Sensitivity to gravistimulus of lentil seedling roots grown in space during the IML 1 Mission of Spacelab

The gravitropic curvature of seedlings of lentil ( Lens culinaris L. cv. Verte du Puy) grown in microgravity and stimulated on the 1 g centrifuge for 5 to 60 min was followed by time lapse photography in near weightlessness in the frame of the IML 1 Mission of Spacelab. In microgravity, the root tip could overshoot the direction of the 1 g acceleration after bending, whereas roots stimulated on the ground did not reach the direction of the gravity vector. On earth, there is, therefore, a regulation (inhibition of root curvature), which is gravity dependent. In space, the initial rate of curvature as well as the amplitude of curvature varied as a function of the quantity of stimulation (Q, in g min). For a given quantity of stimulation, the rate of curvature remained constant for 80 min. The bending has thus a certain inertia, which is linked to the mechanism of differential growth. The presentation time (Tp) of the lentil root was calculated by extrapolation to zero curvature of the regression line representing either the initial rate of curvature or the amplitude of curvature at 2 h after the end of the stimulation. Tp was estimated to 27 and 26 s. respectively. These results confirm the values of Tp obtained by clinostats, and they also lead to a reconsideration of the causes of the kinetics of root curvature.     

Random root movements in weightlessness

The dynamics of root growth was studied in weightlessness. In the absence of the gravitropic reference direction during weightlessness, root movements could be controlled by spontaneous growth processes, without any corrective growth induced by the gravitropic system. If truly random of nature, the bending behavior should follow socalled 'random walk' mathematics during weightlessness. Predictions from this hypothesis were critically tested.
In a Spacelab ESA-experiment, denoted RANDOM and carried out during the IML-2 Shuttle flight in July 1994, the growth of garden cress ( Lepidium sativum ) roots was followed by time lapse photography at 1-h intervals.
The growth pattern was recorded for about 20 h. Root growth was significantly smaller in weightlessness as compared to gravity (control) conditions.
It was found that the roots performed spontaneous movements in weightlessness. The average direction of deviation of the plants consistently stayed equal to zero, despite these spontaneous movements. The average squared deviation increased linearly with time as predicted theoretically (but only for 8–10 h).
Autocorrelation calculations showed that bendings of the roots, as determined from the 1-h photographs, were uncorrelated after about a 2-h interval.
It is concluded that random processes play an important role in root growth. Predictions from a random walk hypothesis as to the growth dynamics could explain parts of the growth patterns recorded. This test of the hypothesis required microgravity conditions as provided for in a space experiment.     

Gravitropic responses of the Avena coleoptile in space and on clinostats. II. Is reciprocity valid?

Experiments were undertaken to determine if the reciprocity rule is valid for gravitropic responses of oat coleoptiles in the acceleration region below 1 g. The rule predicts that the gravitropic response should be proportional to the product of the applied acceleration and the stimulation time.
Seedlings were cultivated on 1 g centrifuges and transferred to test centrifuges to apply a transverse g-stimulation. Since responses occurred in microgravity, the uncertainties about the validity of clinostat simulation of weightlessness was avoided Plants at two stages of coleoptile development were tested. Plant responses were obtained using time-lapse video recordings that were analyzed after the flight. Stimulus intensities and durations were varied and ranged from 0.1 to 1.0 g and from 2 to 130 min, respectively. For threshold g-doses the reciprocity rule was obeyed. The threshold dose was of the order of 55 g s and 120 g s, respectively, for two groups of plants investigated. Reciprocity was studied also at bending responses which are from just above the detectable level to about 10 degrees. The validity of the rule could not be confirmed for higher g-doses, chiefly because the data were more variable.
It was investigated whether the uniformity of the overall response data increased when the gravitropic dose was defined as (g^m× 1), with m-values different from unity. This was not the case and the reciprocity concept is, therefore, valid also in the hypogravity region. The concept of gravitropic dose, the product of the transverse acceleration and the stimulation time, is also well-defined in the acceleration region studied. With the same hardware, tests were done on earth where responses occurred on clinostats. The results did not contradict the reciprocity rule but scatter in the data was large.     

