Differential signalling by variant ligands of the T cell receptor and the kinetic model of T cell activation

The structural basis of T cell activation through the T cell receptor is still a major unresolved issue in T cell biology. The wealth of information on the generation and structure of T cell receptor ligands and the biochemistry of signal transduction from this receptor have been useful in the initial approach to explain how T cell activation occurs. More recently, the generation of variant T cell receptor ligands with partial agonist or antagonist properties, the determination of crystal structures for unengaged and engaged T cell receptors, and the kinetics of T cell receptor interactions with peptide:MHC molecule complexes have provided new insights on T cell receptor function. The common theme arising from these experiments is that the T cell receptor is a versatile signalling machine, with an inherent flexibility for ligand recognition that translates in different signalling patterns. Here, I will review the data on differential signalling from the T cell receptor upon recognition of partial agonist and antagonist ligands and how these data impact on a more general kinetic model of T cell receptor-mediated activation.     

TLR ligands differentially modulate T cell responses to acute and chronic antigen presentation

The outcome of peripheral T cell activation is thought to be largely determined by the context in which the cognate Ag is initially presented. In this framework, microbial products that can activate APCs via TLRs are considered critical in converting an otherwise tolerogenic context to an immunogenic one. We examine this idea using a model system where naive T cells are stimulated in the periphery by a persistent self Ag. The addition of multiple TLR ligands to this context, acutely or chronically, failed to significantly alter the tolerogenic phenotype in the responding T cells. This contrasts with the ability of such adjuvants to improve T cell responses to soluble peptide immunizations. We reconcile this difference by revealing a hitherto poorly appreciated property of TLR ligands, which extends the duration of soluble Ag presentation in vivo by an additional two to three days. Finally, we could replace the requirement for TLR-mediated APC activation in soluble-Ag-induced T cell expansion and differentiation, by maintaining the Ag depot in vivo using repeated immunizations. These data suggest a novel process by which TLR ligands modulate T cell responses to acute Ags, without disrupting the induction of tolerance to persistent self Ags.     

Tumor cells prevent mouse dendritic cell maturation induced by TLR ligands

Tumor cells can evade the immune system through several mechanisms, one of which is to block DC maturation. It has been suggested that signaling via Toll-like receptors (TLR) may be involved in the induction of prophylactic anti-cancer immunity and in the treatment of established tumors. In the present study we found that high numbers of tumor cells interfere with BMDC activation induced by the TLR ligands LPS and poly IC. Tumor cells blocked TLR3- and TLR4-mediated induction of MHCII and the co-stimulatory molecules CD40 and CD86, as well as the cytokines IL-12, TNF-α and IL-6. Importantly, tumor cells induced inhibitory molecules (B7-DC, B7-H1 and CD80) on spleen DC in vivo and on BMDC, even in the presence of TLR ligands. Moreover, after a long exposure with tumor cells, purified BMDC were unable to respond to a second challenge with TLR ligands. The failure of tumor exposed-BMDC to express co-stimulatory molecules and cytokines in the presence of TLR ligands has implications for the future development of DC-based cancer immune therapies using TLR ligands as adjuvants for the activation of DC.     

Staphylococcus aureus protein A triggers T cell-independent B cell proliferation by sensitizing B cells for TLR2 ligands

B cells possess functional characteristics of innate immune cells, as they can present Ag to T cells and can be stimulated with microbial molecules such as TLR ligands. Because crude preparations of Staphylococcus aureus are frequently used as polyclonal B cell activators and contain potent TLR2 activity, the scope of this study was to analyze the impact of S. aureus-derived TLR2-active substances on human B cell activation. Peripheral B cells stimulated with chemically modified S. aureus cell wall preparations proliferated in response to stimulation with crude cell wall preparations but failed to be activated with pure peptidoglycan, indicating that cell wall molecules other than peptidoglycan are responsible for B cell proliferation. Subsequent analysis revealed that surface protein A (SpA), similar to BCR cross-linking with anti-human Ig, sensitizes B cells for the recognition of cell wall-associated TLR2-active lipopeptides (LP). In marked contrast to TLR7- and TLR9-triggered B cell stimulation, stimulation with TLR2-active LP and SpA or with crude cell wall preparations failed to induce IgM secretion, thereby revealing qualitative differences in TLR2 signaling compared with TLR7/9 signaling. Notably, combined stimulation with SpA plus TLR2 ligands induced vigorous proliferation of a defined B cell subset that expressed intracellular IgM in the presence of IL-2. Conclusion: S. aureus triggers B cell activation via SpA-induced sensitization of B cells for TLR2-active LP. Combined SpA and TLR2-mediated B cell activation promotes B cell proliferation but fails to induce polyclonal IgM secretion as seen after TLR7 and TLR9 ligation.     

