A meta-analytical test of elevated CO2 effects on plant respiration

Contrasting results regarding elevated CO₂ effects on leafdark respiration (Rd) have hampered efforts to incorporate this importantcomponent of the plant carbon budget into long-term predictions of ecologicalresponses to rising atmospheric CO₂. To help resolve some of theseinconsistencies in the literature, we used meta-analysis to quantitativelysummarize 45 area-based leaf Rd (Rd_a) and 44 mass-based leaf Rd(Rd_m) observations from independent studies on 33 species. Ouranalysis showed that across all studies, leaf Rd_m was significantlyreduced (–18%, P < 0.05), while leaf Rd_a was marginallyincreased (+8%, P < 0.15), under elevated CO₂. There weresignificant differences among categorical groups in CO₂ effects onleaf Rd_a and Rd_m. For example, leaf Rd_a ofherbaceous species increased 28%, but leaf Rd_a of woody speciesremained unchanged under elevated CO₂. Plants exposed to elevatedCO₂ for < 60 days had significantly higher leaf Rd_a atelevated compared to ambient CO₂, while plants exposed to elevatedCO₂ for longer period of time showed no response. The magnitude ofreduction in leaf Rd_m for plants exposed to elevated CO₂for > 100 days was significantly greater than that for plants exposed toelevated CO₂ for < 100 days. Our meta-analysis of publishedresults suggest that the amount of carbon loss through leaf Rd will likelyincrease in a higher CO₂ environment because of higher leafRd_a and a proportionally greater leaf biomass increase than leafRd_m reduction at elevated CO₂. Our results alsodemonstrated the strong dependency of Rd responses to elevated CO₂onexperimental conditions.     

Effects of elevated CO2 on five plant-aphid interactions

We investigated interactions between five species of phloem-feeding aphids (Homoptera: Aphididae) and their host plants at elevated CO₂; Acyrthosiphon pisum (Harris) on Vicia faba L., Aphis nerii Boyer de Fonscolombe on Asclepias syriaca L., Aphis oenotherae Oestlund on Oenothera biennis L., Aulacorthum solani (Kaltenbach) on Nicotiana sylvestris Speg. & Comes and Myzus persicae (Sulzer) on Solanum dulcamara L. Host plants grown at elevated CO₂ generally had greater biomass, leaf area and C:N ratios than those grown at ambient CO₂, while plants with aphids had lower biomass and leaf area than those without aphids.The responses of aphid populations to elevated CO₂ were species-specific with one species increasing (M. persicae), one decreasing (A. pisum), and the other three being unaffected. CO₂ treatment did not affect the proportion of alate individuals produced. In general, aphid abundance was not significantly related to foliar nitrogen concentration.We performed separate analyses to test whether either aphid presence or aphid abundance modified the response of host plants to elevated CO₂. In terms of aphid presence, only three of the potential 15 interactions (five aphid species x three plant traits) were significant; A. solani slightly modified the response of the plant biomass to elevated CO₂ and M. persicae affected the response of leaf area and allocation. In terms of aphid abundance, only two of the potential 15 interactions were significant with A. nerii modifying the plant response to CO₂ in terms of total leaf area and allocation.We conclude that, in contrast to other insect groups such as leaf chewers, populations of most phloem-feeders may not be negatively affected by increased CO₂ concentrations in the future. The reasons for this difference include the possibility that aphids may be able to compensate for changes in host plant quality by altering feeding behaviour or by synthesizing amino acids. In addition, there is little evidence that aphid herbivory, even at high levels, will substantially modify the response of plants to elevated CO₂.     

