Structural transition in inactive Balbiani ring chromatin of Chironomus during micrococcus nuclease digestion

We have analysed by micrococcus nuclease digestion the chromatin structure of genes in the Balbiani ring (BR) regions of a Chironomus cell line. Gel electrophoresis of the DNA fragments reveals a repeating structure which consists of two repeat sizes, a long repeat seen in the large fragments and a small repeat seen in the small fragments. The two repeats hardly overlap, except in a narrow transition zone which is at a different fragment size in the BR 2.2 and the BR 2.1 gene. The sizes of the large repeats fit the repeat of the underlying DNA sequence. The short repeats are between 170 and 180 bp, and after H1 depletion the short repeat in the BR 2.2 gene is 160 bp. Our most favoured interpretation of these data is that in intact chromatin the nucleosomes in the BR genes are phased with respect to the repeating DNA sequence, whereas micrococcus nuclease digestion leads to loss of a nucleosome-positioning constraint and hence to rearrangement of the nucleosomes. Our results imply a possible artefact of nuclease digestion of chromatin, which has to be taken into account in mapping nucleosome positions.     

The subunit structure of chromatin from Physarum polycephalum.

Nucleosome DNA repeat lengths in Physarum chromatin, determined by nuclease digestion experiments, are shorter than those observed in most mammalian chromatin and longer than those reported for chromatin of certain other lower eukaryotes. After digestion with staphylococcal nuclease for short periods of time an average repeat length of 190 base pairs is measured. After more extensive digestion an average repeat length of 172 base pairs is measured. Upon prolonged digestion DNA is degraded to an average monomer subunit length of 160 base pairs, with only a small amount of DNA found in lengths of 130 base pairs or smaller. Mathematical analysis of the data suggests that the Physarum nucleosome DNA repeat comprises a protected DNA segment of about 159 base pairs with a nuclease-accessible interconnecting segment which ranges from 13 to 31 base pairs. The spacing data are compatible with measurements from electron micrographs of Physarum chromatin.     

The variation with age of the structure of chromatin in three cell types from rat liver.

The organization of chromatin in three rat liver nuclear populations, namely diploid stromal, diploid parenchymal, and tetraploid parenchymal nuclei, which were separated by zonal centrifugation, was studied by digestion with micrococcal nuclease and pancreatic deoxyribonuclease in 3-week-old rats in which the parenchymal cells contain diploid nuclei and in 2-and 4-month-old rats with a high proportion of tetraploid nuclei. Digestion by micrococcal nuclease allowed the estimation of DNA-repeat length in chromatin. Parenchymal nuclei have shorter repeat length than stromal nuclei and DNA-repeat length increases with the age in all three nuclei populations. The kinetics of digestion by micrococcal nuclease showed that nuclei with shorter repeat length are more sensitive to micrococcal nuclease and that the sensitivity of chromatin decreases with age for all the types of nuclei in this study. The kinetics of digestion by pancreatic deoxyribonuclease showed that sensitivity of chromatin is related to the repeat length and that the sensitivity decreases with the ages.     

Reduced repeat length of nascent nucleosomal DNA is generated by replicating chromatin in vivo

Micrococcal nuclease digestion of nuclei from sea urchin embryos revealed transient changes in chromatin structure which resulted in a reduction in the repeat length of nascent chromatin DNA as compared with bulk DNA. This was considered to be entirely the consequence of in vivo events at the replication fork (Cell 14, 259, 1978). However, a micrococcal nuclease-generated sliding of nucleosome cores relative to nascent DNA, which might account for the smaller DNA fragments, was not excluded. In vivo [3H]thymidine pulse-labeled nuclei were fixed with a formaldehyde prior to micrococcal nuclease digestion. This linked chromatin proteins to DNA and thus prevented any in vitro sliding of histone cores. All the nascent DNAs exhibiting shorter repeat lengths after micrococcal nuclease digestion, were resolved at identical mobilities in polyacrylamide gels of DNA from fixed and unfixed nuclei. We conclude that these differences in repeat lengths between nascent and bulk DNA was generated in vivo by changes in chromatin structure during replication, rather than by micrococcal nuclease-induced sliding of histone cores in vitro.     

Two types of fragmentation of total chromatin by DNAase I--an artifact or reality?

