Dilution-induced disassembly of microtubules: relation to dynamic instability and the GTP cap

Microtubules were assembled from purified tubulin in the buffer originally used to study dynamic instability (100 mM PIPES, 2 mM EGTA, 1 mM magnesium, 0.2 mM GTP) and then diluted in the same buffer to study the rate of disassembly. Following a 15-fold dilution, microtubule polymer decreased linearly to about 20% of the starting value in 15 sec. We determined the length distribution of microtubules before dilution, and prepared computer simulations of polymer loss for different assumed rates of disassembly. Our experimental data were consistent with a disassembly rate per microtubule of 60 microns/min. This is the total rate of depolymerization for microtubules in the rapid shortening phase, as determined by light microscopy of individual microtubules (Walker et al.: Journal of Cell Biology 107:1437-1448, 1988). We conclude, therefore, that microtubules began rapid shortening at both ends upon dilution. Moreover, since we could detect no lag between dilution and the onset of rapid disassembly, the transition from elongation to rapid shortening apparently occurred within 1 sec following dilution. Assuming that this transition (catastrophe) involves the loss of the GTP cap, and that cap loss is achieved by the sequential dissociation of GTP-tubulin subunits following dilution, we can estimate the maximum size of the cap based on the kinetic data and model interpretation of Walker et al. The cap is probably shorter than 40 and 20 subunits at the plus and minus ends, respectively.     

Asymmetric behavior of severed microtubule ends after ultraviolet- microbeam irradiation of individual microtubules in vitro

The molecular basis of microtubule dynamic instability is controversial, but is thought to be related to a "GTP cap." A key prediction of the GTP cap model is that the proposed labile GDP-tubulin core will rapidly dissociate if the GTP-tubulin cap is lost. We have tested this prediction by using a UV microbeam to cut the ends from elongating microtubules. Phosphocellulose-purified tubulin was assembled onto the plus and minus ends of sea urchin flagellar axoneme fragments at 21-22 degrees C. The assembly dynamics of individual microtubules were recorded in real time using video microscopy. When the tip of an elongating plus end microtubule was cut off, the severed plus end microtubule always rapidly shortened back to the axoneme at the normal plus end rate. However, when the distal tip of an elongating minus end microtubule was cut off, no rapid shortening occurred. Instead, the severed minus end resumed elongation at the normal minus end rate. Our results show that some form of "stabilizing cap," possibly a GTP cap, governs the transition (catastrophe) from elongation to rapid shortening at the plus end. At the minus end, a simple GTP cap is not sufficient to explain the observed behavior unless UV induces immediate recapping of minus, but not plus, ends. Another possibility is that a second step, perhaps a structural transformation, is required in addition to GTP cap loss for rapid shortening to occur. This transformation would be favored at plus, but not minus ends, to account for the asymmetric behavior of the ends.     

Mechanism of the microtubule GTPase reaction

The rate of GTP hydrolysis by microtubules has been measured at tubulin subunit concentrations where microtubules undergo net disassembly. This was made possible by using microtubules stabilized against disassembly by reaction with ethylene glycol bis-(succinimidylsuccinate) (EGS) as sites for the addition of tubulin-GTP subunits. The tubulin subunit concentration was varied from 25 to 90% of the steady state concentration, and there was no net elongation of stabilized microtubule seeds. The GTPase rate with EGS microtubules was linearly proportional to the tubulin-GTP subunit concentration when this concentration was varied by dilution and by using GDP to compete with GTP for the tubulin E-site. The linear dependence of the rate is consistent with a GTP mechanism in which hydrolysis is coupled to the tubulin-GTP subunit addition to microtubule ends. It is inconsistent with reaction schemes in which: microtubules are capped by a single tubulin-GTP subunit, which hydrolyzes GTP when a tubulin-GTP subunit adds to the end; hydrolysis occurs primarily in subunits at the interface of a tubulin-GTP cap and the tubulin-GDP microtubule core; hydrolysis is not coupled to subunit addition and occurs randomly in subunits in a tubulin-GTP cap. It was also found that GDP inhibition of the microtubule GTPase rate results from GDP competition for GTP at the tubulin subunit E-site. There is no additional effect of GDP on the GTPase rate resulting from exchange into tubulin subunits at microtubule ends.     

