Characterization of antigen-binding receptors in vitro. II. Antigen-binding capacity and affinity of lymphoid receptors after immunization.

We examined the kinetics and affinity of antigen binding in lymphoid populations in mice after immunization. There is increased binding capacity in lymphoid cells from animals that have undergone primary immunization. This increase would seem to be related to increased numbers of antigen-binding cells (rosette-forming cells). The serum antibody titers rise after the increasing binding capacity and numbers of BSA rosette-forming cells have increased. There is an increased amount of antigen bound per antigen-binding cell at certain times after immunization with two peaks in this capacity being demonstrable--one occurring at 4 days after immunization and the second occurring approximately 12 days after immunization and persisting for prolonged periods after that. With time, after immunization two separable peaks of increased antigen-binding cells become apparent, one very early (before Day 4) and one later (after Day 20 to 30). The affinity constants for antigen-binding cells have been measured and found to be high, and to increase with time after immunization. It appears that the heterogeneity of the affinity constants for antigen-binding cells is high early in immunity and becomes more homogeneous with time after immunization.     

Antigen-Specific Proliferative Response of Peritoneal Exudate Lymphocytes Primed with Antigen and Bacterial Lipopolysaccharide: The Roles of Ia+ Accessory Cells and IL-2

In vitro antigen-specific proliferation was investigated in a lymphocyte population that had been taken from the peritoneal exudate cells (PEC) of C3H/HeN mice (Ia^k) primed in vivo with both bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and horse red blood cells (HRBC) and had been purified by passage through a nylon fiber column (Nfc). The proliferative response of the Nfc-passed lymphocytes primed with HRBC and LPS [T(HRBC + LPS) cells] depended on the dose of antigen in the cultures, and the response was higher than that of cells prepared from mice primed with HRBC alone [T(HRBC) cells]. No response was seen in the cells prepared from the LPS-primed mice [T(LPS) cells] or normal mice [T(N) cells]. The response of the T(HRBC) cells was abolished by previous treatment of the cells with anti-Ia^k antibody and complement (C), whereas the response of the T(HRBC + LPS) cells was retained after the same treatment, indicating that the Ia^– T(HRBC + LPS) cells can proliferate in response to antigen in spite of Ia+ accessory cell-depletion. Supernatants from the cultures of Ia^– T(HRBC + LPS) cells in the presence of HRBC showed abundant IL-2 activity, while those of Ia^– T(HRBC) cells did not. The IL-2 should be produced by the L3T4 cell population in T(HRBC + LPS) cells in response to antigen, since the previous treatment of the cells with anti-L3T4 antibody and C abrogated the production. On the other hand, the Ia^– T(HRBC + LPS) cells as well as the Ia^– T(LPS) cells could respond to IL-2 dose-dependently when recombinant IL-2 was added into the cultures, but the response of Ia^– T(HRBC) cells to IL-2 was very weak. The cell population responding to IL-2 in the T(HRBC + LPS) cells as well as T(LPS) cells must be AsGM1-positive or natural killer (NK) cells, since previous treatment of the cells with anti-AsGM1 antibody and C abrogates the response. Together these results suggest that L3T4 lymphocytes capable of producing IL-2 in response to HRBC antigen without Ia⁺ accessory cells are generated in the PEC of the mice after priming with LPS and antigen together, and the IL-2 produced by the L3T4 lymphocytes induces the proliferation of the LPS-primed AsGM1+ cells.     

Immunomodulating therapy with myelopid in experimental Salmonella infection

The influence of myelopid on immunological characteristics in experimental Salmonella infection has been studied. This preparation has been found to produce a pronounced effect on the characteristics of immune response: it increases the number of T- and B-lymphocytes in the blood and the lymphoid organs. The indirect rosette-formation test has shown that myelopid facilitates earlier and more rapid binding and elimination of the antigen (S. typhimurium) from the body. Under the influence of myelopid the release of antigen-binding lymphocytes from the thymus to the peripheral lymphoid organs becomes more intensive.     

