Directed evolution of novel protein functions

Directed evolution has been successfully used to engineer proteins for basic and applied biological research. However, engineering of novel protein functions by directed evolution remains an overwhelming challenge. This challenge may come from the fact that multiple simultaneously or synergistic mutations are required for the creation of a novel protein function. Here we review the key developments in engineering of novel protein functions by using either directed evolution or a combined directed evolution and rational or computational design approach. Specific attention will be paid to a molecular evolution model for generation of novel proteins. The engineered novel proteins should not only broaden the range of applications of proteins but also provide new insights into protein structure-function relationship and protein evolution.     

Revisiting the phosphotyrosine binding pocket of Fyn SH2 domain led to the identification of novel SH2 superbinders.

Protein engineering through directed evolution is an effective way to obtain proteins with novel functions with the potential applications as tools for diagnosis or therapeutics. Many natural proteins have undergone directed evolution in vitro in the test tubes in the laboratories worldwide, resulting in the numerous protein variants with novel or enhanced functions. we constructed here an SH2 variant library by randomizing 8 variable residues in its phosphotyrosine (pTyr) binding pocket. Selection of this library by a pTyr peptide led to the identification of SH2 variants with enhanced affinities measured by EC50. Fluorescent polarization was then applied to quantify the binding affinities of the newly identified SH2 variants. As a result, three SH2 variants, named V3, V13 and V24, have comparable binding affinities with the previously identified SH2 triple‐mutant superbinder. Biolayer Interferometry assay was employed to disclose the kinetics of the binding of these SH2 superbinders to the phosphotyrosine peptide. The results indicated that all the SH2 superbinders have two‐orders increase of the dissociation rate when binding the pTyr peptide while there was no significant change in their associate rates. Intriguingly, though binding the pTyr peptide with comparable affinity with other SH2 superbinders, the V3 does not bind to the sTyr peptide. However, variant V13 and V24 have cross‐reactivity with both pTyr and sTyr peptides. The newly identified superbinders could be utilized as tools for the identification of pTyr‐containing proteins from tissues under different physiological or pathophysiological conditions and may have the potential in the therapeutics.     

Context-dependent mutations predominate in an engineered high-affinity single chain antibody fragment

A mutational analysis of the femtomolar-affinity anti-fluorescein antibody 4M5.3, compared to its wild-type progenitor, 4-4-20, indicates both context-dependent and -independent mutations are responsible for the 1800-fold affinity improvement. 4M5.3 was engineered from 4-4-20 by directed evolution and contains 14 mutations. The seven mutations identified as present in each of 10 final round affinity maturation clones were studied here. Affinities of the 4-4-20 single mutant addition and 4M5.3 single site reversion mutants were compared. These experiments identified four mutations, of these seven, that were context-dependent in their contribution to higher affinity. A simplified mutant containing only these seven mutations was created to analyze complete double mutant cycles of selected sets of mutations. Specific mutational sets studied included the ligand contact mutations, the heavy chain CDR3 mutations, the heavy chain CDR3 mutations plus the neighboring residue at site H108, and the early and late acquired mutations on the directed evolution pathway. The heavy chain CDR3 mutational set and the ligand-contacting mutations were shown to provide -1.4 and -2.0 kcal/mol, respectively, of the total -3.5 kcal/mol change in free energy of binding of the seven-site consensus mutant. The mutations acquired late in the directed evolution rounds provided much of the change in free energy without the earlier acquired mutations (-3.1 kcal/mol of the total -3.5 kcal/mol). Prior structural data and electrostatic calculations presented several hypotheses for the higher affinity contributions, some of which are supported by these mutational data.     

Using experimental evolution to probe molecular mechanisms of protein function

Directed evolution is a powerful tool for engineering protein function. The process of directed evolution involves iterative rounds of sequence diversification followed by assaying activity of variants and selection. The range of sequence variants and linked activities generated in the course of an evolution are a rich information source for investigating relationships between sequence and function. Key residue positions determining protein function, combinatorial contributors to activity and even potential functional mechanisms have been revealed in directed evolutions. The recent application of high throughput sequencing substantially increases the information that can be retrieved from directed evolution experiments. Combined with computational analysis this additional sequence information has allowed high‐resolution analysis of individual residue contributions to activity. These developments promise to significantly enhance the depth of insight that experimental evolution provides into mechanisms of protein function.     

