Recognition of 5-methyl-CG and CG base pairs in duplex DNA with high stability using antiparallel-type triplex-forming oligonucleotides with 2-guanidinoethyl-2′-deoxynebularine

The formation of triplex DNA is a site-specific recognition method that directly targets duplex DNA. However, triplex DNA formation is generally formed for the GC and AT base pairs of duplex DNA, and there are no natural nucleotides that recognize the CG and TA base pairs, or even the 5-methyl-CG (^5mCG) base pair. Moreover, duplex DNA, including ^5mCG base pairs, epigenetically regulates gene expression in vivo, and thus targeting strategies are of biological importance. Therefore, the development of triplex-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) with artificial nucleosides that selectively recognize these base pairs with high affinity is needed. We recently reported that 2′-deoxy-2-aminonebularine derivatives exhibited the ability to recognize ^5mCG and CG base pairs in triplex formation; however, this ability was dependent on sequences. Therefore, we designed and synthesized new nucleoside derivatives based on the 2′-deoxy-nebularine (dN) skeleton to shorten the linker length connecting to the hydrogen-bonding unit in formation of the antiparallel motif triplex. We successfully demonstrated that TFOs with 2-guanidinoethyl-2′-deoxynebularine (guanidino-dN) recognized ^5mCG and CG base pairs with very high affinity in all four DNA sequences with different adjacent nucleobases of guanidino-dN as well as in the promoter sequences of human genes containing ^5mCG base pairs with a high DNA methylation frequency.     

Binding of T and T analogs to CG base pairs in antiparallel triplexes.

The goal of this study was to address antiparallel triplex formation at duplex targets that do not conform to a strict oligopurine.oligopyrimidine motif. We focused on the ability of natural bases and base analogs incorporated into oligonucleotide third strands to bind to so-called CG inversions. These are sites where a cytosine base is present in an otherwise purine-rich strand of a duplex target. Using a 26-base-triplet test system, we found that of the standard bases, only thymine (T) shows substantial binding to CG inversions. This is quantitatively similar to the report of Beal and Dervan [Science (1991), 251, 1360-1363]. Binding to CG inversions was only slightly weaker than binding to AT base pairs. Binding of T to CG inversions was also evaluated in two other sequences, with qualitatively similar results. Six different analogs of thymine were also tested for binding to CG inversions and AT base pairs. Significant changes in affinity were observed. In particular, 5-fluoro-2'-deoxyuridine was found to increase affinity for CG inversions as well as for AT base pairs. Studies with oligonucleotides containing pyridin-2-one or pyridin-4-one suggest that thymine O4 plays a critical role in the T.CG interaction. Possible models to account for these observations are discussed.     

Approaches to Enhance the Binding Affinity and Nuclease Stability of Triplex Forming Oligonucleotides

Abstract

The ability of simple azole nucleosides to promote antiparallel triplex formation at non-homopurine duplex targets was explored. It was also shown that spermidine-cholesterol conjugation is effective in enhancing cellular uptake and stability of oligonucleotides.     

DNA triple helix formation at target sites containing several pyrimidine interruptions: stabilization by protonated cytosine or 5-(1-propargylamino)dU.

