The alpha- and beta-tubulin folding pathways

The alpha-beta tubulin heterodimer is the subunit from which microtubules are assembled. The pathway leading to correctly folded alpha- and beta-tubulins is unusually complex: it involves cycles of ATP-dependent interaction of newly synthesized tubulin subunits with cytosolic chaperonin, resulting in the production of quasi-native folding intermediates, which must then be acted upon by additional protein cofactors. These cofactors form a supercomplex containing both alpha- and beta-tubulin polypeptides, from which native heterodimer is released in a GTP-dependent reaction. Here, we discuss the current state of our understanding of the function of cytosolic chaperonin and cofactors in tubulin folding.     

Tubulin Subunits Exist in an Activated Conformational State Generated and Maintained by Protein Cofactors

The production of native α/β tubulin heterodimer in vitro depends on the action of cytosolic chaperonin and several protein cofactors. We previously showed that four such cofactors (termed A, C, D, and E) together with native tubulin act on β-tubulin folding intermediates generated by the chaperonin to produce polymerizable tubulin heterodimers. However, this set of cofactors generates native heterodimers only very inefficiently from α-tubulin folding intermediates produced by the same chaperonin. Here we describe the isolation, characterization, and genetic analysis of a novel tubulin folding cofactor (cofactor B) that greatly enhances the efficiency of α-tubulin folding in vitro. This enabled an integrated study of α- and β-tubulin folding: we find that the pathways leading to the formation of native α- and β-tubulin converge in that the folding of the α subunit requires the participation of cofactor complexes containing the β subunit and vice versa. We also show that sequestration of native α-or β-tubulins by complex formation with cofactors results in the destabilization and decay of the remaining free subunit. These data demonstrate that tubulin folding cofactors function by placing and/or maintaining α-and β-tubulin polypeptides in an activated conformational state required for the formation of native α/β heterodimers, and imply that each subunit provides information necessary for the proper folding of the other.     

Tubulin folding cofactors as GTPase-activating proteins. GTP hydrolysis and the assembly of the alpha/beta-tubulin heterodimer.

In vivo, many proteins must interact with molecular chaperones to attain their native conformation. In the case of tubulin, newly synthesized alpha- and beta-subunits are partially folded by cytosolic chaperonin, a double-toroidal ATPase with homologs in all kingdoms of life and in most cellular compartments. alpha- and beta-tubulin folding intermediates are then brought together by tubulin-specific chaperone proteins (named cofactors A-E) in a cofactor-containing supercomplex with GTPase activity. Here we show that tubulin subunit exchange can only occur by passage through this supercomplex, thus defining it as a dimer-making machine. We also show that hydrolysis of GTP by beta-tubulin in the supercomplex acts as a switch for the release of native tubulin heterodimer. In this folding reaction and in the related reaction of tubulin-folding cofactors with native tubulin, the cofactors behave as GTPase-activating proteins, stimulating the GTP-binding protein beta-tubulin to hydrolyze its GTP.     

Review: postchaperonin tubulin folding cofactors and their role in microtubule dynamics

The microtubule cytoskeleton consists of a highly organized network of microtubule polymers bound to their accessory proteins: microtubule-associated proteins, molecular motors, and microtubule-organizing proteins. The microtubule subunits are heterodimers composed of one alpha-tubulin polypeptide and one beta-tubulin polypeptide that should undergo a complex folding processing before they achieve a quaternary structure that will allow their incorporation into the polymer. Due to the extremely high protein concentration that exists at the cell cytoplasm, there are alpha- and beta-tubulin interacting proteins that prevent the unwanted interaction of these polypeptides with the surrounding protein pool during folding, thus allowing microtubule dynamics. Several years ago, the development of a nondenaturing electrophoretic technique made it possible to identify different tubulin intermediate complexes during tubulin biogenesis in vitro. By these means, the cytosolic chaperonin containing TCP-1 (CCT or TriC) and prefoldin have been demonstrated to intervene through tubulin and actin folding. Various other cofactors also identified along the alpha- and beta-tubulin postchaperonin folding route are now known to have additional roles in tubulin biogenesis such as participating in the synthesis, transport, and storage of alpha- and beta-tubulin. The future characterization of the tubulin-binding sites to these proteins, and perhaps other still unknown proteins, will help in the development of chemicals that could interfere with tubulin folding and thus modulating microtubule dynamics. In this paper, current knowledge of the above postchaperonin folding cofactors, which are in fact chaperones involved in tubulin heterodimer quaternary structure achievement, will be reviewed.     

