Mutations to nonsense codons in human genetic disease: implications for gene therapy by nonsense suppressor tRNAs.

Nonsense suppressor tRNAs have been suggested as potential agents for human somatic gene therapy. Recent work from this laboratory has described significant effects of 3' codon context on the efficiency of human nonsense suppressors. A rapid increase in the number of reports of human diseases caused by nonsense codons, prompted us to determine how the spectrum of mutation to either UAG, UAA or UGA codons and their respective 3' contexts, might effect the efficiency of human suppressor tRNAs employed for purposes of gene therapy. This paper presents a survey of 179 events of mutations to nonsense codons which cause human germline or somatic disease. The analysis revealed a ratio of approximately 1:2:3 for mutation to UAA, UAG and UGA respectively. This pattern is similar, but not identical, to that of naturally occurring stop codons. The 3' contexts of new mutations to stop were also analysed. Once again, the pattern was similar to the contexts surrounding natural termination signals. These results imply there will be little difference in the sensitivity of nonsense mutations and natural stop codons to suppression by nonsense suppressor tRNAs. Analysis of the codons altered by nonsense mutations suggests that efforts to design human UAG suppressor tRNAs charged with Trp, Gln, and Glu; UAA suppressors charged with Gln and Glu, and UGA suppressors which insert Arg, would be an essential step in the development of suppressor tRNAs as agents of human somatic gene therapy.     

The type of somatic mutation at APC in familial adenomatous polyposis is determined by the site of the germline mutation: a new facet to Knudson's 'two-hit' hypothesis.

APC is often cited as a prime example of a tumor suppressor gene. Truncating germline and somatic mutations (or, infrequently, allelic loss) occur in tumors in FAP (familial adenomatous polyposis). Most sporadic colorectal cancers also have two APC mutations. Clues from attenuated polyposis, missense germline variants with mild disease and the somatic mutation cluster region (codons 1,250-1,450) indicate, however, that APC mutations might not result in simple loss of protein function. We have found that FAP patients with germline APC mutations within a small region (codons 1,194-1,392 at most) mainly show allelic loss in their colorectal adenomas, in contrast to other FAP patients, whose 'second hits' tend to occur by truncating mutations in the mutation cluster region. Our results indicate that different APC mutations provide cells with different selective advantages, with mutations close to codon 1,300 providing the greatest advantage. Allelic loss is selected strongly in cells with one mutation near codon 1,300. A different germline-somatic APC mutation association exists in FAP desmoids. APC is not, therefore, a classical tumor suppressor. Our findings also indicate a new mechanism for disease severity: if a broader spectrum of mutations is selected in tumors, the somatic mutation rate is effectively higher and more tumors grow.     

Statistical analysis of pathogenicity of somatic mutations in cancer

Recent large-scale sequencing studies have revealed that cancer genomes contain variable numbers of somatic point mutations distributed across many genes. These somatic mutations most likely include passenger mutations that are not cancer causing and pathogenic driver mutations in cancer genes. Establishing a significant presence of driver mutations in such data sets is of biological interest. Whereas current techniques from phylogeny are applicable to large data sets composed of singly mutated samples, recently exemplified with a p53 mutation database, methods for smaller data sets containing individual samples with multiple mutations need to be developed. By constructing distinct models of both the mutation process and selection pressure upon the cancer samples, exact statistical tests to examine this problem are devised. Tests to examine the significance of selection toward missense, nonsense, and splice site mutations are derived, along with tests assessing variation in selection between functional domains. Maximum-likelihood methods facilitate parameter estimation, including levels of selection pressure and minimum numbers of pathogenic mutations. These methods are illustrated with 25 breast cancers screened across the coding sequences of 518 kinase genes, revealing 90 base substitutions in 71 genes. Significant selection pressure upon truncating mutations was established. Furthermore, an estimated minimum of 29.8 mutations were pathogenic.     

Incorporation of transition to transversion ratio and nonsense mutations,improves the estimation of the number of synonymous and non-synonymous sites in codons

A common approach to estimate the strength and direction of selection acting on protein coding sequences is to calculate the dN/dS ratio. The method to calculate dN/dS has been widely used by many researchers and many critical reviews have been made on its application after the proposition by Nei and Gojobori in 1986. However, the method is still evolving considering the non-uniform substitution rates and pretermination codons. In our study of SNPs in 586 genes across 156 Escherichia coli strains, synonymous polymorphism in 2-fold degenerate codons were higher in comparison to that in 4-fold degenerate codons, which could be attributed to the difference between transition (Ti) and transversion (Tv) substitution rates where the average rate of a transition is four times more than that of a transversion in general. We considered both the Ti/Tv ratio, and nonsense mutation in pretermination codons, to improve estimates of synonymous (S) and non-synonymous (NS) sites. The accuracy of estimating dN/dS has been improved by considering the Ti/Tv ratio and nonsense substitutions in pretermination codons. We showed that applying the modified approach based on Ti/Tv ratio and pretermination codons results in higher values of dN/dS in 29 common genes of equal reading-frames between E. coli and Salmonella enterica. This study emphasizes the robustness of amino acid composition with varying codon degeneracy, as well as the pretermination codons when calculating dN/dS values.     

