Lipopolythiourea transfecting agents: lysine thiourea derivatives

Synthetic vectors represent an alternative to recombinant viruses for gene transfer. We have recently explored the transfection potential of a class of noncationic lipids bearing thiourea moieties as DNA-associating headgroups. The encouraging results obtained with lipopolythioureas derived from serinol prompted us to further investigate this family of vectors. In the present study, we considered the transfection properties of a series of derivatives based on a different thiourea polar headgroup bearing a lysine scaffold. The synthesis of these compounds could be readily achieved in three steps with good yields. We found that these lipopolythioureas (LPT) might be considered as alternative systems for gene transfection since their activity reached the same magnitude range as that of cationic vectors in the presence of serum. LPT with 14-carbon length chains appeared to be more efficient as a transfecting agent than the ones with shorter chains. Toxicity studies proved that the hydration film method led to particles well tolerated both by the cells in vitro and by the mice in vivo. The ability to induce gene expression in vivo was demonstrated by intratumoral injection. Finally, biodistribution studies showed that the quantity recovered in blood circulation, 2 h after systemic injection, was improved as compared to that in cationic lipids.     

Alkyl chain moieties of polyamidoamine dendron-bearing lipids influence their function as a nonviral gene vector

We recently developed a novel family of cationic lipids consisting of a polyamidoamine (PAMAM) dendron and two dodecyl chains. Their transfection activity increases with increasing generation of the dendron moiety [Takahashi et al. (2003) Bioconjugate Chem. 14, 764-773]. In the present study, to elucidate the effect of hydrophobic tail moieties of the dendron-bearing lipids, two kinds of PAMAM G3 dendron-bearing lipids were synthesized with different alkyl lengths, DL-G3-2C18 and DL-G3-2C12. Their functions as gene vectors were compared. Irrespective of their different alkyl chain lengths, these dendron-bearing lipids formed complexes with plasmid DNA with similar efficiency. However, their complex sizes differed markedly: DL-G3-2C18 lipoplexes exhibited much smaller diameters than DL-G3-2C12 lipoplexes. Interaction of the lipoplexes with heparin revealed that the DL-G3-2C18 lipoplexes required more heparin than DL-G3-2C12 lipoplexes to cause dissociation of plasmid DNA from the lipoplexes. Although the DL-G3-2C12 lipoplexes and DL-G3-2C18 lipoplexes transfected CV1 cells with similar efficiency in the absence of serum, only the latter retained high transfection activity in the presence of serum. These results indicate that hydrophobic interaction of alkyl chain moieties plays an important role in the increment of stability and the serum-resistant transfection activity for dendron-bearing lipid lipoplexes.     

Biophysical and lipofection studies of DOTAP analogs

In order to investigate the relationship between lipid structure and liposome-mediated gene transfer, we have studied biophysical parameters and transfection properties of monocationic DOTAP analogs, systematically modified in their non-polar hydrocarbon chains. Stability, size and (by means of anisotropy profiles) membrane fluidity of liposomes and lipoplexes were determined, and lipofection efficiency was tested in a luciferase reporter gene assay. DOTAP analogs were used as single components or combined with a helper lipid, either DOPE or cholesterol. Stability of liposomes was a precondition for formation of temporarily stable lipoplexes. Addition of DOPE or cholesterol improved liposome and lipoplex stability. Transfection efficiencies of lipoplexes based on pure DOTAP analogs could be correlated with stability data and membrane fluidity at transfection temperature. Inclusion of DOPE led to rather uniform transfection and anisotropy profiles, corresponding to lipoplex stability. Cholesterol-containing lipoplexes were generally stable, showing high transfection efficiency at low relative fluidity. Our results demonstrate that the efficiency of gene transfer mediated by monocationic lipids is greatly influenced by lipoplex biophysics due to lipid composition. The measurement of fluorescence anisotropy is an appropriate method to characterize membrane fluidity within a defined system of liposomes or lipoplexes and may be helpful to elucidate structure-activity relationships.     

