The effect of temperature fluctuations on oxygen consumption and ammonia excretion of underyearling Lake Inari Arctic charr

Underyearling Lake Inari Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus were acclimated to 11·0) C for 3 weeks, and then one group was maintained at 11·0) C and others were exposed to 14·4) Cconst, 17·7) C_const or a diel fluctuating temperature of 14·3° C ± 1° C (14·3° C_fluc). Routine rates of oxygen consumption and ammonia excretion were measured over 10 days before the temperature change and over 31 days following the change. Measurements were made on fish that were feeding and growing. The temperature increase produced an immediate increase in oxygen consumption. There was then a decline over the next few days, suggesting that thermal acclimation was rapid. For groups exposed to constant temperature there was an increase in oxygen consumption ( M _accl, mg kg⁻¹ h⁻¹) with increasing temperature ( T ), the relationship being approximated by an exponential model: M _accl= 46·53e0·^{086 T} . At 14·3° C_fluc oxygen consumption declined during the 3–4 days following the temperature shift, but remained higher than at 14·4° C_const. This indicates that small temperature fluctuations have some additional influences that increase metabolic rate. Ammonia excretion rates showed diel variations. Excretion was lower at 11° C_const than at other temperatures, and increases in temperature had a significant effect on ammonia excretion rate. Fluctuating (14·3° C_fluc) temperature did not influence ammonia excretion relative to constant temperature (14·4° C_const).     

Thermal tolerance of a northern population of striped bass Morone saxatilis

Thermal tolerance of age 0+ year Shubenacadie River (Nova Scotia, Canada) striped bass Morone saxatilis juveniles (mean ± s . e . fork length, L _F, 19·2 ± 0·2 cm) acclimated in fresh water to six temperatures from 5 to 30° C was measured by both the incipient lethal technique (72 h assay), and the critical thermal method ( C _m). The lower incipient lethal temperature ranged from 2·4 to 11·3° C, and the upper incipient lethal temperature ( I _U) from 24·4 to 33·9° C. The area of thermal tolerance was 618° C². In a separate experiment, the I _U of large age 2+ year fish (34·4 ± 0·5 cm L _F) was 1·2 and 0·6° C lower ( P < 0·01) than smaller age 1+ year fish (21·8 ± 0·5 cm L _F) at acclimation temperatures of 16 and 23° C. Using the C _m, loss of equilibrium occurred at 27·4–37·7° C, loss of righting response at 28·1–38·4° C and onset of spasms at 28·5–38·8° C, depending on acclimation temperature. The linear regression slopes for these three responses were statistically similar (0·41; P > 0·05), but the intercepts differed (25·3, 26·0 and 26·5° C; P < 0·01). The thermal tolerance of this northern population appears to be broader than southern populations.     

The effect of temperature and fish size on growth and feed efficiency ratio of juvenile spotted wolffish Anarhichas minor

The growth properties of juvenile spotted wolffish Anarhichas minor reared at 4, 6, 8 and 12° C, and a group reared under 'temperature steps', (T‐step) i.e . with temperature reduced successively from 12 to 9 and 6° C were investigated. Growth rate and feed efficiency ration was significantly influenced by temperature and fish size. Overall growth rate was highest at 6° C (0·68% day⁻¹) and lowest at 12° C (0·48% day⁻¹), while the 4 and 8° C, and the T‐step groups had similar overall growth rates, i.e . 0·59, 0·62 and 0·51% day⁻¹ respectively. Optimal temperature for growth ( T _{opt G} ) and feed efficiency ratio (T_{opt FCE}) decreased as fish size increased, indicating an ontogenetic reduction in T _{opt G} and T _{opt FCE}. The results suggest a T _{opt G} of juvenile spotted wolffish in the size range 135–380 g, dropping from 7·9° C for 130–135 g to 6·6° C for 360–380 g juveniles. The T _{opt FCE} dropped from 7·4° C for 120–150 g to 6·5° C for 300–380 g juveniles. A wider parabolic regression curve between growth, feed efficiency ratio and temperature as fish size increased, may indicate increased temperature tolerance with size. Individual growth rates varied greatly at all time periods within the experimental temperatures, but at the same time significant size rank correlations were maintained and this may indicate stable size hierarchies in juvenile spotted wolffish.     

