A study of staining for electron microscopy using collagen as a model system—VII. The effect of formaldehyde fixation

Exposure to formaldehyde brings about small but readily detectable changes in the staining behaviour of collagen fibrils. These changes can be interpreted in chemical terms by comparing fibril staining patterns with artificial patterns computer-generated from sequence data. Positive staining with phosphotung-state (where heavy metal is confined to anions), shows that most of the lysyl and hydroxylysyl side-chains lose their charge character as a result of formaldehyde treatment and cease to take up staining ions. The charge character of arginyl (and probably histidyl) residues is unaltered and these residues continue to react with stain. Acidic residues are also unaffected. These results accord with biochemical evidence that the initial reaction between proteins and formaldehyde leading to subsequent cross-linking involves modification of ε-amino (and α-amino) groups. They show too that the secondary condensation producing the actual cross-link does not alter the charge character of the second group, at least when it is on an arginyl (or histidyl) side-chain.Formaldehyde-induced changes in stain deposition can also be detected after negative staining, although they are slight compared with those brought about by glutaraldehyde. Unlike glutaraldehyde, formaldehyde introduces no bulky polymeric adducts into the fibril structure, and the conspicuous stain-excluding bands seen in negative staining patterns following glutaraldehyde fixation are absent after exposure to formaldehyde. For this reason, where chemical fixation is used to stabilize macromolecules and supramolecular aggregates prior to negative staining and high resolution electron optical imaging, formaldehyde would seem to be preferable to glutaraldehyde. Data from fibril staining patterns and from thermal stability measurements (made on collagen gels) show that formaldehyde fixation does not preclude a subsequent reaction with glutaraldehyde.As with other fixatives, there is reduced accessibility to stain after formaldehyde treatment. Accessibility is least in the overlap zone where the denser packing of collagen molecules provides greater opportunities for intermolecular cross-linking. Gel electrophoresis confirms that formaldehyde-induced cross-links in fibrils are predominantly intermolecular.     

Interpretation of the meridional X-ray diffraction pattern from collagen fibrils in corneal stroma

The low angle X-ray diffraction pattern from corneal stroma can be interpreted as arising from the equivalent of sharp meridional reflections due to the packing of molecules along the collagen fibrils and an equatorial pattern due to the packing of these fibrils within lamellae.Axial electron density profiles for corneal collagen fibrils have been produced by combining intensity data from the meridional pattern with two independent sets of phases. The first set was obtained using an electron microscopical technique, whereas the second set consisted of calculated tendon collagen phases given in the literature. Substantial agreement between the two electron density profiles was found.A quantitative analysis of the difference between the electron density profiles of rat tail tendon and corneal collagen showed that the step between the gap and overlap regions is smaller in cornea than in tendon. This is probably due to the binding of non-collagenous material in the gap region as occurs in bone and other tissue. Two peaks corresponding to regions where electron density is greater in the cornea are situated at the gap/overlap junctions. A third region where the corneal collagen is more electron dense is located near the centre of the gap region. The proximity of these peaks to the positions of hydroxylysine residues along the fibril axis suggests that they may be the major sites at which sugars are bound to corneal collagen.     

Phasing the meridional diffraction pattern of type I collagen using isomorphous derivatives

The meridional X-ray diffraction pattern of wet rat tail tendon contains information about the one-dimensional structure, or axial projection of electron density distribution of the type I collagen fibril. Using synchrotron radiation we have determined the intensities of the first 50 meridional X-ray diffraction reflections. The approach of isomorphous addition with reagents, selected using criteria of chemical reactivity, which label at fewer sites than the stains used in previous studies was applied to phase these 50 reflections to produce a one-dimensional electron density distribution map of a single D-repeat of the collagen fibril. This method is not model-dependent and thus constitutes the first unambiguous determination of the meridional phases of type I collagen.     

