Gene expression in visceral endoderm: a comparison of mutant and wild- type F9 embryonal carcinoma cell differentiation

We have examined the abundance and cell specificity of several mRNAs that are regulated during the retinoic acid (RA)-induced differentiation of F9 embryonal carcinoma cells to visceral endoderm. The experiments confirmed the multistep nature of this process by demonstrating the expression of the ERA-1/Hox 1.6 message within 6 h after RA addition; the expression of messages specific for the extracellular matrix proteins laminin B1 and B2, and collagen IV(alpha 1) between days 4 and 12; and the expression of two visceral endoderm markers, alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) and H19, by days 8-15. In situ hybridization experiments revealed that the collagen IV(alpha 1) mRNA is restricted to the outer cell layer of F9 cell aggregates regardless of the presence or absence of RA. Laminin B1 and B2 mRNAs are concentrated in the outer cell layer of RA-treated aggregates although significant levels of message are also observed within the interior cells of the aggregates. Unexpectedly, AFP mRNA is detectable in only a subset of the outer cells of F9 cell aggregates grown 15 d in the presence of RA. The results obtained from wild-type F9 cells were compared with those from a mutant F9 cell line, RA-5-1, which was previously shown to synthesize collagen IV containing six- to ninefold less 4-hydroxyproline than that in wild-type F9 cells. RA-5-1 cells exhibit four- to sixfold less of the mRNAs encoding two visceral endoderm proteins, AFP and H19, than wild-type F9 cells after RA treatment of RA-5-1 aggregates. RA-5-1 cells, however, do exhibit an RA-associated increase in the level of ERA-1/Hox 1.6 mRNA within 6 h after adding RA. Although the collagen IV protein level is similar in wild-type F9 and RA-5-1 aggregates, the collagen IV(alpha 1) message level is 6-20-fold greater in aggregates of mutant cells than in aggregates of wild-type cells. Moreover, in situ hybridizations showed that this message is evenly distributed throughout the RA-5-1 aggregates rather than restricted to the outer cell layers as it is in wild-type F9 aggregates. These results suggest that abnormal collagen IV expression and localization are associated with decreased expression of the visceral endoderm markers, AFP and H19, in RA-5-1 cell aggregates.     

Reversible interconversion between primitive endoderm- and parietal endoderm-like F9 cells demonstrated by mRNAs expression

The differentiation of retinoic acid-treated F9 cells (primitive endoderm-like F9 cells) into parietal endoderm-like F9 cells induced by dibutyryl cAMP was studied as a culture model of the morphogenesis of early mouse embryo. For this purpose, 6 cDNA clones coding for mRNAs specifically expressed in parietal endoderm-like F9 cells were selected. Northern hybridization of RNA extracted from variously treated F9 cells to nick-translated plasmid DNA of these clones demonstrated the reversible expression of many mRNAs depending on the presence of dibutyryl cAMP in the culture medium. This result suggested that the differentiated state of parietal endoderm, which is formed from primitive endoderm at a position adjacent to the trophectoderm in mouse embryo, can be reversed if the local signal is removed. One of the selected clones, pLAM, hybridized to an mRNA of 6.3 kb and selected mRNA producing a laminin B subunit in an in vitro translation system. This clone has an inserted sequence of 3.1 kb. Among the restriction sites in this sequence, six were consistent with those in a 1.7 kb inserted sequence of pPE 49 and pPE 386, which were isolated by Barlow et al. as laminin B1 clones. An XbaI site found in both pPE 49 and pPE 386 was, however, not found at the corresponding position of pLAM. Dot hybridization of RNA with pLAM showed that expression of laminin B in F9 cells is stimulated more than 100-fold during differentiation of F9 stem cells into parietal endoderm-like F9 cells.     

Overexpression of the cellular retinoic acid binding protein-I (CRABP- I) results in a reduction in differentiation-specific gene expression in F9 teratocarcinoma cells

Treatment of F9 teratocarcinoma stem cells with retinoic acid (RA) causes their irreversible differentiation into extraembryonic endoderm. To elucidate the role of the cellular retinoic acid binding protein-I (CRABP-I) in this differentiation process, we have generated several different stably transfected F9 stem cell lines expressing either elevated or reduced levels of functional CRABP-I protein. Stably transfected lines expressing elevated levels of CRABP-I exhibit an 80-90% reduction in the RA induced expression of retinoic acid receptor (RAR) beta, laminin B1, and collagen type IV (alpha 1) mRNAs at low exogenous RA concentrations, but this reduction is eliminated at higher RA concentrations. Thus, greater expression of CRABP-I reduces the potency of RA in this differentiation system. Moreover, transfection of a CRABP-I expression vector into F9 cells resulted in five- and threefold decreases in the activation of the laminin B1 RARE (retinoic acid response element) and the RAR beta RARE, respectively, as measured from RARE/CAT expression vectors in transient transfection assays. These results support the idea that CRABP-I sequesters RA within the cell and thereby prevents RA from acting to regulate differentiation specific gene expression. Our data suggest a mechanism whereby the level of CRABP-I can regulate responsiveness to RA during development.     

