青藏高原东缘不同树种人工林对土壤酶活性及养分的影响

为评价不同树种人工林对土壤酶及养分的影响,选择立地条件和营林方式相同的4种人工林(连香树[CJ]、油松[PT]、落叶松[LK]和华山松[PA])为研究对象,以落叶灌丛(QC)为对照,比较不同树种人工林地土壤酶活性和土壤养分的变化。结果显示:(1)造林降低了土壤酸性磷酸酶、脱氢酶、β-葡萄糖苷酶和过氧化氢酶活性,但人工造林后土壤脲酶活性增加;(2)造林也明显影响了土壤养分,与对照林地相比,除CJ人工林土壤中磷(P)略高外,造林地土壤有机碳(TOC)、氮(N)、水可提取有机碳(WEOC)和氮(WEON)、铵态氮(NH+4-N)和硝态氮(NO-3-N)均降低;(3)不同的人工林树种之间土壤养分及酶活性也存在一定的差异性,CJ和LK人工林土壤C、N、P及相关酶活性明显不同于PT和PA人工林;(4)土壤酶与养分变化有一定的相关性,除转化酶和多酚氧化酶反应较迟钝外,其它酶对环境反应较敏感。综合分析表明,在川西地区选择高密度单一树种造林并没有改善土壤养分和酶活性,在该地区选择落叶或阔叶树种造林可使土壤肥力恢复。     

不同类型油松混交林土壤物理特性

长期大面积栽植油松人工纯林会产生较多生态问题,选择具有和谐种间关系的树种是纯林混交改造成功的关键所在。本研究以晋南油松辽东栎针阔混交林、油松纯林、油松华山松针叶混交林为对象,探讨不同混交类型对土壤物理特性的影响,为区域树种合理配置和森林可持续经营提供科学依据。结果表明:(1)树种混交能够改变土壤密度和土壤孔隙度。油松辽东栎针阔混交显著降低土壤密度,增加土壤总孔隙度、毛管孔隙度和非毛管孔隙;而油松华山松针叶混交对以上指标的影响甚微。(2)树种混交能够改变土壤持水特性。油松辽东栎针阔混交显著增加土壤最大持水量、毛管持水量和田间持水量等;而油松华山松针叶混交对以上指标的影响甚微。(3)树种混交对表层土壤密度、孔隙度和持水特性等物理性质的影响更为强烈,对0～10 cm表层土壤的影响超过10～20和20～40 cm更深层次的土壤。(4)树种混交未改变土壤属性垂直分异的基本规律。随土层深度的增加,不同混交林分土壤密度不断增大,总孔隙度、毛管孔隙度、非毛管孔隙度、最大持水量、毛管持水量以及田间持水量等均不断降低。     

亚高山森林自然与人工恢复对土壤涵水能力的影响

西南亚高山原始针叶林被大规模采伐后,在皆伐迹地上营造了大量云杉林进行人工恢复。但关于这些人工林的土壤涵水能力如何,一直没有系统深入的研究与评价。选择川西米亚罗林区系列不同林龄云杉人工林(20 a、30 a、40 a、70 a)为对象,以相邻同龄自然更新恢复的针阔混交林为对照,比较人工林土壤涵水能力随着演替进程的动态及其与自然恢复次生林之间的差异,结合人工与自然恢复后的林地特征(如细根生物量、凋落物储量和土壤有机碳等)和土壤物理结构参数等差异,阐释自然与人工恢复后土壤涵水能力差异的影响因素。结果显示:随着人工林演替,土壤0—40 cm层最大持水量随林龄的增加而降低,但变化不显著,从20年的2200 t/hm~2下降到70年的2138 t/hm~2,年平均下降速率为1.24 t/hm~2;然而在自然次生林中,土壤最大持水量随着林龄的增加呈现出波动式变化,从20年的2142 t/hm~2增加到40年的2565 t/hm~2,到70年又下降为2302 t/hm~2。通过土壤持水特性与林地凋落物贮量、细根生物量和土壤物理结构参数的相关分析表明,由不同恢复途径导致的林地土壤有机碳含量、凋落物特性及细根差异,进而改变土壤物理结构是影响土壤持水性能差异的主要因素。这些结果说明,从土壤持水量角度考虑,在对采伐迹地进行造林恢复时,应尽量避免营造结构单一、高密度的人工纯林,应选择营造针阔混交林的模式进行恢复。     

