Similarities and differences between the light and heavy chain Ig variable region gene repertoires in chronic lymphocytic leukemia

Analyses of Ig V(H)DJ(H) rearrangements expressed by B-CLL cells have provided insights into the antigen receptor repertoire of B-CLL cells and the maturation stages of B-lymphocytes that give rise to this disease. However, less information is available about the L chain V gene segments utilized by B-CLL cells and to what extent their characteristics resemble those of the H chain. We analyzed the V(L) and J(L) gene segments of 206 B-CLL patients, paying particular attention to frequency of use and association, mutation status, and LCDR3 characteristics. Approximately 40% of B-CLL cases express V(L) genes that differ significantly from their germline counterparts. Certain genes were virtually always mutated and others virtually never. In addition, preferential pairing of specific V(L) and J(L) segments was found. These findings are reminiscent of the expressed VH repertoire in B-CLL. However unlike the V(H) repertoire, V(L) gene use was not significantly different than that of normal B-lymphocytes. In addition, Vkappa genes that lie more upstream on the germline locus were less frequently mutated than those at the 3' end of the locus; this was not the case for Vlambda genes and is not for V(H) genes. These similarities and differences between the IgH and IgL V gene repertoires expressed in B-CLL suggest some novel features while also reinforcing concepts derived from studies of the IgH repertoire.     

Heavy chain V region diversity in the duck-billed platypus (Ornithorhynchus anatinus): long and highly variable complementarity-determining region 3 compensates for limited germline diversity

In this work, to study the emergence of the H chain V region repertoire during mammalian evolution, we present an analysis of 25 independent H chain V regions from a monotreme, the Australian duck-billed platypus, Ornithorhynchus anatinus. All the sequences analyzed were found to form a single branch within the clan III of mammalian V region sequences in a distance tree. However, compared with a classical V gene family this branch was more diversified in sequence. Sequence analysis indicates that the apparent lack of diversity in germline V segments is well compensated for by relatively long and highly diversified D and N nucleotides. In addition, extensive sequence variation was observed in the framework region 3. Furthermore, at least five and possibly seven different J segments seem to be actively used in recombination. Interestingly, internal cysteine bridges in the complementarity-determining region (CDR)3 loop, or between the CDR2 and CDR3 loops, are found in approximately 36% of the platypus V(H) sequences. Such cysteine bridges have also been observed in cow, camel, and shark. Internal cysteine bridges may play a role in stabilizing long and diversified CDR3 and thereby have a role in increasing the affinity of the Ab-Ag interaction.     

Unusually similar patterns of antibody V segment diversity in distantly related marsupials

A pattern of coevolution between the V gene segments of Ig H and L chains has been noted previously by several investigators. Species with restricted germline V(H) diversity tend to have limited germline V(L) diversity, whereas species with high levels of germline V(H) diversity have more diverse V(L) gene segments. Evidence for a limited pool of V(H) but diverse V(L) gene segments in a South American opossum, Monodelphis domestica, is consistent with this marsupial being an exception to the pattern. To determine whether M. domestica is unique or the norm for marsupials, the V(H) and V(L) of an Australian possum, Trichosurus vulpecula, were characterized. The Ig repertoire in T. vulpecula is also derived from a restricted V(H) pool but a diverse V(L) pool. The V(L) gene segments of T. vulpecula are highly complex and contain lineages that predate the separation of marsupials and placental mammals. Thus, neither marsupial follows a pattern of coevolution of V(H) and V(L) gene segments observed in other mammals. Rather, marsupial V(H) and V(L) complexity appears to be evolving divergently, retaining diversity in V(L) perhaps to compensate for limited V(H) diversity. There is a high degree of similarity between the V(H) and V(L) in M. domestica and T. vulpecula, with the majority of V(L) families being shared between both species. All marsupial V(H) sequences isolated so far form a common clade of closely related sequences, and in contrast to the V(L) genes, the V(H) likely underwent a major loss of diversity early in marsupial evolution.     

The structural repertoire of the human V kappa domain.

In humans, the gene for the V kappa domain is produced by the recombination of one of 40 functional V kappa segments and one of five functional J kappa segments. We have analysed the sequences of these germline segments and of 736 rearranged V kappa genes to determine the repertoire of main chain conformations, or canonical structures, they encode. Over 96% of the sequences correspond to one of four canonical structures for the first antigen binding loop (L1) and one canonical structure for the second antigen binding loop (L2). Junctional diversity produces some variation in the length of the third antigen binding loop (L3) and in the identity of residues at the V kappa-J kappa join. However, this is limited and 70% of the rearranged sequences correspond to one of three known canonical structures for the L3 region. Furthermore, we show that the canonical structures selected during the primary response are conserved during affinity maturation: the key residues that determine the conformations of the antigen binding loops are unmutated or undergo conservative mutation. The implications of these results for immune recognition are discussed.     