Roles of extracellular matrix components in differentiating teratocarcinoma cells

F9 embryonal carcinoma cells treated with 5 X 10(-8) M retinoic acid and cultured in suspension for 8 days form aggregates consisting of an outer epithelial layer of alpha-fetoprotein-producing visceral endoderm cells. We have previously shown (Grover, A., Oshima, R. G., and Adamson, E. D. (1983) J. Cell Biol. 96, 1690-1696) that the differentiation of F9 cells to visceral endoderm is accompanied by the activation of several genes, and increased laminin synthesis is one of the earliest events. Here we analyze in detail the syntheses and secretion of fibronectin, type IV collagen, and laminin during the 8-day process. Employing immunoprecipitation and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, we show that the levels of all three components change with different patterns. Unstimulated F9 cells synthesize and secrete relatively high levels of fibronectin and low levels of type IV collagen. Fibronectin synthesis and secretion decreases to 10% of its original level whereas type IV collagen synthesis rises approximately 3-fold during the differentiation process. Laminin synthesis also rises at least 2-fold, and the proportions of its subunits change as the syntheses of B1 and A accelerate starting on day 2. However, unlike fibronectin and type IV collagen, laminin is largely accumulated in the aggregates. The data suggest that fibronectin has a role in aggregation whereas laminin is important in the differentiation process.     

Evidence for the existence of an early common biochemical pathway in the differentiation of F9 cells into visceral or parietal endoderm: Modulation by cyclic AMP

The addition of dibutyryl cyclic AMP (dbcAMP) to aggregate cultures of F9 cells in medium containing retinoic acid (RA) directs the pathway of differentiation into parietal endoderm instead of visceral endoderm. We examined the levels of some of the markers that characterize the two pathways and studied the time of commitment of cells to either direction of differentiation by using immunoprecipitation and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays (ELISA). For either pathway, the levels and patterns of laminin, type IV collagen, and fibronectin are the same on the first day of differentiation, characterized by slightly decreased levels of laminin and type IV collagen synthesis and an increased level of fibronectin synthesis. These levels reverse on the second day of culture when the pathways diverge markedly. The differentiation pathway, however, can be redirected into the alternate one; parietal endoderm cells become committed after 3 days, whereas visceral endoderm cells are able to change into parietal endoderm cells at any time. Thus, α-fetoprotein (AFP)-producing F9 embryoid bodies switched to dbcAMP-containing medium lose the capacity to synthesize AFP and start to express genes characteristic of parietal endoderm. Our results indicate that at least some visceral endoderm cells may redifferentiate into parietal endoderm cells. These phenomena thus mimic features of endoderm differentiation in the mouse embryo.     

Targeted disruption of retinoic acid receptor alpha (RAR alpha) and RAR gamma results in receptor-specific alterations in retinoic acid-mediated differentiation and retinoic acid metabolism.

F9 embryonic teratocarcinoma stem cells differentiate into an epithelial cell type called extraembryonic endoderm when treated with retinoic acid (RA), a derivative of retinol (vitamin A). This differentiation is presumably mediated through the actions of retinoid receptors, the RARs and RXRs. To delineate the functions of each of the different retinoid receptors in this model system, we have generated F9 cell lines in which both copies of either the RAR alpha gene or the RAR gamma gene are disrupted by homologous recombination. The absence of RAR alpha is associated with a reduction in the RA-induced expression of both the CRABP-II and Hoxb-1 (formerly 2.9) genes. The absence of RAR gamma is associated with a loss of the RA-inducible expression of the Hoxa-1 (formerly Hox-1.6), Hoxa-3 (formerly Hox-1.5), laminin B1, collagen IV (alpha 1), GATA-4, and BMP-2 genes. Furthermore, the loss of RAR gamma is associated with a reduction in the metabolism of all-trans-RA to more polar derivatives, while the loss of RAR alpha is associated with an increase in metabolism of RA relative to wild-type F9 cells. Thus, each of these RARs exhibits some specificity with respect to the regulation of differentiation-specific gene expression. These results provide an explanation for the expression of multiple RAR types within one cell type and suggest that each RAR has specific functions.     

