Two nuclear mutations disrupt distinct pathways for targeting proteins to the chloroplast thylakoid.

Results of in vitro experiments have suggested the existence of at least three pathways by which nuclear-encoded proteins are targeted to the chloroplast thylakoid membrane. However, few components of the targeting machinery have been identified and the relationship between the three pathways is not clear. To investigate mechanisms underlying thylakoid protein targeting, we identified nuclear mutations in maize that cause targeting defects. We found two mutations, tha1 and hcf106, that disrupt the localization of different sets of proteins to the thylakoid lumen. The tha1 mutation interferes with the targeting of one chloroplast-encoded protein, cytochrome f, and three nuclear-encoded proteins, plastocyanin, the psaF gene product and the 33 kDa subunit of the oxygen-evolving complex. The hcf106 mutation interferes with the targeting of the 16 and 23 kDa subunits of the oxygen-evolving complex. The tha1 and hcf106 phenotypes provide the first in vivo evidence supporting the existence of two distinct thylakoid-targeting pathways. Their phenotypes also provide evidence that one chloroplast-encoded protein, cytochrome f, engages the 'tha1' pathway, indicating that nuclear- and chloroplast-encoded proteins can be targeted via common machinery.     

Component specificity for the thylakoidal Sec and Delta pH-dependent protein transport pathways.

Prokaryotes and prokaryote-derived thylakoid membranes of chloroplasts share multiple, evolutionarily conserved pathways for protein export. These include the Sec, signal recognition particle (SRP), and Delta pH/Tat systems. Little is known regarding the thylakoid membrane components involved in these pathways. We isolated a cDNA clone to a novel component of the Delta pH pathway, Tha4, and prepared antibodies against pea Tha4, against maize Hcf106, a protein implicated in Delta pH pathway transport by genetic studies, and against cpSecY, the thylakoid homologue of the bacterial SecY translocon protein. These components were localized to the nonappressed thylakoid membranes. Tha4 and Hcf106 were present in approximately 10-fold excess over active translocation sites. Antibodies to either Tha4 or Hcf106 inhibited translocation of four known Delta pH pathway substrate proteins, but not of Sec pathway or SRP pathway substrates. This suggests that Tha4 and Hcf106 operate either in series or as subunits of a heteromultimeric complex. cpSecY antibodies inhibited translocation of Sec pathway substrates but not of Delta pH or SRP pathway substrates. These studies provide the first biochemical evidence that Tha4 and Hcf106 are specific components of the Delta pH pathway and provide one line of evidence that cpSecY is used specifically by the Sec pathway.     

Overlapping functions of components of a bacterial Sec-independent protein export pathway.

We describe the identification of two Escherichia coli genes required for the export of cofactor-containing periplasmic proteins, synthesized with signal peptides containing a twin arginine motif. Both gene products are homologous to the maize HCF106 protein required for the translocation of a subset of lumenal proteins across the thylakoid membrane. Disruption of either gene affects the export of a range of such proteins, and a complete block is observed when both genes are inactivated. The Sec protein export pathway was unaffected, indicating the involvement of the gene products in a novel export system. The accumulation of active cofactor-containing proteins in the cytoplasm of the mutant strains suggests a role for the gene products in the translocation of folded proteins. One of the two HCF106 homologues is encoded by the first gene of a four cistron operon, tatABCD, and the second by an unlinked gene, tatE. A mutation previously assigned to the hcf106 homologue encoded at the tatABCD locus, mttA, lies instead in the tatB gene.     

Duplication and suppression of chloroplast protein translocation genes in maize

The HCF106 (high chlorophyll fluorescence) gene of maize encodes a chloroplast membrane protein required for translocation of a subset of proteins across the thylakoid membrane. Mutations in HCF106 caused by the insertion of Robertson's Mutator transposable elements have been mapped to chromosome 2S. Here we show that there is a closely related homolog of HCF106 encoded elsewhere in the maize genome (HCF106c) that can partially compensate for these mutations. This homolog maps on chromosome 10L and is part of the most recent set of segmental duplications in the maize genome. Triple mutants that are disrupted in both the HCF106 and Sec-dependent protein translocation pathways provide evidence that they act independently. The HCF106c gene accounts for a previously reported exception to the correlation between epigenetic suppression of hcf106 and methylation of Mutator transposons. We also demonstrate that insertions of Robertson's Mutator elements into either introns or promoters can lead to mutations whose phenotypes are suppressed in the absence of Mu activity, while alleles with insertions in both positions are not suppressed. The implications of these observations are discussed.     

