IL 2 restores memory B cell activation by antigen-specific T cell clone variants

It has recently been demonstrated that there are at least two separate pathways by which a single keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) reactive T cell clone can induce B cell differentiation. With the use of the high-dose antigen-driven system (10 micrograms/ml trinitrophenyl (TNP)-KLH), a KLH-specific T cell clone was able to induce a primary anti-TNP response in unprimed B cells. In the presence of aliquots of the same T cell clone, a low-dose of antigen (5 X 10(-2) micrograms/ml TNP-KLH) induced an immunoglobulin (Ig)G response in primed B cells. It has also been demonstrated that there are variant subclones of such KLH-specific helper T cell clones that are unable to provide antigen-specific help in the presence of low-dose antigen but maintain the high-dose antigen-driven helper response. This study was undertaken to investigate whether interleukin 2 (IL 2) had some activity in the low-dose, antigen-driven response induced by the T cell clone. With the use of a variant T cell clone (which lost low-dose, antigen-driven helper activity), it was demonstrated that IL 2 was capable of reconstituting the low-dose, antigen-driven helper activity. To investigate whether accessory cells were required in this system, we removed the adherent cell population from the primed spleen cells added to culture. Interestingly, removal of the G10-adherent cells eliminated the low-dose, antigen-driven response induced by IL 2. Additionally by add-back experiments, we were able to demonstrate that the necessary adherent cell population did not require major histocompatibility complex (MHC) restriction for reconstitution of the IL 2-dependent, low-dose, antigen-driven response. Furthermore, 1% concanavalin A (Con A) supernatant (Sn), but not interleukin 1 (IL 1), could replace this adherent cell function. These data suggest that in this system, IL 2 bypasses the MHC-restricted interaction between T cells and antigen-charged adherent cells; B cells can present antigen to cloned helper T cells efficiently for primary responses but need an added factor(s) to induce IgG production; and adherent cells are essential for IgG production in primed B cells, possibly through the release of soluble factor(s) included in Con A Sn.     

Macrophage requirements of CR- and CR+ B lymphocytes for antibody production in vitro.

A Sephadex G-10 column coated with antigen-antibody complexes and complement retains complement receptor-bearing (CR+) mouse spleen cells. The effluent is rich in thymus-derived cells (T cells), and contains bone marrow-derived cells (B cells) which carry surface immunoglobulin (Ig), Ir-associated antigen (Ia), and Fc receptors, but no complement receptors (CR-). Although both unfractionated and CR- B cell populations are capable of producing antibody to red cell antigens, they differ in their requirements for the initiation of the response. Unfractionated B cells cooperate with primed as well as unprimed helper T cells; macrophages are required for this cooperation but can be replaced by 2-mercaptoethanol. CR- B cells cooperate with primed but not with unprimed T cells provided macrophages are added to cultures. After addition of culture supernatant from BCG-activated macrophages CR- B cells cooperate with both unprimed and primed T helper cells.     

Induction of antigen-specific antibody responses in primed and unprimed B cells. Functional heterogeneity among Th1 and Th2 T cell clones

CD4+ T cells have been recently divided into two subsets. The functions of these subsets are thought to be distinct: one subset (Th1) is responsible for delayed type hypersensitivity responses and another (Th2) is primarily responsible for induction of antibody synthesis. To more precisely define the roles of both subsets in humoral immune responses, we examined the ability of a panel of nominal antigen specific Th1 and Th2 clones to induce anti-TNP specific antibody synthesis in TNP-primed or unprimed B cells. Four of nine Th1 clones induced little or no antibody synthesis with TNP-primed B cells. However, five other Th1 clones were very effective at inducing IgG anti-TNP plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses in primed B cells. One of these Th1 clones was analysed in detail and found to also provide helper function for unprimed B cells. Cognate B-T cell interaction was required for induction of both primary and secondary responses with this clone, indicating that a Th1 clone could function as a "classical" Th cell. The seven IL-4 producing Th2 clones examined were also heterogeneous in their ability to induce antibody secretion by TNP-primed B cells. Although four of the Th2 clones induced IgG and IgM anti-TNP PFC responses, two Th2 clones induced only IgM and no IgG antibody, and another clone failed to induce any anti-TNP PFC. All Th2 clones failed to induce any anti-TNP PFC. All Th2 clones produced high levels of IL-4, but "helper" Th2 clones produced significantly greater amounts of IL-5 than "non-helper" Th2 clones. These studies indicate that some IL-2- and some IL-4-producing T cell clones can induce TNP-specific antibody in cell clones can induce TNP-specific antibody in primed and unprimed B cells, and that Th1 and Th2 clones are heterogeneous in their ability to induce Ig synthesis. Therefore, although T cell clones can be classified as Th1 or Th2 types according to patterns of IL-2, IFN-gamma, or IL-4 synthesis, the functional capacity to induce antibody synthesis cannot be predicted solely by their ability to secrete these lymphokines.     

