Tumorigenicity testing of primate cell lines in nude mice, muscle organ culture and for colony formation in soft agarose

Primate neoplastic and finite cell lines were tested in one in vivo and two in vitro test systems: adult nude mice, muscle organ culture (MOC) and soft agarose (SA). Comparison of the sensitivity of the systems indicated that nude mice were inferior to either in vitro system: WI-38 VA13 (an SV40 transformed cell line) did not cause tumours in these animals yet it behaved as if it were neoplastic in MOC and formed colonies in SA. There was complete correlation between results obtained in MOC and SA. All cell lines which produced tumors in vivo were positive in both in vitro test systems. None of the lines which showed normal patterns in MOC and in SA was tumorigenic in nude mice. Since testing in vitro is simpler, faster, and is thought to be reliable, we recommend SA followed by MOC as the initial assays for determining tumorigenicity of cells.     

Tumorigenicity of Vero cells

One of the current criteria for evaluating the acceptability of cell lines for use in vaccine production is lack of tumorigenicity. Vero cells represent an example of a class of cells known as continuous cell lines. They were derived from African green monkey kidney, and their growth properties and culture characteristics have many advantages over other cell substrates for use in vaccine production. We have tested Vero cells for tumorigenicity in nude mice and in a human muscle organ culture system, and found a significant increase in their tumorigenic potential with increasing passage numbers. Cells at passage 232 and higher produced nodules in all nude mice inoculated. Histologically the nodules were well defined, anaplastic tumors, which exhibited some of the characteristics of renal adenocarcinomas. In about 6 to 8 days all of the nodules began to regress. Data were obtained that suggested an immune mechanism was the basis for the regression phenomenon.     

Cellular tumorigenicity in nude mice. Role of susceptibility to natural killer cells

The athymic nude mouse is a useful animal model for assaying the neoplastic growth potential in vivo of animal cells transformed in vitro. Despite the demonstrated absence of thymus-dependent immunological functions, however, the nude mouse has now been shown to reject transplants of certain highly malignant heterologous tumors. In addition, a few transformed mammalian cell lines that exhibit all or most of the cellular phenotypes usually associated with malignancy fail to grow as tumors when injected into nude mice. In a continuing study to identify the in vitro phenotypes associated with tumor-forming ability in vivo, we investigated the role of cellular susceptibility to the naturally occurring, thymus-independent lymphocytes (natural killer or NK cells) in determining tumor induction by animal cells in nude mice. A representative collection of animal cells (ranging from normal human diploid cell strains to highly tumorigenic clonal cell lines, either transformed in vitro or derived from experimental tumors) was tested to see if the ability of cells to form tumors is consistently correlated with their susceptibility to NK cell-mediated lysis measured in vitro with splenic leukocytes from nude mice. If the physiological role of the NK cells in vivo were to recognize, and possibly to destroy, incipient tumor cells in situ, a direct association between cellular tumorigenicity and susceptibility to NK activity, might be expected. If, on the other hand, the formation of growing tumors by animal cells in nude mice depended on their ability to escape the cytolytic activity of NK cells, cellular tumorigenicity would be associated with cellular resistance to NK cells. Results obtained in this study failed to confirm either of these associations. Thus, cellular suscepbibility to NK cells, at least as determined by direct cytotoxicity assay in vitro, is not a useful predictive indicator of cellular tumorigenicity in nude mice.     

Malignant transformation of p53-deficient astrocytes is modulated by environmental cues in vitro.

The early incidence of p53 mutation in astrocytomas suggests that it plays an important role in astrocyte transformation. Astrocytes isolated from homozygous p53 knockout mice grow rapidly, lack contact inhibition, and are immortal. Here we tested whether the loss of p53 is sufficient for progression to tumorigenicity of astrocytes. We grew primary astrocytes under three conditions for over 120 population doublings and assessed their antigenic phenotype, chromosome number, and expression of glioma-associated genes as well as their ability to form colonies in soft agarose and tumors s.c. and intracranially in nude mice. Under two conditions (10% FCS and 0.5% FCS plus 20 ng/ml EGF), cells acquired the ability to form colonies in soft agarose and tumors in nude mice, and this was accompanied by the expression of genes, including epidermal growth factor receptor, platelet-derived growth factor receptor alpha and beta, protein kinase Cdelta, and vascular endothelial growth factor, which are known to be aberrantly regulated in human astrocytomas. Under the third condition (0.5% FCS plus 10 ng/ml basic fibroblast growth factor), astrocytes gained the ability to form colonies in soft agarose and had abnormal chromosome numbers similar to cells in the first two conditions but did not form tumors in nude mice or overexpress glioma-associated genes. These data provide experimental evidence for the idea that the malignant progression initiated by the loss of p53 may be subject to modulation by extracellular environmental influences.     