Possible regulation of microtubules through destabilization of tubulin

Chaperones and folding cofactors are known to mediate posttranslational folding of nascent tubulin, thus forming functional dimers. Based on sequence likeness, a novel protein similar to cofactor E, E-like protein (El), was identified. In overexpression experiments El, similar to a subset of folding factors (i.e. cofactors D and E), appears to disrupt functional dimers and target them for destruction by the proteasome. El apparently does not interact with microtubules directly and has no function in the tubulin folding pathway. Suppression of El expression seems to increase the cellular content of stable, posttranslationally modified microtubules by an unknown mechanism. Degradation of functional tubulin dimers as well as the alteration of the cellular content of stable microtubules through El might regulate the distribution and organization of organelles in vivo.     

Solution structure of a ubiquitin-like domain from tubulin-binding cofactor B

Proper folding and assembly of tubulin alphabeta-heterodimers involves a stepwise progression mediated by a group of protein cofactors A through E. Upon release of the tubulin monomers from the chaperonin CCT, they are acted upon by each cofactor in the folding pathway through a unique combination of protein interaction domains. Three-dimensional structures have previously been reported for cofactor A and the C-terminal CAP-Gly domain of cofactor B (CoB). Here we report the NMR structure of the N-terminal domain of Caenorhabditis elegans CoB and show that it closely resembles ubiquitin as was recently postulated on the basis of bioinformatic analysis (Grynberg, M., Jaroszewski, L., and Godzik, A. (2003) BMC Bioinformatics 4, 46). CoB binds partially folded alpha-tubulin monomers, and a putative tubulin-binding motif within the N-terminal domain is identified from sequence and structure comparisons. Based on modeling of the homologous cofactor E ubiquitin-like domain, we hypothesize that cofactors B and E may associate via their beta-grasp domains in a manner analogous to the PB1 and caspase-activated deoxyribonuclease superfamily of protein interaction domains.     

A chaperone with a hydrophilic surface.

The folding of native tubulin involves at least seven different chaperone proteins: prefoldin, the cytosolic chaperonin CCT and five tubulin-specific chaperone proteins named cofactors A-E. The structure of the yeast homolog of cofactor A, Rbl2p, shows it to be a dimer with largely hydrophilic surfaces, reflecting the fact that it interacts with quasi-native, not unfolded, beta-tubulin.     

Arabidopsis tubulin folding cofactor B interacts with alpha-tubulin in vivo

Microtubule biogenesis requires alphabeta tubulin dimers that are generated from alpha and beta tubulin following post-translational modification by several tubulin folding cofactors (TFCs). Here we report the isolation and characterization of Arabidopsis TFCB (AtTFCB). AtTFCB is expressed in all organs of Arabidopsis. The subcellular localization of AtTFCB is mainly cytosolic. AtTFCB-overexpressing cells have fewer microtubules compared with the controls. Multimode fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) microscopy reveals a direct physical interaction of AtTFCB with alpha tubulin in living plant cells. We conclude that AtTFCB interacts with alpha tubulin in vivo and its overexpression reduces the number of microtubules.     