Macrophages and T cells control distinct phases of B cell differentiation in the humoral immune response in vitro

The differentiation of B cells in the in vitro PFC-response to red blood cell antigen proceeds through 2 phases. Antigen-reactive B cells acquire the ability to interact with helper T cells in the first phase. This phase is controlled by macrophages through a mediator that they release (Interleukin 1 ([Il-1]). B cells convert into antibody-secreting cells (PFC) in the second phase, which is controlled by helper T cells or by a mediator that they release (T cell-replacing factors [TRF]). This is demonstrated in experiments in which Il-1 increases the number of B cells capable of responding to T cell help. The majority of antigen-reactive B cells reaches that state of differentiation within 40 hr of incubation with Il-1. After this time, the response of B cells depends no longer on the presence of Il-1 but on the presence of T cells or TRF. The presented data suggest that antigen-primed helper T cells (but not unprimed T cells) induce the release of Il-1 by macrophages, thereby also influencing the early phase of B cell differentiation.     

Human T cell leukemia/lymphoma virus-infected antigen-specific T cell clones: indiscriminant helper function and lymphokine production

The ability of human T cell leukemia/lymphoma virus (HTLV)-I to alter the function of infected T lymphocytes was examined directly by investigating the properties of an antigen-specific T cell clone before and after transformation with HTLV-I. Following infection, the T4 antigen-specific clone manifested a tenfold increase in its surface interleukin 2 (IL 2) receptor (Tac) density and acquired the viral determinants p19, p24, and 4D12 not present in the uninfected clone. Prior to infection, the T cell clone responded to antigen stimulation in the presence of histocompatible antigen-presenting cells with proliferation and secretion of multiple lymphokines, including IL 2, B cell growth factor (BCGF), B cell differentiation factor (BCDF), and interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma). Following infection, the T cell clone both proliferated and produced constitutively three of these lymphokines (BCGF, BCDF, and IFN-gamma) in the absence of accessory cells or antigen. Co-cultivation with any accessory cells regardless of histocompatibility resulted in increased proliferation and lymphokine production. IL 2 production by the HTLV-I-transformed cell, however, could not be detected. Similarly, the uninfected clone was able to provide B cell help for Ig production only when stimulated with both histocompatible cells and antigen. In contrast, the infected cell provided T cell help to B cells in an unregulated manner, independent of antigen or histocompatibility. Thus, functions such as the induction of proliferation, B cell help, and lymphokine production, which are finely regulated in uninfected antigen-specific T cell clones, became indiscriminant after HTLV-I infection.     

Heterogeneity among T helper cells. Interleukin 2 secretion and help for immunoglobulin secretion

T lymphocytes are thought to provide "help" for B cells by activating them from the resting state, by secretion of antigen-nonspecific lymphokines that promote B cell differentiation and maturation, and by providing signals that induce isotype switching. To clarify the extent to which these different forms of helper activity could be carried out by individual T cells, we set up cultures in which B cells activated, and were in turn themselves stimulated by, limiting numbers of T cells through differences at the H-2 or Mls loci. At T cell doses at which responses were likely to represent the activity of individual helper T cells (or their immediate clonal progeny), we found that some T cells were able both to produce interleukin 2 (IL-2) and to induce secretion of both IgM and IgG, whereas others induced immunoglobulin (Ig) secretion without detectable IL-2 production, and still others made IL-2 but did not promote antibody secretion. We could not detect B cell stimulatory factor 1 production by alloantigen-stimulated T cells, and the addition of antibodies to B cell stimulatory factor 1 did not prevent Ig production. Two results, however--higher Ig accumulation in those wells that received an IL-2-producing cell, and inhibition by anti-IL-2 receptor antibodies of B cell but not T cell function--are consistent with a direct stimulatory effect of IL-2 on B cells in this system. The pattern of helper functions exhibited by T cells freshly isolated from mice differs from that inferred from studies of cloned lines of T cells in long term cultures.     