Effects of magnesium on the dynamic instability of individual microtubules

We investigated the effect of magnesium ion (Mg) on the parameters of dynamic instability of individual porcine brain microtubules. Rates of elongation and rapid shortening were measured by using video-enhanced DIC light microscopy and evaluated by using computer-generated plots of microtubule length vs time. Increasing [Mg] from 0.25 to 6 mM increased the second-order association rate constant for elongation about 25% at each end. At plus ends, this resulted in a 1.5-2-fold increase in elongation rates over the tubulin concentrations explored. Rapid shortening rates were more dramatically affected by Mg. As [Mg] was increased from 0.25 to 6 mM, the average rate of rapid shortening increased about 3-fold at plus ends and 4-5-fold at minus ends. The ends had roughly equivalent average rates at low [Mg], of 30-45 microns/min. At any Mg concentration, rates of disassembly varied from one microtubule to another, and often an individual microtubule would exhibit more than one rate during a single shortening phase. Individual rates at 6 mM Mg varied from 12 to 250 microns/min. Over the concentration range explored, Mg affected the frequencies of transition from elongation to shortening and back only at minus ends. Minus ends were relatively stable at low [Mg], having 4 times the frequency of rescue than at high [Mg], and a lower frequency of catastrophe (particularly evident at low tubulin concentrations). Plus ends, surprisingly, were highly unstable at all Mg concentrations investigated, having about the same transition frequencies as did the least stable (high Mg) minus ends. Our results have implications for models of the GTP cap, again emphasizing that GTP caps cannot build up in proportion to elongation rate, and must be constrained to the tips of growing microtubules.     

Role of GTP hydrolysis in microtubule polymerization: evidence for a coupled hydrolysis mechanism

The relationship between GTP hydrolysis and microtubule assembly has been investigated by using a rapid filtration method. Microtubules assembled from phosphocellulose-purified tubulin, double-labeled with [gamma-32P]- and [3H]GTP, were trapped and washed free of unbound nucleotide on glass fiber filters. The transient accumulation of microtubule-bound GTP predicted by uncoupled GTP hydrolysis models [Carlier & Pantaloni (1981) Biochemistry 20, 1918-1924; Carlier et al. (1987) Biochemistry 26, 4428-4437] during the rapid assembly of microtubules was not detectable under our experimental conditions. By calculating hypothetical time courses for the transient accumulation of microtubule-bound GTP, we demonstrate that microtubule-bound GTP would have been detectable even if the first-order rate constant for GTP hydrolysis were 4-5 times greater than the pseudo-first-order rate constant for tubulin subunit addition to microtubules. In a similar manner, we demonstrate that if GTP hydrolysis were uncoupled from microtubule assembly but were limited to the interface between GTP subunits and GDP subunits (uncoupled vectorial hydrolysis), then microtubule-bound GTP would have been detectable if GTP hydrolysis became uncoupled from microtubule assembly at less than 50 microM free tubulin, 5 times the steady-state tubulin concentration of our experimental conditions. In addition, during rapid microtubule assembly, we have not detected any microtubule-bound Pi, which has been proposed to form a stabilizing cap at the ends of microtubules [Carlier et al. (1988) Biochemistry 27, 3555-3559]. Also, several conditions that could be expected to increase the degree of potential uncoupling between GTP hydrolysis and microtubule assembly were examined, and no evidence of uncoupling was found. Our results are consistent with models that propose cooperative mechanisms that limit GTP hydrolysis to the terminal ring of tubulin subunits [e.g., O'Brien et al. (1987) Biochemistry 26, 4148-4156]. The results are also consistent with the hypothesis that a slow conformational change in tubulin subunits after GTP hydrolysis and Pi release occurs that results in destabilized microtubule ends when such subunits become exposed at the ends.     