Sec-independent protein translocation in Escherichia coli. A distinct and pivotal role for the TatB protein

In Escherichia coli, transmembrane translocation of proteins can proceed by a number of routes. A subset of periplasmic proteins are exported via the Tat pathway to which proteins are directed by N-terminal "transfer peptides" bearing the consensus (S/T)RRXFLK "twin-arginine" motif. The Tat system involves the integral membrane proteins TatA, TatB, TatC, and TatE. Of these, TatA, TatB, and TatE are homologues of the Hcf106 component of the DeltapH-dependent protein import system of plant thylakoids. Deletion of the tatB gene alone is sufficient to block the export of seven endogenous Tat substrates, including hydrogenase-2. Complementation analysis indicates that while TatA and TatE are functionally interchangeable, the TatB protein is functionally distinct. This conclusion is supported by the observation that Helicobacter pylori tatA will complement an E. coli tatA mutant, but not a tatB mutant. Analysis of Tat component stability in various tat deletion backgrounds shows that TatC is rapidly degraded in the absence of TatB suggesting that TatC complexes, and is stabilized by, TatB.     

Functional assembly of thylakoid deltapH-dependent/Tat protein transport pathway components in vitro.

Assembly of the components of the thylakoid deltapH-dependent/Tat protein transport machinery was analyzed in vitro. Upon incubation with intact chloroplasts, precursors to all three components, Hcf106, cpTatC and Tha4, were imported into the organelle and assembled into characteristic endogenous complexes. In particular, all of the imported cpTatC and approximately two-thirds of the imported Hcf106 functionally assembled into 700 kDa complexes capable of binding Tat pathway precursor proteins. The amounts assembled into thylakoids by this procedure were moderate. However, physiological quantities of mature forms of Tha4 and Hcf106 were integrated into isolated thylakoids and a significant percentage of the Hcf106 so integrated was assembled into the 700 kDa complex. Interestingly, a mutant form of Hcf106 in which an invariant transmembrane glutamate was changed to glutamine integrated into the membrane but did not assemble into the receptor complex. Analysis of energy and known pathway component requirements indicated that Hcf106 and Tha4 integrate by an unassisted or 'spontaneous' mechanism. The functionality of in vitro integrated Tha4 was verified by its ability to restore transport to thylakoid membranes from the maize tha4 mutant, which lacks the Tha4 protein. Development of this functional in vitro assembly assay will facilitate structure-function studies of the thylakoid Tat pathway translocation machinery.     

Old and new pathways of protein export in chloroplasts and bacteria

Targeting of chloroplast proteins to the thylakoid membrane is analogous to bacterial secretion, and much of what we know has been learned from secretory mechanisms in Escherichia coli. However, chloroplasts also use a ΔpH-dependent pathway to target thylakoid proteins, at least some of which are folded before transport. Previously, this pathway seemed to have no cognate in bacteria, but recent results have shown that the HCF106 gene in maize encodes a component of this pathway and has bacterial homologues. This ΔpH-dependent pathway might be an ancient conserved mechanism for protein translocation that evolved before the endosymbiotic origin of plastids and mitochondria.     

Precursors bind to specific sites on thylakoid membranes prior to transport on the delta pH protein translocation system

The Delta pH pathway is one of two systems for protein transport to the thylakoid lumen. It is a novel transport system that requires only the thylakoidal DeltapH to power translocation. Several substrates of the Delta pH pathway, including the intermediate precursor form of OE17 (iOE17) and the truncated precursor form of OE17 (tOE17), were shown to bind to the membrane in the absence of the DeltapH and be transported into the lumen when the DeltapH was restored. Binding occurred without energy or soluble factors, and efficient transport from the bound state ( approximately 80-90%) required only the DeltapH. Binding is due to protein-protein interactions because protease pretreatment of thylakoids destroyed their binding capability. Precursors are bound to a specific site on the Delta pH pathway because binding was competed by saturating amounts of Delta pH pathway precursor proteins, but not by a Sec pathway precursor protein. These results suggested that precursor tOE17 binds to components of the Delta pathway translocation machinery. Hcf106 and Tha4 are two components of the Delta pH pathway machinery. Antibodies to Hcf106 or Tha4, when prebound to thylakoids, specifically inhibited precursor transport on the Delta pH pathway. However, only Hcf106 antibodies reduced the level of precursor binding. These results suggest that Hcf106 functions in early steps of the transport process.     