Genes for basement membrane proteins are coordinately expressed in differentiating F9 cells but not in normal adult murine tissues

We have obtained cDNA clones coding for the A, B1, and B2 chains of laminin by screening a cDNA library prepared from mouse EHS tumor poly(A)RNA in the lambda gt11 expression vector with polyclonal antibody against denatured laminin. These cDNA clones were used in combination with a cDNA clone coding for the alpha 1 type IV collagen chain to study the regulation of genes for these basement membrane proteins in retinoic acid-induced differentiating mouse F9 teratocarcinoma cells and in various adult murine tissues. The levels of mRNA for the laminin A, B1, and B2 chains and for the alpha 1 type IV collagen chain were increased simultaneously and reached a maximum at almost the same time during the differentiation of F9 cells, suggesting coordinate expression in these cells. The tissue levels of mRNA encoding for the basement membrane components, however, varied considerably. The highest level of the B1 chain mRNA was observed in kidney, whereas, the levels of mRNA for A and B2 chains were highest in heart. Almost the same levels of expression of the alpha 1(IV) collagen mRNA were found in kidney, lung, and heart. The results indicate that the expression of genes for the basement membrane proteins is not coordinately regulated in these tissues. It is thus possible that different subunit structures of the laminin molecule may exist in tissues.     

RXRalpha-null F9 embryonal carcinoma cells are resistant to the differentiation, anti-proliferative and apoptotic effects of retinoids.

The F9 murine embryonal carcinoma (EC) cell line, a well established model system for the study of retinoic acid (RA)-induced differentiation, differentiates into cells resembling three types of extra-embryonic endoderm (primitive, parietal and visceral), depending on the culture conditions and RA concentration used. A number of previously identified genes are differentially expressed during this process and serve as markers for the different endodermal cell types. Differentiation is also accompanied by a decreased rate of proliferation and an apoptotic response. Using homologous recombination, we have disrupted both alleles of the retinoid X receptor (RXR) alpha gene in F9 cells to investigate its role in mediating these responses. The loss of RXRalpha expression impaired the morphological differentiation of F9 EC cells into primitive and parietal endoderm, but has little effect on visceral endodermal differentiation. Concomitantly the inducibility of most primitive and parietal endoderm differentiation-specific genes was impaired, while several genes upregulated during visceral endodermal differentiation were induced normally. We also demonstrate that RXRalpha is required for both the anti-proliferative and apoptotic responses in RA-treated F9 cells. Additionally, we provide further evidence that retinoic acid receptor (RAR)-RXR heterodimers are the functional units transducing the effects of retinoids in F9 cells.     

Isolation and characterization of the cDNAs corresponding to mRNAs abundant in undifferentiated mouse embryonal teratocarcinoma stem cells, but not in differentiated mouse parietal endoderm cells

As retinoic acid (RA) and dibutyryl cAMP (cAMP) treatment induces differentiation of mouse teratocarcinoma F9 cells into parietal endoderm cells in vitro, we initiated studies on the molecular mechanisms underlying early mammalian cell differentiation in this system. We constructed cDNA libraries on the poly(A)+RNAs extracted from the undifferentiated F9 cells, and screened for cDNA sequences expressed abundantly in F9 cells, but not in terminally differentiated mouse parietal endoderm PYS-2 cells. Six different cDNA clones were isolated and characterized. The levels of RNAs hybridizable to these clones were at most 5 to 24% in the PYS-2 cells when compared with those in the undifferentiated F9 cells. The six clones were classified into two groups on the basis of their responses to the RA and cAMP treatment. In F9 cells, the levels of RNAs hybridizable to the first group, which contained four clones, were decreased within 72 h after the addition of RA and cAMP, while those of the second group, which contained the remaining two clones, did not decrease significantly. One of the first group clones, named pF9-1, corresponded to the mouse "early transposon-like elements" and another, named pF9-4, hybridized to multi-size RNAs extracted from the undifferentiated F9 cells. The mouse genomic DNA sequences hybridizable to pF9-4 were repeated approximately 5,000 times, and comprise a new gene family, the expression of which is developmentally regulated in mouse F9 cells.     

