Mapping effector functions of a monoclonal antibody to GD3 by characterization of a mouse-human chimeric antibody

R24, a mouse monoclonal antibody against GD3 ganglioside, exhibits a wide range of in vitro effector functions. It also has the ability to bind to itself, presumably through homophilic Fab-Fab interactions, which have been proposed to contribute to its high relative avidity for GD3 and to its effector function activity. It is not known which of these characteristics is necessary for the antitumor effects observed in melanoma patients treated with R24. A mouse-human chimeric R24 (chR24) molecule has been constructed in which the GD3-binding site is preserved. Chimeric R24 demonstrates a lower level of binding to GD3 than does mouse R24 suggesting that there may be some differences between the GD3-binding sites of the two mAb or that Fc determinants can contribute to R24 avidity for GD3. The property of homophilic binding is retained by chR24, demonstrating formally that homophilic binding of R24 involves interactions between variable domains. Both R24 and chR24 fix human complement and mediate antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity although chR24 was slightly less efficient at the latter. Unlike R24, chR24 was not able to inhibit melanoma cell attachment to plastic surfaces and was not able to activate human T lymphocytes. We hypothesize that chR24 does not bind to GD3 with an avidity high enough to mediate these effector functions.Supported by Public Health Service grants PO1-CA33049 and RO1-CA57363     

Homophilic binding of mouse monoclonal antibodies against GD3 ganglioside.

R24, a mouse IgG3 mAb against GD3 ganglioside, was shown to bind to itself in a homophilic manner. This was demonstrated by augmented binding of 125I-labeled R24 to the cell surface of GD3+ cells by unlabeled R24 and by direct binding of biotinylated R24 to R24 adsorbed on solid phase. Although homophilic binding was evident when R24 was bound to solid phase, R24-R24 aggregates could not be detected in solution under otherwise identical conditions. R24 bound to four other mAb (two IgG3, one IgG2a, one IgM) directed against GD3 but did not bind to a panel of 21 other mAb including other IgG3 mAb and mAb directed against non-GD3 ganglioside. Evidence implicating the GD3-binding site of R24 in homophilic binding included the following observations: 1) F(ab')2 fragments of R24 could bind to R24, 2) an antiidiotypic mAb against the GD3-binding site of R24 inhibited R24 homophilic binding, 3) an IgM anti-GD3 mAb also demonstrated homophilic binding to R24, and 4) homophilic binding was a function of immunoreactivity and avidity for GD3. R24 variants with 40-fold lower avidity for GD3 demonstrated a similar decrease in homophilic binding. Inasmuch as R24 bound to R24 F(ab')2 fragments and specifically to anti-GD3 mAb, it appeared that the target for homophilic binding was an epitope within the V region of anti-GD3 mAb. It is likely that homophilic interactions result in increased affinity of R24 for GD3 through increased effective valency of antibody-Ag complexes.     

A single-domain antibody fragment in complex with RNase A: non-canonical loop structures and nanomolar affinity using two CDR loops

BACKGROUND: Camelid serum contains a large fraction of functional heavy-chain antibodies - homodimers of heavy chains without light chains. The variable domains of these heavy-chain antibodies (VHH) have a long complementarity determining region 3 (CDR3) loop that compensates for the absence of the antigen-binding loops of the variable light chains (VL). In the case of the VHH fragment cAb-Lys3, part of the 24 amino acid long CDR3 loop protrudes from the antigen-binding surface and inserts into the active-site cleft of its antigen, rendering cAb-Lys3 a competitive enzyme inhibitor. RESULTS: A dromedary VHH with specificity for bovine RNase A, cAb-RN05, has a short CDR3 loop of 12 amino acids and is not a competitive enzyme inhibitor. The structure of the cAb-RN05-RNase A complex has been solved at 2.8 A. The VHH scaffold architecture is close to that of a human VH (variable heavy chain). The structure of the antigen-binding hypervariable 1 loop (H1) of both cAb-RN05 and cAb-Lys3 differ from the known canonical structures; in addition these H1 loops resemble each other. The CDR3 provides an antigen-binding surface and shields the face of the domain that interacts with VL in conventional antibodies. CONCLUSIONS: VHHs adopt the common immunoglobulin fold of variable domains, but the antigen-binding loops deviate from the predicted canonical structure. We define a new canonical structure for the H1 loop of immunoglobulins, with cAb-RN05 and cAb-Lys3 as reference structures. This new loop structure might also occur in human or mouse VH domains. Surprisingly, only two loops are involved in antigen recognition; the CDR2 does not participate. Nevertheless, the antigen binding occurs with nanomolar affinities because of a preferential usage of mainchain atoms for antigen interaction.     