Caspase activation in response to cytotoxic Rana catesbeiana ribonuclease in MCF-7 cells

The thylakoid (Delta)pH-dependent pathway transports folded proteins. Identified components include Hcf106 and Tha4. Orthologs of these proteins plus a membrane protein called TatC are essential for the homologous bacterial Tat system. Here we report identification of a chloroplast TatC (cpTatC). cpTatC is an integral thylakoid membrane protein as determined by in vitro chloroplast import and immunoblotting. Antibody to cpTatC specifically inhibited the thylakoid (Delta)pH-dependent pathway in vitro. cpTatC is present in about the same quantity as estimated translocation sites, whereas Hcf106 and Tha4 are present in 5-8-fold excess. These results are relevant to mechanistic models for this system.     

A putative twin-arginine translocation system in the phytopathogenic bacterium Xylella fastidiosa

The twin-arginine translocation (Tat) pathway of the xylem-limited phytopathogenic bacterium Xylella fastidiosa strain 9a5c, responsible for citrus variegated chlorosis, was explored. The presence of tatA, tatB, and tatC in the X. fastidiosa genome together with a list of proteins harboring 2 consecutive arginines in their signal peptides suggested the presence of a Tat pathway. The functional Tat dependence of X. fastidiosa OpgD was examined. Native or mutated signal peptides were fused to the β-lactamase. Expression of fusion with intact signal peptides mediated high resistance to ampicillin in Escherichia coli tat+ but not in the E. coli tat null mutant. The replacement of the 2 arginines by 2 lysines prevented the export of β-lactamase in E. coli tat+, demonstrating that X. fastidiosa OpgD carries a signal peptide capable of engaging the E. coli Tat machinery. RT-PCR analysis revealed that the tat genes are transcribed as a single operon. tatA, tatB, and tatC genes were cloned. Complementation assays in E. coli devoid of all Tat or TatC components were unsuccessful, whereas X. fastidiosa Tat components led to a functional Tat translocase in E. coli TatB-deficient strain. Additional experiments implicated that X. fastidiosa TatB component could form a functional heterologous complex with the E. coli TatC component.     

A putative twin-arginine translocation pathway in Legionella pneumophila

Legionella pneumophila is a facultative intracellular human pathogen causing Legionnaires' disease, a severe form of pneumonia. Because of the importance of secretion pathways in virulence, we were interested in the possible presence of the twin-arginine translocation (Tat) pathway in L. pneumophila. This secretion pathway is used to transport folded proteins, characterized by two arginines in their signal peptide, across the cytoplasmic membrane. We describe here the presence of a putative Tat pathway in L. pneumophila. Three genes encoding Escherichia coli TatA, TatB, and TatC homologues were identified. The tatA and tatB genes were shown to constitute an operon while tatC is monocistronic. RT-PCR analysis revealed expression of the tat genes during both exponential and stationary growth as well as during intracellular growth in Acanthamoeba castellanii. A search for the conserved twin-arginine motif in predicted signal peptides resulted in a list of putative Tat substrates.     

Functional analysis of the twin-arginine translocation pathway in Corynebacterium glutamicum ATCC 13869

Compared to those of other gram-positive bacteria, the genetic structure of the Corynebacterium glutamicum Tat system is unique in that it contains the tatE gene in addition to tatA, tatB, and tatC. The tatE homologue has been detected only in the genomes of gram-negative enterobacteria. To assess the function of the C. glutamicum Tat pathway, we cloned the tatA, tatB, tatC, and tatE genes from C. glutamicum ATCC 13869 and constructed mutants carrying deletions of each tat gene or of both the tatA and tatE genes. Using green fluorescent protein (GFP) fused with the twin-arginine signal peptide of the Escherichia coli TorA protein, we demonstrated that the minimal functional Tat system required TatA and TatC. TatA and TatE provide overlapping function. Unlike the TatB proteins from gram-negative bacteria, C. glutamicum TatB was dispensable for Tat function, although it was required for maximal efficiency of secretion. The signal peptide sequence of the isomaltodextranase (IMD) of Arthrobacter globiformis contains a twin-arginine motif. We showed that both IMD and GFP fused with the signal peptide of IMD were secreted via the C. glutamicum Tat pathway. These observations indicate that IMD is a bona fide Tat substrate and imply great potential of the C. glutamicum Tat system for industrial production of heterologous folded proteins.     

