Novel Mutations in the CLCN1 Gene of Myotonia Congenita: 2 Case Reports

Introduction: Myotonia Congenita is an inherited myotonia that is due to a mutation in the skeletal muscle chloride channel CLCN1. These mutations lead to reduced sarcolemmal chloride conductance, causing delayed muscle relaxation that is evident as clinical and electrical myotonia.Methods: We report the clinical presentations of two individuals with Myotonia Congenita (MC).Results: Patient 1 has been diagnosed with the recessive form of MC, known as the Becker variant, and Patient 2 has been diagnosed with the dominant form of MC, known as the Thomsen variant. In both patients, the diagnosis was made based on the clinical presentation, EMG and CLCN1 gene sequencing. Patient 1 also had a muscle biopsy.Conclusions: Genetic testing in both patients reveals previously unidentified mutations in the CLCN1 gene specific to Myotonia Congenita. We report the salient clinical features of each patient and discuss the effects and common types of CLCN1 mutations and review the literature.     

Myotonia congenita: novel mutations in CLCN1 gene

Myotonia congenita belongs to the group of non-dystrophic myotonia caused by mutations of CLCN1gene, which encodes human skeletal muscle chloride channel 1. It can be inherited either in autosomal dominant (Thomsen disease) or recessive (Becker disease) forms. Here we have sequenced all 23 exons and exon-intron boundaries of the CLCN1 gene, in a panel of 5 unrelated Chinese patients with myotonia congenita (2 with dominant and 3 with recessive form). In addition, detailed clinical analysis was performed in these patients to summarize their clinical characteristics in relation to their genotypes. Mutational analyses revealed 7 different point mutations. Of these, we have found 3 novel mutations including 2 missense (R47W, V229M), one splicing (IVS19+2T>C), and 4 known mutations (Y261C,G523D, M560T, G859D). Our data expand the spectrum of CLCN1 mutations and provide insights for genotype–phenotype correlations of myotonia congenita in the Chinese population.     

Electrophysiological Characteristics of Six Mutations in hClC-1 of Korean Patients with Myotonia Congenita

ClC-1 is a member of a large family of voltage-gated chloride channels, abundantly expressed in human skeletal muscle. Mutations in ClC-1 are associated with myotonia congenita (MC) and result in loss of regulation of membrane excitability in skeletal muscle. We studied the electrophysiological characteristics of six mutants found among Korean MC patients, using patch clamp methods in HEK293 cells. Here, we found that the autosomal dominant mutants S189C and P480S displayed reduced chloride conductances compared to WT. Autosomal recessive mutant M128I did not show a typical rapid deactivation of Cl⁻ currents. While sporadic mutant G523D displayed sustained activation of Cl⁻ currents in the whole cell traces, the other sporadic mutants, M373L and M609K, demonstrated rapid deactivations. V_1/2 of these mutants was shifted to more depolarizing potentials. In order to identify potential effects on gating processes, slow and fast gating was analyzed for each mutant. We show that slow gating of the mutants tends to be shifted toward more positive potentials in comparison to WT. Collectively, these six mutants found among Korean patients demonstrated modifications of channel gating behaviors and reduced chloride conductances that likely contribute to the physiologic changes of MC.     

Myotonia congenita: novel mutations in CLCN1 gene

Myotonia congenita belongs to the group of non-dystrophic myotonia caused by mutations of CLCN1gene, which encodes human skeletal muscle chloride channel 1. It can be inherited either in autosomal dominant (Thomsen disease) or recessive (Becker disease) forms. Here we have sequenced all 23 exons and exon-intron boundaries of the CLCN1 gene, in a panel of 5 unrelated Chinese patients with myotonia congenita (2 with dominant and 3 with recessive form). In addition, detailed clinical analysis was performed in these patients to summarize their clinical characteristics in relation to their genotypes. Mutational analyses revealed 7 different point mutations. Of these, we have found 3 novel mutations including 2 missense (R47W, V229M), one splicing (IVS19+2T>C), and 4 known mutations (Y261C,G523D, M560T, G859D). Our data expand the spectrum of CLCN1 mutations and provide insights for genotype–phenotype correlations of myotonia congenita in the Chinese population.     