Activation of B cells by autoreactive T cells: cloned autoreactive T cells activate B cells by two distinct pathways

Although the existence of autoreactive T cells has been widely reported, the functional capacities of these populations have been less well defined. Studies were therefore carried out to characterize the relationship of autoreactive T cells to antigen-specific major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted T cells in their ability to act as helper cells for the induction of immunoglobulin synthesis by B cells. A number of autoreactive T cell lines and clones were isolated from antigen-primed spleen and lymph node cell populations. Autoreactive T cells were found to proliferate in response to direct recognition of syngeneic I-A or I-E subregion-encoded antigens in the absence of any apparent foreign antigen. It was shown that cloned autoreactive T cells were capable of activating B cell responses through two distinct pathways. After appropriate stimulation by syngeneic cells, autoreactive T cells polyclonally activated primed or unprimed B cells to synthesize IgM antibodies. These activated T cells functioned in these responses through an MHC-unrestricted pathway in which polyclonal responses were induced in both syngeneic and allogeneic B cells. These cloned autoreactive T cells were also able to activate IgG responses by primed B cells through a different activation pathway. In contrast to the polyclonal activation of IgM responses, the induction of IgG antibodies by the same cloned T cells required primed B cells and stimulation with the priming antigen. The activation of B cells to produce IgG was strongly MHC restricted and required the direct recognition by the autoreactive T cells of self MHC determinants expressed on the B cell surface, with no bystander activation of allogeneic B cells. These results indicate that cloned autoreactive T cells resemble antigen-specific MHC-restricted T cells in their ability to function as T helper cells through distinct MHC-restricted and MHC-unrestricted pathways.     

Inhibition of the helper function of murine T cells with Fab'-anti-L3T4 ricin A chain immunotoxin

The ability of Fab'-anti-L3T4 A chain-containing immunotoxins to inhibit the helper function of keyhole limpet hemocyanin-specific T helper lymphocytes was evaluated. Keyhole limpet hemocyanin-specific T helper cells were prepared from the lymph nodes of primed mice and were enriched for T cells. Enriched populations of trinitrophenyl-specific B cells were prepared from spleens of normal mice. In the presence of antigen, the keyhole limpet hemocyanin-specific T helper cells were able to induce proliferation and differentiation of the trinitrophenyl-specific B cells. However, when the T helper cells were first treated with an immunotoxin composed of Fab' fragments of anti-L3T4 antibody coupled to ricin A chain (Fab'-anti-L3T4-A), they failed to induce proliferation and differentiation of the antigen-specific B cells. The concentrations of Fab'-anti-L3T4-A required to inhibit T cell help for the proliferation and differentiation of trinitrophenyl-specific B cells by 50% were 1 X 10(-9)M and 4 X 10(-10) M, respectively. Fab'-anti-L3T4 antibody alone did not inhibit T cell-induced B cell proliferation and differentiation by 50% at greater than 100-fold higher concentrations.     

Triggering of affinity-enriched B cells. II. Composition and B cell triggering properties of affinity-purified, antigen-specific, T cell-derived helper factor

Antigen-specific, T cell-derived helper factor (ASHF), recognizing alloantigens on chicken red blood cells (CRBC), had previously been shown to trigger an IgM anti-CRBC response in vitro by 2 X 10(3) affinity-enriched B cells. Triggering signals for B cell proliferation were shown to be substituted by ASHF or lipopolysaccharide, and signals for differentiation to IgM production by Thy-1+ cells. In an effort to demonstrate unequivocally antigen specificity of helper factor, secretory products and cell extracts from helper T cells that had been primed by either the B2 or the B13 chicken alloantigens, were purified by antigen affinity and ion exchange chromatography. With each step of purification, antigen-specific biologic activity of ASHF-containing material increased such that ASHF from B2, but not B13, primed helper T cells would help trigger a B2, but not a B13, -specific response and vice versa. Gel filtration of ASHF suggests it to have a m.w. of at least 50,000. Absorption studies showed that ASHF binds to B cells in the absence of antigen. Delivery of the triggering signal requires ASHF to bind simultaneously to both, the cell surface and the antigen. ASHF consists of at least two subunits that may be separated from each other by chelating agents. This yields two biologically inactive fractions, only one of which binds to the nominal antigen. Upon recombining them in the presence of Ca++, full biologic activity is restored.     

