Modeling and alanine scanning mutagenesis studies of recombinant pokeweed antiviral protein

The Phytolacca americana-derived naturally occurring ribosome inhibitory protein pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP) is an N-glycosidase that catalytically removes a specific adenine residue from the stem loop of ribosomal RNA. We have employed molecular modeling studies using a novel model of PAP-RNA complexes and site-directed mutagenesis combined with bioassays to evaluate the importance of the residues at the catalytic site and a putative RNA binding active center cleft between the catalytic site and C-terminal domain for the enzymatic deadenylation of ribosomal RNA by PAP. As anticipated, alanine substitutions by site-directed mutagenesis of the PAP active site residues Tyr(72), Tyr(123), Glu(176), and Arg(179) that directly participate in the catalytic deadenylation of RNA resulted in greater than 3 logs of loss in depurinating and ribosome inhibitory activity. Similarly, alanine substitution of the conserved active site residue Trp(208), which results in the loss of stabilizing hydrophobic interactions with the ribose as well as a hydrogen bond to the phosphate backbone of the RNA substrate, caused greater than 3 logs of loss in enzymatic activity. By comparison, alanine substitutions of residues (28)KD(29), (80)FE(81), (111)SR(112), (166)FL(167) that are distant from the active site did not significantly reduce the enzymatic activity of PAP. Our modeling studies predicted that the residues of the active center cleft could via electrostatic interactions contribute to both the correct orientation and stable binding of the substrate RNA molecule in the active site pocket. Notably, alanine substitutions of the highly conserved, charged, and polar residues of the active site cleft including (48)KY(49), (67)RR(68), (69)NN(70), and (90)FND(92) substantially reduced the depurinating and ribosome inhibitory activity of PAP. These results provide unprecedented evidence that besides the active site residues of PAP, the conserved, charged, and polar side chains located at its active center cleft also play a critical role in the PAP-mediated depurination of ribosomal RNA.     

Binding interactions between the active center cleft of recombinant pokeweed antiviral protein and the alpha-sarcin/ricin stem loop of ribosomal RNA

Pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP) is a ribosome-inactivating protein that catalytically cleaves a specific adenine base from the highly conserved alpha-sarcin/ricin loop of the large ribosomal RNA, thereby inhibiting protein synthesis at the elongation step. Recently, we discovered that alanine substitutions of the active center cleft residues significantly impair the depurinating and ribosome inhibitory activity of PAP. Here we employed site-directed mutagenesis combined with standard filter binding assays, equilibrium binding assays with Scatchard analyses, and surface plasmon resonance technology to elucidate the putative role of the PAP active center cleft in the binding of PAP to the alpha-sarcin/ricin stem loop of rRNA. Our findings presented herein provide experimental evidence that besides the catalytic site, the active center cleft also participates in the binding of PAP to the target tetraloop structure of rRNA. These results extend our recent modeling studies, which predicted that the residues of the active center cleft could, via electrostatic interactions, contribute to both the correct orientation and stable binding of the substrate RNA molecules in PAP active site pocket. The insights gained from this study also explain why and how the conserved charged and polar side chains located at the active center cleft of PAP and certain catalytic site residues, that do not directly participate in the catalytic deadenylation of ribosomal RNA, play a critical role in the catalytic removal of the adenine base from target rRNA substrates by affecting the binding interactions between PAP and rRNA.     

Pokeweed antiviral protein depurinates the sarcin/ricin loop of the rRNA prior to binding of aminoacyl-tRNA to the ribosomal A-site

Ribosome-inactivating proteins, such as the pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP), inhibit translation by depurinating the conserved sarcin/ricin loop of the large ribosomal RNA. Depurinated ribosomes are unable to bind elongation factor 2, and, thus, the translocation step of the elongation cycle is inhibited. Though the consequences of depurination are well characterized, the ribosome conformation required for depurination to take place has not been described. In this report, we correlate biochemical and genetic data to conclude that pokeweed antiviral protein depurinates the sarcin/ricin loop when the A-site of the ribosomal peptidyl-transferase center is unoccupied. We show that prior incubation of ribosomes with puromycin, an analog of the 3'-terminus of aminoacyl-tRNA, inhibits both binding and depurination by PAP in a concentration-dependent manner. Expression of PAP in the yeast strain mak8-1 results in little depurination unless the cells are lysed, a process that would promote loss of aminoacyl-tRNA from the ribosome. The mak8-1 strain is known to exhibit a higher affinity for aminoacyl-tRNA compared with wild-type cells, and therefore, its ribosomes are more resistant to PAP in vivo. These data contribute to the mechanism of action of pokeweed antiviral protein; specifically, they have uncovered the ribosomal conformation required for depurination that leads to subsequent translation inhibition.     

