Unequal exchanges and the coevolution of X and Y rDNA arrays in Drosophila melanogaster

We have examined the molecular basis of the response of individuals of D. melanogaster to artificial selection for high and low abdominal bristles. By monitoring the fate of particular rDNA spacer length variants associated with individually isolated X and Y chromosomes, we show that flies from the low bristle number selection lines have undergone an unequal exchange between the X and Y rDNA arrays. Such exchanges result in translocations between X and Y chromosomes, visualised as X.Y compound chromosomes at mitosis. Transfer of few copies of a length variant between X and Y indicates a clustering of variants. Flies that have reverted back to wild-type seemingly have undergone a second unequal exchange, giving rise to a compound X.Y chromosome containing Y rDNA of normal amounts. Unequal exchanges between X and Y rDNA arrays could contribute to the observed coevolution of rDNA sequences on these chromosomes. The biological significance of this outcome is discussed.     

Extraordinary ribosomal spacer length heterogeneity in a neotyphodium endophyte hybrid: implications for concerted evolution.

An extraordinary level of length heterogeneity was found in the ribosomal DNA (rDNA) of an asexual hybrid Neotyphodium grass endophyte, isolate Lp1. This hybrid Neotyphodium endophyte is an interspecific hybrid between two grass endophytes, Neotyphodium lolii, and a sexual form, Epichlöe typhina, and the length heterogeneity was not found in either of these progenitor species. The length heterogeneity in the hybrid is localized to the intergenic spacer (IGS) and is the result of copy-number variation of a tandemly repeated subrepeat class within the IGS, the 111-/119-bp subrepeats. Copy number variation of this subrepeat class appears to be a consequence of mitotic unequal crossing over that occurs between these subrepeats. This implies that unequal crossing over plays a role in the concerted evolution of the whole rDNA. Changes in the pattern of IGS length variants occurred in just two rounds of single-spore purification. Analysis of the IGS length heterogeneity revealed features that are unexpected in a simple model of unequal crossing over. Potential refinements of the molecular details of unequal crossing over are presented, and we also discuss evidence for a combination of homogenization mechanisms that drive the concerted evolution of the Lp1 rDNA.     

Physical localization of NORs and ITS length variants in old Portuguese durum wheat cultivars

The variation at the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region of the ribosomal DNA has been correlated with the number of nucleolar organizer regions (NORs) in some plant species. Besides, the number of NORs might influence the rate of homogenization of the rDNA repeats. In recent studies, ITS length variants were detected in bread wheat cultivars but no reports about their presence in durum wheat were found. In the present study, we localized and identified the NORs of 51 old Portuguese durum wheat cultivars by using sequential silver staining and fluorescence in situ hybridization performed with the pTa71 rDNA probe. We also detected ITS length variants by PCR-RFLP. No variation at the number of Ag-NORs per metaphase was found among the 51 durum wheat cultivars, but the PCR-RFLP technique carried out with the restriction enzyme HpaII, allowed the detection of ITS length variants among them. The molecular data was used in order to establish the genetic relationships among cultivars and botanical varieties of durum wheat. The knowledge of this feature could be useful for future design of breeding strategies, involving this collection that constitutes an excellent repository of germplasm in Portugal.     

Internal Repetition and Intraindividual Variation in the rDNA ITS1 of the <Emphasis Type="Italic">Anopheles punctulatus</Emphasis> Group (Diptera: Culicidae): Multiple Units and Rates of Turnover

The rapid divergence of repetitive sequences makes them desirable markers for phylogenetic studies of closely related groups, provided that a high level of sequence homogeneity has been maintained within species. Intraspecific polymorphisms are found in an increasing number of studies now, and this highlights the need to determine why these occur. In this study we examined intraindividual variation present in the first ribosomal internal transcribed spacer (ITS1) from a group of cryptic mosquito species. Individuals of the Anopheles punctulatus group contained multiple ITS1 length variants that ranged from 1.2 to 8.0 kb. Nucleotide and copy number variation for several homologous internal repeats is common, yet the intraspecific sequence divergence of cloned PCR isolates is comparable to that of other mosquito species (~0.2–1.5%). Most of the length variation is comprised of a 5′-ITS1 repeat that was identified as a duplication of a conserved ITS2 region. Secondary structure conservation for this repeat is pronounced and several repeat types that are highly homogenized have formed. Significant interspecific divergence indicates a high rate of evolutionary change for this spacer. A maximum likelihood tree constructed here was congruent with previous phylogenetic hypotheses and suggests that concerted evolution is also accompanied by interpopulation divergence. The lack of interindividual differences and the presence of homogenized internal repeats suggest that a high rate of turnover has reduced the overall level of variation. However, the intraindividual variation also appears to be maintained by the absence of a single turnover rate and the complex dynamics of ongoing recombination within the spacer. Electronic supplementary material  The online version of this article (doi:) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.     