Structural study of the calcifying collagen in turkey leg tendons

The calcified turkey leg tendon represents a simple bone-like tissue that is ideally suited to analysis by diffraction methods. In this paper we report some structural studies of the tendon collagen in the uncalcified, fully calcified and partially calcified states. The low-angle meridional X-ray pattern from the uncalcified tendon is very similar to that of the rat tail tendon, and the resulting one-dimensional structure of the collagen fibril exhibits no feature that could be related to its eventual calcification. The structure of the fully calcified tendon, as determined by a combination of X-ray and neutron diffraction analyses, shows that the mineral is associated with the collagen at the level of the hole or gap region. In the calcifying tendon, increases in the amplitudes of the first and second X-ray meridional reflections are correlated with an increase in the mineral content of the collagen. On the basis of simple models, it is shown that this change in the pattern can be explained by a nucleation mechanism of calcification. It is concluded that when collagen becomes calcified the mineral penetrates throughout the fibril and is crystalline in the hole region but amorphous between the collagen molecules. The mechanism of calcification and the mechanical implications of the fully calcified structure are also discussed.     

Variations in collagen fibril structure in tendons

Variation of collagen fibril structure in tendon was investigated by x-ray diffraction. Anatomically distinct tendons from single species, as well as tendons from different species, were examined to determine the variations that exist in both the axial and lateral structure of the collagen fibrils. The meridional diffraction is derived from the axial collagen fibril structure. Anatomically distinct tendons of a particular species give meridional patterns that are indistinguishable within experimental error. The meridional diffraction patterns from tendons of different mammals are similar but show small species-specific variations, most noticeably in the 14th–18th orders. Tendons of birds also give meridional patterns that are similar to each other, but the avian patterns differ considerably from the mammalian ones. Avian tendons give stronger odd and weaker even low orders, a feature consistent with a reduced gap:overlap ratio, and have a distinctive intensity pattern for the higher meridional orders. Interpretation of these differences has been approached using biochemical data, diffraction by reconsituted fibers of purified collagen, and Fourier transform analysis. From these methods, it appears that the variations observed in the lower orders (2nd–8th) and in the higher orders (29th–52nd) are probably related to differences in the primary structure of the Type I collagen found in the different species. The variations observed in the 14th–18th orders appear not to be related to features within the triple-helical domain of the molecule. Equatorial diffraction yields information on the lateral packing of collagen molecules in the fibrils, and considerable variation was seen in different tendons. Rat tail tendon gives sharp Bragg reflections, demonstrating the presence of a crystalline lateral arrangement of molecules in the fibril. For the first time, sharp lattice reflections similar to those in rat tail tendon have been observed in nontail tendons, including rat achilles tendon, rabbit leg tendon, and wing and leg tendons of quail. In the rabbit and quail tendons, one of the strong equatorial reflections characteristic of the rat tendon pattern, at 1.26 nm, was absent. The positions of the equatorial maxima, which are a measure of intermolecular spacing, varied considerably, being smallest in the specimens displaying crystalline packing. The intermolecular distance in chiken and turkey leg tendons is longer than that found in mammalian tendons, or in avian wing tendons, which supports the hypothesis that a larger intermolecular spacing is characteristic of tendons that calcify. Thus, x-ray diffraction indicates there are reproducible differences in both the axial and lateral structure of collagen fibrils among different tendons. This work on tendon, a tissue containing almost exclusively Type I collagen as its major component, should serve as a basis for analyzing the structure of other connective tissues, which contain different genetic types of collagen and larger amounts of noncollagenous components.     

Structure of type I and type III heterotypic collagen fibrils: an X-ray diffraction study

The molecular packing arrangement within collagen fibrils has a significant effect on the tensile properties of tissues. To date, most studies have focused on homotypic fibrils composed of type I collagen. This study investigates the packing of type I/III collagen molecules in heterotypic fibrils of colonic submucosa using a combination of X-ray diffraction data, molecular model building, and simulated X-ray diffraction fibre diagrams. A model comprising a 70-nm-diameter D- (approximately 65 nm) axial periodic structure containing type I and type III collagen chains was constructed from amino acid scattering factors organised in a liquid-like lateral packing arrangement simulated using a classical Lennard-Jones potential. The models that gave the most accurate correspondence with diffraction data revealed that the structure of the fibril involves liquid-like lateral packing combined with a constant helical inclination angle for molecules throughout the fibril. Combinations of type I:type III scattering factors in a ratio of 4:1 gave a reasonable correspondence with the meridional diffraction series. The attenuation of the meridional intensities may be explained by a blurring of the electron density profile of the D period caused by nonspecific or random interactions between collagen types I and III in the heterotypic fibril.     

