Mutagenic DNA repair in Escherichia coli XIII Proofreading exonuclease of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme is not operational during UV mutagenesis

We have introduced a mutD5 mutation (which results in defective 3′–5′-exonuclease activity of the ϵ proofreading subunit of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme) into excision-defective Escherichia coli strains with varying SOS responses to UV light. MutD5 increased the spontaneous mutation frequency in all strains tested, including recA430, umuC122::Tn5, and umuC36 derivatives. It had no effect of UV mutability or immutability in any strain or on misincorporation revealed by delayed photoreversal in UV-irradiated umuC36, umuC122::Tn5, or recA430 bacteria. It is concluded that the ϵ proofreading subunit of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme is excluded, inhibited, or inoperative during misincorporation and mutagenesis after UV.     

Current understanding of UV-induced base pair substitution mutation in E. coli with particular reference to the DNA polymerase III complex

UV mutagenesis in E. coli is believed to occur in two discrete steps. The second step involves continued DNA synthesis beyond a blocking lesion in the template strand. This bypass step requires induced levels of umuD and umuC gene products and activated recA protein. DNA polymerase III may be involved since a dnaE mutator strain (believed to have defective base selection) is associated with enhanced UV mutagenesis in conjunction with a genetic background permitting the bypass step. In non-UV-mutable umu and lexA strains, UV mutagenesis can be demonstrated if delayed photorevesal is given. This is interpreted as indicating that an earlier misincorporation step can occur in such strains but the resulting mutations do not survive because the bypass step is blocked. The misincorporation step does not require any induced SOS gene products and can occur either at the replication fork or during repair replication following excision of a DNA lesion. Neither a dnaE mutator gene (leading to a defective subunit of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme) nor a mutD5 mutator gene (leading to a defective ε proofreading subunit) had any effect on he misincorporation step. Although this is consistent with DNA polymerase III holoenzyme not being involved in the misincorporation step, other interpretations involving the inhibition of ε proofreading activity by recA protein are possible.

In vitro studies are reported in which sites of termination of synthesis by DNA polymerase III holoenzyme on UV-irradiated M13 mp8 DNA were examined in the presence of inhibitors of the 3′–5′ proofreading exonuclease (including recA protein). No evidence was found for incorporation of bases opposite photoproducts suggesting that either inhibition is more complete in the cell and/or that other factors are involved in the misincorporation step.     

An Escherichia coli dnaE mutation with suppressor activity toward mutator mutD5.

The Escherichia coli mutator mutD5 is a conditional mutator whose strength is moderate when the strain is growing in minimal medium but very strong when it is growing in rich medium. The primary defect of this strain resides in the dnaQ gene, which encodes the epsilon (exonucleolytic proofreading) subunit of the DNA polymerase III holoenzyme. In one of our mutD5 strains we discovered a mutation that suppressed the mutability of mutD5. Interestingly, the level of suppression was strong in minimal medium but weak in rich medium. The mutation was localized to the dnaE gene, which encodes the alpha (polymerase) subunit of the DNA polymerase III holoenzyme. This mutation, termed dnaE910, also conferred improved growth of the mutD5 strain and caused increased temperature sensitivity in both wild-type and dnaQ49 backgrounds. The reduction in mutator strength by dnaE910 was also observed when this allele was placed in a mutL, a mutT, or a dnaQ49 background. The results suggest that dnaE910 encodes an antimutator DNA polymerase whose effect might be mediated by improved insertion fidelity or by increased proofreading via its effect on the exonuclease activity.     

