The Mrs1 Splicing Factor Binds the bI3 Group I Intron at Each of Two Tetraloop-Receptor Motifs

Most large ribozymes require protein cofactors in order to function efficiently. The yeast mitochondrial bI3 group I intron requires two proteins for efficient splicing, Mrs1 and the bI3 maturase. Mrs1 has evolved from DNA junction resolvases to function as an RNA cofactor for at least two group I introns; however, the RNA binding site and the mechanism by which Mrs1 facilitates splicing were unknown. Here we use high-throughput RNA structure analysis to show that Mrs1 binds a ubiquitous RNA tertiary structure motif, the GNRA tetraloop-receptor interaction, at two sites in the bI3 RNA. Mrs1 also interacts at similar tetraloop-receptor elements, as well as other structures, in the self-folding Azoarcus group I intron and in the RNase P enzyme. Thus, Mrs1 recognizes general features found in the tetraloop-receptor motif. Identification of the two Mrs1 binding sites now makes it possible to create a model of the complete six-component bI3 ribonucleoprotein. All protein cofactors bind at the periphery of the RNA such that every long-range RNA tertiary interaction is stabilized by protein binding, involving either Mrs1 or the bI3 maturase. This work emphasizes the strong evolutionary pressure to bolster RNA tertiary structure with RNA-binding interactions as seen in the ribosome, spliceosome, and other large RNA machines.     

Connections between RNA splicing and DNA intron mobility in yeast mitochondria: RNA maturase and DNA endonuclease switching experiments.

The intron-encoded proteins bI4 RNA maturase and aI4 DNA endonuclease can be faithfully expressed in yeast cytoplasm from engineered forms of their mitochondrial coding sequences. In this work we studied the relationships between these two activities associated with two homologous intron-encoded proteins: the bI4 RNA maturase encoded in the fourth intron of the cytochrome b gene and the aI4 DNA endonuclease (I-SceII) encoded in the fourth intron of the gene coding for the subunit I of cytochrome oxidase. Taking advantage of both the high recombinogenic properties of yeast and the similarities between the two genes, we constructed in vivo a family of hybrid genes carrying parts of both RNA maturase and DNA endonuclease coding sequences. The presence of a sequence coding for a mitochondrial targeting peptide upstream from these hybrid genes allowed us to study the properties of their translation products within the mitochondria in vivo. We thus could analyze the ability of the recombinant proteins to complement RNA maturase deficiencies in different strains. Many combinations of the two parental intronic sequences were found in the recombinants. Their structural and functional analysis revealed the following features. (i) The N-terminal half of the bI4 RNA maturase could be replaced in total by its equivalent from the aI4 DNA endonuclease without affecting the RNA maturase activity. In contrast, replacing the C-terminal half of the bI4 RNA maturase with its equivalent from the aI4 DNA endonuclease led to a very weak RNA maturase activity, indicating that this region is more differentiated and linked to the maturase activity. (ii) None of the hybrid proteins carrying an RNA maturase activity kept the DNA endonuclease activity, suggesting that the latter requires the integrity of the aI4 protein. These observations are interesting because the aI4 DNA endonuclease is known to promote the propagation, at the DNA level, of the aI4 intron, whereas the bI4 RNA maturase, which is required for the splicing of its coding intron, also controls the splicing process of the aI4 intron. We propose a scenario for the evolution of these intronic proteins that relies on a switch from DNA endonuclease to RNA maturase activity.     

Kinetic and thermodynamic framework for assembly of the six-component bI3 group I intron ribonucleoprotein catalyst

