A review of methods used to measure sediment resuspension

Resuspension of bottom sediments is an important lake-internal process with regard to particle cycling and sedimentation. Current methods to measure sediment resuspension are reviewed, such as optical and acoustical instruments, instantaneous multiple point water samplers, sediment traps, sediment cores and grabs, radiotracers such as Pb²¹⁰, Cs¹³⁷ and Be⁷, mass balance calculations, various modelling approaches, statistical methods (correlation analysis), and laboratory experiments.For the quantification of resuspension, the combined use of sediment traps, sediment cores, near bottom current meters, and turbidity meters to measure suspended and settling particulate matter in the hypolimnion of lakes is recommended; in addition, wind stress, seiches, slumping and sliding, and riverine input may be monitored to elucidate the mechanisms behind the process.     

The role of sedimentation and resuspension for the transport of sediments and contaminants in the Skagerrak

An investigation was conducted in winter of 1997/1998 in the Skagerrak off southern Norway to collect data on the influence of sedimentation and resuspension on the transport of organic contaminants. Data from the water column and sediments, as well as on sedimentation and current regime near the sea floor, indicated that the deposition of contaminants is a continual process. Deposition is subject not only to seasonal biological processes such as growth and sedimentation of the spring phytoplankton bloom, but also to hydrographic events such as surges in near-bottom currents causing sediment resuspension. Contaminants at the sea floor may be transported considerable distances. It is suggested that in simplest terms, this transport can be envisaged as a conveyor belt skipping along the seabed. The dominant iterative processes regulating this near-bottom transport are sedimentation, resuspension and advection. In this way, particles and associated polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, as well as other hydrophobic contaminants, may be transported over hundreds of kilometers.     

High resolution measurements of sediment resuspension above an accumulation bottom in a stratified lake

A detailed record of suspended particulate matter (SPM) concentrations in the benthic boundary layer (BBL) 1.5 m above an accumulation bottom and 13.5 m below the surface was obtained from frequent (30 min interval) beam attenuation measurements made with a Sea Tech transmissometer in the main basin of Lake Erken, a moderately deep (mean depth 9 m, maximum depth 21 m) dimictic lake in central Sweden. Concentrations of SPM (g m^–3) were not as strongly correlated to the beam attenuation coefficient (c, [m^–1]), as were concentrations of the inorganic SPM fraction. Apparently, this was caused by large optically inactive organic particles which significantly affected the measurements of SPM, but had little effect on the attenuation of light.When the water column was thermally stratified, SPM concentrations in the BBL showed a seasonal increase which was related to an increase in the thermocline depth. As the epilimnion deepened, there was also a marked increase in the occurrence of rapid and large changes in SPM concentration. After the loss of stratification, the amount of SPM and the temporal variability in its concentration was reduced. Since surface waves could not influence sediment resuspension at the depth of measurement, these data show the importance of internal waves in promoting sediment resuspension in areas of sediment accumulation. The relatively short period in each summer, when the thermocline reaches a sufficient depth to allow for resuspension over accumulation bottoms, can have important consequences for both the redistribution of lake sediments and the internal loading of phosphorus.     

The effect of different submerged macrophyte species and biomass on sediment resuspension in a shallow freshwater lake

Our study aim was to elucidate the effects of different species of submerged macrophytes and biomass levels on sediment resuspension. For this purpose experiments were conducted in four different enclosures (Potamogeton maackianus enclosure-PE, Vallisneria spinulosa enclosure-VE, manipulated enclosure-ME and aquaculture enclosure-AE). A sediment trap method was employed and the experiments were conducted from summer to winter in a shallow freshwater lake located in central China. A total of 813, 1277, 613 and 693 g DW m⁻² of sediment was resuspended in VE, AE, ME and PE, respectively. Our results showed that P. maackianus was more effective than V. spinulosa in restraining sediment resuspension. Macrophytes reached their maximum effectiveness of reducing resuspension at a certain species-specific biomass threshold above which biomass effects on resuspension were negligible. The threshold biomass was estimated as 300 g m⁻² for P. maackianus. Accordingly, within a lake management and aquaculture aspect, we conclude that as long as biomass does not fall below this threshold its consumption will not influence sediment resuspension. In the mid-lower reaches of the Yangtze River macrophyte coverage protects the lake sediment against adverse effects of monsoon wind; if the vegetation is eroded aquaculture sediment resuspension increases significantly.     