The polymerase subunit of DNA polymerase III of Escherichia coli. II. Purification of the alpha subunit, devoid of nuclease activities

The alpha subunit (140 kDa) of DNA polymerase III (pol III) holoenzyme has been purified to near-homogeneity from a plasmid-carrying Escherichia coli strain which overproduced the alpha subunit about 20-fold. Pol III core (containing only the alpha, epsilon, and theta subunits), produced at twice the normal level, was also purified in good yield. The isolated alpha subunit has DNA polymerase activity, which is completely inhibited by 10 mM N-ethylmaleimide or 150 mM KCl as observed in the pol III core or holoenzyme. The alpha subunit has an apparent turnover number of 7.7 nucleotides polymerized per s, compared to 20 for pol III core, and is more thermolabile. The alpha subunit lacks the 3'----5' exonuclease (proofreading) activity of pol III core; neither alpha subunit nor core (nor holoenzyme) possesses any of the previously reported 5'----3' exonuclease activity. Thus, the alpha polypeptide is the polymerase subunit and epsilon (27 kDa) is the proofreading subunit (Scheuermann, R. H., and Echols, H. (1984) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 81, 7747-7751). Together with the theta polypeptide (10 kDa), of unknown function, they form a pol III core with greater stability and catalytic efficiency.     

umuC-dependent and umuC-independent gamma- and UV-radiation mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

The effects of the umuC36 and umuC122::Tn 5 mutations on gamma- and UV radiation mutagenesis (nonsense, missense, and frameshift mutation assays) in Escherichia coli K12 were studied. Although both mutations reduced radiation mutagenesis, the umuC36 mutation appeared to be leaky since considerably more UV radiation mutagenesis could be detected in the umuC36 strain than in the umuC122::Tn 5 strain. In general, the umuC strain showed much larger deficiencies in UV radiation mutagenesis than they did for gamma-radiation mutagenesis. The mutability of the umuC122:: Tn 5 strain varied depending on the radiation dose, and the mutation assay used. For gamma-radiation mutagenesis, the deficiency varied from no deficiency to a 50-fold deficiency; for UV radiation mutagenesis, the deficiency varied from 100-fold to at least 5000-fold. We concluded that both umuC-dependent and umuC-independent modes function for gamma-radiation mutagenesis, while UV radiation mutagenesis seems to depend almost exclusively on the umuC-dependent mode.     

The theta subunit of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase III: a role in stabilizing the epsilon proofreading subunit

The function of the theta subunit of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase III holoenzyme is not well established. theta is a tightly bound component of the DNA polymerase III core, which contains the alpha subunit (polymerase), the epsilon subunit (3'-->5' exonuclease), and the theta subunit, in the linear order alpha-epsilon-theta. Previous studies have shown that the theta subunit is not essential, as strains carrying a deletion of the holE gene (which encodes theta) proved fully viable. No significant phenotypic effects of the holE deletion could be detected, as the strain displayed normal cell health, morphology, and mutation rates. On the other hand, in vitro experiments have indicated the efficiency of the 3'-exonuclease activity of epsilon to be modestly enhanced by the presence of theta. Here, we report a series of genetic experiments that suggest that theta has a stabilizing role for the epsilon proofreading subunit. The observations include (i) defined DeltaholE mutator effects in mismatch-repair-defective mutL backgrounds, (ii) strong DeltaholE mutator effects in certain proofreading-impaired dnaQ strains, and (iii) yeast two- and three-hybrid experiments demonstrating enhancement of alpha-epsilon interactions by the presence of theta. theta appears conserved among gram-negative organisms which have an exonuclease subunit that exists as a separate protein (i.e., not part of the polymerase polypeptide), and the presence of theta might be uniquely beneficial in those instances where the proofreading 3'-exonuclease is not part of the polymerase polypeptide.     

DNA polymerase III of Escherichia coli. Purification and identification of subunits.

