Cholesterol domains in biological membranes

Membrane cholesterol is distributed asymmetrically both within the cell or within cellular membranes. Elaboration of intracellular cholesterol trafficking, targeting and intramembrane distribution has been spurred by both molecular and structural approaches. The expression of recombinant sterol carrier proteins in L-cell fibroblasts has been especially useful in demonstrating for the first time that such proteins actually elicit intracellular and intra-plasma membrane redistribution of sterol. Additional advances in the use of native fluorescent sterols allowed resolution of transbilayer and lateral cholesterol domains in plasma membranes from cultured fibroblasts, brain synaptosomes and erythrocytes. In all three cell surface membranes, cholesterol is enriched in the inner, cytofacial leaflet. Up to three different cholesterol domains have been identified in the lateral plane of the plasma membrane: a fast exchanging domain comprising less than 10% of cholesterol, a slowly exchanging domain comprising about 30% of cholesterol, and a very slowly or non-exchangeable sterol domain comprising 50–60.

Of plasma membrane cholesterol. Factors modulating plasma membrane cholesterol domains include polyunsaturated fatty acids, expression of intracellular sterol carrier proteins, drugs such as ethanol, and several membrane pathologies (systemic lupus erythematosus, sickle cell anaemia and aging). Disturbances in plasma membrane cholesterol domains after transbilayer fluidity gradients in plasma membranes. Such changes are associated with decreased Ca²⁺ -ATPase and Na ⁺, K⁺ -ATPase activity. Thus, the size, dynamics and distribution of cholesterol domains within membranes not only regulate cholesterol efflux/influx but also modulate plasma membrane protein functions and receptor-effector coupled systems.     

Direct evidence for cholesterol crystalline domains in biological membranes: role in human pathobiology

This review will discuss the use of small-angle X-ray diffraction approaches to study the organization of lipids in plasma membranes derived from two distinct mammalian cell types: arterial smooth muscle cells and ocular lens fiber cells. These studies indicate that cholesterol at an elevated concentration can self-associate and form immiscible domains in the plasma membrane, a phenomenon that contributes to both physiologic and pathologic cellular processes, depending on tissue source. In plasma membrane samples isolated from atherosclerotic smooth muscle cells, the formation of sterol-rich domains is associated with loss of normal cell function, including ion transport activity and control of cell replication. Analysis of meridional diffraction patterns from intact and reconstituted plasma membrane samples indicates the presence of an immiscible cholesterol domain with a unit cell periodicity of 34 A, consistent with a cholesterol monohydrate tail-to-tail bilayer, under disease conditions. These cholesterol domains were observed in smooth muscle cells enriched with cholesterol in vitro as well as from cells obtained ex vivo from an animal model of atherosclerosis. By contrast, well-defined cholesterol domains appear to be essential to the normal physiology of fiber cell plasma membranes of the human ocular lens. The organization of cholesterol into separate domains underlies the role of lens fiber cell plasma membranes in maintaining lens transparency. These domains may also interfere with cataractogenic aggregation of soluble lens proteins at the membrane surface. Taken together, these analyses provide examples of both physiologic and pathologic roles that sterol-rich domains may have in mammalian plasma membranes. These findings support a model of the membrane in which cholesterol aggregates into structurally distinct regions that regulate the function of the cell membrane.     

Partitioning of lipidated peptide sequences into liquid-ordered lipid domains in model and biological membranes.

We have used a fluorescence assay and detergent fractionation to examine the partitioning of different fluorescent lipidated peptides, with sequences and lipid substituents matching those found in various classes of lipidated cellular proteins, into liquid-ordered (raft-like) domains in lipid bilayers. Peptides incorporating isoprenyl groups, or multiple unsaturated acyl chains, show negligible affinity for liquid-ordered domains in mixed-phase liquid-ordered/liquid-disordered (l(o)/l(d)) bilayers composed of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine, a spin-labeled unsaturated phosphatidylcholine, and cholesterol. By contrast, peptides incorporating multiple S- and/or N-acyl chains, or a cholesterol residue plus an N-terminal palmitoyl chain, show significant partitioning into liquid-ordered domains under the same conditions. Interestingly, the affinity of a lipidated peptide for l(o) domains can be strongly influenced, not only by the structures of the lipid substituents but also by the nature and the positions of their attachment to the peptide chain. These results are well correlated with those obtained from parallel assays based on low-temperature detergent fractionation. Using the latter approach, we further demonstrate that a truly minimal l(o) domain partitioning motif [myristoylGlyCys(palmitoyl)-] can mediate efficient incorporation into the "raft" fraction of COS-7 cell membranes.     

Domains in biological membranes

Our current view on biological membranes has gradually evolved from the influential fluid mosaic model of the early 1970s to a distinctively more complex picture. Biological membranes are now assumed to encompass multiple membrane domains and a plethora of protein-lipid and protein-protein interactions that compartmentalize and temporarily order what has originally been envisioned to be mostly random. In this minireview, we will first highlight some structural principles that govern membrane domain formation and permit a classification of membrane domains. We will then focus on the still controversial issue of lipid-based membrane domains, or lipid rafts, and discuss recent advances in detecting these enigmatic structures in living cells. Finally we will evaluate biochemical approaches to characterize lipid rafts and discuss their contribution to the emerging topic of lipid raft diversity     

