Compensatory mutations demonstrate that P8 and P6 are RNA secondary structure elements important for processing of a group I intron.

Compensatory mutations have been constructed which demonstrate that P8 and P6, two of nine proposed base-pairing interactions characteristic of group I introns, exist within the folded structure of the Tetrahymena thermophila rRNA intervening sequence, and that these secondary structure elements are important for splicing in E. coli and self-splicing in vitro. Two-base mutations in the 5' and 3' segments of P8 are predicted to disrupt P8 and a strong splicing-defective phenotype is observed in each case. A compensatory four-base mutation in P8 is predicted to restore pairing, and results in the restoration of splicing activity to nearly wild type levels. Thus, we conclude that P8 exists and is essential for splicing. In contrast to the strong phenotypes generally exhibited by mutations which disrupt RNA secondary structure, a two-base mutation in L8, the loop between P8[5'] and P8[3'], results in only a slight decrease in splicing activity. We also tested P6, a pairing which is proposed to consist of only two base-pairs in this intron. A two-base mutation in P6[3'] reduces splicing activity to a greater extent than does a two-base mutation in P6[5']. Comparison of the activities of these mutants and a compensatory P6 four-base mutant support the existence of P6, and suggest that the P6 pairing may be particularly important in the exon ligation step of splicing.     

Mutations at the 3' splice site can be suppressed by compensatory base changes in U1 snRNA in fission yeast.

U1 snRNA is an essential splicing factor known to base pair with 5' splice sites of premessenger RNAs. We demonstrate that pairing between the universally conserved CU just downstream from the 5' junction interaction region and the 3' splice site AG contributes to efficient splicing of Schizosaccharomyces pombe introns that typify the AG-dependent class described in mammals. Strains carrying mutations in the 3' AG of an artificial intron accumulate linear precursor, indicative of a first step block. Lariat formation is partially restored in these mutants by compensatory changes in nucleotides C7 and U8 of U1 snRNA. Consistent with a general role in fission yeast splicing, mutations at C7 are lethal, while U8 mutants are growth impaired and accumulate linear, unspliced precursor to U6 snRNA. U1 RNA-mediated recognition of the 3' splice site may have origins in analogous intramolecular interactions in an ancestral self-splicing RNA.     

Two domains for splicing in the intron of the phage T4 thymidylate synthase (td) gene established by nondirected mutagenesis

Of 97 nondirected T4 thymidylate synthase-defective (td) mutations, 27 were mapped to the intron of the split td gene. Clustering of these intron mutations defined two domains that are functional in splicing, each within approximately 220 residues of the respective splice sites. Two selected mutations, tdN57 and tdN47, fell within phylogenetically conserved pairings, with tdN57 disrupting the exon I-internal guide pairing (P1) in the 5' domain and tdN47 destabilizing the P9 helix in the 3' domain. A splicing assay with synthetic oligonucleotides complementary to RNA junction sequences revealed processing defects for T4tdN57 and T4tdN47, both of which are impaired in cleavage at the 5' and 3' splice sites. Thus prokaryotic genetics facilitates association of specific residue changes with their consequences to splicing.     

Activation of a cryptic 5' splice site by U1 snRNA

In the course of analyzing 5' splice site mutations in the second intron of Schizosaccharomyces pombe cdc2, we identified a cryptic 5' junction containing a nonconsensus nucleotide at position +2. An even more unusual feature of this cryptic 5' junction was its pattern of activation. By analyzing the profile of splicing products for an extensive series of cdc2 mutants in the presence and absence of compensatory U1 alleles, we have obtained evidence that the natural 5' splice site participates in activation of the cryptic 5' splice site, and that it does so via base pairing to U1 snRNA. Furthermore, the results of follow-up experiments strongly suggest that base pairing between U1 snRNA and the cryptic 5' junction itself plays a dominant role in its activation. Most remarkably, a mutant U1 can activate the cryptic 5' splice site even in the presence of a wild-type sequence at the natural 5' junction, providing unambiguous evidence that this snRNA redirects splicing via base pairing. Although previous work has demonstrated that U5 and U6 snRNAs can activate cryptic 5' splice sites through base pairing interactions, this is the first example in which U1 snRNA has been implicated in the final selection of a cryptic 5' junction.     