DODAB:monoolein-based lipoplexes as non-viral vectors for transfection of mammalian cells

DNA/Cationic liposome complexes (lipoplexes) have been widely used as non-viral vectors for transfection. Neutral lipids in liposomal formulation are determinant for transfection efficiency using these vectors. In this work, we studied the potential of monoolein (MO) as helper lipid for cellular transfection. Lipoplexes composed of pDNA and dioctadecyldimethylammonium bromide (DODAB)/1-monooleoyl-rac-glycerol (MO) at different molar ratios (4:1, 2:1 and 1:1) and at different cationic lipid/DNA ratios were investigated. The physicochemical properties of the lipoplexes (size, charge and structure), were studied by Dynamic Light Scattering (DLS), Zeta Potential (ζ) and cryo-transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM). The effect of MO on pDNA condensation and the effect of heparin and heparan sulphate on the percentage of pDNA release from the lipoplexes were also studied by Ethidium Bromide (EtBr) exclusion assays and electrophoresis. Cytotoxicity and transfection efficiency of these lipoplexes were evaluated using 293T cells and compared with the golden standard helper lipids 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-hosphoethanolamine (DOPE) and cholesterol (Chol) as well as with a commercial transfection agent (Lipofectamine? LTX). The internalization of transfected fluorescently-labeled pDNA was also visualized using the same cell line. The results demonstrate that the presence of MO not only increases pDNA compactation efficiency, but also affects the physicochemical properties of the lipoplexes, which can interfere with lipoplex-cell interactions. The DODAB:MO formulations tested showed little toxicity and successfully mediated in vitro cell transfection. These results were supported by fluorescence microscopy studies, which illustrated that lipoplexes were able to access the cytosol and deliver pDNA to the nucleus. DODAB:MO-based lipoplexes were thus validated as non-toxic, efficient lipofection vectors for genetic modification of mammalian cells. Understanding the relation between structure and activity of MO-based lipoplexes will further strengthen the development of these novel delivery systems.     

Dependence of the cellular internalization and transfection efficiency on the structure and physicochemical properties of cationic detergent/DNA/liposomes

BACKGROUND: Control of the structure and physicochemical properties of DNA complexed with nonviral vectors is essential for efficient biodistribution and gene delivery to cells. Cationic liposomes interact with DNA giving transfection competent but large and heterogeneous aggregates. On the other hand, cationic detergents condense DNA into small homogeneous but reversible complexes inefficient for transfection. METHODS: In order to combine the favorable features of both vectors, ternary complexes were prepared by adding cationic liposomes to plasmid DNA condensed by cationic detergents. The structure and physicochemical properties of these complexes were investigated by electron microscopy, quasi-elastic light scattering, gel electrophoresis and fluorescence techniques. These data were then correlated with the transfection efficiency and intracellular trafficking of the ternary complexes determined by luciferase gene expression and confocal microscopy, respectively. RESULTS: The ternary complexes were found to form small, homogeneous, globular, stable and positively charged particles with a highly dense and packed lamellar internal structure differing from the multilamellar structure (L(alpha)(C)) of the corresponding lipoplexes. In the presence of serum, the ternary complexes were more efficiently internalized into cells, less toxic and showed 20-fold higher transfection efficiency than lipoplexes. CONCLUSIONS: This study showed that small, monodisperse and highly stable complexes could be obtained by precompaction of DNA with cetyltrimethylammonium bromide, followed by addition of cationic lipids. The higher efficiency of the ternary complexes with respect to their corresponding lipoplexes was related to their internal structure which prevents their dissociation by serum proteins and allows efficient internalization in the target cells.     