Estimation of the in-situ settling velocity of particles in lakes using a time series sediment trap

SUMMARY 1. We outline a simple method for estimating the in-situ settling velocity of particles in wind disturbed lakes. The total sedimentation rate (primary and secondary sedimentation) was measured during storm events in two lakes using a time series sediment trap.
2. The sediment trap had 12 sample bottles which were programmed to open for periods of 3–4 h, giving total deployment times ranging from 36 to 48 h.
3. Wave mixed layer theory was used to infer if and when sediment resuspension occurred and the first order rate equation was used to estimate the settling velocity of resuspended particles.
4. The settling velocity during three resuspension events in Lough Neagh and one in Lough Macnean were 34.3, 29.5, 24.1 and 77.3 m day⁻¹, respectively. These are similar to values obtained using recent in-situ video imaging in marine environments, but much larger than previous lake sediment trap studies.     

Phosphorus in settling matter and bottom sediments in lakes loaded by agriculture

In shallow lakes, the cycling of P between water and bottom sediments is strongly influenced by wind-induced resuspension of particulate matter. The significance of this P flux as an algal nutrient source is unclear. We examined gross sedimentation in 3 open and shallow agriculturally loaded lakes. In addition, we estimated the potential P-release from settling and bottom matter by laboratory tests. The mean daily rate of gross sedimentation was 21–170 g m^–2 d^–1 of dry sediment, 0.04–0.18 g m^–2 d^–1 of P and 0.18–2.0 g m^–2 d^–1 of N; being the highest in the shallowest and most eutrophic lake. In Lake Karhijärvi, where the most intensive measurements were taken, wind explained the temporal variation in the gross sedimentation to some extent. The settling matter consisted of inorganic particles low in nutrients, especially during peak sedimentation periods. On average, 7.7 ± 3.1% (x ± 95% confidence interval) of the P in the settling matter in L. Karhijärvi was in an algal-available form according to 2–3 week bioassays. In the bottom matter of the three lakes, 3.0 ± 1.7% and 2.5 ± 3.6%, and 4.3 ± 3.7% of the P was utilized by the algae. In L. Karhijärvi, resuspension of the potentially available P exceeded 20 times the external loading during the open water season. According to sorption tests, P is released from the bottom matter only when the concentration of o-P is <2 g l^–1. Although such a low value cannot be determined with common analytical procedures, it seems probable that the P concentration allows P desorption during P-limited periods. However, the significance of resuspended matter as an algal nutrient source calls for further research.     

Release of metals from polluted sediments in a shallow lake: quantifying resuspension

The contribution of erosion of bed sediment to the load of metals leaving Lake Ketelmeer, a shallow lake in the Netherlands fed by the IJssel branch of the River Rhine, is reported. Transport of suspended matter and associated trace metals was measured using both centrifuges and sediment traps at several locations in the lake. Mass balances of suspended matter and heavy metals were calculated using data from these field measurements.Metal/scandium-ratios were used to identify the source of the suspended matter in the lake. Since the bed sediment is more polluted than the suspended sediment entering the lake, higher metal/scandium-ratios were found for bottom sediment in the lake compared with those for suspended matter entering the lake from the River IJssel. Using the metal/scadium-ratio in suspended matter from the lake, it was calculated that bottom sediments made up 43% of the suspended matter leaving the lake. This implies an erosion flux of bottom sediment of 16 g m^–2 d^–1. For cadmium, mercury, chromium and zinc, this erosion process accounts for more than 50% of the pollutant load leaving Lake Ketelmeer and entering Lake IJsselmeer.     

Modulation of dissolved oxygen levels in a hypertidal estuary by sediment resuspension

Hyperconcentrated benthic layers, which form during neap tides, recruit much of the fine sediment population of the turbidity maximum of a hypertidal estuary. Measurements of tidal amplitude and suspended solids concentration reveal that resuspension of the hyperconcentrated layers occurs between three and eight tides after neap tides rather than during spring tides (12 to 15 tides after neaps). During these resuspension events, dissolved oxygen levels are reduced but recover by spring tides. Peak solids concentrations and critically depressed dissolved oxygen levels are out of phase with tidal current amplitude. Thus observations close to neap and spring tides do not necessaraly capture the extremes of the envelope of water quality conditions.     