DNase I footprinting has been used to study the formation of parallel triplexes at oligopurine target sequences which are interrupted by pyrimidines at regular intervals. TA interruptions are targeted with third strand oligonucleotides containing guanine, generating G x TA triplets, while CG base pairs are targeted with thymine, forming T x CG triplets. We have attempted to optimize the stability of these complexes by varying the base composition and sequence arrangement of the target sites, and by replacing the third strand thymines with the positively charged analogue 5-(1-propargylamino)dU (U(P)). For the target sequence (AAAT)(5)AA, in which pyrimidines are positioned at every fourth residue, triplex formation with TG-containing oligonucleotides is only detected in the presence of a triplex-binding ligand, though stable triplexes were detected at the target site (AAAAAT)(3)AAAA. Triplex stability at targets containing pyrimidines at every fourth residue is increased by introducing guanines into the duplex repeat unit using the targets (AGAT)(5)AA and (ATGA)(5)AA. In contrast, placing C(+) x GC triplets on the 5'-side of G x TA, using the target (AGTA)(5)TT, produces complexes of lower stability. We have attempted further to increase the stability of these complexes by using the positively charged thymine base analogue U(P), and have shown that (TU(P)TG)(5)TT forms a more stable complex with target (AAAT)(5)AA than the unmodified third strand, generating a footprint in the absence of a triplex-binding ligand. Triplex formation at (AGTA)(5)AA is improved by using the modified oligonucleotide (TCGU(P))(5)TT, generating a complex in which the charged triplets C(+) x GC and U(P) x AT alternate with uncharged triplets. In contrast, placing U(P) x AT triplets adjacent to C(+) x GC, using the third strand oligonucleotide (U(P)CGT)(5)TT, reduces triplex formation, while the third strand with both substitutions, (U(P)CGU(P))(5)TT, produces a complex with intermediate stability. It appears that, although adjacent U(P) x AT triplets form stable triplexes, placing U(P) x AT adjacent to C(+) x GC is unfavorable. Similar results were obtained with fragments containing CG inversions within the oligopurine tract, though triplexes at (AAAAAC)(3)AA were only detected in the presence of a triplex-binding ligand. Placing C(+) x GC on the 5'-side of T x CG triplets also reduces triplex formation, while a 3'-C(+) x GC produces complexes with increased stability.     

Synthesis of Triple Helix Forming Oligonucleotides with a Stretched Phosphodiester Backbone

Abstract

Total synthesis of novel DMT-phosphoramidites of thymidine (11 and 15) and 2′-deoxyguanosine (8 and 20) have been accomplished. The utility of these modified building blocks in the preparation of triple helix forming oligodeoxyribonucleotides with a stretched phosphodiester backbone has been evaluated. It was found that the oligonucleotides with extended backbones were unable to enhance the binding to duplex targets containing CG or TA base pairs.     

Triplex-forming ability of oligonucleotides containing 1-aryl-1,2,3-triazole nucleobases linked via a two atom-length spacer

Phosphoramidites containing 2-propynyloxy or 1-butyn-4-yl as nucleobase precursors were synthesized and introduced into oligonucleotides using an automated DNA synthesizer. Copper-catalyzed alkyne-azide 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of the oligonucleotides with various azides gave the corresponding triazolylated oligonucleotides, triplex-forming ability of these synthetic oligonucleotides with double-stranded DNA targets was evaluated by UV melting experiments. It was found that nucleobases containing 2-(1-m-carbonylaminophenyl-1,2,3-triazol-4-yl)ethyl units likely interacted with A of a TA base pair in a parallel triplex DNA.     

Site-resolved energetics in DNA triple helices containing G*TA and T*CG triads

Recognition of specific sites in double-helical DNA by triplex-forming oligonucleotides has been limited until recently to sites containing homopurine-homopyrimidine sequences. G*TA and T*CG triads, in which TA and CG base pairs are specifically recognized by guanine or by thymine, have now extended this recognition code to DNA target sites of mixed base sequences. In the present work, we have obtained a characterization of the stabilities of G*TA and T*CG triads, and of the effects of these triads upon canonical triads, in triple-helical DNA. The three DNA triplexes investigated are formed by the folding of the 31-mers d(GAAXAGGT(5)CCTYTTCT(5)CTTZTCC) with X = G, T, or C, Y = C, A, or G, and Z = C, G, or T. We have measured the exchange rates of imino protons in each triad of the three triplexes using nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. The exchange rates are used to map the local free energy of structural stabilization in each triplex. The results indicate that the stability of Watson-Crick base pairs in the G*TA and T*CG triads is comparable to that of Watson-Crick base pairs in canonical triads. The presence of G*TA and T*CG triads, however, destabilizes neighboring canonical triads, two or three positions removed from the G*TA/T*CG site. Moreover, the long-range destabilizing effects induced by the T*CG triad are larger than those induced by the G*TA triad. These findings reveal the molecular basis for the lower overall stability of G*TA- and T*CG-containing triplexes.     

Oligodeoxyribonucleotide length and sequence effects on intermolecular purine-purine-pyrimidine triple-helix formation.