Arginine Residues on the Opposite Side of the Active Site Stimulate the Catalysis of Ribosome Depurination by Ricin A Chain by Interacting with the P-protein Stalk

Ricin inhibits protein synthesis by depurinating the α-sarcin/ricin loop (SRL). Ricin holotoxin does not inhibit translation unless the disulfide bond between the A (RTA) and B (RTB) subunits is reduced. Ricin holotoxin did not bind ribosomes or depurinate them but could depurinate free RNA. When RTA is separated from RTB, arginine residues located at the interface are exposed to the solvent. Because this positively charged region, but not the active site, is blocked by RTB, we mutated arginine residues at or near the interface of RTB to determine if they are critical for ribosome binding. These variants were structurally similar to wild type RTA but could not bind ribosomes. Their K_m values and catalytic rates (k_cat) for an SRL mimic RNA were similar to those of wild type, indicating that their activity was not altered. However, they showed an up to 5-fold increase in K_m and up to 38-fold decrease in k_cat toward ribosomes. These results suggest that the stalk binding stimulates the catalysis of ribosome depurination by RTA. The mutated arginines have side chains behind the active site cleft, indicating that the ribosome binding surface of RTA is on the opposite side of the surface that interacts with the SRL. We propose that stalk binding stimulates the catalysis of ribosome depurination by orienting the active site of RTA toward the SRL and thereby allows docking of the target adenine into the active site. This model may apply to the translation factors that interact with the stalk.     

Evidence for retro-translocation of pokeweed antiviral protein from endoplasmic reticulum into cytosol and separation of its activity on ribosomes from its activity on capped RNA

Pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP) is a single-chain ribosome inactivating protein (RIP) that binds to ribosomes and depurinates the highly conserved alpha-sarcin/ricin loop (SRL) of the large subunit rRNA. Catalytic depurination of a specific adenine has been proposed to result in translation arrest and cytotoxicity. Here, we show that both precursor and mature forms of PAP are localized in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) in yeast. The mature form is retro-translocated from the ER into the cytosol where it escapes degradation unlike the other substrates of the retro-translocation pathway. A mutation of a highly conserved asparagine residue at position 70 (N70A) delays ribosome depurination and the onset of translation arrest. The ribosomes are eventually depurinated, yet cytotoxicity and loss of viability are markedly absent. Analysis of the variant protein, N70A, does not reveal any decrease in the rate of synthesis, subcellular localization, or the rate of transport into the cytosol. N70A destabilizes its own mRNA, binds to cap, and blocks cap dependent translation, as previously reported for the wild-type PAP. However, it cannot depurinate ribosomes in a translation-independent manner. These results demonstrate that N70 near the active-site pocket is required for depurination of cytosolic ribosomes but not for cap binding or mRNA destabilization, indicating that the activity of PAP on capped RNA can be uncoupled from its activity on rRNA. These findings suggest that the altered active site of PAP might accommodate a narrower range of substrates, thus reducing ribotoxicity while maintaining potential therapeutic benefits.     