The yeast mitochondrial bI3 group I intron RNA splices in vitro as a six-component ribonucleoprotein complex with the bI3 maturase and Mrs1 proteins. We report a comprehensive framework for assembly of the catalytically active bI3 ribonucleoprotein. (1) In the absence of Mg(2+), two Mrs1 dimers bind independently to the bI3 RNA. The ratio of dissociation to association rate constants, k(off)/k(on), is approximately equal to the observed equilibrium K(1/2) of 0.12 nM. (2) At magnesium ion concentrations optimal for splicing (20 mM), two Mrs1 dimers bind with strong cooperativity to the bI3 RNA. k(off)/k(on) is 15-fold lower than the observed K(1/2) of 11 nM, which reflects formation of an obligate intermediate involving one Mrs1 dimer and the RNA in cooperative assembly of the Mrs1-RNA complex. (3) The bI3 maturase monomer binds to the bI3 RNA at almost the diffusion-controlled limit and dissociates with a half-life of 1 h. k(off)/k(on) is approximately equal to the equilibrium K(D) of 2.8 pM. The bI3 maturase thus represents a rare example of a group I intron protein cofactor whose binding is adequately characterized by a one-step mechanism under conditions that promote splicing. (4) Maturase and Mrs1 proteins each bind the bI3 RNA tightly, but with only modest coupling (approximately 1 kcal/mol), suggesting that the proteins interact at independent RNA binding sites. Maturase binding functions to slow dissociation of Mrs1; whereas prior Mrs1 binding increases the bI3 maturase k(on) right to the diffusion limit. (5) At effective concentrations plausibly present in yeast mitochondria, a predominant assembly pathway emerges involving rapid, tight binding by the bI3 maturase, followed by slower, cooperative assembly of two Mrs1 dimers. In the absence of other factors, disassembly of all protein subunits will occur in a single apparent step, governed by dissociation of the bI3 maturase.     

The bI4 group I intron binds directly to both its protein splicing partners, a tRNA synthetase and maturase, to facilitate RNA splicing activity

The imported mitochondrial leucyl-tRNA synthetase (NAM2p) and a mitochondrial-expressed intron-encoded maturase protein are required for splicing the fourth intron (bI4) of the yeast cob gene, which expresses an electron transfer protein that is essential to respiration. However, the role of the tRNA synthetase, as well as the function of the bI4 maturase, remain unclear. As a first step towards elucidating the mechanistic role of these protein splicing factors in this group I intron splicing reaction, we tested the hypothesis that both leucyl-tRNA synthetase and bI4 maturase interact directly with the bI4 intron. We developed a yeast three-hybrid system and determined that both the tRNA synthetase and bI4 maturase can bind directly and independently via RNA-protein interactions to the large bI4 group I intron. We also showed, using modified two-hybrid and three-hybrid assays, that the bI4 intron bridges interactions between the two protein splicing partners. In the presence of either the bI4 maturase or the Leu-tRNA synthetase, bI4 intron transcribed recombinantly with flanking exons in the yeast nucleus exhibited splicing activity. These data combined with previous genetic results are consistent with a novel model for a ternary splicing complex (two protein: one RNA) in which both protein splicing partners bind directly to the bI4 intron and facilitate its self-splicing activity.     