Crystalline fibril structure of type II collagen in lamprey notochord sheath

We report here the existence of a crystalline molecular packing of type II collagen in the fibrils of the lamprey notochord sheath. This is the first finding of a crystalline structure in any collagen other than type I.The lamprey notochord sheath has a composition similar to that of cartilage, with type II collagen, a minor collagen component with 1α, 2α and 3α chains, and cartilage-like proteoglycan. The high degree of orientation of fibrils in the notochord makes it possible to use X-ray diffraction to determine collagen fibril organization in this type II-containing tissue. The low angle equatorial scattering shows the fibrils are all about 17 nm in diameter and have an average center-to-center separation of 31 nm. These results are supported by electron microscope observations. A set of broad equatorial diffraction maxima at higher angles represents the sampling of the collagen molecular transform by a limited crystalline lattice, extending over a lateral dimension close to the diameter of one fibril. This indicates that each 17 nm fibril contains a crystalline array of molecules and, although a unit cell is difficult to determine because of the broad overlapping reflections, it is clear that the quasi-hexagonal triclinic unit cell of type I collagen in rat tail tendon is not consistent with the data. The meridional diffraction pattern showed 26 orders with the characteristic 67 nm periodicity found for tendon. However, the intensities of these reflections differ markedly from those found for tendon and cannot be explained by an unmodified gap/ overlap model within each 67 nm period. Both X-ray diffraction and electron microscope data indicate a low degree of contrast along the fibril axis and are consistent with a periodic binding of a non-collagenous component in such a way as to obscure the gap region.     

The in situ supermolecular structure of type I collagen.

BACKGROUND: The proteins belonging to the collagen family are ubiquitous throughout the animal kingdom. The most abundant collagen, type I, readily forms fibrils that convey the principal mechanical support and structural organization in the extracellular matrix of connective tissues such as bone, skin, tendon, and vasculature. An understanding of the molecular arrangement of collagen in fibrils is essential since it relates molecular interactions to the mechanical strength of fibrous tissues and may reveal the underlying molecular pathology of numerous connective tissue diseases. RESULTS: Using synchrotron radiation, we have conducted a study of the native fibril structure at anisotropic resolution (5.4 A axial and 10 A lateral). The intensities of the tendon X-ray diffraction pattern that arise from the lateral packing (three-dimensional arrangement) of collagen molecules were measured by using a method analogous to Rietveld methods in powder crystallography and to the separation of closely spaced peaks in Laue diffraction patterns. These were then used to determine the packing structure of collagen by MIR. CONCLUSIONS: Our electron density map is the first obtained from a natural fiber using these techniques (more commonly applied to single crystal crystallography). It reveals the three-dimensional molecular packing arrangement of type I collagen and conclusively proves that the molecules are arranged on a quasihexagonal lattice. The molecular segments that contain the telopeptides (central to the function of collagen fibrils in health and disease) have been identified, revealing that they form a corrugated arrangement of crosslinked molecules that strengthen and stabilize the native fibril.     

The variability in type I collagen helical pitch is reflected in the D periodic fibrillar structure

The variability in amino acid axial rise per residue of the collagen helix is a potentially important parameter that is missing in many structural models of fibrillar collagen to date. The significance of this variability has been supported by evidence from collagen axial structures determined by electron microscopy and X-ray diffraction, as well as studies of the local sequence-dependent conformation of the collagen helix. Here, sequence-dependent variation of the axial rise per residue was used to improve the fit between simulated diffraction patterns derived from model structures of the axially projected microfibrillar structure and the observed X-ray diffraction pattern from hydrated rat tail tendon. Structural models were adjusted using a genetic algorithm that allowed a wide range of structures to be tested efficiently. The results show that variation of the axial rise per residue could reduce the difference metric between model and observed data by up to 50%, indicating that such a variable is a necessary part of fibril model structure building. The variation in amino acid translation was also found to be influenced by the number of proline and hydroxyproline residues in the triple helix structure.     

