Use of phage display for detecting single-nucleotide differences in genes]

Experimental strategy has been developed for selection of mismatched DNA binding phages from library of E. coli f1 filamentous phages carrying random peptide inserts on the surface of bacteriophage particles. The strategy is based on the use of phage display technique, DNA heteroduplexes (with single nucleotide variations), and paramagnetic beads. DNA heteroduplexes have been obtained from biotin-labeled PCR product. During the first stage the phage particles were incubated with DNA heteroduplexes possessing mismatched nucleotides. The next step after elimination of free phages and separation of bound phages from DNA heteroduplexes was subtraction of phages binding with DNA heteroduplexes (without mismatched nucleotides). Phages selected by this method were capable of discriminating DNA heteroduplexes with single nucleotide variations from DNA homoduplexes. Phages immobilized on solid base retain their activity and specificity, and therefore can be used for developing a new screening automated method for detecting point mutations and gene polymorphism.     

Detecting single base substitutions as heteroduplex polymorphisms.

We have developed a sensitive technique for detecting single base substitutions in polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products from individuals heterozygous for polymorphisms or new mutations. This technique takes advantage of the formation of heteroduplexes in the PCR between different alleles from heterozygous individuals. These heteroduplexes can be detected on polyacrylamide gels because they migrate slower than their corresponding homoduplexes. Using PCR, we have generated a series of point mutations in a defined region of DNA in the equine infectious anemia virus (EIAV). Each mutation is the result of a single base substitution. By mixing the PCR products amplified from these mutations with one another, as well as with wildtype PCR products, we can generate heteroduplexes in which the identity of the mismatched bases is known. We detected eight of nine point mutations using this technique. We have also modified the electrophoretic conditions to optimize the detection of these heteroduplexes. In addition, the usefulness of this technique is demonstrated by its ability to detect a mutation in the cystic fibrosis gene that is the result of a single base substitution. This technique should prove useful for rapidly screening large numbers of individuals for new mutations or polymorphisms.     

Analysis of sequence alterations in a defined DNA region: comparison of temperature-modulated heteroduplex analysis and denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis

The ability to detect DNA sequence heterogeneity quickly and reliably is becoming increasingly important as more genes involved in disease processes are discovered. We have assessed the ability of a high pressure liquid chromatography technique (HPLC) termed temperature-modulated heteroduplex analysis (TMHA) to detect a collection of 20 point mutations distributed throughout a 279 base pair fragment spanning the exon 8 region of the human HPRT gene. All mutant/wild type heteroduplexes formed from mutations in the lowest temperature melting domain of the fragment were easily resolved from the corresponding mutant and wt homoduplexes, while those generated from mutants in the next higher melting domain barely resolved from their parental homoduplexes. For comparison, identical heteroduplex samples were subjected to denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE). Heteroduplexes in the lowest temperature melting domain were easily resolved, while no resolution was achieved with those in the next higher melting domain. These results suggest that TMHA and DGGE are measuring similar melting characteristics in heteroduplex molecules. TMHA appears to be a robust approach for detecting and/or purifying a wide variety of mutations in a defined region of DNA, provided that the melting characteristics of the fragment under study are carefully considered.     

Detection of complex alleles by direct analysis of DNA heteroduplexes

DNA molecules derived from three alleles of the HLA-DRB3 locus and differing from each other at several nucleotide sites were denatured and cross-hybridized. Each allelic combination was found to generate a pair of heteroduplexes of different mobility. Their retardation as compared to homoduplexes was proportional to the number of mismatches. In each heteroduplexes pair the component possessing the highest number of Pyr-Pyr oppositions was the most retarded. The results are those predicted by a theoretical model implying a correlation between base-pair opening and bending of the DNA double helix. These observations introduce a new HLA typing method at the genomic level and indicate an experimental approach to the analysis of the superhelical DNA conformation as related to different types of base oppositions.     

Mutation detection by denaturing DNA chromatography using fluorescently labeled polymerase chain reaction products.