Antigenic markers on mouse lymphoid cells: origin of cells mediating immunologic memory

Specific antisera were used for the purification of thymus dependent and thymus independent or bursa equivalent lymphoid cells in the mouse. Spleen cells from mice immune to sheep erythrocytes, a thymus dependent antigen, or to E. coli 055:B5 lipopolysaccharide, a thymus independent antigen, were treated with anti-θ (C3H) serum or anti-MBLA serum and complement prior to their adoptive transfer into lethally irradiated syngeneic recipients. Syngeneic thymocytes, bone marrow cells, or spleen cells from nonimmune donors were appropriately added to antiserum treated cells prior to transfer. The secondary response to these antigens was assayed in recipient spleens six days after cell transfer. The kinetics of the primary response to SRBC was investigated as to its effect on origin of specific hyper-reactive T or B lymphoid cells.The adoptive response to CPS originated in the B lymphoid cell population. Immunologic memory to CPS was demonstrated in recipients of immune cells, compared to recipients of normal cells, by a five fold increase in antibody forming cells.The IgM and IgG adoptive immune response to high doses of SRBC depended upon an increased number of specifically hyper-reactive T-lymphoid cells to facilitate cooperation between T and B lymphocytes. High doses of SRBC initially stimulated T cell memory but at 42 days after priming an increased number of specifically hyper-reactive B lymphoid cells were present.     

Immune Response against Hamster Erythrocytes in the Low-Responder Mouse Strains

1) A subcutaneous injection of hamster erythrocytes (HRBC) in Freund's complete adjuvant (FCA) or an intravenous injection of hamster lymph node (HLN) cells suppressed antibody production against HRBC in the low-responder C57BL/6 and AKR mice, when HRBC in saline were given on the same day; 2) The suppressing effect of such treatments was neither detectable in the high-responder SL mice, nor in the C57BL/6 mice, which had been pre-sensitized with HRBC in FCA or hamster lymphoma cells; 3) Positive reactions of the peritoneal macrophage disappearance test and the enhanced antibody production were detected seven days after treatment with HRBC in FCA and HRBC in saline, or HLN cells and HRBC in saline; 4) The suppressing effect of such simultaneous treatments on anti-HRBC antibody production was eliminated by a transfer of normal syngeneic thymus cells to AKR mice or a transfer of thymus cells from SL to C57BL/6 mice. Suppression of the antibody production in the low-responder mice by the described simultaneous treatments may be due to a competitive involvement of HRBC-specific thymus-derived cells (T cells) in the developmental stages of delayed hypersensitivity and antibody production. High-responder SL mice appear to have enough T cells for development of the delayed hypersensitivity and as helper cells in antibody production. These results appear to support the concept that T cells for delayed hypersensitivity and antibody production to HRBC antigen are derived from the same original pool.     

Cellular cooperation in hapten-carrier responses in the newt, Triturus viridescens

Heterologous erythrocyte responses in the three hematopoietic organs, spleen, liver and kidney, were studied in the American Common Newt, Triturus (Diemictylus) viridescens. These responses were measured by immunocytoadherence. Horse (HRBC) and sheep (SRBC) red cells were used as immunogens. Background and response values to HRBC were consistent in all three organs. Activity levels and their kinetics were greater in spleen than in liver or kidney. Anti-SRBC activity levels proved to be too variable and as a consequence HRBC's were used in subsequent studies. Secondary responses in the newt showed modest increases in the spleen, a decrease in liver activity levels and a proportionately large (5×) increase within kidney. While splenectomy prior to immunization did not effect primary response activity in liver and kidney, it caused a three-fold enhancement of the usual loss of activity in secondary responses within liver. Kidney secondary response levels were unaffected by prior splenectomy. Spleen-liver lymphoid traffic may be involved in anamnestic responses in the newt.The main question had to do with whether one could demonstrate cellular cooperation in immune responses in so primitive a vertebrate. Chicken (CRBC) and toad (TRBC) red cells were used as carriers for the hapten trinitrophenol (TNP). Pre-immunization with the carrier immunogen led to the development of rosette forming cells (RFC) specific for the hapten in spleen, liver, and kidney after challenge with the TNP on the same carrier. Injection of the TNP carrier alone or pre-immunization with a different carrier caused no TNP-specific RFC's to be generated. The anti-TNP responses were assayed with HRBC and TNP-HRBC. Prior treatment with TNP-HSA (human serum albumin), before TNP-HRBC assay, blocked the RFC with TNP-HRBC and helped to establish the specificity of the hapten-specific RFC's. These kinds of immune responses in the newt require at least two cooperating cellular populations. Cellular cooperation may have been an early phylogenetic feature of immune responses.     