Molecular tilting in dried elastoidin and its implications for the structures of other collagen fibrils

Wet elastoidin spicules (fish fin rays) yield low-angle meridional X-ray diffraction patterns which resemble those from tendons. However, when the spicule dries the meridian splits into the arms of a diagonal cross (sometimes only one arm appears). Of the possible explanations we reject shearing of the axial arrangement of molecules but confirm tilting. We suggest that, in three dimensions, the molecules are tilted at angles which vary from 0 degrees at the centre to some maximum value at the surface of the spicule, resembling torsion of the array of molecules. Molecular tilting probably occurs in other collagen fibrils.     

Structure of corneal scar tissue: an X-ray diffraction study.

Full-thickness corneal wounds (2 mm diameter) were produced in rabbits at the Schepens Eye Research Institute, Boston. These wounds were allowed to heal for periods ranging from 3 weeks to 21 months. The scar tissue was examined using low- and wide-angle x-ray diffraction from which average values were calculated for 1) the center-to-center collagen fibril spacing, 2) the fibril diameter, 3) the collagen axial periodicity D, and 4) the intermolecular spacing within the collagen fibrils. Selected samples were processed for transmission electron microscopy. The results showed that the average spacing between collagen fibrils within the healing tissue remained slightly elevated after 21 months and there was a small increase in the fibril diameter. The collagen D-periodicity was unchanged. There was a significant drop in the intermolecular spacing in the scar tissues up to 6 weeks, but thereafter the spacing returned to normal. The first-order equatorial reflection in the low-angle pattern was visible after 3 weeks and became sharper and more intense with time, suggesting that, as healing progressed, the number of nearest neighbor fibrils increased and the distribution of nearest neighbor spacings reduced. This corresponded to the fibrils becoming more ordered although, even after 21 months, normal packing was not achieved. Ultrastructural changes in collagen fibril density measured from electron micrographs were consistent with the increased order of fibril packing measured by x-ray diffraction. The results suggest that collagen molecules have a normal axial and lateral arrangement within the fibrils of scar tissue. The gradual reduction in the spread of interfibrillar spacings may be related to the progressive decrease in the light scattered from the tissue as the wound heals.     

Axial electron density of human scleral collagen. Location of proteoglycans by x-ray diffraction.

The low angle meridional x-ray diffraction pattern from fresh human sclera was analyzed to ascertain if collagen-bound proteoglycans affect the axially-projected electron density distribution to the same extent as appears to occur in the cornea. The results showed that, unlike cornea, the electron density of the sclera is similar to that seen in rat tail tendon collagen. The proteoglycans were specifically stained using either Cuprolinic blue or Cupromeronic blue, both under critical electrolyte conditions. The tissue was then examined by electron microscopy and by low angle x-ray diffraction. The electron-optical observations suggested that proteoglycans associate with collagen near the d/e staining bands in the gap zone. A difference Fourier analysis from the x-ray results confirmed that these observations were not e.m. preparative artefacts and allowed a quantitative estimate to be made of the axial extent of the proteglycans in the wet tissue.     

Interpretation of the electron microscopical appearance of collagen fibrils from corneal stroma

The appearance in the electron microscope of mechanically-dispersed corneal collagen has been observed after positive staining with phosphotungstic acid and/or uranyl acetate and after negative staining with phosphotungstate ions. The distributions of positive stains (both cationic and anionic) were similar to those observed in other type I collagens (e.g. skin, tendon). A high correlation was found between charge density in the fibril and the distribution of charged amino acids predicted from the sequence of calf skin collagen. This correlation could be improved by including type III sequence data, suggesting the presence of 20% type III collagen within each fibril. Negative staining showed the usual collagen D-periodicity but without a clear gap/overlap structure. Detailed analysis revealed at least six sites where stain penetration was inhibited. Specific staining of glycosides using N,N,N′,N′-tetramethylethylenediamine(TEMED)-osmate suggested that these sites identify the covalent attachment of disaccharides to the collagen. Using synchroton X-ray diffraction from TEMED-osmate stained corneas we have determined the locations of the stain ions (and hence the glycosides) in the moist tissue. The results demonstrate that even though the detailed charge distribution and axial molecular packing in corneal collagen are similar to other type I collalgens, carbohydrate material, probably disaccharide, is attached at fairly regular intervals. This does not occur in other type I collagens. In particular, the presence of glycoside in the overlap region may play a role in producing the narrow uniform fibrils which are essential for the transparency of the cornea.     

