Plant–Pathogen Interaction-Related MicroRNAs and Their Targets Provide Indicators of Phytoplasma Infection in Paulownia tomentosa × Paulownia fortunei

Paulownia witches’ broom (PaWB) caused by a phytoplasma, has caused extensive losses in the yields of paulownia timber and resulted in significant economic losses. However, the molecular mechanisms in Paulownia that underlie the phytoplasma stress are poorly characterized. In this study, we use an Illumina platform to sequence four small RNA libraries and four degradome sequencing libraries derived from healthy, PaWB-infected, and PaWB-infected 15 mg·L⁻¹ and 30 mg·L⁻¹ methyl methane sulfonate (MMS)-treated plants. In total, 125 conserved and 118 novel microRNAs (miRNAs) were identified and 33 miRNAs responsive to PaWB disease were discovered. Furthermore, 166 target genes for 18 PaWB disease-related miRNAs were obtained, and found to be involved in plant-pathogen interaction and plant hormone signal transduction metabolic pathways. Eleven miRNAs and target genes responsive to PaWB disease were examined by a quantitative real-time PCR approach. Our findings will contribute to studies on miRNAs and their targets in Paulownia, and provide new insights to further understand plant-phytoplasma interactions.     

Comparative analyses of genetic/epigenetic diversities and structures in a wild barley species (Hordeum brevisubulatum) using MSAP, SSAP and AFLP

We analyzed genetic diversity and population genetic structure of four artificial populations of wild barley (Hordeum brevisubulatum); 96 plants collected from the Songnen Prairie in northeastern China were analyzed using amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP), specific-sequence amplified polymorphism (SSAP) and methylation-sensitive amplified polymorphism (MSAP) markers. Indices of (epi-)genetic diversity, (epi-)genetic distance, gene flow, genotype frequency, cluster analysis, PCA analysis and AMOVA analysis generated from MSAP, AFLP and SSAP markers had the same trend. We found a high level of correlation in the artificial populations between MSAP, SSAP and AFLP markers by the Mantel test (r > 0.8). This is incongruent with previous findings showing that there is virtually no correlation between DNA methylation polymorphism and classical genetic variation; the high level of genetic polymorphism could be a result of epigenetic regulation. We compared our results with data from natural populations. The population diversity of the artificial populations was lower. However, different from what was found using AFLP and SSAP, based on MSAP results the methylation polymorphism of the artificial populations was not significantly reduced. This leads us to suggest that the DNA methylation pattern change in H. brevisubulatum populations is not only related to DNA sequence variation, but is also regulated by other controlling systems.     

Genetic diversity analysis of Jatropha curcas L. (Euphorbiaceae) based on methylation-sensitive amplification polymorphism

Genetic analysis of 56 samples of Jatropha curcas L. collected from Thailand and other countries was performed using the methylation-sensitive amplification polymorphism (MSAP) technique. Nine primer combinations were used to generate MSAP fingerprints. When the data were interpreted as amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) markers, 471 markers were scored. All 56 samples were classified into three major groups: γ-irradiated, non-toxic and toxic accessions. Genetic similarity among the samples was extremely high, ranging from 0.95 to 1.00, which indicated very low genetic diversity in this species. The MSAP fingerprint was further analyzed for DNA methylation polymorphisms. The results revealed differences in the DNA methylation level among the samples. However, the samples collected from saline areas and some species hybrids showed specific DNA methylation patterns. AFLP data were used, together with methylation-sensitive AFLP (MS-AFLP) data, to construct a phylogenetic tree, resulting in higher efficiency to distinguish the samples. This combined analysis separated samples previously grouped in the AFLP analysis. This analysis also distinguished some hybrids. Principal component analysis was also performed; the results confirmed the separation in the phylogenetic tree. Some polymorphic bands, involving both nucleotide and DNA methylation polymorphism, that differed between toxic and non-toxic samples were identified, cloned and sequenced. BLAST analysis of these fragments revealed differences in DNA methylation in some known genes and nucleotide polymorphism in chloroplast DNA. We conclude that MSAP is a powerful technique for the study of genetic diversity for organisms that have a narrow genetic base.     

