Comparison of label-free methods for quantifying human proteins by shotgun proteomics

Measurements of mass spectral peak intensities and spectral counts are promising methods for quantifying protein abundance changes in shotgun proteomic analyses. We describe Serac, software developed to evaluate the ability of each method to quantify relative changes in protein abundance. Dynamic range and linearity using a three-dimensional ion trap were tested using standard proteins spiked into a complex sample. Linearity and good agreement between observed versus expected protein ratios were obtained after normalization and background subtraction of peak area intensity measurements and correction of spectral counts to eliminate discontinuity in ratio estimates. Peak intensity values useful for protein quantitation ranged from 10(7) to 10(11) counts with no obvious saturation effect, and proteins in replicate samples showed variations of less than 2-fold within the 95% range (+/-2sigma) when >or=3 peptides/protein were shared between samples. Protein ratios were determined with high confidence from spectral counts when maximum spectral counts were >or=4 spectra/protein, and replicates showed equivalent measurements well within 95% confidence limits. In further tests, complex samples were separated by gel exclusion chromatography, quantifying changes in protein abundance between different fractions. Linear behavior of peak area intensity measurements was obtained for peptides from proteins in different fractions. Protein ratios determined by spectral counting agreed well with those determined from peak area intensity measurements, and both agreed with independent measurements based on gel staining intensities. Overall spectral counting proved to be a more sensitive method for detecting proteins that undergo changes in abundance, whereas peak area intensity measurements yielded more accurate estimates of protein ratios. Finally these methods were used to analyze differential changes in protein expression in human erythroleukemia K562 cells stimulated under conditions that promote cell differentiation by mitogen-activated protein kinase pathway activation. Protein changes identified with p<0.1 showed good correlations with parallel measurements of changes in mRNA expression.     

Detecting differential and correlated protein expression in label-free shotgun proteomics

Recent studies have revealed a relationship between protein abundance and sampling statistics, such as sequence coverage, peptide count, and spectral count, in label-free liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) shotgun proteomics. The use of sampling statistics offers a promising method of measuring relative protein abundance and detecting differentially expressed or coexpressed proteins. We performed a systematic analysis of various approaches to quantifying differential protein expression in eukaryotic Saccharomyces cerevisiae and prokaryotic Rhodopseudomonas palustris label-free LC-MS/MS data. First, we showed that, among three sampling statistics, the spectral count has the highest technical reproducibility, followed by the less-reproducible peptide count and relatively nonreproducible sequence coverage. Second, we used spectral count statistics to measure differential protein expression in pairwise experiments using five statistical tests: Fisher's exact test, G-test, AC test, t-test, and LPE test. Given the S. cerevisiae data set with spiked proteins as a benchmark and the false positive rate as a metric, our evaluation suggested that the Fisher's exact test, G-test, and AC test can be used when the number of replications is limited (one or two), whereas the t-test is useful with three or more replicates available. Third, we generalized the G-test to increase the sensitivity of detecting differential protein expression under multiple experimental conditions. Out of 1622 identified R. palustris proteins in the LC-MS/MS experiment, the generalized G-test detected 1119 differentially expressed proteins under six growth conditions. Finally, we studied correlated expression of these 1119 proteins by analyzing pairwise expression correlations and by delineating protein clusters according to expression patterns. Through pairwise expression correlation analysis, we demonstrated that proteins co-located in the same operon were much more strongly coexpressed than those from different operons. Combining cluster analysis with existing protein functional annotations, we identified six protein clusters with known biological significance. In summary, the proposed generalized G-test using spectral count sampling statistics is a viable methodology for robust quantification of relative protein abundance and for sensitive detection of biologically significant differential protein expression under multiple experimental conditions in label-free shotgun proteomics.     

Significance analysis of spectral count data in label-free shotgun proteomics

Spectral counting has become a commonly used approach for measuring protein abundance in label-free shotgun proteomics. At the same time, the development of data analysis methods has lagged behind. Currently most studies utilizing spectral counts rely on simple data transforms and posthoc corrections of conventional signal-to-noise ratio statistics. However, these adjustments can neither handle the bias toward high abundance proteins nor deal with the drawbacks due to the limited number of replicates. We present a novel statistical framework (QSpec) for the significance analysis of differential expression with extensions to a variety of experimental design factors and adjustments for protein properties. Using synthetic and real experimental data sets, we show that the proposed method outperforms conventional statistical methods that search for differential expression for individual proteins. We illustrate the flexibility of the model by analyzing a data set with a complicated experimental design involving cellular localization and time course.     