Transgenerational effects of global environmental change: long-term CO2 and nitrogen treatments influence offspring growth response to elevated CO2

Global environmental changes can have immediate impacts on plant growth, physiology, and phenology. Long-term effects that are only observable after one or more generations are also likely to occur. These transgenerational effects can result either from maternal environmental effects or from evolutionary responses to novel selection pressures and are important because they may alter the ultimate ecological impact of the environmental change. Here, we show that transgenerational effects of atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO₂) and soil nitrogen (N) treatments influence the magnitude of plant growth responses to elevated CO₂ (eCO₂). We collected seeds from Lupinus perennis, Poa pratensis, and Schizachyrium scoparium populations that had experienced five growing seasons of ambient CO₂ (aCO₂) or eCO₂ treatments and ambient or increased N deposition and planted these seeds into aCO₂ or eCO₂ environments. We found that the offspring eCO₂ treatments stimulated immediate increases in L. perennis and P. pratensis growth and that the maternal CO₂ environment influenced the magnitude of this growth response for L. perennis: biomass responses of offspring from the eCO₂ maternal treatments were only 54% that of the offspring from the aCO₂ maternal treatments. Similar trends were observed for P. pratensis and S. scoparium. We detected some evidence that long-term N treatments also altered growth responses to eCO₂; offspring reared from seed from maternal N-addition treatments tended to show greater positive growth responses to eCO₂ than offspring from ambient N maternal treatments. However, the effects of long-term N treatments on offspring survival showed the opposite pattern. Combined, our results suggest that transgenerational effects of eCO₂ and N-addition may influence the growth stimulation effects of eCO₂, potentially altering the long-term impacts of eCO₂ on plant populations.     

大气CO2浓度升高对植物根系的影响

植物长期生长在CO2浓度不断升高的环境中,其结构和功能都将受到影响,这种影响不仅表现在植物的地上部分,同时也表现在植物的地下部分(根系),尤其是细根的长度、直径、产量、周转以及根与枝的分配模式等方面。植物根系结构和功能的改变影响植物地上部分和生态系统物质循环中的碳动态及土壤中碳库的变化。目前有关大气CO2浓度升高对根系动态影响的研究报道主要包括大气CO2浓度升高对根系结构(直径、分枝、长度、数量等)和根系生理(周转率、产量、碳分配模式等)的影响2个方面。目前,该领域研究还存在一些不足,例如在CO2浓度升高条件下,对植物根系内部的调控机制,以及由其引起的物质循环和能量流动的动态变化的了解较少;至今没有令人信服的证据说明大气CO2浓度升高使根系周转升高还是降低。今后应加强研究在CO2浓度升高条件下根系的周转变化和光合产物分配模式变化,CO2浓度升高和外界环境因素的共同作用对根系的影响,以及采用不同研究方法和研究对象在不同立地条件下开展升高CO2浓度对根系影响的对比研究等。     

Combined effects of elevated CO2 and temperature on multitrophic interactions involving a parasitoid of plant virus vectors

BioControl - Atmospheric concentration of carbon dioxide (CO2) is predicted to double by late twenty-first century, likely increasing global temperature by 2.2&nbsp;°C. Elevated CO2 (eCO2)...     

The space‐time continuum: the effects of elevated CO2 and temperature on trees and the importance of scaling

To predict how forests will respond to rising temperatures and atmospheric CO₂ concentrations, we need to understand how trees respond to both of these environmental factors. In this review, we discuss the importance of scaling, moving from leaf‐level responses to those of the canopy, and from short‐term to long‐term responses of vegetation to climate change. While our knowledge of leaf‐level, instantaneous responses of photosynthesis, respiration, stomatal conductance, transpiration and water‐use efficiency to elevated CO₂ and temperature is quite good, our ability to scale these responses up to larger spatial and temporal scales is less developed. We highlight which physiological processes are least understood at various levels of study, and discuss how ignoring differences in the spatial or temporal scale of a physiological process impedes our ability to predict how forest carbon and water fluxes forests will be altered in the future. We also synthesize data from the literature to show that light respiration follows a generalized temperature response across studies, and that the light compensation point of photosynthesis is reduced by elevated growth CO₂. Lastly, we emphasize the need to move beyond single factorial experiments whenever possible, and to combine both CO₂ and temperature treatments in studies of tree performance.     

