Structural basis for the PufX-mediated dimerization of bacterial photosynthetic core complexes

In Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides, the subunit PufX is involved in the dimeric organization of the core complex. Here, we report the 3D reconstruction at 12 A by cryoelectron microscopy of the core complex of Rba. veldkampii, a complex of approximately 300 kDa without symmetry. The core complex is monomeric and constituted by a light-harvesting complex 1 (LH1) ring surrounding a uniquely oriented reaction center (RC). The LH1 consists of 15 resolved alpha/beta heterodimers and is interrupted. Within the opening, PufX polypeptide is assigned at a position facing the Q(B) site of the RC. This core complex is different from a dissociated dimer of the core complex of Rba. sphaeroides revealing that PufX in Rba. veldkampii is unable to dimerize. The absence in PufX of Rba. veldkampii of a G(31)XXXG(35) dimerization motif highlights the transmembrane interactions between PufX subunits involved in the dimerization of the core complexes of Rhodobacter species.     

The 8.5A projection structure of the core RC-LH1-PufX dimer of Rhodobacter sphaeroides

Two-dimensional crystals of dimeric photosynthetic reaction centre-LH1-PufX complexes have been analysed by cryoelectron microscopy. The 8.5A resolution projection map extends previous analyses of complexes within native membranes to reveal the alpha-helical structure of two reaction centres and 28 LH1 alphabeta subunits within the dimer. For the first time, we have achieved sufficient resolution to suggest a possible location for the PufX transmembrane helix, the orientation of the RC and the arrangement of helices within the surrounding LH1 complex. Whereas low-resolution projections have shown an apparent break in the LH1, our current map reveals a diffuse density within this region, possibly reflecting high mobility. Within this region the separation between beta14 of one monomer and beta2 of the other monomer is approximately 6A larger than the average beta-beta spacing within LH1; we propose that this is sufficient for exchange of quinol at the RC Q(B) site. We have determined the position and orientation of the RC within the dimer, which places its Q(B) site adjacent to the putative PufX, with access to the point in LH1 that appears most easily breached. PufX appears to occupy a strategic position between the mobile alphabeta14 subunit and the Q(B) site, suggesting how the structure, possibly coupled with a flexible ring, plays a role in optimizing quinone exchange during photosynthesis.     

Functional and structural analysis of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter veldkampii

In the widely studied purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides, a small transmembrane protein, named PufX, is required for photosynthetic growth and is involved in the supramolecular dimeric organization of the core complex. We performed a structural and functional analysis of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter veldkampii, a related species which evolved independently. Time-resolved optical spectroscopy of R. veldkampii chromatophores showed that the reaction center shares with R. sphaeroides spectral and redox properties and interacts with a cytochrome bc(1) complex through a Q-cycle mechanism. Kinetic analysis of flash-induced cytochrome b(561) reduction indicated a fast delivery of the reduced quinol produced by the reaction center to the cytochrome bc(1) complex. A core complex, along with two light-harvesting LH2 complexes significantly different in size, was purified and analyzed by sedimentation, size exclusion chromatography, mass spectroscopy, and electron microscopy. A PufX subunit identified by MALDI-TOF was found to be associated with the core complex. However, as shown by sedimentation and single-particle analysis by electron microscopy, the core complex is monomeric, suggesting that in R. veldkampii, PufX is involved in the photosynthetic growth but is unable to induce the dimerization of the core complex.     

Protein-Induced Membrane Curvature Investigated through Molecular Dynamics Flexible Fitting