The ribosomal stalk is required for ribosome binding,depurination of the rRNA and cytotoxicity of ricin A chain in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Ribosome inactivating proteins (RIPs) like ricin, pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP) and Shiga‐like toxins 1 and 2 (Stx1 and Stx2) share the same substrate, the α‐sarcin/ricin loop, but differ in their specificities towards prokaryotic and eukaryotic ribosomes. Ricin depurinates the eukaryotic ribosomes more efficiently than the prokaryotic ribosomes, while PAP can depurinate both types of ribosomes. Accumulating evidence suggests that different docking sites on the ribosome might be used by different RIPs, providing a basis for understanding the mechanism underlying their kingdom specificity. Our previous results demonstrated that PAP binds to the ribosomal protein L3 to depurinate the α‐sarcin/ricin loop and binding of PAP to L3 was critical for its cytotoxicity. Here, we used surface plasmon resonance to demonstrate that ricin toxin A chain (RTA) binds to the P1 and P2 proteins of the ribosomal stalk in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Ribosomes from the P protein mutants were depurinated less than the wild‐type ribosomes when treated with RTA in vitro. Ribosome depurination was reduced when RTA was expressed in the ΔP1 and ΔP2 mutants in vivo and these mutants were more resistant to the cytotoxicity of RTA than the wild‐type cells. We further show that while RTA, Stx1 and Stx2 have similar requirements for ribosome depurination, PAP has different requirements, providing evidence that the interaction of RIPs with different ribosomal proteins is responsible for their ribosome specificity.     

The influence of ricin-mediated rRNA depurination on the translational machinery in vivo - New insight into ricin toxicity

The generally accepted model of ricin intoxication assumes that direct inactivation of ribosomes by depurination of a specific adenine residue within the sarcin-ricin-loop (SRL) on the 60S ribosomal subunit is a major source of its toxicity. The model proposes that SRL depurination leads to protein synthesis inhibition, evoking ribotoxic stress with concomitant induction of numerous metabolic pathways, which lead to cell death. However, the direct relationship between the depurination and its impact on the translational machinery in vivo has never been satisfactorily explained. In this work, we approached a long-standing question about the influence of SRL depurination on the functioning of the translational machinery in vivo. We have shown that an already low level of depurinated ribosomes exert an effect on cell metabolism, indicating that minute modification within the ribosomal pool is sufficient to elicit a toxic effect. Importantly, depurination does not affect notably any particular step of translation, and translational slowdown caused by ricin is not a direct consequence of depurination and cannot be considered as the sole source of cell death. Instead, SRL depurination in a small fraction of ribosomes blocks cell cycle progression with no effect on cell viability. In this work, we have provided a comprehensive picture of the impact of SRL depurination on the translational apparatus in vivo. We propose that ribosomes with depurinated SRL represent a small imprinted ribosomal pool, which generates a specific signal for the cell to halt the cell cycle.     

Depurination of plant ribosomes by pokeweed antiviral protein

Mammalian ribosomes have been shown to be enzymatically modified by ribosomal inactivating protein (RIPs) via specific depurination of rRNA. Here we report that ribosomes isolated from wheat germ contain intact and undepurinated rRNA and are depurinated by pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP). Pokeweed ribosomes isolated under the same conditions are depurinated. Total RNA isolated from pokeweed in the presence of strong denaturants was found to pbe partially depurinated. We conclude that wheat germ ribosomes are resistant to the endogenous RIP, tritin, but are sensitive to PAP and that pokeweed ribosomes can be depurinated by the N-glycosidase activity of endogenous PAP during isolation.     

Homodimerization of pokeweed antiviral protein as a mechanism to limit depurination of pokeweed ribosomes

Ribosome inactivating proteins are glycosidases synthesized by many plants and have been hypothesized to serve in defence against pathogens. These enzymes catalytically remove a conserved purine from the sarcin/ricin loop of the large ribosomal RNA, which has been shown in vitro to limit protein synthesis. The resulting toxicity suggests that plants may possess a mechanism to protect their ribosomes from depurination during the synthesis of these enzymes. For example, pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP) is cotranslationally inserted into the lumen of the endoplasmic reticulum and travels via the endomembrane system to be stored in the cell wall. However, some PAP may retrotranslocate across the endoplasmic reticulum membrane to be released back into the cytosol, thereby exposing ribosomes to depurination. In this work, we isolated and characterized a complexed form of the enzyme that exhibits substantially reduced activity. We showed that this complex is a homodimer of PAP and that dimerization involves a peptide that contains a conserved aromatic amino acid, tyrosine 123, located in the active site of the enzyme. Bimolecular fluorescence complementation demonstrated that the homodimer may form in vivo and that dimerization is prevented by the substitution of tyrosine 123 for alanine. The homodimer is a minor form of PAP, observed only in the cytosol of cells and not in the apoplast. Taken together, these data support a novel mechanism for the limitation of depurination of autologous ribosomes by molecules of the protein that escape transport to the cell wall by the endomembrane system.     