DNA polymerase III, the core of the DNA polymerase III holoenzyme, has been purified 28,000-fold to 97% homogeneity from Escherichia coli HMS-83. The enzyme contains subunits: alpha, epsilon, and theta of 140,000, 25,000, and 10,000 daltons, respectively. The alpha subunit has been previously shown to be a component of both DNA polymerase III and the more complex DNA polymerase III holoenzyme (Livingston, D.M., Hinkle, D., and Richardson, C. (1975) J. Biol. Chem. 250, 461-469; McHenry, C., and Kornberg, A. (1977) J. Biol. Chem. 252, 6478-6484). It is demonstrated here that the epsilon and theta subunits are also subunits of the DNA polymerase III holoenzyme. Thus, the DNA polymerase III holoenzyme contains at least six different subunits. Our preparation has both the 3' leads to 5' and 5' leads to 3' exonuclease activities previously assigned to DNA polymerase III (Livingston, D., and Richardson, C. (1975) J. Biol. Chem. 250, 470-478).     

The interaction of the Escherichia coli mutD and mutT pathways in the prevention of A:T-->C:G transversions.

The Escherichia coli mutT mutator allele produces high frequencies of exclusively A:T-->C:G transversions. This is thought to be caused by a failure to prevent or remove A:G mispairs during DNA replication. The mutD5 mutator allele maps to the dnaQ locus which encodes the epsilon subunit of the DNA polymerase III holoenzyme. This subunit provides 3'-->5' exonuclease, proofreading, activity for removing mispaired nucleotides at the 3' end of the newly synthesized DNA strand. mutD5 has an altered epsilon resulting in reduced levels of proofreading and subsequent high mutation frequencies for all base-pair substitutions. We have analyzed the interaction between mutD5 and mutT-induced A:T-->C:G transversions by measuring reversion frequencies in mutD5 and mutT single mutator strains and mutD5mutT double mutator strains using the well-characterized trpA58 and trpA88 alleles. We find that the double mutator strains produce more A:T-->C:G substitutions than would be expected from simple additivity of the single mutator strains. We interpret this to mean that the two systems, at least in part, do act together to prevent the same mutational intermediate from producing A:T-->C:G transversions. It is estimated that over 90% of the mutT-induced A:G mispairs are corrected by proofreading at the trpA58 site while only about 30% are corrected at trpA88. Reversion frequencies in the mutD5mutT double mutator strains indicate A:G misincorporations occur about 100 x more frequently at trpA58 than at the trpA88 site. Using these and other data we also provide estimations of the fidelity contributions for mutT editing, proofreading and methyl-directed mismatch repair at the two trpA sites for both transversions and the transition that could be scored. In the case of A:T-->C:G transversions, both mutT editing and proofreading make major contributions in error reduction with mismatch repair playing a small or no role at all. For the A:T-->G:C transition, proofreading and mismatch repair were both important in preventing mutations while no contribution was observed for mutT editing.     

Mutagenic DNA repair in Escherichia coli. XV. Mutation frequency decline of ochre suppressor mutations in umuC and lexA bacteria occurring between ultraviolet irradiation and delayed photoreversal

Tryptophan-independent mutations were induced in CM1141 trpE65 umuC122::Tn5 following exposure to ultraviolet light (UV) plus delayed photoreversal. The mutations appeared to be exclusively class 2 ochre suppressors and showed mutation frequency decline (MFD) when the bacteria were incubated in glucose-salts medium after UV and before photoreversal. The phenomenon was similar to MFD after normal UV mutagenesis of umu+ bacteria, being inhibited in the presence of caffeine or in the absence of glucose. Mutations were also induced by UV plus delayed photoreversal in the lexA (Ind-) strain CM561, and the yield was higher than in the umuC strain suggesting that potentially mutagenic configurations might be removed or altered to some extent by the product of a gene under lexA control such that fewer were available for misincorporation events. MFD was also demonstrated in CM561 showing that this process is not dependent on the derepression of any genes under lexA control. MFD could still be demonstrated 23 min after UV at a time when most misincorporations seem to have occurred, but for technical reasons the possibility could not be excluded that the misincorporations in question could have occurred during rather than before the exposure to photoreversing light. Delayed photoreversal mutagenesis of normally non-UV-mutable strains has been interpreted as a first stage (misincorporation) of normal UV mutagenesis. The present results are consistent with this interpretation since MFD of suppressor mutations is a feature of both processes.     

holE, the gene coding for the theta subunit of DNA polymerase III of Escherichia coli: characterization of a holE mutant and comparison with a dnaQ (epsilon-subunit) mutant.

