Quantitation of endogenous liver apolipoprotein B mRNA editing

The mRNA for apolipoprotein B is translated into either a high molecular weight (apo BH) or low molecular weight (apo BL) form of the protein depending on a novel form of RNA processing known as RNA editing. Apo BH mRNA editing is both tissue-specific and hormonally regulated and involves transition of cytidine to uridine at codon 2153 thereby converting a glutamine codon (CAA) to a translational stop codon (UAA). Three methods for quantitating the endogenous levels of liver apo B mRNA editing were compared: (1) Southern blot hybridization with discriminative thermal washes, (2) competimer-hybridization with discriminative thermal washes and (3) competimer-polymerase chain reaction (competimer-PCR). The data suggest that hybridization and PCR can yield similar quantitation when competing oligonucleotides are used. Based on competimer-PCR it is proposed that 40% and 85% of normal rat liver and small intestine apo B mRNA (respectively) are edited.     

Apolipoprotein B mRNA editing: a new tier for the control of gene expression.

Two forms of apolipoprotein (apo) B are found in mammals. The shorter form is translated from an edited mRNA in which a specific cytidine base is deaminated to a uridine, creating a new stop codon. Apo B mRNA editing is mediated by a site-specific cytidine deaminase that recognizes a downstream target sequence in the RNA. The enzyme has no energy or cofactor requirements and no RNA component, and thus bears no obvious relationship to RNA processing events such as splicing or polyadenylation. While apo B mRNA editing activity may have arrived late in evolution to target dietary lipid to the liver in mammals, the discovery of the editing activity in tissues and cells that do not express apo B suggests a more widespread role in the generation of RNA and protein diversity.     

Sequence requirements for apolipoprotein B RNA editing in transfected rat hepatoma cells

Apolipoprotein (apo) B mRNA undergoes a novel tissue-specific editing reaction, which replaces a genomically templated cytidine with uridine. This substitution converts codon 2153 from glutamine (CAA) in apo B100 mRNA to a stop codon (UAA) in apoB48 mRNA (Powell, L. M., Wallis, S. C., Pease, R. J., Edwards, Y. H., Knott, T. J., and Scott, J. (1987) Cell 50, 831-840). To examine sequences in the human apoB mRNA required for the editing reaction, a series of deletion mutants around the cytidine conversion site was prepared and transfected into a rat hepatoma cell line (McArdle 7777). This cell makes both apoB100 and apoB48. Editing was detected by a primer extension assay on cDNA that had been amplified by the polymerase chain reaction. RNAs of between 2385 and 26 nucleotides spanning the conversion site underwent similar levels of conversion. Editing was confirmed by cloning and sequencing of cDNA corresponding to the transfected RNAs. Conversion did not occur in transfected human hepatoblastoma (HepG2) or epithelial carcinoma (HeLa) cell lines, which do not make apoB48. These results verify that apoB48 is generated by a genuine tissue-specific RNA editing reaction and show that 26 nucleotides of apoB mRNA are sufficient for editing.     

Apolipoprotein B mRNA editing. Direct determination of the edited base and occurrence in non-apolipoprotein B-producing cell lines

In humans, apolipoprotein (apo) B48 is synthesized in the intestine as an obligatory constituent of chylomicrons. Apolipoprotein B48 is identical to the amino-terminal 2152 amino acids (240 kDa) of apoB100 and is translated from an edited apoB mRNA in which codon 2153 has been converted from glutamine (CAA) to what is recognized as a premature stop codon (UAA). To determine whether the apoB mRNA editing in fact converts cytosine 6666 in codon 2153 to uracil, we incubated a synthetic apoB RNA containing 32P-labeled cytosines in an in vitro editing system prepared from rabbit enterocytes. The in vitro edited RNA was purified and digested to nucleoside 5'-monophosphates, which were analyzed on two-dimensional thin-layer chromatography. We found that the edited base co-migrated with authentic uridine 5'-monophosphate. Thus, cytosine 6666 is converted to uracil, most likely by a nucleotide-specific cytosine deaminase. To determine whether apoB mRNA editing occurs in cell lines that do not synthesize apoB, we stably transfected a high expression vector containing 354 base pairs of apoB sequence into 18 different cell lines. We found apoB mRNA editing activity in five osteosarcoma cell lines and one epidermoid cell line, none of which synthesizes any detectable apoB. Thus, apoB mRNA editing occurs in cell lines that do not synthesize apoB, which suggests that mRNA editing may be a common biological phenomenon in eukaryotic cells.     

