Role of SUMO in RNF4-mediated Promyelocytic Leukemia Protein (PML) Degradation: Sumoylation of pml and phospho-switch control of its sumo binding domain dissected in living cells*

Promyelocytic leukemia protein (PML) is a tumor suppressor acting as the organizer of subnuclear structures called PML nuclear bodies (NBs). Both covalent modification of PML by the small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) and non-covalent binding of SUMO to the PML SUMO binding domain (SBD) are necessary for PML NB formation and maturation. PML sumoylation and proteasome-dependent degradation induced by the E3 ubiquitin ligase, RNF4, are enhanced by the acute promyelocytic leukemia therapeutic agent, arsenic trioxide (As₂O₃). Here, we established a novel bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) assay to dissect and monitor PML/SUMO interactions dynamically in living cells upon addition of therapeutic agents. Using this sensitive and quantitative SUMO BRET assay that distinguishes PML sumoylation from SBD-mediated PML/SUMO non-covalent interactions, we probed the respective roles of covalent and non-covalent PML/SUMO interactions in PML degradation and interaction with RNF4. We found that, although dispensable for As₂O₃-enhanced PML sumoylation and RNF4 interaction, PML SBD core sequence was required for As₂O₃- and RNF4-induced PML degradation. As confirmed with a phosphomimetic mutant, phosphorylation of a stretch of serine residues, contained within PML SBD was needed for PML interaction with SUMO-modified protein partners and thus for NB maturation. However, mutation of these serine residues did not impair As₂O₃- and RNF4-induced PML degradation, contrasting with the known role of these phosphoserine residues for casein kinase 2-promoted PML degradation. Altogether, these data suggest a model whereby sumoylation- and SBD-dependent PML oligomerization within NBs is sufficient for RNF4-mediated PML degradation and does not require the phosphorylation-dependent association of PML with other sumoylated partners.Promyelocytic leukemia protein (PML)⁵ is a tumor suppressor (1) whose gene is translocated in cases of acute promyelocytic leukemia (2). PML functions as the organizer of PML NBs, which are dynamic structures harboring numerous transiently and permanently localized proteins (3). The importance of PML NB structural integrity was first revealed in acute promyelocytic leukemia because, in this malignancy, the abnormal fusion protein PML/RARα leads to NB disruption. Patient treatment with As₂O₃ induces the reversion of the acute promyelocytic leukemia phenotype as well as PML/RARα degradation and PML NB reformation (4).PML is a target for the post-translational modification by SUMO, an ubiquitin-like protein that is covalently coupled to PML lysine residues 65, 160, and 490 via a process called sumoylation (5, 6). Among the four human SUMO paralogs identified, SUMO1, -2, and -3 were found to be conjugated to target proteins. It involves an enzymatic cascade for the transfer of the mature SUMO and the formation of an isopeptide bond between the COOH-terminal glycine of SUMO and a lysine from the target protein. Sumoylation is a reversible process due to the existence of several deconjugating enzymes.PML NB formation requires both the covalent linkage (sumoylation) (reviewed in Ref. 7) and the non-covalent interactions of SUMO with PML through a SUMO binding domain (SBD also named SIM for SUMO interacting motif) (8). Interestingly, PML SBD contains specific serines, acting as substrates for the caseine kinase-2 (CK2), which are implicated in PML ubiquitination and degradation (9) and which phosphorylation status could regulate the function of the SBD.Because sumoylation of proteins is dynamic and reversible, this post-translational modification is difficult to follow in vivo and its detection mainly relies on the identification of sumoylated protein species by Western blot following cell lysis. Recently, we used bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) to detect covalent linkage of ubiquitin (ubiquitination) in living mammalian cells and in real time (10). In brief, BRET monitors the interaction between a protein fused to a luciferase and a protein fused to yellow or green fluorescent protein (YFP or GFP), upon addition of a luciferase substrate; it is a proximity-based assay that requires that the donor of energy (luciferase fusion) and the acceptor (YFP or GFP fusions) are within 50 to 100 Å for an efficient energy transfer (11–13). However, a demonstration that BRET may provide a method of choice to follow the dynamics of protein sumoylation in living cells is lacking. Here, we developed a sensitive and quantitative SUMO BRET assay for the detection of PML interactions with SUMO in living cells. We proved that BRET can be used to detect both SUMO covalent and non-covalent interactions with PML (model, Fig. 1H). For this purpose, we used the PMLIII isoform in which sumoylation is induced by As₂O₃ and triggers a proteasome-dependent PML degradation (14); the degradation process involves the ubiquitination of poly-SUMO covalently coupled to PML by the poly-SUMO-specific E3 ubiquitin ligase RNF4 (15–17). Altogether, our BRET results indicate that, As₂O₃ and/or RNF4-induced PML degradation are dependent on the integrity of both PML sumoylation target sites and the PML SBD core sequence but not on the CK2 serine phosphorylation sites within the SBD. However, phosphorylation of these serines is required for most PML SBD-dependent non-covalent interactions. This phospho-regulation of PML SBD (“SBD phospho-switch”) establishes another link between the phosphorylation and SUMO, different from the phospho-sumoyl switch (18).Open in a separate windowFIGURE 1.BRET reveals both covalent and non-covalent PML/SUMO1 interactions as well as As₂O₃-induced PML sumoylation in living cells. A and B, detection of PML/SUMO1 interactions by BRET¹ (A) or BRET² (B) titration assays using HEK293T cells transfected for expression of increasing amounts of YFP-SUMO1 (BRET¹) or GFP-SUMO1 (BRET²) and a fixed amount of Luc fusion. Negative controls: BRET pairs including PML_C57,60A-Luc (a non-sumoylatable mutant with Cys⁵⁷ and Cys⁶⁰ mutated to Ala) or YFP-SUMO1G (a SUMO1 that cannot be processed) (dotted line) (A) and Luc fused to a NLS (B). C and D, detection of covalent and non-covalent PML/SUMO1 interactions by BRET¹ (C) or BRET² (D) titration assays in the presence (dotted lines, empty symbols) or absence (solid lines and symbols) of As₂O₃ in HEK293T cells transfected for expression of PML_WT-Luc or its sumoylation deficient mutant PML_3K-Luc in pairs with either YFP-SUMO1 (BRET¹) or GFP-SUMO1 (BRET²). Negative control: PML_WT-Luc in pairs with YFP-SUMO1G. E, kinetics of As₂O₃-induced PML_WT-Luc sumoylation revealed by BRET¹ (assay on attached cells) and BRET² (cells in suspension). F, dose-response curve to As₂O₃ treatment for PML_WT-Luc or PML_3KR-Luc/YFP-SUMO1 BRET¹ pairs. Negative control: PML_C57,60A-Luc/YFP-SUMO1. G, comparison of As₂O₃-induced sumoylation of PML_WT, PML_3KR, and its single lysine mutants at an identical YFP acceptor/Luc donor expression ratio as derived from titration curves. As₂O₃ treatment (C–G): 5 μm, 4 h exposure for BRET¹ and Western blot or 10 μm, 70-min exposure for BRET². H, model for the covalent (sumoylation) and non-covalent interactions between a tested protein fused to Luc and SUMO fused to a fluorescent protein (YFP) that generates a BRET signal. The black arrows indicate the bioluminescent transfer of energy (or BRET) that occurs between Luc and GFP fusion upon exposure to the cell-permeable luciferase substrate.     