Dissociation of the tubulin dimer is extremely slow,thermodynamically very unfavorable,and reversible in the absence of an energy source

The finding that exchange of tubulin subunits between tubulin dimers (alpha-beta + alpha'beta' <--> alpha'beta + alphabeta') does not occur in the absence of protein cofactors and GTP hydrolysis conflicts with the assumption that pure tubulin dimer and monomer are in rapid equilibrium. This assumption underlies the many physical chemical measurements of the K(d) for dimer dissociation. To resolve this discrepancy we used surface plasmon resonance to determine the rate constant for dimer dissociation. The half-time for dissociation was approximately 9.6 h with tubulin-GTP, 2.4 h with tubulin-GDP, and 1.3 h in the absence of nucleotide. A Kd equal to 10(-11) M was calculated from the measured rate for dissociation and an estimated rate for association. Dimer dissociation was found to be reversible, and dimer formation does not require GTP hydrolysis or folding information from protein cofactors, because 0.2 microM tubulin-GDP incubated for 20 h was eluted as dimer when analyzed by size exclusion chromatography. Because 20 h corresponds to eight half-times for dissociation, only monomer would be present if dissociation were an irreversible reaction and if dimer formation required GTP or protein cofactors. Additional evidence for a 10(-11) M K(d) was obtained from gel exclusion chromatography studies of 0.02-2 nM tubulin-GDP. The slow dissociation of the tubulin dimer suggests that protein tubulin cofactors function to catalyze dimer dissociation, rather than dimer assembly. Assuming N-site-GTP dissociation is from monomer, our results agree with the 16-h half-time for N-site GTP in vitro and 33 h half-life for tubulin N-site-GTP in CHO cells.     

Chaperonin-mediated folding of vertebrate actin-related protein and gamma-tubulin

The folding of actin and tubulin is mediated via interaction with a heteromeric toroidal complex (cytoplasmic chaperonin) that hydrolyzes ATP as part of the reaction whereby native proteins are ultimately released. Vertebrate actin-related protein (actin-RPV) (also termed centractin) and gamma-tubulin are two proteins that are distantly related to actin and tubulin, respectively: gamma-tubulin is exclusively located at the centrosome, while actin-RPV is conspicuously abundant at the same site. Here we show that actin-RPV and gamma- tubulin are both folded via interaction with the same chaperonin that mediates the folding of beta-actin and alpha- and beta-tubulin. In each case, the unfolded polypeptide forms a binary complex with cytoplasmic chaperonin and is released as a soluble, monomeric protein in the presence of Mg-ATP and the presence or absence of Mg-GTP. In contrast to alpha- and beta-tubulin, the folding of gamma-tubulin does not require the presence of cofactors in addition to chaperonin itself. Monomeric actin-RPV produced in in vitro folding reactions cocycles efficiently with native brain actin, while in vitro folded gamma- tubulin binds to polymerized microtubules in a manner consistent with interaction with microtubule ends. Both monomeric actin-RPV and gamma- tubulin bind to columns of immobilized nucleotide: monomeric actin-RPV has no marked preference for ATP or GTP, while gamma-tubulin shows some preference for GTP binding. We show that actin-RPV and gamma-tubulin compete with one another, and with beta-actin or alpha-tubulin, for binary complex formation with cytoplasmic chaperonin.     

Role of cofactors B (TBCB) and E (TBCE) in tubulin heterodimer dissociation

Tubulin folding cofactors B (TBCB) and E (TBCE) are alpha-tubulin binding proteins that, together with Arl2 and cofactors D (TBCD), A (TBCA or p14) and C (TBCC), participate in tubulin biogenesis. TBCD and TBCE have also been implicated in microtubule dynamics through regulation of tubulin heterodimer dissociation. Understanding the in vivo function of these proteins will shed light on the Kenny-Caffey/Sanjad-Sakati syndrome, an important human disorder associated with TBCE. Here we show that, when overexpressed, TBCB depolymerizes microtubules. We found that this function is based on the ability of TBCB to form a binary complex with TBCE that greatly enhances the efficiency of this cofactor to dissociate tubulin in vivo and in vitro. We also show that TBCE, TBCB and alpha-tubulin form a ternary complex after heterodimer dissociation, whereas the free beta-tubulin subunit is recovered by TBCA. These complexes might serve to escort alpha-tubulin towards degradation or recycling, depending on the cell requirements.     