Length of the antibody heavy chain complementarity determining region 3 as a specificity-determining factor

The antigen binding site of an antibody is made up of residues residing in six hypervariable loops of the heavy and light chains. In most cases several or all of these loops are required for the establishment of the antigen-binding surface. Five of these loops display a limited diversity in length and sequence while the third complementarity determining region (CDR) of the heavy chain is highly different between antibodies not only with respect to sequence but also with respect to length. Its extensive diversity is a key component in the establishment of binding sites allowing for the recognition of essentially any antigen by humoral immunity. The relative importance of its sequence vs its length diversity in this context is however, not very well established. To investigate this matter further we have used an approach employing combinatorial antibody libraries and antigen-specific selection in the search for CDRH3 length and sequence diversity compatible with a given antigen specificity, the major antigenic determinant on the tumour-associated antigen mucin-1. In this way we have now defined heavy chain CDR3 length as a critical parameter in the creation of an antigen-specific binding site. We also propose that this may reflect a dependence of a particular structure of this hypervariable loop, the major carrier of diversity in the binding site, for establishment of a given specificity.     

Human anti-V3 HIV-1 monoclonal antibodies encoded by the VH5-51/VL lambda genes define a conserved antigenic structure

Preferential usage of immunoglobulin (Ig) genes that encode antibodies (Abs) against various pathogens is rarely observed and the nature of their dominance is unclear in the context of stochastic recombination of Ig genes. The hypothesis that restricted usage of Ig genes predetermines the antibody specificity was tested in this study of 18 human anti-V3 monoclonal Abs (mAbs) generated from unrelated individuals infected with various subtypes of HIV-1, all of which preferentially used pairing of the VH5-51 and VL lambda genes. Crystallographic analysis of five VH5-51/VL lambda-encoded Fabs complexed with various V3 peptides revealed a common three dimensional (3D) shape of the antigen-binding sites primarily determined by the four complementarity determining regions (CDR) for the heavy (H) and light (L) chains: specifically, the H1, H2, L1 and L2 domains. The CDR H3 domain did not contribute to the shape of the binding pocket, as it had different lengths, sequences and conformations for each mAb. The same shape of the binding site was further confirmed by the identical backbone conformation exhibited by V3 peptides in complex with Fabs which fully adapted to the binding pocket and the same key contact residues, mainly germline-encoded in the heavy and light chains of five Fabs. Finally, the VH5-51 anti-V3 mAbs recognized an epitope with an identical 3D structure which is mimicked by a single mimotope recognized by the majority of VH5-51-derived mAbs but not by other V3 mAbs. These data suggest that the identification of preferentially used Ig genes by neutralizing mAbs may define conserved epitopes in the diverse virus envelopes. This will be useful information for designing vaccine immunogen inducing cross-neutralizing Abs.     

Bispecific antibodies with Fab-arms featuring exchanged antigen-binding constant domains

Monoclonal antibodies can acquire the property of engagement of a second antigen via fusion methods or modification of their CDR loops, but also by modification of their constant domains, such as in the mAb² format where a set of mutated amino acid residues in the C_H3 domains enables a high-affinity specific interaction with the second antigen. We tested the possibility of introducing multiple binding sites for the second antigen by replacing the Fab C_H1/C_L domain pair with a pair of antigen-binding C_H3 domains in a model scaffold with trastuzumab variable domains and VEGF-binding C_H3 domains. Such bispecific molecules were produced in a “Fab-like” format and in a full-length antibody format. Novel constructs were of expected molecular composition using mass spectrometry. They were expressed at a high level in standard laboratory conditions, purified as monomers with Protein A and gel filtration and were of high thermostability. Their high-affinity binding to both target antigens was retained. Finally, the Her2/VEGF binding domain-exchanged bispecific antibody was able to mediate a potentiated surface Her2-internalization effect on the Her2-overexpressing cell line SK-BR-3 due to improved level of cross-linking with the endogenously secreted cytokine. To conclude, bispecific antibodies with Fabs featuring exchanged antigen-binding C_H3 domains offer an alternative solution in positioning and valency of antigen binding sites.     