Synergy among rat T cells in the proliferative response to alloantigen.

A synergistic interaction in the proliferative response to alloantigen is described for mixtures of rat thymus and lymph node cells. The optimal conditions for synergy are quantitatively defined. Regression analysis of the slope of the dose-response curve has been utilized to estimate the degree of interaction in thymus-lymph node cell mixtures. The slope of the response of cell mixtures was noted to be significantly greater than the slope for the response of lymph node cells alone. Irradiation was shown to have a differential effect on the response of thymus and lymph node cells in mixtures. Irradiated thymus cells retained the capacity for synergy in mixtures, whereas irradiated lymph node cells did not. Additional studies have demonstrated that both de novo protein synthesis and specific antigen recognition by both responding cell populations in mixtures was required for maximal synergy. These studies demonstrate that synergy cannot be explained as an artifact of altered cell density in vitro. They establish that thymus cells and lymph node cells represent distinct subsets which manifest qualitatively different functions in the proliferative response to alloantigen. Thymus cells can respond directly to alloantigen by proliferation but also have the capacity to amplify the proliferative response of lymph node cells—a capacity which is resistant to X irradiation but requires recognition of alloantigen and de novo protein synthesis. Lymph node cells may similarly respond by proliferation to alloantigen but lack the amplifier activity of thymus cells. Synergy for rat lymphoid cells, like mouse lymphoid cells, has been shown to involve an interaction of thymus-derived lymphocytes.     

Fractionation of Specific Antigen-reactive Cells in an <Emphasis Type="Italic">in vitro</Emphasis> System of Cell-mediated Immunity

ACCORDING to present concepts the diversity of antibodies is determined by a similar diversity of the precursors of antibody-producing cells. The existence of a diversified cell population in the lymphoid organs was most directly demonstrated by specific adherence of antigen-reactive cells on antigen columns. Antigen-binding cells were specifically eliminated from lymphoid cell populations of both preimmunized^1,2 and non-immunized donors^3–5. The non-bound cells were incapable of producing antibody to the antigen applied on the column, yet they could produce antibody to non-related antigens. Plaque forming cell precursors, plaque forming cells and memory cells towards various antigens were separated^1–5. In all these cases the cells which specifically adhered to the antigenic column were most probably bone marrow-derived lymphocytes (B cells). On the other hand, no such specific adherence was achieved with thymus-derived lymphocytes (T cells), such as those involved in carrier recognition during immunization with hapten carrier conjugates⁶ and in cell-mediated immunity.     

Activation of antigen-enriched B cells. II. Role of linked recognition in B cell proliferation to thymus-dependent antigens

The responsiveness to T-dependent (TD) and T-independent (TI) TNP-antigens of murine splenic B cells previously enriched for antigen-binding cells (ABC) was examined. TNP-TI antigens induced B cell proliferation. TNP-TD antigens did not induce a proliferative response regardless of the physical form or nature of the TNP-TD antigen (e.g., soluble vs particulate, low or high haptenation of carrier, TNP on various insoluble matrices, etc.). TNP-TD antigens were effective in enhancing the response of the TNP-ABC to all concentrations of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) tested, indicating that binding of antigen to surface immunoglobulin alters the LPS responsiveness of the cell. Irradiated, keyhole limpet hemocyanin- (KLH) primed T cells induced a threefold to fourfold greater B cell proliferative response with TNP-KLH than with fluoresceinated KLH (FLU-KLH) or FLU-KLH together with TNP-human serum albumin (TNP-HSA). Therefore, linked recognition appears essential for optimal T cell-mediated B cell proliferation, whereas the induction of B cell proliferation via nonlinked, carrier-activated T cells is a minor component of the response.     