Serum-free transfection of CHO-cells with tailor-made unilamellar vesicles

At present, a number of transfection techniques are available to introduce foreign DNA into cells, but still minimal intrusion or interference with normal cell physiology, low toxicity, reproducibility, cost efficiency and successful creation of stable transfectants are highly desirable properties for improved transfection techniques. For all previous transfection experiments done in our labs, using serum-free cultivated host cell lines, an efficiency value of ∼0.1% for selection of stable cell lines has not been exceeded, consequently we developed and improved a transfection system based on defined liposomes, so-called large unilamellar vesicles, consisting of different lipid compositions to facilitate clone selection and increase the probability for creation of recombinant high-production clones. DNA and DOTAP/DOPE or CHEMS/DOPE interact by electrostatic means forming so-called lipoplexes (Even-Chen and Barenholz 2000) and the lipofection efficiency of those lipoplexes has been determined via confocal microscopy. In addition, the expression of the EGFP was determined by FACS to investigate transient as well as stable transfection and the transfection efficiency of a selection of different commercially available transfection reagents and kits has been compared to our tailor-made liposomes.     

Lipid mixing between lipoplexes and plasma lipoproteins is a major barrier for intravenous transfection mediated by cationic lipids

It has been previously shown that transfection activity of cationic liposome/DNA lipoplexes delivered systemically is drastically inhibited by lipoproteins (Tandia, B. M., Vandenbranden, M., Wattiez, R., Lakhdar, Z., Ruysschaert, J. M., and Elouahabi, A. (2003) Mol Ther. 8, 264-273). In this work, we have compared the binding/uptake and transfection activities of DOTAP (N-[1-(2,3-dioleoyloxy)propyl]-N,N,N-trimethylammonium chloride) and diC14-amidine (3-tetradecylamino-N-tert-butyl-N'-tetra-decylpropionamidine)-containing lipoplexes in the presence or absence of purified low density lipoproteins and high density lipoprotein. Binding/uptake of both lipoplexes by the mouse lung endothelial cell line was inhibited to a similar extent in the presence of lipoproteins. In contrast, transfection activity of diC14-amidine-containing lipoplexes was almost completely inhibited (approximately by 95%), whereas approximately 40% transfection activity of DOTAP-containing lipoplexes was preserved in the presence of lipoproteins. Interestingly, the ability of lipoproteins to inhibit the transfection efficiency of lipoplexes was well correlated with their ability to undergo lipid mixing with the cationic lipid bilayer as revealed by fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay. Incubation of lipoplexes with increased doses of lipoproteins resulted in enhanced lipid mixing and reduced transfection activity of the lipoplexes in mouse lung endothelial cells. The role of lipid mixing in transfection was further demonstrated using lipid-mixing inhibitor, lyso-phosphatidylcholine, or activator (dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine). Incorporation of Lyso-PC into diC14-amidine-containing lipoplexes completely abolished their capacity to undergo lipid mixing with lipoproteins and allowed them to reach a high transfection efficiency in the presence of lipoproteins. On the other hand, the incorporation of dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine into DOTAP/DNA lipoplex activated lipid mixing with the lipoproteins and was shown to be detrimental toward the transfection activity of these lipoplexes. Taken together, these results indicate that fusion of lipoplexes with lipoproteins is a limiting factor for in vivo transfection.     

The role of lipid charge density in the serum stability of cationic lipid/DNA complexes

To evaluate the role of lipid charge density in the serum stability of DOTAP-Chol/DNA complexes (lipoplexes), lipid-DNA interactions, extent of aggregation, supercoil content, and in vitro transfection efficiency of lipoplexes were investigated. In general, higher serum concentration destabilized, and increasing molar charge ratio of DOTAP to negatively charged phosphates in the DNA (DOTAP(+)/DNA(-)) stabilized lipoplexes in serum as assessed by the criteria used in this study. The increase of cholesterol content led to increased serum stability, and DOTAP:Chol (mol/mol 1:4)/DNA lipoplex with DOTAP(+)/DNA(-) ratio 4 was the most serum stable formulation of all the formulations examined, and maintained lipid-DNA interactions, did not aggregate and exhibited high in vitro transfection efficiency in 50% (v/v) serum. The increased stability of this formulation could not be explained by the decreased charge density of the lipid component. Furthermore, no single parameter examined in the study could be used to consistently predict the in vitro transfection efficiency of lipoplexes in serum. Surprisingly, no correlation between the maintenance of supercoiled DNA content and in vitro transfection efficiency was found in the study.     

