Foot-and-mouth disease virus 3C protease: recent structural and functional insights into an antiviral target

The 3C protease from foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV 3C(pro)) is critical for viral pathogenesis, having vital roles in both the processing of the polyprotein precursor and RNA replication. Although recent structural and functional studies have revealed new insights into the mechanism and function of the enzyme, key questions remain that must be addressed before the potential of FMDV 3C(pro) as an antiviral drug target can be realised.     

Disruption of TLR3 signaling due to cleavage of TRIF by the hepatitis A virus protease-polymerase processing intermediate, 3CD

Toll-like receptor 3 (TLR3) and cytosolic RIG-I-like helicases (RIG-I and MDA5) sense viral RNAs and activate innate immune signaling pathways that induce expression of interferon (IFN) through specific adaptor proteins, TIR domain-containing adaptor inducing interferon-β (TRIF), and mitochondrial antiviral signaling protein (MAVS), respectively. Previously, we demonstrated that hepatitis A virus (HAV), a unique hepatotropic human picornavirus, disrupts RIG-I/MDA5 signaling by targeting MAVS for cleavage by 3ABC, a precursor of the sole HAV protease, 3C(pro), that is derived by auto-processing of the P3 (3ABCD) segment of the viral polyprotein. Here, we show that HAV also disrupts TLR3 signaling, inhibiting poly(I:C)-stimulated dimerization of IFN regulatory factor 3 (IRF-3), IRF-3 translocation to the nucleus, and IFN-β promoter activation, by targeting TRIF for degradation by a distinct 3ABCD processing intermediate, the 3CD protease-polymerase precursor. TRIF is proteolytically cleaved by 3CD, but not by the mature 3C(pro) protease or the 3ABC precursor that degrades MAVS. 3CD-mediated degradation of TRIF depends on both the cysteine protease activity of 3C(pro) and downstream 3D(pol) sequence, but not 3D(pol) polymerase activity. Cleavage occurs at two non-canonical 3C(pro) recognition sequences in TRIF, and involves a hierarchical process in which primary cleavage at Gln-554 is a prerequisite for scission at Gln-190. The results of mutational studies indicate that 3D(pol) sequence modulates the substrate specificity of the upstream 3C(pro) protease when fused to it in cis in 3CD, allowing 3CD to target cleavage sites not normally recognized by 3C(pro). HAV thus disrupts both RIG-I/MDA5 and TLR3 signaling pathways through cleavage of essential adaptor proteins by two distinct protease precursors derived from the common 3ABCD polyprotein processing intermediate.     

The N-terminal region of hepatitis C virus nonstructural protein 3 (NS3) is essential for stable complex formation with NS4A.

Hepatitis C virus proteins are produced by proteolytic processing of the viral precursor polyprotein that is encoded in the largest open reading frame of the viral genome. Processing of the nonstructural viral polyprotein requires the viral serine-type proteinase present in nonstructural protein 3 (NS3). The cleavage of the junction between NS4B and NS5A is mediated by NS3 only when NS4A is present. NS4A is thought to be a cofactor that enhances the cleavage efficiency of NS3 in hepatitis C virus protein-producing cells. Stable NS3-NS4A complex formation required the N-terminal 22 amino acid residues of NS3. This interaction contributed to stabilization of the NS3 product as well as increased the efficiency of cleavage at the NS4B/5A site. The N-terminal 22 amino acid residues fused to Escherichia coli dihydrofolate reductase also formed a stable complex with NS4A. NS3 derivatives which lacked the N-terminal 22 amino acid residues showed drastically reduced cleavage activity at the NS4B/5A site even in the presence of NS4A. These data suggested that the interaction with NS4A through the 22 amino acid residues of NS3 is primarily important for the NS4A-dependent processing of the NS4B/5A site by NS3.     

Foot-and-mouth disease virus 2A protease mediates cleavage in attenuated Sabin 3 poliovirus vectors engineered for delivery of foreign antigens.

Poliovirus vectors are being studied as potential vaccine delivery systems, with foreign genetic sequences incorporated as part of the viral genome. The foreign sequences are expressed as part of the viral polyprotein. Addition of proteolytic cleavage sites at the junction of the foreign polypeptide and the viral proteins results in cleavage during polyprotein processing. The ability of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) 2A to mediate proteolytic cleavage in the context of poliovirus vectors was studied. The results demonstrate that FMDV 2A is able to generate cleavage of the foreign antigen from the viral polyprotein. A second cleavage event between the FMDV 2A peptide and the foreign protein was also observed.     