Characterization of pokeweed antiviral protein binding to mRNA cap analogs: competition with nucleotides and enhancement by translation initiation factor iso4G

Pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP) is a type I ribosomal inactivating protein (RIP). PAP binds to and depurinates the sarcin/ricin loop (SRL) of ribosomal RNA resulting in the cessation of protein synthesis. PAP has also been shown to bind to mRNA cap analogs and depurinate mRNA downstream of the cap structure. The biological role of cap binding and its possible role in PAP activity are not known. Here we show the first direct quantitative evidence for PAP binding to the cap analog m(7)GTP. We report a binding affinity of 43.3+/-0.1 nM at 25 degrees C as determined by fluorescence quenching experiments. This is similar to the values reported for wheat cap-binding proteins eIFiso4E and eIFiso4F. van't Hoff analysis of m(7)GTP-PAP equilibrium reveals a binding reaction that is enthalpy driven and entropy favored with TDeltaS degrees contributing 15% to the overall value of DeltaG degrees . This is in contrast to the wheat cap-binding proteins which are enthalpically driven in the DeltaG degrees for binding. Competition experiments indicate that ATP and GTP compete for the cap-binding site on PAP with slightly different affinities. Fluorescence studies of PAP-eIFiso4G binding reveal a protein-protein interaction with a K(d) of 108.4+/-0.3 nM. eIFiso4G was shown to enhance the interaction of PAP with m(7)GTP cap analog by 2.4-fold. These results suggest the involvement of PAP-translation initiation factor complexes in RNA selection and depurination.     

Generation of pokeweed antiviral protein mutations in Saccharomyces cerevisiae: evidence that ribosome depurination is not sufficient for cytotoxicity

Pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP) is a ribosome-inactivating protein that depurinates the highly conserved α-sarcin/ricin loop in the large rRNA. Here, using site-directed mutagenesis and systematic deletion analysis from the 5′ and the 3′ ends of the PAP cDNA, we identified the amino acids important for ribosome depurination and cytotoxicity of PAP. Truncating the first 16 amino acids of PAP eliminated its cytotoxicity and the ability to depurinate ribosomes. Ribosome depurination gradually decreased upon the sequential deletion of C-terminal amino acids and was abolished when a stop codon was introduced at Glu-244. Cytotoxicity of the C-terminal deletion mutants was lost before their ability to depurinate ribosomes. Mutations in Tyr-123 at the active site affected cytotoxicity without altering the ribosome depurination ability. Total translation was not inhibited in yeast expressing the non-toxic Tyr-123 mutants, although ribosomes were depurinated. These mutants depurinated ribosomes only during their translation and could not depurinate ribosomes in trans in a translation-independent manner. A mutation in Leu-71 in the central domain affected cytotoxicity without altering the ability to depurinate ribosomes in trans and inhibit translation. These results demonstrate that the ability to depurinate ribosomes in trans in a catalytic manner is required for the inhibition of translation, but is not sufficient for cytotoxicity.     

The C-terminus of pokeweed antiviral protein has distinct roles in transport to the cytosol, ribosome depurination and cytotoxicity

Pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP) produced by pokeweed plants is a single-chain (type I) ribosome-inactivating protein (RIP) that depurinates ribosomes at the alpha-sarcin/ricin loop of the large rRNA, resulting in inhibition of translation. Unlike the type II RIPs, which have an active and a binding moiety, PAP has only the active moiety. The mechanism by which toxins without a binding moiety gain access to cytosolic ribosomes is not known. We set up yeast as a simple and genetically tractable system to investigate how PAP accesses ribosomes and showed that the mature form of PAP is targeted to the cytosol from the endomembrane system in yeast. In the present study, we performed a systematic deletion analysis to identify the signal required for transport of PAP to the cytosol. We demonstrate here that processing of the C-terminal extension and sequences at the C-terminus of the mature protein are critical for its accumulation in the cytosol. Using a series of PAP mutants, we identified the C-terminal signal and demonstrated that it is distinct from the sequences required for ribosome depurination and cytotoxicity. The C-terminal motif showed sequence similarity to type II RIPs that retrotranslocate from the endoplasmic reticulum to the cytosol. These results demonstrate that a conserved sequence at the C-terminus of a type I RIP mediates its transport to the cytosol and suggest that type I and II RIPs may use a common signal to enter the cytosol.     