Survival of Escherichia coli O157 : H7 in yoghurt during preparation and storage at 4°C

Cow's milk was inoculated with ca 10³ and 10⁷ cfu ml⁻¹ Escherichia coli O157 : H7. After fermentation at 42°C for 0–5 h, the yoghurt was stored at 4°C. Two kinds of yoghurt were used : traditional yoghurt (TY), made with Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactobacillus bulgaricus starter cultures, and 'bifido' yoghurt (BY), made with the two starter cultures plus Bifidobacterium bifidum . After 7 d E. coli O157 : H7 decreased from 3·52 to 2·72 log₁₀ cfu ml⁻¹ and from 7·08 to 5·32 log₁₀ cfu ml⁻¹ in TY, and from 3·49 to 2·73 log₁₀ cfu ml⁻¹ and from 7·38 to 5·41 log₁₀ cfu ml⁻¹ in BY. The pH values of yoghurt dropped from 6·6 to 4·5 and 4·4 in TY (for low and high pathogen inocula, respectively), and from 6·6 to 4·6 and 4·5 in BY (for low and high pathogen inocula, respectively).     

Ontogenetic changes in temperature preference of Atlantic cod

Final thermal preferendum ( T ) experiments were conducted in a horizontal thermal gradient tank from the beginning of August 2001 to mid‐November 2001 using Atlantic cod Gadus morhua from 6·5 to 79·0 cm fork length ( L _F). The value of T varied significantly ( P  < 0·005) with L _F( T  = 7·23–0·054 L _F), with smaller (younger) fish choosing higher temperatures than larger (older) fish. The preferendum varied from 6·9° C for fish of 6·5 cm to 3·0° C for those of 79·0 cm. Experiments comparing fish positions in the gradient tank between thermal gradients of 0·5–11·0 and 4·5–14·5° C demonstrated that fish positions were determined by temperature selection instead of undesirable tank effects. This study is the first to demonstrate the effect of ontogeny on temperature preferences of a marine fish species.     

A desk study of the relationship between temperature and hatching time for the eggs of five species of salmonid fishes

SUMMARY. Information on temperature (T°C) and time from fertilization to 50% hatch ( D days) for five species of salmonid fishes has been used to assess several mathematical models relating D and T . No single equation gave the best fit to all five data sets. The power law with temperature correction (α), log₁₀₁ D = log₁₀ a + b log₁₀ ( T - α) and the quadratic, log₁₀ D = log₁₀ a + bT + b ₁ T ² (where a, b, b ₁, and α are constants), each accounted for over 97 % of the variance of D and were good fits to the observed data points for all five species. There was little difference between the predictions obtained from these two equations within the range of observed temperatures. Therefore, the simpler power-law model is preferred. However, there were substantial within-species differences between values of D predicted from extrapolations of the two models from 2 or 3°C down to 0°C. When more data for low temperatures become available it will be possible to make a more objective choice of model.     

Impact of temperature on food intake and growth in juvenile burbot

The effect of temperature on food consumption, food conversion and somatic growth was investigated with juvenile burbot Lota lota (age 0 years). Juvenile burbot showed a significant dome shaped relationship between relative daily food consumption ( C _R) and temperature ( T ) with C _R = − 0·00044 T ² + 0·01583 T  − 0·06010; ( n  = 90, r ² = 0·61). Maximum C _R was at 17·9° C (95% CL 17·2–18·6° C). The temperature related instantaneous growth rate ( G ) also followed a dome shaped function with G  = − 0·000063 T ² + 0·002010 T  − 0·007462; ( n  = 95, r ² = 0·57), with maximum growth rate at 16·0° C (95% CL 15·3–16·6° C). A significant linear relationship was found between the water temperature and the conversion coefficient ( C _C) with C _C = − 1·63 T  + 59·04; ( n  = 80, r ² = 0·74). The results indicate that juvenile burbot in large lakes benefit from higher water temperatures in the littoral zone, by increased food uptake and growth, especially during the warm summer months. Because profundal water temperatures do not reflect the optimal temperature for food consumption in large burbot, temperature is unlikely to be the main proximate factor for the obligate littoral‐profundal migration of juvenile burbot observed in many lake populations.     