TCR reserve: a novel principle of CD4 T cell activation by weak ligands

Some ligand-receptor systems have a receptor reserve where a maximal response can be achieved by occupation of a fraction of available receptors. An implication of a receptor reserve is the expansion of the number of ligands for response. To determine whether T cells follow receptor reserve, we have characterized the effect of reducing TCR levels on CD4 T cell responses elicited by altered peptide ligands that vary in potency. Agonist peptide is unaffected by a 90% reduction in TCR level while proliferation to weak agonists is significantly inhibited when TCR expression is reduced by 40%. Thymocyte-negative selection similarly demonstrates a differential requirement of TCR for response to agonist, weak agonist, and partial agonist. Therefore, our data demonstrate receptor reserve as a novel principle of T cell activation in which excess TCRs expand the antigenic repertoire to include less potent ligands.     

Regulation of the alternative pathway of T cell activation by anti-T3 monoclonal antibody

T cell activation may be triggered either through the T3-Ti antigen receptor complex or via an alternative macrophage-independent pathway involving the 50KD T11 sheep erythrocyte-binding glycoprotein. Monoclonal antibodies anti-T11(2) and anti-T11(3), directed at distinct epitopes of the T11 molecule, trigger mature T cells to proliferate and express their functional programs, and induce expression of IL 2 receptors on both T3+ and T3- thymocytes. We now show that a non-mitogenic anti-T3 antibody blocks activation via the T11 pathway of not only peripheral blood T cells, but also T3+ thymocytes. Anti-T3 does not affect surface expression of T11 or the rapid augmentation of T11(3) expression after incubation of cells with anti-T11(2). However, anti-T3 inhibits generation of IL 2 receptors and production of IL 2 by T lineage cells cultured with anti-T11(2) plus anti-T11(3). In contrast, modulation of the T11 molecule by a non-mitogenic anti-T11 antibody does not inhibit activation of T cells by a mitogenic anti-T3 antibody. The ability of anti-T3 to block expression of IL 2 receptors on both thymocytes and mature T cells activated by the T11 pathway suggests that a regulatory interaction may be important during T cell ontogeny to provide a mechanism for inhibiting expansion of autoreactive clones.     

Regulation of T cell receptor-induced activation of the Ras-ERK pathway by diacylglycerol kinase zeta

T cell development in the thymus and activation of mature T cells in the periphery depend on signals stimulated by engagement of the T cell antigen receptor (TCR). Among the second messenger cascades initiated by TCR ligation include the phosphatidylinositol pathway where the membrane phospholipid, phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate, is hydrolyzed to inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate and diacylglycerol (DAG). Inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate signals a rise in intracellular free calcium, leading to translocation of nuclear factor of activated T cells into the nucleus. DAG activates RasGRP and protein kinase C theta. Because both RasGRP and protein kinase C theta are essential for thymocyte and T cell function, it is critical to understand how DAG is regulated. In this report, we demonstrate expression of DAG kinase zeta (DGKzeta, the enzyme that catalyzes the conversion of DAG to phosphatidic acid) in multiple lymphoid organs, with highest expression observed within the T cell compartment. Overexpression studies in Jurkat T cells indicate that DGKzeta interferes with TCR-induced Ras and ERK activation, AP-1 induction, and expression of the activation marker CD69. In contrast, TCR-stimulated calcium influx is not altered. Mutational analysis indicates that the kinase and DAG binding domains, but not the ankyrin repeats of DGKzeta, are required for its inhibitory effects. Collectively these studies demonstrate a potential role of DGKzeta to function as a selective negative regulator of DAG signaling on T cell activation and provide the first structure/function analysis of this enzyme in T cells.     