Patterns of cytosine methylation in an elite rice hybrid and its parental lines, detected by a methylation-sensitive amplification polymorphism technique

DNA methylation is known to play an important role in the regulation of gene expression in eukaryotes. In this study, we assessed the extent and pattern of cytosine methylation in the rice genome, using the technique of methylation-sensitive amplified polymorphism (MSAP), which is a modification of the amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) method that makes use of the differential sensitivity of a pair of isoschizomers to cytosine methylation. The tissues assayed included seedlings and flag leaves of an elite rice hybrid, Shanyou 63, and the parental lines Zhenshan 97 and Minghui 63. In all, 1076 fragments, each representing a recognition site cleaved by either or both of the isoschizomers, were amplified using 16 pairs of selective primers. A total of 195 sites were found to be methylated at cytosines in one or both parents, and the two parents showed approximately the same overall degree of methylation (16.3%), as revealed by the incidence of differential digestion by the isoschizomers. Four classes of patterns were identified in a comparative assay of cytosine methylation in the parents and hybrid; increased methylation was detected in the hybrid compared to the parents at some of the recognition sites, while decreased methylation in the hybrid was detected at other sites. A small proportion of the sites was found to be differentially methylated in seedlings and flag leaves; DNA from young seedlings was methylated to a greater extent than that from flag leaves. Almost all of the methylation patterns detected by MSAP could be confirmed by Southern analysis using the isolated amplified fragments as probes. The results clearly demonstrate that the MSAP technique is highly efficient for large-scale detection of cytosine methylation in the rice genome. We believe that the technique can be adapted for use in other plant species. Received: 23 October 1998 / Accepted: 11 January 1999     

Analysis of DNA methylation in different maize tissues

DNA methylation plays an important role in gene expression regulation during biological development and tissue differentiation in plants. This study adopted methylation-sensitive Amplified fragment length polymorphism （AFLP） to compare the levels of DNA cytosine methylation at CCGG sites in tassel, bracteal leaf, and ear leaf from maize inbred lines, 18 White and 18 Red, respectively, and also examined specific methylation patterns of the three tissues. Significant differences in cytosine methylation level among the three tissues and the same changing tendency in two inbred lines were detected. Both MSAP （methylation sensitive amplification polymorphism） ratio and full methylation level were the highest in bracteal leaf, and the lowest in tassel. Meanwhile, different methylation levels were observed in the same tissue from the inbred lines, 18 White and 18 Red. Full methylation of internal cytosine was the dominant type in the maize genome. The differential methylation patterns in the three tissues were observed. In addition, sequencing of nine differentially methylated fragments and the subsequent blast search revealed that the cytosine methylated 5 ＇ -CCGG-3 ＇ sequences were distributed in repeating sequences, in the coding and noncoding regions. Southern hybridization was used to verify the methylation polymorphism. These results clearly demonstrated the power of the MSAP technique for large-scale DNA methylation detection in the maize genome, and the complexity of DNA methylation change during plant growth and development. The different methylation levels may be related to specific gene expression in various tissues.     

红豆杉脱分化过程中的遗传和表观遗传变异

采用扩增片段长度多态性（AFLP）和甲基化敏感扩增多态性（MSAP）技术分析红豆杉脱分化前后基因组DNA和DNA甲基化状态的变化。选用32个AFLP引物组合从红豆杉植株及其愈伤组织分别扩增出1834个片段,无多态性片段产生。这说明红豆杉植株在诱导形成愈伤组织的过程中基因组DNA保持高度的遗传稳定性。另用32个MSAP引物组合从红豆杉植株及其愈伤组织分别扩增出1197个片段,总扩增位点的甲基化水平由脱分化前的12．4％上升为16．2％,表明红豆杉在脱分化过程中的某些位点发生了甲基化。红豆杉脱分化前后的DNA甲基化模式也存在较大差异,说明DNA甲基化对愈伤组织形成有调控作用。     

Detection of changes in DNA methylation induced by low-energy ion implantation in Arabidopsis thaliana