Survival and growth of Cronobacter species (Enterobacter sakazakii) in wheat-based infant follow-on formulas

Aims:  To determine the survival and growth characteristics of Cronobacter species ( Enterobacter sakazakii ) in infant wheat-based formulas reconstituted with water, milk, grape juice or apple juice during storage.
Methods and Results:  Infant wheat-based formulas were reconstituted with water, ultra high temperature milk, pasteurized grape or apple juices. The reconstituted formulas were inoculated with Cronobacter sakazakii and Cronobacter muytjensii and stored at 4, 25 or 37°C for up to 24 h. At 25 and 37°C, Cronobacter grew more (>5 log₁₀) in formulas reconstituted with water or milk than those prepared with grape or apple juices ( c. 2–3 log₁₀). The organism persisted, but did not grow in any formulas stored at 4°C. Formulas reconstituted with water and milk decreased from pH 6·0 to 4·8–5·0 after 24 h, whereas the pH of the formulas reconstituted with fruit juices remained at their initial pH values, c. pH 4·8–5·0.
Conclusions:  Cronobacter sakazakii and C. muytjensii can grow in reconstituted wheat-based formulas. If not immediately consumed, these formulas should be stored at refrigeration temperatures to reduce the risk of infant infection.
Significance and Impact of the Study:  The results of this study will be of use to regulatory agencies and infant formula producers to recommend storage conditions that reduce the growth of Cronobacter in infant wheat-based formulas.     

Compensatory growth of juvenile brown flounder Paralichthys olivaceus (Temminck & Schlegel) following thermal manipulation

The compensatory growth of juvenile brown flounder Paralichthys olivaceus (body mass c. 12 g) following different thermal exposure was investigated. Fish were exposed to one of the five temperatures: 8·5 ( T _8·5), 13·0 ( T _13·0), 17·5 ( T _17·5), 22·0 ( T _22·0) and 26·5° C ( T _26·5) for 10 days and fish grew best at 22·0° C. Then the water temperature in all treatments was equably adjusted to 22·0° C over 3 days. At the end of the following 30 days after temperature adjustment, there were no significant differences between body masses of fish in the different treatments (wet body mass at the end of the experiment ranged from 22·13 to 24·56 g). Results indicated that the juvenile P. olivaceus achieved complete compensatory growth. Analysis of the dynamics of the feeding rates and feed conversion efficiencies indicated that compensatory growth of the fish experienced low temperature ( T _8·5, T _13·5 and T _17·5) or high temperature ( T _26·5) exposure was mainly dependent on increasing feed intake (hyperphagia) and possibly by improvement in feed conversion efficiency. The moisture content was not affected by different temperature exposure significantly. The lipid and energy content of juvenile P. olivaceus in T _8·5, however, were significantly lower than other treatment. Results of the current study indicate that a short period of low or high temperature exposure may not affect annual growth, but may affect lipid and energy deposition.     

Effects of temperature, body size and feeding on rates of metabolism in young‐of‐the‐year haddock

The mean rate of oxygen consumption (routine respiration rate, R _R, mg O₂ fish⁻¹ h⁻¹), measured for individual or small groups of haddock Melanogrammus aeglefinus (3–12 cm standard length, L _S) maintained for 5 days within flow‐through respiratory chambers at four different temperatures, increased with increasing dry mass ( M _D). The relationship between R _R and M _D was allometric ( R _R = α  M ^b ) with b values of 0·631, 0·606, 0·655 and 0·650 at 5·0, 8·0, 12·0 and 15·0° C, respectively. The effect of temperature ( T ) and M _D on mean R _R was described by     indicating a Q ₁₀ of 2·27 between 5 and 15° C. Juvenile haddock routine metabolic scope, calculated as the ratio of the mean of highest and lowest deciles of R _R measured in each chamber, significantly decreased with temperature such that the routine scope at 15° C was half that at 5° C. The cost of feeding ( R _SDA) was c . 3% of consumed food energy, a value half that found for larger gadoid juveniles and adults.     

Thermal acclimation of photosynthesis in black spruce [Picea mariana (Mill.) B.S.P.