Regulation of TGF-beta response during T cell activation is modulated by IL-10.

TGF-beta1 is an important pleiotropic cytokine that has been described to have both stimulatory and inhibitory effects on cell growth and differentiation. For several cell types, the effect of TGF-beta1 was found to correlate with the differentiation stage of the cells and the presence of other cytokines. In this report, we address the influence of TGF-beta1 on CD4(+) T cell activation by evaluating the effect of TGF-beta1 on the proliferative and cytokine responses of purified resting and activated human or mouse CD4(+) T cells. TGF-beta1 inhibits proliferation and cytokine secretion on resting CD4(+) T cells but has no inhibitory effect on activated T cells. Moreover, TGF-beta1 unresponsiveness of activated T cells was correlated with a down-regulation in the expression of the TGF-beta receptor type II. Interestingly, IL-10 addition enhances TGF-beta receptor type II expression and restores TGF-beta responsiveness on activated T cells. These results indicated that TGF-beta responsiveness is sequentially regulated on T cells by the modulation of the of TGF-beta receptor type II chain expression. Moreover, we have identified a novel regulatory role of IL-10 on TGF-beta-dependent T cell growth that can explain the control of T cell activation on chronic vs acute inflammatory sites.     

Cutting edge: the acquisition of TLR tolerance during malaria infection impacts T cell activation

An effective immune response to infection requires control of pathogen growth while minimizing inflammation-associated pathology. During malaria infection, this balance is particularly important. Murine malaria is characterized by early production of proinflammatory cytokines, which declines in the face of continuing parasitemia. The mechanism by which this occurs remains poorly understood. In this study, we investigated the role of dendritic cells (DCs) in regulating pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokine responses. As malaria infection progresses, DCs become refractory to TLR-mediated IL-12 and TNF-alpha production, while increasing their ability to produce IL-10 and retaining the capacity for activation of naive T cells. IL-12-secreting DCs from early infection stimulate an IFN-gamma-dominated T cell response, whereas IL-10-secreting DCs from later stages induce an IL-10-dominated T cell response. We suggest that phenotypic changes in DCs during Plasmodium yoelii infection represent a mechanism of controlling host inflammation while maintaining effective adaptive immunity.     

T cell selection and differential activation on structurally related HLA-DR4 ligands.

Plasticity of TCR interactions during CD4(+) T cell activation by an MHC-peptide complex accommodates variation in the peptide or MHC contact sites in which recognition of an altered ligand by the T cell can modify the T cell response. To explore the contribution of this form of TCR cross-recognition in the context of T cell selection on disease-associated HLA molecules, we have analyzed the relationship between TCR recognition of the DRB1*0401- and DRB1*0404-encoded HLA class II molecules associated with rheumatoid arthritis. Thymic reaggregation cultures demonstrated that CD4(+) T cells selected on either DRB1*0401 or DRB1*0404 could be subsequently activated by the other MHC molecule. Using HLA tetramer technology we identify hemagglutinin residue 307-319-specific T cells restricted by DRB1*0401, but activated by hemagglutinin residues 307-319, in the context of DRB1*0404. One such clone exhibits an altered cytokine profile upon activation with the alternative MHC ligand. This altered phenotype persists when both class II molecules are present. These findings directly demonstrate that T cells selected on an MHC class II molecule carry the potential for activation on altered self ligands when encountering Ags presented on a related class II molecule. In individuals heterozygous for these alleles the possibility of TCR cross-recognition could lead to an aberrant immune response.     