人乳头瘤病毒16型E6和E7基因及其突变体转化活性的研究

为筛选出可用于研制HPV治疗性疫苗的HPV16型E6和E7基因突变体,故将HPV16型原型株(德国株)E6和E7基因及其各种突变体分别转染Balb/c3T3细胞,观察转染后的细胞在软琼脂培养中的集落形成能力和在裸鼠体内的成瘤能力.结果表明,单独转染和共转染HPV16野生型E6和E7基因的Balb/c3T3细胞系,在软琼脂中呈集落样生长,并在裸鼠体内成瘤;而转染E6基因突变体mE6(50G)、E7基因的两种突变体mE7-1(24G26G)和mE7-3(24G26G67R)以及共转染mE6和mE7-1的Balb/c3T3细胞,在软琼脂培养中极少形成集落,也不能在裸鼠体内成瘤.提示经结构改造后的HPV16 E6和E7基因已失去了对Balb/c3T3细胞的转化活性,而保留了免疫原性,可用于HPV16相关肿瘤治疗性疫苗的构建.     

Activation of metastatic potential in african green monkey kidney cell lines by prolongedin vitro culture

Summary Studies on the tumorigenicity of Vero kidney cells ofCercopithecus aethiops monkey origin were extended to various passage levels of BSC-1 aneuploid cells and to low passage CV-1 diploid cells (derived also fromC. aethiops monkey kidney). It was found that BSC-1 cells—like Vero cells—showed increased tumorigenicity with increasing passage level in antitymocyte globulins (ATG) treated newborn rats and in nude mice. Cells passaged over 250 times in cultures formed invasive adenocarcinomas in newborn rats. Their malignant tumor growth was further demonstrated around the 500 passage level when tumor metastases were detected in the lungs of four of the 14 inoculated rats. Vero cells induced such lung metastases in rats already at passage 227. CV-1 diploid cells at low passage level produced small nodules of epithelioid cells in newborn rats at 6th day after inoculation that had disappeared by the 21st day, and caused no local invasion nor lung metastasis. In vitro tumorigenicity tests on BSC-1 and CV-1 cells, using chick embryo skin, human muscle and colony formation in agarose, confirmed the animal test results. The results of this study indicate that BSC-1 and Vero cell lines at low and high passage levels may prove to be useful tools to study the molecular basis of malignancy. Editor's Statement In this paper Contreras et al. document the increased malignancy of commonly-used monkey cell lines upon long-term culture. These observations have implications for the use of these cell lines in studies of cancer cell biology, as well as the use of these lines for the production of biologicals. David W. Barnes     

Culture of human neoplastic gastrointestinal smooth muscle cells

Summary Due to limited growth potential of primary cultures and the absence of continuous lines of healthy enteric smooth muscle, we have studied the culture behavior of neoplastic gastrointestinal smooth muscle cells. Forty-six human enteric smooth muscle neoplasms (leiomyomas and leiomyosarcomas) were studied while fresh and/or after culture in vitro and growth in vivo in athymic nude mice, with assessments made of morphology, growth characteristics, and biochemical markers of differentiation. The state of differentiation of the tumors varied, with well-differentiated tumors tending to express binding sites for the gastrointestinal hormone cholecystokinin, whereas less well-differentiated tumors did not. Poorly differentiated tumors were the easiest to establish in culture in vitro and to grow in vivo in nude mice. When the cells placed directly into culture proliferated to confluent density, they underwent morphologic differentiation from a spread, fibroblastlike shape to a slender spindle morphology, with these cells possessing fewer biosynthetic organelles and arranging themselves in characteristic “hill and valley” arrays. However, the highly differentiated characteristics of expression of desmin or cholecystokinin-binding sites were not observed in cultured cells. In contrast, cells that had been passaged in nude mice before culture displayed a proliferative phenotype and failed to undergo morphologic differentiation on reaching confluent density. Four human enteric smooth muscle cell lines (documented by chromosomal analysis) originating in stomach, jejunum, ileum, and rectum were established using this strategy. This work was supported by grants DK32878 and DK34988 from the National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD.     