We investigated the thermal acclimation of photosynthesis and respiration in black spruce seedlings [ Picea mariana (Mill.) B.S.P.] grown at 22/14 °C [low temperature (LT)] or 30/22 °C [high temperature (HT)] day/night temperatures. Net CO₂ assimilation rates ( A _net) were greater in LT than in HT seedlings below 30 °C, but were greater in HT seedlings above 30 °C. Dark and day respiration rates were similar between treatments at the respective growth temperatures. When respiration was factored out of the photosynthesis response to temperature, the resulting gross CO₂ assimilation rates ( A _gross) was lower in HT than in LT seedlings below 30 °C, but was similar above 30 °C. The reduced A _gross of HT seedlings was associated with lower needle nitrogen content, lower ribulose 1·5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco) maximum carboxylation rates ( V _cmax) and lower maximum electron transport rates ( J _max). Growth treatment did not affect V _cmax :  J _max. Modelling of the CO₂ response of photosynthesis indicated that LT seedlings at 40 °C might have been limited by heat lability of Rubisco activase, but that in HT seedlings, Rubisco capacity was limiting. In sum, thermal acclimation of A _net was largely caused by reduced respiration and lower nitrogen investments in needles from HT seedlings. At 40 °C, photosynthesis in LT seedlings might be limited by Rubisco activase capacity, while in HT seedlings, acclimation removed this limitation.     

Effect of long-term and rapid cold hardening on the cold torpor temperature of an aphid

Abstract.  The effect of long-term (seasonal) acclimation and rapid cold hardening is investigated on the cold torpor temperature ( CT _min) of adult grain aphids, Sitobion avenae, reared at 20 or 10 °C for more than 6 months before experimentation. Rapid cold hardening is induced by exposing aphids reared at 20 to 0 °C for 3 h and aphids reared at 10 to 0 °C for 30 min (acclimation regimes previously found to induce maximum rapid cold hardening). The effect of cooling aphids from the same rearing regimes from 10 to −10 °C at 1, 0.5 and 0.1 °C min⁻¹ is also investigated. In the 20 °C acclimated population, rapid cold hardening and cooling at 0.1 °C min⁻¹ both produce a significant decrease in CT _min from 1.5 ± 0.3 to –0.9 ± 0.3 and –1.3 ± 0.3 °C, respectively. Rapid cold hardening also results in a significant reduction in CT _min of the population reared at 10 °C from 0.8 ± 0.1 to –0.9 ± 0.2 °C. However, none of the cooling regimes tested reduces the CT _min of the winter-acclimated (10 °C) population. The present study demonstrates that rapid cold-hardening induced during the cooling phase of natural diurnal temperature cycles could lower the movement threshold of S. avenae , allowing insects to move and continue feeding at lower temperatures than would otherwise be possible.     

The effect of temperature and acclimation period on repeat swimming performance in cutthroat trout

Hatchery cutthroat trout Oncorhynchus clarki clarki were used to examine the effects of 48 h and 3 week temperature acclimation periods on critical swimming speed ( U _crit). The U _crit was determined for fish at acclimation temperatures of 7, 14 and 18° C using two consecutive ramp‐ U _crit tests in mobile Brett‐type swim tunnels. An additional group was tested at the stock's ambient rearing temperature of 10° C. The length of the temperature acclimation period had no significant effect on either the first or the second U _crit( U _crit‐1 and U _crit‐2, respectively) or on the recovery ratio (the quotient of U _crit‐2  U _crit‐1⁻¹). As anticipated, there was a significant positive relationship between U _crit‐1 and temperature ( P  < 0·01) for both acclimation periods, and an increasing, though non‐significant, trend between U _crit‐2 and temperature ( P  = 0·10). Acclimation temperature had no significant effect ( P  = 0·71) on the recovery ratio. These results indicate that a 48 h acclimation to experimental temperatures within the range of −3 to +8° C of the acclimation temperature may be sufficient in studies of swimming performance with this species. This ability to acclimate rapidly is probably adaptive for cutthroat trout and other species that occupy thermally variable environments.     

Routine metabolism of juvenile spot, Leiostomus xanthums (Lacépède), as a function of temperature, salinity and weight

Routine oxygen consumption rates of juvenile spot, Leiostomus xanthums , were measured over a range of temperatures, salinities and fish weights. As predicted, Q O₂ increased with temperature and decreased with body weight. However, Q O₂ decreased with decreasing salinity and did not show the expected minimum at isosmotic concentrations. The data are best described by the relationship: log₁₀ Q O₂ (mg O₂ g⁻¹ h⁻¹) = 0.129 log_lo salinity (%0) + 1.604 log₁₀ temperature (°C)-0.1401og₁₀(g)-2.767.     