Myotonia Congenita-Associated Mutations in Chloride Channel-1 Affect Zebrafish Body Wave Swimming Kinematics

Myotonia congenita is a human muscle disorder caused by mutations in CLCN1, which encodes human chloride channel 1 (CLCN1). Zebrafish is becoming an increasingly useful model for human diseases, including muscle disorders. In this study, we generated transgenic zebrafish expressing, under the control of a muscle specific promoter, human CLCN1 carrying mutations that have been identified in human patients suffering from myotonia congenita. We developed video analytic tools that are able to provide precise quantitative measurements of movement abnormalities in order to analyse the effect of these CLCN1 mutations on adult transgenic zebrafish swimming. Two new parameters for body-wave kinematics of swimming reveal changes in body curvature and tail offset in transgenic zebrafish expressing the disease-associated CLCN1 mutants, presumably due to their effect on muscle function. The capability of the developed video analytic tool to distinguish wild-type from transgenic zebrafish could provide a useful asset to screen for compounds that reverse the disease phenotype, and may be applicable to other movement disorders besides myotonia congenita.     

Involvement of helices at the dimer interface in ClC-1 common gating

ClC-1 is a dimeric, double-pored chloride channel that is present in skeletal muscle. Mutations of this channel can result in the condition myotonia, a muscle disorder involving increased muscle stiffness. It has been shown that the dominant form of myotonia often results from mutations that affect the so-called slow, or common, gating process of the ClC-1 channel. Mutations causing dominant myotonia are seen to cluster at the interface of the ClC-1 channel monomers. This study has investigated the role of the H, I, P, and Q helices, which lie on this interface, as well as the G helix, which is situated immediately behind the H and I helices, on ClC-1 gating. 11 mutant ClC-1 channels (T268M, C277S, C278S, S289A, T310M, S312A, V321S, T539A, S541A, M559T, and S572V) were produced using site-directed mutagenesis, and gating properties of these channels were investigated using electrophysiological techniques. Six of the seven mutations in G, H, and I, and two of the four mutations in P and Q, caused shifts of the ClC-1 open probability. In the majority of cases this was due to alterations in the common gating process, with only three of the mutants displaying any change in fast gating. Many of the mutant channels also showed alterations in the kinetics of the common gating process, particularly at positive potentials. The changes observed in common gating were caused by changes in the opening rate (e.g. T310M), the closing rate (e.g. C277S), or both rates. These results indicate that mutations in the helices forming the dimer interface are able to alter the ClC-1 common gating process by changing the energy of the open and/or closed channel states, and hence altering transition rates between these states.     

Novel muscle chloride channel mutations and their effects on heterozygous carriers.

Mutations within CLCN1, the gene encoding the major skeletal muscle chloride channel, cause either dominant Thomsen disease or recessive Becker-type myotonia, which are sometimes difficult to discriminate, because of reduced penetrance or lower clinical expressivity in females. We screened DNA of six unrelated Becker patients and found four novel CLCN1 mutations (Gln-74-Stop, Tyr-150-Cys, Tyr-261-Cys, and Ala-415-Val) and a previously reported 14-bp deletion. Five patients were homozygous for the changes (Gln-74-Stop, Ala-415-Val, and 14-bp deletion), four of them due to parental consanguinity. The sixth patient revealed compound heterozygosity for Tyr-150-Cys and Tyr-261-Cys. Heterozygous carriers of the Becker mutations did not display any clinical symptoms of myotonia. However, all heterozygous males, but none of the heterozygous females, exhibited myotonic discharges in the electromyogram suggesting (i) a gene dosage effect of the mutations on the chloride conductance and (ii) male predominance of subclinical myotonia. Furthermore, we report a novel Gly-200-Arg mutation resulting in a dominant phenotype in a male and a partially dominant phenotype in his mother. We discuss potential causes of the gender preference and the molecular mechanisms that may determine the mode of inheritance.     