Effects of different macrophyte growth forms on sediment and P resuspension in a shallow lake

The effects of floating-leaved, submerged and emergent macrophytes on sediment resuspension and internal phosphorus loading were studied in the shallow Kirkkojärvi basin by placing sedimentation traps among different plant beds and adjacent open water and by sediment and water samples. All the three life forms considerably reduced sediment resuspension compared with non-vegetated areas. Both among submerged (Ceratophyllum demersum, Potamogeton obtusifolius, Ranunculus circinatus) and emergent (Typha angustifolia) plants, resuspension rate was on average 43% of that in the adjacent open water, while within floating-leaved plants (Nuphar lutea) the corresponding value was 87%. The effects of submerged and emergent vegetation increased in the course of the growing season together with increasing plant density. Among floating-leaved vegetation, such seasonal trend in resuspension effects was not observed. Compared with the non-vegetated area, floating-leaved, submerged and emergent plants reduced internal phosphorus loading on average by 21, 12 and 26 mg m⁻² d⁻¹, respectively. The effects of floating-leaved plants on resuspension-mediated internal phosphosrus loading were thus comparable to the effects of the other two life forms.     

Modeling underwater light climate in relation to sedimentation,resuspension, water quality and autotrophic growth

The underwater light climate ultimately determines the depth distribution, abundance and primary production of autotrophs suspended within and rooted beneath the water column. This paper addresses the underwater light climate, with reference to effects of suspended solids and growth responses of autotrophs with emphasis on phytoplankton.Effects of the most important factors contributing to the absorption and scattering of light in surface waters were described. A comparison between spectral and scalar approaches to underwater light climate modeling was made and examples of linear approximations to light attenuation equations were presented. It was demonstrated that spectral and scalar photosynthesis models may converge to similar values in spectral-flat, high photon flux environments, but that scalar PAR models may overestimate biomass-specific production by 70%. Such differences can lead to serious overestimates of habitat suitability for the growth and survival of submersed macrophytes, particularly in relatively turbid, coastal waters.Relationships between physical and optical properties of suspended sediments were described theoretically, and illustrated with modeling examples and measurements. It was found that the slowly settling particulate fraction contributed substantially to the suspended solids concentration, and greatly to light attenuation within the water column. It was concluded that distinguishing particles by fall velocity and concomitant light attenuation properties in the modeling of underwater light conditions allowed the establishment of useful, although not simply linear, relationships.In eutrophic, shallow lakes, the largest contribution to light attenuation often originates from phytoplankton on a seasonal basis (months–years), but from suspended solids behavior on a shorter time scale (days–weeks), particularly when water bodies are wind-exposed. Temporal and spatial variabilities in wave height, suspended solids concentrations, and light attenuation within the water column, and their importance for autotrophic growth were described, and illustrated with a case study pertaining to Markermeer, The Netherlands. The influence of underwater light conditions on phytoplankton succession was briefly discussed and illustrated with a case study pertaining to Lake Veluwe, The Netherlands. It was concluded that modeling the underwater light climate in a water body on a few sites only can indicate how important various components are for the attenuation of light, but based on the current state of the art, it can not be expected that this will provide accurate predictions of the underwater light climate, and of phytoplankton and submersed macrophyte growth.     

Seston sedimentation in a lowland river (River Spree,Germany): their spatial and temporal variations and controlling factors

Sedimentation of organic particles plays a decisive role in streams in relation to pelagic loss as well as retention of nutrients and other substances. The plate sediment trap allows for the direct measurement of these net fluxes. Biweekly measurements were undertaken in the eutrophic lowland River Spree (MQ 14 m³ s^–1) 10 km upstream of Berlin in 1999 and 2000. Trapping rates between 0.5 and 25 g DW m^–2 day^–1 were found near the bank. The variance of seston sedimentation is controlled by the seston concentration, the settling velocity of the particles and the flow velocity. The sinking velocity exhibits significant seasonal fluctuations with highest values in summer. It is shown that the critical flow velocity for sedimentation is another important parameter. This controls the distribution of sedimentation over the width of the river and thus the effective average sedimentation rate for the entire river segment. This average rate ranged between 0.9 and 6.6 g DW m^–2 day^–1.     

Effects of estuarine infauna on sediment stability and particle sedimentation

Secretions produced by the two estuarine benthic invertebrates Corophium volutator and Nereis diversicolor stabilise sediments by increasing their shear strength, and reduce sedimentation of previously resuspended particles. The secretions consist of 1 to 2 m threads which bind the particles together. They are used by both species in the production of complex burrow systems in the top 15 cm of sediment. The burrow systems have been demonstrated by a new resin impregnation technique. These results have widespread implications for the stability and erosion of estuarine sediments.     