Gravisensitivity and automorphogenesis of lentil seedling roots grown on board the International Space Station

The GRAVI-1 experiment was brought on board the International Space Station by Discovery (December 2006) and carried out in January 2007 in the European Modular Cultivation System facility. For the first run of this experiment, lentil seedlings were hydrated and grown in microgravity for 15 h and then subjected for 13 h 40 min to centrifugal accelerations ranging from 0.29 x 10(-2) g to 0.99 x 10(-2) g. During the second run, seedlings were grown either for 30 h 30 min in microgravity (this sample was the control) or for 21 h 30 min and then subjected to centrifugal accelerations ranging from 1.2 x 10(-2) g to 2.0 x 10(-2) g for 9 h. In both cases, root orientation and root curvature were followed by time-lapse photography. Still images were downlinked in near real time to ground Norwegian User Support and Operations Center during the experiment. The position of the root tip and the root curvature were analyzed as a function of time. It has been shown that in microgravity, the embryonic root curved strongly away from the cotyledons (automorphogenesis) and then straightened out slowly from 17 to 30 h following hydration (autotropism). Because of the autotropic straightening of roots in microgravity, their tip was oriented at an angle close to the optimal angle of curvature (120 degrees -135 degrees ) for a period of 2 h during centrifugation. Moreover, it has been demonstrated that lentil roots grown in microgravity before stimulation were more sensitive than roots grown in 1 g. In these conditions, the threshold acceleration perceived by these organs was found to be between 0 and 2.0 x 10(-3) g and estimated punctually at 1.4 x 10(-5) g by using the hyperbolic model for fitting the experimental data and by assuming that autotropism had no or little impact on the gravitropic response. Gravisensing by statoliths should be possible at such a low level of acceleration because the actomyosin system could provide the necessary work to overcome the activation energy for gravisensing.     

Gravitropic responses of the Avena coleoptile in space and on clinostats. I. Gravitropic response thresholds

We conducted a series of gravitropic experiments on Avena coleoptiles in the weightlessness environment of Spacelab. The purpose was to test the threshold stimulus, reciprocity rule and autotropic reactions to a range of g-force stimulations of different intensities and durations The tests avoided the potentially complicating effects of earth's gravity and the interference from clinostat ambiguities. Using slow-speed centrifuges, coleoptiles received transversal accelerations in the hypogravity range between 0.1 and 1.0 g over periods that ranged from 2 to 130 min. All responses that occurred in weightlessness were compared to clinostal experiments on earth using the same apparatus.
Characteristic gravitropistic response patterns of Avena were not substantially different from those observed in ground-based experiments. Gravitropic presentation times were extrapolated. The threshold at 1.0 g was less than 1 min (shortest stimulation time 2 min), in agreement with values obtained on the ground. The least stimulus tested, 0.1 g for 130 min, produced a significant response. Therefore the absolute threshold for a gravitropic response is less than 0.1 g.     

The Role of Starch in the Gravitropic Response of the Lentil Root

It is well accepted that the amyloplasts of the cap are responsible for gravisensing in primary roots. However, roots with starch-depleted plastids are able to respond to gravistimulus, but their curvature is slower than that of roots containing amyloplasts. The goal of our experiment was to analyse the effects of natural variations of statolith starch in the gravitropic response of lentil roots to a stimulation in the horizontal position. In lentil seedlings grown in the vertical position for 26 h, the volume of the amyloplasts in the statocytes differed between individual roots. The amount of starch in the cap was determined parallel to the rate of gravitropic curvature. There was no statistical correlation between the intensity of the gravitropic response and the starch content in the statocytes. Lentil roots were treated with gibberellic acid (GA₃) at 32°C in order to reduce the volume of starch in the statoliths. There was 53% less starch in the cap of GA₃treated roots as compared to the cap of control roots. But there was no relationship between starch content in the cap and the responsiveness of the root to a gravistimulus, except when the amount of starch was small.     