Homogenization of geographical variants at the nontranscribed spacer of rDNA in Drosophila mercatorum

rDNA nontranscribed spacer (NTS) lengths of Drosophila mercatorum have been measured in individuals from several geographic regions. Individuals from the different geographic subpopulations share some length fragments but are in general distinct. The length differences, both within and between individuals, arise from different copy numbers of a 250-bp repeating unit that is localized to one part of the NTS. In addition to the length differences caused by the 250-bp repeat, there is a Y chromosome (male)-specific length variant elsewhere in the NTS that is approximately 70 bp shorter than the NTS fragment from the X chromosome. Sexual dimorphism seems to be present in all Drosophila. Also, D. mercatorum has fewer NTS length variants per individual than does D. melanogaster while possessing comparable levels of restriction- site polymorphism. The mechanisms that may cause this pattern of variation are selection, gene conversion, and unequal recombination.      

Length Polymorphisms in Human Proline-Rich Protein Genes Generated by Intragenic Unequal Crossing over

Southern blot hybridization analysis of genomic DNAs from 44 unrelated individuals revealed extensive insertion/deletion polymorphisms within the BstNI-type loci (PRB1, PRB2, PRB3 and PRB4) of the human proline-rich protein (PRP) multigene family. Ten length variants were cloned, including alleles at each of the four PRB loci, and in every case the region of length difference was localized to the tandemly repetitious third exon. DNA sequences covering the region of length variation were determined for seven of the alleles. The data indicate (1) that the PRB loci can be divided into two subtypes, PRB1 plus PRB2, and PRB3 plus PRB4, and (2) that the length differences result from different numbers of tandem repeats in the third exons. Variant chromosomes were also identified with different numbers of PRP loci resulting from homologous but unequal exchange between the PRB1 and PRB2 loci. The overall data are compatible with the observed length variants having been generated via homologous but unequal intragenic exchange. The results also indicate that these crossover events are sensitive to the amount of homology shared between the interacting DNA strands. Allelic length variants have arisen independently at least 20 times at the PRB loci, but only one has been detected at a PRH locus. Comparison of the detailed structures of the repetitious regions in PRB and PRH loci shows that the repeats in PRB genes are very similar to each other in sequence and in length. The PRH genes contain fewer repeats, which differ considerably in their individual lengths. These differences suggest that the larger number of length variants in PRB genes is related to their greater ease of homologous but unequal pairing compared to PRH genes.     

Polymorphism at the ribosomal DNA spacers and its relation to breeding structure of the widespread mushroom Schizophyllum commune

The common split-gilled mushroom Schizophyllum commune is found throughout the world on woody substrates. This study addresses the dispersal and population structure of this fungal species by studying the phylogeny and evolutionary dynamics of ribosomal DNA (rDNA) spacer regions. Extensive sampling (n = 195) of sequences of the intergenic spacer region (IGS1) revealed a large number of unique haplotypes (n = 143). The phylogeny of these IGS1 sequences revealed strong geographic patterns and supported three evolutionarily distinct lineages within the global population. The same three geographic lineages were found in phylogenetic analysis of both other rDNA spacer regions (IGS2 and ITS). However, nested clade analysis of the IGS1 phylogeny suggested the population structure of S. commune has undergone recent changes, such as a long distance colonization of western North America from Europe as well as a recent range expansion in the Caribbean. Among all spacer regions, variation in length and nucleotide sequence was observed between but not within the tandem rDNA repeats (arrays). This pattern is consistent with strong within-array and weak among-array homogenizing forces. We present evidence for the suppression of recombination between rDNA arrays on homologous chromosomes that may account for this pattern of concerted evolution.     