The impact of elevated CO2 on plant-herbivore interactions: experimental evidence of moderating effects at the community level

Surprisingly little research has been published on the responses to elevated [CO₂] at the community level, where herbivores can select their preferred food. We investigated the combined effects of atmospheric [CO₂] and herbivory on synthesised plant communities growing on soils of different fertility. Factorial combinations of two [CO₂] (350 or 700 l l⁻¹), two fertility (fertilised or non-fertilised), and two herbivory (herbivores present or absent) treatments were applied to a standard mixture of seven fast- and eight slow-growing plants in outdoor microcosms. The herbivores used were the grain aphid (Sitobion avenae) and the garden snail (Helix aspersa). We measured plant biomass, foliar nitrogen and soluble tannin concentration, aphid fecundity, and snail growth, fecundity, and feeding preferences over one growing season. Elevated [CO₂] did not have a significant impact on (1) the combined biomass of fast-growing or slow-growing plants, (2) herbivore feeding preferences, or (3) herbivore fitness. There was, however, a significant biomass increase of Carex flacca (which represented in all cases less than 5% of total live biomass), and some chemical changes in unpalatable plants under elevated [CO₂]. The herbivory treatment significantly increased the biomass of slow-growing plants over fast-growing plants, whereas fertilisation significantly increased the abundance of fast-growing plants over slow-growing plants. Predictions on the effects of elevated [CO₂] based on published single-species experiments were not supported by the results of this microcosm study. Received: 30 November 1997 / Accepted: 24 July 1998     

CO_2浓度升高对水体硝化、反硝化作用的影响研究进展

大气CO_2浓度升高潜移默化地影响着水体生态系统的碳循环过程.然而,该过程如何影响与其耦合的氮循环过程仍不明确.水体硝化、反硝化过程作为水体氮循环的重要环节,必然会对大气CO_2浓度升高产生一系列的响应.本文总结了国内外关于大气CO_2浓度升高对水体理化性质、硝化作用、反硝化作用及N形态转化影响方面的研究工作,发现大气CO_2浓度升高会降低水体的p H,增加水中CO_2和HCO_3^-含量,但对富营养化与寡营养化水体中硝化、反硝化作用的影响具有明显差异.大气CO_2浓度升高抑制寡营养化水体的硝化作用和反硝化作用,降低N2_O的释放通量,抑制富营养化水体的硝化作用,但当水体pH在7～9时,可能促进反硝化作用,增加N2_O的释放通量,最终可能导致水体中NH_4^+的积累及NO_3^-浓度的降低,影响水体中微生物的多样性.在此基础上提出目前相关研究存在的瓶颈问题及值得深入探讨的科学问题,为进一步深入理解温室效应背景下全球CO_2浓度升高对水体生态系统N循环的影响提供参考.     

Interactive effects of elevated carbon dioxide and environmental stresses on root mass fraction in plants: a meta-analytical synthesis using pairwise techniques

Rising atmospheric CO₂ greatly enhances plant production, but its effect on biomass allocation, particularly in the presence of environmental stresses, is not well understood. Here, we used meta-analysis combined with pairwise techniques to examine root mass fraction (RMF; i.e., the fraction of root to total biomass) as affected by elevated CO₂ and environmental stresses. Our results showed that lower soil fertility increased RMF and the magnitude was similar for ambient and elevated CO₂-grown plants. Lower soil water also increased RMF, but to a greater extent at elevated than at ambient CO₂. While CO₂ enrichment had little effect on the magnitude of O₃-caused reduction in RMF in herbaceous species, it alleviated the adverse effect of higher O₃ on root production in woody species. These results demonstrate that CO₂ has less pronounced effects on RMF than other environmental factors. Under abiotic stresses, e.g., drought and higher O₃, elevated CO₂-grown plants will likely increase biomass allocation below-ground. Because of the non-uniform changes in drought and O₃ projected for different parts of the world, we conclude that elevated CO₂ will have regional, but not global, effects on biomass allocation under various global change scenarios.     