A dynamic model for flow and wind driven sediment resuspension in a shallow basin

A model is presented, which describes the daily variations in suspended particulate inorganic matter (SPIM) in a large (61 km²), shallow (mean depth 3.4 m) wind-exposed lake basin at the western end of Lake Mälaren, Sweden. Field studies have shown that wind speed and river inflow are the two major factors leading to changes in SPIM. Wind speed and beam attenuation were measured at high (10 min) frequency, while river inflow were monitored at daily frequency to develop the model. From these field measurements, model-coefficients were determined for the SPIM transport, settling and resuspension. Large-scale variations in SPIM lasting many weeks could be explained by events of high river inflow with a correspondingly high particle load. The threshold for river transported SPIM to have effect on lake concentration was 150 m³ s^–1, while wind induced resuspended SPIM was related to the square root of wind speed.     

Estimation of export production in the coastal Baltic Sea: effect of resuspension and microbial decomposition on sedimentation measurements

Hydrography, nutrient concentrations, primary production and sedimentation of particulate matter were studied during spring, late summer and autumn in the coastal area of the northern Baltic Sea, SW Finland. Vernal phytoplankton productivity peak and biomass maximum in early May were followed by high sedimentation rates of organic matter at the end of May. In summer, sedimentation rates of organic material were generally low. The decay rates of organic carbon in the sediment traps, estimated by measuring oxygen uptake of settled organic matter, varied between 0.005 to 0.08 d^–1 and were on average 0.02 d^–1. Decomposition of organic matter inside the sediment traps was mainly controlled by temperature, while also organic contents of settled material were significant. Microbial decomposition decreased sedimentation rates of organic carbon and nitrogen on average by 11% and 15%, respectively, during the whole study period of ca. 6 months. Resuspension of organic matter from sediment surface was estimated to contribute ca. 17 and 24% of the total sedimentation of organic carbon during spring and summer, respectively. Export production (i.e. primary sedimentation of organic carbon corrected by decomposition) was estimated to be 32% of the net primary production during the whole productive season and 42% in spring when the flux of primary settling material was greatest. Sedimentation of the spring bloom was the major annual supply of organic matter to the benthos (>80% of the total primary sedimentation).     

An automated method for determination of the sedimentation coefficient of macromolecules using a preparative centrifuge

Following centrifugation in a preparative ultracentrifuge at relatively high speeds for 1-3 h, quartz tubes containing approximately 150 microliter of macromolecular solution are optically scanned using an apparatus and method previously described (Attri, A. K., and Minton A. P. (1983) Anal. Biochem. 133, 142-152). The resulting data are processed by microcomputer immediately upon completion of scanning to yield the sedimentation coefficient of the solute. Calculated values agree to within a few percent with those found in the literature and with the results of control experiments carried out using an analytical ultracentrifuge.     

Characteristics of settling matter and its role in nutrient cycles in a deep oligotrophic lake

The settling flux of seston (dry weight, DW), chlorophyll a (Chl a), particulate organic carbon (POC), particulate organic nitrogen (PON), and particulate phosphorus (PP) was measured monthly in 1981–1983 at 10 different depths in Lake Chuzenji, Japan; an oligotrophic lake with a maximum depth of 163 m. The Ti concentration in entrapped matter was used to separate the sedimentation flux into allochthonous and autochthonous components. Inflow loads of dissolved nutrients (DN: 4.5, DP: 0.48 g m^-2a^-1) were almost sufficient to supply the autochthonous fluxes at 30 m (PON: 2.9, PP: 0.51 g m^-2a^-1 ), and this flux of POC (26.6 g m^-2a ^-1) was about one-third of primary production (84 g C M^-2a^-1). Sedimentation of particulate matter was the main path of losing nutrients from lake water, explaining more than 80% removal of inflow loads (TN, TP). Decomposition rates during sedimentation which were calculated from the vertical difference in the autochthonous flux agreed very closely with the results obtained by laboratory experiments of a 100-day incubation (content ratios from field observations were: POC 0.67, PON 0.65, PP 0.85; and from laboratory experiments they were: POC 0.68, PON 0.70, PP 0.94). These decomposition rates and those near the sediment interface were used to explain dissolved oxygen depletion and nitrate increase in the hypolimnion during stratification. The average sinking velocities were 1.82m d^-1 for seston and 1.16 m d^-1 for Chl a at 30m, they were influenced by Chl a content of seston.     

