Differential Histone Acetylation in Alfalfa (Medicago sativa) Due to Growth in NaCl : Responses in Salt Stressed and Salt Tolerant Callus Cultures

The steady state distribution of histone variant proteins and their modifications by acetylation were characterized in wild type and salinity stress adapted alfalfa (Medicago sativa). Isotopic labeling detected dynamic acetylation at four sites in the histone H3 variants and five sites in histones H4 and H2B. Histone variant H3.2 was the most highly acetylated histone with 25% higher steady state acetylation and a two- to threefold higher acetylation labeling than histone H3.1. Histone phosphorylation was limited to histone variants H1.A, H1.B, and H1.C and to histone H2A.3, which was also acetylated. Histone variant composition was unaffected by cellular exposure to NaCl. Histone acetylation was qualitatively similar in salt-tolerant and salt-sensitive cells under normal growth conditions. However, short term salt stress in salt sensitive cells or continued growth at 1% NaCl in salt tolerant cells led to major increases in the multiacetylated forms of histone H4 and the two variants of histone H3. These changes were more pronounced in the diploid than in the tetraploid alfalfa strains. The increase in multiacetylation of core histones serves as an in vivo reporter suggesting an altered intranuclear ionic environment in the presence of salt. It may also represent an adaptive response in chromatin structure to permit chromatin function in a more saline intranuclear environment.     

Plant histone acetylation: in the beginning ..

The study of histone acetylation in plants started with protein purification and sequencing, with gel analysis and the use of radioactive tracers. In alfalfa, acid urea Triton gel electrophoresis and in vivo labeling with tritated acetate and lysine quantified dynamic acetylation of core histones and identified the replication-coupled and -independent expression patterns of the histone H3.1 and H3.2 variants. Pulse-chase analyses demonstrated protein turnover of newly synthesized histone H3.2 and thereby identified the replacement H3 histones of plants which maintain the nucleosome density of transcribed chromatin. Sequence analysis of histone H4 revealed acetylation of lysine 20, a site typically methylated in animals and yeasts. Histone deacetylase inhibitors butyrate and trichostatin A are metabolized in alfalfa, but loss of TSA is slow, allowing its use to induce transient hyperacetylation of histones H2B, H4 and H3. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Epigenetic Control of cellular and developmental processes in plants.     

Butyrate-induced histone hyperacetylation in human and mouse cells: estimation of putative sites of histone acetylation in vivo

Human and mouse cells in culture were treated with various concentrations of sodium butyrate. Acid-extracted histones of control and butyrate-treated cells were analyzed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. All core histones of the control cells contained modified forms. All core histones of the butyrate-treated cells were hyperacetylated. Depending on the number of acetylation sites per molecule, each histone or histone variant exhibited a characteristic number of acetylated forms. This number was the same for each histone common in human and mouse cells treated with butyrate. Histones 2A.1, 2A.2, and 2A.X have two sites of inner acetylation; 2A.Z has 3; 2B's have 5; and each one of the H3 variants as well as H4 have 4.     

Dynamics of histone acetylation in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Rates of turnover for the posttranslational acetylation of core histones were measured in logarithmically growing yeast cells by radioactive acetate labeling to near steady-state conditions. On average, acetylation half-lives were approximately 15 min for histone H4, 10 min for histone H3, 4 min for histone H2B, and 5 min for histone H2A. These rates were much faster than the several hours that have previously been reported for the rate of general histone acetylation and deacetylation in yeast. The current estimates are in line with changes in histone acetylation detected directly at specific chromatin locations and the speed of changes in gene expression that can be observed. These results emphasize that histone acetylation within chromatin is subject to constant flux. Detailed analysis revealed that the turnover rates for acetylation of histone H3 are the same from mono- through penta-acetylated forms. A large fraction of acetylated histone H3, including possibly all tetra- and penta-acetylated forms, appears subject to acetylation turnover. In contrast, the rate of acetylation turnover for mono- and di-acetylated forms of histones H4 and H2B, and the fraction subject to acetylation turnover, was lower than for multi-acetylated forms of these histones. This difference may reflect the difference in location of these histones within the nucleosome, a difference in the spectrum of histone-specific acetylating and deacetylating enzymes, and a difference in the role of acetylation in different histones.     

Histones of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. Synthesis, acetylation, and methylation.

Histones of the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii were prepared by a new method and fractionated by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. Acid-urea-Triton gel analysis and tritiated acetate labeling demonstrated high levels of steady-state acetylation for the single histone H3 protein, in contrast to low levels on histones H4 and H2B. Twenty percent of histone H3 is subject to dynamic acetylation with, on average, three acetylated lysine residues per protein molecule. Histone synthesis in light-dark-synchronized cultures was biphasic with pattern differences between two histone H1 variants, between two H2A variants, and between H2B and ubiquitinated H2B. Automated protein sequence analysis of histone H3 demonstrated a site-specific pattern of steady-state acetylation between 7 and 17% at five of the six amino-terminal lysines and of monomethylation between 5 and 81% at five of the eight amino-terminal lysines in a pattern that may limit dynamic acetylation. An algal histone H3 sequence was confirmed by protein sequencing with a single threonine as residue 28 instead of the serine28-alanine29 sequence, present in all other known plant and animal H3 histones.     