Properties of microtubules assembled from mammalian tubulin synthesized in Escherichia coli

When isolated from tissues, the alpha beta-dimeric protein tubulin consists of multiple isoforms which originate from the expression and subsequent posttranslational modification of multiple polypeptide sequences. Microtubules studied in vitro consist of mixtures of these isoforms. It is therefore not known whether dimers composed of single sequences of alpha- and beta-tubulin can polymerize to form microtubules, or whether posttranslational modifications may be necessary for microtubule assembly. To initiate investigation of these questions, rabbit reticulocyte lysate, which contains the cytoplasmic chaperonin CCT and its cofactors, was employed to prepare substantial quantities (tens of micrograms) of active tubulin by in vitro folding of mouse alpha- and beta-tubulins recombinantly synthesized in E. coli. This recombinant tubulin is composed of only a single alpha-chain and a single beta-chain. When analyzed after folding by isoelectric focusing, each chain yielded only one band, indicating that neither was detectably posttranslationally modified in the course of the folding reaction. When subjected to assembly-promoting conditions, this tubulin formed microtubules without the addition of any exogenous protein. Electron microscopy showed them to be of normal morphology. Analysis of their protein composition showed that they are composed nearly entirely of recombinant tubulin. These results demonstrate that the naturally occurring mixtures of isoforms are not strictly required for the formation of microtubules. They also open a route to other studies, both biomedical and structural, of fully defined tubulin in vitro.     

Tubulin cofactor B plays a role in the neuronal growth cone

Tubulin cofactors, initially identified as alpha-, beta-tubulin folding proteins, are now believed to participate in the complex tubulin biogenesis and degradation routes, and thus to contribute to microtubule functional diversity and dynamics. However, a concrete role of tubulin cofactor B (TBCB) remains to be elucidated because this protein is not required for tubulin biogenesis, and it is apparently not essential for life in any of the organisms studied. In agreement with these data, here we show that TBCB localizes at the transition zone of the growth cones of growing neurites during neurogenesis where it plays a role in microtubule dynamics and plasticity. Gene silencing by means of small interfering RNA segments revealed that TBCB knockdown enhances axonal growth. In contrast, excess TBCB, a feature of giant axonal neuropathy, leads to microtubule depolymerization, growth cone retraction, and axonal damage followed by neuronal degeneration. These results provide an important insight into the understanding of the controlling mechanisms of growth cone microtubule dynamics.     

Mutations affecting beta-tubulin folding and degradation

Revertants of a colcemid-resistant Chinese hamster ovary cell line with an altered (D45Y) beta-tubulin have allowed the identification of four cis-acting mutations (L187R, Y398C, a 12-amino acid in-frame deletion, and a C-terminal truncation) that act by destabilizing the mutant tubulin and preventing it from incorporating into microtubules. These unstable beta-tubulins fail to form heterodimers and are predominantly found in association with the chaperonin CCT, suggesting that they cannot undergo productive folding. In agreement with these in vivo observations, we show that the defective beta-tubulins do not stably interact with cofactors involved in the tubulin folding pathway and, hence, fail to exchange with beta-tubulin in purified alphabeta heterodimers. Treatment of cells with MG132 causes an accumulation of the aberrant tubulins, indicating that improperly folded beta-tubulin is degraded by the proteasome. Rapid degradation of the mutant tubulin does not elicit compensatory changes in wild-type tubulin synthesis or assembly. Instead, loss of beta-tubulin from the mutant allele causes a 30-40% decrease in cellular tubulin content with no obvious effect on cell growth or survival.     