Antigen-specific and nonspecific mediators of T-cell/B-cell cooperation. VI. Distinct patterns of cross-reactivity by two human gamma-globulin-primed helper T-cell subpopulations.

We have previously characterized the activities, in vitro, of two different helper T-cell subpopulations, primed with human γ-globulin (HGG). One T-cell subpopulation helps the response of B cells to determinants (e.g., haptens) bound to the same antigen to which the T cells are primed (specific help); the other helper T-cell subpopulation responds to the same priming antigen by secreting a nonspecific molecule which helps B-cell responses to erythrocyte antigens co-cultured with the priming antigen (nonspecific help). These subpopulations also differ in their frequency and dose response to antigen, both in vivo and in vitro. They are similarly susceptible to the induction of unresponsiveness to HGG. In order to determine whether these T-cell subpopulations share or differ in their ranges of antigen recognition, we have compared the reaction of these two HGG-primed helper T-cell subpopulations to a number of γ-globulins (γG's) from other species. Plaque-forming cells generated in response to HGG shared little or no cross-reactivity with any of the heterologous (γG's) tested. In contrast, HGG-primed nonspecific helper T cells responded with significant cross-reactivity when challenged in vitro with dog γG, but HGG-primed specific helper T cells did not respond with any such cross-reactivity. No other heterologous γG tested stimulated any significant cross-reactivity from either HGG-primed T-cell subpopulation. Thus, these two T-cell subpopulations differ in their antigenic recognition. Possible explanations of these data include: (i) a difference in receptor specificity; (ii) a difference in the receptor affinity; (iii) a difference in Ia determinants of the two subpopulations.     

Toxoplasma gondii: a new diagnostic approach based on the specific binding of erythrocytes to lymphoid cells.

Red blood cells coated with toxoplasma antigen were bound to surface receptors, possibly of Ig nature, on lymphoid cells which appeared in the spleen of albino rats a few days after intraperitoneal injection of living T. gondii of the RH strain. Antigen-binding cells appeared before specific antibody, then declined in number, while the antibody response was progressing.Available information stresses the identity of antigen-binding cells with precursors of antibody-forming cells, thus pointing to the early occurrence of the immunocytoadherence phenomenon in the immune response. The applicability of these concepts to the field of human toxoplasmosis was proved by the demonstration of circulating lymphocytes specifically binding toxoplasma antigen early in the course of human toxoplasmic lymphadenitis and only in relation to active disease, thus providing an interesting approach to the early diagnosis and the detection of the active state of the disease.Possible clinical implications are discussed.     

Immune Response against Hamster Erythrocytes in the Low-Responder Mouse Strains

It was confirmed by passive transfer experiments that the function of thymus-derived cells specific for hamster erythrocytes (HRBC) was deficient in the low-responder mouse strains. 1) Antibody production against HRBC was enhanced by passive transfer of thymus cells from normal SL mice (high-responder) to normal C57BL/6 mice (low-responder). 2) The enhancing effect of passive transfer of thymus cells from SL mice was abrogated by pre-sensitization of the recipients (C57BL/6) with thymus cells from SL mice. 3) In C57BL/6 mice, antibody production against HRBC was enhanced by the transfer of lymph node or spleen cells from C57BL/6 mice which had been sensitized with HRBC in Freund's complete adjuvant or hamster lymphoma cells.     

