewer A. rubi and virus spread more slowly in these cultivars. A. rubi were rare on Mailing Orion and an East Mailing raspberry selection (888/49) which have genes A₁ and A₁₀ respectively for resistance to A.rubi, and these plants remained largely free of virus. The role of minor and major gene resistance to A. rubi in restricting virus spread is discussed. A few Macrosiphum euphorbiae and Myzus ornatus were recorded on several of the raspberry genotypes.     

Genetic control of the reactions of raspberry to black raspberry necrosis, raspberry leaf mottle and raspberry leaf spot viruses

Black raspberry necrosis virus (BRNV) induces a severe apical necrosis in black raspberry (Rubus occidentalis) but fails to induce diagnostic symptoms in red raspberry. However, BRNV infection of F₁, F₂ and F₃ hybrids from the cross black raspberry × red raspberry induced mosaic symptoms of varying intensity but no typical apical necrosis. In a survey of 28 red raspberry cultivars, a few developed severe angular chlorotic leaf spots when infected with raspberry leaf mottle virus and a few others did so when infected with raspberry leaf spot virus. These reactions were determined by single dominant genes designated Lm and Ls respectively. The value of the different host reactions for controlling the effects and spread of these viruses is discussed.     

Immunity from raspberry vein chlorosis virus in raspberry and its potential for control of the virus through plant breeding

The apparent immunity of five cultivars of red raspberry and two of black raspberry from graft inoculation with raspberry vein chlorosis virus (RVCV) was established or confirmed. The segregations obtained from selfs and crosses with infectible cultivars of four of the red raspberry cultivars and the black raspberry cultivar Cumberland indicated that the apparent immunity was not determined by a single major gene. The range in severity of the symptoms expressed in the segregates suggested either that sensitivity to infection is under separate genetic control, or that immunity and sensitivity are opposite expressions of a character which varies continuously rather than discontinuously. Nevertheless, although the precise mechanism of immunity remains unclear, the high proportion of immune segregates obtained in crosses indicated that breeding for immunity from RVCV is feasible and offers the best prospect for control of the virus.     

Infectibility and sensitivity of UK raspberry, blackberry and hybrid berry cultivars to Rubus viruses

Six blackberry or hybrid berry cultivars and 19 raspberry cultivars were assessed for their infectibility with, and sensitivity to, graft inoculation with 10 distinct viruses found infecting Rubus in the UK. Cultivars were grafted with each of, two isolates of the pollen borne raspberry bushy dwarf virus (RBDV), five aphid borne viruses: black raspberry necrosis, raspberry leaf mottle (RLMV), raspberry leaf spot (RLSV), rubus yellow net and raspberry vein chlorosis (RVCV); and isolates of the nematode transmitted nepoviruses, arabis mosaic, raspberry ringspot, strawberry latent ringspot and tomato black ring. All tested cultivars were infectible with a resistance breaking isolate of RBDV but only about half of that number with the Scottish type isolate of the virus. The raspberry cvs Autumn Bliss, and occasionally Glen Garry and Glen Prosen, developed leaf yellowing symptoms following infection with RBDV, but none of the other infected cultivars showed obvious leaf symptoms when kept in a heated glasshouse during the growing season. All tested cultivars were infectible with each of the four viruses transmitted in nature by the aphid, Amphorophora idaei. Most were infected symptomlessly, but seven cultivars developed severe leaf spotting symptoms due to infection with RLMV or RLSV. All but one of the raspberry cultivars were infectible with RVCV, which is transmitted in nature by the aphid Aphis idaei, and almost all infected plants developed leaf symptoms; only one of the hybrid berry or blackberry cultivars tested was infected with RVCV. In tests with the four nepoviruses, all tested cultivars, except Tummelberry, were infectible with at least one or more of these viruses. However, cultivars responded differently to challenge inoculation with different isolates of individual nepoviruses. Several cultivars developed chlorotic leaf mottling following infection with some nepovirus isolates. The implications of these results for virus control are discussed in the light of the changing pattern of virus and virus vector incidence in the UK.     

SOME EFFECTS OF TANNIC ACID AND OF LEAF EXTRACTS WHICH CONTAIN TANNINS ON THE INFECTIVITY OF TOBACCO MOSAIC AND TOBACCO NECROSIS VIRUSES

The inhibition of infection by tobacco necrosis and tobacco mosaic viruses by tannic acid, and by extracts of raspberry and strawberry leaves, was associated with the precipitation of the viruses. Precipitation and inhibition were reversible, and infective virus was obtained from the precipitate formed between the viruses and tannins. Infectivity was fully restored by diluting mixtures of virus and tannin adequately and partially restored by adding alumina or nicotine sulphate.
Viruses and tannins are thought to form non-infective complexes, in which the virus and tannin components are held together by co-ordinate linkages or hydrogen bonds.
Macerating tobacco leaves infected with tobacco mosaic virus together with raspberry leaves greatly decreased the infectivity of the extracts; adding nicotine sulphate to the mixture of leaves before it was ground increased the infectivity, even though nicotine sulphate alone decreases the infectivity of tobacco mosaic virus. Even in the presence of nicotine sulphate, much of the virus was precipitated by substances from the raspberry leaves.
Extracts of roots of Fragaria vesca plants, infected with a tobacco necrosis virus, were more infective when made by macerating the roots with four times their weight of buffer at pH 8 than when made without buffer. Various methods are suggested for facilitating the transmission of viruses from plants that contain tannin.     