DNA polymerase III holoenzyme is a multiprotein complex responsible for the bulk of chromosomal replication in Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium. The catalytic core of the holoenzyme is an alpha epsilon theta heterotrimer that incorporates both a polymerase subunit (alpha; dnaE) and a proofreading subunit (epsilon; dnaQ). The role of theta is unknown. Here, we describe a null mutation of holE, the gene for theta. A strain carrying this mutation was fully viable and displayed no mutant phenotype. In contrast, a dnaQ null mutant exhibited poor growth, chronic SOS induction, and an elevated spontaneous mutation rate, like dnaQ null mutants of S. typhimurium described previously. The poor growth was suppressible by a mutation affecting alpha which was identical to a suppressor mutation identified in S. typhimurium. A double mutant null for both holE and dnaQ was indistinguishable from the dnaQ single mutant. These results show that the theta subunit is dispensable in both dnaQ+ and mutant dnaQ backgrounds, and that the phenotype of epsilon mutants cannot be explained on the basis of interference with theta function.     

Cloning of Salmonella typhimurium DNA encoding mutagenic DNA repair.

Mutagenic DNA repair in Escherichia coli is encoded by the umuDC operon. Salmonella typhimurium DNA which has homology with E. coli umuC and is able to complement E. coli umuC122::Tn5 and umuC36 mutations has been cloned. Complementation of umuD44 mutants and hybridization with E. coli umuD also occurred, but these activities were much weaker than with umuC. Restriction enzyme mapping indicated that the composition of the cloned fragment is different from the E. coli umuDC operon. Therefore, a umu-like function of S. typhimurium has been found; the phenotype of this function is weaker than that of its E. coli counterpart, which is consistent with the weak mutagenic response of S. typhimurium to UV compared with the response in E. coli.     

Specificities mediated by neighboring nucleotides appear to underlie mutation induced by antifolates in E. coli

The antifolate, trimethoprim (TRMP, 5 microM) caused a 10-fold increase in mutation frequency and primarily induced base substitution and deletion mutations in wild-type E. coli. Base-substitutions induced by antifolates were equally divided between transition and transversion mutations. When mutations consistent with expected antifolate-induced deoxynucleotide pool imbalances were considered, 29 out of 32 base-substitution mutations in the i-d region of the lacI gene were followed 3' by the same nucleotide substituted at the base mismatch site and all but one mutation occurred at sites consistent with next nucleotide effects resulting from antifolate-induced deoxynucleotide pool alterations. 66% of the TRMP-induced base-substitutions were also found at sites of frequent mutation identified in the spontaneous spectrum of a mutator D5 strain of E. coli which is deficient in the 3'-exonucleolytic proofreading function of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme. These results suggest that the pool imbalances induced by the antifolate trimethoprim compromise the proofreading activity of polymerase III holoenzyme and lead to mutation at specific sites. The results also imply that not all DNA sequence environments encountered by DNA polymerase III holoenzyme and its accompanying exonuclease are handled with equal facility at the level of nucleotide insertion and exonucleolytic proofreading when the enzyme is faced with an intracellular nucleotide pool imbalance. A number of small deletion and duplication mutations were also induced by the antifolate trimethoprim. In most cases these mutations were flanked by at least two A:T base pairs which could facilitate DNA-strand breakage at deoxyuridine misincorporation sites.     