The binding of guanosine/thymidine-rich oligodeoxyribonucleotides containing various deletions, extensions, and point mutations to polypurine DNA targets was investigated by DNase I footprinting. Intermolecular purine-purine-pyrimidine triple-helical DNA formation was best achieved using oligonucleotides 12 nucleotides in length. Longer oligonucleotides were slightly weaker in binding affinity, whereas shorter oligonucleotides were considerably weaker. Oligonucleotide extensions had a slight effect on triplex formation, while single point mutations located near the oligonucleotide ends had a greater effect. In the cases of extensions and point mutations, changes to the 3' end of the oligonucleotide had a consistently greater effect on triplex formation than changes to the 5' end. Such differences in triplex-forming ability were not caused by an intrinsic property of these oligonucleotides, since the same point mutated oligonucleotides could bind with high affinity to duplex DNAs containing complementary sites. Taken together, our data suggest that there may be an asymmetry involved in the process of purine-motif triplex formation, with interactions between the 3' end of the oligonucleotide and complementary sequences on the target duplex DNA being dominant.     

Recognition of CG interrupting site by W-shaped nucleoside analogs (WNA) having the pyrazole ring in an anti-parallel triplex DNA

We have previously developed W-shaped nucleoside analogs (WNA) for recognition of TA and CG interrupting sites, which are the intrinsic limitation for the formation of a stable triplex DNA by the natural triplex-forming oligonucleotide (TFO). However, the stabilization effect of WNA is dependent on the neighboring nucleobases at both sides of the WNA analogs within the TFO. Considering that the base is located at the hindered site constructed of three bases of the target duplex and the TFO, it was expected that replacement of the pyrimidine base of the WNA analog with a smaller pyrazole ring might avoid steric repulsion to produce a greater stability for the triplex. In this study, the new WNA analogs bearing the pyrazole ring, 3-aminopyrazole (AP), and 4-methyl-3-pyrazole-5-on (MP) were synthesized, incorporated into the TFOs, then their stabilizing effects on the triplexes were evaluated. A remarkable success was illustrated by the fact that the TFO containing WNA-βAP in the 3′G-WNA-G-5′ sequence formed a stable triplex with selectivity to the CG interrupting site where the previous WNA-βC did not induce the triplex formation.     

Cationic oligonucleotides can mediate specific inhibition of gene expression in Xenopus oocytes.

Base-specific hydrogen bonding between an oligonucleotide and the purines in the major groove of a DNA duplex provide an approach to selective inhibition of gene expression. Oligonucleotide-mediated triplex formation in vivo may be enhanced by a number of different chemical modifications. We have previously described an in vitro analysis of triplex formation using oligonucleotides containing internucleoside phosphate linkages modified with the cation N , N -diethyl-ethylenediamine (DEED). When compared with unmodified oligonucleotides of identical base composition, DEED-modified oligonucleotides were better able to form DNA triplexes under conditions that approximate the pH, magnesium and potassium levels found in vivo . Here we report the ability of DEED-modified oligonucleotides to inhibit the expression of plasmid DNA injected into Xenopus oocytes. Inhibition is specific to plasmids containing a triplex formation target and sensitive to sequence alteration in the triplex forming target site. Inhibition of gene expression was nearly complete when oligonucleotide and plasmid were mixed together prior to injection. Inhibition was partial when oligonucleotide was injected first and not evident when plasmid was injected and allowed to form chromatin prior to oligonucleotide injection. Thus, access to DNA is a determining factor in effective triplex inhibition of gene expression.     