Clustering of T cell ligands on artificial APC membranes influences T cell activation and protein kinase C theta translocation to the T cell plasma membrane

T cell activation is associated with active clustering of relevant molecules in membrane microdomains defined as the supramolecular activation cluster. The contact area between these regions on the surface of T cells and APC is defined as the immunological synapse. It has been recently shown that preclustering of MHC-peptide complexes in membrane microdomains on the APC surface affects the efficiency of immune synapse formation and the related T cell activation. Disruption of such clusters may reduce the efficiency of stimulation. We describe here an entirely artificial system for Ag-specific, ex vivo stimulation of human polyclonal T cells (artificial APC (aAPC)). aAPC are based on artificial membrane bilayers containing discrete membrane microdomains encompassing T cell ligands (i.e., appropriate MHC-peptide complexes in association with costimulatory molecules). We show here that preclustering of T cell ligands triggered a degree of T cell activation significantly higher than the one achieved when we used either soluble tetramers or aAPC in which MHC-peptide complexes were uniformly distributed within artificial bilayer membranes. This increased efficiency in stimulation was mirrored by increased translocation from the cytoplasm to the membrane of protein kinase theta, a T cell signaling molecule that colocalizes with the TCR within the supramolecular activation cluster, thus indicating efficient engagement of T cell activation pathways. Engineered aAPC may have immediate application for basic and clinical immunology studies pertaining to modulation of T cells ex vivo.     

Regulation of RasGRP1 function in T cell development and activation by its unique tail domain

The Ras-guanyl nucleotide exchange factor RasGRP1 plays a critical role in T cell receptor-mediated Erk activation. Previous studies have emphasized the importance of RasGRP1 in the positive selection of thymocytes, activation of T cells, and control of autoimmunity. RasGRP1 consists of a number of well-characterized domains, which it shares with its other family members; however, RasGRP1 also contains an ~200 residue-long tail domain, the function of which is unknown. To elucidate the physiological role of this domain, we generated knock-in mice expressing RasGRP1 without the tail domain. Further analysis of these knock-in mice showed that thymocytes lacking the tail domain of RasGRP1 underwent aberrant thymic selection and, following TCR stimulation, were unable to activate Erk. Furthermore, the deletion of the tail domain led to enhanced CD4(+) T cell expansion in aged mice, as well as the production of autoantibodies. Mechanistically, the tail-deleted form of RasGRP1 was not able to traffic to the cell membrane following stimulation, indicating a potential reason for its inability to activate Erk. While the DAG-binding C1 domain of RasGRP1 has long been recognized as an important factor mediating Erk activation, we have revealed the physiological relevance of the tail domain in RasGRP1 function and control of Erk signaling.     

Regulation of T cell proliferation by IL-7

The regulation of murine T cell proliferation by IL-7 was investigated. Highly purified resting splenic T cells were induced to proliferate in a short term assay by IL-7 in the presence of the comitogen, Con A. The proliferation of these resting T cells showed both IL-2-dependent and -independent components as determined by the susceptibility of the response to the blocking effects of anti-IL-2 mAb. Furthermore, IL-7 was found to augment the Con A-induced production of IL-2 and expression of IL-2R by resting splenic T cells. In contrast, Con A blasts and long term, Ag-dependent cloned T cells proliferated in response to IL-7 independently of any involvement of IL-2. Finally, differences were observed between IL-7 and IL-6 with regard to the regulation of T cell growth and activation. As with IL-7, IL-6 stimulated resting splenic T cells to proliferate in the presence of comitogen. However, in contrast to IL-7, IL-6 failed to stimulate the proliferation of Con A blasts or T cell clones and did not augment the Con A-induced expression of IL-2R on resting T cells.     

Regulation of T cell priming by lymphoid stroma

The priming of immune T cells by their interaction with dendritic cells (DCs) in lymph nodes (LN), one of the early events in productive adaptive immune responses, occurs on a scaffold of lymphoid stromal cells, which have largely been seen as support cells or sources of chemokines and homeostatic growth factors. Here we show that murine fibroblastic reticular cells (FRCs), isolated from LN of B6 mice, play a more direct role in the immune response by sensing and modulating T cell activation through their upregulation of inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) in response to early T cell IFNγ production. Stromal iNOS, which only functions in very close proximity, attenuates responses to inflammatory DC immunization but not to other priming regimens and preferentially affects Th1 cells rather than Th2. The resultant nitric oxide production does not affect T cell-DC coupling or initial calcium signaling, but restricts homotypic T cell clustering, cell cycle progression, and proliferation. Stromal feedback inhibition thus provides basal attenuation of T cell responses, particularly those characterized by strong local inflammatory cues.     