Involvement of brassinosteroids in the gravitropic response of primary root of maize

Exogenously applied brassinolide (BL, 10(-9)-10(-5) M) increased gravitropic curvature in maize (Zea mays) primary roots. The BL-enhanced gravitropic curvature was clearly promoted in the presence of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA, 10(-10)-10(-8) M), indicating that BL is interactive with IAA during the gravitropic response. The interactive effect between BL and IAA was completely diminished by treatment of p-chlorophenoxy isobutric acid, an auxin action antagonist. The activation of the gravitropic response by BL in the absence and in the presence of IAA was nullified by application of 2, 3,5-triiodobenzoic acid, a polar auxin transport inhibitor. The data indicate that brassinosteroids (BRs) might be involved in auxin-mediated processes for the gravitropic response. Gas chromotography-selected ion-monitoring analysis revealed that maize primary roots contained approximately 0.3 ng g(-1) fresh weight castasterone as an endogenous BR. Exogenously applied castasterone also increased the gravitropic response of maize roots in an IAA-dependent manner. This study provides the first evidence, to our knowledge, for occurrence and gravitropic activity of BRs in plant roots.     

Wavelet and Fourier analysis of ventricular and main arteries pulsations in anesthetized dogs

The purpose of this study was to characterize time-frequency behavior using the Continuous Wavelet Transform (CWT) and Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) to analyze ventricular and arterial pressure signals from anesthetized mongrel dogs. Both ventricular and arterial pressure pulsations were recorded using catheter-tip manometers and the CWT was applied to these signals to obtain module coefficients, associated contours, and the 3-D representation of these modules. FFT was applied to obtain the Fourier spectrum. The mathematical analysis of the cardiovascular pressure pulsations permitted the identification of the evolution of the frequency components for the aortic and pulmonary valve functions as well as the intra-ventricular and respiratory influences on the cardiovascular dynamics. The CWT is a very sensitive and reliable procedure for determining the three-dimensional (time-frequency-amplitude) of the oscillatory phenomena during each cardiac cycle, providing more, although complementary, information than the spectral analysis obtained with the FFT. Thanks to the FFT, exact values in Hz could be found for the different events produced in each cycle, and thus the information provided by CWT could be related to the information provided by FFT. The combination of both mathematical methodologies permitted identification of each component of the analyzed signals. The 3D representation allowed an easy comparison of the relative importance of the complex magnitudes in frequency for the different components of the pulsatile waves.     

The response to auxin of rapeseed (Brassica napus L.) roots displaying reduced gravitropism due to transformation by Agrobacterium rhizogenes

It has recently been documented that, compared to untransformed controls, the roots of oilseed rape (Brassica napus L. CV CrGC5) seedlings transformed by Agrobacterium rhizogenes A4 show a reduced gravitropic reaction (Legué et al. 1994, Physiol Plant 91: 559–566). After stimulation at 90°C or 135°, the transformed root tips curve, but never reach a vertical orientation. In the present study, we investigated the causes of reduced gravitropic bending observed in stimulated transformed root tips. First, we localized the gravitropic curvature in normal and in transformed roots after 1.5 h of stimulation. The cells involved in root curvature (target cells) corresponded at the cellular level to the apical part of the zone of increasing cell length. In transformed roots grown in the vertical position, these cells showed a reduction in cell length compared to controls. Because auxin is considered to be the gravitropic mediator, the response of normal and transformed roots to exogenous auxin was studied. Indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) was applied along the first 3 mm using resin beads loaded with the hormone. In comparison to normal roots, transformed roots showed reduced bending toward the bead at all points of bead application. Moreover, the cells which responded to IAA corresponded to the target cells involved in the gravitropic reaction. The level of endogenous IAA was lower in transformed roots. Thus, it was concluded that the modified behavior of transformed roots during gravitropic stimulation could be due to differences either in IAA levels or in reactivity of the target cells to the message from the cap.Abbreviations DEZ distal elongation zone - ELISA enzymelinked immunosorbent assay - T-DNA DNA transferred from Agrobacterium rhizogenes to the plant genome This work was supported by the Centre National d'Etudes Spatiales.     