Cell transfection by DNA-lipid complexes — Lipoplexes

Nonviral vectors such as complexes of plasmid DNA with cationic lipids known as lipoplexes are considered as an attractive alternative to virus-based delivery systems. Unlike viruses, lipoplexes do not suffer from immunological and mutational hazards, though the efficiency of lipoplexes is often not sufficient for therapeutic purposes and require higher level of transfection than achieved until now. A number of critical steps responsible for transfection efficiency are discussed here. They include processes of lipoplexes formation, interaction with cell surface, their internalization into cell, and DNA release and delivery into the nucleus. All these processes should be thoroughly studied to be able to enhance the transfection efficacy.     

Multilamellar Cationic Liposomes are Efficient Vectors for in Vitro Gene Transfer in Serum

Abstract

Multilamellar vesicles (MLVs) containing the cationic lipid DOTAP were used as vectors to lipofect a number of culture cell lines in the presence of serum. The lipofection efficiency of lipoplexes made of MLVs and the plasmid pSV-β galactosidase are much less sensitive to the lipofection-inhibitory effect of serum than the conventionally used lipoplexes made of sonicated small unilamellar vesicles (SUVs). In order to determine the factors favoring the lipofection efficiency of MLVs, we measured the size, as well as the cellular association and uptake of MLV and SUV lipoplexes containing DOTAP alone or DOTAP:DOPE (1:1). Electron microscope images of these complexes were taken to confirm their structure and size. The single most important factor that correlates with transfection efficiency in serum is the size of the lipoplex. SUV lipoplexes remain smaller than 300 nm in the presence of serum, and the lipofection efficiencies are low. MLV lipoplexes are larger (>300 nm) and the lipofection efficiency, as well as cellular association and uptake, are much higher than those of SUV lipoplexes. Exceptions are those lipoplexes made of MLVs of DOTAP and DOPE (1:1) combined with DNA at higher charge ratios, which form hexagonal structures and show poor lipofection as well as cellular association and uptake, even if their lipoplex size exceeds 300 nm. This finding lends credence to our theory of the serum inhibition effect upon lipofection, and suggests ways to improve the transfection efficiency in the presence of serum, by fabricating lipoplexes of defined sizes.     

Lipid composition of cationic nanoliposomes implicate on transfection efficiency

Abstract

Cationic liposome (CL)-DNA complexes (lipoplexes) have appeared as leading nonviral gene carriers in worldwide gene therapy clinical trials. Arriving at therapeutic dosages requires the full understanding of the mechanism of transfection. However, using CLs to deliver therapeutic nucleic acids and drugs to target organs have some problems, including low transfection efficiency. The aim of this study was developing novel CLs containing four neutral lipids; cholesterol, 1,2-dioleoyl phosphatidylethanolamine, distearoylphosphatidylcholine and dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine as a helper lipid and dimethyl dioctadecyl ammonium bromide as a cationic lipid to increase transfection efficiency. We have investigated the correlation between number of lipid composition and transfection efficiency. The morphology, size and zeta potential of liposomes and lipoplexes were measured and lipoplexes formation was monitored by gel retardation assay. Transfection efficiency was assessed using firefly luciferase reporter assay. It was found that transfection efficiency markedly depended on liposome to plasmid DNA (pDNA) weight ratio, lipid composition and efficiency of pDNA entrapment. High transfection efficiency of plasmid by four component lipoplexes was achieved. Moreover, lipoplexes showed lower transfection efficiency and less cytotoxicity compared to Lipofectamine?. These results suggest that lipid composition of nanoliposomes is an important factor in control of their physical properties and also yield of transfection.     

