Chondrogenesis in chick limb mesenchyme in vitro derived from distal limb bud tips: changes in cyclic AMP and in prostaglandin responsiveness

Chondrogenesis was monitored in micromass cultures of mesenchymal cells derived from the distal tip of stage-25 chick limb buds over a 6-day period. Alcian green staining and immunofluorescent localization of cartilage-specific proteoglycans revealed the appearance of cartilage matrix by day 3 of cell culture. By day 6, cultures contained a uniform and homogeneous population of fully differentiated chondrocytes throughout the cell layer, with only a narrow rim of nonchondrogenic cells around the extreme periphery of the culture. Synthesis of sulfated glycosaminoglycans also progressively increased between days 3 and 6, being 8-fold higher at day 6 than at day 1 of culture. Both adenylate cyclase (AC) activity and cAMP concentrations increased dramatically during the first 2 days of culture, reaching maximal levels by day 2, which remained elevated and stable throughout the remaining chondrogenic period (days 3-6). Responsiveness of both AC and cAMP concentrations of the cells to PGE2 was maximal by day 1 of culture and was increased over control cells by 12-fold and 8-fold respectively. Both responses, however, were dramatically reduced by day 3, at which time the initiation of cartilage formation was apparent. Responsiveness of cells during the prechondrogenic period to PGE2 was relatively specific in that no effects could be demonstrated with equivalent concentrations of PGF2 alpha or 6-keto-PGF1 alpha, although PGl2 did produce increases in cAMP concentrations of about 50% of those of PGE2. These results indicate that previously reported changes in the cAMP system in heterogeneous cell cultures derived from whole limb buds reflect changes occurring in the chondrogenic cell type and indicate further that peak responsiveness of the cAMP system of these cells to prostaglandins is restricted to prechondrogenic developmental periods.     

Chondrogenesis from single limb mesenchyme cells

It is believed that cell-cell interaction between mesenchyme cells is involved in the initiation of chondrogenesis, based largely on the inability of limb mesenchyme cells to differentiate into cartilage unless cultures are inoculated at densities greater than confluency. The present study describes a culture situation in which single limb mesenchyme cells either in or on type I collagen gels are shown to differentiate into cartilage, as defined by the appearance of a pericellular alcian blue staining matrix, intracellular type II collagen (demonstrated by indirect immunofluorescence with monoclonal antibody), and clonable cartilage cells. Because the differentiation of cartilage cells from single mesenchyme cells occurs only when the cells are in a round configuration, it is proposed that cell shape changes are one factor that can mediate effects of cell-cell interaction on differentiation.     

Chondrogenesis in mouse limb bud in vitro. I. Effect of the ectoderm

The role of the ectoderm in the chondrogenesis of mouse limb bud mesoderm was investigated in vitro at several developmental stages by analysis of the evolution of DNA content, the accumulation of sulfated glycosaminoglycans and histochemical procedures. Young limb buds or the undifferentiated apex of older buds (stages 17 and 19 of Theiler's table) from which the ectoderm had been removed with trypsin treatment initiated a large chondrogenesis but not morphogenesis. When the ectoderm was present, these limb buds showed a polarized proximal to distal outgrowth and differentiated skeletal primordia. Mesodermal cells of stage 20 limb bud apex were able to differentiate autopodial skeletons with or without the presence of the ectoderm: cartilaginous areas of the limb skeleton seem determined at this developmental stage. These results, which show the importance of the ectoderm in limb bud morphogenesis, are compared with results obtained using other methods with mouse or bird buds.     

Modification of the cell cycle of limb bud mesenchyme during in vitro cartilage differentiation

A consistent chondrogenesis takes place in micro high-density cultures derived from limb mesenchymal cells of chick embryos of stages 23-24. Flow-cytometric measurements of DNA content showed that cells in the phase of G1 or G0 made up 51% of the dispersed cell suspensions. The proportion of these cells increased to 71% by the onset of cartilage differentiation in day-2 cultures. This ratio was 84% when the voluminous matrix formation began on the 4th day of culturing. Thereafter, it increased to 90% by the 6th day, and to 93% by the 14th day. The results suggest that cartilage differentiates from G0 mesenchymal cells of the limb. In our measurements, however, the G0 phase includes all non-proliferative cell population which have identical DNA content with G1 cells. Therefore, the G0 phase contains also an increasing number of chondroblasts and chondrocytes as the chondrogenesis proceeds.     