A major factor in gravitropism in radish hypocotyls is the suppression of growth on the upper side of hypocotyls

The changes in length on the two opposite sides of etiolated radish (Raphanus sativus) hypocotyls prior to, and following gravitropic stimulation, were measured using an infrared-imaging system. It was observed that the growth suppression on the upper side began first at least 10 min after the onset of gravitropic stimulation, and after 30 min the acceleration in growth on the lower side started. The gravitropic curvature was steadily induced from 10 min. When radish hypocotyls were switched from a vertical to horizontal position for different durations and then replaced to the vertical position, the growth suppression on the gravity-stimulated (upper) side was observed in all cases, but the acceleration in growth on the opposite (lower) side appeared only in continuously gravity-stimulated seedlings, although it occurred later than the growth suppression on the upper side. These results suggest that the suppression in growth on the upper side of the hypocotyls is a direct effect of gravitropic stimulation, but not the acceleration on the lower side. When 4-methylthio-3-butenyl isothiocyanate (4-MTBI), which has an inhibitory activity against radish hypocotyl growth, was applied on the one side of radish hypocotyls and then the 4-MTBI-applied side or opposite side was placed in a horizontal position, the former showed greater bending than the control, suggesting that the growth suppression on the upper side is enhanced and maintained with MTBI application there. In the latter case, the seedlings showed less bending than the control, suggesting a decrease in growth on the lower side with MTBI application. All the results suggest that gravitropism of radish hypocotyls may be caused by an increase in growth-inhibiting substance(s) induced with gravitropic stimulation in the upper side, inducing growth inhibition there.     

Gravitropic responses of the Avena coleoptile in space and on clinostats. IV. The clinostat as a substitute for space experiments

Gravitropic responses of dark grown oat coleoptiles were measured in weightlessness and under clinorotation on earth. The tests in microgravity were conducted in Spacelab during the IML-1 mission and those on clinostats were conducted in laboratories on earth. The same apparatus was used for both kinds of tests. In both cases autotropism and gravitropic responsiveness were determined. This allowed a quantitative comparison between the plants' responses after receiving the same tropistic stimulations either in weightlessness or on clinostats.
Autotropism was observed with oat coleoptiles responding in weightlessness but it did not occur on clinostats. Gravitropic responsiveness was measured as the ratio between the incremental bending response (degrees curvature) and the corresponding incremental g-dose (stimulus intensity times duration for which it was applied). Plants were tested at either of two stages of coleoptile development (i.e. different coleoptile lengths). From a total of six different kinds of critical comparisons that could be made from our tests that provided data for clinorotated vs weightless plants, three showed no significant difference between responses in simulated vs authentic weightlessness. Three other comparisons showed highly significant differences. Therefore, the validity of clinorotation as a general substitute for space flight was not supported by these results.     

Circumnutational movement in rice coleoptiles involves the gravitropic response: analysis of an agravitropic mutant and space‐grown seedlings

Plants exhibit helical growth movements known as circumnutation in growing organs. Some studies indicate that circumnutation involves the gravitropic response, but this notion is a matter of debate. Here, using the agravitropic rice mutant lazy1 and space‐grown rice seedlings, we found that circumnutation was reduced or lost during agravitropic growth in coleoptiles. Coleoptiles of wild‐type rice exhibited circumnutation in the dark, with vigorous oscillatory movements during their growth. The gravitropic responses in lazy1 coleoptiles differed depending on the growth stage, with gravitropic responses detected during early growth and agravitropism during later growth. The nutation‐like movements observed in lazy1 coleoptiles at the early stage of growth were no longer detected with the disappearance of the gravitropic response. To verify the relationship between circumnutation and gravitropic responses in rice coleoptiles, we conducted spaceflight experiments in plants under microgravity conditions on the International Space Station. Wild‐type rice seeds were germinated, and the resulting seedlings were grown under microgravity or a centrifuge‐generated 1 g environment in space. We began filming the seedlings 2 days after seed imbibition and obtained images of seedling growth every 15 min. The seed germination rate in space was 92–100% under both microgravity and 1 g conditions. LED‐synchronized flashlight photography induced an attenuation of coleoptile growth and circumnutational movement due to cumulative light exposure. Nevertheless, wild‐type rice coleoptiles still showed circumnutational oscillations under 1 g but not microgravity conditions. These results support the idea that the gravitropic response is involved in plant circumnutation.     

Gravitropically-stimulated seedlings show autotropism in weightlessness

In a spaceflight experiment, autotropism by oat ( Avena sativa L.) coleoptiles following gravitropic responses was prominent in weightlessness: counter-reactions led to the straightening of the curved coleoptiles. This was not the case during clinorotation on earth. The autotropic reactions appeared to be related to the stimulus received during the stimulus period, i.e. the greater the response the greater the autotropic counter-reaction. Previous models of the gravitropic system which predicted that coleoptiles would not straighten in weightlessness are disproved. A modification to one of the models is proposed which includes the autotropic response observed in spaceflight. The nature of the counter-reactions in the absence of gravitropic stimulation is discussed.     

