Vaccine adjuvants: current state and future trends

The problem with pure recombinant or synthetic antigens used in modern day vaccines is that they are generally far less immunogenic than older style live or killed whole organism vaccines. This has created a major need for improved and more powerful adjuvants for use in these vaccines. With few exceptions, alum remains the sole adjuvant approved for human use in the majority of countries worldwide. Although alum is able to induce a good antibody (Th2) response, it has little capacity to stimulate cellular (Th1) immune responses which are so important for protection against many pathogens. In addition, alum has the potential to cause severe local and systemic side-effects including sterile abscesses, eosinophilia and myofascitis, although fortunately most of the more serious side-effects are relatively rare. There is also community concern regarding the possible role of aluminium in neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's disease. Consequently, there is a major unmet need for safer and more effective adjuvants suitable for human use. In particular, there is demand for safe and non-toxic adjuvants able to stimulate cellular (Th1) immunity. Other needs in light of new vaccine technologies are adjuvants suitable for use with mucosally-delivered vaccines, DNA vaccines, cancer and autoimmunity vaccines. Each of these areas are highly specialized with their own unique needs in respect of suitable adjuvant technology. This paper reviews the state of the art in the adjuvant field, explores future directions of adjuvant development and finally examines some of the impediments and barriers to development and registration of new human adjuvants.     

Inulin-derived adjuvants efficiently promote both Th1 and Th2 immune responses

There has been a recent resurgence of interest into new and improved vaccine adjuvants. This interest has been stimulated by the need for new vaccines to combat problematic pathogens such as SARS and HIV, and to counter potential bioterrorist attacks. A major bottleneck in vaccine development is the low immunogenicity of purified subunit or recombinant proteins, creating the need for safe human adjuvants with high potency. A major problem in the search for the ideal adjuvant is that adjuvants that promote cell-mediated (Th1) immunity (e.g. Freund's complete adjuvant) generally have unacceptable local or systemic toxicity that precludes their use in human vaccines. There is a need for a safe, non-toxic adjuvant that is able to stimulate both cell-mediated and humoral immunity. Inulin-derived adjuvants that principally stimulate the innate immune system through their ability to activate the alternative complement pathway have proven ability to induce both cellular and humoral immunity. With their excellent tolerability, long shelf-life, low cost and easy manufacture, they offer great potential for use in a broad range of prophylactic and therapeutic vaccines. Based on successful animal studies in a broad range of species, human trials are about to get underway to validate the use of inulin-based adjuvants in prophylactic vaccines against hepatitis B, malaria and other pathogens. If such trials are successful, then it is possible that inulin-derived adjuvants will one day replace alum as the adjuvant of choice in most human prophylactic vaccines.     

Adjuvants for anti-parasite vaccines

To date the most successful human vaccines use attenuated living pathogens, but the advent of techniques in genetic engineering has meant that pure antigen can be provided in quantity. This has allowed the development of combined vaccines that use only the parasite antigens that convey protective immunity. However, isolated antigens lose immunogenicity so to regain potency, living attenuated carriers like Vaccinia or Salmonella can be used. To avoid the attendant drawbacks of carriers as immunopotentiating agents, adjuvants are under investigation as alternatives for use in vaccines against parasitic infections. In this review, Robert Bomford describes the adjuvants currently being examined for use in vaccines for both protozoan and helminth infections including Leishmania, malaria and Schistosoma. He also points out the drawbacks of using adjuvants and the dilemma of needing to stimulate cell'-mediated immunity while avoiding the immunopathological consequences of doing so.     

The choice of adjuvants in Mycoplasma vaccines

The use of adjuvants in vaccine production is an important aspect of potent vaccines. This investigation was concerned with finding the most efficient adjuvants for use in Mycoplasma vaccines produced in Nigeria. Four different vaccines were produced from the Gladysdale strain of Mycoplasma mycoides subspecies mycoides. They differed depending on the type of adjuvants used. Each vaccine was used to vaccinate eight cattle using a dose of 1 ml. Two other groups of eight cattle were used as controls. One of the two groups received 1 ml dose of inactivated Gladysdale vaccine without adjuvant while the second group received 1 ml dose of saline. The number of cattle that had the peak complement fixing (CF) antibody titres of 1/80 in each group of cattle was four for vaccine containing aluminium hydroxide gel, eight for vaccine containing liquid paraffin, one for vaccine containing sodium alginate and one for vaccine without adjuvant. Seven cattle from the group vaccinated with vaccine containing Freund's incomplete adjuvant had peak CF antibody titres of 1/80 or higher. The two groups vaccinated with vaccine containing liquid paraffin and Freund's incomplete adjuvant survived challenge at 6 months post vaccination. Freund's incomplete adjuvant and liquid paraffin containing 10% Arlacel A are the most efficient adjuvants.     