Knockdown of endogenous RNF4 exacerbates ischaemia‐induced cardiomyocyte apoptosis in mice

RNF4, a poly‐SUMO‐specific E3 ubiquitin ligase, is associated with protein degradation, DNA damage repair and tumour progression. However, the effect of RNF4 in cardiomyocytes remains to be explored. Here, we identified the alteration of RNF4 from ischaemic hearts and oxidative stress‐induced apoptotic cardiomyocytes. Upon myocardial infarction (MI) or H₂O₂/ATO treatment, RNF4 increased rapidly and then decreased gradually. PML SUMOylation and PML nuclear body (PML‐NB) formation first enhanced and then degraded upon oxidative stress. Reactive oxygen species (ROS) inhibitor was able to attenuate the elevation of RNF4 expression and PML SUMOylation. PML overexpression and RNF4 knockdown by small interfering RNA (siRNA) enhanced PML SUMOylation, promoted p53 recruitment and activation and exacerbated H₂O₂/ATO‐induced cardiomyocyte apoptosis which could be partially reversed by knockdown of p53. In vivo, knockdown of endogenous RNF4 via in vivo adeno‐associated virus infection deteriorated post‐MI structure remodelling including more extensive interstitial fibrosis and severely fractured and disordered structure. Furthermore, knockdown of RNF4 worsened ischaemia‐induced cardiac dysfunction of MI models. Our results reveal a novel myocardial apoptosis regulation model that is composed of RNF4, PML and p53. The modulation of these proteins may provide a new approach to tackling cardiac ischaemia.     