Growth and gravitropism of corn roots in solution

Growth and early gravitropic responses of corn roots in solution have been studied using time-lapse photography. Aeration was required for both root growth and gravitropism. The optimum pH for gravitropism was in the range 5 to 6. The bending response seemed to be greater for roots in non-buffered solution than in buffered solution. Fastest growth and maximum curvature occurred with about 0.2 mol m⁻³ Ca²⁺. Under some conditions, the gravitropic response started with apparently negligible time delay after the start of the gravitropic stimulus. This may denote graviperception in or near the elongation zone itself. This mechanism for early but relatively weak gravitropism may help to explain a variety of gravitropic responses such as the ‘early wrong way’ curvature, and the behaviour of roots whose columella cells lack amyloplasts. More rapid bending appears to start at about 20 min, which is consistent with observations on roots in humid air and with the accepted statolith model of perception in the root cap.     

Brassinolide interacts with auxin and ethylene in the root gravitropic response of maize (Zea mays)

This study examines how brassinolide (BL) and ethylene interact in the gravitropic response mechanism of maize ( Zea mays ) primary roots. When applied exogenously, ethylene increases the rate of gravitropic curvature in a dose-dependent manner. This effect of ethylene was confirmed by the fact that AVG, a specific action inhibitor of ACC synthase, reduces the gravitropic curvature in the presence and absence of BL. Since AVG did not inhibit BL-increased gravitropic curvature completely, we investigated the possibility that BL may act on the gravitropic response by ways other than simply through enhanced ethylene production. We show that BL exhibits some of its stimulatory effect in the absence of ethylene. In addition, BL reduces the presentation time and lag period for the gravitropic response, whereas ethylene increases them. One possible mechanism of such action is that BL affects protein kinase activity, since the protein kinase inhibitors, staurosporine and H89, reduce BL-increased gravitropic curvature. In summary, BL is involved in the gravitropic response in maize primary roots via ethylene production, but it acts in a way that differs somewhat from that of ethylene.     

Root movements: Towards an understanding through attempts to model the processes involved

Roots have the ability to change the direction of their forward growth. Sometimes these directional changes are rapid, as in mutations, or they are slower, as in tropisms. The gravitational force is always present and roots have an efficient graviperception mechanism which enables them to initiate gravitropic movements. In trying to model and simulate the course of gravitropic root movements with a view to analyse the component processes, the following aspects of the plant's interaction with gravity have been considered: (1) The level of organization (organism, organ, cell) at which the movement process is expressed; (2) whether the gravity stimulation event is dynamic or static (i.e. whether or not physiologically significant displacements take place with respect to the gravity vector); (3) the sub-systems involved in movement and the processes which they regulate; (4) the mathematical characterization of the relevant sub-systems. A further allied topic is the nature of nutational movements and whether they are linked with gravitropic movements in some way. In considering how they can best be modelled, two types of nutational movements are proponed: stochastic nutation and circumnutation. Most, if not all, natural movements developed in response to static gravistimulation can be viewed as gravimorphisms. This applies at the levels of cell, organ and organism. However, when a system at any one of these levels experiences dynamic gravistimulation, because of its inherent homeostatic properties, it is induced to regenerate a state similar to that previously held. Thus, gravitropism is a regenerative gravimorphic process at the level of the organ.     