The neurofibromatosis type I messenger RNA undergoes base-modification RNA editing.

A functional mooring sequence, known to be required for apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA editing, exists in the mRNA encoding the neurofibromatosis type I (NF1) tumor suppressor. Editing of NF1 mRNA modifies cytidine in an arginine codon (CGA) at nucleotide 2914 to a uridine (UGA), creating an in frame translation stop codon. NF1 editing occurs in normal tissue but was several-fold higher in tumors. In vitro editing and transfection assays demonstrated that apoB and NF1 RNA editing will take place in both neural tumor and hepatoma cells. Unlike apoB, NF1 editing did not demonstrate dependence on rate-limiting quantities of APOBEC-1 (the apoB editing catalytic subunit) suggesting that different trans-acting factors may be involved in the two editing processes.     

An additional editing site is present in apolipoprotein B mRNA.

Human intestinal apolipoprotein (apo) B mRNA undergoes a C to U RNA editing at nucleotide 6666 to generate a translation stop at codon 2153, which defines the carboxy-terminal of apo B48. Here we show that two of eleven human intestinal cDNAs spanning residue 6666 were edited from a genomically-encoded C to a T at residue 6802 as well as at residue 6666. This additional editing converts Thr (ACA) codon 2198 to Ile (AUA). Synthetic RNA including the nucleotide 6802 was edited in vitro by intestinal extracts at 10-15% of the editing efficiency of nucleotide 6666. A sequence is identified as important for recognition by the editing activity. No secondary structural homology was identified between the two edited sites. No other sequence in the region between 6411 and 6893 nucleotides of apo B mRNA was found to be edited in vivo or in vitro. Apo B RNA editing extracts from intestine did not edit maize cytochrome oxidase II mRNA.     

Three distinct RNA sequence elements are required for efficient apolipoprotein B (apoB) RNA editing in vitro.

Apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA is edited in rat liver and intestine to convert a CAA glutamine codon to a UAA translational stop codon by the direct conversion of cytidine to uridine at nucleotide 6666. We have proposed the 'mooring sequence' model for apoB RNA editing, in which editing complexes (editosomes) assemble on specific apoB mRNA flanking sequences to direct this site-specific editing event. One sequence element (approx. nts 6671-81, the presumed 'mooring sequence') has been previously identified as necessary for editing. We have identified two additional sequence elements which are necessary for efficient editing: (1) a 5' 'Regulator' region which modulates editing efficiency and (2) a 'Spacer' region between the editing site and the 3' mooring sequence, whose distance is critical for efficient editing. Utilizing this data, we have induced editing at a cryptic site and have defined a 22 nucleotide 'cassette' of specific apoB sequence which is sufficient to support wild-type levels of editing in vitro in a background of distal apoB RNA sequence.     

Apolipoprotein B mRNA sequences 3'' of the editing site are necessary and sufficient for editing and editosome assembly.

Apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA is edited in rat liver and intestine through the direct conversion of cytidine to uridine at nucleotide 6666. Recently, we have proposed the 'Mooring Sequence' model, in which editing complexes (editosomes) assemble on specific apoB mRNA flanking sequences to direct this site-specific editing event. To test this model, apoB mRNA deletion and translocation mutants were constructed and analyzed. Specific sequences 3' of the editing site were absolutely required for editing, while specific sequences and bulk RNA 5' of the editing site were required for efficient editing. Translocation of apoB 3' flanking sequences induced editing of an upstream cytidine, demonstrating that 3' sequences are necessary and sufficient to direct editing in vitro. 3' flanking sequences were also shown to be necessary and sufficient for editosome complex assembly. These data provide strong support for a 'Mooring Sequence' model in which 3' apoB flanking sequences direct editosome assembly and subsequent editing in vitro, while 5' flanking sequences enhance these functions.     