In vivo selection of better self-splicing introns in Escherichia coli: the role of the P1 extension helix of the Tetrahymena intron

In vivo selection was used to improve the activity of the Tetrahymena pre-rRNA self-splicing intron in the context of heterologous exons. The intron was engineered into a kanamycin nucleotidyltransferase gene, with the pairing between intron bases and the 5' and 3' splice sites maintained. The initial construct failed to confer kanamycin resistance on Escherichia coli, although the pre-mRNA was active in splicing in vitro. Random mutation libraries were constructed to identify active intron variants in E. coli. All the active mutants sequenced contained mutations disrupting a base-paired region above the paired region P1 (referred to as the P1 extension region or P1ex) that involves the very 5' end of the intron. Subsequent site-directed mutagenesis confirmed that these P1ex mutations are responsible and sufficient to activate the intron splicing in E. coli. Thus, it appears that too strong of a secondary structure in the P1ex element can be inhibitory to splicing in vivo. In vitro splicing assays demonstrated that two P1ex mutant constructs splice six to eight times faster than the designed construct at 40 microM GTP concentration. The relative reaction rates of the mutant constructs compared to the original design are further increased at a lower GTP concentration. Possible mechanisms by which the disrupted P1ex structure could influence splicing rates are discussed. This study emphasizes the value of using libraries of random mutations to improve the activity of ribozymes in heterologous contexts in vivo.     

Base pairing with U6atac snRNA is required for 5' splice site activation of U12-dependent introns in vivo.

The minor U12-dependent class of eukaryotic nuclear pre-mRNA introns is spliced by a distinct spliceosomal mechanism that requires the function of U11, U12, U5, U4atac, and U6atac snRNAs. Previous work has shown that U11 snRNA plays a role similar to U1 snRNA in the major class spliceosome by base pairing to the conserved 5'' splice site sequence. Here we show that U6atac snRNA also base pairs to the 5'' splice site in a manner analogous to that of U6 snRNA in the major class spliceosome. We show that splicing defective mutants of the 5'' splice site can be activated for splicing in vivo by the coexpression of compensatory U6atac snRNA mutants. In some cases, maximal restoration of splicing required the coexpression of compensatory U11 snRNA mutants. The allelic specificity of mutant phenotype suppression is consistent with Watson-Crick base pairing between the pre-mRNA and the snRNAs. These results provide support for a model of the RNA-RNA interactions at the core of the U12-dependent spliceosome that is strikingly similar to that of the major class U2-dependent spliceosome.     

Multiple interdependent sequence elements control splicing of a fibroblast growth factor receptor 2 alternative exon.

The fibroblast growth factor receptor 2 gene contains a pair of mutually exclusive alternative exons, one of which (K-SAM) is spliced specifically in epithelial cells. We have described previously (F. Del Gatto and R. Breathnach, Mol. Cell. Biol. 15:4825-4834, 1995) some elements controlling K-SAM exon splicing, namely weak exon splice sites, an exon-repressing sequence, and an intron-activating sequence. We identify here two additional sequences in the intron downstream from the K-SAM exon which activate splicing of the exon. The first sequence (intron-activating sequence 2 [IAS2]) lies 168 to 186 nucleotides downstream from the exon's 5' splice site. The second sequence (intron-activating sequence 3 [IAS3]) lies 933 to 1,052 nucleotides downstream from the exon's 5' splice site. IAS3 is a complex region composed of several parts, one of which (nucleotides 963 to 983) can potentially form an RNA secondary structure with IAS2. This structure is composed of two stems separated by an asymmetric bulge. Mutations which disrupt either stem decrease activation, while compensatory mutations which reestablish the stem restore activation, either completely or partially, depending on the mutation. We present a model for K-SAM exon splicing involving the intervention of multiple, interdependent pre-mRNA sequence elements.     