Compensatory Evolution of a WW Domain Variant Lacking the Strictly Conserved Trp Residue

Replacement of conserved amino acid residues during evolution of proteins can lead to divergence and the formation of new families with novel functions, but is often deleterious to both protein structure and function. Using the WW domain, we experimentally examined whether and to what degree second-site mutations can compensate for the reduction of function and loss of structure that accompany substitution of a strictly conserved amino acid residue. The W17F mutant of the WW domain, with substitution of the most strictly conserved Trp residue, is known to lack a specific three-dimensional structure and shows reduced binding affinity in comparison to the wild type. To obtain second-site revertants, we performed a selection experiment based on the proline-rich peptide (PY ligand) binding affinity using the W17F mutant as the initial sequence. After selection by ribosome display, we were able to select revertants that exhibited a maximum ninefold higher affinity to the PY ligand than the W17F mutant and showed an even better affinity than the wild type. In addition, we found that the functional restoration resulted in increased binding specificity in selected revertants, and the structures were more compact, with increased amounts of secondary structure, in comparison to the W17F mutant. Our results suggest that the defective structure and function of the proteins caused by mutations in highly conserved residues occurring through divergent evolution not only can be restored but can be further improved by compensatory mutations.     

Exploring Nonnatural Evolutionary Pathways by Saturation Mutagenesis: Rapid Improvement of Protein Function

Random point mutagenesis does not access a large fraction of protein sequence space corresponding to primarily nonconservative amino acid substitutions. The cost of this limitation during directed evolution is unknown. Random point mutagenesis over the entire gene encoding the psychrophilic protease subtilisin S41 identified a pair of residues (Lys211 and Arg212) where mutations provided significant increases in thermostability. These were subjected to saturation mutagenesis to test whether the amino acids not easily accessible by point mutagenesis provide even better ``solutions' to the thermostabilization challenge. A significant fraction of these variants surpassed the stability of the variants with point mutations. DNA sequencing revealed highly hydrophobic residues in the four most stable variants (Pro/Ala, Pro/Val, Leu/Val, and Trp/Ser). These nonconservative replacements, accessible only by multiple (two to three) base substitutions in a single codon, would be extremely rare in a point mutation library. Such replacements are also extremely rare in natural evolution. Saturation mutagenesis may be used advantageously during directed evolution to explore nonnatural evolution pathways and enable rapid improvement in protein traits. Received: 15 March 1999 / Accepted: 28 June 1999     

Improving the quality of industrially important enzymes by directed evolution

Directed evolution is a new process for developing industrially viable biocatalysts. This technique does not require a comprehensive knowledge of the relationships between sequence structure and function of proteins as required by protein engineering. It mimics the process of Darwinian evolution in a test tube combining random mutagenesis and recombination with screening or selection for enzyme variants that have the desired properties. Directed evolution helps in enhancing the enzyme performance both in natural and synthetic environments. This article reviews the process of directed evolution and its application to improve substrate specificity, activity, enantioselectivity and thermal stability.     

蛋白质定向进化及其在微生物代谢调控中的应用

蛋白质定向进化是非理性改造蛋白质的一种有效方法。利用蛋白质定向进化技术可以改变代谢流,扩展或构建新的代谢途径,弱化或消除不必要或有害的代谢途径,从而达到提高某种代谢产物产率或降解有害物质的目的。蛋白质定向进化技术在代谢调控中的应用有效拓宽了代谢工程的应用范围。本文介绍了主要的蛋白质定向进化技术如易错PCR技术、DNA改组技术、交错延伸技术和临时模板随机嵌合技术等,评述了蛋白质定向进化技术对微生物细胞代谢中的关键蛋白进行定向改造,从而改善其代谢能力,调控微生物代谢等的应用。     

Combinatorial engineering of a gene therapy vector: directed evolution of adeno-associated virus