Four base recognition by triplex-forming oligonucleotides at physiological pH

We have achieved recognition of all 4 bp by triple helix formation at physiological pH, using triplex-forming oligonucleotides that contain four different synthetic nucleotides. BAU [2′-aminoethoxy-5-(3-aminoprop-1-ynyl)uridine] recognizes AT base pairs with high affinity, ^MeP (3-methyl-2 aminopyridine) binds to GC at higher pHs than cytosine, while ^APP (6-(3-aminopropyl)-7-methyl-3H-pyrrolo[2,3-d]pyrimidin-2(7H)-one) and S [N-(4-(3-acetamidophenyl)thiazol-2-yl-acetamide)] bind to CG and TA base pairs, respectively. Fluorescence melting and DNase I footprinting demonstrate successful triplex formation at a 19mer oligopurine sequence that contains two CG and two TA interruptions. The complexes are pH dependent, but are still stable at pH 7.0. BAU, ^MeP and ^APP retain considerable selectivity, and single base pair changes opposite these residues cause a large reduction in affinity. In contrast, S is less selective and tolerates CG pairs as well as TA.     

Positively charged oligonucleotides overcome potassium-mediated inhibition of triplex DNA formation.

The formation of triplex DNA using unmodified, purine-rich oligonucleotides (ODNs) is inhibited by physiologic levels of potassium. Changing negative phosphodiester bonds in a triplex forming oligonucleotide (TFO) to neutral linkages causes a small increase in triplex formation. When phosphodiester bonds in a TFO are converted to positively-charged linkages the formation of triplex DNA increases dramatically. In the absence of KCl, a 17mer TFO containing 11 positively-charged linkages at a concentration of 0.2 microM converts essentially all of a 30 bp target duplex to a triplex. Less than 15% of the target duplex is shifted by 2 microMolar of the unmodified TFO. In 130 mM KCl, triplex formation is undetectable using the unmodified TFO, while triplex formation is nearly complete with 2 microM positively-charged TFO. With increasing potassium, TFOs containing a higher proportion of modified linkages show enhanced triplex formation compared with those less modified. In contrast with unmodified TFOs, triplex formation with more heavily modified TFOs can occur in the absence of divalent cations. We conclude that replacement of phosphodiester bonds with positively-charged phosphoramidate linkages results in more efficient triplex formation, suggesting that these compounds may prove useful for in vivo applications.     

DNA triple helix formation at oligopurine sites containing multiple contiguous pyrimidines.

We have used DNase I footprinting to assess the formation of triple helices at 15mer oligopurine target sites which are interrupted by several (up to four) adjacent central pyrimidine residues. Third strand oligonucleotides were designed to generate complexes containing central (X.TA)nor (X.CG)n triplets (X = each base in turn) surrounded by C+.GC and T.AT triplets. It has previously been shown that G.TA and T.CG are the most stable triplets for recognition of single TA and CG interruptions. We show that these triplets are the most useful for recognizing consecutive pyrimidine interruptions and find that addition of each pyrimidine residue leads to a 30-fold decrease in third strand affinity. The addition of 10 microM naphthylquinoline triplex-binding ligand stabilizes each complex so that all the oligonucleotides produce footprints at similar concentrations (0.3 microM). Targets containing two pyrimidines are only bound by oligonucleotides generating (G.TA)2 and (T.CG)2 with a further 30-fold decrease in affinity. (G.TA)2 is slightly more stable than (T.CG)2. In the presence of the triplex-binding ligand the order of stability is (G.TA)2 > (C.TA)2 > (T.TA)2 > (A.TA)2 and (T.CG)2 > (C.CG)2 > (G.CG)2 = (A.CG)2. No oligonucleotide footprints are generated at target sites containing three consecutive pyrimidines, though addition of 10 microM triplex-binding ligand produces stable complexes with oligonucleotides generating (G.TA)3, (T.CG)3 and (C.CG)3, with a further 30-fold reduction in affinity. No footprints are generated at targets containing four Ts, though the ligand induces a weak interaction with the oligonucleotide generating (T.CG)4.     

Selectivity and affinity of triplex-forming oligonucleotides containing 2'-aminoethoxy-5-(3-aminoprop-1-ynyl)uridine for recognizing AT base pairs in duplex DNA

We have used DNase I footprinting, fluorescence and ultraviolet (UV) melting experiments and circular dichroism to demonstrate that, in the parallel triplex binding motif, 2′-aminoethoxy-5-(3-aminoprop-1-ynyl)uridine (bis-amino-U, BAU) has very high affinity for AT relative to all other Watson–Crick base pairs in DNA. Complexes containing two or more substitutions with this nucleotide analogue are stable at pH 7.0, even though they contain several C.GC base triplets. These modified triplex-forming oligonucleotides retain exquisite sequence specificity, with enhanced discrimination against YR base pairs (especially CG). These properties make BAU a useful base analogue for the sequence-specific creation of stable triple helices at pH 7.0.     