Proteolytic processing of foot-and-mouth disease virus polyproteins expressed in a cell-free system from clone-derived transcripts

All picornaviral genes are expressed as a single, large polyprotein, which is proteolytically processed into the system produces functional proteins, including viral protease 3C, which plays a major role in processing the precursor proteins. To study the function of the two putative proteases 3C and leader (L) in processing, we constructed several cDNA plasmids encoding various regions of the FMDV type A12 genome. These plasmids, containing FMDV cDNA segments under the control of the T7 promoter, were transcribed in vitro by using T7 RNA polymerase and then translated in rabbit reticulocyte lysates. The expressed FMDV gene products were identified by immunoprecipitation with specific antisera and analyzed by gel electrophoresis. The results demonstrate the following: (i) the leader protein, L, is processed from the structural protein precursor, P1, in the absence of any P2 or P3 region proteins; (ii) protein 2A remains associated with the structural protein precursor, P1, rather than the precursor, P2; (iii) the processing of the P1-2A/P2 junction is not catalyzed by 3C or L; (iv) the proteolytic processing of polyproteins from the structural P1 region (except VP4/VP2) and the nonstructural P2 and P3 region is catalyzed by 3C.     

Proteolytic cleavage of encephalomyocarditis virus capsid region substrates by precursors to the 3C enzyme.

Picornavirus protease 3C is normally released from its P3 precursor by two successive self-cleavage reactions. The free enzyme can then catalyze most of the remaining processing events within the viral polyprotein. To investigate the role of the 3C precursors in the processing cascade, we constructed cDNA clones which expressed genetically altered forms of the encephalomyocarditis P3 region in vitro. Site-specific substitutions were introduced into the Gln-Gly residues at the 3B-3C and 3C-3D junctions, and the resulting proteins were tested for their ability to self-process and to catalyze cleavage of viral capsid precursors in cell-free protease assays. We determined that three P3 region precursor proteins (3ABC, 3CD, and P3), harboring inactive cleavage sites, were as active as the free enzyme (3C) in processing assays with capsid substrates. Further, we found that in addition to the naturally occurring Gln-Gly and Gln-Ser amino acid pairs, the encephalomyocarditis 3C enzyme was able to process Gln-Cys but not Gln-Thr, Gln-Ile, Gln-Tyr, Arg-Gly, or Leu-Gly combinations when these residues were substituted into normal cleavage site contexts.     

Functional analysis of potential carboxy-terminal cleavage sites of tick-borne encephalitis virus capsid protein

The mature capsid protein C of flaviviruses is generated through the proteolytic cleavage of the precursor polyprotein by the viral NS2B/3 protease. This cleavage is a prerequisite for the subsequent processing of the viral surface protein prM, and the concerted progression of these events plays a key role in the process of the assembly of infectious virions. Protein C of tick-borne encephalitis virus (TBEV) contains two amino acid sequence motifs within the carboxy-terminal region that match the canonical NS2B/3 recognition site. Site-specific mutagenesis in the context of the full-length TBEV genome was used to investigate the in vivo cleavage specificity of the viral protease in this functionally important domain. The results indicate that the downstream site is necessary and sufficient for efficient cleavage and virion assembly; in contrast, the upstream site is dispensable and placed in a structural context that renders it largely inaccessible to the viral protease. Mutants with impaired C-prM cleavage generally exhibited a significantly increased cytotoxicity. In spite of the clear preference of the protease for only one of the two naturally occurring motifs, the enzyme was unexpectedly tolerant to both the presence of a noncanonical threonine residue at position P2 and the position of cleavage relative to the adjacent internal prM signal sequence. The insertion of three amino acid residues downstream of the cleavage site did not change the viral phenotype. Thus, this study further illuminates the specificity of the TBEV protease and reveals that the carboxy-terminal region of protein C has a remarkable functional flexibility in its role in the assembly of infectious virions.     

Picornaviral processing: some new ideas

Mature picornaviral proteins are derived by progressive, post-translational cleavage of a giant precursor polyprotein. At least three viral-encoded proteolytic activities are involved in the processing. The first cleavage takes place while the polyprotein is still nascent on a ribosome. In poliovirus, this event is probably catalyzed by peptide 2A, a protein from the middle portion of the genome. Most subsequent processing is effected by viral protease 3C, a thiol-type enzyme, responsible for eight to ten self-cleaving and autocatalytic reactions within the polyprotein. The final proteolytic processing event, maturation of the VPO peptide, may occur by a novel, autocatalytic, serine-type mechanism, where viral RNA serves as proton-acceptor during the cleavage reaction.     