Dynamic instability of individual microtubules analyzed by video light microscopy: rate constants and transition frequencies

We have developed video microscopy methods to visualize the assembly and disassembly of individual microtubules at 33-ms intervals. Porcine brain tubulin, free of microtubule-associated proteins, was assembled onto axoneme fragments at 37 degrees C, and the dynamic behavior of the plus and minus ends of microtubules was analyzed for tubulin concentrations between 7 and 15.5 microM. Elongation and rapid shortening were distinctly different phases. At each end, the elongation phase was characterized by a second order association and a substantial first order dissociation reaction. Association rate constants were 8.9 and 4.3 microM-1 s-1 for the plus and minus ends, respectively; and the corresponding dissociation rate constants were 44 and 23 s-1. For both ends, the rate of tubulin dissociation equaled the rate of tubulin association at 5 microM. The rate of rapid shortening was similar at the two ends (plus = 733 s-1; minus = 915 s-1), and did not vary with tubulin concentration. Transitions between phases were abrupt and stochastic. As the tubulin concentration was increased, catastrophe frequency decreased at both ends, and rescue frequency increased dramatically at the minus end. This resulted in fewer rapid shortening phases at higher tubulin concentrations for both ends and shorter rapid shortening phases at the minus end. At each concentration, the frequency of catastrophe was slightly greater at the plus end, and the frequency of rescue was greater at the minus end. Our data demonstrate that microtubules assembled from pure tubulin undergo dynamic instability over a twofold range of tubulin concentrations, and that the dynamic instability of the plus and minus ends of microtubules can be significantly different. Our analysis indicates that this difference could produce treadmilling, and establishes general limits on the effectiveness of length redistribution as a measure of dynamic instability. Our results are consistent with the existence of a GTP cap during elongation, but are not consistent with existing GTP cap models.     

A Metastable Intermediate State of Microtubule Dynamic Instability That Differs Significantly between Plus and Minus Ends

The current two-state GTP cap model of microtubule dynamic instability proposes that a terminal crown of GTP-tubulin stabilizes the microtubule lattice and promotes elongation while loss of this GTP-tubulin cap converts the microtubule end to shortening. However, when this model was directly tested by using a UV microbeam to sever axoneme-nucleated microtubules and thereby remove the microtubule's GTP cap, severed plus ends rapidly shortened, but severed minus ends immediately resumed elongation (Walker, R.A., S. Inoué, and E.D. Salmon. 1989. J. Cell Biol. 108: 931–937).

To determine if these previous results were dependent on the use of axonemes as seeds or were due to UV damage, or if they instead indicate an intermediate state in cap dynamics, we performed UV cutting of self-assembled microtubules and mechanical cutting of axoneme-nucleated microtubules. These independent methods yielded results consistent with the original work: a significant percentage of severed minus ends are stable after cutting. In additional experiments, we found that the stability of both severed plus and minus ends could be increased by increasing the free tubulin concentration, the solution GTP concentration, or by assembling microtubules with guanylyl-(α,β)-methylene-diphosphonate (GMPCPP).

Our results show that stability of severed ends, particularly minus ends, is not an artifact, but instead reveals the existence of a metastable kinetic intermediate state between the elongation and shortening states of dynamic instability. The kinetic properties of this intermediate state differ between plus and minus ends. We propose a three-state conformational cap model of dynamic instability, which has three structural states and four transition rate constants, and which uses the asymmetry of the tubulin heterodimer to explain many of the differences in dynamic instability at plus and minus ends.

     

The minimum GTP cap required to stabilize microtubules

Background: Microtubules polymerized from pure tubulin show the unusual property of dynamic instability, in which both growing and shrinking polymers coexist at steady state. Shortly after its addition to a microtubule end, a tubulin subunit hydrolyzes its bound GTP. Studies with non-hydrolyzable analogs have shown that GTP hydrolysis is not required for microtubule assembly, but is essential for generating a dynamic polymer, in which the subunits at the growing tip have bound GTP and those in the bulk of the polymer have bound GDP. It has been suggested that loss of the ‘GTP cap’ through dissociation or hydrolysis exposes the unstable GDP core, leading to rapid depolymerization. However, evidence for a stabilizing cap has been very difficult to obtain.Results We developed an assay to determine the minimum GTP cap necessary to stabilize a microtubule from shrinking. Assembly of a small number of subunits containing a slowly hydrolyzed GTP analog (GMPCPP) onto the end of dynamic microtubules stabilized the polymer to dilution. By labeling the subunits with rhodamine, we measured the size of the cap and found that as few as 40 subunits were sufficient to stabilize a microtubule.Conclusion On the basis of statistical arguments, in which the proportion of stabilized microtubules is compared to the probability that when 40 GMPCPP-tubulin subunits have polymerized onto a microtubule end, all protofilaments have added at least one GMPCPP-tubulin subunit, our measurements of cap size support a model in which a single GTP subunit at the end of each of the 13 protofilaments of a microtubule is sufficient for stabilization. Depolymerization of a microtubule may be initiated by an exposed tubulin–GDP subunit at even a single position. These results have implications for the structure of microtubules and their means of regulation.     