BACKGROUND: Viruses are being exploited as vectors to deliver therapeutic genetic information into target cells. The success of this approach will depend on the ability to overcome current limitations, especially in terms of safety and efficiency, through molecular engineering of the viral particles. METHODS: Here we show that in vitro directed evolution can be successfully performed to randomize the viral capsid by error prone PCR and to obtain mutants with improved phenotype. RESULTS: To demonstrate the potential of this technology we selected several adeno-associated virus (AAV) capsid variants that are less efficiently neutralized by human antibodies. These mutations can be used to generate novel vectors for the treatment of patients with pre-existing immunity to AAV. CONCLUSIONS: Our results demonstrate that combinatorial engineering overcomes the limitations of rational design approaches posed by incomplete understanding of the infectious process and at the same time offers a powerful tool to dissect basic viral biology by reverse genetics.     

STEME系统:一种助力体内定向进化的新工具

通过定向进化(directed evolution)可以快速进行蛋白工程改良及重要基因功能研究,以获得新型农艺性状突变体。近期,中国科学院遗传与发育生物学研究所高彩霞团队和李家洋团队合作构建了新型的饱和靶向内源诱变编辑器(saturated targeted endogenous mutagenesis editors, STEMEs),并在植物中实现了基因的定向进化和功能筛选。该系统融合了现有的2种单碱基编辑技术,成功实现在植物体内同时诱导C:G>T:A、A:T>G:C双碱基编辑,通过靶向OsACC羧基转移酶结构域编码序列定向进化出水稻除草剂抗性植株。这种在体内进行基因定向进化的新方法,对于今后农作物重要农艺性状的筛选和功能基因研究具有重要作用。本文对STEME系统的组成、编辑效率和应用原理进行介绍,并与已有的定向进化方法进行比较,为加速作物种质资源创新研究提供参考。     

Expanding the metabolic engineering toolbox with directed evolution

Cellular systems can be engineered into factories that produce high-value chemicals from renewable feedstock. Such an approach requires an expanded toolbox for metabolic engineering. Recently, protein engineering and directed evolution strategies have started to play a growing and critical role within metabolic engineering. This review focuses on the various ways in which directed evolution can be applied in conjunction with metabolic engineering to improve product yields. Specifically, we discuss the application of directed evolution on both catalytic and non-catalytic traits of enzymes, on regulatory elements, and on whole genomes in a metabolic engineering context. We demonstrate how the goals of metabolic pathway engineering can be achieved in part through evolving cellular parts as opposed to traditional approaches that rely on gene overexpression and deletion. Finally, we discuss the current limitations in screening technology that hinder the full implementation of a metabolic pathway-directed evolution approach.     

Site-saturation mutagenesis is more efficient than DNA shuffling for the directed evolution of beta-fucosidase from beta-galactosidase

Protein engineers use a variety of mutagenic strategies to adapt enzymes to novel substrates. Directed evolution techniques (random mutagenesis and high-throughput screening) offer a systematic approach to the management of protein complexity. This sub-discipline was galvanized by the invention of DNA shuffling, a procedure that randomly recombines point mutations in vitro. In one influential study, Escherichia coli beta-galactosidase (BGAL) variants with enhanced beta-fucosidase activity (tenfold increase in k(cat)/K(M) in reactions with the novel para-nitrophenyl-beta-d-fucopyranoside substrate; 39-fold decrease in reactivity with the "native"para-nitrophenyl-beta-d-galactopyranoside substrate) were evolved in seven rounds of DNA shuffling and screening. Here, we show that a single round of site-saturation mutagenesis and screening enabled the identification of beta-fucosidases that are significantly more active (180-fold increase in k(cat)/K(M) in reactions with the novel substrate) and specific (700,000-fold inversion of specificity) than the best variants in the previous study. Site-saturation mutagenesis thus proved faster, less resource-intensive and more effective than DNA shuffling for this particular evolutionary pathway.     