Utility of gel-free,label-free shotgun proteomics approaches to investigate microorganisms

This review will examine the current situation with label-free, quantitative, shotgun-oriented proteomics technology and discuss the advantages and limitations associated with its capability in capturing and quantifying large portions of proteomes of microorganisms. Such an approach allows (1) comparisons between physiological or genetic states of organisms at the protein level, (2) ‘painting’ of proteomic data onto genome data-based metabolic maps, (3) enhancement of the utility of genomic data and finally (4) surveying of non-genome sequenced microorganisms by taking advantage of available inferred protein data in order to gain new insights into strain-dependent metabolic or physiological capacities. The technology essentially is a powerful addition to systems biology with a capacity to be used to ask hypothesis-driven ‘top-down’ questions or for more empirical ‘bottom-up’ exploration.     

Implementation and evaluation of relative and absolute quantification in shotgun proteomics with label-free methods

Tandem mass spectrometry allows for fast protein identification in a complex sample. As mass spectrometers get faster, more sensitive and more accurate, methods were devised by many academic research groups and commercial suppliers that allow protein research also in quantitative respect. Since label-free methods are an attractive alternative to labeling approaches for proteomics researchers seeking for accurate quantitative results we evaluated several open-source analysis tools in terms of performance on two reference data sets, explicitly generated for this purpose.In this paper we present an implementation, T3PQ (Top 3 Protein Quantification), of the method suggested by Silva and colleagues for LC-MS^E applications and we demonstrate its applicability to data generated on FT-ICR instruments acquiring in data dependent acquisition (DDA) mode. In order to validate this method and to show its usefulness also for absolute protein quantification, we generated a reference data set of a sample containing four different proteins with known concentrations. Furthermore, we compare three other label-free quantification methods using a complex biological sample spiked with a standard protein in defined concentrations. We evaluate the applicability of these methods and the quality of the results in terms of robustness and dynamic range of the spiked-in protein as well as other proteins also detected in the mixture. We discuss drawbacks of each method individually and consider crucial points for experimental designs. The source code of our implementation is available under the terms of the GNU GPLv3 and can be downloaded from sourceforge (http://fqms.svn.sourceforge.net/svnroot/fqms). A tarball containing the data used for the evaluation is available on the FGCZ web server (http://fgcz-data.uzh.ch/public/T3PQ.tgz).     

Functional analysis of proteins and protein species using shotgun proteomics and linear mathematics

Covalent post-translational modification of proteins is the primary modulator of protein function in the cell. It greatly expands the functional potential of the proteome compared to the genome. In the past few years shotgun proteomics-based research, where the proteome is digested into peptides prior to mass spectrometric analysis has been prolific in this area. It has determined the kinetics of tens of thousands of sites of covalent modification on an equally large number of proteins under various biological conditions and uncovered a transiently active regulatory network that extends into diverse branches of cellular physiology. In this review, we discuss this work in light of the concept of protein speciation, which emphasizes the entire post-translationally modified molecule and its interactions and not just the modification site as the functional entity. Sometimes, particularly when considering complex multisite modification, all of the modified molecular species involved in the investigated condition, the protein species must be completely resolved for full understanding. We present a mathematical technique that delivers a good approximation for shotgun proteomics data.     

Characterization of the human myocardial proteome in inflammatory dilated cardiomyopathy by label-free quantitative shotgun proteomics of heart biopsies

Dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) is characterized by contractile dysfunction leading to heart failure. The molecular changes in the human heart associated with this disease have so far mostly been addressed at the gene expression level and only a few studies have analyzed global changes in the myocardial proteome. Therefore, our objective was to investigate the changes in the proteome in patients suffering from inflammatory DCM (iDCM) and chronic viral infection by a comprehensive quantitative approach. Comparative proteomic profiling of endomyocardial biopsies (EMB) from 10 patients with iDCM (left ventricular ejection fraction <40%, symptoms of heart failure) as well as 7 controls with normal left ventricular function and histology was performed by label-free proteome analysis (LC-MS/MS). Mass spectrometric data were analyzed with the Rosetta Elucidator software package. The analysis covered a total of 485 proteins. Among the 174 proteins displaying at least a 1.3-fold change in intensity (p < 0.05), major changes were observed for mitochondrial and cytoskeletal proteins, but also metabolic pathways were affected in iDCM compared to controls. In iDCM patients, we observed decreased levels of mitochondrial proteins involved in oxidative phosphorylation and tricarboxylic acid cycle. Furthermore, deregulation of proteins of carbohydrate metabolism, the actin cytoskeleton, and extracellular matrix remodeling was observed. Proteomic observations were confirmed by gene expression data and immunohistochemistry (e.g. collagen I and VI). This study demonstrates that label-free, mass spectrometry-centered approaches can identify disease dependent alterations in the proteome from small tissue samples such as endomyocardial biopsies. Thus, this technique might allow better disease characterization and may be a valuable tool in potential clinical proteomic studies.     