The repertoire of human germline VH sequences reveals about fifty groups of VH segments with different hypervariable loops.

We have used the polymerase chain reaction and VH family-based primers to clone and sequence 74 human germline VH segments from a single individual and built a directory to include all known germline sequences. The directory contains 122 VH segments with different nucleotide sequences, 83 of which have open reading frames. The directory indicates that the structural diversity of the germline repertoire for antigen binding is fixed by about 50 groups of VH segments: each group encodes identical hypervariable loops. The directory should help in mapping the VH locus, in estimating somatic mutation and VH segment usage and in designing and constructing synthetic antibody libraries.     

Multi‐constraint computational design suggests that native sequences of germline antibody H3 loops are nearly optimal for conformational flexibility

The limited size of the germline antibody repertoire has to recognize a far larger number of potential antigens. The ability of a single antibody to bind multiple ligands due to conformational flexibility in the antigen‐binding site can significantly enlarge the repertoire. Among the six complementarity determining regions (CDRs) that generally comprise the binding site, the CDR H3 loop is particularly variable. Computational protein design studies showed that predicted low energy sequences compatible with a given backbone structure often have considerable similarity to the corresponding native sequences of naturally occurring proteins, indicating that native protein sequences are close to optimal for their structures. Here, we take a step forward to determine whether conformational flexibility, believed to play a key functional role in germline antibodies, is also central in shaping their native sequence. In particular, we use a multi‐constraint computational design strategy, along with the Rosetta scoring function, to propose that the native sequences of CDR H3 loops from germline antibodies are nearly optimal for conformational flexibility. Moreover, we find that antibody maturation may lead to sequences with a higher degree of optimization for a single conformation, while disfavoring sequences that are intrinsically flexible. In addition, this computational strategy allows us to predict mutations in the CDR H3 loop to stabilize the antigen‐bound conformation, a computational mimic of affinity maturation, that may increase antigen binding affinity by preorganizing the antigen binding loop. In vivo affinity maturation data are consistent with our predictions. The method described here can be useful to design antibodies with higher selectivity and affinity by reducing conformational diversity. Proteins 2009. © 2008 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Shaping of Human Germline IgH Repertoires Revealed by Deep Sequencing

To understand better how selection processes balance the benefits of Ig repertoire diversity with the risks of autoreactivity and nonfunctionality of highly variable IgH CDR3s, we collected millions of rearranged germline IgH CDR3 sequences by deep sequencing of DNA from mature human naive B cells purified from four individuals and analyzed the data with computational methods. Long HCDR3 regions, often components of HIV-neutralizing Abs, appear to derive not only from incorporation of long D genes and insertion of large N regions but also by usage of multiple D gene segments in tandem. However, comparison of productive and out-of-frame IgH rearrangements revealed a selection bias against long HCDR3 loops, suggesting these may be disproportionately either poorly functional or autoreactive. Our data suggest that developmental selection removes HCDR3 loops containing patches of hydrophobicity, which are commonly found in some auto-antibodies, and at least 69% of the initial productive IgH rearrangements are removed from the repertoire during B cell development. Additionally, we have demonstrated the potential utility of this new technology for vaccine development with the identification in all four individuals of related candidate germline IgH precursors of the HIV-neutralizing Ab 4E10.     

Somatic insertions and deletions shape the human antibody repertoire

We have sequenced the heavy and light chain genes from 365 IgG(+) B cells and found that 24 (6.5 %) contain somatically introduced insertions or deletions. These insertions and deletions are clustered at "hot-spots" in the antigen-binding site and frequently result in the creation of new combinations of canonical loop structures or entirely new loops that are not present in the human germline repertoire, but are similar to those seen in other species. Somatic insertion and deletion therefore provides a further mechanism for introducing structural diversity into antibodies in addition to somatic point mutation and receptor editing, which have small (single amino acid changes) and large (chain replacement) impacts on structural diversity, respectively.     

Detection of a unique human V kappa IV germline gene by a cloned cDNA probe.