Evidence for a dynamic and transient pathway through the TAT protein transport machinery

Tat systems transport completely folded proteins across ion-tight membranes. Three membrane proteins comprise the Tat machinery in most systems. In thylakoids, cpTatC and Hcf106 mediate precursor recognition, whereas Tha4 facilitates translocation. We used chimeric precursor proteins with unstructured peptides and folded domains to test predictions of competing translocation models. Two models invoke protein-conducting channels, whereas another model proposes that cpTatC pulls substrates through a patch of Tha4 on the lipid bilayer. The thylakoid system transported unstructured peptide substrates alone or when fused to folded domains. However, larger substrates stalled before completion, some with amino- and carboxyl-folded domains on opposite sides of the membrane. The length of the precursor that resulted in translocation arrest (20 to 30 nm) exceeded that expected for a single 'pull' mechanism, suggesting that a sustained driving force rather than a single pull moves the protein across the bilayer. Three different methods showed that stalled substrates were not stuck in a channel or even associated with Tat machinery. This finding favors the Tha4 patch model for translocation.     

The thylakoid delta pH-dependent pathway machinery facilitates RR-independent N-tail protein integration

The thylakoidal DeltapH-dependent and bacterial twin arginine transport systems are structurally and functionally related protein export machineries. These recently discovered systems have been shown to transport folded proteins but are not known to assemble integral membrane proteins. We determined the translocation pathway of a thylakoidal FtsH homologue, plastid fusion/protein translocation factor, which is synthesized with a chloroplast-targeting peptide, a hydrophobic signal peptide, and a hydrophobic membrane anchor. The twin arginine motif in its signal peptide and its sole integration requirement of a DeltapH suggested that plastid fusion/protein translocation factor employs the DeltapH pathway. Surprisingly, changing the twin arginine to twin lysine or deleting the signal peptide did not abrogate integration capability or characteristics. Nevertheless, three criteria argue that all three forms require the DeltapH pathway for integration. First, integration was competed by an authentic DeltapH pathway precursor. Second, antibodies to DeltapH pathway component Hcf106 specifically inhibited integration. Finally, chloroplasts from the hcf106 null mutant were unable to integrate Pftf into their thylakoids. Thus, DeltapH pathway machinery facilitates both signal peptide-directed and N-tail-mediated membrane integration and does not strictly require the twin arginine motif.     

Genetic Interactions between a Pep7 Mutation and the Pep12 and Vps45 Genes: Evidence for a Novel Snare Component in Transport between the Saccharomyces Cerevisiae Golgi Complex and Endosome

A nuclear mutant of maize, tha1, which exhibited defects in the translocation of proteins across the thylakoid membrane, was described previously. A transposon insertion at the tha1 locus facilitated the cloning of portions of the tha1 gene. Strong sequence similarity with secA genes from bacteria, pea and spinach indicates that tha1 encodes a SecA homologue (cp-SecA). The tha1-ref allele is either null or nearly so, in that tha1 mRNA is undetectable in mutant leaves and cp-SecA accumulation is reduced >=40-fold. These results, in conjunction with the mutant phenotype described previously, demonstrate that cp-SecA functions in vivo to facilitate the translocation of OEC33, PSI-F and plastocyanin but does not function in the translocation of OEC23 and OEC16. Our results confirm predictions for cp-SecA function made from the results of in vitro experiments and establish several new functions for cp-SecA, including roles in the targeting of a chloroplast-encoded protein, cytochrome f, and in protein targeting in the etioplast, a nonphotosynthetic plastid type. Our finding that the accumulation of properly targeted plastocyanin and cytochrome f in tha1-ref thylakoid membranes is reduced only a few-fold despite the near or complete absence of cp-SecA suggests that cp-SecA facilitates but is not essential in vivo for their translocation across the membrane.     

Thylakoid DeltapH-dependent precursor proteins bind to a cpTatC-Hcf106 complex before Tha4-dependent transport

