Suppressor cell influence in selected strains of inbred rats. III. Evidence for nonspecific suppression by a lymphocyte-macrophage cooperation.

Lewis (LE) and Brown-Norway (BN) rats treated in vivo with rabbit anti rat thymocyte serum demonstrate a reversal in relative responsiveness when assayed to mitogens and antigens via lymphocyte transformation, i.e., the BN rat now responds to a greater magnitude than the LE rats. Spleen cells, from both strains, that have been eluted from glass wool columns, demonstrate elevated responses to mitogens and antigens when compared to unfractionated spleen cells. The responses by these unfractionated and nonadherent populations can 1) be further enhanced subsequent to the treatment with anti-thymocyte serum and 2) suppressed after addition of macrophages from either strain, but especially by BN derived macrophages. The adherent cells from LE spleens respond to the above treatments in a similar fashion as the other populations. The responsiveness of adherent BN cells is only partially restored following treatment with anti-thymocyte serum, and is not further suppressed upon the addition of macrophages. These data are indicative of a lymphocyte-macrophage cooperation in this mechanism of suppression.     

Suppressor cell infleunce in selected strains of inbred rats. II. Macrophage-associated suppression of cell-mediated immune responsiveness.

Responses to concanavalin A or antigen by allogeneic combinations of Lewis (LE) and Brown-Norway (BN) rat derived lymphocytes and macrophages were of comparable magnitude to responses by the syngeneic combinations. But at increased concentrations of macrophages to lymphocytes, suppression of lymphocyte reactivity, as assayed by incorporation of tritiated thymidine, was evident. Suppression associated with BN derived macrophages alone, or in combination with LE or Buffalo derived macrophages, was consistently of a greater magnitude. Possible explanations of the macrophage associated suppression are discussed.     

Studies on the regulation of lymphocyte reactivity by normal and activated macrophages.

To determine the potential role of macrophages as regulators of the immune response, the effect of mouse peritoneal macrophages on transforming mouse spleen lymphocytes was investigated. Mitogen and antigen stimulated lymphocyte transformation, as measured by DNA synthesis, was enhanced by all concentrations of normal macrophages tested, but only by low concentrations of activated macrophages. High concentrations of activated macrophages markedly inhibited lymphocyte transformation. This inhibition occurred whether lymphocyte DNA synthesis was measured by incorporation of [³H]TdR or of ³²P. Activated macrophages cultured with lymphocytes within 4 hr of being removed from the peritoneal cavity inhibited lymphocyte transformation. When activated macrophages were cultured alone for 24 or more hours before addition of lymphocytes, enhancement of transformation was noted. Once lymphocytes were exposed to activated macrophages, they could not be induced to undergo transformation in the presence of Con A. Whereas heat-killed activated macrophages, which appeared intact morphologically, lost their capacity to inhibit lymphocyte transformation, macrophages treated with mitomycin C to inhibit DNA synthesis retained this capacity. Syngeneic and allogeneic macrophages had similar inhibitory ability. Supernatants from cultures of many cell types (including normal or activated macrophages, lymphocytes, lymphocytes plus macrophages, and L cells) inhibited [³H]TdR incorporation by both mitogen stimulated lymphocytes and tumor cells. These studies demonstrate the capacity of macrophages to regulate lymphocyte transformation in vitro and suggest a role for these cells as regulators of cell-mediated immunity in vivo.     

Specific in vitro lymphocyte transformation with Venezuelan equine encephalitis virus.

Specific lymphocyte transformation to viral antigen was detected in individuals vaccinated with live, attenuated Venezuelan equine encephalitis (VEE) virus vaccine, strain TC-83. Suspensions of purified, inactivated virus were used an antigen in 250-μ1 lymphocyte cultures, and under optimal conditions the assay demonstrated 10-fold greater incorporation of ¹⁴C-thymidine by lymphocytes from immune than from nonimmune people. The rise in lymphocyte transformation response occurred 1 week after vaccination. The magnitude and range of the lymphocyte transformation response to the VEE viral antigen were similar to the responses seen using antigens derived from five other microbial sources: Francisella tularensis, Coccidioides immitis, Mycobacterium tuberculosis, Streptococcus, and parainfluenza virus. Autologous plasma containing antibody exerts an inhibitory effect on cultures from immune individuals. The onset, magnitude of response, and specificity of this in vitro assay are correlated with the clinical and pathological events of VEE virus infection.     

The in vitro detection of antigen sensitivity in contact dermatitis by lymphocyte transformation.