In the photosynthetic purple bacterium Rhodobacter (Rba.) sphaeroides, light is absorbed by membrane-bound light-harvesting (LH) proteins LH1 and LH2. LH1 directly surrounds the reaction center (RC) and, together with PufX, forms a dimeric (RC-LH1-PufX)₂ protein complex. In LH2-deficient Rba. sphaeroides mutants, RC-LH1-PufX dimers aggregate into tubular vesicles with a radius of ∼250-550 Å, making RC-LH1-PufX one of the few integral membrane proteins known to actively induce membrane curvature. Recently, a three-dimensional electron microscopy density map showed that the Rba. sphaeroides RC-LH1-PufX dimer exhibits a prominent bend at its dimerizing interface. To investigate the curvature properties of this highly bent protein, we employed molecular dynamics simulations to fit an all-atom structural model of the RC-LH1-PufX dimer within the electron microscopy density map. The simulations reveal how the dimer produces a membrane with high local curvature, even though the location of PufX cannot yet be determined uniquely. The resulting membrane curvature agrees well with the size of RC-LH1-PufX tubular vesicles, and demonstrates how the local curvature properties of the RC-LH1-PufX dimer propagate to form the observed long-range organization of the Rba. sphaeroides tubular vesicles.     

Role of the N- and C-terminal regions of the PufX protein in the structural organization of the photosynthetic core complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides.

The core complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides is formed by the association of the light-harvesting antenna 1 (LH1) and the reaction center (RC). The PufX protein is essential for photosynthetic growth; it is located within the core in a 1 : 1 stoichiometry with the RC. PufX is required for a fast ubiquinol exchange between the Q(B) site of the RC and the Qo site of the cytochrome bc1 complex. In vivo the LH1-PufX-RC complex is assembled in a dimeric form, where PufX is involved as a structural organizer. We have modified the PufX protein at the N and the C-terminus with progressive deletions. The nine mutants obtained have been characterized for their ability for photosynthetic growth, the insertion of PufX in the core LH1-RC complex, the stability of the dimers and the kinetics of flash-induced reduction of cytochrome b561 of the cytochrome bc1 complex. Deletion of 18 residues at the N-terminus destabilizes the dimer in vitro without preventing photosynthetic growth. The dimer (or a stable dimer) does not seem to be a necessary requisite for the photosynthetic phenotype. Partial C-terminal deletions impede the insertion of PufX, while the complete absence of the C-terminus leads to the insertion of a PufX protein composed of only its first 53 residues and does not affect the photosynthetic growth of the bacterium. Overall, the results point to a complex role of the N and C domains in the structural organization of the core complex; the N-terminus is suggested to be responsible mainly for dimerization, while the C-terminus is thought to be involved mainly in PufX assembly.     

On the effects of PufX on the absorption properties of the light-harvesting complexes of Rhodobacter sphaeroides

Some species of purple bacteria as, e.g., Rhodobacter sphaeroides contain the protein PufX. Concurrently, the light harvesting complexes 1 (LH1) form dimers of open rings. In mutants without PufX, the LH1s are closed rings and photosynthesis breaks down, because the ubiquinone exchange at the reaction center is blocked. However, the main purpose of the LH1 is light harvesting. We therefore investigate the effects that the PufX-induced dimerization has on the absorption properties of the core complexes. Calculations with a dipole model, which compare the photosynthetic efficiency of various configurations of monomeric and dimeric core complexes, show that the dimer can absorb photons directly into the reaction centers more efficiently, but that the performance of the more sophisticated dimeric LH1 antenna degrades faster with structural perturbations. The calculations predict an optimal orientation of the reaction centers relative to the LH1 dimer, which agrees well with the experimentally found configuration. Based on experimental observations indicating that the dimeric core complexes are indeed rather rigid, we hypothesize that in PufX⁺ species the association between the LH1 and the reaction centers is enhanced. This mechanical stabilization of the core complexes would lead to the observed quinone blockage, when PufX is missing.     

Supramolecular organization of the photosynthetic apparatus of Rhodobacter sphaeroides.

Native tubular membranes were purified from the purple non-sulfur bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides. These tubular structures contain all the membrane components of the photosynthetic apparatus, in the relative ratio of one cytochrome bc1 complex to two reaction centers, and approximately 24 bacteriochlorophyll molecules per reaction center. Electron micrographs of negative-stained membranes diffract up to 25 A and allow the calculation of a projection map at 20 A. The unit cell (a = 198 A, b = 120 A and gamma = 103 degrees) contains an elongated S-shaped supercomplex presenting a pseudo-2-fold symmetry. Comparison with density maps of isolated reaction center and light-harvesting complexes allowed interpretation of the projection map. Each supercomplex is composed of light-harvesting 1 complexes that take the form of two C-shaped structures of approximately 112 A in external diameter, facing each other on the open side and enclosing the two reaction centers. The remaining positive density is tentatively attributed to one cytochrome bc1 complex. These features shed new light on the association of the reaction center and the light-harvesting complexes. In particular, the organization of the light-harvesting complexes in C-shaped structures ensures an efficient exchange of ubihydroquinone/ubiquinone between the reaction center and the cytochrome bc1 complex.     