Cellular tumorigenicity in nude mice. Test of associations among loss of cell-surface fibronectin, anchorage independence, and tumor-forming ability

Fibronectin (FN; also called large external transformation-sensitive [LETS] protein or cell-surface protein [CSP]) is a large cell-surface glycoprotein that is frequently observed to be either absent or greatly reduced on the surfaces of malignant cells grown in vitro. Because FN may be a useful molecular marker of cellular malignancy, we have carried out an extensive screening to test the specific association among the degree of expression of FN, anchorage-independent growth, and tumorigenicity in the athymic nude mouse. A variety of diploid cell strains and established cell lines were tested for the expression of surface FN by indirect immunofluorescence using rabbit antisera against human cold insoluble globulin, rodent plasma FN, or chicken cell- surface FN. Concomitantly, the cells were assayed for tumor formation in nude mice and for the ability to form colonies in methylcellulose. Tumorigenic cells often showed very low surface fluorescence, confirming earlier reports. However, many highly tumorigenic fibroblast lines from several species stained strongly with all three antisera. In contrast, the anchorage-independent phenotype was nearly always associated with tumorigenicity in approximately 35 cell lines examined in this study. In another series of experiments, FN-positive but anchorage-independent cells were grown as tumors in nude mice and then reintroduced into culture. In five of the six tumor-derived cell lines, cell-surface FN was not significantly reduced; one such cell line showed very little surface FN. Our data thus indicate that the loss of cell-surface FN is not a necessary step in the process of malignant transformation and that the growth of FN-positive cells as tumors does not require a prior selection in vivo for FN-negative subpopulations.     

Neoplastic transformation and tumorigenesis associated with overexpression of IMUP-1 and IMUP-2 genes in cultured NIH/3T3 mouse fibroblasts

Immortalization-upregulated protein 1 (IMUP-1) and immortalization-upregulated protein 2 (IMUP-2) genes have been recently cloned and are known to be involved in SV40-mediated immortalization. IMUP-1 and IMUP-2 genes were strongly expressed in various cancer cell lines and tumors, suggesting the possibility that they might be involved in tumorigenicity. To directly elucidate the functional role of IMUP-1 and IMUP-2 on neoplastic transformation and tumorigenicity, we stably transfected IMUP-1 and IMUP-2 into NIH/3T3 mouse fibroblast cells. Cellular characteristics of the neoplastic transformation were assessed by transformation foci, growth in soft agar, and tumor development in nude mice. We found that IMUP-1 and IMUP-2 overexpressing cells showed altered growth properties, anchorage-independent growth in soft agar and inducing tumor in nude mice. Furthermore, IMUP-1 and IMUP-2 transformants proliferated in reduced serum and shortened cell cycle. These results suggest that ectopic overexpression of IMUP-1 and IMUP-2 may play an important role in acquiring a transformed phenotype, tumorigenicity in vivo, and be related to cellular proliferation.     

Comparison of features of carcinogen-transformed human cells in vitro with sarcoma-derived cells

To define characteristics of chemically transformed phenotypes during and after progression to neoplasia and to assess their relationship to those phenotypes expressed by surgically removed sarcoma lesions, we compared the characteristics in the following manner. We investigated: (1) alterations in growth patterns; (2) anchorage-independent growth; (3) reactivity with monoclonal antibodies directed against surface antigen; (4) invasiveness in embryonic chick skin; (5) tumorigenicity in nude mice; and (6) karyology. Fifty different sarcoma cell lines were examined which exhibited different rates and absolute numbers of population doublings. With one exception, all sarcoma cell lines exhibited a finite life span ranging from 60 to 100 population doublings. Populations of these cells that exhibited anchorage-independent growth in soft agar also reacted positively with a monoclonal antibody (MoAb) 345.134S directed against a 115K-GP cell surface glycoprotein. Similarly, chemically transformed cells that grew in soft agar also reacted with the MoAb 345.134S, whereas cells with an inability to grow in soft agar did not. Cell lines established from human sarcoma and from chemically transformed human fibroblasts that reacted positively with the MoAb 345.134S were invasive for embryonic chick skin and formed tumors in nude mice. The selection medium used during culture of the carcinogen-treated cells resulted in the appearance of an altered phenotype that after at least 16 population doublings exhibited characteristics common to those cells derived from human sarcomas.     

Epstein-Barr virus in nontumorigenic and tumorigenic nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) somatic cell hybrids

Somatic cell hybrids between mouse fibroblasts and human cells derived from nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) biopsies or NPC tumors propagated in nude mice were examined for the expression of the Epstein-Barr nuclear antigen (EBNA), retention of Epstein-Barr viral (EBV) DNA, and tumorigenicity in nude mice. In all hybrids the expression of EBNA correlated with the detection of EBV-DNA. After more than 2 years in culture, the hybrids examined retained similar amounts of EBV-DNA when compared to previously published data. Retention of EBV-DNA did not correlate with the presence of any particular human chromosome. Use of either rodent cell lines, clone 1D or IT-22, did not affect the retention nor loss of EBV-DNA. For tumorigenicity studies, NPC cells were fused with IT-22 cells and injected into nude mice. Tumor formation did not depend on the presence or absence of EBNA and detectable EBV-DNA sequences; tumorigenicity in these studies could not be correlated with the presence of any particular human chromosome or the origin of the NPC biopsy.     