Leucyl-tRNA Synthetase-dependent and -independent Activation of a Group I Intron

Leucyl-tRNA synthetase (LeuRS) is an essential RNA splicing factor for yeast mitochondrial introns. Intracellular experiments have suggested that it works in collaboration with a maturase that is encoded within the bI4 intron. RNA deletion mutants of the large bI4 intron were constructed to identify a competently folded intron for biochemical analysis. The minimized bI4 intron was active in RNA splicing and contrasts with previous proposals that the canonical core of the bI4 intron is deficient for catalysis. The activity of the minimized bI4 intron was enhanced in vitro by the presence of the bI4 maturase or LeuRS.Although the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs)⁶ are best known for their role in protein synthesis, many have functionally expanded and are essential to a wide range of other cellular activities that are unrelated to tRNA aminoacylation (1). The class I aaRSs, leucyl- (LeuRS or NAM2) and tyrosyl-tRNA synthetase (TyrRS or CYT-18) are required for RNA splicing of cognate group I introns in the mitochondria of certain lower eukaryotes (2). In yeast, processing of two related group I introns called bI4 and aI4α (Fig. 1) from the cob and cox1α genes, respectively, require yeast mitochondrial LeuRS (3, 4). Likewise, expression of Neurospora crassa mitochondrial genes, such as those for the large ribosomal RNA, is dependent on TyrRS for excising group I introns (5).Open in a separate windowFIGURE 1.Predicted secondary structures of the bI4 and aI4α group I introns. The secondary structure of the canonical core was based on previous predictions (19). Solid bold lines indicate linear connectivities of the nucleic acid strand with arrowheads oriented in the 5′ to 3′ direction. The dashed lines represent putative tertiary interactions. Dotted lines with numbers identify insertions where secondary structures were ambiguous. Arrows in the P1 and P9 domain show splice sites, whereas boxed nucleotides are paired regions.LeuRS facilitates RNA splicing in concert with a bI4 maturase that is encoded within the bI4 intron. Genetic investigations showed that an inactivated bI4 maturase resulting in deficient splicing activity of the bI4 and aI4α group I introns can be rescued by a suppressor mutation of LeuRS to restore mitochondrial respiration (4, 6). In addition, the splicing defect can be compensated by a mutant aI4α DNA endonuclease that is closely related to the bI4 maturase (7, 8).Previously, we used intracellular three-hybrid assays to demonstrate that LeuRS and bI4 maturase can independently bind to the bI4 intron and stimulate RNA splicing activity in the non-physiological yeast nucleus compartment (9). RNA-dependent two-hybrid assays also supported that the bI4 intron could simultaneously bind both the bI4 maturase and LeuRS. In this case, the RNA was co-expressed with LeuRS and bI4 maturase that was fused to either LexA or B42 to generate a two-hybrid response. This suggested that the bI4 intron was bridging these two protein splicing factors. In either the RNA-dependent two-hybrid or three-hybrid assays, bI4 intron splicing occurred only in the presence of LeuRS or bI4 maturase or both.We hypothesized that the bI4 maturase and LeuRS bind to distinct sites of the bI4 intron to form a ternary complex and promote efficient splicing activity. However, the functional basis of the collaboration between these two splicing cofactors or how either of them promotes RNA splicing remains unclear.We sought to characterize the respective splicing roles of the bI4 maturase and LeuRS via biochemical investigations. Previous attempts to develop an in vitro splicing assay for the bI4 intron or its closely related aI4α intron have failed (10, 11). It was hypothesized that the long length of the bI4 intron (∼1600 nucleotides) and its highly A:U-rich content (∼80%) hindered RNA folding in vitro as well as stabilization of its competent structure.Efforts to produce an active form of the bI4 intron have relied on building chimeric group I introns by interchanging RNA domains with the more stable Tetrahymena thermophila group I intron (11). Based on these results, it was proposed that the catalytic core of the bI4 group I intron was inherently defective (11). In this case, the group I intron would be expected to be completely dependent on its protein splicing factors similar to the bI3 intron that relies on the bI3 maturase and Mrs1 for activity (12). Thus, it was hypothesized that the bI4 maturase and/or LeuRS splicing factors aided the bI4 group I intron by targeting its core region to compensate for these deficiencies.We focused our efforts on re-designing the bI4 intron to develop a minimized molecule that might be competent for splicing. Because both the bI4 and aI4α group I introns rely on the bI4 maturase and LeuRS for their splicing activity, we compared their secondary structures to identify and eliminate peripheral regions outside of their catalytic cores. A small active derivative of the bI4 intron, comprised of just 380 nucleotides primarily from the canonical core, was generated. Thus, we show that, in and of itself, the canonical core of this group I intron is competent for splicing. Both the bI4 maturase and LeuRS enhance the splicing activity of the minimized bI4 intron. However, it is possible that protein-dependent splicing of the bI4 intron represents an intermediate evolutionary step in which the RNA activity is becoming increasingly dependent on its protein splicing factors.     

Functionally distinct nucleic acid binding sites for a group I intron encoded RNA maturase/DNA homing endonuclease

A large number of group I introns encode a family of homologous proteins that either promote intron splicing (maturases) or are site-specific DNA endonucleases that function in intron mobility (a process called "homing"). Genetic studies have shown that some of these proteins have both activities, yet how a single protein carries out both functions remains obscure. The similarity between respective DNA-binding sites and the RNA structure near the 5' and 3' splice sites has fueled speculation that such proteins may use analogous interactions to perform both functions. The Aspergillus nidulans mitochondrial COB group I intron encodes a bi-functional protein, I-AniI, that has both RNA maturase and site-specific DNA endonuclease activities in vitro. Here, we show that I-AniI shows distinctive features of the endonuclease family to which it belongs, including highly specific, tight binding and sequential DNA strand cleavage. Competition experiments demonstrate that I-AniI binds the COB intron RNA even in saturating concentrations of its DNA target site substrate, suggesting that the protein has a separate binding site for RNA. In addition, we provide evidence that two different DNA-binding site mutants of I-AniI have little effect on the protein's RNA maturation activity. Since RNA splicing is likely a secondary adaptation of the protein, these observations support a model in which homing endonucleases may have developed maturase function by utilizing a hitherto "non-functional" protein surface.     

