Perspective on Mutagenesis and Repair: The Standard Model and Alternate Modes of Mutagenesis

ABSTRACT

The basic ideas of replication, mutagenesis, and repair have outlined a picture of how point mutations occur that has provided a valuable framework for theory and experiment, much as the Standard Model of particle physics has done for our concept of fundamental particles. However, alternative modes of mutagenesis are being defined that are changing our perspective of the “Standard Model” of mutagenesis, requiring an expanded model. The genome is now envisioned as being in dynamic equilibrium between a multitude of forces for mutational change and forces that counteract such change. By maintaining a delicate balance between these forces, cells avoid unwanted or excessive mutations. Yet, cells allow mutagenesis to occur under certain conditions. We can define an emerging paradigm. Namely, mechanisms exist that can direct point mutations to specific designated genes or regions of genes. In some cases, this is achieved by specific enzymes, and in other cases high mutability is programmed into the sequence of certain genes to help generate diversity. In yet additional cases, general mutability is increased under stress, and selective forces allow the recovery of favorable mutants.     

Molecular characterization of ENU mouse mutagenesis and archives

The large-scale mouse mutagenesis with ENU has provided forward-genetic resources for functional genomics. The frozen sperm archive of ENU-mutagenized generation-1 (G1) mice could also provide a "mutant mouse library" that allows us to conduct reverse genetics in any particular target genes. We have archived frozen sperm as well as genomic DNA from 9224 G1 mice. By genome-wide screening of 63 target loci covering a sum of 197 Mbp of the mouse genome, a total of 148 ENU-induced mutations have been directly identified. The sites of mutations were primarily identified by temperature gradient capillary electrophoresis method followed by direct sequencing. The molecular characterization revealed that all the identified mutations were point mutations and mostly independent events except a few cases of redundant mutations. The base-substitution spectra in this study were different from those of the phenotype-based mutagenesis. The ENU-based gene-driven mutagenesis in the mouse now becomes feasible and practical.     

Chemical mutagenesis of the mouse genome: an overview

The careful comparison of the phenotypic variations generated by different alleles at a given locus, including of course, those alleles with a deleterious effect, is often an important source of information for the understanding of gene functions. In fact, every time it is possible to match a specific alteration observed at the genomic level with a particular pathology, it is possible to establish a relationship between a gene and its function. When considered from this point of view, the production of new mutations by experimental mutagenesis appears as an alternative to the strategy of in vitro gene invalidation by homologous recombination in embryonic stem (ES) cells, with the advantage that experimental mutagenesis does not require any previous knowledge of the gene structure at the molecular level. Homologous recombination in ES cells is a gene driven approach, in which mutant alleles are produced for those genes that we already know. Experimental mutagenesis, on the contrary, is a phenotype driven approach, in which unknown genes are identified based on phenotypic changes. Also, while homologous recombination in ES cells requires a rather sophisticated technology, mutagenesis is simple to achieve but relies greatly on the efficiency of the mutagenic treatment as well as on the use of an accurate protocol for phenotyping. In this review, we will address a few comments about the different techniques that can be used for the induction of point mutations in the mouse germ line with special emphasis on chemical mutagenesis. We will also discuss the limitations of experimental mutagenesis and the necessity to look for alternative ways for the discovery of new genes and gene functions in the mouse.     

Base-pair substitutions alter the site-specific mutagenicity of UV and MNNG in the SUP4-o gene of yeast

Yeast strains carrying SUP4-o genes that have base-pair substitutions at hotspots for UV or MNNG mutagenesis were treated with these agents. In both cases, the induced mutation frequencies were substantially reduced. Furthermore, specific substitutions at positions in SUP4-o that had not been mutated by MNNG resulted in the recovery of MNNG-induced mutations at these sites. These results demonstrate that base-pair identity is an important factor determining the site-specific mutagenicity of UV and MNNG in yeast. For UV, our findings suggest that the type of lesion that is induced, but not flanking DNA sequences, plays a role in specifying mutability at the sites examined. In contrast, DNA sequence context seems to be an important factor for MNNG mutagenesis.     

Insertional versus targeted mutagenesis in mice.

