Systematic measurements of interleaflet friction in supported bilayers

When lipid membranes curve or are subjected to strong shear forces, the two apposed leaflets of the bilayer slide past each other. The drag that one leaflet creates on the other is quantified by the coefficient of interleaflet friction, b. Existing measurements of this coefficient range over several orders of magnitude, so we used a recently developed microfluidic technique to measure it systematically in supported lipid membranes. Fluid shear stress was used to force the top leaflet of a supported membrane to slide over the stationary lower leaflet. Here, we show that this technique yields a reproducible measurement of the friction coefficient and is sensitive enough to detect differences in friction between membranes made from saturated and unsaturated lipids. Adding cholesterol to saturated and unsaturated membranes increased interleaflet friction significantly. We also discovered that fluid shear stress can reversibly induce gel phase in supported lipid bilayers that are close to the gel-transition temperature.     

Accelerated interleaflet transport of phosphatidylcholine molecules in membranes under deformation.

Biological membranes are lamellar structures composed of two leaflets capable of supporting different mechanical stresses. Stress differences between leaflets were generated during micromechanical experiments in which long thin tubes of lipid (tethers) were formed from the surfaces of giant phospholipid vesicles. A recent dynamic analysis of this experiment predicts the relaxation of local differences in leaflet stress by lateral slip between the leaflets. Differential stress may also relax by interleaflet transport of lipid molecules ("flip-flop"). In this report, we extend the former analysis to include interleaflet lipid transport. We show that transmembrane lipid flux will evidence itself as a linear increase in tether length with time after a step reduction in membrane tension. Multiple measurements were performed on 24 different vesicles composed of stearoyl-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine plus 3% dinitrophenol-linked di-oleoyl-phosphatidylethanolamine. These tethers all exhibited a linear phase of growth with a mean value of the rate of interlayer permeation, cp = 0.009 s-1. This corresponds to a half-time of approximately 8 min for mechanically driven interleaflet transport. This value is found to be consistent with longer times obtained for chemically driven transport if the lipids cross the membrane via transient, localized defects in the bilayer.     

Water permeability of asymmetric planar lipid bilayers: leaflets of different composition offer independent and additive resistances to permeation

To understand how plasma membranes may limit water flux, we have modeled the apical membrane of MDCK type 1 cells. Previous experiments demonstrated that liposomes designed to mimic the inner and outer leaflet of this membrane exhibited 18-fold lower water permeation for outer leaflet lipids than inner leaflet lipids (Hill, W.G., and M.L. Zeidel. 2000. J. Biol. Chem. 275:30176-30185), confirming that the outer leaflet is the primary barrier to permeation. If leaflets in a bilayer resist permeation independently, the following equation estimates single leaflet permeabilities: 1/P(AB) = 1/P(A) + 1/P(B) (Eq. l), where P(AB) is the permeability of a bilayer composed of leaflets A and B, P(A) is the permeability of leaflet A, and P(B) is the permeability of leaflet B. Using for the MDCK leaflet-specific liposomes gives an estimated value for the osmotic water permeability (P(f)) of 4.6 x 10(-4) cm/s (at 25 degrees C) that correlated well with experimentally measured values in intact cells. We have now constructed both symmetric and asymmetric planar lipid bilayers that model the MDCK apical membrane. Water permeability across these bilayers was monitored in the immediate membrane vicinity using a Na+-sensitive scanning microelectrode and an osmotic gradient induced by addition of urea. The near-membrane concentration distribution of solute was used to calculate the velocity of water flow (Pohl, P., S.M. Saparov, and Y.N. Antonenko. 1997. Biophys. J. 72:1711-1718). At 36 degrees C, P(f) was 3.44 +/- 0.35 x 10(-3) cm/s for symmetrical inner leaflet membranes and 3.40 +/- 0.34 x 10(-4) cm/s for symmetrical exofacial membranes. From, the estimated permeability of an asymmetric membrane is 6.2 x 10(-4) cm/s. Water permeability measured for the asymmetric planar bilayer was 6.7 +/- 0.7 x 10(-4) cm/s, which is within 10% of the calculated value. Direct experimental measurement of P(f) for an asymmetric planar membrane confirms that leaflets in a bilayer offer independent and additive resistances to water permeation and validates the use of.     