Inheritance of rDNA spacer length variants in man

Summary We studied the rDNA spacer length polymorphism in a sample of 121 individuals belonging to families of 2–3 generations. Our data, obtained by restriction pattern analysis of genomic DNA, confirmed the limited and discrete nature of this polymorphism. Using the pattern as a genetic marker, we analyzed the segregation of length variants in the different families and we investigated the possible occurrence of unequal crossing-over events among homologous and nonhomologous rDNA clusters. No direct evidence of recombination in the spacer region that we analyzed emeged from our study. All the differences in the restriction patterns observed among individuals from the same family could be explained as resulting from meiotic segregation. Family data showed a multichromosomal distribution of NTS length variants and demonstrated a direct correspondence between the frequency of a variant in the population and its degree of spreading on the different rDNA clusters.     

Rates of recombination in the ribosomal DNA of apomictically propagated Daphnia obtusa lines

Ribosomal (r)DNA undergoes concerted evolution, the mechanisms of which are unequal crossing over and gene conversion. Despite the fundamental importance of these mechanisms to the evolution of rDNA, their rates have been estimated only in a few model species. We estimated recombination rate in rDNA by quantifying the relative frequency of intraindividual length variants in an expansion segment of the 18S rRNA gene of the cladoceran crustacean, Daphnia obtusa, in four apomictically propagated lines. We also used quantitative PCR to estimate rDNA copy number. The apomictic lines were sampled every 5 generations for 90 generations, and we considered each significant change in the frequency distribution of length variants between time intervals to be the result of a recombination event. Using this method, we calculated the recombination rate for this region to be 0.02-0.06 events/generation on the basis of three different estimates of rDNA copy number. In addition, we observed substantial changes in rDNA copy number within and between lines. Estimates of haploid copy number varied from 53 to 233, with a mean of 150. We also measured the relative frequency of length variants in 30 lines at generations 5, 50, and 90. Although length variant frequencies changed significantly within and between lines, the overall average frequency of each length variant did not change significantly between the three generations sampled, suggesting that there is little or no bias in the direction of change due to recombination.     

Length and sequence heterogeneity in 5S rDNA of Populus deltoides.

The 5S rRNA genes and their associated non-transcribed spacer (NTS) regions are present as repeat units arranged in tandem arrays in plant genomes. Length heterogeneity in 5S rDNA repeats was previously identified in Populus deltoides and was also observed in the present study. Primers were designed to amplify the 5S rDNA NTS variants from the P. deltoides genome. The PCR-amplified products from the two accessions of P. deltoides (G3 and G48) suggested the presence of length heterogeneity of 5S rDNA units within and among accessions, and the size of the spacers ranged from 385 to 434 bp. Sequence analysis of the non-transcribed spacer (NTS) revealed two distinct classes of 5S rDNA within both accessions: class 1, which contained GAA trinucleotide microsatellite repeats, and class 2, which lacked the repeats. The class 1 spacer shows length variation owing to the microsatellite, with two clones exhibiting 10 GAA repeat units and one clone exhibiting 16 such repeat units. However, distance analysis shows that class 1 spacer sequences are highly similar inter se, yielding nucleotide diversity (pi) estimates that are less than 0.15% of those obtained for class 2 spacers (pi = 0.0183 vs. 0.1433, respectively). The presence of microsatellite in the NTS region leading to variation in spacer length is reported and discussed for the first time in P. deltoides.     

Intra- and interindividual variation in ITS1 of paragonimus westermani (Trematoda: digenea) and related species: implications for phylogenetic studies

We investigated the utility of the ribosomal first internal transcribed spacer (ITS1) for phylogenetic studies on trematodes of the genus Paragonimus. Numerous clones containing ITS1 PCR products were sequenced for P. miyazakii, P. macrorchis, and members of the P. ohirai and P. westermani species complexes. Some additional data were obtained by direct sequencing of PCR products. The ITS1 is composed of three distinct regions: the short 5' end, followed by a tract of approximately 120 nucleotides which occurs a variable number of times in tandem, and the 3' region, which lacks repeats and is referred to as the "post-repeat" fragment. Sequences from all three regions can be aligned among the species studied. Our initial hypothesis, that the post-repeat region would be valuable for phylogenetic studies within the P. westermani complex, was proved wrong. Intraindividual sequence variation in P. westermani was sometimes greater than between individuals of the species complex. In the P. ohirai species complex, however, sequence variation within individuals was minimal. Possible reasons for these observations are discussed. We also wished to determine whether the length variants sequenced were the dominant variants present in Paragonimus species. This was done by probing Southern blots of genomic digests with an ITS1 fragment which lacks repeat sequences. There is generally greater abundance of large variants, with much lower abundance of small variants, such as those sequenced. Differences in ITS1 lengths are attributed largely to differing numbers of repeats, though some exceptions (which are discussed) were found.     