Spectrum of mutations in the major human skeletal muscle chloride channel gene (CLCN1) leading to myotonia.

Autosomal dominant myotonia congenita and autosomal recessive generalized myotonia (GM) are genetic disorders characterized by the symptom of myotonia, which is based on an electrical instability of the muscle fiber membrane. Recently, these two phenotypes have been associated with mutations in the major muscle chloride channel gene CLCN1 on human chromosome 7q35. We have systematically screened the open reading frame of the CLCN1 gene for mutations by SSC analysis (SSCA) in a panel of 24 families and 17 single unrelated patients with human myotonia. By direct sequencing of aberrant SSCA conformers were revealed 15 different mutations in a total of 18 unrelated families and 13 single patients. Of these, 10 were novel (7 missense mutations, 2 mutations leading to frameshift, and 1 mutation predicted to affect normal splicing). In our overall sample of 94 GM chromosomes we were able to detect 48 (51%) mutant GM alleles. Three mutations (F413C), R894X, and a 14-bp deletion in exon 13) account for 32% of the GM chromosomes in the German population. Our finding that A437T is probably a polymorphism is in contrast to a recent report that the recessive phenotype GM is associated with this amino acid change. We also demonstrate that the R894X mutation may act as a recessive or a dominant mutation in the CLCN1 gene, probably depending on the genetic background. Functional expression of the R894X mutant in Xenopus oocytes revealed a large reduction, but not complete abolition, of chloride currents. Further, it had a weak dominant negative effect on wild-type currents in coexpression studies. Reduction of currents predicted for heterozygous carriers are close to the borderline value, which is sufficient to elicit myotonia.     

Multimeric structure of ClC-1 chloride channel revealed by mutations in dominant myotonia congenita (Thomsen).

Voltage-gated ClC chloride channels play important roles in cell volume regulation, control of muscle excitability, and probably transepithelial transport. ClC channels can be functionally expressed without other subunits, but it is unknown whether they function as monomers. We now exploit the properties of human mutations in the muscle chloride channel, ClC-1, to explore its multimeric structure. This is based on analysis of the dominant negative effects of ClC-1 mutations causing myotonia congenita (MC, Thomsen's disease), including a newly identified mutation (P480L) in Thomsen's own family. In a co-expression assay, Thomsen's mutation dramatically inhibits normal ClC-1 function. A mutation found in Canadian MC families (G230E) has a less pronounced dominant negative effect, which can be explained by functional WT/G230E heterooligomeric channels with altered kinetics and selectivity. Analysis of both mutants shows independently that ClC-1 functions as a homooligomer with most likely four subunits.     

A Novel Mutation in CLCN1 Associated with Feline Myotonia Congenita

Myotonia congenita (MC) is a skeletal muscle channelopathy characterized by inability of the muscle to relax following voluntary contraction. Worldwide population prevalence in humans is 1∶100,000. Studies in mice, dogs, humans and goats confirmed myotonia associated with functional defects in chloride channels and mutations in a skeletal muscle chloride channel (CLCN1). CLCN1 encodes for the most abundant chloride channel in the skeletal muscle cell membrane. Five random bred cats from Winnipeg, Canada with MC were examined. All cats had a protruding tongue, limited range of jaw motion and drooling with prominent neck and proximal limb musculature. All cats had blepharospasm upon palpebral reflex testing and a short-strided gait. Electromyograms demonstrated myotonic discharges at a mean frequency of 300 Hz resembling the sound of a ‘swarm of bees’. Muscle histopathology showed hypertrophy of all fiber types. Direct sequencing of CLCN1 revealed a mutation disrupting a donor splice site downstream of exon 16 in only the affected cats. In vitro translation of the mutated protein predicted a premature truncation and partial lack of the highly conserved CBS1 (cystathionine β-synthase) domain critical for ion transport activity and one dimerization domain pivotal in channel formation. Genetic screening of the Winnipeg random bred population of the cats'' origin identified carriers of the mutation. A genetic test for population screening is now available and carrier cats from the feral population can be identified.     