The yeast mitochondrial leucyl-tRNA synthetase is a splicing factor for the excision of several group I introns

Summary The Saccharomyces cerevisiae nuclear gene NAM2 codes for mitochondrial leucyl-tRNA synthetase (mLRS). Herbert et al. (1988, EMBO J 7:473–483) proposed that this protein is involved in mitochondrial RNA splicing. Here we present the construction and analyses of nine mutations obtained by creating two-codon insertions within the NAM2 gene. Three of these prevent respiration while maintaining the mitochondrial genome. These three mutants: (1) display in vitro a mLRS activity ranging from 0%–50% that of the wild type: (2) allow in vivo the synthesis of several mitochondrially encoded proteins; (3) prevent the synthesis of the COXII protein but not of its mRNA; (4) abolish the splicing of the group I introns bI4 and aI4; and (5) affect significantly the excision of the group I introns bI2, bI3 and aI3. Importation of the bI4 maturase from the cytoplasm into mitochondria in a nam2 ^– mutant strain does not restore the excision of the introns bI4 and aI4 implying that the splicing deficiency does not result from the absence of the bI4 maturase. We conclude that the mLRS is a splicing factor essential for the excision of the group I introns bI4 and aI4 and probably important for the excision of other group I introns.     

SHAPE analysis of long-range interactions reveals extensive and thermodynamically preferred misfolding in a fragile group I intron RNA

Most functional RNAs require proteins to facilitate formation of their active structures. In the case of the yeast bI3 group I intron, splicing requires binding by two proteins, the intron-encoded bI3 maturase and the nuclear encoded Mrs1. Here, we use selective 2'-hydroxyl acylation analyzed by primer extension (SHAPE) chemistry coupled with analysis of point mutants to map long-range interactions in this RNA. This analysis reveals two critical features of the free RNA state. First, the catalytic intron is separated from the flanking exons via a stable anchoring helix. This anchoring helix creates an autonomous structural domain for the intron and functions to prevent misfolding with the flanking exons. Second, the thermodynamically most stable structure for the free RNA is not consistent with the catalytically active conformation as phylogenetically conserved elements form stable, non-native structures. These results highlight a fragile bI3 RNA for which binding by protein cofactors functions to promote extensive secondary structure rearrangements that are an obligatory prerequisite for forming the catalytically active tertiary structure.     

The bI4 RNA mitochondrial maturase of Saccharomyces cerevisiae can stimulate intra-chromosomal recombination in Escherichia coli

Summary When the bI4 RNA maturase, encoded by the fourth intron of the mitochondrial cytochrome b gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, was expressed in Escherichia coli, formation of intra-chromosomal Lac⁺ recombinants was stimulated threefold. This hyper-rec phenotype was recA as well as recBCD dependent. The most active form of the bI4 maturase stimulated homologous recombination whereas splicing deficient mutants of bI4 maturase were either deficient in or unable to stimulate homologous recombination.     

In vitro analysis of the relationship between endonuclease and maturase activities in the bi-functional group I intron-encoded protein, I-AniI.

The AnCOB group I intron from Aspergillus nidulans encodes a homing DNA endonuclease called I-AniI which also functions as a maturase, assisting in AnCOB intron RNA splicing. In this investigation we biochemically characterized the endonuclease activity of I-AniI in vitro and utilized competition assays to probe the relationship between the RNA- and DNA-binding sites. Despite functioning as an RNA maturase, I-AniI still retains several characteristic properties of homing endonucleases including relaxed substrate specificity, DNA cleavage product retention and instability in the reaction buffer, which suggest that the protein has not undergone dramatic structural adaptations to function as an RNA-binding protein. Nitrocellulose filter binding and kinetic burst assays showed that both nucleic acids bind I-AniI with the same 1 : 1 stoichiometry. Furthermore, in vitro competition activity assays revealed that the RNA substrate, when prebound to I-AniI, stoichiometrically inhibits DNA cleavage activity, yet in reciprocal experiments, saturating amounts of prebound DNA substrate fails to inhibit RNA splicing activity. The data suggest therefore that both nucleic acids do not bind the same single binding site, rather that I-AniI appears to contain two binding sites.     