This study evaluated changes in DNA methylation in Arabidopsis thaliana plants grown from seeds implanted with low-energy N(+) and Ar(+) ions. Methylation-sensitive amplified polymorphism (MSAP) testing revealed altered DNA methylation patterns after ion implantation at doses of 1 × 10(14) to 1 × 10(16) ions/cm(2). Comparison of the MSAP electrophoretic profiles revealed nine types of polymorphisms in ion-implanted seedlings relative to control seedlings, among which four represented methylation events, three represented demethylation events, and the methylation status of two was uncertain. The diversity of plant DNA methylation was increased by low-energy ion implantation. At the same time, total genomic DNA methylation levels at CCGG sites were unchanged by ion implantation. Moreover, a comparison of polymorphisms seen in N(+) ion-implanted, Ar(+) ion-implanted, and control DNA demonstrated that the species of incident ion influenced the resulting DNA methylation pattern. Sequencing of eight isolated fragments that showed different changing patterns in implanted plants allowed their mapping onto variable regions on one or more of the five Arabidopsis chromosomes; these segments included protein-coding genes, transposon and repeat DNA sequence. A further sodium bisulfite sequencing of three fragments also displayed alterations in methylation among either different types or doses of incident ions. Possible causes for the changes in methylation are discussed.     

甘露醇对拟南芥基因组DNA甲基化的影响

以拟南芥(Arabidopsis thaliana)为材料, 研究不同浓度甘露醇处理下拟南芥幼苗生长发育及其基因组DNA的甲基化水平和变化模式。结果表明, 用50、100、150和200 mmol·L^―1甘露醇处理拟南芥种子会对拟南芥幼苗的形态特征和生长态势产生影响; 甲基化敏感扩增多态性(methylation-sensitive amplification polymorphism, MSAP)分析表明, 经50、100、150和200 mmol·L^―1甘露醇处理后, 基因组DNA甲基化比率分别为17.75%、21.15%、15.49%和46.10%。甘露醇处理使拟南芥发生基于DNA甲基化水平和模式改变的表观遗传变异。与对照相比, 在50、100、150和200 mmol·L^–1甘露醇处理下拟南芥幼苗基因组DNA的甲基化和去甲基化比率分别为5.78%、15.48%、10.71%、33.73%及10.98%、5.36%、8.33%、7.69%。由此推测, 5-甲基胞嘧啶百分含量随着甘露醇胁迫的增强而发生不同程度的变化。     

Variation and Patterns of DNA Methylation in Maize C-type CMS Lines and their Maintainers

DNA methylation plays an important role in gene expression regulation during biological development in plants. This study adopted methylation sensitive amplification polymorphism (MSAP) to compare the levels and patterns of cytosine methylation at CCGG sites in maize genome. The tissues assayed included seedlings and tassels of C-type cytoplasmic male sterility (C Huang Zao Si, C 48-2) and its maintainer lines. For each tissue, both C Huang Zao Si and C 48-2 were more methylated than their corresponding maintainers not only on MSAP ratios, but also on the full methylation levels. In different nuclear backgrounds, the two tissues were more methylated in Huang Zao Si than in 48-2, although the two lines shared the same cytoplasm. Full methylation of internal cytosine was the dominant type in the maize genome. In addition, four different classes of methylation patterns were identified in tassels between C-CMS lines and their maintainer lines; these were specific-methylation, demethylation, hypo-methylation, and hyper-methylation. The results obtained demonstrated the power of the MSAP technique for large-scale DNA methylation detection in the maize genome, and suggested the possible association between DNA methylation polymorphism and C-type cytoplasmic male sterility.     

甘露醇对拟南芥基因组DNA甲基化的影响

以拟南芥（Arabidopsis thaliana）为材料,研究不同浓度甘露醇处理下拟南芥幼苗生长发育及其基因组DNA的甲基化水平和变化模式。结果表明,用50、100、150和200mmol·L―1甘露醇处理拟南芥种子会对拟南芥幼苗的形态特征和生长态势产生影响;甲基化敏感扩增多态性（methylation-sensitive amplification polymorphism,MSAP）分析表明,经50、100、150和200mmol·L―1甘露醇处理后,基因组DNA甲基化比率分别为17.75%、21.15%、15.49%和46.10%。甘露醇处理使拟南芥发生基于DNA甲基化水平和模式改变的表观遗传变异。与对照相比,在50、100、150和200mmol·L-1甘露醇处理下拟南芥幼苗基因组DNA的甲基化和去甲基化比率分别为5.78%、15.48%、10.71%、33.73%及10.98%、5.36%、8.33%、7.69%。由此推测,5-甲基胞嘧啶百分含量随着甘露醇胁迫的增强而发生不同程度的变化。     