Adjuvants and the promotion of Th1-type cytokines in tumour immunotherapy

Immunotherapy includes both active and passive mechanisms that have the potential to treat many tumour types. Whereas monoclonal antibodies may kill cells by merely binding to them, 'cancer vaccines' involve the induction of an active immune response. The activation of tumour antigen-specific T-helper and cytotoxic T lymphocytes or non-specific macrophages and natural killer (NK) cells using immunotherapeutic approaches may lead to the subsequent destruction of tumour tissue. Administration of a tumour antigen alone is often not sufficient to stimulate an appropriate immune response. However, incorporating an immunological adjuvant into a vaccine regime often improves anti-tumour immunity. There are various types of adjuvants used in immunotherapy, ranging from microbial, chemical, and cellular components to proteins and cytokines. Previous reports have demonstrated that the induction of Th1-promoting cytokines, using specific adjuvants, can enhance anti-tumour immunity and can reduce or even prevent tumour growth. There is also increasing evidence that many adjuvants induce Th1-type cytokines, which correlates with the induction anti-tumour immunity. Th1-type responses which comprise cell-mediated immunity are characterised by the secretion of interferon-gamma by T cells, which is induced by antigen-presenting cell (APC)-derived IL-12. This review describes immunoadjuvants that are currently undergoing preclinical investigation, and emerging clinical data revealing that adjuvants which induce Th1-type responses can improve the efficacy of cancer vaccines. Therefore, the use of Th1-inducing adjuvants may provide an essential strategy for the future success of immunotherapy.     

Adjuvant properties of bacterial product cantastim

Aluminum compounds have been used as adjuvants in practical vaccination for more than 60 years to induce an early, an efficient and a long lasting protective immunity. Nowadays they are the most widely used adjuvants in both veterinary and human vaccines. Unfortunately these adjuvants do not only cause undesirable side effects, but often induce T-helper type 2 (Th2)-biased responses. In this study we investigated the ability of the bacterial product CANTASTIM (CS) to augment the immune responses to a model antigen, tetanus toxoid (TT). Immunization of mice with TT+CS elicited higher anti-TT IgG antibody levels as compared to mice that received TT alone. Moreover, treatment with TT+CS resulted in a lower IgG1/IgG2a ratio and a stronger in vitro IFN-gamma synthesis by splenocytes and T cells cocultured with macrophages. These data suggest that CS can be used to enhance the magnitude of the immune response and to skew it towards the Th1 type.     

Biotechnology approaches to produce potent,self-adjuvanting antigen-adjuvant fusion protein subunit vaccines

Traditional vaccination approaches (e.g. live attenuated or killed microorganisms) are among the most effective means to prevent the spread of infectious diseases. These approaches, nevertheless, have failed to yield successful vaccines against many important pathogens. To overcome this problem, methods have been developed to identify microbial components, against which protective immune responses can be elicited. Subunit antigens identified by these approaches enable the production of defined vaccines, with improved safety profiles. However, they are generally poorly immunogenic, necessitating their administration with potent immunostimulatory adjuvants. Since few safe and effective adjuvants are currently used in vaccines approved for human use, with those available displaying poor potency, or an inability to stimulate the types of immune responses required for vaccines against specific diseases (e.g. cytotoxic lymphocytes (CTLs) to treat cancers), the development of new vaccines will be aided by the availability of characterized platforms of new adjuvants, improving our capacity to rationally select adjuvants for different applications. One such approach, involves the addition of microbial components (pathogen-associated molecular patterns; PAMPs), that can stimulate strong immune responses, into subunit vaccine formulations. The conjugation of PAMPs to subunit antigens provides a means to greatly increase vaccine potency, by targeting immunostimulation and antigen to the same antigen presenting cell. Thus, methods that enable the efficient, and inexpensive production of antigen-adjuvant fusions represent an exciting mean to improve immunity towards subunit antigens. Herein we review four protein-based adjuvants (flagellin, bacterial lipoproteins, the extra domain A of fibronectin (EDA), and heat shock proteins (Hsps)), which can be genetically fused to antigens to enable recombinant production of antigen-adjuvant fusion proteins, with a focus on their mechanisms of action, structural or sequence requirements for activity, sequence modifications to enhance their activity or simplify production, adverse effects, and examples of vaccines in preclinical or human clinical trials.     