The possibility of N+2N repeat (a nucleosomal-type repeat in which the even-numbered peaks dominate) being an artifact has been studied. The repeat results from digestion of chromatin of several rat cells by DNAase I. Endogenous nucleases are not shown to be involved in formation of the repeat. N+2N repeat is also formed during digestion of nuclei isolated from homogeneous lymphocyte populations indicating that the repeat is inherent of chromatin of distinct cells and is not the result of superimposition of different repeats arising from diverse tissue cells. We suppose the N+2N repeat to indicate the existence of the second type of total chromatin differing from the one giving rise to the dinucleosome repeat under the same conditions.     

Variation in chromatin structure in two cell types from the same tissue: a short DNA repeat length in cerebral cortex neurons

We have used micrococcal nuclease as a probe of the repeating structure of chromatin in four nuclear populations from three tissues of the rabbit. Neuronal nuclei isolated from the cerebral cortex contain about 160 base pairs of DNA in the chromatin repeat unit, as compared with about 200 base pairs for nonastrocytic glial cell nuclei from the same tissue, neuronal nuclei from the cerebellum and liver nuclei. All four types of nuclei show the same features of nucleosomal organization as other eucaryotic nuclei so far studied: nucleosomes liberated by digestion with micrococcal nuclease give a “core particle” containing 140 base pairs as a metastable intermediate on further digestion and a series of single-strand DNA fragments which are mutiples of 10 bases after digestion with DNAase I. Nuclei from cerebral cortex neurons, which have a short repeat, are distinct from the others in being larger, in having a higher proportion of euchromatin (dispersed chromatin) as judged by microscopy and in being more active in RNA synthesis in vitro.     

DNA repeat size in chick embryonic lens epithelium, lens fiber, brain and liver cell nuclei

The DNA repeat size is determined by micrococcal nuclease digestion kinetics and subsequent electrophoresis of the products among various chick embryonic tissues. The repeat size is found to be not significantly different from 193 to 197 bp, for brain and liver at 11 days and for lens epithelium and fiber at different embryonic stages. However, the pattern of micrococcal digestion seems to reveal an overall chromatin modification as a function of development in the lens fibers.     

Unmethylated regions in the intergenic spacer of maize and teosinte ribosomal RNA genes

The restriction endonucleases Hpa II and Msp I were used to examine cytosine methylation in the ribosomal RNA genes (rDNA) of inbred lines of maize and species of teosinte. In all of the rDNAs examined, Msp I (not sensitive to mCpG) digestion yielded a distribution of lower molecular weight fragments indicative of multiple recognition sites. The majority of the rDNA arrays in an individual were inaccessible to Hpa II (sensitive to mCpG) cleavage, but a significant fraction (10–25%) was cleaved at least once by Hpa II into repeat unit length fragments (9.1 kbp). In some maize inbred lines, one or two additional fragment populations (less than 9.1 kbp in length) were also produced by Hpa II digestion. All of the unmethylated Hpa II sites mapped to the intergenic spacer (IGS), and the major unmethylated site was located approximately 800 bp 5 to the start of the 18S RNA coding sequence. An Eco RI polymorphism, present in the 26S gene of certain inbred lines and hybrids, was utilized to investigate the organization of unmethylated repeat units in the rDNA array. In double digest experiments with Hpa II/Eco RI, the fragments from repeat units with two Eco RI sites were sensitive to Hpa II digestion, whereas, the fragments from repeat units with a single Eco RI site were almost completely resistant to Hpa II digestion. Similar digestion patterns were also observed in Eco RII (sensitive to mCNG)/Eco RI digests. These results suggest that unmethylated and Eco RI polymorphic sites occur in the same repeat units.     

Chromatin organization in the rat hypothalamus during early development.

The organization of chromatin in neuronal and glial nuclei isolated from different brain regions of rats during development was studied by digestion of nuclei with micrococcal nuclease. A short chromatin repeat length (approx. 176 base-pairs compared with that of glial nuclei from foetal cerebral cortex (approx. 200 base-pairs) was present in hypothalamic neurons throughout the ages studied, which was similar to the repeat length of cortical neurons from 7- and 25-day-old animals (approx. 174 base-pairs). Whereas in cortical neurons the chromatin repeat length shortened from approx. 200 base-pairs in the foetus to approx. 174 base-pairs in the first postnatal week, the short chromatin repeat length of hypothalamic neurons was already present 2 days before birth, indicating that hypothalamic neurons differentiate earlier than cortical neurons during brain development.     