Identification of missense, nonsense, and deletion mutations in the GRHPR gene in patients with primary hyperoxaluria type II (PH2)

Primary hyperoxaluria type II (PH2) is a rare disease characterized by the absence of an enzyme with glyoxylate reductase, hydroxypyruvate reductase, and D-glycerate dehydrogenase activities. The gene encoding this enzyme (GRHPR) has been characterized, and a single mutation has been detected in four PH2 patients. In this report, we have identified five novel mutations. One nonsense mutation (C295T) results in a premature stop codon at codon 99. A 4-bp deletion mutation has been found in the 5' consensus splice site of intron D, resulting in a predicted splicing error. Three missense mutations have been detected, including a missense transversion (T965G) in exon 9 (Met322Arg), a missense transition (G494A) in the putative co-factor binding site in exon 6 (Gly165Asp), and a substitution of an adenosine for a guanine in the 3' splice site of intron G. The functional consequences of the missense transversion and transition mutations have been investigated by transfection of cDNA encoding the mutated protein into COS cells. Cells transfected with either mutant construct have no enzymatic activity, a finding that is not significantly different from the control (empty) vector (P<0.05). These results further confirm that mutations in the GRHPR gene form the genetic basis of PH2. Ten of the 11 patients that we have genotyped are homozygous for one of the six mutations identified to date. Because of this high proportion of homozygotes, we have used microsatellite markers in close linkage with the GRHPR gene to investigate the possibility that the patients are the offspring of related individuals. Our data suggest that two thirds of our patients are the offspring of either closely or distantly related persons. Furthermore, genotyping has revealed the possible presence of a founder effect for the two most common mutations and the location of the gene near the marker D9S1874.     

TP53 and mutations in human cancer

TP53 is the most frequently mutated gene in human cancer, with a predominance of missense mutations scattered over 200 codons. In many cancers, specific mutation patterns can be identified, which are shaped by site-specific mutagenesis and by biological selection. In tobacco-related cancers (lung, head and neck), organ-specific patterns are observed, with many mutations compatible with the ones experimentally induced by tobacco carcinogens. In several other cancers, such as squamous cell carcinoma of the oesophagus or hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), mutation patterns show geographic variations between regions of high and low incidence, suggesting a role for region-specific risk factors. HCC from high-incidence regions showing also a high prevalence of a specific Ser-249 TP53 mutation is one of the most striking examples of a mutagen fingerprint. All such assessments are useful to generate clues on the mutagenic mechanisms involved in human cancer. Moreover, it has been shown that DNA retrieved from plasma can be successfully used for detection of TP53 mutations, which gives hope for earlier more accurate detection of human cancers.     

Germline and somatic mutations in hMSH6 and hMSH3 in gastrointestinal cancers of the microsatellite mutator phenotype

Hereditary and sporadic gastrointestinal cancer of the microsatellite mutator phenotype (MMP) is characterized by a remarkable genomic instability at simple repeated sequences. The genomic instability is often caused by germline and somatic mutations in DNA mismatch repair (MMR) genes hMSH2 and hMLH1. The MMP can be also caused by epigenetic inactivation of hMLH1. The MMP generates many somatic frameshift mutations in genes containing mononucleotide repeats. We previously reported that in MMP tumors the hMSH6 and hMSH3 MMR genes often carry frameshift mutations in their (C)(8) and (A)(8) tracks, respectively. We proposed that these 'secondary mutator mutations' contribute to a gradual manifestation of the MMP. Here we report the detection of other frameshift, nonsense, and missense mutations in these genes in colon and gastric cancers of the MMP. A germline frameshift mutation was found in hMSH6 in a colon tumor harboring another somatic frameshift mutation. Several germline sequence variants and somatic missense mutations at conserved residues were detected in hMSH6 and only one was detected in hMSH3. Of the three hMSH6 germline variants in conserved residues, one coexisted with a somatic mutation at the (C)(8) track and another had a somatic missense mutation. We suggest that some of these germline and somatic missense variants are pathogenic. While biallelic hMSH6 and hMSH3 frameshift mutations were found in some tumors, many tumors seemed to contain only monoallelic mutations. In some tumors, these somatic monoallelic frameshift mutations at the (C)(8) and (A)(8) tracks were found to coexist with other somatic mutations in the other allele, supporting their functionality during tumorigenesis. However, the low incidence of these additional somatic mutations in hMSH6 and hMSH3 leaves many tumors with only monoallelic mutations. The impact of the frameshift mutations in gene expression was studied by comparative analysis of RNA and protein expression in different tumor cell clones with different genotypes. The results show that the hMSH6 (C)(8) frameshift mutation abolishes protein expression, ruling out a dominant negative effect by a truncated protein. We suggest the functionality of these secondary monoallelic mutator mutations in the context of an accumulative haploinsufficiency model.     