抚育对林地土壤碳释放的影响——基于Yasso07估算

间伐是森林经营的有效措施之一,其能减少林木枯损,有利于林下植被生长和植物种群更新,但也可改变森林小气候,从而影响林地土壤碳释放。以秦岭火地塘林区松栎混交林为研究对象,运用Yasso07模型模拟了不同间伐强度和间伐残留物移除强度下林地土壤CO_2释放。结果表明:(1)针叶树种(油松Pinus tabulaefomis、华山松Pinus armandi)和阔叶树种(锐齿栎Quercus aliena var.acutesrrata)叶凋落物化学组分有较明显差异,针叶树种酒精溶解性化合物(ESC)和水溶性化合物(WSC)含量明显低于阔叶树种,其不溶性化合物(NSC)含量明显高于阔叶树种;(2)凋落物化学组分对林地土壤CO_2释放有显著的影响;(3)在研究两个控制因子中,间伐强度是影响林地土壤CO_2释放的主导因子,间伐后林地土壤CO_2释放量有升高趋势;当间伐强度为12.38%,间伐残留物移除强度为53.18%时,林地土壤CO_2释放量最小,为15.318 Mg hm~(-2)a~(-1)。     

落叶松人工林凋落物与土壤肥力变化的研究

以东北东部山区帽儿山实验林场落叶松人工林作为研究对象,从林地凋落量、林地凋落物归还量、凋落物层现存量以及土壤理化性质的变化等方面,研究了经抚育间伐后不同年龄阶段同一落叶松林分土壤肥力的变化以及间伐与未间伐林分土壤理化性质的差异．结果表明,落叶松人工林凋落量和以凋落物形式归还于林地的营养元素呈现出随年龄增加而增长的总趋势．经抚育间伐后,由于阔叶树种的引入使凋落物的组成结构发生变化,凋落物层的分解率逐步提高,加速了凋落物中营养物质的释放和归还,减缓了凋落物积累与分解的矛盾,提高了落叶松人工林的土壤肥力．１５年间土壤有机质、全Ｎ和全Ｐ２Ｏ５平均值分别增长了３５２．００％、２２５．５３％和３４．９６％．间伐后的落叶松人工林土壤的理化性质得到不同程度的改善．     

半干旱地区不同森林类型土壤水分动态模拟

采用暖温带落叶阔叶次生林、油松人工林和华北落叶松人工林样地土壤水分的生长季内观测数据和其他辅助观测数据,检验了Georgakakos等提出的土壤水分模型在半干旱林地的适用性。结果表明,该模型用于模拟半干旱林地日尺度土壤水分动态具有一定的可信度,且能够较好的反映不同森林类型的水文效应。模型参数的敏感性分析表明,不同目标函数的参数敏感度信息反映了该模型"异参同效"现象不显著,模型结构不确定性也较小。各参数的敏感度结果揭示了各参数在降雨入渗、深层渗漏和蒸散部分中的控制作用。从模型模拟的土壤水分变化通量来看,油松人工林地实际年蒸散发量大于其他林地,落叶阔叶林地年入渗量大于其他林地,而3种森林类型林地深层渗漏所占生长季降雨量的比例都较小。研究半干旱地区多年生人工林土壤水分的情况,不仅有助于从根本上认清半干旱地区土壤-大气-植被连续体的复杂作用关系,也为半干旱地区树种选择及造林后的生态水文效应研究提供理论依据。     

秦岭火地塘林区四种主要树种凋落叶分解速率

利用野外分解袋法对秦岭火地塘林区油松、华山松、华北落叶松、锐齿栎凋落叶的分解速率和养分释放趋势进行研究。结果表明,分解2年后,4种树种凋落叶的干物质残留率在35.6%～58.6%,残留率大小顺序为油松>华山松>华北落叶松>锐齿栎。除油松与华山松凋落叶之间残留率差异不显著外,各树种之间凋落叶分解后的残留率差异显著。在2个试验年度中,4-9月凋落叶分解最快,在其他月份保持较平稳的分解速度,分解前12个月凋落叶失重速度明显大于后12个月,呈明显的季节和阶段性差异。利用Olson模型对凋落叶分解50%和95%所需时间进行估测,结果显示,不同树种所需时间差异显著,其中锐齿栎凋落叶95%被分解所需时间最短,为5.43年,油松最长,为9.87年。凋落叶中N、P元素在分解第1年均表现出富集现象,直至1年后达到一个最高值后,开始释放,C含量则呈现出逐步下降的趋势。导致不同树种凋落叶分解速率及养分释放速率差异主要与不同凋落叶的初始质量和性质有关。     