Ras diffusion is sensitive to plasma membrane viscosity

The cell surface contains a variety of barriers and obstacles that slow the lateral diffusion of glycosylphosphatidylinositol (GPI)-anchored and transmembrane proteins below the theoretical limit imposed by membrane viscosity. How the diffusion of proteins residing exclusively on the inner leaflet of the plasma membrane is regulated has been largely unexplored. We show here that the diffusion of the small GTPase Ras is sensitive to the viscosity of the plasma membrane. Using confocal fluorescence recovery after photobleaching, we examined the diffusion of green fluorescent protein (GFP)-tagged HRas, NRas, and KRas in COS-7 cells loaded with or depleted of cholesterol, a well-known modulator of membrane bilayer viscosity. In cells loaded with excess cholesterol, the diffusional mobilities of GFP-HRas, GFP-NRas, and GFP-KRas were significantly reduced, paralleling the behavior of the viscosity-sensitive lipid probes DiIC(16) and DiIC(18). However, the effects of cholesterol depletion on protein and lipid diffusion in cell membranes were highly dependent on the depletion method used. Cholesterol depletion with methyl-beta-cyclodextrin slowed Ras diffusion by a viscosity-independent mechanism, whereas overnight cholesterol depletion slightly increased both protein and lipid diffusion. The ability of Ras to sense membrane viscosity may represent a general feature of proteins residing on the cytoplasmic face of the plasma membrane.     

Coupled Diffusion of Peripherally Bound Peptides along the Outer and Inner Membrane Leaflets

Transmembrane signaling implies that peripheral protein binding to one leaflet be detected by the opposite leaflet. Therefore, protein recruitment into preexisting cholesterol and sphingolipid rich platforms may be required. However, no clear molecular picture has evolved about how these rafts in both leaflets are connected. By using planar lipid bilayers, we show that the peripheral binding of a charged molecule (poly-lysine, PLL) is detected at the other side of the bilayer without involvement of raft lipids. The diffusion coefficient, D_P, of PLL differed by a factor of √2 when PLL absorbed to one or to both leaflets of planar membranes. Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy showed that the changes of the lipid diffusion coefficient, D_M, were even more pronounced. Although D_M remained larger than D_P on PLL binding to the first membrane leaflet, D_M dropped to D_P on PLL binding to both leaflets, which indicated that the lipids sandwiched between two PLL molecules had formed a nanodomain. Due to its small area of ∼20 nm² membrane electrostriction or leaflet interaction at bilayer midplane can only make a small contribution to interleaflet coupling. The tendency of the system to maximize the area where the membrane is free to undulate seems to be more important. As a spot with increased bending stiffness, the PLL bound patch in one leaflet attracts a stiffening additive on the other leaflet. That is to say, instead of suppressing undulations in two spots, two opposing PLL molecules migrate along a membrane at matching positions and suppress these undulations in a single spot. The gain in undulation energy is larger than the energy required for the alignment of two small PLL domains in opposite leafs and their coordinated diffusion. We propose that this type of mechanical interaction between two membrane separated ligands generally contributes to transmembrane signaling.     

Domain coupling in asymmetric lipid bilayers

Biological membranes are heterogeneous assemblies of lipids, proteins, and cholesterol that are organized as asymmetric bimolecular leaflets of lipids with embedded proteins. Modulated by the concentration of cholesterol lipids and proteins may segregate into two or more liquid phases with different physical properties that can coexist in the same membrane. In this review, we summarize recent advances on how this situation can be recreated in a supported bilayer format and how this system has been used to demonstrate the induction of ordered lipid domains in lipid compositions that are typical for the inner leaflet by lipid compositions that are typical for the outer leaflet of mammalian plasma membranes. Proteins are shown to differentially target such induced inner leaflet domains.     

Domain coupling in asymmetric lipid bilayers

Biological membranes are heterogeneous assemblies of lipids, proteins, and cholesterol that are organized as asymmetric bimolecular leaflets of lipids with embedded proteins. Modulated by the concentration of cholesterol lipids and proteins may segregate into two or more liquid phases with different physical properties that can coexist in the same membrane. In this review, we summarize recent advances on how this situation can be recreated in a supported bilayer format and how this system has been used to demonstrate the induction of ordered lipid domains in lipid compositions that are typical for the inner leaflet by lipid compositions that are typical for the outer leaflet of mammalian plasma membranes. Proteins are shown to differentially target such induced inner leaflet domains.     