Antigen-specific helper factor production by immortalized clone of OVA-specific T cells. I. In vitro activity

Immortalized clones of virally transformed OVA-specific T cells produce antigen-specific helper factor upon stimulation in vitro. The helper factor activate DNP-primed B cells to multiply and synthesize IgG anti-DNP antibodies. The trigger of the helper clone is antigen specific and the B cell-stimulating hapten must be coupled to the specific T cell carrier in order to transfer the help signal from the activated T clone to the B lymphocytes. Activation of the helper clone is performed by antigen-pulsed macrophages and cannot be achieved by the free soluble antigen. However, cell-free supernatant of the antigen-pulsed macrophages can stimulate the helper cells. Thus the antigenic determinant must be presented to the helper cell in the form of macrophage-processed antigen. These requirements for antigenic stimulation and the activity of the secreted helper factor demonstrate that the immortalized helper clone preserved the cellular components which control the antigen-specific immune function of the normal T lymphocyte.     

Two types of murine helper T cell clone. I. Definition according to profiles of lymphokine activities and secreted proteins

A panel of antigen-specific mouse helper T cell clones was characterized according to patterns of lymphokine activity production, and two types of T cell were distinguished. Type 1 T helper cells (TH1) produced IL 2, interferon-gamma, GM-CSF, and IL 3 in response to antigen + presenting cells or to Con A, whereas type 2 helper T cells (TH2) produced IL 3, BSF1, and two other activities unique to the TH2 subset, a mast cell growth factor distinct from IL 3 and a T cell growth factor distinct from IL 2. Clones representing each type of T cell were characterized, and the pattern of lymphokine activities was consistent within each set. The secreted proteins induced by Con A were analyzed by biosynthetic labeling and SDS gel electrophoresis, and significant differences were seen between the two groups of T cell line. Both types of T cell grew in response to alternating cycles of antigen stimulation, followed by growth in IL 2-containing medium. Examples of both types of T cell were also specific for or restricted by the I region of the MHC, and the surface marker phenotype of the majority of both types was Ly-1+, Lyt-2-, L3T4+, Both types of helper T cell could provide help for B cells, but the nature of the help differed. TH1 cells were found among examples of T cell clones specific for chicken RBC and mouse alloantigens. TH2 cells were found among clones specific for mouse alloantigens, fowl gamma-globulin, and KLH. The relationship between these two types of T cells and previously described subsets of T helper cells is discussed.     

In vivo priming of helper T cells in the absence of B cell activation

This paper describes an adjuvant-free immunization regimen that results in the priming of T cells but not B cells. B10.A mice were primed s.c. with syngeneic spleen cells that had been pulsed with the peptide 81-104 derived from pigeon cytochrome c. The T cell response was measured by using a sensitive limiting dilution assay that measures lymphokine production. The precursor frequency of Ag-specific cells found in these mice was indistinguishable from the frequency found in mice primed in the footpads with 81-104 in CFA. A striking difference in antibody induction was found, however, when these two immunization regimens were compared. Mice primed with 81-104 in CFA developed significant serum antibody responses against the peptide, whereas mice primed with Ag-pulsed spleen cells produced no detectable anti-peptide antibodies. This lack of antibody did not result from detectable differences in the T cells that were primed: no differences were seen in IL-2 and IL-4 production or in the ability to provide help to B cells in vitro. In vitro stimulation with LPS suggested that the B cells were not primed by the Ag-pulsed spleen cells. The B cells were not tolerized, however, because boosting the mice with Ag in CFA resulted in the induction of an antibody response. The failure to induce an antibody response by priming with Ag-pulsed spleen cells was not caused by the site of immunization or the total amount of Ag used for priming. The critical variable may be the introduction of the Ag on the surface of an APC; in this form, B cell Ag recognition was apparently inefficient, whereas T cell Ag recognition was optimal.     