Identification of a novel histone H3 specific protease activity in nuclei of chicken liver

Evolutionary conserved histone proteins play a very important role in the regulation of eukaryotic gene expression by undergoing post translational modifications within the tail regions. However, their role in tissue-specific gene expression and development remains unclear. In this study, we provide evidence for in vivo tissue-specific proteolytic cleavage of histone H3 in the liver of adult white Leghorn chickens, which we believe to be regulated by tissue-specific protease activity and epigenetic markers. The cleavage of histone H3 in the liver of adult chickens is very unique, and can serve as a model for studying tissue-specific changes in chromatin organization and gene expression. For the first time, we have identified and partially purified histone H3-specific protease activity that is distinct from histone H3 protease activities recently reported. Together, our data provide evidence of proteolytic processing and identification of protease activity that is specific to histone H3 in the liver of adult chickens, which may be involved in the regulation of gene expression during development, aging, and age-associated diseases.     

Synthetic peptides as substrates and inhibitors of human immune deficiency virus-1 protease

Retroviruses code for a virus-specific protease which is essential for polyprotein processing and viral infectivity. The human immune deficiency virus-1 protease is an aspartic protease of 9 kDa which was synthesized by recombinant DNA technology and arises by autocatalytic processing from a polyprotein precursor which has recently been demonstrated by use of a protease-specific monoclonal antibody. The protease was shown to form dimers. Here we demonstrate that synthetic peptides can be used as both model substrates as well as inhibitors for investigation of the protease. 14 synthetic peptides, 7-18 amino acids in length, containing putative protease cleavage sites of the viral polyprotein gag and pol precursors, have been analyzed with the partially purified protease by the use of high performance liquid chromatography. In seven cases, where cleavage was observed, the length of the peptides did not significantly influence the cleavage efficiencies, heptapeptides being large enough as model substrates. No cleavage was observed with a protein preparation purified in parallel from control bacteria not expressing the human immune deficiency virus-1 protease. The protease was not only able to cut next to a proline but also between other peptides indicating that the proline is not a prerequisite. Three peptides with either reduced bonds at the cleavage site or a substitution by statin were inhibitory while another uncleaved substrate was not. The usefulness of small model substrates for characterization of the protease is further demonstrated by determination of a kinetic optimum pH (3.5-5.5) and incubation temperature (37 degrees C).     

Nucleotide sequence and genome organization of foot-and-mouth disease virus.

A continuous 7802 nucleotide sequence spanning the 94% of foot and mouth disease virus RNA between the 5'-proximal poly(C) tract and the 3'-terminal poly(A) was obtained from cloned cDNA, and the total size of the RNA genome was corrected to 8450 nucleotides. A long open reading frame was identified within this sequence starting about 1300 bases from the 5' end of the RNA genome and extending to a termination codon 92 bases from its polyadenylated 3' end. The protein sequence of 2332 amino acids deduced from this coding sequence was correlated with the 260 K FMDV polyprotein. Its processing sites and twelve mature viral proteins were inferred from protein data, available for some proteins, a predicted cleavage specificity of an FMDV encoded protease for Glu/Gly(Thr, Ser) linkages, and homologies to related proteins from poliovirus. In addition, a short unlinked reading frame of 92 codons has been identified by sequence homology to the polyprotein initiation signal and by in vitro translation studies.     

Leader protein of foot-and-mouth disease virus is required for cleavage of the p220 component of the cap-binding protein complex.

Suppression of host protein synthesis in cells infected by poliovirus and certain other picornaviruses involves inactivation of the cap-binding protein complex. Inactivation of this complex has been correlated with the proteolytic cleavage of p220, a component of the cap-binding protein complex. Since picornaviral RNA is not capped, it continues to be translated as the cap-binding protein complex is inactivated. The cleavage of p220 can be induced to occur in vitro, catalyzed by extracts from infected cells or by reticulocyte lysates translating viral RNA. Expression of polioviral protease 2A is sufficient to induce p220 cleavage, and the presence in 2A of an 18-amino-acid sequence representing a putative cysteine protease active site correlates with the ability of different picornaviruses to induce p220 cleavage. Foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) infection induces complete cleavage of p220, yet the FMDV genome codes for a 2A protein of only 16 amino acids, which does not include the putative cysteine protease active site. Using cDNA plasmids encoding various regions of the FMDV genome, we have determined that the leader protein is required to initiate p220 cleavage. This is the first report of a function for the leader protein, other than that of autocatalytic cleavage from the FMDV polyprotein.     