Plant water relations and the effects of elevated CO2: a review and suggestions for future research

Increased ambient carbon dioxide (CO₂) has been found to ameliorate water stress in the majority of species studied. The results of many studies indicate that lower evaporative flux density is associated with high CO₂-induced stomatal closure. As a result of decreases in evaporative flux density and increases in net photosynthesis, also found to occur in high CO₂ environments, plants have often been shown to maintain higher water use efficiencies when grown at high CO₂ than when grown in normal, ambient air. Plants grown at high CO₂ have also been found to maintain higher total water potentials, to increase biomass production, have larger root-to-shoot ratios, and to be generally more drought resistant (through avoidance mechanisms) than those grown at ambient CO₂ levels. High CO₂-induced changes in plant structure (i.e., vessel or tracheid anatomy, leaf specific conductivity) may be associated with changes in vulnerability to xylem cavitation or in environmental conditions in which runaway embolism is likely to occur. Further study is needed to resolve these important issues. Methodology and other CO₂ effects on plant water relations are discussed.Abbreviations A net photosynthesis - C_a ambient [CO₂] - C_i internal [CO₂] - E evaporative flux density - g₁ leaf conductance - g_s stomatal conductance - LSC leaf specific conductivity - IRGA infrared gas analyzer - LAI leaf area index - PAR photosynthetically active radiation - total plant water potential - _soil soil water potential - _s solute potential - _pt turgor pressure potential - _px xylem pressure potential - RH relative humidity - R : S root to shoot ratio - RWC relative water content - SLA specific leaf area - SLW specific leaf weight - SPAC soil-plant-atmosphere-continuum - SWC soil water content - VPD vapor pressure deficit - WUE water use efficiency     

The physiological and molecular effects of elevated CO2 levels

Carbon dioxide (CO₂) is an end product of cellular respiration, a process by which organisms including all plants, animals, many fungi and some bacteria obtain energy¹. CO₂ has several physiologic roles in respiration, pH buffering, autoregulation of the blood supply and others². Here we review recent findings from studies in mammalian lung cells, Caenorhabditis elegans and Drosophila melanogaster that help shed light on the molecular sensing and response to hypercapnia.     

Non-litter effects of elevated CO2 on forest floor microarthropod abundances

The arthropod assemblages of the litter and soil play significant roles in decomposition and nutrient cycling. At the FACE (Free-Air CO₂ Enrichment) site at the Duke Forest, we assessed the responses of the litter microarthropod assemblage to elevated CO₂ (200 ppm above ambient) in a loblolly pine plantation. Following the initiation of the elevated CO₂ treatment, a trend toward lower microarthropod abundance under elevated CO₂ emerged. After 18 months, the mean microarthropod abundance was 33% lower in the elevated treatment (P=0.04). The decline was evident in all microarthropod groups, but was significant only in the oribatid mites (P=0.04). Because these responses precede any changes in litter quality resulting from the CO₂ treatment, they may reflect plant-derived changes in the soil that are being conveyed into the litter layer.     

The effects of chamber pressurization on soil-surface CO2 flux and the implications for NEE measurements under elevated CO2

Soil and ecosystem trace gas fluxes are commonly measured using the dynamic chamber technique. Although the chamber pressure anomalies associated with this method are known to be a source of error, their effects have not been fully characterized. In this study, we use results from soil gas-exchange experiments and a soil CO₂ transport model to characterize the effects of chamber pressure on soil CO₂ efflux in an annual California grassland. For greater than ambient chamber pressures, experimental data show that soil-surface CO₂ flux decreases as a nonlinear function of increasing chamber pressure; this decrease is larger for drier soils. In dry soil, a gauge pressure of 0.5 Pa reduced the measured soil CO₂ efflux by roughly 70% relative to the control measurement at ambient pressure. Results from the soil CO₂ transport model show that pressurizing the flux chamber above ambient pressure effectively flushes CO₂ from the soil by generating a downward flow of air through the soil air-filled pore space. This advective flow of air reduces the CO₂ concentration gradient across the soil–atmosphere interface, resulting in a smaller diffusive flux into the chamber head space. Simulations also show that the reduction in diffusive flux is a function of chamber pressure, soil moisture, soil texture, the depth distribution of soil CO₂ generation, and chamber diameter. These results highlight the need for caution in the interpretation of dynamic chamber trace gas flux measurements. A portion of the frequently observed increase in net ecosystem carbon uptake under elevated CO₂ may be an artifact resulting from the impact of chamber pressurization on soil CO₂ efflux.     