Dynamics of BMP signaling in limb bud mesenchyme and polydactyly

Mutations in the Bone Morphogenetic Protein (BMP) pathway are associated with a range of defects in skeletal formation. Genetic analysis of BMP signaling requirements is complicated by the presence of three partially redundant BMPs that are required for multiple stages of limb development. We generated an inducible allele of a BMP inhibitor, Gremlin, which reduces BMP signaling. We show that BMPs act in a dose and time dependent manner in which early reduction of BMPs result in digit loss, while inhibiting overall BMP signaling between E10.5 and E11.5 allows polydactylous digit formation. During this period, inhibiting BMPs extends the duration of FGF signaling. Sox9 is initially expressed in normal digit ray domains but at reduced levels that correlate with the reduction in BMP signaling. The persistence of elevated FGF signaling likely promotes cell proliferation and survival, inhibiting the activation of Sox9 and secondarily, inhibiting the differentiation of Sox9-expressing chondrocytes. Our results provide new insights into the timing and clarify the mechanisms underlying BMP signaling during digit morphogenesis.     

Separation of precursor myogenic and chondrogenic cells in early limb bud mesenchyme by a monoclonal antibody

We have addressed the problem of the segregation of cell lineages during the development of cartilage and muscle in the chick limb bud. The following experiments demonstrate that early limb buds consist of at least two independent subpopulations of committed precursor cells-- those in (a) the myogenic and (b) the chondrogenic lineage--which can be physically separated. Cells obtained from stage 20, 21, and 22 limb buds were cultured for 5 h in the presence of a monoclonal antibody that was originally isolated for its ability to detach preferentially myogenic cells from extracellular matrices. The detached limb bud cells were collected and replated in normal medium. Within 2 d nearly all of the replated cells had differentiated into myoblasts and myotubes; no chondroblasts differentiated in these cultures. In contrast, the original adherent population that remained after the antibody-induced detachment of the myogenic cells differentiated largely into cartilage and was devoid of muscle. Rearing the antibody-detached cells (i.e., replicating myogenic precursors and postmitotic myoblasts) in medium known to promote chondrogenesis did not induce these cells to chondrify. Conversely, rearing the attached precursor cells (i.e., chondrogenic precursors) in medium known to promote myogenesis did not induce these cells to undergo myogenesis. The definitive mononucleated myoblasts and multinucleated myotubes were identified by muscle- specific antibodies against light meromyosin or desmin, whereas the definitive chondroblasts were identified by a monoclonal antibody against the keratan sulfate chains of the cartilage-specific sulfated proteoglycan. These findings are interpreted as supporting the lineage hypothesis in which the differentiation program of a cell is determined by means of transit through compartments of a lineage.     

The differentiation of normal and muscle-free distal chick limb bud mesenchyme in micromass culture

Distal chick wing bud mesenchyme from stages 19 to 27 embryos has been grown in micromass culture. The behavior of cultures comprising mesenchyme located within 350 microns of the apical ectodermal ridge (distal zone mesenchyme) was compared to that of cultures of the immediately proximal mesenchyme (subdistal zone cultures). In cultures of the distal mesenchyme from stages 21-24 limbs, all of the cells stained immunocytochemically for type II collagen within 3 days, indicating ubiquitous chondrogenic differentiation. At stage 19 and 20, this behavior was only observed in cultures of the distal most 50-100 microns of the limb bud mesenchyme. Between stages 25 and 27, distal zone cultures failed to become entirely chondrogenic. At all stages, subdistal zone cultures always contained substantial areas of nonchondrogenic cells. The different behavior observed between distal zone and corresponding subdistal zone cultures appears to be a consequence of the presence of somite-derived presumptive muscle cells in the latter, since no such difference was observed in analagous cultures prepared from muscle-free wing buds. The high capacity of the distal zone for cartilage differentiation supports a view of pattern formation in which inhibition of cartilage is an important component. However, its consistent behavior in vitro indicates that micromass cultures do not reflect the in vivo differences between the distal zones at different stages. The subdistal region retains a high capacity of cartilage differentiation and the observed behavior in micromass reflects interactions with a different cell population.     