Contact sensitivity induced in rabbits by the topical application of 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene (DNCB) was evaluated by the in vitro lymphocyte transformation response. The antigen employed to stimulate cultures was a preparation of DNCB conjugated homologous lymphocytes. This antigen preparation specifically stimulated blood lymphocytes from DNCB sensitive animals to transform in vitro. The kinetics of the primary immune response were determined by antigen mediated lymphocyte transformation in rabbits percutaneously sensitized with DNCB. The peak response was reached 12 days following initial exposure to DNCB. Sensitivity decreased but remained at detectable levels through 57 days of the primary response. Skin testing the animals late in the primary response stimulated an increase in the number of circulating sensitive lymphocytes. Serum proteins, conjugated with DNCB, were not suitable antigens for the in vitro detection of contact sensitivity.     

Dipetalonema viteae: in vitro blastogenesis of hamster spleen and lymph node cells to phytohemagglutinin and filarial antigens

Hamsters of the randomly bred LAKZ and inbred LSH strains were infected with Dipetalonema viteae, and the in vitro responses of lymph node and spleen lymphocytes to male and female worm antigens and phytohemagglutinin (PHA) were measured by a [³H]-thymidine-uptake assay at various times after infection. The PHA response remained unchanged at the level of controls in infected LAKZ hamsters while LSH hamsters showed a depressed response to the mitogen during late infection. Stimulation of lymph node cells by filarial antigens was maximal in both strains of hamsters at Week 4 postinfection, almost reaching values obtained in PHA stimulated cultures. A similar high lymphocyte transformation reaction was measured after the injection of dead third stage larvae. During transient microfilaremia, when antibody titers reached a maximal level, the lymphocyte reactivity to filarial antigens decreased drastically and only occasionally was demonstrated in hamsters 20 and 30 weeks after infection. No correlation between lymphocyte reactivity and parasitological findings (worm load or intensity and duration of microfilaremia) could be demonstrated. The cellular unresponsiveness to filarial antigens was further analyzed in chronically infected LAKZ hamsters. No suppressor cells could be found in lymphocyte suspensions of nonresponding hamsters. A challenge infection did not restore lymphocyte reactivity. Serum of chronically infected hamsters caused marked inhibition when added to filarial antigen-sensitive lymphocytes. Lymphocytes from hamsters with a mixed D. viteae and Schistosoma mansoni infection responded as well to soluble schistosomal egg antigens at Week 30 of a D. viteae infection as lymphocytes from hamsters infected with S. mansoni alone. The humoral immune response to schistosomal antigens, however, was significantly lower in animals with a mixed infection.     

Further studies of the selective inhibition by ouabain of antigen-induced proliferation of human lymphocytes

Cultures of human lymphocytes incubated for 48 hr in the presence of 2 × 10^?7M solutions of the cardiotonic steroid ouabain lose the proliferative response to antigens (SL-0, SK-SD) but can still proliferate when stimulated by nonspecific mitogens (PHA, Con A, pokeweed mitogen). The two-way mixed lymphocyte reaction was also irreversibly lost if cells of both donors were subjected to ouabain pretreatment. Neither cell counts nor cell viability (determined by dye exclusion) were significantly affected by the ouabain treatment. Pretreatment of a suspension of macrophages with the cardiac glycoside did not diminish their capacity to restore the proliferative response to antigen of macrophage-depleted lymphocyte suspensions; on the other hand, untreated macrophages could not restore the proliferative response of cultures of ouabain-pretreated lymphocytes. The ouabain treatment did not change the proportion of cells able to bind fluorescent anti-immunoglobulin nor did it modify the proportion of lymphocytes forming rosettes with either untreated, or antibody coated, red cells. Increased concentration of K⁺ in the medium, either during or after the ouabain treatment, did not reduce the ouabain effect. We conclude that the selective loss of certain lymphocyte functions caused by ouabain pretreatment was due to an effect on the lymphocyte and not on the macrophage; the effect was not due to the elimination of a relatively large fraction of the cells nor to a generalized disappearance of membrane antigens and receptors.     

Tolerization of Bepsilon cells by conjugates of haptens and isologous gamma-globulins

Fluorescence-activated cell sorter (FACS) analysis of B-lymphocyte surface isotype expression, and limiting dilution B-lymphocyte cloning techniques, have been used to establish characteristics of B lymphocytes from New Zealand Black (NZB) mice which might contribute to the predisposition of this strain to autoimmune disease. The NZB mice and two other strains (BALB/c and CBA) used were either specific pathogen free (SPF) or germ free (GF). The NZB B lymphocytes differed from the normal strains in the following respects: they showed considerably higher spontaneous conversion into antibody-forming cell clones in the absence of antigen or mitogen; substantially higher cloning efficiency at optimal antigen or mitogen concentration; a slightly lower antigen concentration optimum; and an abnormally high proportion of large cells among the s-IgM⁺, s-IgD^? lymphocyte subset. All these differences argue for a heightened excitability of the NZB B cell to triggering stimuli. Although there was a small-to-moderate increase in the proportion of s-IgM⁺, s-IgD^? b cells, the differences in μ:δ ratio were less than those previously reported. Finally, only a minor and barely significant resistance to tolerance induction in vitro was observed. The results suggest that the heightened B-cell excitability is only one factor in the etiology of autoimmune disease.     