The reaction center-LH1 antenna complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides contains one PufX molecule which is involved in dimerization of this complex.

The PufX membrane protein is essential for photosynthetic growth of Rhodobacter sphaeroides wild-type cells. PufX is associated with the reaction center-light harvesting 1 (RC-LH1) core complex and plays a key role in lateral ubiquinone/ubiquinol transfer. We have determined the PufX/RC stoichiometry by quantitative Western blot analysis and RC photobleaching. Independent of copy number effects and growth conditions, one PufX molecule per RC was observed in native membranes as well as in detergent-solubilized RC-LH1 complexes which had been purified over sucrose gradients. Surprisingly, two gradient bands with significantly different sedimentation coefficients were found to have a similar subunit composition, as judged by absorption spectroscopy and protein gel electrophoresis. Gel filtration chromatography and electron microscopy revealed that these membrane complexes represent a monomeric and a dimeric form of the RC-LH1 complex. Since PufX is strictly required for the isolation of dimeric core complexes, we suggest that PufX has a central structural role in forming dimeric RC-LH1 complexes, thus allowing efficient ubiquinone/ubiquinol exchange through the LH1 ring surrounding the RC.     

Monomeric RC-LH1 core complexes retard LH2 assembly and intracytoplasmic membrane formation in PufX-minus mutants of Rhodobacter sphaeroides

In the model photosynthetic bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides domains of light-harvesting 2 (LH2) complexes surround and interconnect dimeric reaction centre-light-harvesting 1-PufX (RC-LH1-PufX) 'core' complexes, forming extensive networks for energy transfer and trapping. These complexes are housed in spherical intracytoplasmic membranes (ICMs), which are assembled in a stepwise process where biosynthesis of core complexes tends to dominate the early stages of membrane invagination. The kinetics of LH2 assembly were measured in PufX mutants that assemble monomeric core complexes, as a consequence of either a twelve-residue N-terminal truncation of PufX (PufXΔ12) or the complete removal of PufX (PufX(-)). Lower rates of LH2 assembly and retarded maturation of membrane invagination were observed for the larger and less curved ICM from the PufX(-) mutant, consistent with the proposition that local membrane curvature, initiated by arrays of bent RC-LH1-PufX dimers, creates a favourable environment for stable assembly of LH2 complexes. Transmission electron microscopy and high-resolution atomic force microscopy were used to examine ICM morphology and membrane protein organisation in these mutants. Some partitioning of core and LH2 complexes was observed in PufX(-) membranes, resulting in locally ordered clusters of monomeric RC-LH1 complexes. The distribution of core and LH2 complexes in the three types of membrane examined is consistent with previous models of membrane curvature and domain formation (Frese et al., 2008), which demonstrated that a combination of crowding and asymmetries in sizes and shapes of membrane protein complexes drives membrane organisation.     

Native architecture of the photosynthetic membrane from Rhodobacter veldkampii

The photosynthetic membrane in purple bacteria contains several pigment–protein complexes that assure light capture and establishment of the chemiosmotic gradient. The bioenergetic tasks of the photosynthetic membrane require the strong interaction between these various complexes. In the present work, we acquired the first images of the native outer membrane architecture and the supramolecular organization of the photosynthetic apparatus in vesicular chromatophores of Rhodobacter (Rb.) veldkampii. Mixed with LH2 (light-harvesting complex 2) rings, the PufX-containing LH1–RC (light-harvesting complex 1 – reaction center) core complexes appear as C-shaped monomers, with random orientations in the photosynthetic membrane. Within the LH1 fence surrounding the RC, a remarkable gap that is probably occupied (or partially occupied) by PufX is visualized. Sequence alignment revealed that one specific region in PufX may be essential for PufX-induced core dimerization. In this region of ten amino acids in length all Rhodobacter species had five conserved amino acids, with the exception of Rb. veldkampii. Our findings provide direct evidence that the presence of PufX in Rb. veldkampii does not directly govern the dimerization of LH1–RC core complexes in the native membrane. It is indicated, furthermore, that the high membrane curvature of Rb. veldkampii chromatophores (Rb. veldkampii features equally small vesicular chromatophores alike Rb. sphaeroides) is not due to membrane bending induced by dimeric RC–LH1–PufX cores, as it has been proposed in Rb. sphaeroides.     