Processing of the intracellular form of the west Nile virus capsid protein by the viral NS2B-NS3 protease: an in vitro study.

According to the existing model of flavivirus polyprotein processing, one of the cleavages in the amino-terminal part of the flavivirus polyprotein by host cell signalases results in formation of prM (precursor to one of the structural proteins, M) and the membrane-bound intracellular form of the viral capsid protein (Cint) retaining the prM signal sequence at its carboxy terminus. This hydrophobic anchor is subsequently removed by the viral protease, resulting in formation of the mature viral capsid protein found in virions (Cvir). We have prepared in vitro expression cassettes coding for both forms of the capsid protein, for the prM protein, for the C-prM precursor, and for the viral protease components of West Nile flavivirus and characterized their translation products. Using Cint and Cvir translation products as molecular markers, we have observed processing of the intracellular form of the West Nile capsid protein by the viral protease in vitro both upon cotranslation of the C-prM precursor and the viral protease-encoding cassette and by incubation of C-prM translation products with a detergent-solubilized extract of cells infected with a recombinant vaccinia virus expressing the active viral protease. The cleavage of Cint by the viral protease at the predicted dibasic site was verified by introduction of point mutations into the cleavage site and an adjacent region. These studies provide the first direct demonstration of processing of the intracellular form of the flavivirus capsid protein by the viral protease.     

Hepatitis A virus 3C proteinase substrate specificity.

Hepatitis A virus (HAV) 3C proteinase is responsible for processing the viral precursor polyprotein into mature proteins. The substrate specificity of recombinant hepatitis A 3C proteinase was investigated using a series of synthetic peptides representing putative polyprotein junction sequences. Two peptides, corresponding to the viral polyprotein 2B/2C and 2C/3A junctions, were determined to be cleaved most efficiently by the viral 3C proteinase. The kcat/Km values determined for the hydrolysis of a further series of 2B/2C peptides, in which C-terminal and N-terminal amino acids were systematically removed, revealed that P4 through P2' amino acids were necessary for efficient substrate cleavage. The substitution of Ala for amino acids in P1 and P4 positions decreased the rate of peptide hydrolysis by 100- and 10-fold, respectively, indicating that the side chains of Gln in P1 and Leu in P4 are important determinants of substrate specificity. Rates of hydrolysis measured for other P1- and P4-substituted peptides indicate that S1 is very specific for the Gln side chain whereas S4 requires only that the amino acid in P4 be hydrophobic. A continuous fluorescence quench assay was developed, allowing the determination of kcat/Km dependence on pH. The pH rate profile suggests that catalyzed peptide hydrolysis is dependent on deprotonation of a reactive group having a pKa of 6.2 (+/- 0.2). The results of tests with several proteinase inhibitors indicate that this cysteine proteinase, like other picornaviral 3C proteinases, is not a member of the papain family.     

The NS2 protein of hepatitis C virus is a transmembrane polypeptide.

The NS2 protein of hepatitis C virus (HCV) is released from its polyprotein precursor by two proteolytic cleavages. The N terminus of this protein is separated from the E2/p7 polypeptide by a cleavage thought to be mediated by signal peptidase, whereas the NS2-3 junction located at the C terminus is processed by a viral protease. To characterize the biogenesis of NS2 encoded by the BK strain of HCV, we have defined the minimal region of the polyprotein required for efficient cleavage at the NS2-3 site and analyzed the interaction of the mature polypeptide with the membrane of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). We have observed that although cleavage can occur in vitro in the absence of microsomal membranes, synthesis of the polyprotein precursor in the presence of membranes greatly increases processing at this site. Furthermore, we show that the membrane dependency for efficient in vitro processing varies among different HCV strains and that host proteins located on the ER membrane, and in particular the signal recognition particle receptor, are required to sustain efficient proteolysis. By means of sedimentation analysis, protease protection assay, and site-directed mutagenesis, we also demonstrate that the NS2 protein derived from processing at the NS2-3 site is a transmembrane polypeptide, with the C terminus translocated in the lumen of the ER and the N terminus located in the cytosol.     