An intronic splicing enhancer binds U1 snRNPs to enhance splicing and select 5' splice sites

Intronic G triplets are frequently located adjacent to 5' splice sites in vertebrate pre-mRNAs and have been correlated with splicing efficiency and specificity via a mechanism that activates upstream 5' splice sites in exons containing duplicated sites (26). Using an intron dependent upon G triplets for maximal activity and 5' splice site specificity, we determined that these elements bind U1 snRNPs via base pairing with U1 RNA. This interaction is novel in that it uses nucleotides 8 to 10 of U1 RNA and is independent of nucleotides 1 to 7. In vivo functionality of base pairing was documented by restoring activity and specificity to mutated G triplets through compensating U1 RNA mutations. We suggest that the G-rich region near vertebrate 5' splice sites promotes accurate splice site recognition by recruiting the U1 snRNP.     

Natural base-pairing interactions between 5' splice site and branch site sequences affect mammalian 5' splice site selection.

In the murine gene encoding the neuronal cell adhesion molecule (NCAM), the integrity of the 5' splice site of exon 18 (E18) is essential for regulation of alternative splicing. To further study the contribution of 5' splice site sequences, we used a simple NCAM pre-mRNA containing a portion of E18 fused to E19 and separated by a shortened intron. This RNA is spliced in vitro to produce five sets of lariat intermediates and products, the most abundant set displaying aberrant migration in acrylamide/urea gels. Base pairing interactions between positions +5 and +8 of the intron and positions -3 and -6 from the branch point were responsible for the faster migration of this set of lariat molecules. To test whether the duplex structure forms earlier and contributes to 5' splice site selection, we used NCAM substrates carrying the 5' splice sites of E17 and E18 in competition for the 3' splice site of E19. Mutations upstream of the major branch site improve E18/E19 splicing in NIH3T3 extracts, whereas compensatory mutations at positions +7 and +8 neutralize the effect of branch site mutations and curtail E18/E19 splicing. Our data suggest that duplex formation occurs early and interferes with the assembly of complexes initiated on the 5' splice site of NCAM E18. This novel type of intron interaction may exist in the introns of other mammalian pre-mRNAs.     

Functional analyses of positions across the 5' splice site of the trypanosomatid spliced leader RNA. Implications for base-pair interaction with U5 and U6 snRNAs

In this study, we have used a genetic compensatory approach to examine the functional significance of the previously proposed interaction of spliced leader (SL) RNA with U5 small nuclear RNA (snRNA) (Dungan, J. D., Watkins, K. P., and Agabian, N. (1996) EMBO J. 15, 4016-4029; Xu, Y.-X., Ben Shlomo, H., and Michaeli, S. (1997) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 94, 8473-8478) and the interaction of the SL RNA intron with U6 snRNA analogous to cis-splicing. Mutations were introduced at positions -4, -1, +1, +4, +5, and +7/+8 relative to the SL RNA 5' splice site that were proposed to interact with U5 and U6 snRNAs. All mutants exhibited altered splicing phenotypes compared with the parental strain, showing the importance of these intron and exon positions for trans-splicing. Surprisingly, mutation at invariant +1 position did not abolish splicing completely, unlike cis-splicing, but position +2 had the most severe effect on trans-splicing. Compensatory mutations were introduced in U5 and U6 snRNAs to examine whether the defects resulted from failure to interact with these snRNAs by base pairing. Suppression was observed only for positions +5 and +7/+8 with U5 compensatory mutations and for position +5 with a U6 compensatory mutation, supporting the existence of a base pair interaction of U5 and U6 with the SL RNA intron region. The failure to suppress the other SL RNA mutants by the U5 compensatory mutations suggests that another factor(s) interacts with these key SL RNA positions.     

Folding problems of the 5' splice site containing the P1 stem of the group I thymidylate synthase intron: substrate binding inhibition in vitro and mis-splicing in vivo

We developed an in vitro cleaving assay for the thymidylate synthase (td) group I intron and observed that the off-rate of the substrate is faster than cleavage. From the sequence stems P1 and P2 can vary from 4 to 8 and from 6 to 10 base pairs, respectively, with folding of a long P1 stem being in competition with folding of a long P2 stem. Shorter substrates, which cannot compete with the formation of an extended P2, result in faster cleavage, suggesting that binding of the substrate indeed interferes with folding of stem P2. In vivo splicing analyses of mutants containing alterations in stems P1 and P2 indicate that the wild-type exon sequence of P1 is suboptimal for splicing. Furthermore, folding of P1 in vivo is in competition with an alternative cryptic P1 stem resulting in mis-splicing. Translation promotes splicing at the correct 5' splice site, whereas in the absence of translation, mis-splicing is favored. The combination of the in vitro and in vivo assays clearly displays the folding problems for correct splice site selection in this group I intron.     