Advances in vaccine adjuvants.

Currently, aluminum salts and MF59 are the only vaccine adjuvants approved for human use. With the development of new-generation vaccines (including recombinant subunit and mucosal vaccines) that are less immunogenic, the search for more potent vaccine adjuvants has intensified. Of the novel compounds recently evaluated in human trials, immunostimulatory molecules such as the lipopolysaccharide derived MPL and the saponin derivative QS21 appear most promising, although doubts have been raised as to their safety in humans. Preclinical work with particulate adjuvants, such as the MF59 microemulsion and lipid-particle immune-stimulating complexes (Iscoms), suggest that these molecules are also potent elicitors of humoral and cellular immune responses. In addition, preclinical data on CpG oligonucleotides appear to be encouraging, particularly with respect to their ability to selectively manipulate immune responses. While all these adjuvants show promise, further work is needed to better define the mechanisms of adjuvant action. Ultimately, the development of more potent adjuvants may allow vaccines to be used as therapeutic, rather than prophylactic, agents.     

新型疫苗佐剂的研究进展

与传统的灭活或活体疫苗相比,由基因工程重组抗原或化学合成多肽组成的现代疫苗往往存在免疫原性弱等问题,需要新型的免疫佐剂来增强其作用。尽管传统的铝盐佐剂是目前唯一全球公认的人用佐剂,但存在激发细胞免疫应答能力差等不足,因此,需要研发更为安全有效的人用新型佐剂,尤其是安全无毒、能够刺激较强细胞免疫应答的佐剂,以及适合粘膜疫苗、DNA疫苗和癌症疫苗的免疫佐剂。分析阐述了新型佐剂研究状况和佐剂发展方向,并进一步对新型佐剂的临床前和临床试验研究以及已批准上市的新型疫苗佐剂进行了综述。     

Adjuvant formulations and delivery systems for DNA vaccines

DNA vaccines have become a reliable and major means to elicit immune responses in the past decade. We and others have attempted to obtain stronger, more long lasting, and optimized immune responses, subsequent to the pioneering works demonstrating the ability of plasmid DNA to raise specific immune responses. Advances in molecular biology and biotechnology allow the application of various adjuvants, immunologic agents that increase the antigenic response, in DNA vaccines. Adjuvants can be broadly separated into two classes based on their origin-genetic and conventional. Genetic adjuvants are expression vectors of cytokines or other molecules that can modulate immune responses when administered with a vaccine antigen. Conventional adjuvants are chemical compounds that enhance, prolong, or modulate antigen-specific immune responses. The use of an appropriate adjuvant is pivotal in optimizing the response to DNA vaccines. Moreover, DNA vaccines themselves possess their own adjuvant activity because of the presence of unmethylated CpG motifs in particular base contents. The route of inoculation is also a critical factor in determining the outcome of vaccination. It is well known that intramuscular injection preferentially induces Th1-type immunity, whereas particle bombardment by gene gun predominantly induces Th2-type response. This article focuses on providing the detailed procedure to construct genetic adjuvant plasmids and prepare DNA vaccines formulated with conventional adjuvants. We also offer a practical guide for the procedure of intramuscular DNA injection.     

Evaluation of transmission electron microscopy for examination of components of acellular pertussis and combination vaccines.

New acellular pertussis and combination vaccines vary in the concentration and presence or absence of specific components and in extent of adsorption to adjuvants. There is a pressing need to develop new control methods for acellular pertussis vaccines. Negative staining electron microscopy has been evaluated as a method for assessing the purity of individual vaccine components and the amount of adsorption to aluminium gels. Negative staining showed the characteristic morphology of vaccine components and permitted detection of contaminants and morphological changes. Reproducible results were obtained by use of a standardized negative staining technique and confidence in the technique was increased by comparison of previously unexamined specimens with a specimen that had been characterized by repeated observations. The degree of adsorption to aluminium adjuvants could only be assessed by observation of the amount of non-adsorbed material in the specimen. Negative staining electron microscopy can be used as one of a number of techniques for control of acellular pertussis combination vaccines.     