Chondrogenesis in mouse limb buds in vitro: Effects of dibutyryl cyclic AMP treatment

Abstract. We studied the effects of dibutyryl cyclic AMP (dbcAMP) on mouse limb-bud chondrogenesis at three stages of embryonic development. After 24 h of culture, limb buds with or without a covering of ectoderm were treated with 1 mM dbcAMP for 48 h and were then compared with untreated cultured limb buds. Treatment with dbcAMP enhanced cartilaginous differentiation in organ cultures of stage-17 and -19 (according to Theiler's) limb buds, although the presence of ectoderm reduced the level of dbcAMP stimulation. By stage 20, treatment with dbcAMP irreversibly inhibited cartilaginous differentiation. These results suggest that the responsiveness of mesenchymal limb-bud cells to dbcAMP is stage related. The results of histological studies as well as of analyses of DNA content and sulphated glycosaminoglycan accumulation supported the hypothesis that dbcAMP treatment induces recruitment of initially non-chondrogenic cells whose commitment explains the enhancement of cartilaginous differentiation. Limb-bud competence for chondrogenesis throughout the three developmental stages studied is also discussed.     

Cell tracing reveals a dorsoventral lineage restriction plane in the mouse limb bud mesenchyme

Regionalization of embryonic fields into independent units of growth and patterning is a widespread strategy during metazoan development. Compartments represent a particular instance of this regionalization, in which unit coherence is maintained by cell lineage restriction between adjacent regions. Lineage compartments have been described during insect and vertebrate development. Two common characteristics of the compartments described so far are their occurrence in epithelial structures and the presence of signaling regions at compartment borders. Whereas Drosophila compartmental organization represents a background subdivision of embryonic fields that is not necessarily related to anatomical structures, vertebrate compartment borders described thus far coincide with, or anticipate, anatomical or cell-type discontinuities. Here, we describe a general method for clonal analysis in the mouse and use it to determine the topology of clone distribution along the three limb axes. We identify a lineage restriction boundary at the limb mesenchyme dorsoventral border that is unrelated to any anatomical discontinuity, and whose lineage restriction border is not obviously associated with any signaling center. This restriction is the first example in vertebrates of a mechanism of primordium subdivision unrelated to anatomical boundaries. Furthermore, this is the first lineage compartment described within a mesenchymal structure in any organism, suggesting that lineage restrictions are fundamental not only for epithelial structures, but also for mesenchymal field patterning. No lineage compartmentalization was found along the proximodistal or anteroposterior axes, indicating that patterning along these axes does not involve restriction of cell dispersion at specific axial positions.     

Speed of pattern appearance in reaction-diffusion models: Implications in the pattern formation of limb bud mesenchyme cells

It has been postulated that fibroblast growth factor (FGF) treatment of cultured limb bud mesenchyme cells reinforces the lateral inhibitory effect, but the cells also show accelerated pattern appearance. In the present study, we analyze how a small change in a specific parameter affects the speed of pattern appearance in a Turing reaction-diffusion system using linear stability analysis. It is shown that the sign of the change in appearance speed is qualitatively decided if the system is under the diffusion-driven instability condition, and this is confirmed by numerical simulations. Numerical simulations also show that a small change in parameter value induced easily detectable differences in the appearance speed of patterns. Analysis of the Gierer-Meinhardt model revealed that a change in a single parameter can explain two effects of FGF on limb mesenchyme cells—reinforcement of lateral inhibition and earlier appearance of pattern. These qualitative properties and easy detectability make this feature a promising tool to elucidate the underlying mechanisms of biological pattern formationwhere the quantitative parameters are difficult to obtain.     

Chondrogenesis in mouse limb buds in vitro: Effects of dibutyryl cyclic AMP treatment

We studied the effects of dibutyryl cyclic AMP (dbcAMP) on mouse limb-bud chondrogenesis at three stages of embryonic development. After 24 h of culture, limb buds with or without a covering of ectoderm were treated with 1 mM dbcAMP for 48 h and were then compared with untreated cultured limb buds. Treatment with dbcAMP enhanced cartilaginous differentiation in organ cultures of stage-17 and -19 (according to Theiler's) limb buds, although the presence of ectoderm reduced the level of dbcAMP stimulation. By stage 20, treatment with dbcAMP irreversibly inhibited cartilaginous differentiation. These results suggest that the responsiveness of mesenchymal limb-bud cells to dbcAMP is stage related. The results of histological studies as well as of analyses of DNA content and sulphated glycosaminoglycan accumulation supported the hypothesis that dbcAMP treatment induces recruitment of initially non-chondrogenic cells whose commitment explains the enhancement of cartilaginous differentiation. Limb-bud competence for chondrogenesis throughout the three developmental stages studied is also discussed.     