Poliovirus/Hepatitis C Virus (Internal Ribosomal Entry Site-Core) Chimeric Viruses: Improved Growth Properties through Modification of a Proteolytic Cleavage Site and Requirement for Core RNA Sequences but Not for Core-Related Polypeptides

H.-H. Lu and E. Wimmer (Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 93:1412–1417, 1996) have demonstrated that the internal ribosomal entry site (IRES) of poliovirus (PV) can be functionally replaced by the related genetic element from hepatitis C virus (HCV). One important finding of this study was that open reading frame sequences 3′ of the initiating AUG, corresponding to the open reading frame of the HCV core polypeptide, are required to create a viable chimeric virus. This made necessary the inclusion of a PV 3C protease (3C^pro) cleavage site for proper polyprotein processing to create the authentic N terminus of the PV capsid precursor. Chimeric PV/HCV (P/H) viruses, however, grew poorly relative to PV. The goal of this study was to determine the molecular basis of impaired replication and enhance the growth properties of this chimeric virus. Genetic modifications leading to a different proteinase (PV 2A^pro) cleavage site between the HCV core sequence and the PV polyprotein (P/H701-2A) proved far superior with respect to viral protein expression, core-PV fusion polyprotein processing, plaque phenotype, and viral titer than the original prototype PV/HCV chimera containing the PV 3C^pro-specific cleavage site (P/H701). We have used this new virus model to answer two questions concerning the role of the HCV core protein in P/H chimeric viral proliferation. First, a derivative of P/H701-2A with frameshifts in the core-encoding sequence was used to demonstrate that production of the core protein was not necessary for the translation and replication of the P/H chimera. Second, a viral construct with a C-terminal truncation of 23 amino acids of the core gene was used to show that a signal sequence for signal peptidase processing, when present in the viral construct, is detrimental to P/H virus growth. The novel P/H chimera described here are suitable models for analyzing the function(s) of the HCV elements by genetic analyses in vivo and for antiviral drug discovery.     

Differential requirements of NS4A for internal NS3 cleavage and polyprotein processing of hepatitis C virus

The NS3 protein of hepatitis C virus (HCV) possesses protease activity responsible for the proteolytic cleavage of the viral polyprotein at the junctions of nonstructural proteins downstream of NS3. The NS3 protein was also found to be internally cleaved. In this study, we demonstrated that internal cleavages occurred on the NS3 protein of genotype 1b in the presence of NS4A, both in culture cells and with a mouse model system. No internal cleavage products were detected with the NS3 and NS4A proteins of genotype 2a. Three potential cleavage sites were detected in the NS3 protein (genotype 1b), with IPT(402)|S being the major one. The internal cleavage requires the polyprotein processing activity of NS3 protease, but when supplemented in trans, the internal cleavage efficiency is reduced. In addition, several mutations in NS4A disrupted the internal cleavage of NS3 but did not affect polyprotein processing, indicating that NS4A contributes differently to these two proteolytic activities. Furthermore, Ile-25, Val-26, and Ile-29 of the NS4A protein, important for the NS4A-dependent internal cleavages, were also shown to be critical for the transforming activity of NS3, but mutations at these critical residues resulted only in a slight increase of HCV replicating efficiency. The internal cleavage-associated enhancement of the transforming activity of NS3 was reduced when a T402A substitution at the major internal cleavage site was introduced. The multiple roles of NS4A in viral multiplication and pathogenesis make NS4A an ideal molecular target for HCV therapy.     

Sumoylation-promoted enterovirus 71 3C degradation correlates with a reduction in viral replication and cell apoptosis

Enterovirus 71 (EV71), a member of the Picornaviridae family, may cause serious clinical manifestations associated with the central nervous system. Enterovirus 3C protease is required for virus replication and can trigger host cell apoptosis via cleaving viral polyprotein precursor and cellular proteins, respectively. Although the role of the 3C protease in processing viral and cellular proteins has been established, very little is known about the modulation of EV71 3C function by host cellular factors. Here, we show that sumoylation promotes EV71 3C protein ubiquitination for degradation, correlating with a decrease of EV71 in virus replication and cell apoptosis. SUMO E2-conjugating enzyme Ubc9 was identified as an EV71 3C-interacting protein. Further studies revealed that EV71 3C can be SUMO (small ubiquitin-like modifier)-modified at residue Lys-52. Sumoylation down-regulated 3C protease activity in vitro and also 3C protein stability in cells, in agreement with data suggesting 3C K52R protein induced greater substrate cleavage and apoptosis in cells. More importantly, the recombinant EV71 3C K52R virus infection conferred more apoptotic phenotype and increased virus levels in culture cells, which also correlated with a mouse model showing increased levels of viral VP1 protein in intestine and neuron loss in the spinal cord with EV71 3C K52R recombinant viral infection. Finally, we show that EV71 3C amino acid residues 45-52 involved in Ubc9 interaction determined the extent of 3C sumoylation and protein stability. Our results uncover a previously undescribed cellular regulatory event against EV71 virus replication and host cell apoptosis by sumoylation at 3C protease.