Flip-Flop-Induced Relaxation of Bending Energy: Implications for Membrane Remodeling

Cellular and organellar membranes are dynamic materials that underlie many aspects of cell biology. Biological membranes have long been thought of as elastic materials with respect to bending deformations. A wealth of theory and experimentation on pure phospholipid membranes provides abundant support for this idea. However, biological membranes are not composed solely of phospholipids—they also incorporate a variety of amphiphilic molecules that undergo rapid transbilayer flip-flop. Here we describe several experimental systems that demonstrate deformation-induced molecular flip-flop. First we use a fluorescence assay to track osmotically controlled membrane deformation in single component fatty acid vesicles, and show that the relaxation of the induced bending stress is mediated by fatty acid flip-flop. We then look at two-component phospholipid/cholesterol composite vesicles. We use NMR to show that the steady-state rate of interleaflet diffusion of cholesterol is fast relative to biological membrane remodeling. We then use a Förster resonance energy transfer assay to detect the transbilayer movement of cholesterol upon deformation. We suggest that our results can be interpreted by modifying the area difference elasticity model to account for the time-dependent relaxation of bending energy. Our findings suggest that rapid interleaflet diffusion of cholesterol may play a role in membrane remodeling in vivo. We suggest that the molecular characteristics of sterols make them evolutionarily preferred mediators of stress relaxation, and that the universal presence of sterols in the membranes of eukaryotes, even at low concentrations, reflects the importance of membrane remodeling in eukaryotic cells.     

Dynamic force spectroscopy on supported lipid bilayers: effect of temperature and sample preparation

Biological membranes are constantly exposed to forces. The stress-strain relation in membranes determines the behavior of many integral membrane proteins or other membrane related-proteins that show a mechanosensitive behavior. Here, we studied by force spectroscopy the behavior of supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) subjected to forces perpendicular to their plane. We measured the lipid bilayer mechanical properties and the force required for the punch-through event characteristic of atomic force spectroscopy on SLBs as a function of the interleaflet coupling. We found that for an uncoupled bilayer, the overall tip penetration occurs sequentially through the two leaflets, giving rise to two penetration events. In the case of a bilayer with coupled leaflets, penetration of the atomic force microscope tip always occurred in a single step. Considering the dependence of the jump-through force value on the tip speed, we also studied the process in the context of dynamic force spectroscopy (DFS). We performed DFS experiments by changing the temperature and cantilever spring constant, and analyzed the results in the context of the developed theories for DFS. We found that experiments performed at different temperatures and with different cantilever spring constants enabled a more effective comparison of experimental data with theory in comparison with previously published data.     

Role of leaflet asymmetry in the permeability of model biological membranes to protons, solutes, and gases.

Bilayer asymmetry in the apical membrane may be important to the barrier function exhibited by epithelia in the stomach, kidney, and bladder. Previously, we showed that reduced fluidity of a single bilayer leaflet reduced water permeability of the bilayer, and in this study we examine the effect of bilayer asymmetry on permeation of nonelectrolytes, gases, and protons. Bilayer asymmetry was induced in dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine liposomes by rigidifying the outer leaflet with the rare earth metal, praseodymium (Pr3+). Rigidification was demonstrated by fluorescence anisotropy over a range of temperatures from 24 to 50 degrees C. Pr3+-treatment reduced membrane fluidity at temperatures above 40 degrees C (the phase-transition temperature). Increased fluidity exhibited by dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine liposomes at 40 degrees C occurred at temperatures 1-3 degrees C higher in Pr3+-treated liposomes, and for both control and Pr3+-treated liposomes permeability coefficients were approximately two orders of magnitude higher at 48 degrees than at 24 degrees C. Reduced fluidity of one leaflet correlated with significantly reduced permeabilities to urea, glycerol, formamide, acetamide, and NH3. Proton permeability of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine liposomes was only fourfold higher at 48 degrees than at 24 degrees C, indicating a weak dependence on membrane fluidity, and this increase was abolished by Pr3+. CO2 permeability was unaffected by temperature. We conclude: (a) that decreasing membrane fluidity in a single leaflet is sufficient to reduce overall membrane permeability to solutes and NH3, suggesting that leaflets in a bilayer offer independent resistances to permeation, (b) bilayer asymmetry is a mechanism by which barrier epithelia can reduce permeability, and (c) CO(2) permeation through membranes occurs by a mechanism that is not dependent on fluidity.     