The effect of wave-reduction engineering on sediment resuspension in a large, shallow, eutrophic lake (Lake Taihu)

Frequent resuspension of sediments is recognized as an important process in large shallow lakes, impeding the recovery of eutrophic lakes. A large-scale project, including a wave barrier (3.3 km long) and a soft enclosure, was implemented to reduce wave energy and sediment resuspension in Lake Taihu, eastern China. The effects of the wave-reduction engineering on sediment resuspension and internal nutrient loading were investigated. Results showed that sediment resuspension rates as well as suspended solids (SS) in the areas protected by the wave barrier and the soft enclosure were significantly lower than in the unprotected areas. There was a positive relationship between total phosphorus (TP) and SS; thus internal loading of phosphorus was significantly reduced by the wave-reduction structure. High nutrient levels and phytoplankton biomass persisted during the experiment period, suggesting that additional measures, such as re-establishment of the macrophyte community, must be included to help restore the water quality in such a large, shallow and eutrophic lake.     

The effect of an emergent macrophyte (Typha angustifolia) on sediment resuspension in a shallow north temperate lake

1. The effects of emergent macrophytes on water turbidity and sediment resuspension in the shallow Kirkkojärvi basin of Lake Hiidenvesi were studied with sediment traps, and concomitant sediment and water samples. The study was conducted during May–August in three different zones of a stand of the emergent Typha angustifolia .
2. Within the stand (5 m from the edge), both the concentration of suspended solids and the rate of sediment resuspension were significantly lower than at the edge and outside the stand (5 m from the edge). The differences between the zones increased towards the end of summer together with the growing stem density. During the study period (82 days), 2210 g dw m⁻² of sediment was resuspended in the outer zone. At the edge and in the inner zone, the corresponding numbers were 1414 and 858 g dw m⁻², respectively.
3. With the resuspended sediment, 39.4 mg P  m⁻² day⁻¹ was brought to the water column outside the stand, 22.4 mg P  m⁻² day⁻¹ at the edge and 13.4 mg P  m⁻² day⁻¹ within the stand.
4. In early summer, the concentration of suspended solids had a highly significant positive effect on soluble reactive phosphorus (SRP) concentration in the water, whereas in late summer no effect was found. During the study period, phosphorus retention by emergent macrophyte stands corresponded to 3–5% of the present annual external phosphorus loading of the Kirkkojärvi basin.     

Interpretation of sedimentation data measured in a former tidal channel Lake Volkerak

In Lake Volkerak, situated in the southwest of the Netherlands, downward settling fluxes are related to external inputs of suspended solids and wind action. The settling fluxes, measured using sediment traps, were 55 g (dw) m ^–2 d ^–1 on average. The ratio of metal concentration to scandium concentration was used to discriminate between external (polluted) suspended solids and internal (relatively clean) suspended solids. Generally, the contribution of the river suspended solids was small compared to that of resuspended material; the river-transported material was mainly deposited in the centre and to the east of the lake. The amount of material trapped increased substantially with increasing wind velocity.A simple model was used to interpretate the data. This model does not have a predictive capacity, but can be used to interpret and assess the significance of material retained in the sediment traps. Erosion was related to the wind velocity, using an empirical relationship between the orbital velocity of the wind-generated waves at the bottom and the wind velocity. The critical wind velocity for erosion to occur was estimated to be 5.5 m s^–1. The extremely high amounts retained in the sediment traps in shallow areas during storms emphasised the importance of these wind conditions for the transport of fine sediments.     

Efficiency of Malaise traps and colored pan traps for collecting flower visiting insects from three forested ecosystems

Pan and Malaise traps have been used widely to sample insect abundance and diversity, but no studies have compared their performance for sampling pollinators in forested ecosystems. Malaise trap design and color of pan traps are important parameters that influence insect pollinator catches. We compared pan trap (blue, yellow, white, and red) and Malaise trap catches from forests in three physiographic provinces (Piedmont, Coastal Plain, and Blue Ridge) of the southeastern United States. Similarities in trap performance between sites were observed with blue pan traps being most effective overall. Our results showed that various pollinator groups preferred certain pan trap colors and that adding color to Malaise traps influenced insect pollinator catches. However, pan traps generally caught more pollinators than Malaise traps. Because of their low cost and simplicity, using several colors of pan traps is an effective way to sample relative abundance and species richness of flower-visiting insects.