Transfection efficiency boost of cholesterol-containing lipoplexes

Most lipid formulations require cholesterol for successful transfection, but the precise reason remains to be more clearly understood. Here, we have studied the effect of cholesterol on the transfection efficiency (TE) of lipoplexes in vitro. Addition of cholesterol to highly effective DC-Chol-DOPE/DNA lipoplexes increases TE, with 40mol% cholesterol yielding about 10-fold improvement. The transfection mechanisms of cholesterol-containing lipoplexes have been investigated by combining dynamic light scattering, synchrotron small angle X-ray scattering, laser scanning confocal microscopy and transfection efficiency measurements. Our results revealed that cholesterol-containing lipoplexes enter the cells partially by membrane fusion and this mechanism accounts for efficient endosomal escape. We also found evidence that formulations with high cholesterol content are not specifically targeted to metabolic degradation. These studies will contribute to rationally design novel delivery systems with superior transfection efficiency.     

Interference of serum with lipoplex-cell interaction: modulation of intracellular processing

We have investigated the mechanism of lipoplex-mediated transfection, employing a dialkyl pyridinium surfactant (SAINT-2), and using serum as a modulator of complex stability and processing. Particle size and stability determine lipoplex internalization, the kinetics of intracellular processing, and transfection efficiency. Clustered SAINT-2 lipoplexes are obtained in the absence of serum (-FBS lipoplexes), but not in its presence (+FBS lipoplexes), or when serum was present during lipoplex formation [FBS], conditions that mimic potential penetration of serum proteins. The topology of DNA in [FBS] lipoplexes shifts from a supercoiled, as in -FBS lipoplexes, to a predominantly open-circular conformation, and is more prone to digestion by DNase. Consistently, atomic force microscopy revealed complexes with tubular extensions, reflecting DNA that protrudes from the lipoplex surface. Interestingly, the internalization of [FBS] lipoplexes is approximately three-fold higher than that of -FBS and +FBS lipoplexes, yet their transfection efficiency is approximately five-fold lower. Moreover, in contrast to -FBS and +FBS complexes, [FBS] complexes were rapidly processed into the late endosomal/lysosomal degradation pathway. Intriguingly, transfection by [FBS] complexes is greatly improved by osmotic rupture of endocytic compartments. Our data imply that constraints in size and morphology govern the complex' ability to interact with and perturb cellular membranes, required for gene release. By extrapolation, we propose that serum may regulate these parameters in an amphiphile-dependent manner, by complex 'penetration' and modulation of DNA conformation.     

Iminothiol/thiourea tautomeric equilibrium in thiourea lipids impacts DNA compaction by inducing a cationic nucleation for complex assembly

Our research on lipidic vectors for transfection led us to develop thiourea lipids able to interact with DNA. Hence, we developed a series of lipopolythioureas based on the strong hydrogen bond donor ability of thiourea. More recently we have reported a branched hydroxylated bis-thiourea derivative with interesting transfecting properties. The last step of the syntheses involved a strong acidic condition, leading to an unstable product upon storage. Therefore we designed a new synthesis in mild acidic conditions. Though they exhibit the same mass, the lipids obtained in the two different conditions differ by their interaction with DNA. We therefore explored the physicochemical properties of these two lipids by different means that we describe in this article. In order to insure easier and reliable ¹³C-NMR studies of the thiourea group we have designed the synthesis of the corresponding ¹³C-labeled thiourea lipids. We have thus shown that when the lipid was submitted to mildly acidic medium; only the thiourea group was observed; while a thiourea/charged and/or uncharged iminothiol tautomeric equilibrium formed when the last step of the synthesis was submitted to low pH. NMR experiments showed that this tautomeric equilibrium could not form in polar solvents. However, UV experiments on the liposomal form of the lipopolythiourea showed the presence of the tautomers. Lipid/DNA interaction consequently differed according to the acidic treatment applied. Eventually, these results revealed that on this particular thiourea lipid, electrostatic interactions due to cationic thioureas are likely to be responsible for DNA compaction and that this tautomeric form of the thiourea could be stabilised by hydrogen bonds in a supramolecular assembly. Nevertheless, this does not reflect a general thiourea lipid/DNA interaction as other thiourea lipids that are able to compact DNA do not undergo an acidic treatment during the final stage of their synthesis.     