Development of mucosal influenza inactivated vaccines

In this review recent data on the development of mucosal influenza inactivated vaccines with the use of mucosoadhesive adjuvants are presented. After the intranasal administration of such vaccines the formation of not only systemic, but also local immunity (IgA antibodies), as well as cross protection against the variants of influenza virus within its serotype, can be observed. Some mucosal influenza vaccines have passed clinical tests. Certain drawbacks of Escherichia thermolabile enterotoxin, used as mucosoadhesive adjuvant, and difficulties which may arise in mass immunization with mucosal vaccines due to the necessity of introducing them in two or three intranasal administrations are indicated.     

A review of combination adjuvants for malaria vaccines: a promising approach for vaccine development

It is obvious that there is a critical need for an efficient malaria vaccine to accelerate malaria eradication. Currently, recombinant subunit vaccination against malaria using proteins and peptides is gaining attention. However, one of the major drawbacks of this approach is the lack of an efficient and durable immune response. Therefore, subunit vaccines require adjuvants to make the vaccine sufficiently immunogenic. Considering the history of the RTS,S vaccine, it seems likely that no single adjuvant is capable of eliciting all the protective immune responses required in many malarial subunit vaccines and the use of combination adjuvants will be increasingly important as the science of malaria vaccines advances. In light of this, it appears that identifying the most effective mixture of adjuvants with minimal adverse effects offers tremendous opportunities in improving the efficacy of vaccines against malaria. Owing to the importance of a multi-adjuvanted approach in subunit malaria vaccine development, this review paper outlines some of the best known combination adjuvants used in malaria subunit vaccines, focusing on their proposed mechanisms of action, their immunological properties, and their notable results. The aim of the present review is to consolidate these findings to aid the application of these combination adjuvants in experimental malaria vaccines.     

The perfect mix: recent progress in adjuvant research

Developing efficient and safe adjuvants for use in human vaccines remains both a challenge and a necessity. Past approaches have been largely empirical and generally used a single type of adjuvant, such as aluminium salts or emulsions. However, new vaccine targets often require the induction of well-defined cell-mediated responses in addition to antibodies, and thus new immunostimulants are required. Recent advances in basic immunology have elucidated how early innate immune signals can shape subsequent adaptive responses and this, coupled with improvements in biochemical techniques, has led to the design and development of more specific and focused adjuvants. In this Review, I discuss the research that has made it possible for vaccinologists to now be able to choose between a large panel of adjuvants, which potentially can act synergistically, and combine them in formulations that are specifically adapted to each target and to the relevant correlate(s) of protection.     

Analysis of anthrax and plague biowarfare vaccine interactions with human monocyte-derived dendritic cells

The anti-biowarfare anthrax and plague vaccines require repeated dosing to achieve adequate protection. To test the hypothesis that this limited immunogenicity results from the nature of vaccine interactions with the host innate immune system, we investigated molecular and cellular interactions between vaccines, dendritic cells (DCs), and T cells and explored the potential for adjuvants (pertussis) to boost induction of host immunity. Human monocyte-derived DCs were matured in the presence of vaccines and analyzed for their ability to induce Th1/Th2 development from naive T cells, expression of cell surface maturation/costimulation molecules, and cytokine production. The vaccines showed different behavior patterns. Although the plague vaccine is equivalent to control maturation factors in maturation and stimulation of DCs and induces strong MLR and Th outgrowth, the anthrax vaccine is a poor inducer of DC maturation, as indicated by low levels of HLA-DR, CD86, and CD83 induction and minimal proinflammatory cytokine production. Interestingly, however, anthrax vaccine-treated DCs stimulate Th1 and Th2 outgrowth and a limited MLR response. There was no sustained negative modulatory effects of the anthrax vaccine on DCs, and its limited stimulatory effects could be overridden by coculture with pertussis. These results were supported by analysis of anthrax vaccine recall responses in subjects vaccinated using pertussis as an adjuvant, who demonstrate anthrax-specific effector T cell responses. These data show that the anthrax vaccine is a suboptimal DC stimulus that may in part explain the observation that it requires repeated administration in vivo and offer a rational basis for the use of complementary DC-maturing adjuvants in combined immunotherapy.     

Boosting the immune response: the use of iNKT cell ligands as vaccine adjuvants

Natural killer T (NKT) cells comprise a small, but important T cell subset and are thought to bridge the innate and adaptive immune responses. The discovery of NKT cells and extensive research on their activating ligands have paved the way for modulation of these potent immunoregulatory cells in order to improve the outcome of various clinical conditions. Efforts to modulate NKT cell effector functions have ranged from therapy for influenza to antitumor immunotherapy. These approaches have also led to the use of NKTcell agonists such as ??-Galactosylceramide (??-GalCer) and its analogs as vaccine adjuvants, an approach that is aimed at boosting specific B and Tcell responses to a vaccine candidate by concomitant activation of NKT cells. In this review we will provide a comprehensive overview of the efforts made in using ??-GalCer and its analogs as vaccine adjuvants. The diverse array of vaccination strategies used, as well as the role of NKTcell activating adjuvants will be discussed, with focus on vaccines against malaria, HIV, influenza and tumor vaccines. Collectively, these studies demonstrate the efficacy of NKT cell-specific agonists as adjuvants and suggest that these compounds warrant serious consideration during the development of vaccination strategies.     