Modelling the growth of Weissella cibaria as a function of fermentation conditions

Aims:  To investigate the effect of pH, water activity ( a _w) and temperature on the growth of Weissella cibaria DBPZ1006, a lactic acid bacterium isolated from sourdoughs.
Methods and Results:  The kinetics of growth of W. cibaria DBPZ1006 was investigated during batch fermentations as a function of pH (4·0–8·0), a _w (0·935–0·994) and temperature (10–45°C) in a rich medium. The growth curve parameters (lag time, growth rate and asymptote) were estimated using the dynamic model of Baranyi and Roberts (1994. A dynamic approach to predicting bacterial growth in food. Int J Food Microbiol 23, 277–294). The effect of pH, a _w and temperature on maximum specific growth rate (μ_max) were estimated by fitting a cardinal model. μ_max under optimal conditions (pH = 6·6, a _w = 0·994, T  = 36·3°C) was estimated to be 0·93 h⁻¹. Minimum and maximum estimated pH and temperature for growth were 3·6 and 8·15, and 9·0°C and 47·8°C, respectively, while minimum a _w was 0·918 (equivalent to 12·2% w/v NaCl).
Conclusions:  Weissella cibaria DBPZ1006 is a fast-growing heterofermentative strain, which could be used in a mixed starter culture for making bread.
Significance and Impact of the Study:  This is the first study reporting the modelling of the growth of W. cibaria , a species that is increasingly being used as a starter in sourdough and vegetable fermentations.     

The critical thermal limits for juvenile Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus

The chief objective was to determine the critical thermal limits for alevins, fry and parr of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus , (L.) from four races living in Windermere (northwest England). The experimental fish were reared in a hatchery but were the progeny of wild parents. As comparisons between tethal temperatures at four acclimation temperatures (5, 10, 15, 20° C) revealed few significant racial differences, the data were pooled to estimate the lethal values for survival over 7 days (incipient lethal temperature) and over only 10 min (ultimate lethal temperature) for each life stage. Upper lethal values increased with acclimation temperatures for alevins but this effect was negligible for fry and parr, Alevins were generally less tolerant than fry and parr at lower, but not higher, acclimation temperatures; e.g. after acclimation at 5° C, mean upper ultimate values were 23·3, 25·1 and 25·7° C and mean upper incipient values were 18·7, 21·5 and 21·5° C for alevins, fry and parr respectively; after acclimation at 20° C, mean upper ultimate and incipient values were 26·2, 26·1 and 26·6° C and 20·8, 20·8 and 21·6° C for alevins, fry and parr respectively. The area of the temperature tolerance polygon (expressed as ° C²) for juvenile Arctic charr is amongst the lowest recorded for salmonids; being 409, 439 and 461° C² for alevins, fry and parr respectively. These low values are due to lower upper tolerance limits, not high lower tolerance limits; the latter being close to 0° C (<1°C for parr and fry, <0·3° C for alevins) at all acclimation temperatures. Arctic charr are therefore amongst the least resistant of salmonids to high temperatures but probably the most resistant to low temperatures.     

Growth, diet and metabolism of common wolf–fish in the North Sea, a fast–growing population

The von Bertalanffy growth parameters for common wolf–fish Anarhichas lupus in the North Sea were: male: L ∞=111·2 cm, t ₀=–0·43 and K =0·12; and female: L ∞=115·1 cm, t ₀=–0·39 and K =0·11, making this the fastest growing stock reported. Resting metabolic rates (RMR±S.E.) and maximum metabolic rates (MMR±S.E.) for six adult common wolf–fish (mean weight, 1·39 kg) at 5° C were 12·18±1·6 mg O₂ kg^–1 h^–1 and 70·65±7·63 mg O₂ kg^–1 h^–1 respectively, and at 10° C were 25·43±1·31 mg O₂ kg^–1 h^–1 and 113·84±16·26 mg O₂ kg^–1 h^–1. Absolute metabolic scope was 53% greater at 10° C than at 5° C. The diet was dominated by Decapoda (39% overall by relative occurrence), Bivalvia (20%) and Gastropoda (12%). Sea urchins, typically of low energy value, occupied only 7% of the diet. The fast growth probably resulted from summer temperatures approximating to the optimum for food processing and growth, but may have been influenced by diet, and reduced competition following high fishing intensity.     