Length and sequence polymorphisms in the ribosomal gene spacer of the Hawaiian sea urchin, T. gratilla

Blot-hybridization of sea urchin (Tripneustes gratilla) genomic DNA with a cloned rDNA probe revealed individual variation in the length of the rDNA repeat unit and also in the non-transcribed spacer sequences. The number of distinct rDNA repeat subclasses distinguishable within any one sea urchin was limited and usually 2 to 3. However, examination of a number of sea urchins indicated a large number of distinct rDNA repeat types in the population as a whole; all of the rDNA repeat types in nine individuals were different. The presence of limited heterogeneity in the rDNA repeats of single individuals, with may different repeat types in the population as a whole, suggests that rDNA variants can be rapidly and selectively propagated within a chromosomal lineage.     

The large spacer of a nuclear ribosomal RNA gene from radish: organization and use as a probe in rapeseed breeding

Summary An Eco RI fragment spanning the spacer region separating two adjacent radish rDNA units was isolated and partially characterized. Although previous studies did not reveal obvious length heterogeneity in radish rDNA units, we observed the presence of several short repeats within this spacer, thus demonstrating that these repeats are not typical of species with variable length rDNA spacer. A short fragment containing two and one-half repeats was sequenced and used as a probe to demonstrate that this short sequence is highly specific for the genus Raphanus. We used these rDNA spacer sequences in preliminary assays for variability among 14 rapeseed cultivars and for introgression of radish rDNA in rapeseed to illustrate the usefulness of these probes.     

Karyotype,chromosomal characteristics of multiple rDNA clusters and intragenomic variability of ribosomal ITS2 in Caryophyllaeides fennica (Cestoda)

Karyotype and chromosomal characteristics, i.e. number and location of ribosomal DNA (rDNA) clusters, and sequence variation of the ribosomal internal transcribed spacer 2 (ITS2) were studied in a monozoic (unsegmented) tapeworm, Caryophyllaeides fennica (Caryophyllidea), using conventional and Ag-staining, fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) with 18S rDNA probe, and PCR amplification, cloning and sequencing of the complete ribosomal ITS2 spacer. The karyotype of this species was composed of ten pairs of metacentric (m) chromosomes (2n = 20). All chromosomes except the pair No. 2 displayed DAPI-positive heterochromatin in centromeric regions. In addition, two distinct interstitial DAPI-positive bands were identified on chromosome pair No. 7. FISH with 18S rDNA probe revealed four clusters of major ribosomal genes situated in the pericentromeric region of the short arms in two pairs of metacentric chromosomes Nos. 8 and 9. Hybridization signals were stronger in the pair No. 8, indicating a higher amount of rDNA repeats at this nucleolar organizer region (NOR). Analysis of 15 ITS2 rDNA sequences (five recombinant clones from each of three individuals) showed 13 structurally different ribotypes, distinguished by 26 nucleotide substitutions and variable numbers and combinations of short repetitive motifs that allowed sorting the sequences into four ITS2 variants. These results contribute to recently published evidence for the intraindividual ribosomal ITS sequence variability in basal tapeworms with multiple rDNA loci and imply that both phenomena may be mutually linked.     

Generalized linear mixed model for segregation distortion analysis

Background

Concerted evolution refers to the pattern in which copies of multigene families show high intraspecific sequence homogeneity but high interspecific sequence diversity. Sequence homogeneity of these copies depends on relative rates of mutation and recombination, including gene conversion and unequal crossing over, between misaligned copies. The internally repetitive intergenic spacer (IGS) is located between the genes for the 28S and 18S ribosomal RNAs. To identify patterns of recombination and/or homogenization within IGS repeat arrays, and to identify regions of the IGS that are under functional constraint, we analyzed 13 complete IGS sequences from 10 individuals representing four species in the Daphnia pulex complex.

Results

Gene conversion and unequal crossing over between misaligned IGS repeats generates variation in copy number between arrays, as has been observed in previous studies. Moreover, terminal repeats are rarely involved in these events. Despite the occurrence of recombination, orthologous repeats in different species are more similar to one another than are paralogous repeats within species that diverged less than 4 million years ago. Patterns consistent with concerted evolution of these repeats were observed between species that diverged 8-10 million years ago. Sequence homogeneity varies along the IGS; the most homogeneous regions are downstream of the 28S rRNA gene and in the region containing the core promoter. The inadvertent inclusion of interspecific hybrids in our analysis uncovered evidence of both inter- and intrachromosomal recombination in the nonrepetitive regions of the IGS.