Experimental evidence that the membrane-spanning helix of PufX adopts a bent conformation that facilitates dimerisation of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides RC-LH1 complex through N-terminal interactions

The PufX polypeptide is an integral component of some photosynthetic bacterial reaction center-light harvesting 1 (RC-LH1) core complexes. Many aspects of the structure of PufX are unresolved, including the conformation of its long membrane-spanning helix and whether C-terminal processing occurs. In the present report, NMR data recorded on the Rhodobacter sphaeroides PufX in a detergent micelle confirmed previous conclusions derived from equivalent data obtained in organic solvent, that the α-helix of PufX adopts a bent conformation that would allow the entire helix to reside in the membrane interior or at its surface. In support of this, it was found through the use of site-directed mutagenesis that increasing the size of a conserved glycine on the inside of the bend in the helix was not tolerated. Possible consequences of this bent helical structure were explored using a series of N-terminal deletions. The N-terminal sequence ADKTIFNDHLN on the cytoplasmic face of the membrane was found to be critical for the formation of dimers of the RC-LH1 complex. It was further shown that the C-terminus of PufX is processed at an early stage in the development of the photosynthetic membrane. A model in which two bent PufX polypeptides stabilise a dimeric RC-LH1 complex is presented, and it is proposed that the N-terminus of PufX from one half of the dimer engages in electrostatic interactions with charged residues on the cytoplasmic surface of the LH1α and β polypeptides on the other half of the dimer.     

Two-dimensional crystals of photosystem II: biochemical characterization, cryoelectron microscopy and localization of the D1 and cytochrome b559 polypeptides

Photosystem II (PS II) is a photosynthetic reaction center found in higher plants which has the unique ability to evolve oxygen from water. Several groups have formed two-dimensional PS II crystals or have isolated PS II complexes and studied them by electron microscopy and image analysis. The majority of these specimens have not been well characterized biochemically and have yielded relatively low resolution two-dimensional projection maps with a variety of unit cell sizes. We report the characterization of the polypeptide and lipid content of tubular crystals of PS II. The crystals contain the reaction center core polypeptides D1, D2, cytochrome b559, as well as the chlorophyll- binding polypeptides (CP) CP47, CP43, CP29, CP26, CP24, and CP22. The lipid composition was similar to the lipids found in the stacked portion of thylakoids. We also report a 2.0-nm resolution projection map determined by electron microscopy and image analysis of frozen, hydrated PS II crystals. This projection map includes information on the portion of the complex buried in the lipid bilayer. The unit cell is a dimer with unit vectors of 17.0 and 11.4 nm separated by an angle of 106.6 degrees. In addition, Fab fragments against D1 and cytochrome b559 were used to localize those two polypeptides, and thus the reaction center, within the PS II complex. The results indicate that D1 and cytochrome b559 are found within one of the heaviest densities of the monomeric unit.     

The 8.5 A projection map of the light-harvesting complex I from Rhodospirillum rubrum reveals a ring composed of 16 subunits.

Two-dimensional crystals from light-harvesting complex I (LHC I) of the purple non-sulfur bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum have been reconstituted from detergent-solubilized protein complexes. Frozen-hydrated samples have been analysed by electron microscopy. The crystals diffract beyond 8 A and a projection map was calculated to 8.5 A. The projection map shows 16 subunits in a 116 A diameter ring with a 68 A hole in the centre. These dimensions are sufficient to incorporate a reaction centre in vivo. Within each subunit, density for the alpha- and the beta-polypeptide chains is clearly resolved, and the density for the bacteriochlorophylls can be assigned. The experimentally determined structure contradicts models of the LHC I presented so far.     