阔叶和杉木人工林对土壤碳氮库的影响比较

通过比较我国亚热带地区19年生阔叶人工林和杉木人工林土壤碳氮储量,探讨树种对土壤碳氮库的影响.结果表明：阔叶人工林0～40 cm土层碳储量平均为99.41 Mg·hm^-2,比杉木人工林增加33.1%;土壤氮储量为6.18 Mg·hm^-2,比杉木人工林增加22.6%.阔叶人工林林地枯枝落叶层现存量、碳和氮储量分别是杉木人工林的1.60、1.49和1.52倍,两个树种的枯落叶生物量、碳和氮储量均有显著差异.枯枝落叶层碳氮比值与土壤碳、氮储量之间呈显著负相关.阔叶人工林细根生物量(0～80 cm)是杉木林的1.28倍,其中0～10 cm土壤层细根生物量占48.2%;阔叶人工林细根碳、氮储量均高于杉木人工林.在0～10 cm土层,细根碳储量与土壤碳储量具有显著正相关关系.阔叶树种比杉木的土壤有机碳储存能力更大.     

南亚热带不同植被恢复模式下土壤理化性质

分析了广西大青山南亚热带11种植被恢复模式下（1种天然次生林、2种人工针叶林、5种人工常绿阔叶林、2种人工针阔混交林和1种灌丛）土壤理化性质的变化特征.结果表明:不同植被恢复模式下土壤理化性质存在明显差异.其中,次生林林地土壤的物理性质良好,2种针叶林较差.2种针阔混交林土壤容重较小,土壤总孔隙度、土壤持水量均高于其他人工纯林;而5种人工常绿阔叶林的土壤孔隙度差异不明显.次生林土壤除全K低于柚木林外,其余养分含量均明显高于人工林,C/N和pH值相对较低.与荒草灌丛相比,9种人工林的土壤养分变化明显,全N和速效P含量均呈增加趋势;2种针叶纯林的土壤养分含量较低,但与红椎混交后,土壤养分含量明显改善,C/N值降低.     

冀北山区滦平县4种新造林地水源涵养能力研究

为研究密云水库上游冀北山区生态水源保护林的生长现状和涵养水源能力,以油松×落叶松(林地Ⅰ)、油松×山杏(林地Ⅱ)、油松×蒙古栎(林地Ⅲ)、侧柏×山杏(林地Ⅳ)4种混交林为研究对象,通过测定林下枯落物层和土壤层特征,分析比较不同林地枯落物和土壤的持水能力及林地水源涵养能力。研究结果表明:枯落物现存量为林地Ⅱ林地Ⅳ林地Ⅰ林地Ⅲ,林地Ⅱ的枯落物层有效持水量最大,为81.30 t/hm~2,林地Ⅰ最小。土壤总孔隙度、毛管孔隙度和非毛管孔隙度最大的均为林地Ⅳ,分别为56.02%、50.26%和5.76%,林地Ⅳ的土壤层有效持水量最大,为1507.90 t/hm~2,林地Ⅲ最小。综合4种林地的枯落物层和土壤层持水能力,可知林地Ⅳ(侧柏×山杏)的水源涵养能力最强,为157.43 mm,林地Ⅲ(油松×蒙古栎)最弱。     

关帝山林区退化灌木林转变为华北落叶松林对生态系统碳储量的影响

针对我国大量灌木林出现退化而宜林地又日益减少的现状,在适宜种植乔木的地区,将退化灌木林转变为乔木林被认为是一种可行的植被恢复方式。以关帝山林区退化灌木次生林转变而成的不同林龄（10、18、23、27年和35年）华北落叶松（Larix principis-rupprechtii Mayr.）林为研究对象,并以相邻的退化灌木次生林为对照,探究这种转变对生态系统碳储量及其组分的影响,将为我国开展造林/再造林、林业碳汇项目等工作提供科学依据和数据支撑。与灌木林相比,造林初期的生态系统碳储量及其组分均出现不同程度的下降。10年生华北落叶松林的生态系统碳储量相对于灌木林显著下降了32.9%（P < 0.05）,但并非所有组分的下降都显著（P < 0.05）。植被碳储量下降34.7%,其植被地上和地下碳储量分别下降5.4%和70.9%,但只有植被地下碳储量是显著减少的（P < 0.05）;凋落物碳储量下降42.8%,但并不显著（P=0.71）;土壤有机碳储量（0-50 cm）显著下降32.6%（P < 0.05）,其不同土层（0-10、10-30 cm和30-50 cm）的碳储量也都出现显著减少（P < 0.05）。林龄从10年到35年,华北落叶松林生态系统碳储量增加了1.6倍,植被及其组成（地上和地下）、凋落物、土壤有机碳及其不同土层（0-10、10-30 cm和30-50 cm）等的碳储量也随之不断增加,从而使得生态系统碳储量及其组分逐渐达到并全面超过灌木林。但是,不同组分要达到灌木林的碳储量水平,需要的时间存在较大差异：土壤有机碳库 > 植被地下碳库 > 植被地上碳库,其中深层土壤有机碳 > 表层土壤有机碳（0-10 cm）。     