The immune system of juvenile thick-lipped grey mullet, Chelon labrosus Risso: antibody responses to soluble protein antigens

Juvenile thick-lipped grey mullet, Chelon labrosus , believed to be about 6–7 months old, possessed well developed lymphoid organs including a clearly differentiated thymus with distinct cortical and medullary zones. However, unlike older fish, the juvenile mullet usually failed to produce antibody in response to a single injection of classical thymus-dependent antigen (using the soluble proteins human gamma globulin or keyhole limpet haemocyanin). Prior priming of the juvenile fish with antigen was found to potentiate antibody production following challenge with a second dose of the antigen in adjuvant, priming by oral administration being equally as effective as priming by injection. Neither juvenile nor adult mullet produced any significant level of antibody against ovalbumin.
The results suggest that, despite their apparently well differentiated lymphoid organs, juvenile mullet still show a certain level of immaturity in their antibody responses to soluble proteins; also that immunization can improve their ability to respond.     

Antigen-binding cells in central and peripheral lymphoid tissues of the rabbit

The rosette assay was used to study antigen-binding activity by cells in lymphoid tissues of rabbits immunized with sheep red blood cells and in unimmunized controls. Percentages of rosette-forming cells (RFC) observed were compared with those of cells which secreted antibody (plaque-forming cells, PFC) and cells which both bound antigen and secreted antibody. Rosette-forming cells and PFC were shown to be two distinct reactive cell populations. Thus, in the spleen less than 1% of RFC also formed plaques. Immediately following antigen stimulation, the number of RFC in the bone marrow decreased to below detectable limits. After an initial rise, the number of RFC in the appendix declined similarly. In contrast, RFC levels in the spleen rose steadily from the time of immunization. These patterns suggest that bone marrow and appendix may function as a reservoir of antigen-binding cells which are released to other sites following antigenic stimulation. Rosette-forming cells were rarely observed in the thymus. Rosette-inhibition studies using antisera specific for bone marrow-derived cells (anti-B) and thymus-derived cells (anti-T) revealed a markedly greater proportion of T-RFC in the appendix than in the spleen.     

Cyclic expression of low-dose paralysis

Prior treatment (priming) with a single injection of a subimmunogenic dose of Type III pneumococcal polysaccharide results in an antigen-specific T-cell-dependent form of unresponsiveness (low-dose paralysis) mediated by suppressor T cells. Although such unresponsiveness persists for several months after priming, it is expressed in a cyclic manner with a periodicity of about 3 days. This cyclic pattern is accompanied by concurrent periods of Velban sensitivity that also are cyclic. This suggests that the maintenance of low-dose paralysis in part requires some degree of cell proliferation which proceeds in an ordered manner in response to a "signal" generated after priming with antigen.     

Immunologic properties of mouse thymus cells: membrane antigen patterns associated with various cell subpopulations

The membrane antigen components of mouse thymus cells and fractions derived from BSA density gradient centrifugation were assayed by quantitative cytotoxicity tests. Two subpopulations were identified on the basis of average density and antigen patterns. The major subpopulation consisted of small lymphoid cells and comprised 80%–90% of all cells, was of high relative density and rich in θ, TL, G_IX, Ly-A, Ly-B, and Ly-C, but contained little or no H-2. The minor subpopulation was chiefly large lymphoid cells, comprised 10%–15% of cells, was of low relative density, was relatively rich in H-2 but low in θ and Ly antigens, and contained no detectable TL or G_IX. This minor subpopulation was identical in density and antigen patterns to those cells remaining in the thymus after short-term cortisone treatment or whole-body irradiation. It could also be reproduced by treating whole thymus with anti-TL or anti-θ sera. The antigenic attributes of this minor subpopulation differed from those of spleen lymphocytes only with respect to average density.     

Oral—parenteral immunization leads to the appearance of IgG auto-anti-idiotypic cells in mucosal tissues

The appearance of plasma cells, specific for antigen or autologous idiotypic antibody, in rabbits immunized systemically, orally, or orally-systemically was determined using immunofluorescence techniques. Oral or parenteral immunizations alone did not lead to the appearance of anti-idiotypic cells in mucosal tissues, although IgA antigen-binding cells were observed in these sites after the oral administration of antigen. However, when rabbits were primed with orally administered antigen, followed by a regimen of concurrent oral—parenteral immunizations, IgG anti-idiotypic plasma cells were demonstrated in mucosal lymphoid tissues.     