A specialized form of ion-pair reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography is gaining widespread application in mutation detection for single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP). The technique relies on temperature-modulated heteroduplex analysis (TMHA) by chromatographic separation of partially denatured DNA heteroduplexes from homoduplexes. Here, we demonstrate that fluorescent labeling is compatible with mutation analysis by this form of DNA chromatography and offers advantages over the use of unlabeled DNA fragments. Uniform labeling of wild-type and mutant alleles for TMHA yields peak patterns identical to unlabeled fragments. However, fluorescent labels increase retention times but do not influence resolution of heteroduplexes from homoduplexes. They increase sensitivity and decrease the amount of DNA required for analysis; e.g., in the case presented here, one allele can be detected in the presence of a 500-fold excess of another allele. Furthermore, allele-specific wild-type probes, fluorescently labeled on one strand only, make it possible to selectively monitor specific homoduplexes and wild-type/mutant heteroduplexes. This, in combination with an internal homoduplex standard, greatly reduces the complexity of fluorescence chromatograms compared with chromatograms recorded in the UV. These simplified chromatograms, in which only the internal homoduplex standard and the labeled heteroduplex are detected in the presence of a mutation, greatly facilitate the detection and identification of mutant alleles.     

Methyl-directed repair of frameshift heteroduplexes in cell extracts from Escherichia coli.

The methyl-directed DNA repair efficiency of a series of M13mp9 frameshift heteroduplexes 1, 2, or 3 unpaired bases was determined by using an in vitro DNA mismatch repair assay. Repair of hemimethylated frameshift heteroduplexes in vitro was directed to the unmethylated strand; was dependent on MutH, MutL, and MutS; and was equally efficient on base insertions and deletions. However, fully methylated frameshift heteroduplexes were resistant to repair, while totally unmethylated substrates were repaired with no strand bias. Hemimethylated 1-, 2-, or 3-base insertion and deletion heteroduplexes were repaired by the methyl-directed mismatch repair pathway as efficiently as the G.T mismatch. These results are consistent with earlier in vivo studies and demonstrate the involvement of methyl-directed DNA repair in the efficient prevention of frameshift mutations.     

Recombination following transformation of Escherichia coli by heteroduplex plasmid DNA molecules

Circular heteroduplex DNA molecules introduced into Escherichia coli-competent cells are converted to new recombinant plasmids as a result of enzymatic actions in vivo. A pair of plasmids with partial sequence homology were each linearized at a different position with restriction enzymes, and the termini were made flush with the single-strand-specific S1 nuclease. Duplex molecules were then formed by melting and annealing these plasmid DNAs together. In contrast to linear homoduplex molecules, heteroduplexes circularize and therefore transform E. coli efficiently. Unique DNA sequences on each of the parental strands in the transforming heteroduplexes can be selectively incorporated or deleted as a result of in vivo enzymatic activities in transformed cells. This method permits the generation of new recombinant sequences in vivo without relying solely on the presence of convenient restriction sites for manipulation of DNA fragments in vitro.     

Structural studies of lambda transducing bacteriophage carrying bacterial deoxyribonucleic acid from the metBJLF region of the Escherichia coli chromosome.

The structures of several lambda dmet and related lambda darg transducing phage were studied by restriction fragment mapping and electron microscopic measurements of homoduplexes and heteroduplexes. A new transducing phage (lambda dmet141), in which metF is the only functional gene of the cluster, was isolated. In contrast, lambda dmet117, which expresses the entire metBJLF cluster, has only 3 kilobases more bacterial deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) than lambda dmet141. An EcoRI restriction fragment of lambda dmet117, which carries the leftmost 6 kilobases of the bacterial DNA insert, was isolated and shown to contain a functional copy of metB. Small structural differences at the attachment sites of some of the phage were shown to result from different sites of lambda integration in the two parent insertion lysogens.     

Detection of single-base mutations by reaction of DNA heteroduplexes with a water-soluble carbodiimide followed by primer extension: application to products from the polymerase chain reaction

A new method was developed for the detection of single-base mutations in DNA. The polymerase chain reaction was used to prepare DNA fragments of up to 1 kb. Fragments that differed by a single-base were combined, denatured and renatured to generate heteroduplexes. The heteroduplexes were reacted with a water-soluble carbodiimide under conditions in which the carbodiimide modified Gs and Ts that were not base paired. The DNA was then used as a template for primer extension with Taq DNA polymerase under conditions in which extension terminated at the site of the carbodiimide-modified base and generated a 32P-labeled fragment that was identified by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis as a fragment smaller than the full length product. The procedure detected all four general classes of single-base mutations in several different sequence contexts. The site of the mutation was located to within about 15 bp. Extension with both a 5'- and a 3'-primer made it possible to confirm the site of the mutation in most DNA samples or detect a mutation in heteroduplexes even if a G or T in one strand was unreactive because of its sequence context. The procedure appears to have several advantages over previously published techniques.     