Guided selection of human antibody light chains against TAG-72 using a phage display chain shuffling approach

To enhance therapeutic potential of murine monoclonal antibody, humanization by CDR grafting is usually used to reduce immunogenic mouse residues. Most humanized antibodies still have mouse residues critical for antigen binding, but the mouse residues may evoke immune responses in humans. Previously, we constructed a new humanized version (AKA) of mouse CC49 antibody specific for tumor-associated glycoprotein, TAG-72. In this study, to select a completely human antibody light chain against TAG-72, guided selection strategy using phage display was used. The heavy chain variable region (VH) of AKA was used to guide the selection of a human TAG-72-specific light chain variable region (VL) from a human VL repertoire constructed from human PBL. Most of the selected VLs were identified to be originated from the members of the human germline VK1 family, whereas the VL of AKA is more homologous to the VK4 family. Competition binding assay of the selected Fabs with mouse CC49 suggested that the epitopes of the Fabs overlap with that of CC49. In addition, they showed better antigen-binding affinity compared to parental AKA. The selected human VLs may be used to guide the selection of human VHs to get completely human anti-TAG72 antibody.     

The association of heavy and light chain variable domains in antibodies: implications for antigen specificity

The antigen-binding site of immunoglobulins is formed by six regions, three from the light and three from the heavy chain variable domains, which, on association of the two chains, form the conventional antigen-binding site of the antibody. The mode of interaction between the heavy and light chain variable domains affects the relative position of the antigen-binding loops and therefore has an effect on the overall conformation of the binding site. In this article, we analyze the structure of the interface between the heavy and light chain variable domains and show that there are essentially two different modes for their interaction that can be identified by the presence of key amino acids in specific positions of the antibody sequences. We also show that the different packing modes are related to the type of recognized antigen.     

Structure-based engineering to restore high affinity binding of an isoform-selective anti-TGFβ1 antibody

Metelimumab (CAT192) is a human IgG4 monoclonal antibody developed as a TGFβ1-specific antagonist. It was tested in clinical trials for the treatment of scleroderma but later terminated due to lack of efficacy. Subsequent characterization of CAT192 indicated that its TGFβ1 binding affinity was reduced by ～50-fold upon conversion from the parental single-chain variable fragment (scFv) to IgG4. We hypothesized this result was due to decreased conformational flexibility of the IgG that could be altered via engineering. Therefore, we designed insertion mutants in the elbow region and screened for binding and potency. Our results indicated that increasing the elbow region linker length in each chain successfully restored the isoform-specific and high affinity binding of CAT192 to TGFβ1. The crystal structure of the high binding affinity mutant displays large conformational rearrangements of the variable domains compared to the wild-type antigen-binding fragment (Fab) and the low binding affinity mutants. Insertion of two glycines in both the heavy and light chain elbow regions provided sufficient flexibility for the variable domains to extend further apart than the wild-type Fab, and allow the CDR3s to make additional interactions not seen in the wild-type Fab structure. These interactions coupled with the dramatic conformational changes provide a possible explanation of how the scFv and elbow-engineered Fabs bind TGFβ1 with high affinity. This study demonstrates the benefits of re-examining both structure and function when converting scFv to IgG molecules, and highlights the potential of structure-based engineering to produce fully functional antibodies.     

Calcium-dependent antigen binding as a novel modality for antibody recycling by endosomal antigen dissociation

