Does alpine grazing reduce blazing? A landscape test of a widely‐held hypothesis

Abstract ‘Alpine grazing reduces blazing’ is a widely and strongly held view concerning the effects of livestock grazing on fuels, and therefore fire behaviour and impact, in Australia's high country landscapes. As a test of this hypothesis, we examined the patterns of burning across the alpine (treeless) landscapes of the Bogong High Plains in Victoria, following the extensive fires of January 2003. Data were collected from multiple transects, each 3–5 km long, with survey points located randomly at either 50, 200 or 500 m intervals. The transects traversed the major regions of the Bogong High Plains, both grazed and ungrazed. At each point, we recorded whether the point was burnt or unburnt, the vegetation type (closed‐heath, open‐heath, grassland or herbfield), the estimated prefire shrub cover, slope, aspect, and a GPS location. At burnt heathland sites, we recorded the minimum twig diameter (an a posteriori measure of fire severity) in a sample of common shrubs. In total, there were 108 km of transect lines, 419 survey points and 4050 twig measurements, with sample points equally distributed across grazed and ungrazed country. The occurrence of fire (i.e. burnt or unburnt) in grazed and ungrazed areas was analysed by logistic regression; the variation in twig diameters by anova . Approximately half of all points were burnt. There was no statistically significant difference between grazed and ungrazed areas in the proportion of points burnt. Fire occurrence was determined primarily by vegetation type, with the proportion burnt being 0.87 for closed‐heath, 0.59 for open‐heath, and 0.13 for grassland and all snow‐patch herbfield points unburnt. In both closed‐heath and open‐heath, grazing did not significantly lower the severity of fire, as measured by the diameter of burnt twigs. We interpret the lack of a grazing effect in terms of shrub dynamics (little or no grazing effect on long‐term cover of taller shrubs), diet and behaviour of cattle (herbs and dwarf shrubs eaten; tall shrubs not eaten and closed‐heath vegetation generally avoided), and fuel flammability (shrubs more flammable than grass). Whatever effects livestock grazing may have on vegetation cover, and therefore fuels in alpine landscapes, they are likely to be highly localized, with such effects unlikely to translate into landscape‐scale reduction of fire occurrence or severity. The use of livestock grazing in Australian alpine environments as a fire abatement practice is not justified on scientific grounds.     

高寒草甸放牧生态系统夏秋草场轮牧制度的模拟研究

利用ＧＭＡＭＥ１模拟高寒草甸放牧生态系统夏秋草场在临界放牧压力下的２７０种轮牧制度,并对其累积采食量进行比较分析。结果指出：在高寒草甸放牧生态系统中,最佳的轮牧小区数目为３或４个。证明了Ｍｏｒｌｅｙ规则：最佳轮牧小区数目应该小于１０。推荐２个高寒草甸地区最佳的轮牧模式供野外实验和放牧规划参考：（１）３个轮牧小区,每小区每次持续放牧２９ｄ,放牧压力为３０．１４ｋＪ／ｍ２·ｄ,累积牧草采食量最高为４２５０．４４３ｋＪ／ｍ２。（２）为保持牧草结构的稳定和各轮牧小区牧草生物量的均匀性,可以采用３个轮收小区,放牧持续时间７ｄ,放牧压力Ｉ（１４５）＝２８．８９１４ｋＪ／ｍ２·ｄ,累积采食量为４０７３．３４ｋＪ／ｍ２。     