How protein stability and new functions trade off

Numerous studies have noted that the evolution of new enzymatic specificities is accompanied by loss of the protein's thermodynamic stability (DeltaDeltaG), thus suggesting a tradeoff between the acquisition of new enzymatic functions and stability. However, since most mutations are destabilizing (DeltaDeltaG>0), one should ask how destabilizing mutations that confer new or altered enzymatic functions relative to all other mutations are. We applied DeltaDeltaG computations by FoldX to analyze the effects of 548 mutations that arose from the directed evolution of 22 different enzymes. The stability effects, location, and type of function-altering mutations were compared to DeltaDeltaG changes arising from all possible point mutations in the same enzymes. We found that mutations that modulate enzymatic functions are mostly destabilizing (average DeltaDeltaG = +0.9 kcal/mol), and are almost as destabilizing as the "average" mutation in these enzymes (+1.3 kcal/mol). Although their stability effects are not as dramatic as in key catalytic residues, mutations that modify the substrate binding pockets, and thus mediate new enzymatic specificities, place a larger stability burden than surface mutations that underline neutral, non-adaptive evolutionary changes. How are the destabilizing effects of functional mutations balanced to enable adaptation? Our analysis also indicated that many mutations that appear in directed evolution variants with no obvious role in the new function exert stabilizing effects that may compensate for the destabilizing effects of the crucial function-altering mutations. Thus, the evolution of new enzymatic activities, both in nature and in the laboratory, is dependent on the compensatory, stabilizing effect of apparently "silent" mutations in regions of the protein that are irrelevant to its function.     

A microplate-based evaluation of complex denaturation pathways: structural stability of Escherichia coli transketolase

We have previously developed a rapid microplate-based approach for measuring the denaturation curves by intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence for simple monomeric and two-state unfolding proteins. Here we demonstrate that it can accurately resolve the multiple conformational transitions that occur during the denaturation of a complex multimeric and cofactor associated protein. We have also analyzed the effect of two active-site mutations, D381A and Y440A upon the denaturation pathway of transketolase using intrinsic fluorescence measurements, and we compare the results from classical and microplate-based instrumentation. This work shows that the rapid assay is able to identify changes in the denaturation pathway, due to mutations or removal of cofactors, which affect the stability of the native and intermediate states. This would be of significant benefit for the directed evolution of protein stability, optimizing enzyme stability under biocatalytic process conditions, and also for engineering specific transitions in protein unfolding pathways.     

Transmutation of human glutathione transferase A2-2 with peroxidase activity into an efficient steroid isomerase

A major goal in protein engineering is the tailor-making of enzymes for specified chemical reactions. Successful attempts have frequently been based on directed molecular evolution involving libraries of random mutants in which variants with desired properties were identified. For the engineering of enzymes with novel functions, it would be of great value if the necessary changes of the active site could be predicted and implemented. Such attempts based on the comparison of similar structures with different substrate selectivities have previously met with limited success. However, the present work shows that the knowledge-based redesign restricted to substrate-binding residues in human glutathione transferase A2-2 can introduce high steroid double-bond isomerase activity into the enzyme originally characterized by glutathione peroxidase activity. Both the catalytic center activity (k(cat)) and catalytic efficiency (k(cat)/K(m)) match the values of the naturally evolved glutathione transferase A3-3, the most active steroid isomerase known in human tissues. The substrate selectivity of the mutated glutathione transferase was changed 7000-fold by five point mutations. This example demonstrates the functional plasticity of the glutathione transferase scaffold as well as the potential of rational active-site directed mutagenesis as a complement to DNA shuffling and other stochastic methods for the redesign of proteins with novel functions.     

Novel xylan-binding properties of an engineered family 4 carbohydrate-binding module

Molecular engineering of ligand-binding proteins is commonly used for identification of variants that display novel specificities. Using this approach to introduce novel specificities into CBMs (carbohydrate-binding modules) has not been extensively explored. Here, we report the engineering of a CBM, CBM4-2 from the Rhodothermus marinus xylanase Xyn10A, and the identification of the X-2 variant. As compared with the wild-type protein, this engineered module displays higher specificity for the polysaccharide xylan, and a lower preference for binding xylo-oligomers rather than binding the natural decorated polysaccharide. The mode of binding of X-2 differs from other xylan-specific CBMs in that it only has one aromatic residue in the binding site that can make hydrophobic interactions with the sugar rings of the ligand. The evolution of CBM4-2 has thus generated a xylan-binding module with different binding properties to those displayed by CBMs available in Nature.     