New X-ray diffraction observations on vertebrate muscle: organisation of C-protein (MyBP-C) and troponin and evidence for unknown structures in the vertebrate A-band

Previous low-angle X-ray diffraction studies of various vertebrate skeletal muscles have shown the presence of two rich layer-line patterns, one from the myosin heads and based on a 429 A axial repeat, and one from actin filaments and based on a repeat of about 360-370 A. In addition, meridional intensities have been seen from C-protein (MyBP-C; at about 440 A and its higher orders) and troponin (at about 385 A and its orders). Using preparations of intact, relaxed, bony fish fin muscles and the ID-02 low-angle X-ray camera at the ESRF with a 10 m camera length we have now seen numerous, hitherto unreported, sampled, X-ray layer-lines many of which do not fit onto the previously observed repeats and which require interpretation. The new reflections all fall on the normal ("vertical") hexagonal lattice row-lines in the highly sampled, almost "crystalline", low-angle diffraction X-ray patterns from bony fish muscle, indicating that they all arise from the muscle A-band. However, they do not fall on a single axial repeat. In direct confirmation of our previous analysis, some of these new reflections are explained by the interaction in resting muscle between the N-terminal ends of myosin-bound C-protein molecules with adjacent actin filaments, possibly through the Pro-Ala-rich region. Other newly observed reflections lie on a much longer repeat, but they are most easily interpreted in terms of the arrangement of troponin on the actin filaments. If this is so, then the implication is that the actin filaments and their troponin complexes are systematically arranged in the fish muscle A-band lattice relative to the myosin head positions, and that these newly observed X-ray reflections, when fully analysed, will report on the shape and distribution of troponin molecules in the resting muscle A-band. The less certain contributions of titin and nebulin to these new reflections have also been tested and are described. Many of the new reflections do not appear to come from these known structures. There must be structural features of the A-band that have not yet been described.     

Interpretation of the small-angle X-ray diffraction of collagen in view of the primary structure of the alpha1 chain.

The small-angle X-ray diffraction pattern of collagen has been calculated using the sequence of the alpha 1 chain and a Hodge-Petruska scheme for the packing of the collagen molecules. The molecular stagger giving the best fit of calculated-to observed structure factors has been found to be 236 or 237 amino acid residues for three tendon collagens. But this result depends on the appoximation that the molecular conformation is uniform throughout the molecule. A comparison of the observed and calculated electron density profiles in axial projection leads to a corrected model, in which the COOH-terminal telopeptide is contracted in a way suggesting a saddle-shaped electron density distribution near the collagenase site.     

Preliminary X-ray crystallographic data on phospholipase C from Bacillus cereus.

Low-angle X-ray diffraction shows that, despite the well-defined regular axially projected structure, there is no long-range lateral order in the packing of molecules in native (undried) or dried elastoidin spicules from the fin rays of the spurhound Squalus acanthias. The equatorial intensity distribution of the X-ray diffraction pattern from native elastoidin indicates a molecular diameter of 1.1 nm and a packing fraction for the structure projected on to a plane perpendicular to the spicule (fibril) axis of 0.31 (the value for tendon is much higher at around 0.6). Density measurements support this interpretation. When the spicule dries the packing fraction increases to 0.43 but there is still no long-range order in the structure. The X-ray diffraction patterns provide no convincing evidence for any microfibrils or subfibrils in elastoidin. Gel electrophoresis shows that the three chains in the elastoidin molecule are identical. The low packing fraction for collagen molecules in elastoidin explains the difference in appearance between electron micrographs of negatively stained elastoidin and tendon collagen. In elastoidin, but not in tendon collagen, an appreciable proportion of the stain is able to penetrate between the collagen molecules.     

A study of staining for electron microscopy using collagen as a model system—VIII. Simulation of the negative staining pattern

Simulated negative staining patterns of collagen fibrils were prepared for visual display by a graphical procedure in which amino acid side-chains along the staggered molecules were weighted according to their stain-excluding capacity. The simulated patterns were then compared directly with electron-optical images of collagen fibrils negatively stained with sodium phosphotungstate or lithium tungstate. These visual comparisons confirm previous observations that satisfactory matching occurs when side-chains are weighted according to their ‘bulkiness’ (average cross-sectional area or ‘plumpness’). Optimal matching at the edges of the overlap zones occurred when a hairpin-like conformation was assumed for the N-terminal telopeptides and a condensed conformation for the hydrophobic part of the C-terminal telopeptides. The negative staining pattern is known to include some element of positive staining; visual matching suggests that this additional uptake of positive staining ions occurs predominantly in the more accessible gap zone in a fibril D-period. A slight mismatching between observed and simulated patterns can be understood if the gap zone suffers greater axial shrinkage than the overlap zone when specimens are prepared for electron microscopy.     