Neoplastic potential of rat tracheal epithelial cell lines induced by 1-nitropyrene and dibenzo(a,i)pyrene.

Our previous study showed that both 1-nitropyrene (1-NP) and dibenzo(a,i)pyrene (DBP) induced enhanced growth variants (EGVs) in primary cultures of rat tracheal epithelial (RTE) cells exposed in vivo. Cell lines were established from some of the EGVs. Further studies, using anchorage-independent growth in soft agar and tumorigenicity in athymic nude mice, were performed to determine the neoplastic potential of EGVs induced by 1-NP and DBP. Results show that three of five from DBP- and five of five from 1-NP-induced cell lines displayed anchorage-independent growth. The colony forming efficiency (CFE) from DBP-induced cell lines was 0.067 per thousand and CFE from 1-NP-induced cell lines was 0.151 per thousand. There is a significant difference between the two CFEs (mu = 12.08, P<0. 01). Two of five DBP- and five of five 1-NP-induced cell lines produced squamous cell carcinomas (SCC) in nude mice. The rate of tumorigenicity counted by injected sites was 20% (6/30) for DBP-induced cell lines and 57% (17/30) for 1-NP-induced cell lines. There is a significant difference between the results of tumorigenicity from the cell lines induced by the two different compounds (chi(2)=8.53, P<0.01). Neither of the two cell lines from spontaneously developed foci grew in soft agar or produced SCC in nude mice. It seems that the neoplastic potential of transformed RTE cells induced by 1-NP was higher than that of DBP.     

Assessing the tumorigenic phenotype of VERO cells in adult and newborn nude mice.

VERO cell lines are important substrates for viral vaccine manufacture. The mechanism by which these cells became neoplastically transformed is unknown. During tissue-culture passage, VERO cells can develop the capacity to form tumors. Although at the passage levels (around p140) currently used for vaccine manufacture, VERO cells are non-tumorigenic, questions have been raised about safety issues that might be associated with this capacity to acquire a tumorigenic phenotype. To begin to address these issues, the tumorigenicity of VERO cell lines, derived at different passage levels under different growth conditions, were evaluated in 365-day assays in adult and newborn nude mice. High passage (p>200) VERO cell lines established by random passaging in tissue culture produced tumors in adult (10 out of 27) mice and newborn (21 out of 30) mice, respectively. In contrast, a high passage (p>250) cell line established by passage at sub-confluence produced tumors only in newborn mice (16 out of 30). Progressively growing tumors began forming at 36 days in newborns and at 69 days in adults. Higher tumor incidences and shorter tumor latencies suggest that newborn nude mice may be more sensitive than adults in detecting the expression of a tumorigenic phenotype by some VERO cell lines.     

Dickkopf-1 activates cell death in MDA-MB435 melanoma cells

Dickkopf-1 (DKK-1) is known inhibitor of the canonical Wnt pathway. Recent studies strongly suggested that activation of DKK-1 expression results in inhibition of cell tumorigenicity. Reduced levels of DKK-1 in melanomas were recently shown. However, it is not known if DKK-1 activation in melanoma cells will inhibit cell tumorigenicity. In the present study, we overexpressed DKK-1 in melanoma cell line MDA-MB435. We show that while DKK-1 did not affect cell growth in soft agar, weak but significant inhibition of tumorigenicity in nude mice in vivo was observed. Analysis of resulting tumors revealed activation of cell death. In tumors originating from cells transduced with DKK-1, tumor mass was permeated with areas of necrosis. In tumors, originated from control cells, areas of necrosis were limited to the central region, a common feature of large tumors growing in nude mice. TUNEL assay revealed that in tumors originating from cells transduced with DKK-1 apoptotic cells were detected along the border of necrotic and viable areas of the tumors indicating significant increase in apoptotic process. Thus, our results indicate that activation of DKK-1 in melanoma cells leads to activation of apoptosis in vivo and, thus, is incompatible with tumor growth in nude mice.     

Differential tumorigenicity between Epstein-Barr virus genome-positive and genome-negative cell lines with t(11;14)(q13;q32) derived from mantle cell lymphoma.

Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) genome has been detected in several human lymphoproliferative diseases, but the oncogenic function of EBV is not fully understood. We previously established EBV-positive (SP-50B) and EBV-negative (SP-53) cell lines with the t(11;14)(q13;q32) chromosome abnormality from a single patient with mantle cell lymphoma. Monoclonal EBV DNA in a circular episomal form was demonstrated in the SP-50B cells by Southern blot hybridization with the EBV-terminal fragment probe. SP-50B cells were positive for not only EBV-encoded nuclear antigen-1 (EBNA1) but also latent membrane protein-1 and EBNA2. None of the EBV-encoded proteins was expressed in SP-53 cells. The isogenic EBV-infected and EBV-free cell lines of neoplastic clones made it possible to examine a tumorigenic role of EBV. Only EBV-positive SP-50B cells possessed malignant phenotypes, such as growth ability in low serum, colony formation in soft agarose, and tumorigenicity in nude mice. On the other hand, a lymphoblastoid B-cell line established by infecting the patient's normal B lymphocytes in vitro with exogenous EBV had no tumorigenicity. These results suggested that EBV infection, if it occurred in neoplastic lymphoma cells, could play a role in acquisition of malignant phenotypes.     

Rat embryo fibroblast cells expressing human papillomavirus 1a genes exhibit altered growth properties and tumorigenicity.

Human papillomavirus 1a (HPV1a) induces benign tumors (papillomas or warts) in humans under natural conditions of infection but has not been found to replicate significantly in cell culture or in experimental animals. To establish model systems to study the oncogenic properties and expression of HPV genes, we established cell lines by cotransfecting the 3Y1 rat fibroblast cell line with HPV1a DNA constructs containing an intact early gene region and the Tn5 neomycin resistance gene. Most cell lines selected for expression of the neomycin resistance gene by treatment with the antibiotic G-418 contained viral DNA in a high-molecular-weight form. The growth characteristics of several cell lines containing high copy numbers of HPV1a DNA were studied further. They were shown to differ from the parental cell line and from G-418-resistant cell lines that did not incorporate viral DNA in the following properties: morphological alteration, increased cell density at confluence, growth in 0.5% serum, efficient anchorage-independent growth in soft agar, and rapid formation of tumors in nude mice. Those cell lines that possessed altered growth properties and tumorigenicity were found to express abundant quantities of polyadenylated virus-specific RNA species in the cytoplasm.     

Characteristics of seven clones of the WiDr human colon adenocarcinoma cell line

Summary Seven clonal populations were derived from the WiDr human colon adenocarcinoma cell line and were characterized with respect to chromosome number, DNA content, and tumorigenicity in nude mide. There was no correlation between tumor volume and either DNA content or chromosome number; but there were wide differences among the clones regarding the size of tumors they were able to produce in nude mice.     

Genetic analysis of tumorigenesis: I. Expression of tumor-forming ability in hamster hybrid cell lines

Two new fibroblasts cell lines from a male Chinese hamster embryo are described: one tumorigenic in nude mice (CHEF 16-2) and the other not (CHEF 18-1). Both lines have a stable diploid mode and mean of 22 with 10 pairs of homologous autosomes. The cell lines differ unambiguously in cloning ability in methylcellulose, colony morphology, and tumorigenicity; the expression of these traits was examined in a set of 18-1 X 16-2 hybrid clones. The results show initial suppression of tumorigenicity and anchorage independence, followed by growth in the nude mouse of subsets of cells with chromosomes reduced to the diploid range. Further studies are in progress to establish whether ability to grow in methylcellulose and in the nude mouse segregate coordinately at the cellular level, and whether this segregation has an identifiable chromosomal basis.     

Delayed malignancy and altered growth properties of somatic cell hybrids between rat hepatoma and mouse L-cells.

Somatic cell hybrids of mouse L-cells with rat HTC cells were studied for their growth properties in vitro and tumorigenicity in vivo. Three hybrid clones were selected for detailed study. All were delayed in tumor formation in nude mice compared with the parent lines despite their varied growth properties in vitro. One clone was sensitive to density dependent inhibition of growth (DDIG) and had a relatively low saturation density. A second clone was not sensitive to DDIG and had a higher saturation density. The third clone had atypical morphology, was insensitive to DDIG, and had a relatively high saturation density. All of the clones studied produced colonies suspended in agarose gel which were much smaller than those of the parents incubated for the same period of time. Only the pattern of growth in agarose gel corresponded to the delayed tumor formation in vivo of the hybrids. Sensitivity to DDIG and saturation density were not consistent with tumor growth. The hybrid clone that was sensitive to DDIG was the only one of the three that had a nearly complete set of chromosomes derived from each of the parents. The chromosome numbers of all three clones were unchanged after growth in agarose or as tumors in the nude mice.