Carotenoids are essential for normal levels of dimerisation of the RC-LH1-PufX core complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides: characterisation of R-26 as a crtB (phytoene synthase) mutant

Carotenoids play important roles in photosynthesis where they are involved in light-harvesting, in photo-protection and in the assembly and structural stability of light-harvesting and reaction centre complexes. In order to examine the effects of carotenoids on the oligomeric state of the reaction centre-light-harvesting 1 -PufX (RC-LH1-PufX) core complex of Rhodobacter sphaeroides two carotenoid-less mutants, TC70 and R-26, were studied. Detergent fractionation showed that in the absence of carotenoids LH2 complexes do not assemble, as expected, but also that core complexes are predominantly found as monomers, although levels of the PufX polypeptide appeared to be unaffected. Analysis of R-26 membranes by electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy reveals arrays of hexagonally packed monomeric RC-LH1-PufX complexes. Transfer of the crtB gene encoding phytoene synthase to TC70 and R-26 restores the normal synthesis of carotenoids demonstrating that the R-26 mutant of Rba. sphaeroides harbours a mutation in crtB, among its other defects. The transconjugant TC70 and R-26 strains containing crtB had regained their ability to assemble wild-type levels of dimeric RC-LH1-PufX core complexes and normal energy transfer pathways were restored, demonstrating that carotenoids are essential for the normal assembly and function of both the LH2 and RC-LH1-PufX complexes in this bacterial photosystem.     

Dimerisation of the Rhodobacter sphaeroides RC-LH1 photosynthetic complex is not facilitated by a GxxxG motif in the PufX polypeptide

In purple photosynthetic bacteria the initial steps of light energy transduction take place in an RC-LH1 complex formed by the photochemical reaction centre (RC) and the LH1 light harvesting pigment-protein. In Rhodobacter sphaeroides, the RC-LH1 complex assembles in a dimeric form in which two RCs are surrounded by an S-shaped LH1 antenna. There is currently debate over the detailed architecture of this dimeric RC-LH1 complex, with particular emphasis on the location and precise function of a minor polypeptide component termed PufX. It has been hypothesised that the membrane-spanning helical region of PufX contains a GxxxG dimerisation motif that facilitates the formation of a dimer of PufX at the interface of the RC-LH1 dimer, and more specifically that the formation of this PufX dimer seeds assembly of the remaining RC-LH1 dimer (J. Busselez et al., 2007). In the present work this hypothesis was tested by site directed mutagenesis of the glycine residues proposed to form the GxxxG motif. Mutation of these glycines to leucine did not decrease the propensity of the RC-LH1 complex to assemble in a dimeric form, as would be expected from experimental studies of the effect of mutation on GxxxG motifs in other membrane proteins. Indeed increased yields of dimer were seen in two of the glycine-to-leucine mutants constructed. It is concluded that the PufX from Rhodobacter sphaeroides does not contain a genuine GxxxG helix dimerisation motif.     

Model for the light-harvesting complex I (B875) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides.

The light-harvesting complex I (LH-I) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides has been modeled computationally as a hexadecamer of alphabeta-heterodimers, based on a close homology of the heterodimer to that of light-harvesting complex II (LH-II) of Rhodospirillum molischianum. The resulting LH-I structure yields an electron density projection map that is in agreement with an 8.5-A resolution electron microscopic projection map for the highly homologous LH-I of Rs. rubrum. A complex of the modeled LH-I with the photosynthetic reaction center of the same species has been obtained by a constrained conformational search. This complex and the available structures of LH-II from Rs. molischianum and Rhodopseudomonas acidophila furnish a complete model of the pigment organization in the photosynthetic membrane of purple bacteria.     