Kinetic analysis of tubulin exchange at microtubule ends at low vinblastine concentrations

We have investigated the effects of vinblastine at micromolar concentrations and below on the dynamics of tubulin exchange at the ends of microtubule-associated-protein-rich bovine brain microtubules. The predominant behavior of these microtubules at polymer-mass steady state under the conditions examined was tubulin flux, i.e., net addition of tubulin at one end of each microtubule, operationally defined as the assembly or A end, and balanced net loss at the opposite (disassembly or D) end. No dynamic instability behavior could be detected by video-enhanced dark-field microscopy. Addition of vinblastine to the microtubules at polymer-mass steady state resulted in an initial concentration-dependent depolymerization predominantly at the A ends, until a new steady-state plateau at an elevated critical concentration was established. Microtubules ultimately attained the same stable polymer-mass plateau when vinblastine was added prior to initiation of polymerization as when the drug was added to already polymerized microtubules. Vinblastine inhibited tubulin exchange at the ends of the microtubules at polymer-mass steady state, as determined by using microtubules differentially radiolabeled at their opposite ends. Inhibition of tubulin exchange occurred at concentrations of vinblastine that had very little effect on polymer mass. Both the initial burst of incorporation that occurs in control microtubule suspensions following a pulse of labeled GTP and the relatively slower linear incorporation of label that follows the initial burst were inhibited in a concentration-dependent manner by vinblastine. Both processes were inhibited to the same extent at all vinblastine concentrations examined. If the initial burst of label incorporation represents a low degree of dynamic instability (very short excursions of growth and shortening of the microtubules at one or both ends), then vinblastine inhibits both dynamic instability and flux to similar extents. The ability of vinblastine to inhibit tubulin exchange at microtubule ends in the micromolar concentration range appeared to be mediated by the reversible binding of vinblastine to tubulin binding sites exposed at the polymer ends. Determination by dilution analysis of the effects of vinblastine on the apparent dissociation rate constants for tubulin loss at opposite microtubule ends indicated that a principal effect of vinblastine is to decrease the dissociation rate constant at A ends (i.e., it produces a kinetic cap at A ends), whereas it has no effect on the D-end dissociation rate constant.     

Microtubule elongation and guanosine 5'-triphosphate hydrolysis. Role of guanine nucleotides in microtubule dynamics

The tubulin concentration dependence of the rates of microtubule elongation and accompanying GTP hydrolysis has been studied over a large range of tubulin concentration. GTP hydrolysis followed the elongation process closely at low tubulin concentration and became gradually uncoupled at higher concentrations, reaching a limiting rate of 35-40 s-1. The kinetic parameters for microtubule growth were different at low and high tubulin concentrations. Elongation of microtubules has also been studied in solutions containing GDP and GTP in variable proportions. Only traces of GTP present in GDP were necessary to confer a high stability (low critical concentration) to microtubules. Pure GDP-tubulin was found unable to elongate microtubules in the absence of GTP but blocked microtubule ends with an equilibrium dissociation constant of 5-6 microM. These data were accounted for by a model within which, in the presence of GTP-tubulin at high concentration, microtubules grow at a fast rate with a large GTP cap; the GTP cap may be quite short in the region of the critical concentration; microtubule stability is linked to the strong interaction between GTP and GDP subunits at the elongating site; dimeric GDP-tubulin does not have the appropriate conformation to undergo reversible polymerization. These results are discussed with regard to possible role of GDP and GTP and of GTP hydrolysis in microtubule dynamics.     