Conclusions

Our analysis of variation in ribosomal IGS from Daphnia shows that levels of homogeneity within and between species result from the interaction between rates of recombination and selective constraint. Consequently, different regions of the IGS are on substantially different evolutionary trajectories.     

Structure,molecular evolution and maintenance of copy number of extended repeated structures in the X-heterochromatin of Drosophila melanogaster

The 60 kb repeats located in the distal heterochromatin of the X chromosome of Drosophila melanogaster were cloned in overlapping cosmids. These regions, designated as SCLRs, comprised the following types of repeated elements Stellate genes, which are known to be involved in spermatogenesis; copia-like retrotransposons; LINE elements, including amplified Type rDNA insertions; and rDNA fragments. The following steps in SCLR formation were hypothesized: insertion of mobile elements into the rDNA and Stellate gene clusters: internal tandem duplication events; recombination between the rDNA cluster and Stellate tandem repeat; and amplification of the whole SCLR structure. There are about nine SCLR copies per haploid genome, but there is approximately a twofold variation in copy number between fly stocks. The SCLR copy number differences between closely related stocks are suggested to be the result of unequal sister chromatid exchange (USCE). The restricted variation in SCLR copy number between unrelated stocks and the absence of chromosomes free of SCLRs suggests that natural selection is active in copy number maintenance.     

Molecular evolution of a tandemly repeated trnF(GAA) gene in the chloroplast genomes of Microseris (Asteraceae) and the use of structural mutations in phylogenetic analyses

We sequenced the first ca. 900 bp of the 5'-trnL(UAA)-trnV(UAC)/ndhJ region of the chloroplast DNA of different Microseris accessions in order to resolve homoplasious length variation detected in the trnL(UAA)-trnF(GAA) region. We found two to four tandemly repeated trnF genes in the species of Microseris (Asteraceae, Lactuceae) and two in their sister genus Uropappus. Sequences indicated nonhomologous transitions between two, three, and four trnF genes in different Microseris taxa. Independent origins of similar trnF copy numbers were inferred from a chloroplast phylogeny of Microseris. The taxa involved grow on separate continents, supporting parallel origins of similar length variants. The changes in trnF copy numbers were best explained by interchromosomal recombination with unequal crossing over. The 5' copies of the repeats showed the highest sequence conservation, suggesting that these copies are likely to be functional trnF genes, whereas the other ones probably represent pseudogenes. Our results show that length polymorphisms accumulate once a duplicated sequence has become incorporated. Due to parallel gains of similar trnF copy numbers, homoplasious length variation was introduced into the data matrix. The data demonstrate that length polymorphisms cannot be used as indicators for phylogenetic distance unless they can be analyzed at the sequence level.     

Turnover of R1 (Type I) and R2 (Type Ii) Retrotransposable Elements in the Ribosomal DNA of Drosophila Melanogaster

R1 and R2 are distantly related non-long terminal repeat retrotransposable elements each of which inserts into a specific site in the 28S rRNA genes of most insects. We have analyzed aspects of R1 and R2 abundance and sequence variation in 27 geographical isolates of Drosophila melanogaster. The fraction of 28S rRNA genes containing these elements varied greatly between strains, 17-67% for R1 elements and 2-28% for R2 elements. The total percentage of the rDNA repeats inserted ranged from 32 to 77%. The fraction of the rDNA repeats that contained both of these elements suggested that R1 and R2 exhibit neither an inhibition of nor preference for insertion into a 28S gene already containing the other type of element. Based on the conservation of restriction sites in the elements of all strains, and sequence analysis of individual elements from three strains, nucleotide divergence is very low for R1 and R2 elements within or between strains (less than 0.6%). This sequence uniformity is the expected result of the forces of concerted evolution (unequal crossovers and gene conversion) which act on the rRNA genes themselves. Evidence for the role of retrotransposition in the turnover of R1 and R2 was obtained by using naturally occurring 5' length polymorphisms of the elements as markers for independent transposition events. The pattern of these different length 5' truncations of R1 and R2 was found to be diverse and unique to most strains analyzed. Because recombination can only, with time, amplify or eliminate those length variants already present, the diversity found in each strain suggests that retrotransposition has played a critical role in maintaining these elements in the rDNA repeats of D. melanogaster.