Structure of the dimeric RC–LH1–PufX complex from Rhodobaca bogoriensis investigated by electron microscopy

Electron microscopy and single-particle averaging were performed on isolated reaction centre (RC)—antenna complexes (RC–LH1–PufX complexes) of Rhodobaca bogoriensis strain LBB1, with the aim of establishing the LH1 antenna conformation, and, in particular, the structural role of the PufX protein. Projection maps of dimeric complexes were obtained at 13 Å resolution and show the positions of the 2 × 14 LH1 α- and β-subunits. This new dimeric complex displays two open, C-shaped LH1 aggregates of 13 αβ polypeptides partially surrounding the RCs plus two LH1 units forming the dimer interface in the centre. Between the interface and the two half rings are two openings on each side. Next to the openings, there are four additional densities present per dimer, considered to be occupied by four copies of PufX. The position of the RC in our model was verified by comparison with RC–LH1–PufX complexes in membranes. Our model differs from previously proposed configurations for Rhodobacter species in which the LH1 ribbon is continuous in the shape of an S, and the stoichiometry is of one PufX per RC.     

Molecular architecture of photosynthetic membranes in Rhodobacter sphaeroides: the role of PufX

The effects of the PufX polypeptide on membrane architecture were investigated by comparing the composition and structures of photosynthetic membranes from PufX+ and PufX- strains of Rhodobacter sphaeroides. We show that this single polypeptide profoundly affects membrane morphology, leading to highly elongated cells containing extended tubular membranes. Purified tubular membranes contain helical arrays composed solely of dimeric RC-LH1-PufX (RC, reaction centre; LH, light harvesting) complexes with apparently open LH1 rings. PufX- cells contain crystalline membranes with a pseudo-hexagonal packing of monomeric core complexes. Analysis of purified complexes by electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy shows that LH1 and PufX form a continuous ring of protein around each RC. A model of the tubular membrane is presented with PufX located adjacent to the stained region created by a vacant LH1beta. This arrangement, coupled with a flexible ring, would give the RC QB site transient access to the interstices in the lattice, which might be of functional importance. We discuss the implications of our data for the export of quinol from the RC, for eventual reduction of the cytochrome bc1 complex.     

Electron crystallographic study of photosystem II of the cyanobacterium Synechococcus elongatus

The determination of the structure of PSII at high resolution is required in order to fully understand its reaction mechanisms. Two-dimensional crystals of purified highly active Synechococcus elongatus PSII dimers were obtained by in vitro reconstitution. Images of these crystals were recorded by electron cryo-microscopy, and their analysis revealed they belong to the two-sided plane group p22(1)2(1), with unit cell parameters a = 121 A, b = 333 A, and alpha = 90 degrees. From these crystals, a projection map was calculated to a resolution of approximately 16 A. The reliability of this projection map is confirmed by its close agreement with the recently presented three-dimensional model of the same complex obtained by X-ray crystallography. Comparison of the projection map of the Synechococcus elongatus PSII complex with data obtained by electron crystallography of the spinach PSII core dimer reveals a similar organization of the main transmembrane subunits. However, some differences in density distribution between the cyanobacterial and higher plant PSII complexes exist, especially in the outer region of the complex between CP43 and cytochrome b(559) and adjacent to the B-helix of the D1 protein. These differences are discussed in terms of the number and organization of some of the PSII low molecular weight subunits.     

Structure of the dimeric PufX-containing core complex of Rhodobacter blasticus by in situ atomic force microscopy

We have studied photosynthetic membranes of wild type Rhodobacter blasticus, a closely related strain to the well studied Rhodobacter sphaeroides, using atomic force microscopy. High-resolution atomic force microscopy topographs of both cytoplasmic and periplasmic surfaces of LH2 and RC-LH1-PufX (RC, reaction center) complexes were acquired in situ. The LH2 is a nonameric ring inserted into the membrane with the 9-fold axis perpendicular to the plane. The core complex is an S-shaped dimer composed of two RCs, each encircled by 13 LH1 alpha/beta-heterodimers, and two PufXs. The LH1 assembly is an open ellipse with a topography-free gap of approximately 25 A. The two PufXs, one of each core, are located at the dimer center. Based on our data, we propose a model of the core complex, which provides explanation for the PufX-induced dimerization of the Rhodobacter core complex. The QB site is located facing a approximately 25-A wide gap within LH1, explaining the PufX-favored quinone passage in and out of the core complex.