The spectrum of CLCN1 gene mutations in patients with nondystrophic Thomsen’s and Becker’s myotonias

Thomsen??s and Becker??s diseases are the most prevalent nondystrophic myotonias. Their frequency varies, according to different sources, from 1: 100000 to 1: 10000. Thomsen??s myotonia is autosomal dominant, and Becker??s myotonia is autosomal recessive. Both diseases result from mutations of the CLCN1 gene encoding chloride ion channels of skeletal muscles. Molecular genetic analysis of the CLCN1 gene has been performed in patients with diagnoses of nondystrophic Thomsen??s and Becker??s myotonias living in the Russian Federation. A sample of 79 unrelated probands with nondystrophic Thomsen??s and Becker??s myotonias and 44 their relatives has been formed in the Laboratory of DNA Diagnosis of the Medical Genetic Research Center of the Russian Academy of Medical Sciences. Forty CLCN1 gene mutations have been found in a total of 118 chromosomes of 66 probands, including 21 familial and 45 sporadic cases. About half the mutations detected (45%) have been found for the first time; they are not described in the SNP database (ncbi.nlm.nih.gov). The following mutations (substitutions) have been detected in more than one chromosome, accounting for a total of 59.3% of chromosomes with mutations: Gly190Ser (5.9%), c.1437_1450del14 (9.3%), Ala493Glu (5.1%), Thr550Met (3.4%), Tyr686Stop (5.1%), and Arg894Stop (30.5%).     

Splicing of human chloride channel 1

Expression of chloride channel 1 (CLCN1/ClC-1) in skeletal muscle is driven by alternative splicing, a process regulated in part by RNA-binding protein families MBNL and CELF. Aberrant splicing of CLCN1 produces many mRNAs, which were translated into inactive proteins, resulting in myotonia in myotonic dystrophy (DM), a genetic disorder caused by the expansion of a CTG or CCTG repeat. This increase in abnormal splicing variants containing exons 6B, 7A or the insertion of a TAG stop codon just before exon 7 leads to a decrease in expression of the normal splice pattern. The majority of studies examining splicing in CLCN1 have been performed using mouse Clcn1, as have investigations into the activation and suppression of normal splicing variant expression by MBNL1-3 and CELF3–6, respectively. In contrast, examinations of human CLCN1 have been less common due to the greater complexity of splicing patterns. Here, we constructed a minigene containing CLCN1 exons 5–7 and established a novel assay system to quantify the expression of the normal splicing variant of CLCN1 using real-time RT-PCR. Antisense oligonucleotides could promote normal CLCN1 alternative splicing but the effective sequence was different from that of Clcn1. This result differs from previous reports using Clcn1, highlighting the effect of differences in splicing patterns between mice and humans.     

The muscle chloride channel ClC-1 has a double-barreled appearance that is differentially affected in dominant and recessive myotonia

Single-channel recordings of the currents mediated by the muscle Cl- channel, ClC-1, expressed in Xenopus oocytes, provide the first direct evidence that this channel has two equidistant open conductance levels like the Torpedo ClC-0 prototype. As for the case of ClC-0, the probabilities and dwell times of the closed and conducting states are consistent with the presence of two independently gated pathways with approximately 1.2 pS conductance enabled in parallel via a common gate. However, the voltage dependence of the common gate is different and the kinetics are much faster than for ClC-0. Estimates of single-channel parameters from the analysis of macroscopic current fluctuations agree with those from single-channel recordings. Fluctuation analysis was used to characterize changes in the apparent double-gate behavior of the ClC-1 mutations I290M and I556N causing, respectively, a dominant and a recessive form of myotonia. We find that both mutations reduce about equally the open probability of single protopores and that mutation I290M yields a stronger reduction of the common gate open probability than mutation I556N. Our results suggest that the mammalian ClC-homologues have the same structure and mechanism proposed for the Torpedo channel ClC-0. Differential effects on the two gates that appear to modulate the activation of ClC-1 channels may be important determinants for the different patterns of inheritance of dominant and recessive ClC-1 mutations.     