Sequence specific cleavage of African green monkey alpha-satellite DNA by micrococcal nuclease

The sequence specificity of micrococcal nuclease complicates its use in experiments addressed to the still controversial issue of nucleosome phasing. In the case of alpha-satellite DNA containing chromatin from African green monkey (AGM) cells cleavage by micrococcal nuclease in the nucleus was reported to occur predominantly at only one location around position 126 of the satellite repeat unit (Musich et al. (1982) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79, 118-122). DNA control experiments conducted in the same study indicated the presence of many preferential cleavage sites for micrococcal nuclease on the 172 bp long alpha-satellite repeat unit. This difference was taken as evidence for a direct and simple phase relationship between the alpha-satellite DNA sequence and the position of the nucleosomes on the DNA. We have quantitatively analyzed the digestion products of the protein-free satellite monomer with micrococcal nuclease and found that 50% of all cuts occur at positions 123 and 132, 5% at position 79, and to a level of 1-3% at about 20 other positions. We also digested high molecular weight alpha-satellite DNA from AGM nuclei with micrococcal nuclease. Again cleavage occurred mostly at positions 123 and 132 of the satellite repeat unit. Thus digestion of free DNA yields results very similar to those reported by Musich et al. for the digestion of chromatin. Therefore no conclusions on a possible phase relationship can be drawn from the chromatin digestion experiments.     

Nucleosome structure in Aspergillus nidulans

The structure of chromatin from Aspergillus nidulans was studied using micrococcal nuclease and DNAase I. Limited digestion with micrococcal nuclease revealed a nucleosomal repeat of 154 base pairs for Aspergillus and 198 base pairs for rat liver. With more extensive digestion, both types of chromatin gave a similar quasi-limit product with a prominent fragment at 140 base pairs. The similarity of the two limit digests suggests that the structure of the 140 base pair nucleosome core is conserved. This implies that the difference in nucleosome repeat lengths between Aspergillus and rat liver is caused by a difference in the length of the DNA between two nucleosome cores. Digestion of Aspergillus chromatin with DNAase I produced a pattern of single-stranded fragments at intervals of 10 bases which was similar to that produced from rat liver chromatin.     

DNase I digestion reveals alternating asymmetrical protection of the nucleosome by the higher order chromatin structure

DNase I was used to probe the higher order chromatin structure in whole nuclei. The digestion profiles obtained were the result of single-stranded cuts and were independent of pH, type of divalent ion and chromatin repeat length. Furthermore, the protection from digestion of the DNA at the entry/exit points on the nucleosome was found to be caused not by the H1/H5 histone tails, but by the compact structure that these proteins support. In order to resolve symmetry ambiguities, DNase I digestion fragments over several nucleosome repeat lengths were analysed quantitatively and compared with computer simulations using combinations of the experimentally obtained rate constants (some of which were converted to 0 to simulate steric protection from DNase I digestion). A clear picture of precisely defined, alternating, asymmetrically protected nucleosomes emerged. The linker DNA is inside the fibre, while the nucleosomes are positioned above and below a helical path and/or with alternating orientation towards the dyad axis. The dinucleosomal modulation of the digestion patterns comes from alternate protection of cutting sites inside the nucleosome and not from alternating exposure to the enzyme of the linker DNA.     

The higher order repeat structure of chromatin is built up of globular particles containing eight nucleosomes

Mild nuclease digestion of rat liver chromatin generates particles with sedimentation coefficients of about 33S, 60S, and 90S (in 50 mM NaCl). The kinetics of appearance and disappearance of these particles with progressive digestion suggest that they are produced by cleavage from a higher order repeat structure, the 33S particle representing the monomer. At an intermediate stage of digestion, about 75 % of the nuclear chromatin can be recovered as monomers to trimers of this higher order structure. Sedimentation profiles indicate that monomer particles containing 7–8 nucleosomes occur at the highest frequency. The DNA fragments in monomers have a size corresponding to hepta- and octanucleosomes, and those in dimers have a size corresponding to chains of sixteen nucleosomes. The higher order repeat structure is only stable between 30 and 200 mM NaCl; the particles unfold below 30 and above 200 mM NaCl. When examined by electron microscopy, monomers and dimers appear as compact globular structures. Relaxation by lowering the salt concentration results in the appearance of polynucleosomes with a chain length of eight beads in the monomer and sixteen in the dimer particle. These results indicate that the unit particle of the higher order repeat structure of rat liver chromatin contains eight nucleosomes.     

