Reminiscences of a long-time colleague and friend, Philip C. Hanawalt

Philip Hanawalt is a long time contributor to many areas of the DNA repair field. This article summarizes aspect of his relationship with the author over the past 36 years.     

Gene and sequence specificity of DNA damage induction and repair: consequences for mutagenesis

The field of DNA repair has been expanded enormously in the last 20 years. In this paper, work on gene and sequence specificity of DNA damage induction and repair is summarized in the light of the large and broad contribution of Phil Hanawalt to this field of research. Furthermore, the consequences of DNA damage and repair for mutation induction is discussed, and the contribution of Paul Lohman to the development of assays employing transgenic mice for the detection of gene mutations is highlighted.     

DNA Repair: A changing geography? (1964–2008)

This article aims to explain the current state of DNA Repair studies’ global geography by focusing on the genesis of the community. Bibliometric data is used to localize scientific activities related to DNA Repair at the city level. The keyword “DNA Repair” was introduced first by American scientists. It started to spread after 1964 that is to say, after P. Howard-Flanders (Yale University), P. Hanawalt (Stanford University) and R. Setlow (Oak Ridge Laboratories) found evidence for Excision Repair mechanisms. It was the first stage in the emergence of an autonomous scientific community. In this article, we will try to assess to what extent the geo-history of this scientific field is determinant in understanding its current geography. In order to do so, we will localize the places where the first “DNA Repair” publications were signed fifty years ago and the following spatial diffusion process, which led to the current geography of the field. Then, we will focus on the evolution of the research activity of “early entrants” in relation to the activity of “latecomers”. This article is an opportunity to share with DNA Repair scientists some research results of a dynamic field in Science studies: spatial scientometrics.     

Defective replication of psoralen adducts detected at the gene-specific level in xeroderma pigmentosum variant cells.

Replication of damaged DNA is suspected to play an important role in cell cycle, genetic stability, and survival pathways. Using psoralen photoaddition as prototype DNA damage and the renaturing agarose gel electrophoresis technique to measure DNA cross-linking in individual genes, Vos and Hanawalt previously observed efficient bypass replication of psoralen monoadducts in human genes (J.-M. H. Vos and P. C. Hanawalt, Cell 50:789-799, 1987). To understand the mechanism of bypass replication in human cells, mutants affected in such a process would be useful. We now report that cells from individuals suffering from the hereditary recessive syndrome xeroderma pigmentosum variant (XPV) are hypersensitive to killing induced by photoactivated psoralen. In addition, analysis of psoralen-mediated DNA cross-linking in the rRNA genes indicated that although repair of psoralen adducts was similar to that of normal individuals, XPV cells were markedly deficient in the ability to bypass psoralen adducts during replication; in comparison with normal cells, approximately half as many monoadducts were bypassed during replication in XPV cells. Furthermore, in contrast to normal cells, replication of interstrand cross-links was not detected in XPV. This is the first demonstration of a deficiency in bypass replication detected at the gene-specific level in vivo. A model involving a strand-specific defect in recombinational bypass in XPV is proposed.     

Preferential repair of nuclear matrix associated DNA in xeroderma pigmentosum complementation group C

The distribution of ultraviolet-induced DNA repair patches in the genome of xeroderma pigmentosum cells of complementation group C was investigated by determining the molecular weight distribution of repair labeled DNA and prelabeled DNA in alkaline sucrose gradients after treatment with the dimerspecific endonuclease V of bacteriophage T4. The results were consistent with the data reported by Mansbridge and Hanawalt (1983) and suggest that DNA-repair synthesis in xeroderma pigmentosum cells of complementation group C occurs in localized regions of the genome. Analysis of the spatial distribution of ultraviolet-induced repair patches in DNA loops attached to the nuclear matrix revealed that in xeroderma pigmentosum cells of complementation group C repair patches are preferentially situated near the attachment sites of DNA loops at the nuclear matrix. In normal human fibroblasts we observed no enrichment of repair-labeled DNA at the nuclear matrix and repair patches appeared to be distributed randomly along the DNA loops. The enrichment of repair-labeled DNA at the nuclear matrix in xeroderma pigmentosum cells of complementation group C may indicate that the residual DNA-repair synthesis in these cells occurs preferentially in transcribing regions of the genome.     