The pH-dependent antigen binding antibody, termed a recycling antibody, has recently been reported as an attractive type of second-generation engineered therapeutic antibody. A recycling antibody can dissociate antigen in the acidic endosome, and thus bind to its antigen multiple times. As a consequence, a recycling antibody can neutralize large amounts of antigen in plasma. Because this approach relies on histidine residues to achieve pH-dependent antigen binding, which could limit the epitopes that can be targeted and affect the rate of antigen dissociation in the endosome, we explored an alternative approach for generating recycling antibodies. Since calcium ion concentration is known to be lower in endosome than in plasma, we hypothesized that an antibody with antigen-binding properties that are calcium-dependent could be used as recycling antibody. Here, we report a novel anti-interleukin-6 receptor (IL-6R) antibody, identified from a phage library that binds to IL-6R only in the presence of a calcium ion. Thermal dynamics and a crystal structure study revealed that the calcium ion binds to the heavy chain CDR3 region (HCDR3), which changes and possibly stabilizes the structure of HCDR3 to make it bind to antigen calcium dependently (PDB 5AZE). In vitro and in vivo studies confirmed that this calcium-dependent antigen-binding antibody can dissociate its antigen in the endosome and accelerate antigen clearance from plasma, making it a novel approach for generating recycling antibody.     

A broad range of Fab stabilities within a host of therapeutic IgGs

Although the functional properties of IgGs are well known, little has been published concerning the stability of whole IgG molecules. Stability is, however, a requirement for the development of antibodies for therapeutic or diagnostic applications. The hypervariable antigen-binding region (Fv) is responsible for stability variations between IgGs of identical subclass. To determine the range of stabilities that may be expected for human(ized) antibodies, differential scanning calorimetry was performed on 17 human(ized) antibodies from various in-house programs. The antigen-binding fragments (Fabs) of these antibodies exhibited thermal unfolding transitions with midpoints (T(M)s) varying from 57 to 82 degrees C. Antibodies with very low Fab stabilities were found to aggregate and express poorly. Fab instability was often associated with high levels of uncommonly observed amino acids or CDR loop lengths particularly within the variable heavy chain domain. Overall, the study provides a thermostability range for IgGs and suggests possible stability guidelines for developing antibody diagnostics or therapeutics.     

Structural diversity in a human antibody germline library

To support antibody therapeutic development, the crystal structures of a set of 16 germline variants composed of 4 different kappa light chains paired with 4 different heavy chains have been determined. All four heavy chains of the antigen-binding fragments (Fabs) have the same complementarity-determining region (CDR) H3 that was reported in an earlier Fab structure. The structure analyses include comparisons of the overall structures, canonical structures of the CDRs and the VH:VL packing interactions. The CDR conformations for the most part are tightly clustered, especially for the ones with shorter lengths. The longer CDRs with tandem glycines or serines have more conformational diversity than the others. CDR H3, despite having the same amino acid sequence, exhibits the largest conformational diversity. About half of the structures have CDR H3 conformations similar to that of the parent; the others diverge significantly. One conclusion is that the CDR H3 conformations are influenced by both their amino acid sequence and their structural environment determined by the heavy and light chain pairing. The stem regions of 14 of the variant pairs are in the ‘kinked’ conformation, and only 2 are in the extended conformation. The packing of the VH and VL domains is consistent with our knowledge of antibody structure, and the tilt angles between these domains cover a range of 11 degrees. Two of 16 structures showed particularly large variations in the tilt angles when compared with the other pairings. The structures and their analyses provide a rich foundation for future antibody modeling and engineering efforts.     

The three-dimensional structure of a T-cell antigen receptor V alpha V beta heterodimer reveals a novel arrangement of the V beta domain.

The crystal structure of a mouse T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) Fv fragment complexed to the Fab fragment of a specific anti-clonotypic antibody has been determined to 2.6 A resolution. The polypeptide backbone of the TCR V alpha domain is very similar to those of other crystallographically determined V alphas, whereas the V beta structure is so far unique among TCR V beta domains in that it displays a switch of the c" strand from the inner to the outer beta-sheet. The beta chain variable region of this TCR antigen-binding site is characterized by a rather elongated third complementarity-determining region (CDR3beta) that packs tightly against the CDR3 loop of the alpha chain, without leaving any intervening hydrophobic pocket. Thus, the conformation of the CDR loops with the highest potential diversity distinguishes the structure of this TCR antigen-binding site from those for which crystallographic data are available. On the basis of all these results, we infer that a significant conformational change of the CDR3beta loop found in our TCR is required for binding to its cognate peptide-MHC ligand.     