Resource-use efficiencies of three indigenous tree species planted in resource islands created by shrubs: implications for reforestation of subtropical degraded shrublands

Shrub resource islands are characterized by resources accumulated shrubby areas surrounded by relative barren soils. This research aims to determine resource-use efficiency of native trees species planted on shrub resource islands, and to determine how the planted trees may influence the resource islands in degraded shrublands in South China. Shrub (Rhodomyrtus tomentosa) resource islands were left unplanted or were planted with 0.5-year-old indigenous tree species Schima superba, Castanopsis fissa, and Michelia macclurei. The results indicate that, after 2.5?years, the tree seedlings did not modify the physical traits (light, air temperature, and soil water) but tended to increase soil nutrients (soil organic carbon and soil nitrogen) and soil microbial biomass of the resource islands. Relative to S. superba and M. macclurei, C. fissa had greater effects on soil nutrients and microbial biomass but showed lower plant growth, survival, and resource-use efficiencies (for water, light, energy, and nitrogen). These results rejected our initial assumption that shrub resource islands would effectively promote the growth and resource utility of all the indigenous tree species and shorten the reforestation course in subtropical degraded shrubland. C. fissa performed poorly when growing on shrub resource islands, but its role in soil nutrient accumulation might have long-term impacts on the restoration of degraded shrubland. In contrast, S. superba and M. macclurei could make better use of the shrub resource islands therefore accelerating the construction of native plantations.     

Does plantation forestry restore biodiversity or create green deserts? A synthesis of the effects of land-use transitions on plant species richness

Plantations are established for a variety of reasons including wood production, soil and water conservation, and more recently, carbon sequestration. The effect of this growing land-use change on biodiversity, however, is poorly understood and considerable debate exists as to whether plantations are ‘green deserts’ or valuable habitat for indigenous flora and fauna. This paper synthesizes peer-reviewed articles that provide quantitative data on plant species richness in plantations and paired land uses, most often representative of pre-plantation land cover. The results of this synthesis suggest that the value of plantations for biodiversity varies considerably depending on whether the original land cover is grassland, shrubland, primary forest, secondary forest, or degraded or exotic pasture, and whether native or exotic tree species are planted. The results of this study suggest that plantations are most likely to contribute to biodiversity when established on degraded lands rather than replacing natural ecosystems, such as forests, grasslands, and shrublands, and when indigenous tree species are used rather than exotic species. These findings can help guide afforestation and reforestation programs, including those aimed at increasing terrestrial carbon sequestration.     

The shrub Rhodomyrtus tomentosa acts as a nurse plant for seedlings differing in shade tolerance in degraded land of South China

Questions: What are the nurse effects of Rhodomyrtus tomentosa in degraded land of South China? Are canopy or soil factors responsible for the main nurse effect? Do facilitative effects increase with the shade tolerance of the target species? Location: Degraded shrubland in South China. Methods: Seedlings of three native climax woody species (Schima superba, Michelia macclurei, Castanopsis fissa) that differ in shade tolerance were subjected to four treatments by transplantation: (1) under the canopy of R. tomentosa shrubs; (2) in open interspaces without vegetation cover (control); (3) under the canopy of R. tomentosa from which canopies had been removed; and (4) in open interspaces without vegetation but covered by branches and leaves of R. tomentosa. Results: At low soil nutrient levels, increased canopy shade, soil porosity and soil moisture under the canopy of R. tomentosa increased seedling survival of the climax tree species S. superba, C. fissa and M. macclurei, and shoot height of S. superba. The nurse effect (a form of facilitation) of R. tomentosa depended more on canopy shade than on soil amelioration. The magnitude of facilitation or nurse effect was positively correlated with shade tolerance of the target species. Conclusions: Use of nurse plants in restoration differs from traditional reforestation (clearing and/or burning to reduce interspecific competition between target tree species and non‐target species) because it focuses on positive interactions between nurse plants and target plants that increase establishment of target species and reduce time required for restoration. Because nurse effects of R. tomentosa shrubs tended to be larger on target species with greater shade tolerance, shade‐tolerant plants are suggested as target species to accelerate restoration.     