On the large error introduced in the estimate of the density of membrane pores from permeability measurements when diffusion in "unstirred layer" within the cells is disregarded

After the development of the "black lipid membrane" techniques, studies of the permeability of labeled water and nonelectrolytes across these artificial membranes have yielded permeability constants comparable in magnitude to those obtained from tracer studies of living cell membranes. This general agreement has affirmed the belief that the living cell membranes are indeed closely similar to these bilayer phospholipid membranes. In this report, we draw attention to a hidden assumption behind such comparisons made: the assumption that labeled material passing through the cell membrane barriers instantly reaches diffusion equilibrium inside the cell. The permeability constants to labeled water (and nonelectrolytes) across lipid layers were obtained using setups in which the lipid membrane was sandwiched between aqueous compartments both of which were vigorously stirred. In studies of permeability of living cell membranes only the outside solution was stirred, the intracellular water remained stationary. Yet the calculations of permeability constants of the cell membrane were made with the tacit assumption, that once the labeled materials pass through the cell membrane, they were instantly mixed with the entire cell contents as if a stirrer operating at infinite speed had been present inside the cells. Ignoring this unstirred condition of the intracellular water, in fact, lumped all the real-life delay due to diffusion in the cytoplasm and added it to the resistance to diffusion of the membrane barrier. The result is an estimated membrane permeability to labeled water (and nonelectrolytes) many times slower than it actually is. The present report begins with a detailed analysis of a specific case: tritiated water diffusion from giant barnacle muscle fibers and two non-living models, one real, one imagined.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Transbilayer effects of raft-like lipid domains in asymmetric planar bilayers measured by single molecule tracking

Cell membranes have complex lipid compositions, including an asymmetric distribution of phospholipids between the opposing leaflets of the bilayer. Although it has been demonstrated that the lipid composition of the outer leaflet of the plasma membrane is sufficient for the formation of raft-like liquid-ordered (l(o)) phase domains, the influence that such domains may have on the lipids and proteins of the inner leaflet remains unknown. We used tethered polymer supports and a combined Langmuir-Blodgett/vesicle fusion (LB/VF) technique to build asymmetric planar bilayers that mimic plasma membrane asymmetry in many ways. We show that directly supported LB monolayers containing cholesterol-rich l(o) phases are inherently unstable when exposed to water or vesicle suspensions. However, tethering the LB monolayer to the solid support with the lipid-anchored polymer 1,2-dimyristoyl phophatidylethanolamine-N-[poly(ethylene glycol)-triethoxysilane] significantly improves stability and allows for the formation of complex planar-supported bilayers that retain >90% asymmetry for 1-2 h. We developed a single molecule tracking (SPT) system for the study of lipid diffusion in asymmetric bilayers with coexisting liquid phases. SPT allowed us to study in detail the diffusion of individual lipids inside, outside, or directly opposed to l(o) phase domains. We show here that l(o) phase domains in one monolayer of an asymmetric bilayer do not induce the formation of domains in the opposite leaflet when this leaflet is composed of palmitoyl-oleoyl phosphatidylcholine and cholesterol but do induce domains when this leaflet is composed of porcine brain phosphatidylcholine, phosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidylserine, and cholesterol. The diffusion of lipids is similar in l(o) and liquid-disordered phase domains and is not affected by transbilayer coupling, indicating that lateral and transverse lipid interactions that give rise to the domain structure are weak in the biological lipid mixtures that were employed in this work.     