Lymphocyte transformation in casein-induced murine amyloidosis.

Spleen lymphocytes from casein-induced amyloidotic mice demonstrate diminished transformation in vitro to PHA-P, concanavalin A, and pokeweed mitogen but a normal response to lipopolysaccharide. Thymic and peripheral blood lymphocytes respond normally to these mitogens. The amyloidogen casein acted as a mitogen in both normal and casein injected mice. The diminished PHA responsiveness of spleen lymphocytes in vitro could have resulted from an inhibitory effect of amyloid fibrils on lymphocyte proliferation and did not indicate a generalized diminished cellular immunologic responsiveness of amyloidotic mice.     

Biological characterization of T and B lymphocytes separated from normal mouse spleen by a physical adherence column method

The capacity of spleen cell populations enriched for T and B lymphocytes by a physical adherence column method to respond in vitro to phytomitogens and allogeneic lymphocytes was determined. Column filtrate cells (T lymphocytes) responded well to phytohaemagglutinin- and mitomycin-C-treated allogeneic spleen cells, but poorly to pokeweed mitogen. Adherent cell populations from the column (B and some T lymphocytes) responded well to pokeweed mitogen, but poorly to phytohaemagglutinin- and mitomycin-C-treated allogeneic cells.Purified peripheral T lymphocytes prepared from normal mouse spleen by the column method reconstituted the depleted in vitro antibody response to the thymic-dependent SRBC antigen of all B lymphocyte sources tested, namely, spleen cells from congenitally athymic mice, neonatally thymectomized mice, and adult thymectomized mice which had been reconstituted with bone marrow, and a lymphocyte population prepared by incubating spleen cells with anti-θ serum and complement. When transferred with sheep erythrocytes to congenitally athymic mice, purified peripheral T cells restored the in vivo IgM and IgG responses of these animals. These results confirm that the column filtrate is a thymus derived subpopulation of cells capable of cell-mediated immunity and cooperation with B lymphocytes in humoral immunity both in vitro and in vivo.     

NADH-cytochrome c reductase activity in cultured human lymphocytes: Similarity to the liver microsomal NADH-cytochrome b5 reductase and cytochrome b5 enzyme system

A NADH-cytochrome c reductase activity was increased upon mitogen stimulation of human lymphocytes. The activity was not inhibited by antimycin A or rotenone but was specifically inhibited by antibodies elicited against rat liver NADH-cytochrome b₅ reductase or cytochrome b₅. The activity was linear with cellular homogenates up to 5.2 × 10⁶ cells/ml and had abroad pH optimum of 7.7. The presence of 3-methylcholanthrene in mitogen stimulation media had no effect on the NADH-cytochrome c reductase activity but differentially induced the benzo(a)pyrene hydroxylase (AHH) activity. The reductase activity was present in nonstimulated cells and appears not to be significantly increased in activity per cell upon mitogen-stimulation of the peripheral lymphocyte.     

Cell-mediated immunity in experimental filariasis: lymphocyte reactivity to filarial stage-specific antigens and to B- and T-cell mitogens during acute and chronic infection.

To study immunological responses in chronic filarial infections, a model utilizing inbred Lewis rats infected with Brugia pahangi was developed. Microfilaria were found in the bloodstream of over 90% of the rats by 16 weeks of infection. Using in vitro lymphocyte blastogenesis, cell-mediated immune responses of blood, splenic, and mesenteric node lymphocytes were followed during 1.5 years of infection. Lymphocyte responses to antigen prepared from infective stage filarial larvae were detectable in the early weeks of infection, whereas responses to microfilarial antigen only developed late as microfilaremia waned. Lymphocyte responses to antigen from adult filaria vacillated during the infection. With the mitogens, phytohemagglutinin, pokeweed mitogen, and bacterial lipopolysaccharide, periods of B and T-cell hyporesponsiveness were demonstrable. Between 16 and 36 weeks of infection node lymphocytes from many rats were unresponsive to all mitogens and antigens. The model of B. pahangi in inbred rats offers advantages for immunological studies of filarial infections.     