Phage-induced expression of CRISPR-associated proteins is revealed by shotgun proteomics in Streptococcus thermophilus

The CRISPR/Cas system, comprised of clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats along with their associated (Cas) proteins, protects bacteria and archaea from viral predation and invading nucleic acids. While the mechanism of action for this acquired immunity is currently under investigation, the response of Cas protein expression to phage infection has yet to be elucidated. In this study, we employed shotgun proteomics to measure the global proteome expression in a model system for studying the CRISPR/Cas response in S. thermophilus DGCC7710 infected with phage 2972. Host and viral proteins were simultaneously measured following inoculation at two different multiplicities of infection and across various time points using two-dimensional liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry. Thirty-seven out of forty predicted viral proteins were detected, including all proteins of the structural virome and viral effector proteins. In total, 1,013 of 2,079 predicted S. thermophilus proteins were detected, facilitating the monitoring of host protein synthesis changes in response to virus infection. Importantly, Cas proteins from all four CRISPR loci in the S. thermophilus DGCC7710 genome were detected, including loci previously thought to be inactive. Many Cas proteins were found to be constitutively expressed, but several demonstrated increased abundance following infection, including the signature Cas9 proteins from the CRISPR1 and CRISPR3 loci, which are key players in the interference phase of the CRISPR/Cas response. Altogether, these results provide novel insights into the proteomic response of S. thermophilus, specifically CRISPR-associated proteins, upon phage 2972 infection.     

Tissue proteomics by one-dimensional gel electrophoresis combined with label-free protein quantification

Label-free methods streamline quantitative proteomics of tissues by alleviating the need for metabolic labeling of proteins with stable isotopes. Here we detail and implement solutions to common problems in label-free data processing geared toward tissue proteomics by one-dimensional gel electrophoresis followed by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (geLC MS/MS). Our quantification pipeline showed high levels of performance in terms of duplicate reproducibility, linear dynamic range, and number of proteins identified and quantified. When applied to the liver of an adenomatous polyposis coli (APC) knockout mouse, we demonstrated an 8-fold increase in the number of statistically significant changing proteins compared to alternative approaches, including many more previously unidentified hydrophobic proteins. Better proteome coverage and quantification accuracy revealed molecular details of the perturbed energy metabolism.     

Large-scale identification by shotgun proteomics of proteins expressed in porcine liver and salivary gland

Protein catalogs containing a large number of proteins expressed in a variety of organs can be powerful tools for stem-cell research, because this requires accurate knowledge about how cells differentiate. Salivary gland progenitor (SGP) cells are somatic stem cells isolated from the salivary gland that can differentiate into hepatic or pancreatic cell lineages. Their differentiation state has been assessed by the expression of major protein markers, but to use these cells in regenerative medicine, it will be necessary to establish additional means of quality assessment. We examined the use of shotgun proteomics for porcine salivary gland (a source of SGP cells) and liver (a destination of differentiated SGP cells) for determining the state of SGP cell differentiation. Protein complexes from each organ were digested into peptides and separated by two-dimensional liquid chromatography involving strong cation-exchange chromatography followed by reversed-phase liquid chromatography. The separated peptides were analyzed by on-line electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry using a quadrupole-time of flight mass spectrometer (ESI Q-TOF MS/MS), and the spectra obtained were processed to search peptides against a mammalian database for protein identification. Using this method, we identified 117 proteins in porcine salivary gland and 154 proteins in porcine liver. Of these, 72 and 109 were specific to salivary gland and liver, respectively, and some of these were previously shown to be organ specific. The current study can be utilized in the future as a basis to study the pattern of differentiation in protein expression by stem cells.     