The solution structure of the N-terminal domain of human tubulin binding cofactor C reveals a platform for tubulin interaction

Human Tubulin Binding Cofactor C (TBCC) is a post-chaperonin involved in the folding and assembly of α- and β-tubulin monomers leading to the release of productive tubulin heterodimers ready to polymerize into microtubules. In this process it collaborates with other cofactors (TBC's A, B, D, and E) and forms a supercomplex with TBCD, β-tubulin, TBCE and α-tubulin. Here, we demonstrate that TBCC depletion results in multipolar spindles and mitotic failure. Accordingly, TBCC is found at the centrosome and is implicated in bipolar spindle formation. We also determine by NMR the structure of the N-terminal domain of TBCC. The TBCC N-terminal domain adopts a spectrin-like fold topology composed of a left-handed 3-stranded α-helix bundle. Remarkably, the 30-residue N-terminal segment of the TBCC N-terminal domain is flexible and disordered in solution. This unstructured region is involved in the interaction with tubulin. Our data lead us to propose a testable model for TBCC N-terminal domain/tubulin recognition in which the highly charged N-terminus as well as residues from the three helices and the loops interact with the acidic hypervariable regions of tubulin monomers.     

Three-dimensional structure of human tubulin chaperone cofactor A

alpha and beta-Tubulin fold in a series of chaperone-assisted steps. At least five protein cofactors are involved in the post-chaperonin tubulin folding pathway and required to maintain the supply of tubulin; some of them also participate in microtubule dynamics. The first tubulin chaperone identified in the tubulin folding pathway was cofactor A (CoA). Here we describe the three-dimensional structure of human CoA at 1.7 A resolution, determined by multiwavelength anomalous diffraction (MAD). The structure is a monomer with a rod-like shape and consists of a three-alpha-helix bundle, or coiled coil, with the second helix kinked by a proline break, offering a convex surface at one face of the protein. The helices are connected by short turns, one of them, between alpha2 and alpha3, including a 3(10)-helix. Peptide mapping analysis and competition experiments with peptides show that CoA interacts with beta-tubulin via the three alpha-helical regions but not with the rod-end loops. The main interaction occurs with the middle kinked alpha2 helix, at the convex face of the rod. Strong 3D structural homology is found with the Hsp70 chaperone cofactor BAG domain, suggesting that these proteins define a family of cofactors of simple compact architecture. Further structural homology is found with alpha-spectrin/alpha-actinin repeats, all are rods of identical length of ten helical turns. We propose to call these three-helix bundles alpha ten modules.     

Cofactor D functions as a centrosomal protein and is required for the recruitment of the gamma-tubulin ring complex at centrosomes and organization of the mitotic spindle

Microtubules are highly dynamic structures, composed of alpha/beta-tubulin heterodimers. Biosynthesis of the functional dimer involves the participation of several chaperones, termed cofactors A-E, that act on folding intermediates downstream of the cytosolic chaperonin CCT (1, 2). We show that cofactor D is also a centrosomal protein and that overexpression of either the full-length protein or either of two centrosome localization domains leads to the loss of anchoring of the gamma-tubulin ring complex and of nucleation of microtubule growth at centrosomes. In contrast, depletion of cofactor D by short interfering RNA results in mitotic spindle defects. Because none of these changes in cofactor D activity produced a change in the levels of alpha-or beta-tubulin, we conclude that these newly discovered functions for cofactor D are distinct from its previously described role in tubulin folding. Thus, we describe a new role for cofactor D at centrosomes that is important to its function in polymerization of tubulin and organization of the mitotic spindle.     