放牧干扰下高寒草甸物种多样性指数评价与选择

在青藏高原东北缘高寒草甸设置6个放牧强度样地,连续4年研究10个多样性指数(Richness和Abundance 2个实测指数,优势度指数、均匀度指数、丰富度指数和综合指数各2个)对放牧强度和年限影响植物群落的解释能力.结果表明: 相对于重要值,利用多度计算的多样性指数对放牧干扰更敏感.优势度指数(Berger-Parker、Dominance)与放牧强度和年限均无关,不能将放牧干扰对群落优势种的影响有效区分.均匀度指数(Equitability、Evenness)均与放牧强度无关,但Evenness指数与放牧年限呈显著负相关,不受偶见种影响且与物种多度的变异系数呈显著正相关,在基于时间尺度的均匀度比较中可以选择Evenness指数.丰富度指数(Menhinick、Margalef)均与放牧年限无关,但Margalef指数与放牧强度呈显著正相关,且不受偶见种影响.综合指数(Shannon、Simpson)均与放牧强度无关,但Shannon指数与物种丰富度和多度呈显著正相关,且随放牧年限增加而显著升高,不受偶见种影响,Shannon指数可用于在长时间尺度下比较物种多样性变化.在所有多样性指数中,只有实测物种丰富度和多度均与放牧强度呈显著负相关,与放牧年限呈显著正相关,且不受偶见种影响,故实测物种丰富度和多度相结合可作为放牧干扰下多样性比较的首选指标.此外,多样性指数选择须考虑放牧干扰的强度与时间特征、多样性组分和研究目的.     

不同季节适度放牧对高寒草甸植物群落特征的影响

于2007~2011年对青藏高原高寒矮嵩草草甸在不同季节适度(牧草利用率35%~60%)放牧处理(不放牧、夏季放牧和冬季放牧)下的植物群落组成和物种多样性进行观测研究,结果表明:(1)经过长期的不同季节的适度放牧处理后,夏季放牧与冬季放牧均降低了禾本科植物功能群的比例,提高了杂草类植物功能群的比例。(2)与未放牧(对照)相比,夏季放牧处理下莎草科植物矮嵩草和杂类草蒙古蒲公英、鹅绒委陵菜的相对生物量分别增加了151.38%和318.87%、344.15%,禾本科植物异针茅相对生物量降低了41.16%;冬季放牧鹅绒委陵菜相对生物量增加了124.08%,禾本科植物草地早熟禾减少了45.99%,但夏季放牧和冬季放牧对二柱头藨草、紫羊茅、垂穗披碱草、花苜蓿和高山唐松草等植物的影响均不显著。(3)总体上不同季节适度放牧对植物群落物种丰富度、多样性指数以及均匀度指数的影响均不显著,但对这三者的影响随年份变化而变化。     

放牧对青藏高原东部两种典型高寒草地类型凋落物分解的影响

为认识放牧对青藏高原东部中生性的高寒草甸草地和半湿生的沼泽草地凋落物分解的影响,在这两种草地上分别设置了围栏和放牧样地,研究了其各自的混合凋落物样品和4个优势物种(发草Deschampsiacaespitos、鹅绒委陵菜Potentilla anserine、木里苔草Carexmuliensis、藏嵩草Kobresiatibetica)凋落物的分解和养分释放动态,这4个优势物种也大致代表了当地沼泽草地生态系统在放牧和气候变暖驱动下逆行演替不同阶段的优势物种类群。结果表明,各优势物种凋落物的分解速率有显著差异;放牧在总体上促进了凋落物的分解,但不同物种的响应有所不同;放牧对凋落物C的释放影响不显著或有抑制作用,但对N、P的释放具有一定促进作用。对各优势物种凋落物分解和养分释放模式的分析表明,群落逆行演替过程中,凋落物分解和C释放加速,可能促进沼泽湿地退化的正反馈效应。草甸草地的退化标志物种鹅绒委陵菜具有较高的凋落物质量和分解速度,反映了中生条件下植物应对牲畜啃食采用\"逃避\"而非\"抵抗\"策略的趋向。     

The contribution of grazing to plant diversity in alpine grassland and heath

Abstract Grazing on transplants of a grass, a forb and a tree was examined in low-diversity grassland and more diverse heath in Australia's Snowy Mountains. Transplants were surrounded by 2 mm mesh netting. In one grassland plot, grazers (probably soil invertebrates) attacked 40–90% of tree and forb seedlings but no grass seedlings. In heath, which had about half the grass cover of grassland, grazers consumed grasses but not trees or forbs. The results suggest that grazers can depress diversity in grassland by attacking species other than grass. In heath, they may promote diversity by attacking only grass and releasing other species from competition.     