鸟枪法蛋白质鉴定质量控制方法研究进展

鸟枪法串联质谱蛋白质鉴定策略由于其高可靠和高效率而被广泛应用于蛋白质组学研究中,这种方法直接对蛋白质混合物进行酶切,以肽段为鉴定单元,继而推导真实的样品蛋白质．由于利用质谱图推导肽段存在一定的假阳性率,而且直接对蛋白质混合物的酶切也导致了肽段和蛋白质之间关联信息的丢失,所鉴定的蛋白质难免存在部分不可靠结果．因此,蛋白质鉴定的质量控制在蛋白质组学研究中极为重要．蛋白质鉴定的质量控制包含两大类主要方法,其一为利用肽段进行蛋白质组装,当前最常用也被证明最有效的方法是使用简约原则,即用最少的蛋白质解释所有鉴定肽段,现有的方法可以分为布尔型和概率型,其二为鉴定蛋白质的可靠性评估,包括单个蛋白质鉴定置信度和蛋白质鉴定整体水平的假阳性率计算．综合各种可辅助蛋白质鉴定的先验信息,构建普适的概率统计模型,是目前蛋白质鉴定质量控制方法的发展趋势．     

Stoichiometry of chromatin-associated protein complexes revealed by label-free quantitative mass spectrometry-based proteomics

Many cellular proteins assemble into macromolecular protein complexes. The identification of protein–protein interactions and quantification of their stoichiometry is therefore crucial to understand the molecular function of protein complexes. Determining the stoichiometry of protein complexes is usually achieved by mass spectrometry-based methods that rely on introducing stable isotope-labeled reference peptides into the sample of interest. However, these approaches are laborious and not suitable for high-throughput screenings. Here, we describe a robust and easy to implement label-free relative quantification approach that combines the detection of high-confidence protein–protein interactions with an accurate determination of the stoichiometry of the identified protein–protein interactions in a single experiment. We applied this method to two chromatin-associated protein complexes for which the stoichiometry thus far remained elusive: the MBD3/NuRD and PRC2 complex. For each of these complexes, we accurately determined the stoichiometry of the core subunits while at the same time identifying novel interactors and their stoichiometry.     

Spectral index for assessment of differential protein expression in shotgun proteomics

Detecting differentially expressed proteins is a key goal of proteomics. We describe a label-free method, the spectral index, for analyzing relative protein abundance in large-scale data sets derived from biological samples by shotgun proteomics. The spectral index is comprised of two biochemically plausible features: relative protein abundance (assessed by spectral counts) and the number of samples within a group with detectable peptides. We combined the spectral index with permutation analysis to establish confidence intervals for assessing differential protein expression in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid from cystic fibrosis and control subjects. Significant differences in protein abundance determined by the spectral index agreed well with independent biochemical measurements. When used to analyze simulated data sets, the spectral index outperformed four other statistical tests (Student's t-test, G-test, Bayesian t-test, and Significance Analysis of Microarrays) by correctly identifying the largest number of differentially expressed proteins. Correspondence analysis and functional annotation analysis indicated that the spectral index improves the identification of enriched proteins corresponding to clinical phenotypes. The spectral index is easily implemented and statistically robust, and its results are readily interpreted graphically. Therefore, it should be useful for biomarker discovery and comparisons of protein expression between normal and disease states.     

Microwave-assisted protein preparation and enzymatic digestion in proteomics

The combinations of gel electrophoresis or LC and mass spectrometry are two popular approaches for large scale protein identification. However, the throughput of both approaches is limited by the speed of the protein digestion process. Present research into fast protein enzymatic digestion has been focused mainly on known proteins, and it is unclear whether these results can be extrapolated to complex protein mixtures. In this study microwave technology was used to develop a fast protein preparation and enzymatic digestion method for protein mixtures. The protein mixtures in solution or in gel were prepared and digested by microwave-assisted protein enzymatic digestion, which rapidly produces peptide fragments. The peptide fragments were further analyzed by capillary LC and ESI-ion trap-MS or MALDI-TOF-MS. The technique was optimized using bovine serum albumin and then applied to human urinary proteins and yeast lysate. The method enabled preparation and digestion of protein mixtures in solution (human urinary proteins) or in gel (yeast lysate) in 6 or 25 min, respectively. Equivalent (in-solution) or better (in-gel) digestion efficiency was obtained using microwave-assisted protein enzymatic digestion compared with the standard overnight digestion method. This new application of microwave technology to protein mixture preparation and enzymatic digestion will hasten the application of proteomic techniques to biological and clinical research.