Detection of GD3 ganglioside in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia with monoclonal antibody to GD3: restriction to immunophenotypically defined T-cell disease

We have recently reported that the disialoganglioside GD3 is found in cellular lipid extracts of T-cell acute lymphoblastic malignancies (T-ALL) but is not detectable by resorcinol staining in extracts of non-T acute lymphoblastic leukemia blasts (non-T-ALL). We have now extended this study to assess the detectability of GD3 in T-ALL vs non-T-ALL utilizing an anti-GD3 antibody, R24. Gangliosides isolated from T-ALL and non-T-ALL blasts by two different methods were separated by thin-layer chromatography and stained with anti-GD3 and a control antibody specific for GM3 and sialosylparagloboside (SPG). Anti-GD3 reactivity was observed in extracts from T-ALL cells in all cases, whereas GD3 was not detected in any of the non-T-ALL samples. The anti-GM3/SPG antibody stained GM3 in all of the leukemic samples analyzed as well as SPG in the non-T-ALL samples. Indirect immunofluorescence was used to assess the expression of GD3 at the surface of leukemic blasts. Fluorescence-activated cell sorting analysis with R24 showed that whereas T-ALL blasts were highly reactive with this antibody, non-T-ALL blasts were totally unreactive. In an analysis of a larger number of leukemia patients by fluorescence microscopy, 20 out of 28 samples with the T-ALL phenotype were positive for R24, whereas zero out of 11 non-T-ALL samples were reactive. These results confirm our earlier finding of the specificity of GD3 to the T-ALL subclass of childhood leukemias and furthermore suggest the potential value of anti-GD3 as an immunological tool for the diagnosis and therapy of T-cell ALL.     

Chemical basis for the affinity maturation of a camel single domain antibody

Affinity maturation of classic antibodies supposedly proceeds through the pre-organization of the reactive germ line conformational isomer. It is less evident to foresee how this can be accomplished by camelid heavy-chain antibodies lacking light chains. Although these antibodies are subjected to somatic hypermutation, their antigen-binding fragment consists of a single domain with restricted flexibility in favor of binding energy. An antigen-binding domain derived from a dromedary heavy-chain antibody, cAb-Lys3, accumulated five amino acid substitutions in CDR1 and CDR2 upon maturation against lysozyme. Three of these residues have hydrophobic side chains, replacing serines, and participate in the hydrophobic core of the CDR1 in the mature antibody, suggesting that conformational rearrangements might occur in this loop during maturation. However, transition state analysis of the binding kinetics of mature cAb-Lys3 and germ line variants show that the maturation of this antibody relies on events late in the reaction pathway. This is reflected by a limited perturbation of k(a) and a significantly decreased k(d) upon maturation. In addition, binding reactions and the maturation event are predominantly enthalpically driven. Therefore, maturation proceeds through the increase of favorable binding interactions, or by the reduction of the enthalpic penalty for desolvation, as opposed to large entropic penalties associated with conformational changes and structural plasticity. Furthermore, the crystal structure of the mutant with a restored germ line CDR2 sequence illustrates that the matured hydrophobic core of CDR1 in cAb-Lys3 might be compensated in the germ line precursor by burying solvent molecules engaged in a stable hydrogen-bonding network with CDR1 and CDR2.     

The testosterone binding mechanism of an antibody derived from a naïve human scFv library

A testosterone binding scFv antibody was isolated from a naïve human library with a modest size of 10⁸ clones. The crystal structure of the Fab fragment form of the 5F2 antibody clone complexed with testosterone determined at 1.5 Å resolution shows that the hapten is bound deeply in the antibody binding pocket. In addition to the interactions with framework residues only CDR‐L3 and CDR‐H3 loops interact with testosterone and the heavy chain forms the majority of the contacts with the hapten. The testosterone binding site of the 5F2 antibody with a high abundance of aromatic amino acid residues shows similarity with an in vitro affinity matured antibody having around 300 times higher affinity. The moderate affinity of the 5F2 antibody originates from the different orientation of the hapten and few light chain contacts. This is the first three‐dimensional structure of a human steroid hormone binding antibody that has been isolated from a naïve human repertoire. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Structural analysis of human and macaque mAbs 2909 and 2.5B: implications for the configuration of the quaternary neutralizing epitope of HIV-1 gp120

The quaternary neutralizing epitope (QNE) of HIV-1 gp120 is preferentially expressed on the trimeric envelope spikes of intact HIV virions, and QNE-specific monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) potently neutralize HIV-1. Here, we present the crystal structures of the Fabs of human mAb 2909 and macaque mAb 2.5B. Both mAbs have long beta hairpin CDR H3 regions >20 ? in length that are each situated at the center of their respective antigen-binding sites. Computational analysis showed that the paratopes include the whole CDR H3, while additional CDR residues form shallow binding pockets. Structural modeling suggests a way to understand the configuration of QNEs and the antigen-antibody interaction for QNE mAbs. Our data will be useful in designing immunogens that may elicit potent neutralizing QNE Abs.     