We have cloned the cDNA encoding the KIV chain of a human antibody with specificity against the major carbohydrate antigen of Streptococcus A. The cDNA has been used as a genetic probe to estimate the number of germline VKIV genes in human DNA. The presence of unique hybridizing bands on digestion of human DNA with several restriction endonucleases and the equivalence of the DNA in a band to a single gene per haploid genome point to the conclusion that there is a unique human VKIV germline gene. The corollary of this conclusion is that the diversity of human VKIV chains must be exclusively due to somatic mutation. This is supported by examination of the sequences of human KIV chain genes and their KIV chain products. Fusion of the unique germline VKIV gene (1) with one of several JK segments, followed by somatic mutations in the V region of the rearranged KIV gene, can account for the known sequences. The restricted germline gene repertoire may account for the small proportion of human KIV chains in the human K chain sequence library (2).     

Fully synthetic human combinatorial antibody libraries (HuCAL) based on modular consensus frameworks and CDRs randomized with trinucleotides

By analyzing the human antibody repertoire in terms of structure, amino acid sequence diversity and germline usage, we found that seven V(H) and seven V(L) (four Vkappa and three Vlambda) germline families cover more than 95 % of the human antibody diversity used. A consensus sequence was derived for each family and optimized for expression in Escherichia coli. In order to make all six complementarity determining regions (CDRs) accessible for diversification, the synthetic genes were designed to be modular and mutually compatible by introducing unique restriction endonuclease sites flanking the CDRs. Molecular modeling verified that all canonical classes were present. We could show that all master genes are expressed as soluble proteins in the periplasm of E. coli. A first set of antibody phage display libraries totalling 2x10(9) members was created after cloning the genes in all 49 combinations into a phagemid vector, itself devoid of the restriction sites in question. Diversity was created by replacing the V(H) and V(L) CDR3 regions of the master genes by CDR3 library cassettes, generated from mixed trinucleotides and biased towards natural human antibody CDR3 sequences. The sequencing of 257 members of the unselected libraries indicated that the frequency of correct and thus potentially functional sequences was 61 %. Selection experiments against many antigens yielded a diverse set of binders with high affinities. Due to the modular design of all master genes, either single binders or even pools of binders can now be rapidly optimized without knowledge of the particular sequence, using pre-built CDR cassette libraries. The small number of 49 master genes will allow future improvements to be incorporated quickly, and the separation of the frameworks may help in analyzing why nature has evolved these distinct subfamilies of antibody germline genes.     

Functional consequences of insertions and deletions in the complementarity-determining regions of human antibodies

Insertions and deletions of nucleotides in the genes encoding the variable domains of antibodies are natural components of the hypermutation process, which may expand the available repertoire of hypervariable loop lengths and conformations. Although insertion of amino acids has also been utilized in antibody engineering, little is known about the functional consequences of such modifications. To investigate this further, we have introduced single-codon insertions and deletions as well as more complex modifications in the complementarity-determining regions of human antibody fragments with different specificities. Our results demonstrate that single amino acid insertions and deletions are generally well tolerated and permit production of stably folded proteins, often with retained antigen recognition, despite the fact that the thus modified loops carry amino acids that are disallowed at key residue positions in canonical loops of the corresponding length or are of a length not associated with a known canonical structure. We have thus shown that single-codon insertions and deletions can efficiently be utilized to expand structure and sequence space of the antigen-binding site beyond what is encoded by the germline gene repertoire.     

VDJ genes in VHa2 allotype-suppressed rabbits. Limited germline VH gene usage and accumulation of somatic mutations in D regions

In this study we investigate the molecular genetic basis for VHa- Ig. Knowing that the expression of VHa allotype Ig is suppressed by neonatal injection of rabbits with anti-VHa allotype antibody, and that the decreased level of VHa allotype Ig, VHa+, in the suppressed rabbits is compensated for by an increase in VHa- Ig, we determined the nucleotide sequences of 41 VDJ genes from a2/a2 rabbits neonatally suppressed for the expression of a2 Ig. We compared these nucleotide sequences to each other and identified two groups of VH sequences. We predict that the molecules of each group are encoded by one germline VH gene. Inasmuch as VHa+ Ig is encoded predominantly by one germline VH gene, VH1, it appears that more than 95% of the VDJ repertoire of rabbits may be encoded by as few as three germline VH genes. A genomic VDJ gene whose VH sequence was similar to those of group I molecules was expressed in vitro and was shown by ELISA to encode molecules of the VHa- allotype, y33. Analysis of the D regions in the VDJ gene indicated that germline D2b and D3 gene segments were preferentially used in the VDJ gene rearrangement. A comparison of sequences of D regions of the 41 VDJ gene rearrangements in 3-, 6-, and 9-wk-old rabbits to sequences of germline D gene segments showed an accumulation of mutations in the D region. Inasmuch as we have previously shown that V regions of rabbit VDJ genes are diversified, in part, by somatic gene conversion, it appears now that rabbit VDJ genes diversify by a combination of somatic mutation and somatic gene conversion.     