Benzo[a]pyrene-collagen interactions

In vitro interactions of benzo[a]pyrene (BaP) with acid-soluble type I collagen from rat tail tendon have been investigated. The fluorescence of BaP increases in the presence of collagen. Bound BaP inhibits the formation of collagen fibrils in solution. When BaP-collagen complexes are irradiated in air with UV (365 nm) light, BaP rapidly undergoes photooxidation with the further inhibition of fibril formation. Viscosity and circular dichroism (CD) studies show that neither BaP nor further UV-irradiation alters the size or helical conformation of the protein. During thermal denaturation of collagen, BaP fluorescence changes. Collagen from young rat tail tendon shows a pronounced drop at about 38 degrees C, whereas that from old rat tail tendon exhibits an increase with a plateau in the same temperature range. These anomalous changes are observed when tyrosine residues, present only in the non-helical terminal telopeptides of collagen, are excited at 275 nm, but not by direct BaP excitation at 387 nm. These findings suggest that the specific hydrophobic telopeptide region, which plays an important role in fibril formation, are affected by bound BaP.     

Changes in the structure of neuromuscular junctions caused by variations in osmotic pressure

Reconstituted cartilage collagen fibrils with an oblique banding pattern or with two types of symmetrical patterns, and reconstituted rattail tendon fibrils with a third type of symmetrical pattern were examined by electron microscopy and found to consist of narrow subfibrils having native-type cross-striations. Analysis of the four types of patterns by a graphic method of specific band matching revealed the orientation and axial relation of individual subfibrils and their component molecules. In fibrils with an oblique pattern, subfibrils have the same orientation and a regular 100A axial displacement. Observations on staining characteristics, folded fibrils, and transverse sections of embedded fibrils suggest that the obliquely banded fibrils are ribbonlike or layered structures. In the three types of fibrils with a symmetrical pattern, adjacent subfibrils are oppositely oriented and aligned within a 119-A segment of the 670-A major period. Considered together, the observations suggest that interaction sites on the surface of subfibrils (and perhaps on the surface of native collagen fibrils) occur in various patterns that are manifested accouding to the nature of the environment during fibril formation, and that such patterns can be mapped on the surface of subfibrils by noting the arrangement of subfibrils in polymorphic forms.     

Short and long range order in basement membrane type IV collagen revealed by enzymic and chemical extraction

Oriented bovine lens capsules give X-ray diffraction patterns suggesting a considerable degree of order in the collagenous components, predominantly type IV collagen. Here we report the effects of preliminary treatment of lens capsules before orientation. Extraction with 4 guanidinium hydrochloride or with heparinase/hyaluronidase reveals the same collagenous diffraction patterns previously seen after extraction with 1 NaCl. There is a four-point pattern of d-spacing 3.9 nm, indicating liquid crystal cybotactic nematic organization, along with sharp streaked meridional reflections which index as orders of 21 nm. This suggests that the removal of basement membrane proteoglycans results in a reduction in diffuse scatter and clarification of the pattern. Extraction of the lens capsules with trypsin or dithiothreitol greatly reduces the intensity of the four-point pattern while leaving the meridional pattern unaffected. This strengthens the evidence that the 21 nm period has its origins in the collagen IV helix. Reduction in the four-point pattern could arise if disruption of non-helical NC1 domains or 7S overlap regions allows slippage of the collagen molecules on orientation, weakening the proposed 1 nm intermolecular stagger. Ultra-low angle diffraction patterns of extracted lens capsules show meridional reflections which index as a long-range axial repeat of approximately 95 nm. This is consistent with a model of microfibrils of type IV collagen in which the NC1 domains bind to the collagen helix at approximately 100 nm intervals, as has been previously suggested.