Concerning the chemical nature of tubulin subunits that cap and stabilize microtubules

There is no definitive evidence on the nature of the cap at microtubule ends that is responsible for dynamic instability behavior. It was, therefore, of interest that steady-state microtubules assembled in 20 mM P(i) buffer and pulsed for 15-60 min with [gamma-(32)P]GTP contained approximately 26 [(32)P]P(i)/microtubule [Panda et al. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 1609-1617]. It was concluded that microtubules are capped with a tubulin-GDP-P(i) subunit at the end of each its 13 protofilaments and that this is responsible for stabilizing microtubules in the growth phase. Also, because microtubules with [(32)P]P(i) were isolated despite the presence of 20 mM P(i), it was concluded that P(i) in terminal tubulin-GDP-P(i) subunits does not exchange with solvent. These observations are inconsistent with our finding that tubulin-GDP-P(i) subunits do not stabilize microtubules and with evidence that the nucleotide, and presumably also P(i), in subunits at microtubule ends exchanges with solvent. We have resolved this discrepancy by finding that during the pulse period the added [(32)P]GTP was almost quantitatively hydrolyzed. The so-formed [(32)P]P(i) labeled the 20 mM P(i) buffer, and this exchanged into tubulin-GDP subunits in the core of the microtubule. Evidence for this was our finding of virtually identical [(32)P]P(i) in microtubules pulsed with [(32)P]GTP with a specific activity that varied 11-fold by using either 100 or 1,100 microM GTP in the reaction. Label uptake was insensitive to the [(32)P]GTP specific activity because in both cases hydrolysis generated 20 mM [(32)P]P(i) with a virtually identical specific activity. Also, approximately 0.4 mol of [(32)P]P(i) /tubulin dimer was found in microtubules when steady-state microtubules in 20 mM P(i) were pulsed with a trace amount of [(32)P]P(i). This stoichiometry is consistent with a 25 mM K(d) previously reported for P(i) binding to tubulin-GDP subunits in microtubules. It is concluded that, under the conditions used for the [(32)P]GTP pulse labeling, (32)P was incorporated into the entire microtubule from [(32)P]P(i) released into the solution, rather than into a tubulin-GDP-P(i) cap, from [(32)P]GTP. Thus, there is no evidence that tubulin-GDP-P(i) subunits accumulate in and stabilize microtubule ends.     

GTP hydrolysis during microtubule assembly

The GTP cap model of dynamic instability [Mitchison, T., & Kirschner, M.W. (1984) Nature (London) 312, 237] postulates that a GTP cap at the end of most microtubules stabilizes the polymer and allows continuing assembly of GTP-tubulin subunits while microtubules without a cap rapidly disassemble. This attractive explanation for observed microtubule behavior is based on the suggestion that hydrolysis of GTP is not coupled to assembly but rather takes place as a first-order reaction after a subunit is assembled onto a polymer end. Carlier and Pantaloni [Carlier, M., & Pantaloni, D. (1981) Biochemistry 20, 1918] reported a lag of hydrolysis behind microtubule assembly and a first-order rate constant for hydrolysis (kh) of 0.25/min. A lag has not been demonstrated by other investigators, and a kh value that specifies such a slow rate of hydrolysis is difficult to reconcile with reported steady-state microtubule growth rates and frequencies of disassembly. We have looked for a lag using tubulin free of microtubule-associated protein at concentrations of 18.5-74 microM, assembly with and without glycerol, and two independent assays of GTP hydrolysis. No lag was observed under any of the conditions employed, with initial rates of hydrolysis increasing in proportion to rates of assembly. If hydrolysis is uncoupled from assembly, we estimate that kh must be at least 2.5/min and could be much greater, a result that we argue may be advantageous to the GTP cap model. We also describe a preliminary model of assembly coupled to hydrolysis that specifies formation and loss of a GTP cap, thus allowing dynamic instability.     

Nanomolar concentrations of nocodazole alter microtubule dynamic instability in vivo and in vitro.