Mechanism of allosuppression: evidence for direct suppression of responding B cells.

The mechanism of allosuppression has been investigated. As previously described, negative allogeneic effects result when T cells recognize MHC-encoded alloantigens on responding lymphocytes, preventing the generation of a secondary anti-PFC response in vitro. Several experiments suggested that this suppression was not due to the generation of cytotoxic effectors. First, effective suppression occurred only when T cells, either unprimed or alloantigen activated, were added during the first 24 hr of the responding culture. Even previously generated cytotoxic effectors were relatively ineffective when added late in the response. Furthermore, no detectable cytotoxic effectors were found in suppressed cultures. The major target of suppression was the responding B cell. Only B cells carrying alloantigens (thus recognized by the T cells) were suppressed; bystander B cells were little affected. Thus allosuppression appears to involve the recognition by T cells of alloantigens on responding B cells and direct suppression of some early event in the development of these B cells into PFC. The responses of primed B cells were found to be preferentially sensitive to the suppressive effects of allo- T cells, whereas the response of unprimed B cells was influenced preferentially by the helper effects of alloantigen-activated T cells. It is possible that the state of differentiation of the B cell may determine the outcome of the interaction with regulatory T cells.     

Regulation of the anti-alpha (1,3) dextran response: two populations of dextran-reactive B cells that differ in their T cell requirements for induction to antibody synthesis

The in vitro antibody response to dextran B1355S, a thymus-independent Type 2 antigen, requires T cell-derived lymphokines but is not thought to require an activation signal from an antigen-specific T helper cell. The present study demonstrates that there are two dextran-reactive B cell populations in BALB/c mice with respect to the T cell requirements for the generation of antibody-forming cells. One population found among dextran-reactive spleen B cells from 12- to 14-mo-old BALB/c mice generated anti-dextran PFC in the presence of B cell growth factor (BCGF II) and IL 2 or the combination of BCGF II, IL 2, and IFN-gamma. A second population of dextran-reactive B cells found in spleen and Peyer's patches of 2-mo-old unprimed mice did not respond to these same lymphokines, but did generate anti-dextran plaque-forming cells in the presence of Thy-1.2+, L3T4+ T cells from Peyer's patches. However, splenic B cells obtained from 2-mo-old mice that had been primed with dextran 2 to 3 days after birth were shown to be responsive to the same lymphokines as dextran-reactive B cells from 12- to 14-mo-old mice. These results suggest that previous priming with dextran B1355S induces a dextran-specific B cell population that can be activated to antibody-forming cells in the presence of antigen and T cell-derived lymphokines, whereas a second, unprimed population requires an additional activation signal from L3T4+ T cells.     

Regulation of antibody production by helper T cell clones in experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis

Ten acetylcholine receptor (AChR)-specific T cell clones from Lewis rats were studied. These clones had various AChR subunit and peptide specificities, and proliferated in response to antigen on appropriate APC. All the T cell clones were CD4+CD8- and OX22-, helped anti-AChR antibody production by AChR-primed lymph node B cells, and could secrete IL-2. However, several lines of evidence suggested that IL-2 was not the lymphokine that mediated T cell help. B cells primed with native AChR and then exposed in culture to very low concentrations of native AChR effectively presented the Ag to the T cell lines, presumably due to uptake via Ag receptors, but primed B cells were no more effective than were non-specific APC at presenting a synthetic AChR peptide which is recognized by AChR-specific T cells but not by AChR-specific B cells. Increasing AChR doses produced an antibody production response that was bell shaped and low doses stimulated, whereas higher AChR concentrations suppressed the antibody production response. Evidence suggested that AChR exerted its inhibitory effect through the T cells, but not via IL-2.     