Recent innovations in mutagenesis techniques for mice have the potential to revolutionize the molecular genetic analysis of mouse development. Insertional mutagenesis by the introduction of exogenous DNA into the mouse germline hs permitted the molecular cloning and analysis of several novel genes important for early embryonic development. Targeted mutagenesis by homologous recombination in embryonic stem cells permits, in theory, the production of mutations in any cloned gene. The complementary information being obtained from these two mutagenesis procedures is shedding new light on the genes important for early mouse development, and the roles these genes play in that process.     

How environmental factors regulate mutagenesis and gene transfer in microorganisms

This review is focused on the physiological and evolutionary strategies of the processes occurring during the entry of microbial cells into stationary phase and the subsequent period of stasis. The molecular mechanisms adapting microorganisms from exponential growth to a static state involve activation and complex regulation of the stationary factor Sigma-S, which directs RNA polymerase to the specific promoters. As a result the static cells acquire general resistance (simultaneous tolerances) to different environmental stresses. In parallel with the physiological adaptation to stasis, diverse genetical processes are aimed towards resuming the growth of the static cells. Different types of mutagenesis occur: (i) in cells entering stasis and (ii) in static cells (adaptive mutagenesis). Cessation of growth induces the transient hypermutator state resulting in the accumulation of random mutations in the subpopulation of the static cells. If by chance, one or a few of such mutations lead to resumption of division, the growing cell will return to a normal mechanism of spontaneous mutagenesis. Another mechanism for generating genetical variability in stressed cells involves transposons and conjugative plasmids. Stresses can stimulate the excision of some transposons, which, in turn, can generate chromosomal mutations and activate intracellular mechanisms of mutagenesis. Under stress some conjugative plasmids activate genes encoding antirestriction proteins that repress restriction-modification systems of the recipient cells. Moreover, under stress special cellular mechanisms decrease (alleviate) the activity of restriction-modification systems which, in turn, enhance the probability of gene transfer into the stressed cells. Under stress, the efficiency of inter-species genetical barriers also decreases. This, stimulates inter-species gene transfer and may lead to a burst of incipient speciation in the population of non-growing cells. After resumption of growth the genetical barriers leading to isolation will be restored. In general, the cessation of growth “switches on”, and resumption of growth “switches off”, a set of special processes that are responsible for generating bursts of genetical variability in populations of microorganisms. This article is dedicated to the memory of Nikolai V Timofeev-Ressovsky (1900–1981).     

An aerobic recA-, umuC-dependent pathway of spontaneous base-pair substitution mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

Antimutator alleles indentify genes whose normal products are involved in spontaneous mutagenesis pathways. Mutant alleles of the recA and umuC genes of Escherichia coli, whose wild-type alleles are components of the inducible SOS response, were shown to cause a decrease in the level of spontaneous mutagenesis. Using a series of chromosomal mutant trp alleles, which detect point mutations, as a reversion assay, it was shown that the reduction in mutagenesis is limited to base-pair substitutions. Within the limited number of sites than could be examined, transversions at AT sites were the favored substitutions. Frameshift mutagenesis was slightly enhanced by a mutant recA allele and unchanged by a mutant umuC allele. The wild-type recA and umuC genes are involved in the same mutagenic base-pair substitution pathway, designated "SOS-dependent spontaneous mutagenesis" (SDSM), since a recAumuC strain showed the same degree and specificity of antimutator activity as either single mutant strain. The SDSM pathway is active only in the presence of oxygen, since wild-type, recA, and umuC strains all show the same levels of reduced spontaneous mutagenesis anaerobically. The SDSM pathway can function in starving/stationary cells and may, or may not, be operative in actively dividing cultures. We suggest that, in wild-type cells, SDSM results from basal levels of SOS activity during DNA synthesis. Mutations may result from synthesis past cryptic DNA lesions (targeted mutagenesis) and/or from mispairings during synthesis with a normal DNA template (untargeted mutagenesis). Since it occurs in chromosomal genes of wild-type cells, SDSM may be biologically significant for isolates of natural enteric bacterial populations where extended starvation is often a common mode of existence.     