A non-toxic pokeweed antiviral protein mutant inhibits pathogen infection via a novel salicylic acid-independent pathway

Pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP), a ribosome-inactivating protein isolated from Phytolacca americana, is characterized by its ability to depurinate the sarcin/ricin (S/R) loop of the large rRNA of prokaryotic and eukaryotic ribosomes. In this study, we present evidence that PAP is associated with ribosomes and depurinates tobacco ribosomes in vivo by removing more than one adenine and a guanine. A mutant of pokeweed antiviral protein, PAPn, which has a single amino acid substitution (G75D), did not bind ribosomes efficiently, indicating that Gly-75 in the N-terminal domain is critical for the binding of PAP to ribosomes. PAPn did not depurinate ribosomes and was non-toxic when expressed in transgenic tobacco plants. Unlike wild-type PAP and a C-terminal deletion mutant, transgenic plants expressing PAPn did not have elevated levels of acidic pathogenesis-related (PR) proteins. PAPn, like other forms of PAP, did not trigger production of salicylic acid (SA) in transgenic plants. Expression of the basic PR proteins, the wound-inducible protein kinase and protease inhibitor II, was induced in PAPn-expressing transgenic plants and these plants were resistant to viral and fungal infection. These results demonstrate that PAPn activates a particular SA-independent, stress-associated signal transduction pathway and confers pathogen resistance in the absence of ribosome binding, rRNA depurination and acidic PR protein production.     

Pentameric organization of the ribosomal stalk accelerates recruitment of ricin a chain to the ribosome for depurination

Ribosome inactivating proteins (RIPs) depurinate a universally conserved adenine in the α-sarcin/ricin loop (SRL) and inhibit protein synthesis at the translation elongation step. We previously showed that ribosomal stalk is required for depurination of the SRL by ricin toxin A chain (RTA). The interaction between RTA and ribosomes was characterized by a two-step binding model, where the stalk structure could be considered as an important interacting element. Here, using purified yeast ribosomal stalk complexes assembled in vivo, we show a direct interaction between RTA and the isolated stalk complex. Detailed kinetic analysis of these interactions in real time using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) indicated that there is only one type of interaction between RTA and the ribosomal stalk, which represents one of the two binding steps of the interaction with ribosomes. Interactions of RTA with the isolated stalk were relatively insensitive to salt, indicating that nonelectrostatic interactions were dominant. We compared the interaction of RTA with the full pentameric stalk complex containing two pairs of P1/P2 proteins with its interaction with the trimeric stalk complexes containing only one pair of P1/P2 and found that the rate of association of RTA with the pentamer was higher than with either trimer. These results demonstrate that the stalk is the main landing platform for RTA on the ribosome and that pentameric organization of the stalk accelerates recruitment of RTA to the ribosome for depurination. Our results suggest that multiple copies of the stalk proteins might also increase the scavenging ability of the ribosome for the translational GTPases.     

Correlation between the activities of five ribosome-inactivating proteins in depurination of tobacco ribosomes and inhibition of tobacco mosaic virus infection

The rRNA depurination activities of five ribosome-inactivating proteins (RIPs) were compared in vitro using yeast and tobacco leaf ribosomes as substrates. All of the RIPs (pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP), dianthin 32, tritin, barley RIP and ricin A-chain) were active on yeast ribosomes. PAP and dianthin 32 were highly active and ricin A-chain weakly active on tobacco ribosomes, whereas tritin and barley RIP were inactive. PAP and dianthin 32 were highly effective in inhibiting the formation of local lesions caused by tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) on tobacco leaves, whereas tritin, barley RIP and ricin A-chain were ineffective. The apparent anomaly between the in vitro rRNA depurination activity, but lack of antiviral activity of ricin A-chain was further investigated by assaying for rRNA depurination in situ following the topical application of the RIP to leaves. No activity was detected, a finding consistent with the apparent lack of antiviral activity of this RIP. Thus, it is concluded that there is a positive correlation between RIP-catalysed depurination of tobacco ribosomes and antiviral activity which gives strong support to the hypothesis that the antiviral activity of RIPs works through ribosome inactivation.     