Oxidative stress–induced assembly of PML nuclear bodies controls sumoylation of partner proteins

The promyelocytic leukemia (PML) protein organizes PML nuclear bodies (NBs), which are stress-responsive domains where many partner proteins accumulate. Here, we clarify the basis for NB formation and identify stress-induced partner sumoylation as the primary NB function. NB nucleation does not rely primarily on intermolecular interactions between the PML SUMO-interacting motif (SIM) and SUMO, but instead results from oxidation-mediated PML multimerization. Oxidized PML spherical meshes recruit UBC9, which enhances PML sumoylation, allow partner recruitment through SIM interactions, and ultimately enhance partner sumoylation. Intermolecular SUMO–SIM interactions then enforce partner sequestration within the NB inner core. Accordingly, oxidative stress enhances NB formation and global sumoylation in vivo. Some NB-associated sumoylated partners also become polyubiquitinated by RNF4, precipitating their proteasomal degradation. As several partners are protein-modifying enzymes, NBs could act as sensors that facilitate and confer oxidative stress sensitivity not only to sumoylation but also to other post-translational modifications, thereby explaining alterations of stress response upon PML or NB loss.     

The PML and PML/RARα Domains: From Autoimmunity to Molecular Oncology and from Retinoic Acid to Arsenic

Acute promyelocytic leukemia (APL) is specifically associated to a t(15; 17) translocation which fuses a gene encoding a nuclear receptor for retinoic acid, RARα, to a previously unknown gene PML. The PML protein is localized in the nucleus on a specific domain of unknown function (PML nuclear bodies, NB) previously detected with autoimmune sera from patients with primary biliary cirrhosis (PBC). These bodies are nuclear matrix-associated and all of their identified components (PML, Sp100, and NDP52) are sharply upregulated by interferons. We show that autoantibodies against both PML and Sp100 are usually associated in sera with multiple nuclear dot anti-nuclear antibodies and demonstrate that PML is an autoantigen, not only in PBC, but also in other autoimmune diseases. In APL, the PML/RARα fusion interferes with both the retinoic acid (RA) response and PML localization on nuclear bodies, but the respective contribution of each defect to leukemogenesis is unclear. RA induces the terminal differentiation of APL blasts, yielding to complete remissions, and corrects the localization of NB antigens. Arsenic trioxide (As₂O₃) also induces remissions in APL, seemingly through induction of apoptosis. We show that in APL, As₂O₃leads to the rapid reformation of PML bodies. Thus, both agents correct the defect in NB antigen localization, stressing the role of nuclear bodies in the pathogenesis of APL.     

Arsenic-induced SUMO-dependent recruitment of RNF4 into PML nuclear bodies

In acute promyelocytic leukemia (APL), the promyelocytic leukemia (PML) protein is fused to the retinoic acid receptor alpha (RAR). Arsenic is an effective treatment for this disease as it induces SUMO-dependent ubiquitin-mediated proteasomal degradation of the PML-RAR fusion protein. Here we analyze the nuclear trafficking dynamics of PML and its SUMO-dependent ubiquitin E3 ligase, RNF4 in response to arsenic. After administration of arsenic, PML immediately transits into nuclear bodies where it undergoes SUMO modification. This initial recruitment of PML into nuclear bodies is not dependent on RNF4, but RNF4 quickly follows PML into the nuclear bodies where it is responsible for ubiquitylation of SUMO-modified PML and its degradation by the proteasome. While arsenic restricts the mobility of PML, FRAP analysis indicates that RNF4 continues to rapidly shuttle into PML nuclear bodies in a SUMO-dependent manner. Under these conditions FRET studies indicate that RNF4 interacts with SUMO in PML bodies but not directly with PML. These studies indicate that arsenic induces the rapid reorganization of the cell nucleus by SUMO modification of nuclear body-associated PML and uptake of the ubiquitin E3 ligase RNF4 leading to the ubiquitin-mediated degradation of PML.     