Effect of cell-free murine liver extract on lymphocyte blastogenesis in vitro.

The effect of cell-free liver extract (LE) on the proliferation of spleen cells in vitro was examined using [³H]thymidine incorporation. LE inhibited the blastogenic response of murine lymphocytes stimulated with plant mitogens, phytohemagglutinin, and concanavalin A and in the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). Suppression of cell proliferation occurred whether the LE was syngeneic or allogeneic to the responding cells. This effect was observed only when LE was present in cultures, as preincubation of cells with LE did not impair their capacity to respond to stimulation. Profound suppression of proliferation was achieved with the addition of LE to the culture up to 48 hr after the onset of stimulation. However, the inhibitory effect was readily reversible upon removal of LE from the culture. Furthermore, although LE was capable of suppressing the generation of cytotoxic lymphocytes, LE did not interfere with their capacity for cytolysis. These findings indicate the presence of a potent inhibitor of lymphocyte proliferation in a cell-free extract of murine liver.     

In vitro analysis of immune responses of inbred guinea pigs infected in vivo with Leishmania enriettii and an investigation of active immunization of susceptible animals

Adherent skin cell monolayers have been prepared from the infected area of inbred guinea pigs inoculated with Leishmania enrietti. Cells from those animals most susceptible to disease (2/N) are less able to promote proliferation and the production of macrophage migration inhibition factor (MIF) from leishmania-immune lymphocytes than are infected cells taken from the more resistant 13/N or (2/N × 13/N)F₁ animals. Exposure of immune lymphocytes of all strains to parasite antigen in the relative absence of autologous antigen-presenting cells induced the development of a suppressor pool capable of inhibiting lymphocyte proliferation in response to immunogenic signals. Decreased lymphocyte proliferation during the course of disease may be caused by the endogenous release of products of arachidonic acid metabolism from host monocytes, though along with the decline in DTH reactivity in infected animals, and apparently in concert with the healing of the primary lesion, there occurs an increase in titer of antileishmania antibody in infected animals. Preliminary attempts to confer protection of naive animals by preimmunization with lymphocytes from previously infected, susceptible, or resistant guinea pigs suggested a role for interacting “helper” and suppressor lymphocyte pools in the immunoprotection from leishmania infection.     

Lymphocyte responses of rats vaccinated with cDNA encoding a phosphoglycerate kinase of Fasciola hepatica (FhPGK) and F. hepatica infection

Lymphocyte responses in the blood, peritoneal fluid and both mesenteric and hepatic lymph nodes of cDNA-FhPGK/pCMV vaccinated and/or Fasciola hepatica infected rats of both sexes were investigated to provide an insight into the immune responses that develop in different body compartments. The immune response that developed in cDNA-FhPGK/pCMV vaccinated females contributed to partial protection against F. hepatica infection (54% reduction in fluke recovery), while more liver flukes were found in the livers and bile ducts of cDNA-FhPGK/pCMV vaccinated male rats than in unvaccinated animals (increase of 13%). Rat sex not only affected the ultimate effectiveness of vaccination but also lymphocyte responses following vaccination and/or infection. Different CD4 + and CD8 + T cell profiles were noted in peritoneal fluid and lymph nodes, but not in blood, during acute and chronic fasciolosis. Moreover, independent lymphocyte responses developed in distinct body compartments. Immune responses of rats were polarized towards Th2/Treg with lymphocytes isolated from male rats showing higher IL-4 and IL-10 production than females. Lymphocyte proliferative capacities in response to mitogen (PHA) or vaccine antigen (FhPGK) were impaired in both sexes with a considerably higher reduction observed for males and restored lymphocyte proliferative capacities reported for females vaccinated with cDNA-FhPGK/pCMV during chronic fasciolosis.     

Measles virus-induced suppression of lymphocyte reactivity in vitro

Measles virus (Edmonston strain B), in various multiplicities of infection, was added to human lymphocytes which were cultured in medium containing fetal bovine serum. Live measles virus was found to cause an almost complete inhibition of [³H]-thymidine incorporation in lymphocytes cultured in the presence of phytohemagglutinin, pokeweed mitogen, tuberculin purified protein derivate (PPD), or allogeneic lymphocytes. Analysis of cell size in the lymphocyte cultures revealed that blast transformation was inhibited as well. Measles virus, inactivated by heat or ultraviolet irradiation, did not cause inhibition. The inhibitory effect of measles virus was only measurable in the initial stages of culture; when added later, i.e., 24 hr before measuring [³H]-thymidine incorporation, it had no effect. The diminished reactivity of measles virus-infected lymphocytes cannot be explained by cytopathologic effects or by altered kinetics of lymphocyte transformation. When lymphocytes were cultured at 39 °C the extent of virus-induced suppression was significantly reduced. Very small amounts of pooled normal human serum, as well as IgG, prepared from the serum of a patient with subacute sclerosing panencephalitis, were able to prevent the inhibitory effect of measles virus.     