Uncoupling two functions of the U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein particle during in vitro splicing.

To probe functions of the U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein particle (snRNP) during in vitro splicing, we have used unusual splicing substrates which replace the 5' splice site region of an adenovirus substrate with spliced leader (SL) RNA sequences from Leptomonas collosoma or Caenorhabditis elegans. In agreement with previous results (J.P. Bruzik and J.A. Steitz, Cell 62:889-899, 1990), we find that oligonucleotide-targeted RNase H destruction of the 5' end of U1 snRNA inhibits the splicing of a standard adenovirus splicing substrate but not of the SL RNA-containing substrates. However, use of an antisense 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotide that disrupts the first stem of U1 snRNA as well as stably sequestering positions of U1 snRNA involved in 5' and 3' splice site recognition inhibits the splicing of both the SL constructs and the standard adenovirus substrate. The 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotide is no more effective than RNase H pretreatment in preventing pairing of U1 with the 5' splice site, as assessed by inhibition of psoralen cross-link formation between the SL RNA-containing substrate and U1. The 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotide does not alter the protein composition of the U1 monoparticle or deplete the system of essential splicing factors. Native gel analysis indicates that the 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotide inhibits splicing by diminishing the formation of splicing complexes. One interpretation of these results is that removal of the 5' end of U1 inhibits base pairing in a different way than sequestering the same sequence with a complementary oligoribonucleotide. Alternatively, our data may indicate that two elements near the 5' end of U1 RNA normally act during spliceosome assembly; the extreme 5' end base pairs with the 5' splice site, while the sequence or structural integrity of stem I is essential for some additional function. It follows that different introns may differ in their use of the repertoire of U1 snRNP functions.     

Interactions between the terminal bases of mammalian introns are retained in inosine-containing pre-mRNAs.

Nuclear pre-mRNA splicing has a fundamentally similar two-step mechanism to that employed by group II self-splicing introns. It is believed that nuclear pre-mRNA splicing involves a network of RNA-RNA interactions which form the catalytic core of the active spliceosome. We show here a non-Watson-Crick interaction between the first and last guanosine residues of a mammalian intron. As in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, substitution of the conserved guanosines at the 5' and 3' splice sites by A and C respectively, specifically suppresses step 2 splicing defects resulting from the individual mutations. No other combination of terminal nucleotides was able to restore splicing. We additionally provide independent evidence for an indirect interaction between other nucleotides of the consensus splice sites during step 2 of splicing. Substitution of the nucleotide in the +3 position of the 5' splice site affects competition between closely spaced AG dinucleotides at the 3' splice site, although the interaction is not via direct differential base pairing. Finally, we show that complete substitution of guanosine residues by inosine in a pre-mRNA has only a modest effect upon step 2 of splicing, although earlier spliceosome assembly steps are impaired. Predictions can thus be made about the precise configuration of the non-Watson-Crick interaction between the terminal residues.     

Genetic interaction between U6 snRNA and the first intron nucleotide in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Nuclear pre-mRNA splicing necessitates specific recognition of the pre-mRNA splice sites. It is known that 5' splice site selection requires base pairing of U6 snRNA with intron positions 4-6. However, no factor recognizing the highly conserved 5' splice site GU has yet been identified. We have tested if the known U6 snRNA-pre-mRNA interaction could be extended to include the first intron nucleotides and the conserved 50GAG52 sequence of U6 snRNA. We observe that some combinations of 5' splice site and U6 snRNA mutations produce a specific synthetic block to the first splicing step. In addition, the U6-G52U allele can switch between two competing 5' splice sites harboring different nucleotides following the cleavage site. These results indicate that U6 snRNA position 52 interacts with the first nucleotide of the intron before 5' splice site cleavage. Some combinations of U6 snRNA and pre-mRNA mutations also blocked the second splicing step, suggesting a role for the corresponding nucleotides in a proofreading step before exon ligation. From studies in diverse organisms, various functions have been ascribed to the conserved U6 snRNA 47ACAGAG52 sequence. Our results suggest that these discrepancies might reflect variations between different experimental systems and point to an important conserved role of this sequence in the splicing reaction.     