Crystal structure of the Melampsora lini effector AvrP reveals insights into a possible nuclear function and recognition by the flax disease resistance protein P

The effector protein AvrP is secreted by the flax rust fungal pathogen (Melampsora lini) and recognized specifically by the flax (Linum usitatissimum) P disease resistance protein, leading to effector‐triggered immunity. To investigate the biological function of this effector and the mechanisms of specific recognition by the P resistance protein, we determined the crystal structure of AvrP. The structure reveals an elongated zinc‐finger‐like structure with a novel interleaved zinc‐binding topology. The residues responsible for zinc binding are conserved in AvrP effector variants and mutations of these motifs result in a loss of P‐mediated recognition. The first zinc‐coordinating region of the structure displays a positively charged surface and shows some limited similarities to nucleic acid‐binding and chromatin‐associated proteins. We show that the majority of the AvrP protein accumulates in the plant nucleus when transiently expressed in Nicotiana benthamiana cells, suggesting a nuclear pathogenic function. Polymorphic residues in AvrP and its allelic variants map to the protein surface and could be associated with differences in recognition specificity. Several point mutations of residues on the non‐conserved surface patch result in a loss of recognition by P, suggesting that these residues are required for recognition.     

Parallel evolution between aromatase and androgen receptor in the animal kingdom

There are now many known cases of orthologous or unrelated proteinsin different species that have undergone parallel evolutionto satisfy a similar function. However, there are no reportedcases of parallel evolution for proteins that bind a commonligand but have different functions. We focused on two proteinsthat have different functions in steroid hormone biosynthesisand action but bind a common ligand, androgen. The first protein,androgen receptor (AR), is a nuclear hormone receptor and thesecond one, aromatase (cytochrome P450 19 [CYP19]), convertsandrogen to estrogen. We hypothesized that binding of the androgenligand has exerted common selective pressure on both AR andCYP19, resulting in a signature of parallel evolution betweenthese two proteins, though they perform different functions.Consistent with this hypothesis, we found that rates of aminoacid change in AR and CYP19 are strongly correlated across themetazoan phylogeny, whereas no significant correlation was foundin the control set of proteins. Moreover, we inferred that genomictoolkits required for steroid biosynthesis and action were presentin a basal metazoan, cnidarians. The close similarities betweenvertebrate and sea anemone AR and CYP19 suggest a very ancientorigin of their endocrine functions at the base of metazoanevolution. Finally, we found evidence supporting the hypothesisthat the androgen-to-estrogen ratio determines the gonadal sexin all metazoans.     

Directed evolution of a stable scaffold for T-cell receptor engineering

Here we have constructed a single-chain T-cell receptor (scTCR) scaffold with high stability and soluble expression efficiency by directed evolution and yeast surface display. We evolved scTCRs in parallel for either enhanced resistance to thermal denaturation at 46 degrees C, or improved intracellular processing at 37 degrees C, with essentially equivalent results. This indicates that the efficiency of the consecutive kinetic processes of membrane translocation, protein folding, quality control, and vesicular transport can be well predicted by the single thermodynamic parameter of thermal stability. Selected mutations were recombined to create an scTCR scaffold that was stable for over an hour at 65 degrees C, had solubility of over 4 mg ml(-1), and shake-flask expression levels of 7.5 mg l(-1), while retaining specific ligand binding to peptide-major histocompatibility complexes (pMHCs) and bacterial superantigen. These properties are comparable to those for stable single-chain antibodies, but are markedly improved over existing scTCR constructs. Availability of this scaffold allows engineering of high-affinity soluble scTCRs as antigen-specific antagonists of cell-mediated immunity. Moreover, yeast displaying the scTCR formed specific conjugates with antigen-presenting cells (APCs), which could allow development of novel cell-to-cell selection strategies for evolving scTCRs with improved binding to various pMHC ligands in situ.