Nucleoside triphosphate binding to DNA polymerase III holoenzyme of Escherichia coli. A direct photoaffinity labeling study

The physical basis of ATP binding and activation of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme was studied by an ultraviolet irradiation cross-linking technique. ATP and dATP were photocrosslinked to the alpha, tau, gamma, and delta subunits of holoenzyme; photocrosslinking of dATP was competitively inhibited by ATP. No photocrosslinking was observed with GTP or CTP, nor did GTP, CTP, or UTP inhibit cross-linking of ATP. ADP and adenosine 5'-O-(3-thio)-triphosphate, both potent inhibitors of ATP activation of holoenzyme, inhibited cross-linking of ATP to tau, gamma, and delta subunits, but not to the alpha subunit, suggesting that one or more of these subunits are ATP (or dATP)-binding sites. Photocrosslinking of dTTP to the ATP-activated holoenzyme was exclusively to the epsilon subunit, the dnaQ ( mutD ) gene product; dCTP and dGTP were not photocrosslinked to any subunit. Binding of dTTP was enhanced by ATP, but by no other nucleotide (or deoxynucleotide). This binding of dTTP to epsilon, a subunit likely responsible for regulation of proofreading by the holoenzyme, may function in the control of the fidelity of replication.     

Overproduction of the beta subunit of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme reduces UV mutagenesis in Escherichia coli.

Overproduction of the beta subunit of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme caused a 5- to 10-fold reduction of UV mutagenesis along with a slight increase in sensitivity to UV light in Escherichia coli. The same effects were observed in excision-deficient cells, excluding the possibility that they were mediated via changes in excision repair. In contrast, overproduction of the alpha subunit of the polymerase did not influence either UV mutagenesis or UV sensitivity. The presence of the mutagenesis proteins MucA and MucB expressed from a plasmid alleviated the effect of overproduced beta on UV mutagenesis. We have previously suggested that DNA polymerase III holoenzyme can exist in two forms: beta-rich form unable to bypass UV lesions and a beta-poor form capable of bypassing UV lesions (O. Shavitt and Z. Livneh, J. Biol. Chem. 264:11275-11281, 1989). The beta-poor form may be related to an SOS form of DNA polymerase III designed to perform translesion polymerization under SOS conditions and thereby generate mutations. On the basis of this model, we propose that the overproduced beta subunit affects the relative abundance of the regular replicative beta-rich polymerase and the SOS bypass-proficient polymerase by sequestering the polymerase molecules to the beta-rich form and blocking the SOS form.     

Regulatory role of recF in the SOS response of Escherichia coli: impaired induction of SOS genes by UV irradiation and nalidixic acid in a recF mutant

We isolated a new recF mutant of Escherichia coli K-12 by insertion of transposon Tn5 into the recF gene. This recF400::Tn5 allele displayed the same phenotypic characteristics as the classic recF143 mutation. By using Mu d(Ap lac) fusions, the induction of nine SOS genes, including recA, umuC, dinA, dinB, dinD, dinF, recN, and sulA, by UV irradiation and nalidixic acid was examined. Induction of eight genes by the two agents was impaired by recF400::Tn5 to different extents. The ninth fused SOS gene, dinF, was no longer inducible by UV when combined with recF400::Tn5. The generally impaired SOS response in recF strains did not result from weak induction of recA protein synthesis, since a recA operator-constitutive mutation did not alleviate the inhibitory effect of the recF mutation. The results suggest that recF plays a regulatory role in the SOS response. It is proposed that this role is to optimize the signal usage by recA protein to become a protease.     

Fidelity of DNA polymerase epsilon holoenzyme from budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae

DNA polymerases delta and epsilon (pol delta and epsilon) are the major replicative polymerases and possess 3'-5' proofreading exonuclease activities that correct errors arising during DNA replication in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. This study measures the fidelity of the holoenzyme of wild-type pol epsilon, the 3'-5' exonuclease-deficient pol2-4, a +1 frameshift mutator for homonucleotide runs, pol2C1089Y, and pol2C1089Y pol2-4 enzymes using a synthetic 30-mer primer/100-mer template. The nucleotide substitution rate for wild-type pol epsilon was 0.47 x 10(-5) for G:G mismatches, 0.15 x 10(-5) for T:G mismatches, and less than 0.01 x 10(-5) for A:G mismatches. The accuracy for A opposite G was not altered in the exonuclease-deficient pol2-4 pol epsilon; however, G:G and T:G misincorporation rates increased 40- and 73-fold, respectively. The pol2C1089Y pol epsilon mutant also exhibited increased G:G and T:G misincorporation rates, 22- and 10-fold, respectively, whereas A:G misincorporation did not differ from that of wild type. Since the fidelity of the double mutant pol2-4 pol2C1089Y was not greatly decreased, these results suggest that the proofreading 3'-5' exonuclease activity of pol2C1089Y pol epsilon is impaired even though it retains nuclease activity and the mutation is not in the known exonuclease domain.     