Highly fluorinated lipospermines for gene transfer: synthesis and evaluation of their in vitro transfection efficiency

Fluorinated double-chain lipospermines (one or both of these chains being ended by a highly fluorinated tail of various length) which are close analogues of DOGS (Transfectam) were designed as synthetic vectors for gene delivery. For N/P ratios (N = number of amine functions of the lipid; P = number of DNA phosphates) from 0.8 to 10, these lipospermines condensed DNA, with or without the use of DOPE, to form fluorinated lipoplexes. The efficiency of the fluorinated lipoplexes to transfect lung epithelial A549 cells was significantly higher than that of the DOGS lipoplexes. No specific cell toxicity was evidenced for the fluorinated lipoplexes as compared to that of the DOGS ones. The palette of structural elements explored allowed to determine those required for efficient transfection, highlighting the importance of highly fluorinated chains, the unique properties of unsaturated double-chain lipids and of the use of DOPE as helper lipid on transfection.     

Transfection efficiency of lipoplexes for site-directed delivery

Targeted gene delivery is a promising strategy to cure disease on its basic level at the site of interest. The ultrastructure, internalization, and transfection efficiency of lipoplexes was investigated. We found that at a charge ratio (ρ) of 4.0 lipoplexes had optimum characteristics for gene delivery in vitro. To decrease the size of lipoplexes, we used a method of continuous-flow microfluidics. PEGylation of lipoplexes did not hinder internalization, but was found to hamper transfection. To discriminate between uptake and transfection efficiency of lipoplexes, we used fluorescence-based approaches: microscopy and FACS. To this end, GFP plasmid was labeled with Alexa 594, and, in parallel experiments, GFP plasmid was combined with rhodamine-labeled lipid. Our studies confirm that cellular uptake does not imply transfection efficiency, and that hurdles in cellular processing have to be taken before targeted gene delivery becomes an established therapeutic option.     

Evaluation of cationic assemblies constructed with amino acid based lipids for plasmid DNA delivery

We synthesized cationic lipids bearing lysine, histidine, or arginine as a cationic headgroup for use in gene transfer studies. The cationic assemblies formed from lysine- or arginine-type lipids gave unilamellar vesicles (approximately 100 nm diameter), whereas the morphology of the histidine-type lipids was tube-like. The competences of the cationic assemblies were sufficient to form lipoplexes, and the resulting lipoplexes were evaluated in terms of gene expression efficiencies with COS-7 cells. The lysine- or arginine-type lipids exhibited higher gene expression efficiencies than that of Lipofectamine2000, a conventional transgenic reagent, indicating that stable lipoplexes could be prepared between spherical cationic assemblies and plasmid DNA. The gene expression efficiency in relation to the cationic headgroup of the lipids was as follows: lysine > or = arginine > histidine. In addition, gene expression efficiency was enhanced by decreasing the length of the alkyl chain of the hydrophobic moiety. Unlike Lipofectamine2000, no reduction in transfection efficiency in the presence of fetal bovine serum was observed for the lipoplexes formed using synthetic cationic lipids. Moreover, the synthetic cationic lipids revealed remarkably low cytotoxicity compared with Lipofectamine2000. In conclusion, cationic assemblies formed from 1,5-ditetradecyl-N-lysyl-L-glutamate or 1,5-ditetradecyl-N-arginyl-L-glutamate can be used as an effective plasmid DNA delivery system.     