Oligocellular mechanism in the production of antibodies: in vitro response to a haptenic determinant

Spleen explants from mice tolerant to rabbit serum albumin (RSA) failed to react in vitro to dinitrophenyl (DNP)-RSA; antibodies to DNP were, however, produced by such spleens, when stimulated with α-DNP-poly(Lys). To study the function of T and B cells in recognition of carrier determinants, spleen explants from X-irradiated mice, which had been inoculated with combinations of thymus and bone marrow cells from normal and from RSA tolerant donors, were tested for their reactivity in vitro to the DNP-RSA conjugate. A significant response was obtained only by spleens of mice containing bone marrow and thymus from normal donors. Spleens of mice treated with thymus from tolerant and bone marrow from normal or with thymus from normal and bone marrow from tolerant donors did not respond to DNP-RSA. The absence of the response to DNP-RSA by tolerant B cells combined with normal T cells was unexpected. It could not be attributed to binding of the tolerogen to B cells which would have prevented the interaction with T-cells. Neither could the result be attributed to an inhibition of normal cells by RSA-tolerant B-cells. θ-positive cells in the bone marrow are not the cells controlling the recognition of carrier determinants in the B population, since elimination of θ-positive cells did not affect the reactivity of spleens repopulated with B and T cells. Nor are bone marrow macrophages responsible for the lack of reactivity in spleens containing tolerant B cells, since normal macrophages did not restore reactivity. Hence, the production of antibodies to DNP is based on the recognition of carrier determinants not only by T cells, as previously established, but also by B cells. Whether this indicates a B-B in addition to the T-B cell cooperation is an inviting possibility.     

The in vitro induction of T cells which mediate delayed-type hypersensitivity toward horse red blood cells.

Humoral and cell-mediated immunity to the antigen horse red blood cells (HRBC) were induced in vitro. The type of immune response induced, however, was dependent on the concentration of antigen present in the culture. Whereas intermediate concentrations of HRBC induced antibody-forming cells, high and low concentrations of HRBC induced T cells which, on transfer, mediated delayed-type hypersensitivity reactions. The inverse relationship between humoral and cell-mediated immunity often observed in vivo is, therefore, also evident when lymphocytes are stimulated with antigen in vitro.     

Recognition of xenogeneic erythrocytes: the GalNAc/Gal-particle receptor of rat liver macrophages mediates or participates in recognition

We studied mechanisms that mediate recognition of human erythrocytes (HRBC) and sheep erythrocytes (SRBC) by rat liver macrophages. We used an in vitro cell binding assay that allows spontaneous formation of cell contacts. Binding of HRBC to rat macrophages shows the following characteristics: inhibition studies with several monosaccharides and oligosaccharides yield complete inhibition of cell contacts with saccharides, which block the GalNAc/Gal-particle receptor on rat liver macrophages. We found the inhibition pattern: N-acetyl-D-galactosamine, lactose greater than D-galactose, D-fucose greater than L-fucose much greater than N-acetyl-D-glucosamine. Cell binding is dependent on the presence of calcium ions, but not influenced by heat-aggregated IgG or gangliosides. The inhibition pattern was the same after treatment of HRBC with neuraminidase. Therefore, binding of HRBC, as well as binding of neuraminidase-treated HRBC, is mediated by the GalNAc/Gal-particle receptor. Binding of SRBC is partly inhibited by galactose-related saccharides. Binding is also partly inhibited by heat-aggregated IgG, gangliosides, and L-fucose. Complete inhibition of cell contacts with SRBC is achieved by combination of all inhibitors. We therefore conclude that binding of SRBC is mediated by several different mechanisms, including the GalNAc/Gal-particle receptor. Binding of neuraminidase-treated SRBC, however, was found to be completely inhibited by saccharides, which block the GalNAc/Gal-particle receptor. We conclude that the GalNAc/Gal-particle receptor mediates or participates in recognition of non-self structures.