外来树种日本落叶松和日本花柏对鄂西北森林群落的影响

【目的】研究大面积栽植外来树种日本落叶松和日本花柏对鄂西北森林群落物种多样性的影响,为评价外来树种的入侵风险提供依据。【方法】采用样地调查法对比研究外来树种日本落叶松和日本花柏人工林与当地森林群落特征差异。【结果】日本落叶松人工林样地林下植物种类丰富,样地平均物种数与当地天然林样地物种数相比无显著差异;林下灌木层和草本层多样性指数较高,草本层多样性指数与当地天然林相比无显著差异;林下未发现日本落叶松的更新苗。日本花柏人工林样地平均物种数显著少于当地其他人工林样地;乔木层、灌木层和草本层的4个多样性指数值均小于当地其他人工林样地;在3个样地中出现日本花柏更新苗,更新苗数量达479株·hm~(-2)。【结论】引种栽培日本落叶松不会导致当地森林群落的物种多样性降低,不会引起生物入侵风险;但引种栽培日本花柏会明显降低当地森林群落的物种多样性,对当地森林生态系统的稳定构成一定威胁。     

黄土高原丘陵区退耕还林地油松人工林碳储量及分配特征研究

以黄土高原丘陵区主要退耕还林树种油松为研究对象,对甘肃省庆阳市合水县采用样地调查与生物量实测方法,分析不同坡向（阳坡、阴坡）及退耕年限（退耕6年、9年和12年）油松人工林的乔木不同器官、灌草层、枯落物层和土壤层的碳含量,以及油松人工林乔木层、灌草层、枯落物层和土壤层碳储量及其分配特征,探讨甘肃黄土高原丘陵区生态林的固碳作用。结果表明:（1）油松不同器官碳含量为48.15%~53.90%,各器官碳含量大小为树干>叶>细枝>粗枝>根桩>粗根>树皮>大根>中根>小根>细根>球果;灌木层碳含量为茎>叶>根;草本层碳含量为地上部分>地下部分。（2）油松人工林的枯落物层碳含量为未分解层大于半分解层。（3）0~100 cm土壤层的碳含量随退耕年限增加而增大,随土壤深度的增加而下降;0~10 cm、10~20 cm土壤层不同坡向间碳含量差异显著。（4）阳坡和阴坡退耕6年、9年和12年油松林总碳储量分别为42.90、50.50、59.22 t·hm^-2和45.08、53.77、65.70 t·hm^-2。研究认为,黄土高原丘陵区阳坡和阴坡均适宜油松林发挥固碳效益,且阴坡要优于阳坡,是甘肃黄土高原丘陵区的理想树种。     

固氮树种旱冬瓜对退化林地土壤修复和林下植被重建的生态驱动效应

固氮树种对退化土壤和森林的结构与功能修复和改良具有重要价值,但是,固氮树种的混交配置、林龄变化和人工与天然起源林分对土壤修复和林下植被重建方面的生态驱动效应与影响机制的认识尚不够深入。因此,在金沙江上游选择退耕地上不同混交配置模式、不同林龄旱冬瓜(Alnus nepalensis)人工林和旱冬瓜天然次生林,对比分析了土壤养分、林下植被生长、林下植被多样性和旱冬瓜材积等指标的差异,以期阐明固氮树种旱冬瓜对土壤养分状况及林下植被重建的生态驱动效应。结果表明：(1)不同旱冬瓜人工林配置模式中,旱冬瓜纯林的土壤养分综合指标显著高于旱冬瓜+云南松混交林和云南松纯林(P<0.05);(2)不同林龄旱冬瓜人工林中土壤有机质、总氮及土壤养分综合指标呈现8年生林均显著大于5年生林(P<0.05);(3)土壤有机质、总氮及土壤养分综合指标均为旱冬瓜天然林>旱冬瓜和云南松人工混交林>云南松天然林(P<0.05);(4)SEM模型分析发现,旱冬瓜材积与土壤养分综合指标呈极显著的正相关关系(R=0.473,P<0.001);(5)在不同旱冬瓜人工配置模式和不同优势种的天然林中...     