Increased spontaneous mutation frequency in human cells expressing the phage PBS2-encoded inhibitor of uracil-DNA glycosylase

The Ugi protein inhibitor of uracil-DNA glycosylase encoded by bacteriophage PBS2 inactivates human uracil-DNA glycosylases (UDG) by forming a tight enzyme:inhibitor complex. To create human cells that are impaired for UDG activity, the human glioma U251 cell line was engineered to produce active Ugi protein. In vitro assays of crude cell extracts from several Ugi-expressing clonal lines showed UDG inactivation under standard assay conditions as compared to control cells, and four of these UDG defective cell lines were characterized for their ability to conduct in vivo uracil-DNA repair. Whereas transfected plasmid DNA containing either a U:G mispair or U:A base pairs was efficiently repaired in the control lines, uracil-DNA repair was not evident in the lines producing Ugi. Experiments using a shuttle vector to detect mutations in a target gene showed that Ugi-expressing cells exhibited a 3-fold higher overall spontaneous mutation frequency compared to control cells, due to increased C:G to T:A base pair substitutions. The growth rate and cell cycle distribution of Ugi-expressing cells did not differ appreciably from their parental cell counterpart. Further in vitro examination revealed that a thymine DNA glycosylase (TDG) previously shown to mediate Ugi-insensitive excision of uracil bases from DNA was not detected in the parental U251 cells. However, a Ugi-insensitive UDG activity of unknown origin that recognizes U:G mispairs and to a lesser extent U:A base pairs in duplex DNA, but which was inactive toward uracil residues in single-stranded DNA, was detected under assay conditions previously shown to be efficient for detecting TDG.     

Human methylated DNA-binding protein. Determinants of a pBR322 recognition site

Methylated DNA-binding protein (MDBP) from human placenta has a high affinity for a site in pBR322 (pB site 1) when that site is methylated at its CpG dinucleotides. Dimethyl sulfate interference analysis and experiments with ligands prepared by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis indicate that 15 contiguous base pairs, 14 of which exhibit hyphenated dyad symmetry, influence MDBP binding to pB site 1. These 14 base pairs, 5'-RTMGYCAMGG(M/T)GAY-3' (M, 5-methylcytosine), suffice for recognition by MDBP as demonstrated with a double-stranded, MpG-containing oligonucleotide used as a free ligand or cloned into M13mp19 and subsequently methylated. Seven single-site mutations at different positions of this 14-base pair region largely eliminated binding, and several others increased binding up to 2-fold when compared to the nonmutant, triply methylated sequence. However, MDBP recognizes a site in hemimethylated M13mp19 replicative form DNA, which was homology to pB site 1 at only 10 of 14 base pairs, and all four of these different base pairs are equivalent to transversions. Based upon the above data, a mixed oligonucleotide probe was constructed that contains variants of pB site 1 which should be recognized by MDBP. This 14-base probe hybridizes under stringent conditions to a number of discrete fragments in restriction digests of human DNA. this suggests that there are multiple pB site 1-related sequences in human DNA that might, when methylated, bind MDBP in vivo.     

Mammalian cell processing of a unique uracil residue in simian virus 40 DNA.

The processing of a unique uracil in DNA has been studied in mammalian cells. A synthetic oligodeoxyribonucleotide carrying a potential Bgl II restriction site, where one base has been substituted with a uracil, was inserted in the early intron of SV40 genome. Various heteroduplexes were constructed in such a manner that the restitution of an active Bgl II restriction site corresponds in each case to the specific substitution of the uracil by one of the four bases normally present in the DNA. DNA cuts by this restriction enzyme in one or several constructed heteroduplexes immediately determine the type of base pair substitution produced at the site of the U residue. When the uracil is inserted opposite a purine it is fully repaired; when facing a guanine it is replaced by a cytosine and opposite an adenine it is replaced by a thymine. These results indicate the error-free repair of uracil when it appears in the cell with the usual mechanisms such as cytosine deamination or incorporation of dUTP in place of dTTP during replication. When the uracil is inserted opposite a pyrimidine no error free repair at all is detected for U:C or U:T mismatches. It appears, moreover, that in approximately 18% of the cases U:T mismatch leads to a C:G base pairing. In the majority of the U:pyrimidine mismatches, mutations occur in the vicinity of the uracil, including base substitutions and frameshifts by addition of one or several bases.     