An immunoglobulin heavy chain variable region gene is generated from three segments of DNA: VH, D and JH

We have determined the sequences of separate germline genetic elements which encode two parts of a mouse immunglobulin heavy chain variable region. These elements, termed gene segments, are heavy chain counterparts of the variable (V) and joining (J) gene segments of immunoglobulin light chains. The VH gene segment encodes amino acids 1-101 and the JH gene segment encodes amino acids 107-123 of the S107 phosphorylcholine-binding VH region. This JH gene segment and two other JH gene segments are located 5' to the mu constant region gene (Cmu) in germline DNA. We have also determined the sequence of a rearranged VH gene encoding a complete VH region, M603, which is closely related to S107. In addition, we have partially determined the VH coding sequences of the S107 and M167 heavy chain mRNAs. By comparing these sequences to the germline gene segments, we conclude that the germline VH and JH gene segments do not contain at least 13 nucleotides which are present in the rearranged VH genes. In S107, these nucleotides encode amino acids 102-106, which form part of the third hypervariable region and consequently influence the antigen-binding specificity of the immunoglobulin molecule. This portion of the variable region may be encoded by a separate germline gene segment which can be joined to the VH and JH gene segments. We term this postulated genetic element the D gene segment, referring to its role in the generation of heavy chain diversity. Essentially the same noncoding sequences are found 3' to the VH gene segment and as inverse complements 5' to two JH gene segments. These are the same conserved nucleotides previously found adjacent to light chain V and J gene segments. Each conserved sequence consists of blocks of seven and ten conserved nucleotides which are separated by a spacer of either 11 or 22 nonconserved nucleotides. The highly conserved spacing, corresponding to one or two turns of the DNA helix, maintains precise spatial orientations between blocks of conserved nucleotides. Gene segments which can join to one another (VK and JK, for example) always have spacers of different lengths. Based on these observations, we propose a model for variable region gene rearrangement mediated by proteins which recognize the same conserved sequences adjacent to both light and heavy chain immunoglobulin gene segments.     

Characterization of the human Ig heavy chain antigen binding complementarity determining region 3 using a newly developed software algorithm, JOINSOLVER

We analyzed 77 nonproductive and 574 productive human V(H)DJ(H) rearrangements with a newly developed program, JOINSOLVER. In the productive repertoire, the H chain complementarity determining region 3 (CDR3(H)) was significantly shorter (46.7 +/- 0.5 nucleotides) than in the nonproductive repertoire (53.8 +/- 1.9 nucleotides) because of the tendency to select rearrangements with less TdT activity and shorter D segments. Using criteria established by Monte Carlo simulations, D segments could be identified in 71.4% of nonproductive and 64.4% of productive rearrangements, with a mean of 17.6 +/- 0.7 and 14.6 +/- 0.2 retained germline nucleotides, respectively. Eight of 27 D segments were used more frequently than expected in the nonproductive repertoire, whereas 3 D segments were positively selected and 3 were negatively selected, indicating that both molecular mechanisms and selection biased the D segment usage. There was no bias for D segment reading frame (RF) use in the nonproductive repertoire, whereas negative selection of the RFs encoding stop codons and positive selection of RF2 that frequently encodes hydrophilic amino acids were noted in the productive repertoire. Except for serine, there was no consistent selection or expression of hydrophilic amino acids. A bias toward the pairing of 5' D segments with 3' J(H) segments was observed in the nonproductive but not the productive repertoire, whereas V(H) usage was random. Rearrangements using inverted D segments, DIR family segments, chromosome 15 D segments and multiple D segments were found infrequently. Analysis of the human CDR3(H) with JOINSOLVER has provided comprehensive information on the influences that shape this important Ag binding region of V(H) chains.     

New human V beta genes and polymorphic variants.