Correlation between the biologic functions and the generation of lymphokines in T cell clones

We have recently reported that various murine T cell clones produce IL-1. Based on this observation we have analyzed in the present study the correlation between the biological functions and the generation of different lymphokines in (T,G)-A--L specific CD4+ clones. One subset of clones--the "helper clones"--were found to provide help to primed B cells, in vitro. These cells could be shown to produce IL-1, IL-2, and B cell stimulatory factor 1 (IL-4) activities and to express mRNA encoding for these three cytokines. The second subset of clones, termed "proliferative clones", were unable to help B cells in vitro but expressed vigorous Ag-dependent proliferations. These cells did not express IL-1, IL-2, or IL-4 activities. They produced another lymphokine(s) which may be granulocyte-macrophage-CSF, or some other factor recognized by the HT2 cell line. This study further substantiates the link between T cell activities and lymphokine repertoire with a special emphasis on the potential role(s) of T cell-derived IL-1.     

Accessory cells in the in vitro generation of type C virus-specific T killer lymphocytes. II. Demonstration of a T helper cell in the spleen of in vivo primed mice

The existence of a helper T cell cooperating with cytolytic T lymphocytes (CTL) in cell-mediated anti-tumor responses specific for the virus-induced FMR antigens can be demonstrated by using unprimed thymocytes as CTL precursors and in vivo primed irradiated spleen cells as helper. The helper T cells express Thy-1.2 and Lyt-1.2 antigens at their surface, but not Lyt-2.2. The helper function required the presence of macrophages to be detected, is antigen specific, and appears unusually radiosensitive compared with previously described helper T cell function.     

In vitro antibody response to influenza virus. I. T cell dependence of secondary response to hemagglutinin.

A good secondary IgG response to the hemagglutinin (HA) of influenza virus has been obtained in vitro in Marbrook-type cultures of influenza-primed mouse spleen cell suspensions stimulated with inactivated influenza virus. Anti-HA antibody was quantitated by a solid phase radioimmunoassay (RIA) by using purified HA as substrate. The T dependence of this secondary response was shown by depletion of T cells and reconstitution with a source of primed or unprimed T cells. The help given by T cells primed to the homologous virus was many times greater than that given by unprimed T cells, although the latter was significant. The system described will allow investigation of the specificity requirements of helper T cells engaged in the anti-HA response.     

Antigen-specific and nonspecific mediatiors of T cell/B cell cooperation. II. Two helper T cells distinguished by their antigen sensitivities.

Further evidence is presented for two types of helper T cells in the mouse specific for the protein antigen, keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH). The first cell helps B cells respond to the trinitrophenyl hapten (TNP) coupled to KLH, is primed by relatively high doses of antigen in vivo, and yet the effector cell is stimulated by very low doses of antigen in vitro. The second cell helps B cells respond to a non-cross-reacting antigen, sheep red blood cells, presumably via production of a nonspecific factor. This cell is primed by relatively low doses of antigen in vivo, but the effector cell requires relatively high doses of antigen in vitro. Thus, the two T cell types are differently sensitive to antigen dose, both in priming and challenge. The properties of T cells responding to KLH by proliferation in vitro were also studied. These cells showed the same antigen-sensitivity in vitro, as cells producing nonspecific B cell-stimulating factors.     

Activation via TCR or IL-2 receptor of a CD8+ suppressor T cell clone: Effect on IL-10 production and on proliferation of the suppressor T cell

In a previous study, we established CD8⁺ suppressor T cell (Ts) clone 13G2 which produced the suppressive lymphokine, interleukin-10 (IL-10). In this study, we examined what physiological activator could induce both production of IL-10 from 13G2 and the proliferation of 13G2. Both the antigenic stimulation mimicked by the anti-CD3 antibody and the T cell growth factor interleukin-2 (IL-2) induced IL-10 production from the 13G2 clone equally well. 13G2 cells proliferated remarkably with IL-2 stimulation, while anti-CD3 only slightly induced proliferation of the clone. 13G2 cells also produced IL-10 in the presence of hydroxyurea which blocked transit of cells from G₁ to S phase. However, cycloheximide blocked the production of IL-10 from the Ts clone. The study demonstrates that both the anti-CD3 antibody and IL-2 induced IL-10 synthesis of the Ts clone equally well, and the proliferative response of Ts cells was induced more by IL-2 than by anti-CD3. IL-2 proved to be a good stimulator for Ts cells to produce suppressive lymphokine and to multiply their population.Abbreviation Ts suppressor T cell - Th helper T cell - Ag antigen - APC antigen presenting cell - IL interleukin - TCR T cell receptor - mAb monoclonal antibody