The isolation of HTC variant cells which can replicate in butyrate. Changes in histone acetylation and tyrosine aminotransferase induction

We have obtained a number of variant HTC cells which are capable of vigorous replication in the presence of 6 mM sodium butyrate. These cells show characteristic changes in histone acetylation. H2A/H2B are no longer modified and the turnover of histones H3/H4 acetate is about 4-fold greater than in control HTC cells at the same butyrate concentration. Histone deposition continues successfully even though histones H3/H4 become hyperacetylated upon association with the chromatin. Prompt deacetylation of new histones does not appear to be a prerequisite for successful deposition processes. Initial enzymatic studies indicate that not only do the butyrate-resistant cells show an increased deacetylase activity (on a per cell basis), but also the enzyme is less sensitive to sodium butyrate under in vitro assay conditions. In contrast to control HTC cells in 6 mM butyrate in which dexamethasone induction of tyrosine aminotransferase is inhibited, the butyrate-resistant variant cells are capable of tyrosine aminotransferase induction even in the presence of butyrate. The implications of these observations are discussed.     

Increase in histone acetylation and transitions in histone variants during Friend cell differentiation

Histone acetylation of Murine Erythroleukemia Cells (MELC) has been re-examined. It is demonstrated that sodium butyrate causes hyperacetylation of core histones in inducible as well as non-inducible MELC strains. This indicates that histone hyperacetylation per se is not sufficient to activate genes. However, [3H]acetate incorporation into core histones of the inducible MELC line F4N increases after induction of differentiation with dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO), in contrast to the non-inducible variant F4+. Thus histone acetylation may play a role as an auxiliary mechanism for gene activation (and inactivation). In addition, the appearance of a histone H3 variant during differentiation of MELC is reported.     

Identification of five sites of acetylation in alfalfa histone H4.

Radioactive acetylation in vivo of plant histone H4 of alfalfa, Arabidopsis, tobacco, and carrot revealed five distinct forms of radioactive, acetylated histone. In histone H4 of eukaryotes ranging from fungi to man, acetylation is restricted to four lysines (residues 5, 8, 12, and 16) possibly caused by a quantitative methylation of lysine-20. Chemical and proteolytic fragmentation of the amino terminally blocked alfalfa H4 protein, dynamically acetylated by radioactive acetate in vivo, allowed protein sequencing and identification of selected peptides. Peptide identification was facilitated by analyzing fully characterized calf histone H4 in parallel. Acetylation in vivo of alfalfa histone H4 was restricted to the lysines in the amino-terminal domain of the protein, residues 1-23. Lysine-20 was shown to be free of methylation, as in pea histone H4. This apparently makes lysine-20 accessible as a novel target for histone acetylation. The in vivo pattern of lysine acetylation (16 greater than 12 greater than 8 greater than or equal to 5 = 20) revealed a preference for lysines -16 and -12 without an apparent strict sequential specificity of acetylation.     

Histone variants and acetylated species from the alfalfa plant Medicago sativa

The histones from the alfalfa plant Medicago sativa have been characterized in terms of type variants and levels of acetylation. Histones were isolated directly from total plant tissue (callus), eliminating the need to develop methods for nuclear isolation. An acid-urea-polyacrylamide gel with a transverse Triton X-100 gradient resolved and identified in a single gel at least one type of histone H4, two variant forms of histone H2B, two variant forms of histone H3, and four variant forms of histone H2A from a crude histone preparation. Histone H4 was present 25% in an unmodified state and 75% as monomodified, presumably as monoacetylated histone. Both histone H3 variants displayed five bands, consistent with up to four internal sites of acetylation. The two H3 variants differed in their steady-state level of acetylation, suggesting that they may reside in different chromatin environments. Several histone H1 species were identified by solubility and cross-reactivity with antiserum raised against the globular part of bovine H1(0), indicating conservation of epitopes between histone H1 of mammals and higher plants.     

Enzymes involved in the dynamic equilibrium of core histone acetylation of Physarum polycephalum.

DEAE-Sepharose chromatography of extracts from plasmodia of the myxomycete Physarum polycephalum revealed the presence of multiple histone acetyltransferases and histone deacetylases. A cytoplasmic histone acetyltransferase B, specific for histone H4, and two nuclear acetyltransferases A1 and A2 were identified; A1 acetylates all core histones with a preference for H3 and H2A, whereas A2 is specific for H3 and also slightly for H2B. Two histone deacetylases, HD1 and HD2, could be discriminated. They differ with respect to substrate specificity and pH dependence. For the first time the substrate specificity of histone deacetylases was determined using HPLC-purified individual core histone species. The order of acetylated substrate preference is H2A much greater than H3 greater than or equal to H4 greater than H2B for HD1 and H3 greater than H2A greater than H4 for HD2, respectively; HD2 is inactive with H2B as substrate. Moreover histone deacetylases are very sensitive to butyrate, since 2 mM butyrate leads to more than 50% inhibition of enzyme activity.     