Improving our picture of the plasma membrane: Rafts induce ordered domains in a simplified model cytoplasmic leaflet

By study of asymmetric membranes, models of the cell plasma membrane (PM) have improved, with more realistic properties of the asymmetric lipid composition of the membrane being explored. We used hemifusion of symmetric giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) with a supported lipid bilayer (SLB) to engineer bilayer leaflets of different composition. During hemifusion, only the outer leaflets of GUV and SLB are connected, exchanging lipids by simple diffusion. aGUVs were detached from the SLB for study. In general these aGUVs are formed with one leaflet that phase-separates into Ld (liquid disordered) + Lo (liquid ordered) phases, and another leaflet with lipid composition that would form a single fluid phase in a symmetric bilayer. We observed that ordered phases of either Lo or Lβ (gel phase) induce an ordered domain in the apposed fluid leaflet that lacks high melting lipids. Results suggest both an inter-leaflet and an intra-leaflet redistribution of cholesterol. We used C-Laurdan spectral images to investigate the lipid packing/order of aGUVs, finding that cholesterol partitions into the induced ordered domains. We suggest this behavior to be commonplace, that when Ld + Lo phase separation occurs in a cell PM exoplasmic leaflet, an induced order domain forms in the cytoplasmic leaflet.     

The mystery of phospholipid flip-flop in biogenic membranes

Phospholipid flip-flop is required for bilayer assembly and the maintenance of biogenic (self-synthesizing) membranes such as the eukaryotic endoplasmic reticulum and the bacterial cytoplasmic membrane. Due to the membrane topology of phospholipid biosynthesis, newly synthesized phospholipids are initially located in the cytoplasmic leaflet of biogenic membranes and must be translocated to the exoplasmic leaflet to give uniform bilayer growth. It is clear from many studies that phospholipid flip-flop in biogenic membranes occurs very rapidly, within a period of a few minutes. These studies also reveal that phospholipid translocation in biogenic membranes occurs bi-directionally, independently of the phospholipid head group, via a facilitated diffusion process in the absence of metabolic energy input, and that this type of transport requires specific membrane proteins. These translocators have been termed biogenic membrane flippases, and they differ from metabolic energy-dependent transporters (ABC transporters and MDR proteins). No biogenic membrane flippases have been characterized. This review briefly discusses the importance of biogenic membrane flippases, the various assay methods used for measuring the rate of phospholipid flip-flop, and the progress that has been made towards identifying these proteins.     

Transbilayer Colocalization of Lipid Domains Explained via Measurement of Strong Coupling Parameters

When micron-scale compositional heterogeneity develops in membranes, the distribution of lipids on one face of the membrane strongly affects the distribution on the other. Specifically, when lipid membranes phase separate into coexisting liquid phases, domains in each monolayer leaflet of the membrane are colocalized with domains in the opposite leaflet. Colocalized domains have never been observed to spontaneously move out of registry. This result indicates that the lipid compositions in one leaflet are strongly coupled to compositions in the opposing leaflet. Predictions of the interleaflet coupling parameter, Λ, vary by a factor of 50. We measure the value of Λ by applying high shear forces to supported lipid bilayers. This causes the upper leaflet to slide over the lower leaflet, moving domains out of registry. We find that the threshold shear stress required to deregister domains in the upper and lower leaflets increases with the inverse length of domains. We derive a simple, closed-form expression relating the threshold shear to Λ, and find Λ = 0.016 ± 0.004 k_BT/nm².     

Transbilayer movement of cholesterol in the human erythrocyte membrane

The rate of transbilayer movement of cholesterol was measured in intact human erythrocytes. Suspended erythrocytes were incubated briefly with [3H]cholesterol in ethanol at 4 degrees C, or with liposomes containing [3H]cholesterol over 6 hr at 4 degrees C to incorporate the tracer into the outer leaflet of erythrocyte plasma membranes. The erythrocytes were then incubated at 37 degrees C to allow diffusion of cholesterol across the membrane bilayer. Cells were treated briefly with cholesterol oxidase to convert a portion of the outer leaflet cholesterol to cholestenone, and the specific radioactivity of cholestenone was determined over the time of tracer equilibration. The decrease in specific radioactivity of cholestenone reflected transbilayer movement of [3H]cholesterol. The transbilayer movement of cholesterol had a mean half-time of 50 min at 37 degrees C in cells labeled with [3H]cholesterol in ethanol, and 130 min at 37 degrees C in cells labeled with [3H]cholesterol exchanged from liposomes. The cells were shown, by the absence of hemolysis, to remain intact throughout the assay. The presence of 1 mM Mg2+ in the assay buffer was essential to prevent hemolysis of cells treated with cholesterol oxidase perturbed the cells, resulting in an accelerated rate of apparent transbilayer movement. Our data are also consistent with an asymmetric distribution of cholesterol in erythrocyte membranes, with the majority of cholesterol in the inner leaflet.     