Genetic analysis of mitochondrial rho-mutability in Saccharomyces. III. Comparative analysis of the effect of various nuclear srm mutations and disomy for chromosome IV on rho-mutagenesis

Different combinations of modifying genes which enhance the rho- mutability of haploid yeast cells are shown to be suppressible by the srm1, srm2, srm3 mutations and by the disomy for chromosome IV. The srm1 mutation leads to dramatic decrease in both the spontaneous and ethidium-bromide induced rho- mutability. Other srm mutations studied and the disomy appear to cause relatively moderate quantitative changes in the spontaneous rho- mutation rate and to have no significant effect on mutation induction by ethidium bromide. Neither additivity nor synergism was revealed by the analysis of the interaction between the srm mutations. We suggest that in Saccharomyces an efficient mechanism of the rho- mutagenesis operates which can be directly affected by the srm1 mutation and more or less modified by other srm mutations under study and by the disomy for chromosome IV.     

An inducible pathway is required for mutagenesis in Salmonella typhimurium LT2.

UV mutability of Salmonella typhimurium LT2 was eliminated in the presence of a multicopy plasmid carrying the Escherichia coli lexA+ gene. This result suggests that inducible, SOS-like functions are required for UV mutagenesis in S. typhimurium. S. typhimurium strains carrying either point or deletion mutations in topA had previously been shown to lose their mutability by UV or methyl methanesulfonate (K. Overbye and P. Margolin, J. Bacteriol. 146:170-178, 1981; K. Overbye, S. M. Basu, and P. Margolin, Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quant. Biol. 47:785-791, 1983). Mitomycin C induction of the phi(mucB'-lacZ') fusion (a DNA damage-inducible locus carried on plasmid pSE205) in S. typhimurium topA was normal, suggesting that RecA is activated in topA mutants. These observations lead us to deduce that S. typhimurium has at least one DNA damage-inducible locus in addition to recA that is required for UV mutability.     

Spectrum of N4-aminocytidine mutagenesis

N4-Aminocytidine, a nucleoside analog, is a potent mutagen towards phages, bacteria, Drosophila and mammalian cells in culture. In vitro, biochemical studies indicate that this reagent acts by being incorporated into DNA. To elucidate the mechanism of N4-aminocytidine mutagenesis, it is essential to identify the nature of DNA sequence alterations taking place during the mutagenesis. We have analyzed the nucleotide sequence changes in the lac promoter-lacZ alpha region of M13mp2 phage induced by treatment of phage-infected Escherichia coli with N4-aminocytidine. The sequence alterations of DNA samples from 89 mutants of the phage were determined. These mutants had single point mutations, except one mutant, in which a double point mutation was detected. Several hot spots were found: however, there are no apparent relations to particular DNA sequences regarding the locations of these spots. All the mutations are transitions; neither transversions nor deletions/insertions were found. A feature in these transitions is that the A/T to G/C and G/C to A/T changes occur at approximately equal rates. The overall picture of the mutagenesis is consistent with a scheme in which misincorporation and misreplication caused by the modified cytosine structure are the key steps in the DNA replication leading to transitions. Similar nucleotide alterations were found for the mutagenesis induced by an alkylated derivative, N'-methyl-N4-aminocytidine. N4-Aminocytidine also induced reversions of these mutants; both A/T to G/C and G/C to A/T transitions again took place.     

Random oligonucleotide mutagenesis: application to a large protein coding sequence of a major histocompatibility complex class I gene, H-2DP.

We have used random oligonucleotide mutagenesis (or saturation mutagenesis) to create a library of point mutations in the alpha 1 protein domain of a Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC) molecule. This protein domain is critical for T cell and B cell recognition. We altered the MHC class I H-2DP gene sequence such that synthetic mutant alpha 1 exons (270 bp of coding sequence), which contain mutations identified by sequence analysis, can replace the wild type alpha 1 exon. The synthetic exons were constructed from twelve overlapping oligonucleotides which contained an average of 1.3 random point mutations per intact exon. DNA sequence analysis of mutant alpha 1 exons has shown a point mutant distribution that fits a Poisson distribution, and thus emphasizes the utility of this mutagenesis technique to "scan" a large protein sequence for important mutations. We report our use of saturation mutagenesis to scan an entire exon of the H-2DP gene, a cassette strategy to replace the wild type alpha 1 exon with individual mutant alpha 1 exons, and analysis of mutant molecules expressed on the surface of transfected mouse L cells.     