Contribution of 3' leads to 5' exonuclease activity of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme from Escherichia coli to specificity

The effects of deoxynucleoside monophosphates on the 3' leads to 5' exonuclease activity of DNA polymerase III holoenzyme have been correlated with their effects on the fidelity of DNA replication. In particular, dGMP inhibits the proofreading activity of the enzyme and decreases the fidelity in those cases where a "following nucleotide effect" is also noted. This is strong evidence for proofreading. However, the absence of the effects of proofreading inhibitors or following nucleotides need not be evidence against the occurrence of proofreading: a theoretical analysis shows that these effects may not be observed even though there is active proofreading. This is suggested to be the case with the phage T4 enzyme system. The proofreading activity of Pol III appears to be directed primarily towards removing purine x pyrimidine-mediated rather than purine x purine-mediated misincorporations. recA protein inhibits the proofreading activity of Pol III on synthetic templates containing mismatched 3' termini. This is paralleled by a decrease in the fidelity of DNA replication in vitro. The inhibition is increased in the presence of dGMP or dAMP but there is no further increase in the infidelity of replication. The presence of both dNMPs and recA protein does not enable Pol III to copy past pyrimidine photodimers.     

Resolving a fidelity paradox: why Escherichia coli DNA polymerase II makes more base substitution errors in AT- compared with GC-rich DNA.

The activity of DNA polymerase-associated proofreading 3'-exonucleases is generally enhanced in less stable DNA regions leading to a reduction in base substitution error frequencies in AT- versus GC-rich sequences. Unexpectedly, however, the opposite result was found for Escherichia coli DNA polymerase II (pol II). Nucleotide misincorporation frequencies for pol II were found to be 3-5-fold higher in AT- compared with GC-rich DNA, both in the presence and absence of polymerase processivity subunits, beta dimer and gamma complex. In contrast, E. coli pol III holoenzyme, behaving "as expected," exhibited 3-5-fold lower misincorporation frequencies in AT-rich DNA. A reduction in fidelity in AT-rich regions occurred for pol II despite having an associated 3'-exonuclease proofreading activity that preferentially degrades AT-rich compared with GC-rich DNA primer-template in the absence of DNA synthesis. Concomitant with a reduction in fidelity, pol II polymerization efficiencies were 2-6-fold higher in AT-rich DNA, depending on sequence context. Pol II paradoxical fidelity behavior can be accounted for by the enzyme's preference for forward polymerization in AT-rich sequences. The more efficient polymerization suppresses proofreading thereby causing a significant increase in base substitution error rates in AT-rich regions.     

Structure of the Escherichia coli DNA polymerase III epsilon-HOT proofreading complex

The epsilon subunit of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase III possesses 3'-exonucleolytic proofreading activity. Within the Pol III core, epsilon is tightly bound between the alpha subunit (DNA polymerase) and subunit. Here, we present the crystal structure of epsilon in complex with HOT, the bacteriophage P1-encoded homolog of , at 2.1 A resolution. The epsilon-HOT interface is defined by two areas of contact: an interaction of the previously unstructured N terminus of HOT with an edge of the epsilon central beta-sheet as well as interactions between HOT and the catalytically important helix alpha1-loop-helix alpha2 motif of epsilon. This structure provides insight into how HOT and, by implication, may stabilize the epsilon subunit, thus promoting efficient proofreading during chromosomal replication.