MBNL and CELF proteins regulate alternative splicing of the skeletal muscle chloride channel CLCN1

The expression and function of the skeletal muscle chloride channel CLCN1/ClC-1 is regulated by alternative splicing. Inclusion of the CLCN1 exon 7A is aberrantly elevated in myotonic dystrophy (DM), a genetic disorder caused by the expansion of a CTG or CCTG repeat. Increased exon 7A inclusion leads to a reduction in CLCN1 function, which can be causative of myotonia. Two RNA-binding protein families—muscleblind-like (MBNL) and CUG-BP and ETR-3-like factor (CELF) proteins—are thought to mediate the splicing misregulation in DM. Here, we have identified multiple factors that regulate the alternative splicing of a mouse Clcn1 minigene. The inclusion of exon 7A was repressed by MBNL proteins while promoted by an expanded CUG repeat or CELF4, but not by CUG-BP. Mutation analyses suggested that exon 7A and its flanking region mediate the effect of MBNL1, whereas another distinct region in intron 6 mediates that of CELF4. An exonic splicing enhancer essential for the inclusion of exon 7A was identified at the 5′ end of this exon, which might be inhibited by MBNL1. Collectively, these results provide a mechanistic model for the regulation of Clcn1 splicing, and reveal novel regulatory properties of MBNL and CELF proteins.     

Inward Rectification in ClC-0 Chloride Channels Caused by Mutations in Several Protein Regions

Several cloned ClC-type Cl⁻ channels open and close in a voltage-dependent manner. The Torpedo electric organ Cl⁻ channel, ClC-0, is the best studied member of this gene family. ClC-0 is gated by a fast and a slow gating mechanism of opposite voltage direction. Fast gating is dependent on voltage and on the external and internal Cl⁻ concentration, and it has been proposed that the permeant anion serves as the gating charge in ClC-0 (Pusch, M., U. Ludewig, A. Rehfeldt, and T.J. Jentsch. 1995. Nature (Lond.). 373:527–531). The deactivation at negative voltages of the muscular ClC-1 channel is similar but not identical to ClC-0. Different from the extrinsic voltage dependence suggested for ClC-0, an intrinsic voltage sensor had been proposed to underlie the voltage dependence in ClC-1 (Fahlke, C., R. Rüdel, N. Mitrovic, M. Zhou, and A.L. George. 1995. Neuron. 15:463–472; Fahlke, C., A. Rosenbohm, N. Mitrovic, A.L. George, and R. Rüdel. 1996. Biophys. J. 71:695–706). The gating model for ClC-1 was partially based on the properties of a point-mutation found in recessice myotonia (D136G). Here we investigate the functional effects of mutating the corresponding residue in ClC-0 (D70). Both the corresponding charge neutralization (D70G) and a charge conserving mutation (D70E) led to an inwardly rectifying phenotype resembling that of ClC-1 (D136G). Several other mutations at very different positions in ClC-0 (K165R, H472K, S475T, E482D, T484S, T484Q), however, also led to a similar phenotype. In one of these mutants (T484S) the typical wild-type gating, characterized by a deactivation at negative voltages, can be partially restored by using external perchlorate (ClO₄ ⁻) solutions. We conclude that gating in ClC-0 and ClC-1 is due to similar mechanisms. The negative charge at position 70 in ClC-0 does not specifically confer the voltage sensitivity in ClC-channels, and there is no need to postulate an intrinsic voltage sensor in ClC-channels.     