SUMO化修饰与早幼粒白血病蛋白核体形成

早幼粒白血病蛋白核体(promyelocytic leukaemia nuclear bodies,PMLNBs)是哺乳动物细胞中普遍存在的一种亚核结构,广泛参与如转录调节、基因组稳定性维持、抗病毒、细胞凋亡、肿瘤抑制等一系列的生物学事件.SUMO(smallubiquitinmodifier)修饰是蛋白质翻译后修饰领域中的研究热点,SUMO修饰对PML核体的形成与降解都发挥着重要作用.近年来研究发现,人的E3泛素连接酶RNF4(RING finger protein4),可促进依赖SUMO-2/3修饰的PML核体的泛素化连接,并且ATO(三氧化二砷)可加速其对PML核体的降解.荧光共振能量转移(fluorescence resonance energy transfer,FRET)技术可完全应用于活细胞内PML核体和SUMO蛋白之间在时间和空间上的精确互作.因此,更深入地研究PML核体形成和降解的机理以及在这个过程中重要蛋白质之间的相互作用具有重要而深远的意义.     

The SUMO protease SENP6 is a direct regulator of PML nuclear bodies

Promyelocytic leukemia protein (PML) is the core component of PML-nuclear bodies (PML NBs). The small ubiquitin-like modifier (SUMO) system (and, in particular, SUMOylation of PML) is a critical component in the formation and regulation of PML NBs. SUMO protease SENP6 has been shown previously to be specific for SUMO-2/3-modified substrates and shows preference for SUMO polymers. Here, we further investigate the substrate specificity of SENP6 and show that it is also capable of cleaving mixed chains of SUMO-1 and SUMO-2/3. Depletion of SENP6 results in accumulation of endogenous SUMO-2/3 and SUMO-1 conjugates, and immunofluorescence analysis shows accumulation of SUMO and PML in an increased number of PML NBs. Although SENP6 depletion drastically increases the size of PML NBs, the organizational structure of the body is not affected. Mutation of the catalytic cysteine of SENP6 results in its accumulation in PML NBs, and biochemical analysis indicates that SUMO-modified PML is a substrate of SENP6.     

Arsenic degrades PML or PML-RARalpha through a SUMO-triggered RNF4/ubiquitin-mediated pathway

In acute promyelocytic leukaemia (APL), arsenic trioxide induces degradation of the fusion protein encoded by the PML-RARA oncogene, differentiation of leukaemic cells and produces clinical remissions. SUMOylation of its PML moiety was previously implicated, but the nature of the degradation pathway involved and the role of PML-RARalpha catabolism in the response to therapy have both remained elusive. Here, we demonstrate that arsenic-induced PML SUMOylation triggers its Lys 48-linked polyubiquitination and proteasome-dependent degradation. When exposed to arsenic, SUMOylated PML recruits RNF4, the human orthologue of the yeast SUMO-dependent E3 ubiquitin-ligase, as well as ubiquitin and proteasomes onto PML nuclear bodies. Arsenic-induced differentiation is impaired in cells transformed by a non-degradable PML-RARalpha SUMOylation mutant or in APL cells transduced with a dominant-negative RNF4, directly implicating PML-RARalpha catabolism in the therapeutic response. We thus identify PML as the first protein degraded by SUMO-dependent polyubiquitination. As PML SUMOylation recruits not only RNF4, ubiquitin and proteasomes, but also many SUMOylated proteins onto PML nuclear bodies, these domains could physically integrate the SUMOylation, ubiquitination and degradation pathways.     

The herpesvirus associated ubiquitin specific protease, USP7, is a negative regulator of PML proteins and PML nuclear bodies

The PML tumor suppressor is the founding component of the multiprotein nuclear structures known as PML nuclear bodies (PML-NBs), which control several cellular functions including apoptosis and antiviral effects. The ubiquitin specific protease USP7 (also called HAUSP) is known to associate with PML-NBs and to be a tight binding partner of two herpesvirus proteins that disrupt PML NBs. Here we investigated whether USP7 itself regulates PML-NBs. Silencing of USP7 was found to increase the number of PML-NBs, to increase the levels of PML protein and to inhibit PML polyubiquitylation in nasopharyngeal carcinoma cells. This effect of USP7 was independent of p53 as PML loss was observed in p53-null cells. PML-NBs disruption was induced by USP7 overexpression independently of its catalytic activity and was induced by either of the protein interaction domains of USP7, each of which localized to PML-NBs. USP7 also disrupted NBs formed from some single PML isoforms, most notably isoforms I and IV. CK2α and RNF4, which are known regulators of PML, were dispensable for USP7-associated PML-NB disruption. The results are consistent with a novel model of PML regulation where a deubiquitylase disrupts PML-NBs through recruitment of another cellular protein(s) to PML NBs, independently of its catalytic activity.     