Somatic Variations in Cervical Cancers in Indian Patients

There are very few reports that describe the mutational landscape of cervical cancer, one of the leading cancers in Indian women. The aim of the present study was to investigate the somatic mutations that occur in cervical cancer. Whole exome sequencing of 10 treatment naïve tumour biopsies with matched blood samples, from a cohort of Indian patients with locally advanced disease, was performed. The data revealed missense mutations across 1282 genes, out of 1831 genes harbouring somatic mutations. These missense mutations (nonsynonymous + stop-gained) when compared with pre-existing mutations in the COSMIC database showed that 272 mutations in 250 genes were already reported although from cancers other than cervical cancer. More than 1000 novel somatic variations were obtained in matched tumour samples. Pathways / genes that are frequently mutated in various other cancers were found to be mutated in cervical cancers. A significant enrichment of somatic mutations in the MAPK pathway was observed, some of which could be potentially targetable. This is the first report of whole exome sequencing of well annotated cervical cancer samples from Indian women and helps identify trends in mutation profiles that are found in an Indian cohort of cervical cancer.     

Mutation screening of the EXT1 and EXT2 genes in patients with hereditary multiple exostoses.

Hereditary multiple exostoses (HME), the most frequent of all skeletal dysplasias, is an autosomal dominant disorder characterized by the presence of multiple exostoses localized mainly at the end of long bones. HME is genetically heterogeneous, with at least three loci, on 8q24.1 (EXT1), 11p11-p13 (EXT2), and 19p (EXT3). Both the EXT1 and EXT2 genes have been cloned recently and define a new family of potential tumor suppressor genes. This is the first study in which mutation screening has been performed for both the EXT1 and EXT2 genes prior to any linkage analysis. We have screened 17 probands with the HME phenotype, for alterations in all translated exons and flanking intronic sequences, in the EXT1 and EXT2 genes, by conformation-sensitive gel electrophoresis. We found the disease-causing mutation in 12 families (70%), 7 (41%) of which have EXT1 mutations and 5 (29%) EXT2 mutations. Together with the previously described 1-bp deletion in exon 6, which is present in 2 of our families, we report five new mutations in EXT1. Two are missense mutations in exon 2 (G339D and R340C), and the other three alterations (a nonsense mutation, a frameshift, and a splicing mutation) are likely to result in truncated nonfunctional proteins. Four new mutations are described in EXT2. A missense mutation (D227N) was found in 2 different families; the other three alterations (two nonsense mutations and one frameshift mutation) lead directly or indirectly to premature stop codons. The missense mutations in EXT1 and EXT2 may pinpoint crucial domains in both proteins and therefore give clues for the understanding of the pathophysiology of this skeletal disorder.     

Characterization and significance of nine novel mutations in exon 16 of the neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1) gene

Nine novel mutations have been characterized as the result of screening exon 16 of the human NF1 gene in 465 unrelated neurofibromatosis type 1 patients. These lesions include three nonsense and two missense mutations, two deletions, one duplication, and one mutation in the 5′ splice site of intron 16. Although exon 16 is the largest NF1 exon, no mutations have so far been reported in this region. This apparent paucity of lesions may be due either to a reduced functional importance of exon 16 or a screening bias or both. However, consideration of the mutability of exon 16 in comparison with other exons suggests that, at least for single base pair substitutions, no such factors need be invoked. Any previous lack of exon 16 mutations in this category would be explicable in terms of a lower propensity to mutate for codons in this gene region. Received: 1 November 1996 / Revised: 5 December 1996     

Hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer: causative role of a germline missense mutation in the hMLH1 gene confirmed by the independent occurrence of the same somatic mutation in tumour tissue

Evaluation of the causative role of germline mutations in DNA mismatch repair genes in hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC) families can be difficult. Whereas nonsense, frameshift or splice-site mutations are presumed to lead to dysfunctional gene products and thus are generally considered to be causative, the evaluation of missense mutations often remains uncertain. We observed a novel germline mutation in the hMLH1 gene (His→Pro at codon 329) in an HNPCC family. The same missense mutation also occurred as a somatic event in the colonic tumours of two other HNPCC patients who had germline mutations at different sites of the hMLH1gene. Thus, the H329P mutation present in the germline can be considered as having an aetiological role in this HNPCC family. Received: 1 April 1997 / Accepted: 13 May 1997     