trans-2-Aminocyclohexanol-based amphiphiles as highly efficient helper lipids for gene delivery by lipoplexes

Lipidic amphiphiles equipped with the trans-2-aminocyclohexanol (TACH) moiety are promising pH-sensitive conformational switches (“flipids”) that can trigger a lipid bilayer perturbation in response to increased acidity. Because pH-sensitivity was shown to improve the efficiency of several gene delivery systems, we expected that such flipids could significantly enhance the gene transfection by lipoplexes. Thus a series of novel lipids with various TACH-based head groups and hydrocarbon tails were designed, prepared and incorporated into lipoplexes that contain the cationic lipid 1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonio-propane (DOTAP) and plasmid DNA encoding a luciferase gene. B16F1 and HeLa cells were transfected with such lipoplexes in both serum-free and serum-containing media. The lipoplexes consisting of TACH-lipids exhibited up to two orders of magnitude better transfection efficiency and yet similar toxicity compared to the ones with the conventional helper lipids 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DOPE) or cholesterol. Thus, the TACH-lipids can be used as novel helper lipids for efficient gene transfection with low cytotoxicity.     

Transfection efficiency boost by designer multicomponent lipoplexes

Cationic liposome-DNA complexes (lipoplexes) have emerged as leading nonviral gene carriers in worldwide gene therapy clinical trials. Arriving at therapeutic dosages requires the full understanding of the mechanism of transfection. We investigated the correlation between structural evolution of multicomponent lipoplexes when interacting with cellular lipids, the extent of DNA release and the efficiency in transfecting mouse fibroblast (NIH 3T3), ovarian (CHO) and tumoral myofibroblast-like (A17) cell lines. We show, for the first time, that the transfection pattern increases monotonically with the number of lipid components and further demonstrate by means of synchrotron small angle X- ray scattering (SAXS) that structural changes of lipoplexes induced by cellular lipids correlate with the transfection efficiency. Specifically, inefficient lipoplexes either fused too rapidly upon interaction with anionic lipids or, alternatively, are found to be extremely resistant to solubilization. The most efficient lipoplex formulations exhibited an intermediate behaviour. The extent of DNA unbinding (measured by electrophoresis on agarose gel) correlates with structural evolution of the lipoplexes but DNA-release does not scale with the extent of transfection. The general meaning of our results is of broad interest in the field of non-viral gene delivery: rational adjusting of lipoplex composition to generate the proper interaction between lipoplexes and cellular lipids may be the most appropriate strategy in optimizing synthetic lipid transfection agents.     

Transfection efficiency boost by designer multicomponent lipoplexes

Cationic liposome-DNA complexes (lipoplexes) have emerged as leading nonviral gene carriers in worldwide gene therapy clinical trials. Arriving at therapeutic dosages requires the full understanding of the mechanism of transfection. We investigated the correlation between structural evolution of multicomponent lipoplexes when interacting with cellular lipids, the extent of DNA release and the efficiency in transfecting mouse fibroblast (NIH 3T3), ovarian (CHO) and tumoral myofibroblast-like (A17) cell lines. We show, for the first time, that the transfection pattern increases monotonically with the number of lipid components and further demonstrate by means of synchrotron small angle X- ray scattering (SAXS) that structural changes of lipoplexes induced by cellular lipids correlate with the transfection efficiency. Specifically, inefficient lipoplexes either fused too rapidly upon interaction with anionic lipids or, alternatively, are found to be extremely resistant to solubilization. The most efficient lipoplex formulations exhibited an intermediate behaviour. The extent of DNA unbinding (measured by electrophoresis on agarose gel) correlates with structural evolution of the lipoplexes but DNA-release does not scale with the extent of transfection. The general meaning of our results is of broad interest in the field of non-viral gene delivery: rational adjusting of lipoplex composition to generate the proper interaction between lipoplexes and cellular lipids may be the most appropriate strategy in optimizing synthetic lipid transfection agents.