STUDIES ON THE HOST RANGE, PROPERTIES AND MODE OF TRANSMISSION OF BEET RINGSPOT VIRUS

An apparently undescribed mechanically transmissible virus has been named beet ringspot virus (BRV). It occurs naturally in Scotland in sugar-beet, turnip, swede, potato and many kinds of weed plants. BRV is readily distinguished from raspberry ringspot virus by the symptoms produced in Chenopodium amaranticolor , French bean, tobacco and Petunia hybrida plants. BRV lost infectivity when heated for 10 min. at 63°C. but not at 60°C.: at 20°C. its longevity in vitro was about 3 weeks. BRV was precipitated by ammonium sulphate, ethanol and acetone.
Protection experiments with tobacco plants, and serological tests, gave no evidence that BRV was related to tobacco ringspot, raspberry ringspot, potato bouquet or tobacco rattle viruses, but showed that viruses isolated from different host plants and from different localities were strains of BRV.
BRV is soil-borne: in glasshouse experiments sugar-beet, beetroot, potato, turnip, swede, French bean, Fragaria vesca , oat and wheat plants often became systemically infected when grown in soil from the site of a disease outbreak, but the virus was restricted to the roots of many infected plants. When sugar-beet seedlings were grown in virus-containing soil, BRV was first detected in their roots, where its concentration increased, before progressively increasing amounts of virus were found in the shoots.
Soils from five localities were found to contain BRV. BRV has been found only where the soil is light in texture, and often in fields where raspberry ringspot virus occurs.     

Epidemiology of Raspberry Bushy Dwarf Virus in the Czech Republic

Extensive monitoring of the raspberry bushy dwarf virus (RBDV) in cultivated raspberry, wild raspberry and blackberry was conducted in 1994‐99. RBDV was revealed by ELISA in 31.6% of field samples, 15.7% plants in germplasm collections and in 43.8% of propagated plants. Infected cultivars were Aborigen, Balzam, Brigantina, Bulharský Rubín, Canby, Comox, F‐103, Findus, Gatineau, Glen Moy, Granát, Heritage, Lloyd George, M‐101, Mája, Meeker, Norfolk Giant, Norna, NS?‐1D‐101, Skeena, Trent, Veten, ZamatoS? and Zeva. The virus was detected in 6.5 and 6.7% of wild raspberry and wild blackberry plants, respectively, at 22.8% and 11.4% of sampled locations. Vegetatively propagated plants seem to be the main source for virus spread in cultivated raspberry, rather than naturally infested wild Rubus populations.     

Further properties of black raspberry latent virus, and evidence for its relationship to tobacco streak virus

Purified preparations of an isolate of black raspberry latent virus (BRLV) contained quasispherical particles with a mean diameter of 28·5 nm; these particles were resolved into three sedimenting components (s_{20, w}= 82S, 95S and 104S), but when centrifuged to equilibrium in caesium chloride solution they formed a single infective band (σ= 1·35 g/cm³). During electrophoresis in polyacrylamide gels, virus particles separated into three classes, and virus RNA was resolved into three major (mol. wt 1·35, 1·10 and 0·85 × 10⁶) and one minor (mol. wt 0·4 × 10⁶) component. The protein from virus particles had an estimated mol. wt of 28000. Isolates of BRLV were found to be serologically related but not identical to some strains of tobacco streak virus. No symptoms developed in black raspberry seedlings infected with BRLV by mechanical inoculation, nor in eight red raspberry cultivars infected by graft inoculation. However, graft inoculation of BRLV to Rubus henryi, R. phoenicolasius and Himalaya blackberry induced symptoms typical of necrotic shock disease.     

A comparison of the effectiveness of the four British virus vector species of Longidorus and Xiphinema

The frequency with which the four virus-vector species of longidoroid nematodes occurring in Britain transmitted their associated plant viruses were compared in a series of experiments using a standard procedure. In these tests Xiphinema diversicaudatum proved an effective vector of British isolates of arabis mosaic virus and strawberry latent ringspot virus and Longidorus attenuatus of an isolate of tomato black ring virus from England. In comparison, isolates of raspberry ringspot virus and tomato blackring virus from Scotland and of raspberry ringspot virus from England were transmitted much less readily by their respective vectors, L. elongatus and L. macrosoma. These differences in ability to transmit virus were not related to differences in feeding access on the virus source- or bait-plants, in the extent to which virus was retained within the nematode feeding apparatus or in the frequency with which virus was recovered from Longidorus in concurrent slash tests. Three Scottish isolates of raspberry ringspot and tomato black ring viruses were transmitted equally infrequently by two populations of L. elongatus and the frequency with which virus was transmitted was not greatly increased when the species of source or bait plants was changed.