Efficient splicing of two yeast mitochondrial introns controlled by a nuclear-encoded maturase.

bI4 maturase encoded by the fourth intron of the yeast mitochondrial cytochrome b gene, controls the splicing of both the fourth intron of the cytochrome b gene and the fourth intron of the gene encoding subunit I of cytochrome oxidase. It has been shown previously that a cytoplasmically translated hybrid protein composed of the pre-sequence of subunit 9 of Neurospora ATPase fused to a part of the bI4 maturase can be guided to mitochondria where it could compensate maturase deficiencies. This in vivo complementation of maturase mutants can be easily estimated by restoration of respiration. This work examines the efficiency of different bI4 maturase constructions to restore respiration in different yeast maturase-deficient strains. It is shown that the N-terminal end of the bI4 maturase plays a crucial role in the maturase activity. Moreover, the 12 N-terminal amino acids of the mitochondrial outer membrane protein constitute the most efficient mitochondrial targeting sequence in this system. Surprisingly enough, it was found that the cytoplasmically translated bI4 maturase containing the 254 C-terminal amino acid coded by the intron open reading frame can complement maturase mutations without any added mitochondrial-targeting sequence.     

A mitochondrial RNA maturase gene transferred to the yeast nucleus can control mitochondrial mRNA splicing

bI4 maturase, encoded by the fourth intron of the yeast mitochondrial cytochrome b gene, controls the splicing of both the fourth intron of the cytochrome b gene and the fourth intron of the gene encoding subunit I of cytochrome oxidase. By fusing the encoding presequence of subunit 9 of the Neurospora ATPase to a restriction fragment containing the bI4 maturase coding sequence, we have constructed a hybrid gene that can be translated on yeast cytosolic ribosomes. The resulting protein is imported into mitochondria, which was revealed by its ability to restore to respiratory competence a yeast mutant defective in the bI4 maturase. Moreover, a protein reacting with antimaturase antibodies was detected in the mitochondria of the transformed cells; this imported maturase functioned similarly to the endogenous maturase.     

An inserted region of leucyl-tRNA synthetase plays a critical role in group I intron splicing

Yeast mitochondrial leucyl-tRNA synthetase (LeuRS) binds to the bI4 intron and collaborates with the bI4 maturase to aid excision of the group I intron. Deletion analysis isolated the inserted LeuRS CP1 domain as a critical factor in the protein's splicing activity. Protein fragments comprised of just the LeuRS CP1 region rescued complementation of a yeast strain that expressed a splicing-defective LeuRS. Three-hybrid analysis determined that these CP1-containing LeuRS fragments, ranging from 214 to 375 amino acids, bound to the bI4 intron. In each case, interactions with only the LeuRS protein fragment specifically stimulated bI4 intron splicing activity. Substitution of a homologous CP1 domain from isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase or mutation within the LeuRS CP1 region of the smallest protein fragment abolished RNA binding and splicing activity. The CP1 domain is best known for its amino acid editing activity. However, these results suggest that elements within the LeuRS CP1 domain also play a novel role, independent of the full-length tRNA synthetase, in binding the bI4 group I intron and facilitating its self-splicing activity.     

An intron-encoded protein assists RNA splicing of multiple similar introns of different bacterial genes

Four group II introns were found in an unusually intron-rich dnaN gene (encoding the beta subunit of DNA polymerase III) of the cyanobacterium Trichodesmium erythraeum, and they have strong similarities to two introns of the RIR gene (encoding ribonucleotide reductase) of the same organism. Of these six introns, only the RIR-3 intron encodes a maturase protein and showed efficient RNA splicing when expressed in Escherichia coli cells. The other five introns do not encode a maturase protein and did not show RNA splicing in E. coli. But these maturase-less introns showed efficient RNA splicing when the RIR-3 intron-encoded maturase protein was co-expressed from a freestanding gene in the same cell. These findings demonstrated that an intron-encoded protein could function as a general maturase for multiple introns of different genes. Major implications may include an intron-mediated co-regulation of the different genes and a resemblance of the evolutionary origin of spliceosomal introns.     