To extend the characterization of the human V beta gene repertoire, we utilized anchored or V beta-specific polymerase chain reaction to generate a large (approximately 200 clones) beta-chain library from the thymus of a single individual. Nine new V beta genes were identified, including single members for two new subfamilies (V beta 22 and 23), two new members of the V beta 5 subfamily, and one new member each for V beta 2, 6, 7, 9, and 12. Full-length sequences were also obtained for the published partial sequences of V beta 3, 5.3, 9.1, and 13.4, and additional nucleotides for V beta 7.1 and V beta 7.2. Based on consensus sequences from multiple clones, apparent allelic variants for six V beta genes (V beta 2.1, 5.3, 7.2, 8.2, 13.4, and 16) were also tentatively identified. Population and family studies for two of these (V beta 2.1 and 16) further confirmed that these V beta were alleles and not separate genes. Nonconservative substitutions in some of these alleles, as well as in previously identified alleles, are located at the hypervariable loops or the framework region. These findings indicate that V beta gene polymorphism appears to be significant in humans and might be the result of selective pressure imposed by conventional Ag (hypervariable loops) or superantigens (framework regions).     

Restricted Ig H chain V gene usage in the human antibody response to Haemophilus influenzae type b capsular polysaccharide

The mechanisms that govern the content of the human antibody repertoire are poorly understood. To investigate the antibody response to a clinically relevant Ag, we have produced heterohybridomas secreting human antibodies directed against the capsular polysaccharide of Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib PS). Immune lymphocytes were harvested 7 days after immunization with either of two vaccine formulations, a plain polysaccharide vaccine (Hib PS) or a polysaccharide-protein conjugate of Hib PS and diphtheria toxoid (Hib PS-D). H chain V region gene nucleic acid sequences were determined for five stable hybridomas. All use members of the VHIII gene family and are 83% to 98% homologous to two candidate germ-line sequences. A variety of D and JH segments are used. Thus the Ig H chain repertoire appears to be restricted to a limited group of VHIII family members. The previously reported expression of homologous sequences in the human fetal repertoire suggests that the inability of young children to respond to this Ag is not caused by deficiencies of these important elements early in development. The restricted use of VHIII gene segments suggests that this gene family plays a pivotal role in the immune response to this important childhood pathogen.     

Structural repertoire of the human VH segments.

The VH gene segments produce the part of the VH domains of antibodies that contains the first two hypervariable regions. The sequences of 83 human VH segments with open reading frames, from several individuals, are currently known. It has been shown that these sequences are likely to form a high proportion of the total human repertoire and that an individual's gene repertoire produces about 50 VH segments with different protein sequences. In this paper we present a structural analysis of the amino acid sequences produced by the 83 segments. Particular residue patterns in the sequences of V domains imply particular main-chain conformations, canonical structures, for the hypervariable regions. We show that, in almost all cases, the residue patterns in the VH segments imply that the first hypervariable regions have one of three different canonical structures and that the second hypervariable regions have one of five different canonical structures. The different observed combinations of the canonical structures in the first and second regions means that almost all sequences have one of seven main-chain folds. We describe, in outline, structures of the antigen binding site loops produced by nearly all the VH segments. The exact specificity of the loops is produced by (1) sequence differences in their surface residues, particularly at sites near the centre of the combining site, and (2) sequence differences in the hypervariable and framework regions that modulate the relative positions of the loops.     

The reported germline repertoire of human immunoglobulin kappa chain genes is relatively complete and accurate

We describe a bioinformatic analysis of germline and rearranged immunoglobulin kappa chain (IGK) gene sequences, performed in order to assess the completeness and reliability of the reported IGK repertoire. In contrast to the reported heavy-chain gene repertoire, which includes many dubious sequences, only five IGK variable gene (IGKV) alleles appear to have been reported in error. There was, however, insufficient evidence to justify removing these IGKV genes from the germline repertoire. Bioinformatic analysis of apparent mismatches between reported germline genes and 1,863 expressed IGK sequences suggested the existence of two unreported IGKV polymorphisms. Genomic screening of 12 individuals led to the confirmation of both of these polymorphisms, IGKV1-16*02 and IGKV2-30*02. We also show that in contrast to the heavy chain, the IGK repertoire is dominated by sequences that use just a handful of kappa variable (IGKV) and junction (IGKJ) gene pairs. There is also little modification of IGKV and IGKJ genes by the processes of exonuclease removal and N nucleotide addition. The expressed IGK repertoire therefore lacks diversity and the junction region is particularly constrained. Remarkably, the analysis of a dataset of 435 relatively unmutated rearranged kappa genes showed that ten amino acid sequences account for almost 10% of the rearrangements, with identical sequences being derived from as many as seven independent sources. Such dominant sequences are likely to have important roles in the operation of the humoral immune response.