Previous studies demonstrated that nanomolar concentrations of nocodazole can block cells in mitosis without net microtubule disassembly and resulted in the hypothesis that this block was due to a nocodazole-induced stabilization of microtubules. We tested this hypothesis by examining the effects of nanomolar concentrations of nocodazole on microtubule dynamic instability in interphase cells and in vitro with purified brain tubulin. Newt lung epithelial cell microtubules were visualized by video-enhanced differential interference contrast microscopy and cells were perfused with solutions of nocodazole ranging in concentration from 4 to 400 nM. Microtubules showed a loss of the two-state behavior typical of dynamic instability as evidenced by the addition of a third state where they exhibited little net change in length (a paused state). Nocodazole perfusion also resulted in slower elongation and shortening velocities, increased catastrophe, and an overall decrease in microtubule turnover. Experiments performed on BSC-1 cells that were microinjected with rhodamine-labeled tubulin, incubated in nocodazole for 1 h, and visualized by using low-light-level fluorescence microscopy showed similar results except that nocodazole-treated BSC-1 cells showed a decrease in catastrophe. To gain insight into possible mechanisms responsible for changes in dynamic instability, we examined the effects of 4 nM to 12 microM nocodazole on the assembly of purified tubulin from axoneme seeds. At both microtubule plus and minus ends, perfusion with nocodazole resulted in a dose-dependent decrease in elongation and shortening velocities, increase in pause duration and catastrophe frequency, and decrease in rescue frequency. These effects, which result in an overall decrease in microtubule turnover after nocodazole treatment, suggest that the mitotic block observed is due to a reduction in microtubule dynamic turnover. In addition, the in vitro results are similar to the effects of increasing concentrations of GDP-tubulin (TuD) subunits on microtubule assembly. Given that nocodazole increases tubulin GTPase activity, we propose that nocodazole acts by generating TuD subunits that then alter dynamic instability.     

Dilution of individual microtubules observed in real time in vitro: evidence that cap size is small and independent of elongation rate

Although the mechanism of microtubule dynamic instability is thought to involve the hydrolysis of tubulin-bound GTP, the mechanism of GTP hydrolysis and the basis of microtubule stability are controversial. Video microscopy of individual microtubules and dilution protocols were used to examine the size and lifetime of the stabilizing cap. Purified porcine brain tubulin (7-23 microM) was assembled at 37 degrees C onto both ends of isolated sea urchin axoneme fragments in a miniature flow cell to give a 10-fold variation in elongation rate. The tubulin concentration in the region of microtubule growth could be diluted rapidly (by 84% within 3 s of the onset of dilution). Upon perfusion with buffer containing no tubulin, microtubules experienced a catastrophe (conversion from elongation to rapid shortening) within 4-6 s on average after dilution to 16% of the initial concentration, independent of the predilution rate of elongation and length. Based on extrapolation of catastrophe frequency to zero tubulin concentration, the estimated lifetime of the stable cap after infinite dilution was less than 3-4 s for plus and minus ends, much shorter than the approximately 200 s observed at steady state (Walker, R. A., E. T. O'Brien, N. K. Pryer, M. Soboeiro, W. A. Voter, H. P. Erickson, and E. D. Salmon. 1988. J. Cell Biol. 107:1437-1448.). We conclude that during elongation, both plus and minus ends are stabilized by a short region (approximately 200 dimers or less) and that the size of the stable cap is independent of 10-fold variation in elongation rate. These results eliminate models of dynamic instability which predict extensive "build-up" stabilizing caps and support models which constrain the cap to the elongating tip. We propose that the cell may take advantage of such an assembly mechanism by using "catastrophe factors" that can promote frequent catastrophe even at high elongation rates by transiently binding to microtubule ends and briefly inhibiting GTP-tubulin association.     

Mechanism for oscillatory assembly of microtubules

Dampened oscillations of microtubule assembly can accompany polymerization at high tubulin subunit concentrations. This presumably results from a synchronization of dynamic instability behavior, which generates a large population of rapidly disassembling microtubules, that liberate tubulin-GDP oligomers. Subunits in oligomers cannot assemble until they dissociate, to allow GDP-GTP exchange. To determine whether rapidly disassembling microtubules generate oligomers directly, we measured the rate of dilution-induced disassembly of tubulin-GDP microtubules and the rate of dissociation of GDP from the so-formed tubulin-GDP subunits. The rate of GDP dissociation from liberated subunits was found to correspond to that of tubulin-GDP subunits (t1/2 = 5 s), rather than tubulin-GDP oligomers. This indicates that tubulin-GDP subunits are released from microtubules undergoing rapid disassembly. Oligomers apparently form in a side reaction from the high concentration of tubulin-GDP subunits liberated from the synchronously disassembling microtubule population. The rate of subunit dissociation is 0.11 s-1 with oligomers formed by concentrating tubulin-GDP subunits and 0.045 s-1 with oligomers formed by cold-induced microtubule disassembly. This difference provides evidence that the conformation of tubulin-GDP subunits released from rapidly disassembling microtubules differs from tubulin-GDP subunits that were not recently in the microtubule lattice.     