Mechanism of inverted activation of ClC-1 channels caused by a novel myotonia congenita mutation

The voltage-gated chloride channel ClC-1 is the major contributor of membrane conductance in skeletal muscle and has been associated with the inherited muscular disorder myotonia congenita. Here, we report a novel mutation identified in a recessive myotonia congenita family. This mutation, Gly-499 to Arg (G499R) is located in the putative transmembrane domain 10 of the ClC-1 protein. In contrast to normal ClC-1 channels that deactivate upon hyperpolarization, functional expression of G499R ClC-1 yielded a hyperpolarization-activated chloride current when measured in the presence of a high (134 mM) intracellular chloride concentration. Current was abolished when measured with a physiological chloride transmembrane gradient. Electrophysiological analysis of other Gly-499 mutants (G499K, G499Q, and G499E) suggests that the positive charge introduced by the G499R mutation may be responsible for this unique gating behavior. To further explore the function of domain 10, we mutated two charged residues near Gly-499 of ClC-1. Functional analyses of R496Q, R496Q/G499R, R496K, and E500Q mutant channels suggest that the charged residues in domain 10 are important for normal channel function. Study of these mutants may shed further light on the structure and voltage-gating of this channel.     

Functional evaluation of Dent’s disease-causing mutations: implications for ClC-5 channel trafficking and internalization

ClC-5 is a member of the ClC family of voltage-gated chloride channels. Loss-of-function mutations of its corresponding gene (CLCN5) cause Dents disease, an X-linked kidney disorder, characterized by low-molecular weight proteinuria, hypercalciuria, nephrocalcinosis/nephrolithiasis, and progressive renal failure. Here, we examined the effect of different mutations on function and cellular trafficking of the recombinant protein. Mutant CLCN5 cDNAs were generated by site directed mutagenesis for two premature stop codon variants (R347X and M517IfsX528), and several missense mutations (C221R, L324R, G462 V, and R516 W). We also tested L521R (instead of L521RfsX526 observed) and mutants G506E and R648X (previously reported by others). After heterologous expression in Xenopus oocytes, ClC-5 channel activity and surface expression were determined by two-electrode voltage-clamp analysis and ClC-5 surface ELISA, respectively. Except for the R516 W and R648X variants, none of the mutated proteins induced functional chloride currents or reached the plasma membrane. This is readily understandable for the truncation mutations. Yet, the tested missense mutations are distributed over different transmembrane regions, implying that correct channel structure and orientation in the membrane is not only a prerequisite for proper ClC-5 function but also for Golgi exit. Interestingly, the R648X mutant although functionally compromised, displayed a significant increase in surface expression. This finding might be explained by the deletion of a ClC-5 carboxy-terminal PY-like internalization signal, which in turn impairs channel removal from the membrane. Our observations further imply that recruitment of ClC-5 to alternative routes (plasma membrane or early endosomes) in the trans-Golgi network is mediated via different signal sequences.Electronic Supplementary Material Supplementary material is available for this article at .     

Intracellular β-nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide inhibits the skeletal muscle ClC-1 chloride channel

ClC-1 is the dominant sarcolemmal chloride channel and plays an important role in regulating membrane excitability that is underscored by ClC-1 mutations in congenital myotonia. Here we show that the coenzyme β-nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD), an important metabolic regulator, robustly inhibits ClC-1 when included in the pipette solution in whole cell patch clamp experiments and when transiently applied to inside-out patches. The oxidized (NAD(+)) form of the coenzyme was more efficacious than the reduced (NADH) form, and inhibition by both was greatly enhanced by acidification. Molecular modeling, based on the structural coordinates of the homologous ClC-5 and CmClC proteins and in silico docking, suggest that NAD(+) binds with the adenine base deep in a cleft formed by ClC-1 intracellular cystathionine β-synthase domains, and the nicotinamide base interacts with the membrane-embedded channel domain. Consistent with predictions from the models, mutation of residues in cystathionine β-synthase and channel domains either attenuated (G200R, T636A, H847A) or abrogated (L848A) the effect of NAD(+). In addition, the myotonic mutations G200R and Y261C abolished potentiation of NAD(+) inhibition at low pH. Our results identify a new biological role for NAD and suggest that the main physiological relevance may be the exquisite sensitivity to intracellular pH that NAD(+) inhibition imparts to ClC-1 gating. These findings are consistent with the reduction of sarcolemmal chloride conductance that occurs upon acidification of skeletal muscle and suggest a previously unexplored mechanism in the pathophysiology of myotonia.