Transition-transversion bias is not universal: a counter example from grasshopper pseudogenes

Comparisons of the DNA sequences of metazoa show an excess of transitional over transversional substitutions. Part of this bias is due to the relatively high rate of mutation of methylated cytosines to thymine. Postmutation processes also introduce a bias, particularly selection for codon-usage bias in coding regions. It is generally assumed, however, that there is a universal bias in favour of transitions over transversions, possibly as a result of the underlying chemistry of mutation. Surprisingly, this underlying trend has been evaluated only in two types of metazoan, namely Drosophila and the Mammalia. Here, we investigate a third group, and find no such bias. We characterize the point substitution spectrum in Podisma pedestris, a grasshopper species with a very large genome. The accumulation of mutations was surveyed in two pseudogene families, nuclear mitochondrial and ribosomal DNA sequences. The cytosine-guanine (CpG) dinucleotides exhibit the high transition frequencies expected of methylated sites. The transition rate at other cytosine residues is significantly lower. After accounting for this methylation effect, there is no significant difference between transition and transversion rates. These results contrast with reports from other taxa and lead us to reject the hypothesis of a universal transition/transversion bias. Instead we suggest fundamental interspecific differences in point substitution processes.     

AVPR2 variants and mutations in nephrogenic diabetes insipidus: review and missense mutation significance

Almost 90% of nephrogenic diabetes insipidus (NDI) is due to mutations in the arginine-vasopressin receptor 2 gene (AVPR2). We retrospectively examined all the published mutations/variants in AVPR2. We planned to perform a comprehensive review of all the AVPR2 mutations/variants and to test whether any amino acid change causing a missense mutation is significantly more or less common than others. We performed a Medline search and collected detailed information regarding all AVPR2 mutations and variants. We performed a frequency comparison between mutated and wild-type amino acids and codons. We predicted the mutation effect or reported it based on published in vitro studies. We also reported the ethnicity of each mutation/variant carrier. In summary, we identified 211 AVPR2 mutations which cause NDI in 326 families and 21 variants which do not cause NDI in 71 NDI families. We described 15 different types of mutations including missense, frameshift, inframe deletion, deletion, insertion, nonsense, duplication, splicing and combined mutations. The missense mutations represent the 55.83% of all the NDI published families. Arginine and tyrosine are significantly (P = 4.07E-08 and P = 3.27E-04, respectively) the AVPR2 most commonly mutated amino acids. Alanine and glutamate are significantly (P = 0.009 and P = 0.019, respectively) the least mutated AVPR2 amino acids. The spectrum of mutations varies from rare gene variants or polymorphisms not causing NDI to rare mutations causing NDI, among which arginine and tyrosine are the most common missense. The AVPR2 mutations are spread world-wide. Our study may serve as an updated review, comprehensive of all AVPR2 variants and specific gene locations. J. Cell. Physiol. 217: 605-617, 2008. (c) 2008 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Characterization of mutations in the factor VIII gene by direct sequencing of amplified genomic DNA

In order to search for mutations resulting in hemophilia A that are not detectable by restriction analysis, three regions of the factor VIII gene were chosen for direct sequence analysis. Short segments of genomic DNA of 127 unrelated patients with hemophilia A were amplified by polymerase chain reaction. A total of 136,017 nucleotides were sequenced, and four mutations leading to the disease were found: a frameshift at codon 360 due to deletion of two nucleotides (GA), a nonsense codon 1705 due to a C----T transition, and two missense codons at positions 1699 and 1708. The first missense mutation (A----T) results in a Tyr----Phe substitution at a putative von Willebrand factor binding site. The second results in an Arg----Cys substitution at a thrombin cleavage site. In addition, we identified three rare sequence variants: a silent C----T transition at codon 34 which does not result in an amino acid change, a G----C change at codon 345 (Val----Leu), and an A----G change at the third nucleotide of intron 14. Direct sequence analysis of amplified DNA is a powerful but labor-intensive method of identifying mutations in large genes such as the human factor VIII gene.     

A novel missense mutation in the factor VIII gene identified by analysis of amplified hemophilia DNA sequences.

To date the only point mutations demonstrated to cause hemophilia are C to T transitions in TaqI sites. These were detected by screening Southern blots with cloned factor VIII probes. During the development of improved methods for detecting and analyzing mutations in genomic DNA, a novel G to C transversion mutation has been identified. This rare transversion results in a missense mutation, with proline being substituted for arginine in one of the active domains of the factor VIII molecule. The results suggest that the improved methods will be useful for detecting mutations in hemophilia as well as in other genetic disorders. In this method, specific DNA sequences in genomic DNA are amplified using oligonucleotide primers and a heat-resistant DNA polymerase. Mutations are detected and localized in the amplified samples by RNase A cleavage, and the altered region is then sequenced.