Evidence that stationary-phase hypermutation in the Escherichia coli chromosome is promoted by recombination

Adaptive (or stationary-phase) mutation is a group of phenomena in which mutations appear to occur more often when selected than when not. They may represent cellular responses to the environment in which the genome is altered to allow survival. The best-characterized assay system and mechanism is reversion of a lac allele on an F' sex plasmid in Escherichia coli, in which the stationary-phase mutability requires homologous recombination functions. A key issue has concerned whether the recombination-dependent mutation mechanism is F' specific or is general. Hypermutation of chromosomal genes occurs in association with adaptive Lac(+) mutation. Here we present evidence that the chromosomal hypermutation is promoted by recombination. Hyperrecombinagenic recD cells show elevated chromosomal hypermutation. Further, recG mutation, which promotes accumulation of recombination intermediates proposed to prime replication and mutation, also stimulates chromosomal hypermutation. The coincident mutations at lac (on the F') and chromosomal genes behave as independent events, whereas coincident mutations at lac and other F-linked sites do not. This implies that transient covalent linkage of F' and chromosomal DNA (Hfr formation) does not underlie chromosomal mutation. The data suggest that recombinational stationary-phase mutation occurs in the bacterial chromosome and thus can be a general strategy for programmed genetic change.     

Stress-induced mutation via DNA breaks in Escherichia coli: A molecular mechanism with implications for evolution and medicine

Evolutionary theory assumed that mutations occur constantly, gradually, and randomly over time. This formulation from the "modern synthesis" of the 1930s was embraced decades before molecular understanding of genes or mutations. Since then, our labs and others have elucidated mutation mechanisms activated by stress responses. Stress-induced mutation mechanisms produce mutations, potentially accelerating evolution, specifically when cells are maladapted to their environment, that is, when they are stressed. The mechanisms of stress-induced mutation that are being revealed experimentally in laboratory settings provide compelling models for mutagenesis that propels pathogen-host adaptation, antibiotic resistance, cancer progression and resistance, and perhaps much of evolution generally. We discuss double-strand-break-dependent stress-induced mutation in Escherichia coli. Recent results illustrate how a stress response activates mutagenesis and demonstrate this mechanism's generality and importance to spontaneous mutation. New data also suggest a possible harmony between previous, apparently opposed, models for the molecular mechanism. They additionally strengthen the case for anti-evolvability therapeutics for infectious disease and cancer.     

umuC-dependent and umuC-independent gamma- and UV-radiation mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

The effects of the umuC36 and umuC122::Tn 5 mutations on gamma- and UV radiation mutagenesis (nonsense, missense, and frameshift mutation assays) in Escherichia coli K12 were studied. Although both mutations reduced radiation mutagenesis, the umuC36 mutation appeared to be leaky since considerably more UV radiation mutagenesis could be detected in the umuC36 strain than in the umuC122::Tn 5 strain. In general, the umuC strain showed much larger deficiencies in UV radiation mutagenesis than they did for gamma-radiation mutagenesis. The mutability of the umuC122:: Tn 5 strain varied depending on the radiation dose, and the mutation assay used. For gamma-radiation mutagenesis, the deficiency varied from no deficiency to a 50-fold deficiency; for UV radiation mutagenesis, the deficiency varied from 100-fold to at least 5000-fold. We concluded that both umuC-dependent and umuC-independent modes function for gamma-radiation mutagenesis, while UV radiation mutagenesis seems to depend almost exclusively on the umuC-dependent mode.     

Screening for improved activity of a transglutaminase from Streptomyces mobaraensis created by a novel rational mutagenesis and random mutagenesis

Microbial transglutaminase (MTG) has been used extensively in academic research and the food industries through its cross-linking or posttranslational modification of proteins. Two enzyme engineering approaches were applied to improve MTG activity. One is a novel method of rational mutagenesis, called water-accessible surface hot-space region-oriented mutagenesis (WASH-ROM). One hundred and fifty-one point mutations were selected at 40 residues, bearing high solvent-accessibility surface area, within a 15?Å space from the active site Cys64. Among them, 32 mutants showed higher specific activity than the wild type. The other is a random mutagenesis of the whole region of the MTG gene, coupled with a new plate assay screening system, using Corynebacterium Expression System CORYNEX®. This in vivo system allowed us to readily distinguish the change in enzymatic activity by monitoring the intensity of enzymatic reaction-derived color zones surrounding recombinant cells. From the library of 24,000 mutants, ten were finally selected as beneficial mutants exhibiting higher specific activity than the wild type. Furthermore, we found that Ser199Ala mutant with additional N-terminal tetrapeptide showed the highest specific activity (1.7 times higher than the wild type). These various beneficial positions leading to increased specific activity of MTG were identified to achieve further enzyme improvements.     