Evaluation of Genetic and Epigenetic Modification in Rapeseed （Brassica napus） Induced by Salt Stress

Salinity is an important limiting environmental factor for rapeseed production worldwide. In this study, we assessed the extent and pattern of DNA damages caused by salt stress in rapeseed plants. Amplified fragment length polymorphism （AFLP） analysis revealed dose-related increases in sequence alterations in plantlets exposed to 10-1000 mmol/L sodium chloride. In addition, individual plantlets exposed to the same salt concentration showed different AFLP and selected region amplified polymorphism banding patterns. These observations suggested that DNA mutation in response to salt stress was random in the genome and the effect was dose-dependant. DNA methylation changes in response to salt stress were also evaluated by methylation sensitive amplified polymorphism （MSAP）. Three types of MSAP bands were recovered. Type Ⅰ bands were observed with both isoschizomers Hpa Ⅱ and Msp Ⅰ, while type Ⅱ and type Ⅲ bands were observed only with Hpa Ⅱ and Msp Ⅰ, respectively. Extensive changes in types of MSAP bands after NaCI treatments were observed, including appearance and disappearance of type Ⅰ, Ⅱ and Ⅲ bands, as well as exchanges between either type Ⅰand type Ⅱ or type Ⅰ and type Ⅲ bands. An increase of 0.2-17.6% cytosine methylated CCGG sites were detected in plantlets exposed to 10- 200 mmol/L salt compared to the control, and these changes included both de novo methylation and demethylation events. Nine methylation related fragments were also recovered and sequenced, and one sharing a high sequence homology with the ethylene responsive element binding factor was identified. These results demonstrated clear DNA genetic and epigenetic alterations in planUets as a response to salt stress, and these changes may suggest a mechanism for plants adaptation under salt stress.     

Genetically stable regeneration of apple plants from slow growth

Shoot-tips of apple cultivar `Gala' were stored in vitrousing a low temperature slow-growth culture method. All shoot-tips survived 1-year storage, with a significant height increment over that period. Eight `Gala' single-bud sibling lines were established for genetic analysis. Although cytological examination detected chromosomal variation in plants recovered from slow growth culture, the ploidy remained genetically stable relative to the before-storage cultures. An amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) assay was performed to detect DNA sequence variation. No differences in the DNA fragment patterns were observed using 20 primer combinations between the before-storage and the stored samples. In addition, a methylation sensitive amplified polymorphism (MSAP) assay was performed to investigate the DNA methylation status in both the before-storage and stored samples. It was found that the slow-growth storage resulted in a significant DNA methylation change in the stored shoots compared with the before-storage samples.     

Citrus somatic hybrid: an alternative system to study rapid structural and epigenetic reorganization in allotetraploid genomes

Citrus somatic hybrids produced in the past years provide a novel opportunity to study the immediate effects of allopolyploidization on genome structure and methylation. Here, we present a first attempt to investigate the alterations in genome structure and methylation in three sets of citrus somatic allotetraploids and their diploid parents using amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) and methylation-sensitive amplified polymorphism (MSAP) techniques. Our results indicate that all the allotetraploids mainly have the AFLP and MSAP banding patterns containing specific bands from both parents plus some alterations. The incidences of the AFLP polymorphic bands in allotetraploids show a range from 4.61 to 7.88 %, while from 12.50 to 15.67 % of the sites are methylated. In addition, the proportions of callus-parent-specific DNA structure and methylation alterations are much greater than those of leaf-parent-specific alterations in the somatic hybrids. Furthermore, we find that the somatic hybrids take on a greater divergence from the callus parent and a closer relationship to leaf parent in all groups of plants by dendrogram analysis based on AFLP or MSAP data. Taken together, our results suggest that somatic hybrids are very useful in elucidating the immediate changes that occur in newly synthesized allotetraploid.     