Changes in leaf nitrogen and carbohydrates underlie temperature and CO2 acclimation of dark respiration in five boreal tree species

We tested the hypothesis that acclimation of foliar dark respiration to CO₂ concentration and temperature is associated with adjustments in leaf structure and chemistry. Populus tremuloides Michx. , Betula papyrifera Marsh. , Larix laricina (Du Roi) K. Koch , Pinus banksiana Lamb., and Picea mariana (Mill.) B.S.P. were grown from seed in combined CO₂ (370 or 580 μ mol mol^–1) and temperature treatments (18/12, 24/18, or 30/24 °C). Temperature and CO₂ effects were predominately independent. Specific respiration rates partially acclimated to warmer thermal environments through downward adjustment in the intercept, but not Q ₁₀ of the temperature–response functions. Temperature acclimation of respiration was larger for conifers than broad-leaved species and was associated with pronounced reductions in leaf nitrogen concentrations in conifers at higher growth temperatures. Short-term increases in CO₂ concentration did not inhibit respiration. Growth in the elevated CO₂ concentration reduced leaf nitrogen and increased non-structural carbohydrate concentrations. However, for a given nitrogen concentration, respiration was higher in leaves grown in the elevated CO₂ concentration, as rates increased with increasing carbohydrates. Across species and treatments, respiration rates were a function of both leaf nitrogen and carbohydrate concentrations ( R ² = 0·71, P < 0·0001). Long-term acclimation of foliar dark respiration to temperature and CO₂ concentration is largely associated with changes in nitrogen and carbohydrate concentrations.     

The Effect of Temperature, Pressure and Chlorine Concentration of Spray Washing Water on Numbers of Bacteria on Lamb Carcases

Combined analysis of three experiments showed that when lamb carcases with initial bacterial numbers of between logi₁₀3.29 and 4.22/cm² were spray washed, statistically significant reductions in bacterial numbers of log₁₀O.5 were obtained when the spray wash water temperature was > 57°C, and reductions of log₁₀1.0 were obtained when the temperature was ≥ 80°C. Reductions at all temperatures were enhanced by log₁₀0.66 when the water contained 30 µg/ml chlorine, but increasing the concentration to 450 µg/ml reduced bacterial numbers only by a further log₁₀0–29. At highly contaminated sites increasing the duration of spraying from 30 to 120 s significantly increased the reductions obtained when water containing added chlorine was used. Reductions in bacterial numbers after spray washing with pressures of 3.5, 5.6. 7.7 kg/cm² were not significantly different.     

The relationship of oocyte diameter and incubation temperature to incubation time in temperate freshwater fish species

Based on the analysis of six egg variables and incubation temperature of 65 temperate freshwater fish species, the possible relationships between oocyte diameter, incubation time and incubation temperature were reassessed and compared to the results obtained from marine fishes. Most freshwater species have eggs (mean ± s . d . 2·19 ± 1·52 mm) larger than marine species, that are chiefly demersal and develop stuck to various substrata, such as plants or rocks. A strong negative relationship was found between incubation time ( t , days) and incubation temperature ( T , ° C): t = 186·23e^{−0·197 T} ( r ²= 0·87). A strong dependence of incubation time on oocyte diameter ( Ø , mm) and incubation temperature was also found and was defined as: log₁₀ t = 3·002 + 0·599 log₁₀ Ø − 1·91 log₁₀ ( T + 2), which explained 92% of the variance of the data set. Five major groups of species were defined based on the principal component analysis (PCA) of four quantitative variables. There were two distinct groups of salmonids, displaying demersal and non-adhesive eggs with a long incubation time at low temperature, the eggs of which required a high number of degree-days. There was a large group of species possessing small, mostly demersal and adhesive eggs developing at high temperature during a short period of time, and requiring a low number of degree-days. Between these two extremes, there was a fourth group displaying intermediate values and a fifth group including three species with large, adhesive and demersal eggs incubating at high temperatures during a short period of time. The burbot Lota lota displayed an unusual combination of variables compared to the remaining species in the data set.