Phylogenetic analysis of the apolipoprotein B mRNA-editing region. Evidence for a secondary structure between the mooring sequence and the 3' efficiency element

Apolipoprotein (apo) B mRNA editing is the deamination of C(6666) to uridine, which changes the codon at position 2153 from a genomically encoded glutamine (CAA) to an in-frame stop codon (UAA). The apoB mRNA-editing enzyme complex recognizes the editing region of the apoB pre-mRNA with exquisite precision. Four sequence elements spanning 139 nucleotides (nt) on the apoB mRNA have been identified that specify this precision. In cooperation with the indispensable mooring sequence and spacer element, a 5' efficiency element and a 3' efficiency element enhance editing in vitro. A phylogenetic comparison of 32 species showed minor differences in the apoB mRNA sequence, and the apoB mRNA from 31 species was robustly edited in vitro. However, guinea pig mRNA was poorly edited. Compared with the consensus sequences of these 31 species, guinea pig apoB mRNA has three variations in the 3' efficiency element, and the conversion of these to the consensus sequence increased editing to the levels in the other species. From this information, a model for the secondary structure was formulated in which the mooring sequence and the 3' efficiency element form a double-stranded stem. Thirty-one mammalian apoB mRNA sequences are predicted to form this stem positioning C(6666) two nucleotides upstream of the stem. However, the guinea pig apoB mRNA has a mutation in the 3' efficiency element (C(6743) to U) that predicts an extension of the stem and hence the lower editing efficiency. A test of this model demonstrated that a single substitution at 6743 (U to C) in the guinea pig apoB mRNA, that should reduce the stem, enhanced editing, and mutations in the 3' efficiency element that extended the stem for three base pairs dramatically reduced editing. Furthermore, the addition of a 20-nucleotide 3' efficiency element RNA, to a 58-nucleotide guinea pig apoB mRNA lacking the 3' efficiency element more than doubled the in vitro editing activity. Based on these results, a model is proposed in which the mooring sequence and the 3' efficiency element form a double-stranded stem, thus suggesting a mechanism of how the 3' efficiency element enhances editing.     

Separate pyrimidine-nucleotide pools for messenger-RNA and ribosomal-RNA synthesis in HeLa S3 cells.

Kinetic analyses of mRNA and 28-S RNA labeling [3H]uridine revealed distinctly different steady-state specific radioactivities finally reached for uridine in mRNA and 28-S RNA when exogenous [3H]uridine was kept constant for several cell doubling times. While the steady-state label of (total) UTP and of uridine in mRNA responded to the same extent to a suppression of pyrimidine synthesis de novo by high uridine concentrations in the culture medium, uridine in 28-S RNA was scarcely influenced. Similar findings were obtained with respect to labeling of cytidine in the various RNA species due to an equilibration of UTP with CTP [5-3H]Uridine is also incorporated into deoxycytidine of DNA, presumably via dCTP. The specific radioactivity of this nucleosidase attained the same steady-state value as UTP, uridine in mRNA and cytidine in mRNA. The data indicate the existence of two pyrimidine nucleotide pools. One is a large, general UTP pool comprising the bulk of the cellular UTP and serving nucleoplasmic nucleic acid formation (uridine and cytidine in mRNA, deoxycytidine in DNA). Its replenishment by de novo synthesis can be suppressed completely by exogenous uridine above 100 muM concentrations. A second, very small UTP (and CTP) pool with a high turnover provides most of the precursors for nucleolar RNA formation (rRNA). This pool is not subject to feedback inhibition by extracellular uridine to an appreciable extent. Determinations of (total) UTP turnover also show that the bulk of cellular RNA (rRNA) cannot be derived from the large UTP pool.     

APOBEC-1 dependent cytidine to uridine editing of apolipoprotein B RNA in yeast

Cytidine to uridine editing of apolipoprotein B (apoB) mRNA requires the cytidine deaminase APOBEC-1 as well as a tripartite sequence motif flanking a target cytidine in apoB mRNA and an undefined number of auxiliary proteins that mediate RNA recognition and determine site-specific editing. Yeast engineered to express APOBEC-1 and apoB mRNA supported editing under conditions of late log phase growth and stationary phase. The cis-acting sequence requirements and the intracellular distribution of APOBEC-1 in yeast were similar to those described in mammalian cells. These findings suggest that auxiliary protein functions necessary for the assembly of editing complexes, or ‘editosomes’, are expressed in yeast and that the distribution of editing activity is to the cell nucleus.