Regular arrangement of restriction sites in drosophila DNA

When DNA of Drosophila melanogaster is digested to completion with Hemophilus aegyptius restriction endonuclease, the majority of the products are DNA segments whose lengths fit a random distribution with an average of 350 base pairs. However, some 10% of the DNA is recovered as various segments of discrete lengths, ranging from 30,000 to 365 base pairs. These segments arise from the regular spacing of the enzyme restriction sites in limited portions of the Drosophila genome. Three segments have been shown to originate from mitochondrial DNA, while all the others can be assigned to one or more isopycnic density classes of nuclear DNA. Five of the discrete fragments display modular lengths, each being an integral multiple of a 365 base pairs subunit. The relative frequencies of these multiple segments suggest that they are derived from DNA originally containing restriction sites every 365 base pairs, and that approximately 25% of these sites have been randomly inactivated.     

Physical locus of the DNA polymerase gene and genetic maps of bacteriophage T5 mutants.

Segments of DNA that contained the DNA polymerase gene of bacteriophage T5 were isolated. The physical locus of the gene was identified by transforming Escherichia coli with purified DNA fragments generated by restriction enzyme digestions, and the transformed cells were used to rescue amber mutants of T5 with mutations in the gene for DNA polymerase. The method is applicable to any other gene that has mutations with low reversion frequencies. We studied the following mutations of the T5 DNA polymerase gene, reading from left to right by the standard convention (D. J. McCorquodale, Crit. Rev. Microbiol. 4:101-159, 1975): D7, D8, aml, ts5E-ts53, am6, and D9. These loci were found to reside within three pieces of DNA with a total length of 3,600 base pairs. Because the structural gene for T5 DNA polymerase is estimated to be 2,600 base pairs long, the whole structural gene may reside in these segments. These are located 58.3 to 61.3% of the distance from the left end of the DNA. The left-end piece of the DNA (1,100 base pairs) containing the polymerase gene has loci D7 and D8, and the right-end piece (1,600 base pairs) has locus D9, according to the results of the transformation assay. These results are consistent with the genetic map.     

A protocol for TILLING and Ecotilling in plants and animals

We describe Targeting-Induced Local Lesions IN Genomes (TILLING), a reverse-genetic strategy for the discovery and mapping of induced mutations. TILLING is suitable for essentially any organism that can be mutagenized. The TILLING procedure has also been adapted for the discovery and cataloguing of natural polymorphisms, a method called Ecotilling. To discover nucleotide changes within a particular gene, PCR is performed with gene-specific primers that are end-labeled with fluorescent molecules. After PCR, samples are denatured and annealed to form heteroduplexes between polymorphic DNA strands. Mismatched base pairs in these heteroduplexes are cleaved by digestion with a single-strand specific nuclease. The resulting products are size-fractionated using denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and visualized by fluorescence detection. The migration of cleaved products indicates the approximate location of nucleotide polymorphisms. Throughput is increased and costs are reduced by sample pooling, multi-well liquid handling and automated gel band mapping. Once genomic DNA samples have been obtained, pooled and arrayed, thousands of samples can be screened daily.     

Spontaneous Mutations Occur near Dam Recognition Sites in a dam-Escherichia coli Host

The mismatch repair system of Escherichia coli K12 removes mispaired bases from DNA. Mismatch repair can occur on either strand of DNA if it lacks N6-methyladenines within 5'-GATC-3' sequences. In hemimethylated heteroduplexes, repair occurs preferentially on the unmethylated strand. If both strands are fully methylated, repair is inhibited. Mutant (dam-) strains of E. coli defective in the adenine methylase that recognizes 5'-GATC-3' sequences (Dam), and therefore defective in mismatch repair, show increased spontaneous mutation rates compared to otherwise isogenic dam+ hosts. We have isolated and characterized 91 independent mutations that arise as a consequence of the Dam- defect in a plasmid-borne phage P22 repressor gene, mnt. The majority of these mutations are A:T----G:C transitions that occur within six base pairs of the two 5'-GATC-3' sequences in the mnt gene. In contrast, the spectrum of mnt- mutations in a dam+ host is comprised of a majority of insertions of IS elements and deletions that do not cluster near Dam recognition sites. These results show that Dam-directed post-replicative mismatch repair plays a significant role in the rectification of potential transition mutations in vivo, and suggest that sequences associated with Dam recognition sites are particularly prone to replication or repair errors.     