Acyl Chain Length and Saturation Modulate Interleaflet Coupling in Asymmetric Bilayers: Effects on Dynamics and Structural Order

A long-standing question about membrane structure and function is the degree to which the physical properties of the inner and outer leaflets of a bilayer are coupled to one another. Using our recently developed methods to prepare asymmetric vesicles, coupling was investigated for vesicles containing phosphatidylcholine (PC) in the inner leaflet and sphingomyelin (SM) in the outer leaflet. The coupling of both lateral diffusion and membrane order was monitored as a function of PC and SM acyl chain structure. The presence in the outer leaflet of brain SM, which decreased outer-leaflet lateral diffusion, had little effect upon lateral diffusion in inner leaflets composed of dioleoyl PC (i.e., diffusion was only weakly coupled in the two leaflets) but did greatly reduce lateral diffusion in inner leaflets composed of PC with one saturated and one oleoyl acyl chain (i.e., diffusion was strongly coupled in these cases). In addition, reduced outer-leaflet diffusion upon introduction of outer-leaflet milk SM or a synthetic C24:0 SM, both of which have long interdigitating acyl chains, also greatly reduce diffusion of inner leaflets composed of dioleoyl PC, indicative of strong coupling. Strikingly, several assays showed that the ordering of the outer leaflet induced by the presence of SM was not reflected in increased lipid order in the inner leaflet, i.e., there was no detectable coupling between inner and outer leaflet membrane order. We propose a model for how lateral diffusion can be coupled in opposite leaflets and discuss how this might impact membrane function.     

Outer membranes of Gram-negative bacteria are permeable to steroid probes

The permeability of bacterial outer membranes was assayed by coupling the influx of highly hydrophobic probes, 3-oxosteroids, with their subsequent oxidation catalysed by 3-oxosteroid delta 1-dehydrogenase, expressed from a gene cloned from Pseudomonas testosteroni. In Salmonella typhimurium producing wild-type lipopolysaccharide, the permeability coefficients for uncharged steroids were 0.45 to 1 x 10(-5) cm s-1, and the diffusion appeared to occur mainly through the lipid bilayer domains of the outer membrane. These rates are one or two magnitudes lower than that expected for their diffusion through the usual biological membranes. The permeation rates were markedly increased (up to 100 times) when the lipopolysaccharide leaflet was perturbed either by adding deacylpolymyxin or by introducing mutations leading to the production of deep rough lipopolysaccharides. An amphiphilic, negatively charged probe, testosterone hemisuccinate, penetrated much more slowly than the uncharged steroids. Study of various Gram-negative species revealed that P. testosteroni, Pseudomonas acidovorans, and Acinetobacter calcoaceticus showed higher outer membrane permeability to steroid probes and higher susceptibility to hydrophobic agents such as fusidic acid, novobiocin and crystal violet relative to S. typhimurium and Escherichia coli.     

Role of phosphatidylglycerols in the stability of bacterial membranes

An extensive 100-ns molecular dynamics simulation of lipid bilayer composed of mixture of phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) and phosphatidylglycerol (PG) was performed to elucidate the role of PGs to the stability of bacterial membranes. In addition, a control simulation of pure PE over 150 ns was performed. We observed that PGs decrease both the PE headgroup protrusions into the water phase, and the PE headgroup motion along bilayer normal. The above effects are caused by stronger inter-lipid interactions in the mixed bilayer: the number of hydrogen bonds created by PEs is 34% higher in the mixed than in the pure bilayer. Another contribution is due to the numerous ion-mediated inter-lipid links, which strongly enhance interface stability. That provides a plausible mechanism for preventing lipid desorption from the membrane, for example, under the influence of an organic solvent. A more compact and less dynamic interface structure also decreases membrane permeability. That provides a possible mechanism for stabilizing, e.g., bacterial membranes.