Triplex forming ability of oligonucleotides containing 2'-O-methyl-2-thiouridine or 2-thiothymidine

The triplex forming ability of oligonucleotides containing 2'-O-methyl-2-thiouridine (s2Um) and 2-thiothymidine (s2T) was studied. The UV melting experiments revealed that triplex forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) containing both s2Um or s2T stabilized significantly parallel triplexes. The main reason for stabilization of triplexes was due to the stacking effect of the 2-thiocarbonyl group. Moreover, it turned out that these modified TFOs had a high selectivity in recognition of a matched Hoogsteen base from a mismatched one.     

Strong, specific, monodentate G-C base pair recognition by N7-inosine derivatives in the pyrimidine.purine-pyrimidine triple-helical binding motif.

The nucleoside analogs 7-(2'-deoxy-alpha-D-ribofuranosyl)hypoxanthine (alpha7H,1), 7-(2'-deoxy-beta-D-ribofuranosyl)hypoxanthine (beta7H,2) and 7-7-(2'-O-methyl-beta-D- ribofuranosyl)hypoxanthine (beta7HOMe,3) were prepared and incorporated into triplex forming oligodeoxynucleotides, designed to bind to DNA in the parallel (pyrimidine.purine-pyrimidine) motif. By DNase I footprinting techniques and UV-melting curve analysis it was found that, at pH 7. 0, the 15mer oligonucleotides d(TTTTTMeCTXTMeCTMeCTMeCT) (MeC = 5-methyl-deoxycytidine, X =beta7H,beta7HOMe) bind to a DNA target duplex forming a H.G-C base triple with equal to slightly increased (10-fold) stability compared to a control oligodeoxynucleotide in which the hypoxanthine residue is replaced by MeC. Remarkably, triple-helix formation is specific to G-C base pairs and up to 40 microM third strand concentration, no stable triplex exhibiting H.A-T, H.T-A or H.C-G base arrangements could be found (target duplex concentration approximately 0.1 nM). Multiply substituted sequences containing beta7H residues either in an isolated [d(TTTTTbeta7HTbeta7HTbeta7HTbeta7HTbeta7HT)] or in a contiguous [d(TTTbeta7Hbeta7Hbeta7Hbeta7HTTTTbeta7HTTT)] manner still form triplexes with their targets of comparable stability as the control (MeC-containing) sequences at pH 7.0 and high salt or spermine containing buffers. General considerations lead to a structural model in which the recognition of the G-C base pair by hypoxanthine takes place via only one H-bond of the N-H of hypoxanthine to N7 of guanine. This model is supported by a molecular dynamics simulation. A general comparison of the triplex forming properties of oligonucleotides containing beta7H with those containing MeC or N7-2'-deoxyguanosine (N7G) reveals that monodentate recognition in the former case can energetically compete with bidentate recognition in the latter two cases.     

Triplex formation by oligonucleotides containing novel deoxycytidine derivatives.

Homopurine sequences of duplex DNA are binding sites for triplex-forming oligodeoxyribopyrimidines. The interactions of synthetic duplex DNA targets with an oligodeoxyribopyrimidine containing N4-(6-amino-2-pyridinyl)deoxycytidine (1), a nucleoside designed to interact with a single C-G base pair interruption of the purine target tract, was studied by UV melting, circular dichroism spectroscopy and dimethylsulfate alkylation experiments. Nucleoside 1 supports stable triplex formation at pH 7.0 with formation of a 1-Y-Z triad, where Y-Z is a base pair in the homopurine tract of the target. Selective interaction was observed when Y-Z was C-G, although A-T and, to a lesser extent, T-A and G-C base pairs were also recognized. The circular dichroism spectra of the triplex having a 1-C-G triad were similar to those of a triplex having a C(+)-G-C triad, suggesting that the overall structures of the two triplexes are quite similar. Removal of the 6-amino group from 1 essentially eliminated triplex formation. Reaction of a triplex having the 1-C-G triad with dimethylsulfate resulted in a 50% reduction of methylation of the G residue of this triad. In contrast, the G of a similar triplex containing a U-C-G triad was not protected from methylation by dimethylsulfate. These results are consistent with a binding mode in which the 6-amino-2-pyridinyl group of 1 spans the major groove of the target duplex at the 1-C-G binding site and forms a hydrogen bond with the O6 of G. An additional stabilizing hydrogen bond could form between the N4 of the imino tautomer of 1 and the N4 amino group of C.     