Chondrogenesis and cell proliferation in limb bud cell cultures treated with cytosine arabinoside and vitamin A

Mesenchyme cells derived from limb buds of day 10 mouse embryos were plated out at confluent and sub-confluent cell densities. Cells in confluent cultures multiplied and differentiated into chondrocytes. The addition of vitamin A to the culture medium inhibited both cell proliferation and chondrogenesis. However, cytosine arabinoside, which also inhibited growth, did not block chondrogenesis. This indicates that the inhibition of growth in the vitamin A-treated cultures did not necessarily contribute to the inhibition of chondrogenesis. Cells in sub-confluent cultures multiplied but did not differentiate into chondrocytes. In contrast to confluent cultures, vitamin A did not inhibit growth in sub-confluent cultures. This observation suggests that vitamin A may inhibit growth by causing contact inhibition.     

The effect of growth rate on differentiation of chick embryo limb bud mesenchyme in organ culture

Small explants of limb bud mesenchyme of day chick embryos which form muscle in organ culture synthesize proportionally less protein than DNA than do large explants which form cartilage. Chondrogenesis occurred in the central area of greatest population density in reaggregating limb bud cells, myotubes in areas of lesser density and fibroblasts in the sparsely populated periphery. Small explants grown in microdrops in plastic dishes undergo less cell division and form cartilage, but not muscle. Small explants on lens paper undergo more cell division and form muscle, but not cartilage.     

Retinoic acid respecifies limb bud cells in vitro.

Retinoic acid (RA) is known to have dramatic effects on limb pattern formation and has been shown to exert its effects on limbs by converting anterior limb bud cells into cells with posterior positional properties. In this study we find that dissociated posterior limb bud cells from chick and mouse embryos cultured at high density (micromass cultures) are able to stimulate the formation of supernumerary digits when grafted into developing wing buds and that the positional identity of both chick and mouse limb bud cells can be maintained for finite periods of time in vitro. Furthermore, using this assay system we have tested whether anterior cells from mouse and chick limb buds can be converted into cells with posterior identity by exposure to RA in vitro. We find that anterior limb bud cells acquire posterior properties after culture in the presence of RA.     

Effects of ethanol and hydrogen peroxide on mouse limb bud mesenchyme differentiation and cell death

Many of the morphological defects associated with embryonic alcohol exposure are a result of cell death. During limb development, ethanol administration produces cell death in the limb and digital defects, including postaxial ectrodactyly. Because an accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) is produced in adult and embryonic tissues by ethanol exposure, this investigation examines the possibility that ethanol-induced cell death in the limb is a result of ROS. Using an in vitro primary culture of limb mesenchyme, the effects of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) and ethanol on cell death and differentiation were examined. In addition, a dichlorofluorescein diacetate assay was performed to determine the relative intracellular ROS levels after exposure to several concentrations of ethanol and H2O2. Exposure of 1 to 100 microM H2O2 resulted in a 1.08-1.21 times control increase in cartilage matrix accumulation. Cell death was increased 1.69-2.76 times the untreated control value. Production of ROS ranged from 1.25-1.51 times untreated controls. Ethanol exposure of 0.25 to 1.00% (v/v) did not affect cartilage matrix accumulation but resulted in an increase of cell death (1.45-2.31 times untreated control). Intracellular ROS levels after ethanol exposure increased 1.08-1.15 times control but were lower than that produced by 1 microM H2O2. On the basis of the correlation between ROS level produced by H2O2, it was concluded that ethanol-induced cell death in limb mesenchyme is a result of a non-ROS-mediated mechanism. Therefore, in addition to ethanol-induced cell death mediated by ROS reported in the literature, ethanol-induced cell death can be induced in limb mesenchyme by mechanisms that are not dependent upon ROS.     

Position-specific growth of mouse limb bud cells in vitro.

The relationship between cellular position and growth control has been studied in cultures of dissociated fragments of mouse limb bud cells. Using cells derived from various positions along the anterior-posterior axis of the limb bud we have developed culture conditions that optimize growth of positionally isolated cells. Under these conditions limb bud cells display an inherent, position-specific growth response; proliferation of cells derived from anterior and central regions of the limb is enhanced over that of posterior derived cells. Thus, within the total population of limb bud cells the in vitro growth of posterior cells is unique and correlates with the positional activity associated with the zone of polarizing activity. Anterior and posterior cells were cocultured to determine whether interactions between these two groups of positionally distinct cells lead to the stimulation of growth that has been observed in vivo. We observe a slight but consistent position-dependent stimulation of growth that is indicative of a mitogenic signal passing between these positionally disparate cells. Similarities between position-related growth dynamics in vivo and in vitro suggest that positional interactions that are important for limb formation can occur between dissociated cells cultured under standard conditions.