Affinity transfer to a human protein by CDR3 grafting of camelid VHH

VHH is the binding domain of the IgG heavy chain. Some VHHs have an extremely long CDR3 that contributes to antigen binding. We studied the antigen binding ability of CDR3 by grafting a CDR3 from an antigen-binding VHH onto a nonbinding VHH. cAb-CA05-(1RI8), the CDR3-grafted VHH, had an antigen-binding ability. To find a human scaffold protein acceptable for VHH CDR3 grafting, we focused on the conserved structure of VHH, especially the N-terminal and C-terminal amino acid residues of the CDR3 loop and the Cys residue of CDR1. Human origin protein structures with the same orientation were searched in PDB and ubiquitin was selected. Ubi-(1RI8), the CDR3-grafted ubiquitin, had antigen-binding ability, though the affinity was relatively low compared to cAb-CA05-(1RI8). The thermodynamic parameters of Ubi-(1RI8) binding to HEWL were different from cAb-CA05-(1RI8). Hydrogen-deuterium exchange experiments showed decreased stability around the CDR3 grafting region of Ubi-(1RI8), which might explain the decreased antigen-binding ability and the differences in thermodynamic properties. We concluded that the orientation of the CDR3 sequence of Ubi-(1RI8) could not be reconstructed correctly.     

Development of phage biopanning strategies to identify affinity peptide ligands for kappa light chain Fab fragments

In this work, two phage biopanning strategies were developed to identify affinity peptides for a single Fab and multiple kappa Fabs. For the biopanning rounds, protein L beads were employed to bind Fab targets in a fixed orientation, and NHS functionalized magnetic beads were used to facilitate evaluation of low pH elution conditions. The resulting peptide sequences were synthesized and the binding to different Fabs was evaluated using fluorescence polarization. The first biopanning approach yielded a peptide with similar affinities for two forms of the Fab (recombinantly expressed and post papain-digestion) as well as the intact antibody. While moderate affinity was observed toward a murine variant of the Fab with the same complementarity determining regions (CDR) region but different framework, minimal binding occurred to a Fab with high sequence homology but containing different CDR loops. The second biopanning strategy yielded a peptide with affinity for all three kappa Fabs indicating that it may be a good lead for the development of more general affinity reagents for recombinant kappa Fabs. Finally, an affinity peptide column was developed, and its efficacy was demonstrated for Fab purification from a complex cell culture fluid mixture. The results presented in this article demonstrate that different peptide-based phage biopanning strategies can be effectively employed to identify affinity peptide leads for specific Fab and more general kappa Fab purifications.     

Use of 2D NMR, protein engineering, and molecular modeling to study the hapten-binding site of an antibody Fv fragment against 2-phenyloxazolone

Two-dimensional (2D) 1H NMR spectroscopy was used to study the hapten-binding site of a recombinant antibody Fv fragment expressed in Escherichia coli. Point mutations of residues in the CDR loops of the Fv fragment were designed in order to investigate their influence on hapten binding and to make site-specific assignments of aromatic NMR proton signals. Two tyrosines giving NOEs to the ligand 2-phenyloxazolone were identified, residue 33 in CDR1 of the heavy chain and residue 32 in CDR1 of the light chain. The benzyl portion of 2-phenyloxazolone is located between these two residues. The binding site is close to the surface of the Fv fragment. Comparison with a different anti-2-phenyloxazolone antibody, the crystal structure of which has recently been solved, shows that the general location of the hapten-binding site in both antibodies is similar. However, in the crystallographically solved antibody, the hapten is bound farther from the surface in a pocket created by a short CDR3 loop of the heavy chain. In the binding site identified in the Fv fragment studied in this report, this space is probably filled by the extra seven residues of the CDR3.