The thylakoid DeltapH-dependent pathway transports folded proteins with twin arginine-containing signal peptides. Identified components of the machinery include cpTatC, Hcf106, and Tha4. The reaction occurs in two steps: precursor binding to the machinery, and transport across the membrane. Here, we show that a cpTatC-Hcf106 complex serves as receptor for specific binding of twin arginine-containing precursors. Antibodies to either Hcf106 or cpTatC, but not Tha4, inhibited precursor binding. Blue native gel electrophoresis and coimmunoprecipitation of digitonin-solubilized thylakoids showed that Hcf106 and cpTatC are members of an approximately 700-kD complex that lacks Tha4. Thylakoid-bound precursor proteins were also associated with an approximately 700-kD complex and were coimmunoprecipitated with antibodies to cpTatC or Hcf106. Chemical cross-linking revealed that precursors make direct contact with cpTatC and Hcf106 and confirmed that Tha4 is not associated with precursor, cpTatC, or Hcf106 in the membrane. Precursor binding to the cpTatC-Hcf106 complex required both the twin arginine and the hydrophobic core of the signal peptide. Precursors remained bound to the complex when Tha4 was sequestered by antibody, even in the presence of DeltapH. These results indicate that precursor binding to the cpTatC-Hcf106 complex constitutes the recognition event for this pathway and that subsequent participation by Tha4 leads to translocation.     

Targeting Determinants and Proposed Evolutionary Basis for the Sec and the Delta pH Protein Transport Systems in Chloroplast Thylakoid Membranes

Transport of proteins to the thylakoid lumen is accomplished by two precursor-specific pathways, the Sec and the unique Delta pH transport systems. Pathway selection is specified by transient lumen-targeting domains (LTDs) on precursor proteins. Here, chimeric and mutant LTDs were used to identify elements responsible for targeting specificity. The results showed that: (a) minimal signal peptide motifs consisting of charged N, hydrophobic H, and cleavage C domains were both necessary and sufficient for pathway-specific targeting; (b) exclusive targeting to the Delta pH pathway requires a twin arginine in the N domain and an H domain that is incompatible with the Sec pathway; (c) exclusive targeting to the Sec pathway is achieved by an N domain that lacks the twin arginine, although the twin arginine was completely compatible with the Sec system. A dual-targeting signal peptide, constructed by combining Delta pH and Sec domains, was used to simultaneously compare the transport capability of both pathways when confronted with different passenger proteins. Whereas Sec passengers were efficiently transported by both pathways, Delta pH passengers were arrested in translocation on the Sec pathway. This finding suggests that the Delta pH mechanism evolved to accommodate transport of proteins incompatible with the thylakoid Sec machinery.     

Site-selected transposon mutagenesis at the hcf106 locus in maize.

The High chlorophyll fluorescence106 (Hcf106) gene in maize is required for chloroplast membrane biogenesis, and the hcf106-mum1 allele is caused by the insertion of a Robertson's Mutator Mu1 element into the promoter of the gene. Seedlings homozygous for hcf106-mum1 are pale green and die 3 weeks after germination, but only in the presence of Mutator activity conferred by active, autonomous Mu regulatory transposons elsewhere in the genome. When Mutator activity is lost, the mutant phenotype is suppressed, and homozygous plants have an almost wild-type phenotype. To isolate derivative alleles at the hcf106 locus that no longer require Mutator activity for phenotypic expression, we have developed a method for site-selected transposon mutagenesis in maize. This procedure, first described for Caenorhabditis elegans and Drosophila, involves using polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to screen pools of individuals for insertions and deletions in genes of known sequence. Pools of seedlings segregating for the progenitor allele hcf106-mum1 were screened by PCR for insertions and deletions associated with Robertson's Mutator. In a 360-bp target region, two new insertions and one deletion were identified in only 700 Mu-active gametes screened. One of the insertions was in the progenitor hcf106-mum1 allele and the other was in the wild-type allele, but all three new alleles were found to have break-points at the same nucleotide in the first intron. Unlike the hcf-106-mum1 progenitor allele, the deletion and one of the insertions conferred pale green seedling lethal phenotypes in the absence of mutator activity. However, the second insertion had a weak, viable phenotype under these conditions.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Truncation analysis of TatA and TatB defines the minimal functional units required for protein translocation

The TatA and TatB proteins are essential components of the twin arginine protein translocation pathway in Escherichia coli. C-terminal truncation analysis of the TatA protein revealed that a plasmid-expressed TatA protein shortened by 40 amino acids is still fully competent to support protein translocation. Similar truncation analysis of TatB indicated that the final 30 residues of TatB are dispensable for function. Further deletion experiments with TatB indicated that removal of even 70 residues from its C terminus still allowed significant transport. These results imply that the transmembrane and amphipathic helical regions of TatA and TatB are critical for their function but that the C-terminal domains are not essential for Tat transport activity. A chimeric protein comprising the N-terminal region of TatA fused to the amphipathic and C-terminal domains of TatB supports a low level of Tat activity in a strain in which the wild-type copy of either tatA or tatB (but not both) is deleted.