Regulation of dendritic cell differentiation and function by estrogen receptor ligands

Estrogen receptor (ER) ligands can modulate innate and adaptive immunity and hematopoiesis, which may explain the clear sex differences in immune responses during autoimmunity, infection or trauma. Dendritic cells (DC) are antigen presenting cells important for initiation of innate and adaptive immunity, as well as immune tolerance. DC progenitors and terminally differentiated DC express ER, indicating the ER ligands may regulate DC at multiple developmental and functional stages. Although there are profound differences in innate immunity between males and females or upon systemic imposition of sex hormones, studies are just beginning to link these differences to DC. Our and others studies demonstrate that estradiol and other ER ligands regulate the homeostasis of bone marrow myeloid and lymphoid progenitors of DC, as well as DC differentiation mediated by GM-CSF and Flt3 Ligand. Since DC have a brief lifespan, these data suggest that relatively short exposures to ER ligands in vivo will alter DC numbers and intrinsic functional capacity related to their developmental state. Studies in diverse experimental models also show that agonist and antagonist ER ligands modulate DC activation and production of inflammatory mediators. These findings have implications for human health and disease since they suggest that both DC development and functional capacity will be responsive to the physiological, pharmacological and environmental ER ligands to which an individual is exposed in vivo.     

Regulation of encephalitogenic T cells with recombinant TCR ligands

We have previously described recombinant MHC class II beta1 and alpha1 domains loaded with free antigenic peptides with potent inhibitory activity on encephalitogenic T cells. We have now produced single-chain constructs in which the peptide Ag is genetically encoded within the same exon as the linked beta1 and alpha1 domains, overcoming the problem of displacement of peptide Ag from the peptide binding cleft. We here describe clinical effects of recombinant TCR ligands (RTLs) comprised of the rat RT1.B beta1alpha1 domains covalently linked to the 72-89 peptide of guinea pig myelin basic protein (RTL-201), to the corresponding 72-89 peptide from rat myelin basic protein (RTL-200), or to cardiac myosin peptide CM-2 (RTL-203). Only RTL-201 possessed the ability to prevent and treat active or passive experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis. Amelioration of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis was associated with a selective inhibition of proliferation response and cytokine production by Ag-stimulated lymph node T cells and a drastic reduction in the number of encephalitogenic and recruited inflammatory cells infiltrating the CNS. The exquisitely selective inhibition could be observed between molecules that differ by a single methyl group (the single amino acid residue difference between RTL-200 (threonine) and RTL-201 (serine) at position 80 of the myelin basic protein peptide). These novel RTLs provide a platform for developing potent and selective human diagnostic and therapeutic agents for treatment of autoimmune disease.     

Modulation of cytokine production and enhancement of cell viability by TLR7 and TLR9 ligands during anthrax infection of macrophages

Inhalation of Bacillus anthracis, a bioterrorism agent, results in a high mortality rate despite appropriate antibiotic therapy. Macrophages appear to be a key factor in B. anthracis pathogenesis. The burst of pro-inflammatory cytokines from macrophages could be a major cause of death in anthrax. However, preactivation of Toll-like receptors (TLRs) could modify the host response. TLR ligands stimulate the release of activating cytokines but may also down-modulate the subsequent deleterious cytokine response to pathogens. We developed a cell culture model to measure macrophage responses to B. anthracis spores and bacilli. We found that germination from spores to bacilli produced a substantial stimulus for the secretion of the cytokines IL-6, TNF-alpha, IL-10, and IL-12 p40. Our studies showed that pretreatment of mouse macrophages with the TLR9 ligand ISS-1018, or the TLR7 ligands R-848 and IT-37, results in a substantial decrease in the subsequent secretion of IL-6 and TNF-alpha in response to B. anthracis infection of macrophages. Furthermore, the TLR7 and TLR9 ligands significantly decreased anthrax-induced cytotoxicity in the macrophages. These findings suggest that TLR ligands may contribute to the enhancement of innate immunity in B. anthracis infection by suppressing potentially deleterious pro-inflammatory cytokine responses and by improving macrophage viability.