Mechanotransduction in root gravity sensing cells

The analysis of the dose-response curve of the gravitropic reaction of lentil seedling roots has shown that these organs are more sensitive when they have been grown in microgravity than when they have been grown on a 1 g centrifuge in space before gravistimulation. This difference of gravisensitivity is not due to the volume or the density of starch grains of statoliths, which are about the same in both conditions (1 g or microgravity). However, the distribution of statoliths within the statocyte may be responsible for this differential sensitivity, since the dispersion of these organelles is greater in microgravity than in 1 g. When lentil roots grown in microgravity or in 1 g are stimulated at 0.93 g for 22 min, the amyloplasts sediment following two different trajectories. They move from the proximal half of the statocytes toward the lower longitudinal wall in the microgravity grown sample and from the distal half toward the longitudinal wall in the 1 g grown sample. At the end of the stimulation, they reach a similar position within the statocytes. If the roots of both samples are left in microgravity for 3 h, the amyloplasts move toward the cell centre in a direction that makes an average angle of 40 degrees with respect to the lower longitudinal wall. The actin filaments, which are responsible for this movement, may have an overall orientation of 40 degrees with respect to this wall. Thus, when roots grown in microgravity are stimulated on the minicentrifuge the amyloplasts slide on the actin filaments, whereas they move perpendicular to them in 1 g grown roots. Our results suggest that greater sensitivity of seedling roots grown in microgravity should be due to greater dispersion of statoliths, to better contacts between statoliths and the actin network and to greater number of activated mechanoreceptors. One can hypothesize that stretch activated ion channels (SACs) located in the plasma membrane are responsible for the transduction of gravistimulus. These SACs may be connected together by elements of the cytoskeleton lining the plasma membrane and to the actin filaments. They could be stimulated by the action of statoliths on the actin network and/or on these elements of the cytoskeleton which link the mechanoreceptors (SACs).     

Anomalous gravitropic response of Chara rhizoids during enhanced accelerations

Centrifugal accelerations of 50-250 g were applied to rhizoids of Chara globularis Thuill. at stimulation angles (alpha) of 5-90 degrees between the acceleration vector and the rhizoid axis. After the start of centrifugation, the statoliths were pressed asymmetrically onto the centrifugal flank of the apical cell wall. In contrast to the well-known bending (by bowing) under 1 g, the rhizoids responded in two distinct phases. Following an initial phase of sharp bending (by bulging), which is similar to the negatively gravitropic response of Chara protonemata, rhizoids stopped bending and, in the second phase, grew straight in directions clearly deviating from the direction of acceleration. These response angles (beta) between the axis of the bent part of the rhizoid and the acceleration vector were strictly correlated with the g-level of acceleration. The higher the acceleration the greater was beta. Except for the sharp bending, the shape and growth rate of the centrifuged rhizoids were not different from those of gravistimulated control rhizoids at 1 g. These results indicate that gravitropic bending of rhizoids during enhanced accelerations (5 degrees < or = alpha < or = 90 degrees) is caused not only by subapical differential flank growth, as it is the case at 1 g, but also by also by the centripetal displacement of the growth centre as was recently discussed for the negative gravitropism of Chara protonemata. A hypothesis for cytoskeletally mediated polar growth is presented based on data from positive gravitropic bending of Chara rhizoids at 1 g and from the anomalous gravitropic bending of rhizoids compared with the negatively gravitropic bending of Chara protonemata. The data obtained are also relevant to a general understanding of graviperception in higher-plant organs.     

A polarized cell: the root statocyte

In the gravity-perceiving cells (statocytes), located in the centre of the root cap, polarity is expressed in the arrangement of the organelles since, in most genera, the nucleus and the endoplasmic reticulum are maintained at the opposite ends of each cell by actin. Polarity is also evident in the distribution of plasmodesmata, which are more numerous in the transverse walls than in the longitudinal walls. The centre of each statocyte is depleted of microtubules (they are only located at the periphery) but is occupied by numerous amyloplasts (statoliths), denser than the cytoplasm. The amyloplasts do not contribute to the inherent structural polarity since their position is dependent upon the gravity vector. This article focuses on new microscopic analyses and on data obtained from experiments performed in microgravity, which have contributed to our better understanding of the architecture of the actin web implicated in the perception of gravity. Depending upon the plant, the actin network seems to be formed of single filaments arranged in various ways, or, of thin bundles of actin filaments. The amyloplasts are enmeshed in this web of actin and their envelopes are associated with it, but they can have autonomous movement via myosin in the absence of gravity. From calculations of the value of the force necessary to move one amyloplast in the lentil root, and from videomicroscopy performed with living statocytes of maize roots, it is hypothesized that actin microfilaments could be orientated in an overall diagonal direction in the statocyte. These observations could help in understanding how slight amyloplast movements may trigger and transmit the gravitropic signal.