Effects of thinning and excluding deer browsing on sapling establishment and growth in larch plantations

Monoculture plantations with rapidly growing trees are often used for reforestation schemes on abandoned land. There is evidence that in some cases, reforestation facilitates forest succession toward natural species composition. However, the success of a scheme varies according to site conditions, and systematic investigations are required for adaptive management. Monoculture plantations were used to reforest abandoned pastures at the study site in Hokkaido, northern Japan. At the study site—a 40-year-old nonnative larch (Larix kaempferi) plantation—the effects of thinning and deer-browsing exclusion treatments on the demography of understory saplings were analyzed to achieve appropriate management planning for reforestation. After deer-browsing exclusion, saplings of various species became established, and species composition corresponded closely to that of a natural conifer–broadleaved mixed stand. Saplings of shade-tolerant species, such as Abies sachalinensis and Acer mono, were abundant. Thinning influenced the demography of saplings over an 8-year period and significantly affected the height growth rate of A. sachalinensis saplings, which show strong variations in response to varying light conditions. There were also negative effects of thinning, such as increased mortality and decreased height growth rate of broadleaved saplings, the growth of which was suppressed by facilitated growth of A. sachalinensis. Thus, treatments used for reforestation must take into account differences in demographic traits of tree species by including long-term monitoring.     

Consistent pattern of habitat and species selection by post-dispersal seed predators in a Mediterranean mosaic landscape

There is still little information on effects of habitat degradation on post-dispersal seed predation at the landscape scale. The aim of this study was to determine the influence of habitat degradation and seed species on the variability of post-dispersal seed-predation rate. Experimental seed removal was investigated in six Mediterranean woody plant species, four trees (Pinus sylvestris, Quercus ilex, Acer opalus ssp. granatense, and Sorbus aria) and two shrubs (Berberis vulgaris and Crataegus monogyna), in an extensively used mosaic landscape on the Sierra Nevada massif (SE Spain). Seed depots were distributed over 2 years in five differently degraded landscape units, each one with three plots: shrubland; native forest; and dense, cleared and fenced reforestation stands. Predation was the highest in native forest, shrubland, and fenced reforestation, and the lowest in dense and cleared reforestation stands, being partially due to a positive correlation between shrub cover and post-dispersal seed predation. However, the main factors driving post-dispersal seed predation were intrinsic to seeds, as species preference explained most of the variance in our model for predation. The plant-species ranking was Quercus > Pinus > Sorbus > Berberis > Acer > Crataegus, the dominant tree species being the most depredated. These findings are novel because they suggest for the first time that species-selection patterns by post-dispersal seed predators tended to remain constant through both study years in all habitats comprising a mosaic landscape, whether native forest, reforestation stands or successional shrubland.     

宝天曼自然保护区不同针叶树径向生长对气候的响应

树木年轮资料能够提供区域内过去长时间的环境和气候信息,成为获取过去气候变化信息的重要手段之一。利用采自宝天曼自然保护区的两种针叶树种油松和华山松树木年轮样本分别建立了油松和华山松树轮宽度标准年表PT和PA,并将油松和华山松样本合并建立了联合树种的区域年表(RC)。3种年表分别与不同气候要素(月平均气温、月平均最高气温、月平均最低气温、月降水量)及其不同月份组合进行相关分析,结果表明,油松年表PT和华山松年表PA都包含较高的气候信息,且都和生长季不同月份温度显著负相关和降水显著正相关。其中,油松和华山松都与当年4月和5月降水显著正相关,油松还与当年5月的平均最高温度和上年11月最低温显著负相关,与当年3月平均最低气温显著正相关;华山松与上年10月和当年4月的平均最高温度显著负相关,与上年12月和当年7月平均最低温度显著正相关;联合年表RC包含了单个年表PT和PA共同的气候信息,与当年4—5月降水和3月最低温显著正相关,与当年7月最低温和4、5月最高温显著负相关。不同年表与生长季(3—8月)内气候要素月份组合的相关分析也表明联合年表RC包含和单物种年表PT、PA相似的气候信息并加强了PT、PA受当年生长季气候变化影响的公共信号。可见,同一地区的多树种联合年表一定程度上能体现出区域性树木生长对气候变化响应的生态生理特征,为同地区建成多树种联合年表来探讨当地区域性气候变化提供了可行性的理论基础和一定的参考作用.