Utility of the methylation-sensitive amplified polymorphism (MSAP) marker for detection of DNA methylation polymorphism and epigenetic population structure in a wild barley species (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Hordeum brevisubulatum</Emphasis>)

We report here that by using a modified scoring criterion, the methylation-sensitive amplified polymorphism or MSAP marker can be used effectively to detect polymorphism in DNA methylation patterns within and among populations of a perennial wild barley species, Hordeum brevisubulatum. Twenty-four selected individual genotypes representing four natural populations of H. brevisubulatum distributed in the Songnen Prairie in northeastern China were studied. The utility of MSAP was evidenced by its detection of high levels of polymorphism in DNA methylation patterns between individuals within a given population, and the clear inter-population differentiation in methylation patterns (methylation-based epigenetic population structure) revealed among the four populations. The resolving power of MSAP to detect DNA methylation polymorphism was found to be comparable with that of a retrotransposon-based sequence-specific amplified polymorphism marker, or SSAP, to detect genetic polymorphism in the same set of plants, suggesting that MSAP with a modified scoring criterion can be used efficiently to detect DNA methylation polymorphism and assess epigenetic population structure in natural plant populations. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

猕猴桃倍性混合居群基因组遗传和表观遗传变异

植物倍性混合居群的形成和维系常伴随着明显的基因组遗传及表观遗传变异。利用AFLP和MSAP两种分子标记探讨了中华猕猴桃复合体(Actinidia chinensis)倍性混合居群的遗传变异和结构及其基因组甲基化变异方式。结果表明, 该倍性混合居群具有较高的遗传和表观遗传多样性, 但两者之间没有明显的相关性。种群的遗传多样性与海拔呈显著的负相关(P<0.05), 但表观遗传多样性与海拔不具显著相关性。AMOVA分析显示, 主要的遗传和表观遗传分化出现在倍性小种内部(97.65% vs 99.84%, P<0.05); 同时, AFLP邻接聚类分析显示二者存在一定程度的倍性相关性, MSAP分析则未显示有明显的倍性相关性。进一步研究发现, 中华猕猴桃居群的总甲基化程度为24.86%, 且多倍体具有更多的甲基化位点变异。该研究结果为深入探讨猕猴桃倍性混合居群的形成和维系机制奠定了基础。     

Rapid alterations of DNA sequence and cytosine methylation induced by somatic hybridization between Brassica oleracea L. var. italica and Brassica nigra (L.) Koch

Somatic hybrids were produced between hypocotyl protoplasts of Brassica oleracea L. var. italica (broccoli) and mesophyll protoplasts of B. nigra (black mustard) using polyethylene glycol—mediated protoplast fusion. A total of fifteen somatic hybrids derived from six calli (no. 1, 3, 8, 21, 38 and 44) were obtained. Cytological analysis showed that all the hybrids possessed 2n = 34, the sum of the parental chromosomes and the genomic in situ hybridization analysis revealed their BBCC genome constitutes. Moreover, all the hybrids exhibited different type of meiosis abnormalities, which were more usually observed in pollen mother cells at metaphase II/anaphase II (MII/AII, 16.1–39.6 %) than at metaphase I/anaphase I (MI/AI, 7.8–15.2 %). Simple sequence repeat analysis revealed that all the hybrids showed the same cytoplasmic genome as broccoli. Structure and methylation-variation of the nuclear were investigated by amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) and DNA methylation-sensitive amplification polymorphism (MSAP). Our results indicated that all the hybrids mainly had the AFLP and MSAP banding patterns from the addition of two parents plus some alterations. The incidences of the AFLP polymorphic bands in the hybrids showed a range of 9.8–18.7 % while the DNA methylation alteration in the hybrid no. 38 was 4.07 %. This result suggested that somatic hybridization could induce more DNA sequence changes than methylation alterations in the early stage of allotetraploid hybrids.     