Disturbance and climatic influences on age structure of ponderosa pine at the pine/grassland ecotone, Colorado Front Range

Abstract. In the Colorado Front Range, disturbances and climatic variation influence stand structure of ponderosa pine (Pinus ponderosa) along the lower timberline ecotone. Over the past 100 years there has been a shift to a greater density and extent of ponderosa pine at the forest-grassland boundaries. Ponderosa pine regeneration at lower timberline appears to be influenced by fires in the 1860s and decreased grazing pressure in the 1970s–1980s. Climatic variation may also have influenced age structure, even though analyses of age structure at a 10-year class scale prevented the detection of climatic influences occurring at a finer scale. These changes in disturbance regimes, possibly together with moister springs/early summers, created favourable conditions for the increase in density and extent of ponderosa pine at lower timberline ecotone.     

青藏高原高寒草甸初级生产力及其主要影响因素

青藏高原有各类天然草地14×108hm2,其中高寒草甸和高寒灌丛约占青藏高原天然草地面积的50%,占全国草地总面积的16.2%。嵩草草甸是高寒草甸的主体,包括矮嵩草草甸、金露梅灌丛草甸、藏嵩草草甸、小嵩草草甸和高山嵩草草甸等,这5类高寒草甸平均地上生物量分别为354.2、422.4、445.1、227.3和368.5g/m2,地下生物量分别为3389.6、3548.3、11922.7、4439.3、5604.8g/m2,地下与地上生物量的比例分别为10.55、10.15、27.82、14.82和15.21,远大于IPCC(2006)报告中地下/地上生物量比例的默认值(2.8±95%)。地下生物量对气候变化和放牧的反应比地上生物量更敏感,干旱和重度放牧均降低了地下/地上生物量的比例。在极度退化状态下地下/地上生物量的比例2。对于轻度和中度退化的高寒草甸应以围封禁牧为主要恢复措施,但如果结合补播和施肥,则恢复速率会加快;对于重度和极度退化的高寒草甸,由于草地植物群落中优良牧草的比例极低,仅靠自然恢复很难进行恢复或需要的年限很长,所以必须采用人工重建的措施,并结合毒杂草防除和施肥等措施进行恢复,通过建立人工或半人工草地的措施予以重建。     

高寒草地土壤温室气体排放对放牧的响应研究进展

高寒草地生态系统具有独特的地理环境和气候特征,对放牧干扰十分敏感,在全球温室气体通量中贡献突出,研究高寒草地放牧对土壤温室气体排放的影响机制具有重要意义。本文总结高寒草地温室气体源/汇特征、不同放牧方式对土壤微环境和微生物群落结构的影响,发现高寒草地主要是CO₂源、CH₄汇、N₂O源。放牧通过家畜选择性采食、践踏和排泄物返还等多重机制作用于地上植物、土壤结构、温度、湿度和养分,进而影响地下微生物及温室气体通量。本文旨在为高寒草地生态系统健康发展和管理及缓解全球气候变化提供科学依据,并对未来研究方向进行展望。     