Histone acetylation and heterochromatin content of cultured Peromyscus cells

In order to explore the relationship between unacetylated arginine-rich histones and condensed chromatin structure, the extent of histone acetylation was examined in cultured cell lines derived from three species of deer mice. These species differ considerably in their genomic content of heterochromatin but contain essentially the same euchromatin content. Cells of Peromyscus eremicus, containing 34–36% more constitutive heterochromatin than Peromyscus boylii or Peromyscus crinitus cells were found to contain 28–35% more unacetylated histone H4, 22–29% more unacetylated histone H3, and 18–22% more unacetylated histone H2B. This relationship between unacetylated histones and heterochromatin content was further explored by inducing hyperacetylation of P. eremicus and P. boylii histones through treatment of cells with 15 mM sodium butyrate for 24 h. It was found that the percentages of unacetylated histones H3 and H4 remaining after butyrate treatment were proportional to the amount of constitutive heterochromatin in the genome. These data support the concept that a small core of histones in constitutive heterochromatin is inaccessible to acetylation. It was also found that the acetylated state of isolated histones was sensitive to the method of histone extraction. Thus concern must be given to preparative procedures when studying histone acetylation in order to minimize these acetate losses.     

K562 human erythroleukemia cell variants resistant to growth inhibition by butyrate have deficient histone acetylation

K562 is an established human erythroleukemia cell line, inducible for hemoglobin synthesis by a variety of compounds including n-butyrate. To elucidate the role of butyrate-induced histone acetylation in the regulation of gene expression in K562 cells, we isolated 20 variants resistant to the growth inhibitory effect of butyrate. Four variants having different degrees of resistance were selected for detailed study. All four were found to be resistant to the hemoglobin-inducing effect of butyrate, suggesting that the two aspects of butyrate response, restriction of growth and induction of hemoglobin synthesis, are coupled. Further, after (5 days) culture with butyrate, two of the four variants exhibit less acetylation of H3 and H4 histones than does the butyrate-treated parent. Analysis of histone deacetylases from the variants indicated that each variant was distinct and that butyrate resistance may be accounted for by decreased affinity of the variant enzymes for butyrate, increased affinity of the enzymes for acetylated histone, or both. The fact that variants selected for resistance to growth inhibition by butyrate are also deficient in butyrate-induced hemoglobin synthesis and have abnormal histone deacetylase activity argues for butyrate inducing K562 cells to synthesize hemoglobin and restrict growth via histone acetylation.     

Acetylation of rat testis histones H2B and TH2B

The in vivo acetylation of rat testis histones H3 and H4 has been demonstrated in previous studies. In this study, analysis of purified histone fractions revealed the in vivo acetylation of histone H2B, the testis histone variant designated TH2B, and two or more of the histone H2A variants. These findings are quite significant, because it is possible that all of the core histones are acetylated in elongating spermatids at the time of removal of the entire histone complement for replacement by basic spermatidal transition proteins (S.R. Grimes and N. Henderson, 1983, Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 221, 108-116).     

Acetylation of histones of rat testis.

When [1-¹⁴C]acetate was injected into rats intratesticularly in the presence of cycloheximide to inhibit protein synthesis, the label was incorporated into histone fractions F2a1 and F3 and into non-histone chromosomal proteins of each of the following stages of spermatogenesis: spermatogonia-preleptotene spermatocytes, leptotene-zygotene-pachytene-diplotene primary spermatocytes, and spermatids. Acetylation of histones was particularly active in the spermatid stages. There was no significant incorporation of acetate into the lysine-rich histone fractions F1 and X₁.In early periods of in vivo incorporation of [³H]amino acids into histones the acetylated histone F2a1 fractions had higher specific activities than the main band of F2a1, but with the passage of time the label moved into the principal band to the extent that specific activities in the acetylated and principal bands were approximately equal at 6 days. However, at 24–36 days the specific activities were again higher in the acetylated bands than in the principal band of F2a1. These data support the conclusions of Candido, Louie, and Dixon, from experiments with trout testis, that acetylation of histone F2a1 may be important in the process of combination of this protein with DNA in chromatin at the spermatogonia-primary spermatocyte stage and also in the subsequent removal of this histone for replacement by protamines at the spermatid stage.[³H]Amino acids were incorporated into histone fractions X₁ and F1 at approximately equal rates, and there was no evidence that one of these fractions was a precursor of the other.Chromatin of the seminiferous epithelial cells of rat testis has a firmly bound acetylase which catalyzes the in vitro acetylation of histones F3 and F2a1 by acetyl CoA.