Sites of preferential induction of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers in the nontranscribed strand of lacI correspond with sites of UV-induced mutation in Escherichia coli

An approach utilizing fluorescence-activated DNA sequencing technology was used to study the position and frequency of UV-induced lesions in the lacI gene of Escherichia coli. The spectrum of sites of UV damage in the NC+ region of the gene was compared with a published spectrum of UV-induced mutation in lacI (Schaaper, R.M., Dunn, R.L., and Glickman, B.W. (1987) J. Mol. Biol. 198, 187-202). On average, the frequency of UV-induced lesions in the nontranscribed strand was higher than that in the transcribed strand in the region analyzed. A large fraction of mutations occurs at sites of UV-induced lesions in the nontranscribed strand, but not in the transcribed strand. This bias is reduced in an excision repair deficient (UvrB-) strain. In addition, mutations occur overwhelmingly at sites where a dipyrimidine sequence is present in the nontranscribed strand. This bias is also markedly reduced in the UvrB- strain. In light of recent work Mellon and Hanawalt (Mellon, I., and Hanawalt, P.C. (1989) Nature 342, 95-98) describing the preferential removal of cyclobutane dimers from the transcribed strand of the expressed lacZ gene in E. coli, our data suggest that preferential strand repair may have a significant effect on mutagenesis.     

Excssive DNA synthesis inLactobacillus acidophilus during amino acid starvation

Replication of the bacterial chromosome was studied in two substrains ofLactobacillus acidophilus R-26 during amino acid starvation. According to the hypothesis of Maaløe and Hanawalt (1961), already initiated DNA replication cycles are completed under such conditions, with a corresponding 40% increase in the DNA content; new cycles cannot be initiated in the absence of proteosynthesis. Our findings are considerably at variance with this hypothesis. It was found that the course of DNA synthesis and the size of DNA increments during amino acid starvation were influenced by some low molecular weight substances, in particular by deoxyadenylate and spermidine. In the presence of these substances in media without the essential amino acids, prolonged DNA synthesis accompanied by large DNA increments was observed, suggesting that new DNA replication cycles were initiated. The possibility that deoxyadenylate and spermidine influence the regulation of synthesis of the bacterial chromosome is discussed.     

Processivity of T4 endonuclease V is sensitive to NaCl concentration

We previously reported that endonuclease V of bacteriophage T4 reacts processively with pyrimidine dimers in UV-irradiated DNA, tending to react with all of the dimers on one DNA molecule before reacting with any dimers on another DNA molecule [Lloyd, R. S., Hanawalt, P. C., & Dodson, M. L. (1980) Nucleic Acids Res. 8, 5113-5127]. In this paper we show that this processivity depends upon salt concentration: it can be detected in 10 mM NaCl but not, by our methods, in 100 mM NaCl. In addition, we show that endonuclease V binds to unirradiated DNA in 10 mM NaCl but not in 100 mM NaCl. We conclude that T4 endonuclease V binds to pyrimidine dimers in a two-step process in 10 mM NaCl. It first binds electrostatically to undamaged sections of DNA, and it remains bound during the second step in which it "searches" for pyrimidine dimers. Our conclusion is analogous to the expanded target theory developed for Lac repressor [Berg, O. G., Winter, R. B., & von Hippel, P. H. (1981) Biochemistry 20, 6929-6948].     

Separation of large DNA molecules by modified pulsed field gradient gel electrophoresis

Resolution of DNA fragments by pulsed field gradient gel electrophoresis is a function of the pulse time, geometry, and strength of the orthogonal electric fields. The first field geometry described had a number of disadvantages. We show that these disadvantages can be largely overcome by a modified electric field geometry together with an altered switch pattern. These changes are shown to have critical consequences for the technique. Resolution is more uniform across the gel, which permits more samples to be analyzed on the same gel. In addition, DNA molecules follow a migration path that is approximately straight down the gel. This aspect also increases the number of usable wells. One important property of the system described here provides some insight into the mechanism whereby DNA molecules are resolved by this method.     