In situ SUMOylation analysis reveals a modulatory role of RanBP2 in the nuclear rim and PML bodies

SUMO modification plays a critical role in a number of cellular functions including nucleocytoplasmic transport, gene expression, cell cycle and formation of subnuclear structures such as promyelocytic leukemia (PML) bodies. In order to identify the sites where SUMOylation takes place in the cell, we developed an in situ SUMOylation assay using a semi-intact cell system and subsequently combined it with siRNA-based knockdown of nucleoporin RanBP2, also known as Nup358, which is one of the known SUMO E3 proteins. With the in situ SUMOylation assay, we found that both nuclear rim and PML bodies, besides mitotic apparatuses, are major targets for active SUMOylation. The ability to analyze possible SUMO conjugation sites would be a valuable tool to investigate where SUMO E3-like activities and/or SUMO substrates exist in the cell. Specific knockdown of RanBP2 completely abolished SUMOylation along the nuclear rim and dislocated RanGAP1 from the nuclear pore complexes. Interestingly, the loss of RanBP2 markedly reduced the number of PML bodies, in contrast to other, normal-appearing nuclear compartments including the nuclear lamina, nucleolus and chromatin, suggesting a novel link between RanBP2 and PML bodies. SUMOylation facilitated by RanBP2 at the nuclear rim may be a key step for the formation of a particular subnuclear organization. Our data imply that SUMO E3 proteins like RanBP2 facilitate spatio-temporal SUMOylation for certain nuclear structure and function.     

The SUMO2/3 specific E3 ligase ZNF451-1 regulates PML stability

The small ubiquitin related modifier SUMO regulates protein functions to maintain cell homeostasis. SUMO attachment is executed by the hierarchical action of E1, E2 and E3 enzymes of which E3 ligases ensure substrate specificity. We recently identified the ZNF451 family as novel class of SUMO2/3 specific E3 ligases and characterized their function in SUMO chain formation. The founding member, ZNF451 isoform1 (ZNF451-1) partially resides in PML bodies, nuclear structures organized by the promyelocytic leukemia gene product PML. As PML and diverse PML components are well known SUMO substrates the question arises whether ZNF451-1 is involved in their sumoylation. Here, we show that ZNF451-1 indeed functions as SUMO2/3 specific E3 ligase for PML and selected PML components in vitro. Mutational analysis indicates that substrate sumoylation employs an identical biochemical mechanism as we described for SUMO chain formation. In vivo, ZNF451-1 RNAi depletion leads to PML stabilization and an increased number of PML bodies. By contrast, PML degradation upon arsenic trioxide treatment is not ZNF451-1 dependent. Our data suggest a regulatory role of ZNF451-1 in fine-tuning physiological PML levels in a RNF4 cooperative manner in the mouse neuroblastoma N2a cell-line.     

The translation initiation factor 3 subunit eIF3K interacts with PML and associates with PML nuclear bodies

The promyelocytic leukemia protein (PML) is a tumor suppressor protein that regulates a variety of important cellular processes, including gene expression, DNA repair and cell fate decisions. Integral to its function is the ability of PML to form nuclear bodies (NBs) that serve as hubs for the interaction and modification of over 90 cellular proteins. There are seven canonical isoforms of PML, which encode diverse C-termini generated by alternative pre-mRNA splicing. Recruitment of specific cellular proteins to PML NBs is mediated by protein–protein interactions with individual PML isoforms. Using a yeast two-hybrid screen employing peptide sequences unique to PML isoform I (PML-I), we identified an interaction with the eukaryotic initiation factor 3 subunit K (eIF3K), and in the process identified a novel eIF3K isoform, which we term eIF3K-2. We further demonstrate that eIF3K and PML interact both in vitro via pull-down assays, as well as in vivo within human cells by co-immunoprecipitation and co-immunofluorescence. In addition, eIF3K isoform 2 (eIF3K-2) colocalizes to PML bodies, particularly those enriched in PML-I, while eIF3K isoform 1 associates poorly with PML NBs. Thus, we report eIF3K as the first known subunit of the eIF3 translation pre-initiation complex to interact directly with the PML protein, and provide data implicating alternative splicing of both PML and eIF3K as a possible regulatory mechanism for eIF3K localization at PML NBs.