短期牦牛放牧强度对川西北高原高寒草甸土壤细菌群落的影响

气候变化和人类干扰使青藏高原的草地退化日趋严重,特别是过度放牧导致的草地退化现象尤为突出;然而,牦牛作为青藏高原分布广且数量多的重要家畜,其不同放牧强度对高寒草甸土壤理化性质与细菌群落的影响仍不明晰。在川西北高原典型高寒草甸开展牦牛放牧强度试验,设置了对照组(禁牧)、轻度放牧(1头牦牛/hm~2)、中度放牧(2头牦牛/hm~2)和重度放牧(3头牦牛/hm~2)4个放牧强度,每个强度设置3个重复。两年放牧实验后的结果表明：短期的重度放牧导致土壤有效磷显著增加,而其它土壤性质在各放牧强度变化不显著;随着放牧强度的增加,土壤细菌α多样性呈先增加后减少的趋势,其主要原因是牦牛活动为细菌的生长繁殖提供了有利的营养条件,但由于放牧的持续时间较短,变化不显著;就优势菌而言,土壤绿弯菌门中存在光合自养细菌,在重度放牧下显著高于对照组,其它各菌门在不同放牧强度下无显著差异;土壤氮与硝化螺旋菌门呈正相关,速效磷与酸杆菌门也呈显著正相关,均说明放牧强度对土壤细菌类群的影响是通过土壤性质间接实现的。本实验通过研究不同牦牛放牧强度下的土壤细菌群落结构,为放牧策略的制定提供了基础数据支持,为草地退化的防治提供理论...     

Biodiversity in montane Britain: habitat variation,vegetation diversity and some objectives for conservation

The montane (low- to mid-alpine) zone in Great Britain (GB) lies above the potential tree-line (700–800 m, but descending to 200 m in the north). It is composed of moss and lichen heaths, snowbeds, blanket bog and dwarf-shrub (Ericaceae) health-covered solifluction/gelifluction terraces (38 communities/sub-communities). Approximately 3.0% of the land surface is covered by this- the most extensive predominantly near-natural terrestrial habitat in GB. Internationally distinctive features include oceanic and southern biotic outliers of arctic-alpine fellfield and mountain tundra, and plant communities that are either globally rare/localised or especially well represented in GB. The absence of extensive sub-alpineBetula spp. andSalix spp. scrub is striking.The main sources of habitat diversity are climate, regional variation in topography and geology, and regional modifications due to land-use impact. Over 50 examples are given. Five important gradients in Scottish Highland vegetation are described. Only some 15% of the sampled montane vegetation is anthropogenic; the rest is semi- or near-natural. The vegetation is divided into 5 functional groups: chionophobous (avoids snow), chionophilous (prefers snow), species-rich, mires (including springs and flushes), and anthropogenic. Chionophobous and then chionophilous communities contribute most to montane vegetation diversity (calculated here as the ShannonH diversity index).H diversity increases asymptotically with montane site area but linearly with the number of communities present. A more varied topography, geology and topo-climate gives the highestH diversity.Two examples of montane biodiversity reductions south of the Highlands are the loss of prostrateCalluna vulgaris heaths and modification ofRacomitrium lanuginosum healths. Five objectives for nature conservation are proposed, covering restoration of montaneR. lanuginosum healths, prostrate dwarf-shrub dominated heaths, sub-alpine scrub and upper treelines, and the extension of the breeding ranges of both ptarmigan (Lagopus mutus) and dotterel (Charadrius morinellus) south of the Scottish Highlands. International support for monitoring is sought.     

牦牛暖季放牧对牧草消化率的影响

通过垂穗披碱草-星星草混播草地连续3个放牧季的牦牛放牧试验,对不同放牧强度下牧草的消化率进行了研究。结果表明：放牧强度对牦牛所食牧草中酸性洗涤纤维消化率的影响极显著（P〈0．01）,对粗纤维消化率的影响显著（P〈0．05）,而对所食牧草中的总能、粗蛋白、粗灰分和中性洗涤纤维的影响不显著（P〉0．05）;放牧时间对中性和酸性洗涤纤维的影响极显著（P〈0．01）,而对牧草总能、粗蛋白、粗纤维和粗灰分的影响不显著（P〉0．05）。尽管牦牛的采食量均随放牧强度的增加而减小,但牦牛对采食牧草各营养成分的消化率并未出现规律性变化。     

Mapping fire severity and fire extent in forest in Victoria for ecological and fuel outcomes