Quantitative analysis of the digestion of yeast chromatin by staphylococcal nuclease.

The DNA in intranuclear yeast chromatin is protected from rapid staphylococcal nuclease degradation so as to yield an oligomeric series of DNA sizes. The course of production and disappearance of the various oligomers agrees quantitatively with a theory of random cleavage by the enzyme at uniformly susceptible sites. The sizes of the oligomers are integral repeats of a basic size, about 160 base pairs, and 80-90% of the yeast genome is involved in this repeating structure. Within this repeat there exists a 140 base pair core of more nuclease-resistant DNA. During the course of digestion, the sizes of the oligomers decrease continuously. The widths of the distribution of DNA sizes increase in order: monomer (1 X repeat size, half width = 5-7 base pairs) less than dimer (2 X repeat size, half width = 30 base pairs) less than trimer (3 X repeat size, half width = 40-45 base pairs). The yeast genome thus seems to have variable spacing of the nucleaseresistant cores, to produce the average repeat size of about 160 base pairs. Also, the presence of more than one species of monomer and dimer at certain times of digestion suggests a possible heterogeneity in the subunit structure.     

Improved characterization of FSHD mutations

Facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy (FSHD) is caused by the shortest alleles of the 3.3kb-tandem repeat array D4Z4 at 4q35. Molecular diagnosis of FSHD depends upon the separation of unusually large alleles by pulse-field electrophoresis after EcoRI and EcoRI/BlnI digestion. The exact number of alleles could not however be directly inferred from the size of DNA fragments owing to polymorphisms in the telomeric region of the locus. Knowing the exact repeat number of disease causing alleles may benefit genetic counselling, help to understand the mechanism of this singular disease and the population dynamics of subtelomeric sequences variations. We present here a partial digestion mapping method giving the exact number of repeats for disease causing alleles, and we suggest that most inaccuracies induced by common polymorphisms could be reduced by using EcoRV in place of EcoRI. After studying more than 300 DNA samples with both the standard method and this new method, we show that alleles size can be evaluated with a precision of less than one half repeat, and that the variations in length of the truncated repeat in the telomeric region of the D4Z4 locus can be evaluated. The results suggest that at least one intact chromosome 4 type repeat at 4q35 is needed to cause FSHD.     

Heterogeneity in cucumber ribosomal DNA

Summary Restriction and hybridization analysis of cucumber native ribosomal (r) DNA purified from actinomycin-D/CsCl gradients suggested that the repeat units were heterogeneous in both length and sequence. Several full length rDNA repeat units were cloned and five are described which account for all the EcoR I and Xba I fragments present in native DNA. One of a number of BamH I sites found in the clones is not found in a proportion of native rDNA because of base modification. Restriction maps are described for the representative clones and aligned with R-loop maps obtained from electron microscope analysis of each type of repeat unit hybridized under R-loop conditions to pure 18S and 25S rRNAs. The major heterogeneity is explained by differences in length of the external spacer region and by a proportion of the repeat units showing a restriction fragment length polymorphism on EcoR I digestion. The regions coding for 18S and 25S rRNA are uninterrupted and highly conserved.     

Organization of internucleosomal DNA in rat liver chromatin

A detailed analysis of the length distribution of DNA in nucleosome dimers trimmed with exonuclease III and S1 nuclease suggests that the previously described variation of internucleosomal distance in rat liver occurs, at least for a subset of the nucleosomes, by integral multiples of the helical repeat of the DNA. Results obtained upon digestion of chromatin with DNase II further suggest that lengths of internucleosomal DNA are integral multiples of the helical repeat of the DNA plus approximately 5 bp. Restraints imposed by these features on the arrangement of nucleosomes along the fiber are discussed.