Periodate-induced lymphocyte transformation. 3. Effects of temperature and pH

The optimum conditions for sodium periodate induced lymphocyte transformation occur at low concentrations of NaIO₄, low temperature, pH between 6 and 7.5, and with short periods of exposure to the NaIO₄. Exposures for prolonged times at elevated temperatures or to NaIO₄ at pH above 7.5 result in diminished responses. The finding of maximum lymphocyte response under these conditions is compatible with the proposal that the triggering event in NaIO₄ transformation of lymphocytes is the oxidation and cleavage of the two terminal carbon atoms of sialic acid. Exposure of lymphocytes to NaIO₄ under conditions of higher temperature, higher pH or longer exposure times does not significantly reduce their ability to respond to phytohemagglutinin (PHA) or pokeweed mitogen (PWM). This finding suggests that these mitogens have different target sites from that of NaIO₄ or that they are acting on different populations of lymphocytes.     

Serum of rabbits infected with Treponema pallidum (Nichols) inhibits in vitro transformation of normal rabbit lymphocytes.

Serum collected from outbred male New Zealand white rabbits infected intratesticularly with Treponema pallidum (Nichols) was assayed for ability to alter transformation of normal rabbit peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) in vitro. Sera collected from 25 infected rabbits inhibited [³H]thymidine incorporation by normal rabbit PBL stimulated with concanavalin A (Con A, 16μg/ml), relative to PBL cultured in normal rabbit serum (NRS). Maximal inhibitory activity was detected in serum collected at the time of peak orchitis. The degree of inhibition was related to the concentration of syphilitic serum in PBL cultures. Inhibition of Con A stimulation was reversed by increased mitogen concentration. Sera which depressed Con A stimulation also depressed lymphocyte transformation induced by oxidation with sodium m-periodate (NaIO₄). Cytotoxic activity was detected in occasional sera. All sera were heat inactivated at 56 °C for 30 min prior to testing. Both freshly collected sera and sera stored at ?70 °C significantly inhibited PBL transformation. These results suggested that serum of syphilitic rabbits contains one or more inhibitors of in vitro lymphocyte transformation.     

Experimental allergic encephalomyelitis and cellular immunity in the Lewis rat

The encephalitogenic difference between purified guinea pig and bovine myelin proteins in the Lewis rat is reflected by the two molecules' lack of crossreactivity in the migration inhibition test. Peritoneal exudate cells from rats injected with guinea pig or bovine derived myelin basic protein in Freund's complete adjuvant demonstrate substantial migration inhibition to the sensitizing antigen but little inhibition when cultured in the presence of the other basic protein. The cellular reactivity to guinea pig basic protein is present throughout the induction phase of Experimental Allergic Encephalomyelitis and persists after the recovery of the rats from the paralytic state. Substantial cellular reactivity is also demonstrated to bovine basic protein even though this molecule shows minimal encephalitogenic activity in the Lewis rat. Minimal lymphocyte transformation could be demonstrated to either of the basic proteins, although the immune cells react strongly to the plant mitogen phytohemagglutinin and to a Mycobacterium tuberculosis antigen.     

The immunological capacity of peripheral lymphocytes in a blast-transformation system using frozen-stored cells

Suspensions of isolated peripheral lymphocytes were frozen to ?95 °C using a programmed freezing apparatus and dimethyl sulphoxide as a cryoprotective agent. In comparisons among fresh cells, frozen cells, and cells stored in storage medium, freezing was found to be the best method of storage with retention of almost the same immunocapacity as fresh cells and with the same coefficients of variation for results after stimulation with phytohemagglutinin, pokeweed mitogen, concanavalin A, purified protein derivative, and allogenic cells in mixed lymphocyte cultures as was obtained with fresh cells. Blast transformation was found to be dependent on the number of cells in the cultures, the amount of [¹⁴C]thymidine added, and the amount of phytohemagglutinin used but independent of the amounts of pokeweed mitogen and concanavalin A. The maximum responses for normal lymphocytes and lymphocytes from uremic patients after stimulation with phytohemagglutinin occurred simultaneously, but after stimulation with allogenic cells maximum response was obtained earlier for “uremic” than for normal lymphocytes.It was concluded that frozen-stored lymphocytes are suitable for in vitro quantitative measurements of the cellular immune response in an immunological sequential study provided that the above mentioned factors are well defined.