A meta-analysis of elevated CO2 effects on woody plant mass, form, and physiology

Quantitative integration of the literature on the effect of elevated CO₂ on woody plants is important to aid our understanding of forest health in coming decades and to better predict terrestrial feedbacks on the global carbon cycle. We used meta-analytic methods to summarize and interpret more than 500 reports of effects of elevated CO₂ on woody plant biomass accumulation and partitioning, gas exchange, and leaf nitrogen and starch content. The CO₂ effect size metric we used was the log-transformed ratio of elevated compared to ambient response means weighted by the inverse of the variance of the log ratio. Variation in effect size among studies was partitioned according to the presence of interacting stress factors, length of CO₂ exposure, functional group status, pot size, and type of CO₂ exposure facility. Both total biomass (W _T) and net CO₂ assimilation (A) increased significantly at about twice ambient CO₂, regardless of growth conditions. Low soil nutrient availability reduced the CO₂ stimulation of W _T by half, from +31% under optimal conditions to +16%, while low light increased the response to +52%. We found no significant shifts in biomass allocation under high CO₂. Interacting stress factors had no effect on the magnitude of responses of A to CO₂, although plants grown in growth chambers had significantly lower responses (+19%) than those grown in greenhouses or in open-top chambers (+54%). We found no consistent evidence for photosynthetic acclimation to CO₂ enrichment except in trees grown in pots <0.5 l (−36%) and no significant CO₂ effect on stomatal conductance. Both leaf dark respiration and leaf nitrogen were significantly reduced under elevated CO₂ (−18% and −16% respectively, data expressed on a leaf mass basis), while leaf starch content increased significantly except in low nutrient grown gymnosperms. Our results provide robust, statistically defensible estimates of elevated CO₂ effect sizes against which new results may be compared or for use in forest and climate model parameterization. Received: 16 May 1997 / Accepted: 9 September 1997     

Interactive effects of elevated CO2 and temperature on water transport inponderosa pine

Many studies report that water flux through trees declines in response to elevated CO₂, but this response may be modified by exposure to increased temperatures. To determine whether elevated CO₂ and temperature interact to affect hydraulic conductivity, we grew ponderosa pine seedlings for 24 wk in growth chambers with one of four atmospheric CO₂ concentrations (350, 550, 750, and 1100 ppm) and either a low (15°C nights, 25°C days) or high (20°C nights, 30°C days) temperature treatment. Vapor pressure deficits were also higher in the elevated temperature treatment. Seedling biomass increased with CO₂ concentration but was not affected by temperature. Root : shoot ratio was unaffected by CO₂ and temperature. Leaf : sapwood area ratio (A_L/A_S) declined in response to elevated temperature but was not influenced by CO₂. Larger tracheid diameters at elevated temperature caused an increase in xylem-specific hydraulic conductivity (K_S). The increase in K_S and decrease in A_L/A_S led to higher leaf-specific hydraulic conductivity (K_L) at elevated temperature. Stomatal conductance (g_S) was correlated with K_L across all treatments. Neither K_S, K_L, nor g_S were affected by elevated CO₂ concentrations. High K_L in response to elevated temperature may support increased transpiration or reduce the incidence of xylem cavitation in ponderosa pine in future, warmer climates.     

开放式空气CO2浓度增高对土壤线虫影响的研究现状与展望

大气CO2浓度增高会对生态系统产生一系列的影响,这些影响在某种程度上受到土壤动物区系的调节,本文通过论述大气CO2浓度增高对不同类型土壤中和不同生态系统中土壤线虫产生的影响,阐明了用土壤线虫作为指示生物来研究生态系统变化的意义,并提出了今后针对大气CO2浓度增高这一现象应着重围绕土壤线虫及土壤动物系优先开展的几方面研究,从而更好地指示整个生态系统的变化情况,为有效地管理农田生态系统提供依据。     

Effects of elevated CO2 and plant genotype on interactions among cotton,aphids and parasitoids