Tubulin folding cofactor D is a microtubule destabilizing protein

A rapid switch between growth and shrinkage at microtubule ends is fundamental for many cellular processes. The main structural components of microtubules, the alphabeta-tubulin heterodimers, are generated through a complex folding process where GTP hydrolysis [Fontalba et al. (1993) J. Cell Sci. 106, 627-632] and a series of molecular chaperones are required [Sternlicht et al. (1993) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 90, 9422-9426; Campo et al. (1994) FEBS Lett. 353, 162-166; Lewis et al. (1996) J. Cell Biol. 132, 1-4; Lewis et al. (1997) Trends Cell Biol. 7, 479-484; Tian et al. (1997) J. Cell Biol. 138, 821-823]. Although the participation of the cofactor proteins along the tubulin folding route has been well established in vitro, there is also evidence that these protein cofactors might contribute to diverse microtubule processes in vivo [Schwahn et al. (1998) Nature Genet. 19, 327-332; Hirata et al. (1998) EMBO J. 17, 658-666; Fanarraga et al. (1999) Cell Motil. Cytoskel. 43, 243-254]. Microtubule dynamics, crucial during mitosis, cellular motility and intracellular transport processes, are known to be regulated by at least four known microtubule-destabilizing proteins. OP18/Stathmin and XKCM1 are microtubule catastrophe-inducing factors operating through different mechanisms [Waters and Salmon (1996) Curr. Biol. 6, 361-363; McNally (1999) Curr. Biol. 9, R274-R276]. Here we show that the tubulin folding cofactor D, although it does not co-polymerize with microtubules either in vivo or in vitro, modulates microtubule dynamics by sequestering beta-tubulin from GTP-bound alphabeta-heterodimers.     

Distinct tubulin genes are differentially expressed during barley grain development

Tubulins, as major components involved in the organization of microtubules, play an important role in plant development. We describe here the expression profiles of all known α-tubulin (TUA), β-tubulin (TUB) and γ-tubulin (TUG) genes of barley ( Hordeum vulgare ), involving eight newly identified TUB sequences, five established TUA genes and one TUG gene. Macroarray and Northern blot-based expression patterns in the pericarp, endosperm and embryo were obtained over the course of the development of the grain between anthesis and maturation. These revealed that the various tubulin genes differed in their levels of expression, and to some extent were tissue specific. Two expression peaks were detected in the developing endosperm. The first and more prominent peak, at 2 days after flowering, included expression of almost all the tubulin genes. These tubulins are thought to be involved in mitoses during the formation of the syncytial endosperm. The second, less pronounced but more extended, peak included only some of the tubulin genes ( HvTUA3 , HvTUB1 and HvTUG ) and might be associated with the cell wall organization in aleurone and starchy endosperm. The HvTUA5 gene is expressed only in embryo of the developing grain and may be associated with shoot establishment. The expression profiles of the tubulin folding cofactors HvTFC A and HvTFC B as well as small G-protein HvArl2 genes were almost perfectly correlated with the global levels of tubulin mRNA, implying that they have a role in the control of the polymerization of α/β-tubulin heterodimers.     

ADP ribosylation factor-like protein 2 (Arl2) regulates the interaction of tubulin-folding cofactor D with native tubulin

The ADP ribosylation factor-like proteins (Arls) are a family of small monomeric G proteins of unknown function. Here, we show that Arl2 interacts with the tubulin-specific chaperone protein known as cofactor D. Cofactors C, D, and E assemble the alpha/beta- tubulin heterodimer and also interact with native tubulin, stimulating it to hydrolyze GTP and thus acting together as a beta-tubulin GTPase activating protein (GAP). We find that Arl2 downregulates the tubulin GAP activity of C, D, and E, and inhibits the binding of D to native tubulin in vitro. We also find that overexpression of cofactors D or E in cultured cells results in the destruction of the tubulin heterodimer and of microtubules. Arl2 specifically prevents destruction of tubulin and microtubules by cofactor D, but not by cofactor E. We generated mutant forms of Arl2 based on the known properties of classical Ras-family mutations. Experiments using these altered forms of Arl2 in vitro and in vivo demonstrate that it is GDP-bound Arl2 that interacts with cofactor D, thereby averting tubulin and microtubule destruction. These data establish a role for Arl2 in modulating the interaction of tubulin-folding cofactors with native tubulin in vivo.