An angle-variable three-dimensional pulsed field gel electrophoresis system

A three-dimensional pulsed field electrophoretic method based on the simultaneous application of fixed and cyclically alternating polarity fields at a right angle is described. Requiring only minimal electronic hardware it provides highly homogeneous field conditions over a large gel area and the versatility to vary the pulse vector angle. The electrophoretic parameters critical to achieve fast high resolution separation over a wide range of molecular sizes have been optimized and applied to megabase-size chromosomal DNA molecules. The empirical relationships between pulse time, field strength conditions, and resolution limits derived allow selection of coordinated experimental conditions for the separation of specific DNA size ranges.     

Microsecond time-scale discrimination among polycytidylic acid, polyadenylic acid, and polyuridylic acid as homopolymers or as segments within single RNA molecules

Single molecules of DNA or RNA can be detected as they are driven through an alpha-hemolysin channel by an applied electric field. During translocation, nucleotides within the polynucleotide must pass through the channel pore in sequential, single-file order because the limiting diameter of the pore can accommodate only one strand of DNA or RNA at a time. Here we demonstrate that this nanopore behaves as a detector that can rapidly discriminate between pyrimidine and purine segments along an RNA molecule. Nanopore detection and characterization of single molecules represent a new method for directly reading information encoded in linear polymers, and are critical first steps toward direct sequencing of individual DNA and RNA molecules.     

Human repair gene restores normal pattern of preferential DNA repair in repair defective CHO cells.

The pattern of preferential DNA repair of UV-induced pyrimidine dimers was studied in repair-deficient Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells transfected with the human excision repair gene, ERCC-1. Repair efficiency was measured in the active dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) gene and in its flanking, non-transcribed sequences in three cell lines: Wild type CHO cells, a UV-sensitive excision deficient CHO mutant, and the transfected line of the mutant carrying the expressed ERCC-1 gene. The CHO cells transformed with the human ERCC-1 gene repaired the active DHFR gene much more efficiently than the non-transcribed sequences, a pattern similar to that seen in wild type CHO cells. This pattern differs from that previously reported in CHO cells transfected with the denV gene of bacteriophage T4, in which both active and non-transcribed DNA sequences were efficiently repaired (Bohr and Hanawalt, Carcinogenesis 8: 1333-1336, 1987). The ERCC-1 gene product may specifically substitute for the repair enzyme present in normal hamster cells while the denV product, T4 endonuclease V, does not be appear to be constrained in its access to inactive chromatin.     

An unusual electrooptical effect observed for DNA fragments and its apparent relation to a permanent electric moment associated with bent DNA

Dichroism decay curves of DNA fragments with chain lengths in the range of 179-256 bp show an amplitude inversion suggesting the existence of a positive dichroism component, when these fragments are dissolved at monovalent salt concentrations above approx. 5 mM and are exposed to field pulses with amplitudes and/or lengths above critical values. At the critical values, the unusual dichroism is reflected by an apparent acceleration of the decay curves, which can be fitted by single exponentials with time constants much below the values expected from the DNA contour lengths. The critical pulse amplitudes and lengths decrease with increasing DNA chain length and increasing salt concentration. The experimental data are consistent with results obtained by hydrodynamic and electric model calculations on smoothly bent DNA double helices. The DNA is represented by a string of overlapping beads, which is used to calculate the rotational diffusion tensor and the center of diffusion. The distribution of phosphate charges is asymmetric with respect to this center and thus gives rise to a substantial permanent dipole moment. The magnitude of this dipole moment is calculated as a function of DNA curvature and is used together with experimental values of polarizabilities for simulations of dichroism decay curves. The curves simulated for bent DNA show the same phenomenon as observed experimentally. The ionic strength dependence of the unusual dichroism is explained by an independently observed strong decrease of the polarizability with increasing salt concentration. The field strength dependence is probably due to field-induced bending of double helices driven by the change of the dipole moment. Although our calculations are on rigid models of DNA and thus any flexibility of the double helix has not been considered, we conclude that the essential part of our experimental results can be explained by our model.     

Cellular responses to DNA damage: current state of the field and review of the 52nd Benzon Symposium

The response of cells to DNA damage is critical for maintaining genomic integrity and for preventing cancer development. Current advances in our understanding of the response of cells to DNA double-strand breaks and to stalled DNA replication forks and the relationship of these responses to human disease were discussed at the 52nd Benzon Symposium in Denmark, Copenhagen. Here we review the novel findings that were presented at this Symposium and the current state of the field.