Phosphate release during microtubule assembly: what stabilizes growing microtubules?

The molecular mechanism underlying microtubule dynamic instability depends on the relationship between the addition of tubulin-GTP to a growing microtubule and its hydrolysis in the microtubule lattice to tubulin-GDP, with release of inorganic phosphate (Pi). Since this relationship remains controversial, we have re-examined the release of Pi upon microtubule assembly using a fluorometric assay for Pi, based on the phosphate-binding protein of Escherichia coli [Brune M., Hunter, J. L., Corrie, J. E. T., and Webb, M. R. (1994) Biochemistry 33, 8262-8271]. Microtubule assembly and Pi release were monitored simultaneously in a standard fluorimeter as an increase in the turbidity and fluorescence, respectively, in tubulin-GTP solutions assembled under conditions supporting dynamic instability. At the steady state of assembly, Pi release is nonlinear with respect to time, proceeding at a rate determined by the following: (a) the intrinsic GTPase activity of the nonpolymerized tubulin-GTP, and (b) the microtubule number concentration, which decreases progressively. Direct observation of the time course of nucleated microtubule assembly indicates that Pi release is closely coupled to microtubule elongation, even during the initial stages of assembly when uncoupling of tubulin-GTP addition and GTP hydrolysis would be most evident. Studies of the inhibition and reversal of the growth phase by cytostatic drugs show no evidence of a burst of Pi release. We conclude that nucleotide hydrolysis can keep pace with tubulin-GTP addition rates of 200 molecules per second per microtubule and that extended caps of tubulin-GTP or tubulin-GDP-Pi are not generated in normal assembly, nor are they required to stabilize growing microtubules or to support the phenomenon of dynamic instability of microtubules at the steady state.     

The Dynamic Behavior of Individual Microtubules Associated with Chromosomes In Vitro

Mitotic movements of chromosomes are usually coupled to the elongation and shortening of the microtubules to which they are bound. The lengths of kinetochore-associated microtubules change by incorporation or loss of tubulin subunits, principally at their chromosome-bound ends. We have reproduced aspects of this phenomenon in vitro, using a real-time assay that displays directly the movements of individual chromosome-associated microtubules as they elongate and shorten. Chromosomes isolated from cultured Chinese hamster ovary cells were adhered to coverslips and then allowed to bind labeled microtubules. In the presence of tubulin and GTP, these microtubules could grow at their chromosome-bound ends, causing the labeled segments to move away from the chromosomes, even in the absence of ATP. Sometimes a microtubule would switch to shortening, causing the direction of movement to change abruptly. The link between a microtubule and a chromosome was mechanically strong; 15 pN of tension was generally insufficient to detach a microtubule, even though it could add subunits at the kinetochore–microtubule junction. The behavior of the microtubules in vitro was regulated by the chromosomes to which they were bound; the frequency of transitions from polymerization to depolymerization was decreased, and the speed of depolymerization-coupled movement toward chromosomes was only one-fifth the rate of shortening for microtubules free in solution. Our results are consistent with a model in which each microtubule interacts with an increasing number of chromosome-associated binding sites as it approaches the kinetochore.     

Evidence that a single monolayer tubulin-GTP cap is both necessary and sufficient to stabilize microtubules.