Molecular cloning of the unintegrated squirrel monkey retrovirus genome: organization and distribution of related sequences in primate DNAs

The closed circular form of the endogenous squirrel monkey type D retrovirus (SMRV) was molecularly cloned in a bacteriophage vector. The restriction map of the biologically active clone was determined and found to be identical to that of the parental SMRV linear DNA except for the deletion of one long terminal repeat. Restriction enzyme analysis and Southern blotting indicated that the SMRV long terminal repeat was approximately 300 base pairs long. The SMRV restriction map was oriented to the viral RNA by using a gene-specific probe from baboon endogenous virus. Restriction enzyme digests of a variety of vertebrate DNAs were analyzed for DNA sequence homology with SMRV by using the cloned SMRV genome as a probe. Consistent with earlier studies, multiple copies of SMRV were detected in squirrel monkey DNA. Related fragments were also detected in the DNAs from other primate species, including humans.     

The regulatory region of the L-arabinose operon: its isolation on a 1000 base-pair fragment from DNA heteroduplexes.

A DNA fragment containing the l-arabinose operon regulatory region of Escherichia coli was purified from DNA heteroduplexes formed between opposite strands of two non-defective ara transducing phage. The phage and arabinose gene orientation is such that the heteroduplex contains two single-stranded “bubbles”. The ara regulatory region and short portions of the flanking araB and araC genes are in the short duplex between the “bubbles”. Extensive regions of homology between the phage genomes allowed nearly half of the DNA renatured from a mixture of the two phage DNAs to be in the form of heteroduplexes. Digestion of the reannealed DNA containing heteroduplexes and homoduplexes with the easily purified, single-strand specific nuclease S₁ yielded the 1000 (1017 ± 20, n = 36) base-pair ara DNA duplex plus half and whole phage-length duplexes. The larger DNA duplexes were selectively precipitated by polyethylene glycol before the final purification by preparative electrophoresis on polyacryl-amide gels. By these methods 10 to 20 μg of the 1000 base-pair DNA fragment were purified.     

A polymorphism in a region with enhancer activity in the second intron of the human apolipoprotein B gene

A 443-base pair fragment (+622 to +1064) from the second intron of the human apolipoprotein B gene was shown to contain a tissue-specific enhancer when placed in front of an apolipoprotein B promoter-chloramphenicol acetyltransferase construct in transfection experiments. To identify potential regulatory mutations in this region of the gene, DNA from various subjects was examined for the presence of point mutations by means of chemical cleavage of mismatched heteroduplexes. An A----G substitution within the second intron of the gene at position +722 was identified in three unrelated subjects and confirmed by DNA sequencing. Although the base substitution was contained within a nuclear protein-binding site, as determined by DNase I footprinting, it did not appear to affect the protein/DNA interaction in its vicinity, as shown by gel retardation experiments. The single base substitution at position +722 abolishes a StyI restriction site, thus creating a StyI polymorphism. Using allele-specific oligonucleotides, we screened the DNA of 172 subjects for the presence of this polymorphism: two other subjects carrying the polymorphism were found. In each of the five unrelated subjects, the polymorphism was associated with the same haplotype.     

Assembling long heteroduplexes by asymmetric polymerase chain reaction and annealing the resulting single-stranded DNAs

We developed an effective protocol for generating high-purity heteroduplexes via annealing single-stranded DNAs (ssDNAs) derived from plasmid DNA by asymmetric polymerase chain reaction (A-PCR). With the addition of dimethyl sulfoxide, a one-step A-PCR procedure can generate ssDNAs stably at a range of reaction temperatures. Several annealing buffers can anneal two ssDNAs into heteroduplexes effectively. We further developed a simple strategy to create d(GATC) hemimethylated heteroduplexes by annealing fully methylated homoduplexes in the presence of excessive unmethylated ssDNAs. The constructed heteroduplexes have been well tested as substrates for mismatch repair in Escherichia coli and, thus, can be used in various biotechnology applications.