Evolution of Ig DNA sequence to target specific base positions within codons for somatic hypermutation

Ig variable (V) region genes are subjected to a somatic hypermutation process as B lymphocytes participate in immune reactions to protein Ags. Although little is known regarding the mechanism of mutagenesis, a consistent hierarchy of trinucleotide target preferences is evident. Analysis of trinucleotide regional distributions predicted and we now empirically confirm the surprising finding that the framework 2 region of kappa V region genes is highly mutable despite its importance to the structural integrity and function of the Ab molecule. Interestingly, much of this mutability appears to be focused on the third codon position where synonymous substitutions are most likely to occur. We also observed a trend for high predicted mutability for codon positions 1 and 2 in complementarity-determining regions. Consequently, amino acid replacements should occur at a higher rate in complementarity-determining regions than in framework regions due to the distribution and subsequent targeting of microsequences by the mutation mechanism. Our results reveal a subtle tier of V region gene evolution in which DNA sequence has been molded to direct mutations to specific base positions within codons in a manner that minimizes damage and maximizes the benefits of the somatic hypermutation process.     

Checkpoint responses to replication stalling: inducing tolerance and preventing mutagenesis

Replication mutants often exhibit a mutator phenotype characterized by point mutations, single base frameshifts, and the deletion or duplication of sequences flanked by homologous repeats. Mutation in genes encoding checkpoint proteins can significantly affect the mutator phenotype. Here, we use fission yeast (Schizosaccharomyces pombe) as a model system to discuss the checkpoint responses to replication perturbations induced by replication mutants. Checkpoint activation induced by a DNA polymerase mutant, aside from delay of mitotic entry, up-regulates the translesion polymerase DinB (Polkappa). Checkpoint Rad9-Rad1-Hus1 (9-1-1) complex, which is loaded onto chromatin by the Rad17-Rfc2-5 checkpoint complex in response to replication perturbation, recruits DinB onto chromatin to generate the point mutations and single nucleotide frameshifts in the replication mutator. This chain of events reveals a novel checkpoint-induced tolerance mechanism that allows cells to cope with replication perturbation, presumably to make possible restarting stalled replication forks.Fission yeast Cds1 kinase plays an essential role in maintaining DNA replication fork stability in the face of DNA damage and replication fork stalling. Cds1 kinase is known to regulate three proteins that are implicated in maintaining replication fork stability: Mus81-Eme1, a hetero-dimeric structure-specific endonuclease complex; Rqh1, a RecQ-family helicase involved in suppressing inappropriate recombination during replication; and Rad60, a protein required for recombinational repair during replication. These Cds1-regulated proteins are thought to cooperatively prevent mutagenesis and maintain replication fork stability in cells under replication stress. These checkpoint-regulated processes allow cells to survive replication perturbation by preventing stalled replication forks from degenerating into deleterious DNA structures resulting in genomic instability and cancer development.     

Coupled mutagenesis screens and genetic mapping in zebrafish

Forward genetic analysis is one of the principal advantages of the zebrafish model system. However, managing zebrafish mutant lines derived from mutagenesis screens and mapping the corresponding mutations and integrating them into the larger collection of mutations remain arduous tasks. To simplify and focus these endeavors, we developed an approach that facilitates the rapid mapping of new zebrafish mutations as they are generated through mutagenesis screens. We selected a minimal panel of 149 simple sequence length polymorphism markers for a first-pass genome scan in crosses involving C32 and SJD inbred lines. We also conducted a small chemical mutagenesis screen that identified several new mutations affecting zebrafish embryonic melanocyte development. Using our first-pass marker panel in bulked-segregant analysis, we were able to identify the genetic map positions of these mutations as they were isolated in our screen. Rapid mapping of the mutations facilitated stock management, helped direct allelism tests, and should accelerate identification of the affected genes. These results demonstrate the efficacy of coupling mutagenesis screens with genetic mapping.