A U1 snRNA:pre-mRNA base pairing interaction is required early in yeast spliceosome assembly but does not uniquely define the 5'' cleavage site.

We analyzed the effects of suppressor mutations in the U1 snRNA (SNR19) gene from Saccharomyces cerevisiae on the splicing of mutant pre-mRNA substrates. The results indicate that pairing between U1 snRNA and the highly conserved position 5 (GTATGT) of the intron occurs early in spliceosome assembly in vitro. This pairing is important for efficient splicing both in vitro and in vivo. However, pairing at position 5 does not appear to influence 5' splice site selection in vivo, indicating that the previously described U1 snRNA:5' splice junction base pairing interaction is not sufficient to define the 5' cleavage site.     

Minimal catalytic domain of a group I self-splicing intron RNA

The self-splicing intron ribozymes have been regarded as primitive forms of the splicing machinery for eukaryotic pre-mRNAs. The splicing activity of group I self-splicing introns is dependent on an absolutely conserved and exceptionally densely packed core region composed of two helical domains, P3-P7 and P4-P6, that are connected rigidly via base triples. Here we show that a mutant group I intron ribozyme lacking both the P4-P6 domain and the base triples can perform the phosphoester transfer reactions required for splicing at both the 5' and 3' splice sites, demonstrating that the elements required for splicing are concentrated in the stacked helical P3-P7 domain. This finding establishes that the conserved core of the intron consists of two physically and functionally separable components, and we present a model showing the architecture of a prototype of this class of intron and the course of its molecular evolution.     

Mutational analysis of the interactions between U1 small nuclear RNA and pre-mRNA of yeast

In recent experiments we have used the power of yeast genetics to study U1 small nuclear RNA (snRNA): pre-messenger RNA (pre-mRNA) base pairing interactions [Séraphin et al. EMBO J. 7 (1988) 2533-2538]. Here we extend these observations to other potential U1 snRNA: pre-mRNA pairings. We show that several U1 snRNA mutants are viable. Using these U1 mutant strains we demonstrate further a base-pairing interaction between U1 snRNA position 3 and intron position 6. However, this interaction is only detected with a poor splicing substrate containing branchpoint mutations. These results provide information on the mechanism of 5' splice site-branch point interaction. We also propose several models which may explain why the sequence of the 5' end of the U1 snRNA is conserved among organisms as divergent as man and yeast.     

Mutational analysis of U1 function in Schizosaccharomyces pombe: pre-mRNAs differ in the extent and nature of their requirements for this snRNA in vivo.

The U1 snRNP is known to play a critical role in spliceosome assembly, at least in part through base pairing of its RNA moiety to the substrate, but many details remain to be elucidated. To further dissect U1 snRNA function, we have analyzed 14 single point mutations in the six nucleotides complementary to the 5' splice site for their effects on growth and splicing in the fission yeast Schizosaccharomyces pombe. Three of the four alleles previously found to support growth of Saccharomyces cerevisiae are lethal in S. pombe, implying a more critical role for the 5' end of U1 in fission yeast. Furthermore, a comparison of phenotypes for individual nucleotide substitutions suggests that the two yeasts use different strategies to modulate the extent of pairing between U1 and the 5' splice site. The importance of U1 function in S. pombe is further underscored by the lethality of several single point mutants not examined previously in S. cerevisiae. In total, only three alleles complement the U1 gene disruption, and these strains are temperature-sensitive for growth. Each viable mutant was tested for impaired splicing of three different S. pombe introns. Among these, only the second intron of the cdc2 gene (cdc2-I2) showed dramatic accumulation of linear precursor. Notably, cdc2-I2 is spliced inefficiently even in cells containing wild-type U1, at least in part due to the presence of a stable hairpin encompassing its 5' splice site. Although point mutations at the 5' end of U1 have no discernible effect on splicing of pre-U6, significant accumulation of unspliced RNA is observed in a metabolic depletion experiment. Taken together, these observations indicate that the repertoire of U1 activities is used to varying extents for splicing of different pre-mRNAs in fission yeast.