A new differentiated cell line (Dif 5) derived by retinoic acid treatment of F9 teratocarcinoma cells capable of extracellular matrix production and growth in the absence of serum

Treatment of F9 teratocarcinoma cells with all trans retinoic acid (RA) causes them to differentiate into two or three morphologically distinct cell types. Whereas the majority of these retinoid-derived cells exhibit properties resembling parietal endoderm, a small percentage of this differentiated cell population manifests properties distinct from the parietal endoderm cell type. The isolation and partial characterization of such a non-parietal endoderm cell line (Dif 5) derived from F9 cells following prolonged (44 days) exposure to 1 μM retinoic acid are described.Unlike the retinoid-induced parietal endoderm-like cell population, which exhibits a dramatic, characteristic morphological change upon treatment with 8-bromo cAMP, Dif 5 cells do not show any morphological change with exposure to this cAMP analog. Dif 5 cells synthesize and deposit an extracellular matrix consisting of several components of Reichert's membrane (fibronectin, laminin, and type IV collagen). This new cell line does not synthesize α-fetoprotein but does secrete plasminogen activator.An interesting property of these cells is their ability to grow in the absence of serum or other hormonal supplements. Yet the Dif 5 cells do exhibit density-dependent inhibition of growth. Unlike the parent F9 cells or parietal yolk sac (PYS-2) cells, these cells do possess specific cell surface receptors for epidermal growth factor (EGF). The growth-arrested Dif 5 cells can be reinitiated to proliferate by the addition of fetal calf serum (FCS) or EGF.The properties of Dif 5 cells determined fail to fulfill all the characteristics described for either parietal or visceral endodermal cells. This raises the possibility that Dif 5 cells might represent an endodermal cell type which is intermediate in differentiation to either parietal or visceral endoderm but which lacks the biochemical signal to complete this stage of differentiation. This new Dif 5 cell line should be of considerable value in studying the modulation of growth requirements and extracellular matrix formation during early embryonic development.     

Changes of surface glycoproteins after retinoic acid-dibutyryl cAMP-induced differentiation of teratocarcinoma stem cells

Retinoic acid induces differentiation of embryonal carcinoma F9 cells into parietal endoderm. The surface proteins of F9 cells from induced and control cultures were labeled with the 125I-lactoperoxidase system and analyzed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Their quantitative comparison has shown an 11-fold increase of protein p220 of apparent MW 220,000 and isoelectric point 5.6. Among other enhanced surface proteins, 3.5-fold increases of p50, p45, and p40 of MW 50,000-40,000 and isoelectric point 5.1-5.3 were observed. Simultaneously another surface protein, p70 of MW 70,000 and isoelectric point 6.1-6.3, disappeared. The quantitative changes of surface proteins produced after treatment with retinoic acid were enhanced in the presence of dibutyryl cAMP. Analysis of lectin-binding proteins demonstrated that increasing proteins p220, p50, p45, and p40 have an affinity for concanavalin A, whereas p70, which decreases, has an affinity for wheat germ agglutinin. Antibodies raised against p70 from undifferentiated cells have shown a specific immunoreaction with p220 from differentiated cells and also with the subunit B of purified laminin. The electrophoretic mobilities of p220 and of the B subunit of laminin are similar. It is suggested that p70, p220, and laminin B subunit share structural homology.     

Retinoic acid modulation of transmembrane signaling. Analysis in F9 teratocarcinoma cells

F9 embryonal mouse teratocarcinoma cells were differentiated to a primitive endoderm-like phenotype by retinoic acid and to a parietal endoderm-like phenotype by retinoic acid in combination with dibutyryl cyclic AMP. The secretion of tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) is a characteristic of the cells displaying the differentiated phenotypes. The fundamental question of whether tPA secretion is regulated acutely by G-protein-mediated transmembrane signaling was explored. Cells differentiated to primitive and parietal endoderm demonstrated a rapid tPA response to stimulation by beta-adrenergic agonist (isoproterenol). Adenylyl cyclase activity in response to isoproterenol and GTP, but not forskolin, was greater in primitive and parietal endoderm than F9 stem cells. Both primitive and parietal endoderm cells, but not F9 stem cells, displayed beta-adrenergic stimulation of cyclic AMP accumulation. Retinoic acid induced F9 stem cells to the primitive endoderm phenotype and increased beta-adrenergic receptor levels 3-fold. Gi alpha 2 levels declined, G beta-subunits increased, and Gs alpha levels were unchanged following differentiation to primitive endoderm. In parietal endoderm cells beta-adrenergic receptors increased 2-fold over F9 stem cells, Gi alpha 2 levels declined even further than in primitive endoderm, G beta-subunits increased compared to F9 stem cells, and Gs alpha levels again were unchanged. The marked potentiation of short-term stimulation of tPA secretion in the differentiated state may be best explained by the retinoic acid-induced increase in expression of beta-adrenergic receptors coupled with a decline in Gi alpha 2 levels. Short-term regulation by G-protein-linked receptors represents a novel mode for the control of tPA secretion.