This study shows how high‐resolution (~15 cm) simultaneous colour and infra‐red digital aerial photography can be used to map both fire severity and, particularly, fire extent, in forest in south‐eastern Australia. The results show that this methodology is capable of detecting and mapping burnt and unburnt edges under unaffected forest canopy (i.e. still green) – that is, revealing the mosaic of burnt and unburnt areas that often result from planned landscape burning under mild weather conditions (i.e. with little of the brownish canopy scorch that results from more intense bushfires). This has important implications for both fuel management and ecology. It can answer the basic questions of fire and biodiversity managers following planned burning –’how much of the planned area burnt, and, within the burnt area, what aspects were burnt, and how hot did they burn?’ The analysis of fire extent by aspect showed that about 80% of southern and eastern aspects remained unburnt during broadscale autumn prescribed burning, with many of these moister aspects potentially providing longer unburnt refuges over multiple burn rotations. The fire severity and extent mapping products, produced using the methodology outlined in this study, have the potential to substantially increase the understanding of the ecological and fuel outcomes of landscape‐scale autumn prescribed burning.     

放牧作用下高寒草甸群落物种分布与土壤因子的关系

以青藏高原东北缘高寒草甸为对象,研究不同放牧强度下植物群落和土壤因子的变化,以及群落物种分布与土壤物理结构和化学养分因子的定量关系.结果表明: 放牧导致优势种为垂穗披碱草和大针茅的原植物群落发生分异,高强度放牧样地优势种变为矮生嵩草和阴山扁蓿豆,低强度放牧样地变为垂穗披碱草和冷地早熟禾.随放牧强度增加,物种丰富度、重要值和生物量均显著降低.各放牧强度样地重要值的物种序列均可用对数模型进行拟合;随放牧强度增加,植物重要值累积到占整个群落重要值50%时,需要的物种数降低.土壤速效P、速效K、紧实度、含水量、稳定入渗速率和大团聚体指标随放牧强度显著变化,但变化规律不一致.CCA排序表明,土壤紧实度是放牧作用下影响群落物种分布格局的最关键因子.方差分解表明,土壤因子共解释群落物种分布变异的30.5%,其中土壤物理性状单独解释群落物种分布的22.8%,对群落物种分布的贡献率最高,主要影响放牧干扰下高寒草甸植物群落物种的分布格局.     

不同放牧方式对高寒草甸植物群落关键种的影响

关键种在群落结构、功能与稳定性方面具有重要作用,为探明不同放牧方式下高寒草甸植物群落关键种的变化特征及其影响因素,以青藏高原最主要的5种放牧方式(禁牧、非生长季放牧、传统放牧、生长季放牧和全年连续放牧)高寒草甸为对象,对群落特征、土壤理化特征和酶活性进行了系统研究,采用网络分析法和方差分解探究了不同放牧方式草地植物群落关键种变化特征及其影响因子,并利用优劣解距离法(TOPSIS)-多准则决策模型对不同放牧方式进行综合评价,以筛选最佳放牧方式,从而为高寒草甸科学管理及可持续利用供数据支撑。结果表明:(1)相较于全年连续放牧,禁牧、非生长季放牧、传统放牧及生长季放牧对禾本科、豆科、凋落物和杂类草生物量,群落地上和地下生物量,植物高度,禾本科盖度,多样性指数,土壤养分含量和土壤酶活性均有显著正效应。(2)禁牧样地的关键种为垂穗披碱草,非生长季放牧样地的关键种为冷地早熟禾、矮生嵩和赖草,传统放牧样地的关键种为赖草,生长季放牧样地的关键种为矮生嵩草,全年连续放牧样地的关键种为异针茅。其中,非生长季放牧样地植物群落物种间的关联性、互作强度、群落组织水平和稳定性均最高,而禁牧样地最低。(3)方差分解表明,土壤纤维素酶、脲酶和过氧化氢酶是影响高寒草甸植物群落关键种变化的最主要因素。(4)TOPSIS-多准则决策模型结果表明,非生长季放牧既能有效利用草地资源,又能维持较高的植物群落多样性和稳定性,是高寒草甸的理想放牧方式。研究结果对科学放牧管理制度的制定、草地生态系统稳定性与多功能性维持提供了科学数据支撑。