Abstract Effects of CO₂ level (ambient vs. elevated) on the interactions among three cotton (Gossypium hirsutum) genotypes, the cotton aphid (Aphis gossypii Glover), and its hymenoptera parasitoid (Lysiphlebia japonica Ashrnead) were quantified. It was hypothesized that aphid‐parasitoid interactions in crop systems may be altered by elevated CO₂, and that the degree of change is influenced by plant genotype. The cotton genotypes had high (M9101), medium (HZ401) and low (ZMS13) gossypol contents, and the response to elevated CO₂ was genotype‐specific. Elevated CO₂ increased the ratio of total non‐structural carbohydrates to nitrogen (TNC: N) in the high‐gossypol genotype and the medium‐gossypol genotype. For all three genotypes, elevated CO₂ had no effect on concentrations of gossypol and condensed tannins. A. gossypii fitness declined when aphids were reared on the high‐gossypol genotype versus the low‐gossypol genotype under elevated CO₂. Furthermore, elevated CO₂ decreased the developmental time of L. japonica associated with the high‐gossypol genotype and the low‐gossypol genotype, but did not affect parasitism or emergence rates. Our study suggests that the abundance of A. gossypii on cotton will not be directly affected by increases in atmospheric CO₂. We speculate that A. gossypii may diminish in pest status in elevated CO₂ and high‐gossypol genotype environments because of reduced fitness to the high‐gossypol genotype and shorter developmental time of L. japonica.     

Increasing CO2 and plant-plant interactions: effects on natural vegetation

Plant species and functional groups of species show marked differences in photosynthesis and growth in relation to rising atmospheric CO₂ concentrations through the range of the 30 % increase of the recent past and the 100 % increase since the last glaciation. A large shift was found in the compositional mix of 26 species of C₃'s and 17 species of C₄'s grown from a native soil seed bank in a competitive mode along a CO₂ gradient that approximated the CO₂ increase of the past 150 years and before. The biomass of C₃'s increased from near zero to 50 % of the total while that of the C₄'s was reduced 25 % as CO₂ levels approached current ambient. The proposition that acclimation to rising CO₂ will largely negate the fertilization effect of higher CO₂ levels on C₃'s is not supported. No signs of photosynthetic acclimation were evident forAvena sativa, Prosopis glandulosa, andSchizachyrium scoparium plants grown in subambient CO₂. The effects of changing CO₂ levels on vegetation since the last glaciation are thought to have been at least as great, if not greater, than those which should be expected for a doubling of current CO₂ levels. Atmospheric CO₂ concentrations below 200 ppm are thought to have been instrumental in the rise of the C₄ grasslands of North America and other extensive C₄ grasslands and savannas of the world. Dramatic invasion of these areas by woody C₃ species are accompanying the historical increase in atmospheric CO₂ concentration now in progress.     

Cladode development, environmental responses of CO2 uptake, and productivity for Opuntia ficus-indica under elevated CO2

Opuntia ficus-indica, an extremely productive CAM plant cultivatedin many countries, was exposed to 36, 52, and 72–73 PaCO₂ in field plots and open-top chambers. Initiation of newcladodes (stem segments) was monitored until the canopy closed,after which bimonthly harvests maintained the plants for oneyear at a cladode area per unit ground area that is optimalfor biomass production. Doubling the CO₂ partial pressure slightlyincreased the number of first-order daughter cladodes growingon the basal (planted) cladodes after 3 months and nearly doubledthe number and area of second-order cladodes. When the C02 levelwas doubled, cladodes were 5% thicker after a few months and11 to 16% thicker after one year. Although the productivityenhancement by elevated C02 tended to decrease during the year,the annual above-ground dry-mass gain was 37 to 40% higher whenthe C02 level was doubled, reaching 65 tons hectare^–1year^–1 in a field plot. Well-watered cladodes at day/nightair temperatures of 25°C/15°C and a total daily photosyntheticphoton flux (PPF) of 15 mol m^–2 d^–1 in controlledenvironment chambers had 74% more net CO₂ uptake over 24 h at73 Pa than at 37 Pa CO₂. With doubled CO₂, the percentage enhancementof net CO₂ uptake increased as the PPF was lowered, as the temperaturewas raised, and during drought. Using an environmental productivityindex based on such factors, net CO₂ uptake and hence productivityof O. ficus-indica can be predicted for elevated CO₂ levelsand other variations accompanying global climate change. Key words: Crassulacean acid metabolism, environmental productivity index, gas exchange, global climate change, plant growth