Evidence that 13 or 14 contiguous tubulin-GTP subunits are sufficient to cap and stabilize a microtubule end and that loss of only one of these subunits results in the transition to rapid disassembly(catastrophe) was obtained using the slowly hydrolyzable GTP analogue guanylyl-(a,b)-methylene-diphosphonate (GMPCPP). The minus end of microtubules assembled with GTP was transiently stabilized against dilution-induced disassembly by reaction with tubulin-GMPCPP subunits for a time sufficient to cap the end with an average 40 subunits. The minimum size of a tubulin-GMPCPP cap sufficient to prevent disassembly was estimated from an observed 25- to 2000-s lifetime of the GMPCPP-stabilized microtubules following dilution with buffer and from the time required for loss of a single tubulin-GMPCPP subunit from the microtubule end (found to be 15 s). Rather than assuming that the 25- to 2000-s dispersion in cap lifetime results from an unlikely 80-fold range in the number of tubulin-GMPCpP subunits added in the 25-s incubation, it is proposed that this results because the minimum stable cap contains 13 to 14 tubulin-GMPCPP subunits. As a consequence, a microtubule capped with 13-14 tubulin-GMPCPP subunits switches to disassembly after only one dissociation event (in about 15 s), whereas the time required for catastrophe of a microtubule with only six times as many subunits (84 subunits) corresponds to 71 dissociation events (84-13). The minimum size of a tubulin-GMPCPP cap sufficient to prevent disassembly was also estimated with microtubules in which a GMPCPP-cap was formed by allowing chance to result in the accumulation of multiple contiguous tubulin-GMPCPP subunits at the end, during the disassembly of microtubules containing both GDP and GMPCPP. Our observation that the disassembly rate was inhibited in proportion to the 13-14th power of the fraction of subunits containing GMPCPP again suggests that a minimum cap contains 13-14 tubulin-GMPCPP subunits. A remeasurement of the rate constant for dissociation of a tubulin-GMPCPP subunit from the plus-end of GMPCPP microtubules, now found to be 0.118 s-1, has allowed a better estimate of the standard free energy for hydrolysis of GMPCPP in a microtubule and release of Pi: this is +0.7 kcal/mol, rather than -0.9 kcal/mol, as previously reported.     

Stathmin family protein SCG10 differentially regulates the plus and minus end dynamics of microtubules at steady state in vitro: implications for its role in neurite outgrowth

SCG10 (superior cervical ganglia neural-specific 10 protein) is a neuron specific member of the stathmin family of microtubule regulatory proteins that like stathmin can bind to soluble tubulin and depolymerize microtubules. The direct actions of SCG10 on microtubules themselves and on their dynamics have not been investigated previously. Here, we analyzed the effects of SCG10 on the dynamic instability behavior of microtubules in vitro, both at steady state and early during microtubule polymerization. In contrast to stathmin, whose major action on dynamics is to destabilize microtubules by increasing the switching frequency from growth to shortening (the catastrophe frequency) at microtubule ends, SCG10 stabilized the plus ends both at steady state and early during polymerization by increasing the rate and extent of growth. For example, early during polymerization at high initial tubulin concentrations (20 microM), a low molar ratio of SCG10 to tubulin of 1:30 increased the growth rate by approximately 50%. In contrast to its effects at plus ends, SCG10 destabilized minus ends by increasing the shortening rate, the length shortened during shortening events, and the catastrophe frequency. Consistent with its ability to modulate microtubule dynamics at steady state, SCG10 bound to purified microtubules along their lengths. The dual activity of SCG10 at opposite microtubule ends may be important for its role in regulating growth cone microtubule dynamics. SCG10's ability to promote plus end growth may facilitate microtubule extension into filopodia, and its ability to destabilize minus ends could provide soluble tubulin for net plus end elongation.     

Temperature-jump studies of microtubule dynamic instability

Evidence for a slowly dissociating tubulin-GTP cap at microtubule ends was derived from observation of a delay for attaining a maximum disassembly rate, after the temperature of steady state microtubules was rapidly decreased from 36 to 34 degrees C. The possibility that the microtubules were capped by a single tubulin-GTP subunit on each subhelix was ruled out, by comparison of the disassembly kinetics following a temperature decrease and dilution. The existence of a subpopulation of microtubules that underwent irreversible or near irreversible disassembly was demonstrated by a 30-s lag for attainment of a maximum assembly rate, after steady state microtubules were shifted from 34 to 36 degrees C. A dynamic instability model predicts that a maximum assembly rate will be delayed until disappearance of a subpopulation of microtubules that disassemble before being recapped. Analysis indicates that the 30-s lag resulted because approximately 2% of the mass in the steady state microtubule population was uncapped and disassembling and not readily recapped. The half-time for recapping of disassembling microtubules, by addition of tubulin-GTP subunits to ends, was equal to or greater than 20 s. Since tubulin-GDP dissociated from microtubules at a rate of about 4500 s-1, slow recapping resulted in dramatic shortening of disassembling microtubules.