CBP2 protein promotes in vitro excision of a yeast mitochondrial group I intron.

The terminal intron (bI2) of the yeast mitochondrial cytochrome b gene is a group I intron capable of self-splicing in vitro at high concentrations of Mg2+. Excision of bI2 in vivo, however, requires a protein encoded by the nuclear gene CBP2. The CBP2 protein has been partially purified from wild-type yeast mitochondria and shown to promote splicing at physiological concentrations of Mg2+. The self-splicing and protein-dependent splicing reactions utilized a guanosine nucleoside cofactor, the hallmark of group I intron self-splicing reactions. Furthermore, mutations that abolished the autocatalytic activity of bI2 also blocked protein-dependent splicing. These results indicated that protein-dependent excision of bI2 is an RNA-catalyzed process involving the same two-step transesterification mechanism responsible for self-splicing of group I introns. We propose that the CBP2 protein binds to the bI2 precursor, thereby stabilizing the catalytically active structure of the RNA. The same or a similar RNA structure is probably induced by high concentrations of Mg2+ in the absence of protein. Binding of the CBP2 protein to the unspliced precursor was supported by the observation that the protein-dependent reaction was saturable by the wild-type precursor. Protein-dependent splicing was competitively inhibited by excised bI2 and by a splicing-defective precursor with a mutation in the 5' exon near the splice site but not by a splicing-defective precursor with a mutation in the core structure. Binding of the CBP2 protein to the precursor RNA had an effect on the 5' splice site helix, as evidenced by suppression of the interaction of an exogenous dinucleotide with the internal guide sequence.     

Maturase and endonuclease functions depend on separate conserved domains of the bifunctional protein encoded by the group I intron aI4 alpha of yeast mitochondrial DNA.

Intron 4 alpha (aI4 alpha) of the yeast mitochondrial COXI gene is a mobile group I intron that contains a reading frame encoding both the homing endonuclease I-SceII and a latent maturase capable of splicing both aI4 alpha and the fourth intron of the cytochrome b (COB) gene (bI4). The aI4 alpha reading frame is a member of a large gene family recognized by the presence of related dodecapeptide sequence motifs called P1 and P2. In this study, missense mutations of P1 and P2 were placed in mitochondrial DNA by biolistic transformation. The effects of the mutations on intron mobility, endonuclease I-SceII activity and maturase function were tested. The mutations of P1 strongly affected mobility and endonuclease I-SceII activity, but had little or no effect on maturase function; mutations of P2 affected splicing but not mobility or endonuclease I-SceII activity. Surprisingly, the conditional (temperature-sensitive) mutations at P1 and P2 block one or the other function of the protein but not both. This study indicates that the two functions depend on separate domains of the intron-encoded protein.     

Two independent activities define Ccm1p as a moonlighting protein in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Ccm1p is a nuclear-encoded PPR (pentatricopeptide repeat) protein that localizes into mitochondria of Saccharomyces cerevisiae. It was first defined as an essential factor to remove the bI4 [COB (cytochrome b) fourth intron)] and aI4 [COX1 (cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1) fourth intron] of pre-mRNAs, along with bI4 maturase, a protein encoded by part of bI4 and preceding exons that removes the intronic RNA sequence that codes for it. Later on, Ccm1p was described as key to maintain the steady-state levels of the mitoribosome small subunit RNA (15S rRNA). bI4 maturase is produced inside the mitochondria and therefore its activity depends on the functionality of mitochondrial translation. This report addresses the dilemma of whether Ccm1p supports bI4 maturase activity by keeping steady-state levels of 15S rRNA or separately and directly supports bI4 maturase activity per se. Experiments involving loss of Ccm1p, SMDC (sudden mitochondrial deprivation of Ccm1p) and mutations in one of the PPR (pentatricopeptide repeat) motifs revealed that the failure of bI4 maturase activity in CCM1 deletion mutants was not due to a malfunction of the translational machinery. Both functions were found to be independent, defining Ccm1p as a moonlighting protein. bI4 maturase activity was significantly more dependent on Ccm1p levels than the maintenance of 15S rRNA. The novel strategy of SMDC described here allowed the study of immediate short-term effects, before the mutant phenotype was definitively established. This approach can be also applied for further studies on 15S rRNA stability and mitoribosome assembly.