MSAP技术及其在植物上的应用

DNA甲基化在植物的很多生命过程中具有重要作用,检测DNA甲基化的技术应运而生。依据对DNA甲基化敏感程度不同的同裂酶,在AFLP技术的基础上发展而来的MSAP技术可以方便的检测全基因组范围内胞嘧啶甲基化模式及程度。该文对MSAP技术的原理、特点、基本程序及应用进行了阐述。     

Epigenetic instability in genetically stable micropropagated plants of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Gardenia jasminoides</Emphasis> Ellis

Gardenia jasminoides Ellis is an evergreen tropical plant and favorite to gardeners throughout the world. Several studies have documented that in vitro micropropagation can be used for clonal propagation of G. jasminoides Ellis, the efficiency remained low. In addition, no information is available on the genetic and epigenetic fidelity of the micropropagated plants. Here, we report on a simplified protocol for high efficient micropropagation of G. jasminoides Ellis cv. “Kinberly” based on enhanced branching of shoot-tips as explants. The protocol consisted of sequential use of three media, namely, bud-induction, elongation and root-induction. By using two molecular markers, amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) and methylation sensitive amplified polymorphism (MSAP), we analyzed the genetic and DNA methylation pattern stability of 23 morphologically normal plants randomly taken from a sub-population (>100) of micropropagated plants originated from a single shoot-tip. We found that of >1,000 scored AFLP bands across the 23 micropropagated plants, no incident of genetic variation was detected. In contrast, of 750 scored MSAP bands, moderate but clear alteration in several DNA methylation patterns occurred in the majority of the 23 micropropagated plants. The changed methylation patterns involved both CG and CHG sites representing either hyper- or hypo-methylation, which occurred without altering the total methylation levels partly due to concomitant hyper- and hypo-methylation alterations. Our results indicated that epigenetic instability in the form of DNA methylation patterns can be susceptible to the in vitro micropropagation process for G. jasminoides Ellis, and needs to be taken into account in the process of large-scale commercial propagation of this plant.     

Genetic and epigenetic status of triple exotic consanguinity cotton introgression lines

Introgression lines are some of the most important germplasm for breeding applications and other research conducted on cotton crops. The DNA methylation level among 10 introgression lines of cotton (Gossypium hirsutum) and three exotic parental species (G. arboreum, G. thurberi and G. barbadense) were assessed by methylation-sensitive amplified polymorphism (MSAP) technology. The methylation level in the introgression lines ranged from 33.3 to 51.5%. However, the lines PD0111 and PD0113 had the lowest methylation level (34.6 and 33.3%, respectively) due to demethylation of most non-coding sequences. Amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) was used to evaluate the genetic polymorphism in the cotton introgression lines. A high degree of polymorphism was observed in all introgression lines (mean 47.2%) based on AFLP and MSAP analyses. This confirmed the effects of genetic improvement on cotton introgression lines. The low methylation varieties, PD0111 and PD0113 (introgression lines), clustered outside of the introgression lines based on MSAP data, which was incongruent with an AFLP-based dendrogram. This phenomenon could be caused by environmental changes or introgression of exotic DNA fragments.     

MSAP markers and global cytosine methylation in plants: a literature survey and comparative analysis for a wild‐growing species

Methylation of DNA cytosines affects whether transposons are silenced and genes are expressed, and is a major epigenetic mechanism whereby plants respond to environmental change. Analyses of methylation‐sensitive amplification polymorphism (MS‐AFLP or MSAP) have been often used to assess methyl‐cytosine changes in response to stress treatments and, more recently, in ecological studies of wild plant populations. MSAP technique does not require a sequenced reference genome and provides many anonymous loci randomly distributed over the genome for which the methylation status can be ascertained. Scoring of MSAP data, however, is not straightforward, and efforts are still required to standardize this step to make use of the potential to distinguish between methylation at different nucleotide contexts. Furthermore, it is not known how accurately MSAP infers genome‐wide cytosine methylation levels in plants. Here, we analyse the relationship between MSAP results and the percentage of global cytosine methylation in genomic DNA obtained by HPLC analysis. A screening of literature revealed that methylation of cytosines at cleavage sites assayed by MSAP was greater than genome‐wide estimates obtained by HPLC, and percentages of methylation at different nucleotide contexts varied within and across species. Concurrent HPLC and MSAP analyses of DNA from 200 individuals of the perennial herb Helleborus foetidus confirmed that methyl‐cytosine was more frequent in CCGG contexts than in the genome as a whole. In this species, global methylation was unrelated to methylation at the inner CG site. We suggest that global HPLC and context‐specific MSAP methylation estimates provide complementary information whose combination can improve our current understanding of methylation‐based epigenetic processes in nonmodel plants.