Expression of a truncated form of ribosomal protein L3 confers resistance to pokeweed antiviral protein and the Fusarium mycotoxin deoxynivalenol

The contamination of important agricultural products such as wheat, barley, or maize with the trichothecene mycotoxin deoxynivalenol (DON) due to infection with Fusarium species is a worldwide problem. Trichothecenes inhibit protein synthesis by targeting ribosomal protein L3. Pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP), a ribosome-inactivating protein binds to L3 to depurinate the alpha-sarcin/loop of the large rRNA. Plants transformed with the wild-type PAP show lesions and express very low levels of PAP because PAP autoregulates its expression by destabilizing its own mRNA. We show here that transgenic tobacco plants expressing both the wild-type PAP and a truncated form of yeast L3 (L3delta) are phenotypically normal. PAP mRNA and protein levels are very high in these plants, indicating that L3delta suppresses the autoregulation of PAP mRNA expression. Ribosomes are not depurinated in the transgenic plants expressing PAP and L3delta, even though PAP is associated with ribosomes. The expression of the endogenous tobacco ribosomal protein L3 is up-regulated in these plants and they are resistant to the Fusarium mycotoxin DON. These results demonstrate that expression of an N-terminal fragment of yeast L3 leads to trans-dominant resistance to PAP and the trichothecene mycotoxin DON, providing evidence that both toxins target L3 by a common mechanism.     

Expression of pokeweed antiviral protein in mammalian cells activates c-Jun NH2-terminal kinase without causing apoptosis

Pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP) is a ribosome inactivating protein isolated from the pokeweed plant (Phytolacca americana L.) that exhibits broad range antiviral activity against several human viruses including HIV and influenza. This characteristic suggests that PAP may have therapeutic applications; however, it is not known whether the protein elicits a ribotoxic stress response that would result in cell death. Therefore, we expressed PAP in 293T cells and showed that the enzyme did not inhibit protein translation even though approximately 15% of the ribosomal RNA (rRNA) was depurinated. PAP expression induced the activation of c-Jun NH2-terminal kinase (JNK), which was specific to rRNA depurination, as the enzymatically inactive mutant PAPx did not affect kinase activity. Moreover, incubation of PAP-expressing cells with translation inhibitors diminished JNK activation, indicating that the signal for induction of the kinase pathway originated from ribosomes. JNK activation did not result in apoptosis as demonstrated by the absence of caspase-3 and poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase cleavage and by the lack of cell staining for morphological changes in membrane permeability. Unlike all ribosome inactivating proteins tested thus far, the stress response triggered by PAP expression did not result in cell death, which supports further investigation of the enzyme in the design of novel antiviral agents.     

Pokeweed antiviral protein region Gly209-Lys225 is critical for RNA N-glycosidase activity of the prokaryotic ribosome

Pokeweed antiviral protein (PAP) isolated from Phytolacca americana is a ribosome-inactivating protein (RIP) that has RNA N-glycosidase (RNG) activity towards both eukaryotic and prokaryotic ribosomes. In contrast, karasurin-A (KRN), a RIP from Trichosanthes kirilowii var. japonica, is active only on eukaryotic ribosomes. Stepwise selection of chimera proteins between PAP and KRN indicated that the C-terminal region of PAP (residues 209–225) was critical for RNG activity toward prokaryotic ribosomes. When the region of PAP (residues 209–225) was replaced with the corresponding region of KRN the PAP chimera protein, like KRN, was active only on eukaryotic ribosomes. Furthermore, insertion of the region of PAP (residues 209–225) into the KRN chimera protein resulted not only in the detectable RNG activity toward prokaryotic ribosome, but also activity toward the eukaryotic ribosomes as well that was seven-fold higher than for the original KRN. In this study, the possibility of genetic manipulation of the activity and substrate specificity of RIPs is demonstrated.