Distance and affinity dependence of triplex-induced recombination

Triplex-forming oligonucleotides (TFOs) have the potential to serve as gene therapeutic agents on the basis of their ability to mediate site-specific genome modification via induced recombination. However, high-affinity triplex formation is limited to polypurine/polypyrimidine sites in duplex DNA. Because of this sequence restriction, careful analysis is needed to identify suitable TFO target sites within or near genes of interest. We report here an examination of two key parameters which influence the efficiency of TFO-induced recombination: (1) binding affinity of the TFO for the target site and (2) the distance between the target site and the mutation to be corrected. To test the influence of binding affinity, we compared induced recombination in human cell-free extracts by a series of G-rich oligonucleotides with an identical base composition and an increasing number of mismatches in the third strand binding code. As the number of mismatches increased and, therefore, binding affinity decreased, induced recombination frequency also dropped. There was an apparent threshold at an equilibrium dissociation constant (K(d)) of 1 x 10(-)(7) M. In addition, TFO chemical modification with N,N-diethylethylenediamine (DEED) internucleoside linkages to confer improved binding was found to yield increased levels of induced recombination. To test the ability of triplex formation to induce recombination at a distance, episomal targets with informative reporter genes were constructed to contain polypurine TFO target sites at varying distances from the mutations to be corrected. TFO-induced recombination in mammalian cells between a plasmid vector and a donor oligonucleotide was detected at distances ranging from 24 to 750 bp. Together, these results indicate that TFO-induced recombination requires high-affinity binding but can affect sites hundreds of base pairs away from the position of triplex formation.     

Secondary binding sites for heavily modified triplex forming oligonucleotides

In order to enhance DNA triple helix stability synthetic oligonucleotides have been developed that bear amino groups on the sugar or base. One of the most effective of these is bis-amino-U (B), which possesses 5-propargylamino and 2′-aminoethoxy modifications. Inclusion of this modified nucleotide not only greatly enhances triplex stability, but also increases the affinity for related sequences. We have used a restriction enzyme protection, selection and amplification assay (REPSA) to isolate sequences that are bound by the heavily modified 9-mer triplex-forming oligonucleotide B₆CBT. The isolated sequences contain A_n tracts (n = 6), suggesting that the 5′-end of this TFO was responsible for successful triplex formation. DNase I footprinting with these sequences confirmed triple helix formation at these secondary targets and demonstrated no interaction with similar oligonucleotides containing T or 5-propargylamino-dU.     

Biosensor detection of triplex formation by modified oligonucleotides

Due to the instability of DNA oligonucleotides in biological solutions, antisense or antigene therapies aimed at modulation of specific gene expression will most likely require the use of oligonucleotides with modified backbones. Here, we examine the use of a surface plasmon resonance biosensor (BIAcore) to compare triplex-directed binding of modified oligonucleotides targeted to a region of the murine c-myc promoter. We describe optimization of experimental conditions to minimize nonspecific interactions between the oligonucleotides and the sensor chip surface, and the limitations imposed by certain backbones and sequence types. The abilities of pyrimidine oligonucleotides with various modified backbones to form specific triple helices with an immobilized hairpin duplex were readily determined using the biosensor. Modification of the third-strand oligonucleotide with RNA or 2(')-O-methyl RNA was found to enhance triplex formation, whereas phosphorothioate or phosphotriester substitutions abrogated it. A comparison of these results to DNase I footprinting experiments using the same oligonucleotides showed complete agreement between the two sets of data.