Beta-glucans as conductors of immune symphonies

The use of immunostimulants has received increased attention due to the discovery of Toll-like receptors (TLR) or/and pattern recognition receptors (PRR). These receptors have been found to bind molecules from a range of pathogens including self-molecules. When cell damage has occurred many of the released molecular structures act as so-called "danger" signals possessing pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMP). These danger signals often consist of repeating molecular moieties yielding high molecular weight compounds. Examples are beta-glucans and CpG containing DNA, but some danger signals possess low molecular weight structures. It has been found that the PRR bind unit structures of PAMP, and that PAMP-binding involves several other humoral and cell membrane proteins, exemplified by the more or less simultaneous LPS recognition displayed by MD-2, CD-14 and TLR4 on the cell membrane. Also, the binding of beta-glucans has been shown to include several different cell membrane receptors. Several immunostimulants are commercially exploited in aquaculture as feed additives. This applies to beta-glucans, alginates and nucleotides. Despite their use as feed additives no targeted approach has been conducted to include PAMP as adjuvants in fish vaccines. Interestingly, most of the PAMP studied activate antigen-presenting cells together with na?ve T cells into dendritic cells and Th1 or Th2 cells [1]. In turn, this may activate Th1 and Th2 immune responses with production of Th1 or Th2 signature molecules such as IFN-gamma and IL-4, respectively [2-4]. This review will mainly focus on binding characteristics of beta-glucans, their effects on T helper cell differentiation, effects on functional levels, gene expression profiles and application of the commonly used ss-glucan in the aquaculture sector. In addition, ss-glucans show promises in shrimp aquaculture by inducing disease resistance, this review will also highlight the use and the effects of beta-glucans in experimental models.     

Beyond empiricism: informing vaccine development through innate immunity research

Although a great public heath success, vaccines provide suboptimal protection in some patient populations and are not available to protect against many infectious diseases. Insights from innate immunity research have led to a better understanding of how existing vaccines work and have informed vaccine development. New adjuvants and delivery systems are being designed based upon their capacity to stimulate innate immune sensors and target antigens to dendritic cells, the cells responsible for initiating adaptive immune responses. Incorporating these adjuvants and delivery systems in vaccines can beneficially alter the quantitative and qualitative nature of the adaptive immune response, resulting in enhanced protection.     

联合疫苗应用现状及评价*

联合疫苗含有两种或多种免疫原（活的、灭活的病原体或者提纯的抗原）,用于预防多种疾病或由同一病原体的不同亚型或血清型引起的疾病,可以避免常规免疫多次注射的问题。然而和单价疫苗相比,联合疫苗研发的复杂性大大增加,将多种免疫原混合到一起进行免疫时不同免疫原间可能因为物理、化学和免疫学机制而干扰其他免疫原的免疫反应,此外佐剂和防腐剂等非活性成分也可能对联合后的活性成分产生影响,这就对联合疫苗的评价提出了特别的要求。本文对联合疫苗的研究应用现状、临床评价和发展前景等方面做一综述。     

Prospects for the use of sulfated polysaccharides from brown seaweeds as vaccine adjuvants

The data from the Russian and foreign literature on the effects of brown seaweed-derived sulfated polysaccharides (fucoidans) used as potential vaccine adjuvants to enhance the anti-infection and anti-tumor immune response are discussed in the present review. Due to their low toxicity, high biocompatibility, safety, and good tolerability by macroorganisms, as well as their mechanisms of immunomodulatory activity, fucoidans can be considered as promising adjuvants to administer in the composition of prophylactic and therapeutic vaccines. Fucoidans are agonists to receptors of innate immunity and are potent inducers of the cellular and humoral immune response, which is an important factor to be taken into account in the development of vaccines against various pathogens, including viruses, as well as anti-tumor vaccines. The results of numerous studies in which sulfated polysaccharides were tested as components of experimental vaccines, as presented in this review, show that these substances can be used as safe and effective adjuvants.