Micrometer-scale domains in fibroblast plasma membranes

We have used the technique of fluorescence photobleaching recovery to measure the lateral diffusion coefficients and the mobile fractions of a fluorescent lipid probe, 1-acyl-2-(12-[(7-nitro-2-1, 3-benzoxadiazol-4-yl)aminododecanoyl]) phosphatidylcholine (NBD-PC), and of labeled membrane proteins of human fibroblasts. Values for mobile fractions decrease monotonically with increasing size of the laser spot used for the measurements, over a range of 0.35-5.0 microns. Values for NBD-PC diffusion coefficients increase in part of this range to reach a plateau at larger laser spots. This variation is not an artifact of the measuring system, since the effects are not seen if diffusion of the probe is measured in liposomes. We also find that the distribution of diffusion coefficients measured with small laser spots is heterogeneous indicating that these small spots can sample different regions of the membrane. These regions appear to differ in protein concentration. Our data strongly indicate that fibroblast surface membranes consist of protein-rich domains approximately 1 micron in diameter, embedded in a relatively protein-poor lipid continuum. These features appear in photographs of labeled cell surfaces illuminated by the expanded laser beam.     

Cardiolipin domains in Bacillus subtilis marburg membranes

Recently, use of the cardiolipin (CL)-specific fluorescent dye 10-N-nonyl-acridine orange (NAO) revealed CL-rich domains in the Escherichia coli membrane (E. Mileykovskaya and W. Dowhan, J. Bacteriol. 182: 1172-1175, 2000). Staining of Bacillus subtilis cells with NAO showed that there were green fluorescence domains in the septal regions and at the poles. These fluorescence domains were scarcely detectable in exponentially growing cells of the clsA-disrupted mutant lacking detectable CL. In sporulating cells with a wild-type lipid composition, fluorescence domains were observed in the polar septa and on the engulfment and forespore membranes. Both in the clsA-disrupted mutant and in a mutant with disruptions in all three of the paralogous genes (clsA, ywjE, and ywiE) for CL synthase, these domains did not vanish but appeared later, after sporulation initiation. A red shift in the fluorescence due to stacking of two dye molecules and the lipid composition suggested that a small amount of CL was present in sporulating cells of the mutants. Mass spectrometry analyses revealed the presence of CL in these mutant cells. At a later stage during sporulation of the mutants the frequency of heat-resistant cells that could form colonies after heat treatment was lower. The frequency of sporulation of these cells at 24 h after sporulation initiation was 30 to 50% of the frequency of the wild type. These results indicate that CL-rich domains are present in the polar septal membrane and in the engulfment and forespore membranes during the sporulation phase even in a B. subtilis mutant with disruptions in all three paralogous genes, as well as in the membranes of the medial septa and at the poles during the exponential growth phase of wild-type cells. The results further suggest that the CL-rich domains in the polar septal membrane and engulfment and forespore membranes are involved in sporulation.     

Effect of anti-tumor ether lipids on ordered domains in model membranes

1-O-octadecyl-2-O-methyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (OMPC, edelfosine) and 1-hexadecylphosphocholine (HePC, miltefosine) represent two groups of synthetic ether lipid analogues with anti-tumor activity. Because of their hydrophobic nature, they may become incorporated into plasma membranes of cells, and it has been argued that they may act via association with lipid rafts. With the quenching of steady-state fluorescence of probes preferentially partitioning into sterol-rich ordered domains (cholestatrienol and trans-parinaric acid), we showed that OMPC and HePC by themselves did not form sterol-rich domains in fluid model membranes, in contrast to the two chain ether lipid 1,2-O-dihexadecyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine. Nevertheless, all three ether lipids significantly stabilized palmitoyl-sphingomyelin/cholesterol-rich domains against temperature induced melting. In conclusion, this study shows that anti-tumor ether lipids are likely to affect the properties of cholesterol-sphingomyelin domains (i.e., lipid rafts) when incorporated into cell membranes.     

Taming membranes: functional immobilization of biological membranes in hydrogels

Single molecule studies on membrane proteins embedded in their native environment are hampered by the intrinsic difficulty of immobilizing elastic and sensitive biological membranes without interfering with protein activity. Here, we present hydrogels composed of nano-scaled fibers as a generally applicable tool to immobilize biological membrane vesicles of various size and lipid composition. Importantly, membrane proteins immobilized in the hydrogel as well as soluble proteins are fully active. The triggered opening of the mechanosensitive channel of large conductance (MscL) reconstituted in giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) was followed in time on single GUVs. Thus, kinetic studies of vectorial transport processes across biological membranes can be assessed on single, hydrogel immobilized, GUVs. Furthermore, protein translocation activity by the membrane embedded protein conducting channel of bacteria, SecYEG, in association with the soluble motor protein SecA was quantitatively assessed in bulk and at the single vesicle level in the hydrogel. This technique provides a new way to investigate membrane proteins in their native environment at the single molecule level by means of fluorescence microscopy.     

Caveolin scaffolding region and cholesterol-rich domains in membranes

A protein that constitutes a good marker for a type of cholesterol-rich domain in biological membranes is caveolin. A segment of this protein has a sequence that corresponds to a cholesterol recognition/interaction amino acid consensus (CRAC) motif; this motif has been suggested to cause the incorporation of proteins into cholesterol-rich domains. We have studied the interaction of two peptides containing the CRAC motif of caveolin-1 by differential scanning calorimetry, fluorescence, circular dichroism and magic angle spinning NMR. These peptides promote the segregation of cholesterol into domains from mixtures of the sterol with phosphatidylcholine, as shown by depletion of cholesterol from a portion of the membrane and enrichment of cholesterol in another domain. Cholesterol passes its solubility limit in the cholesterol-rich domain, resulting in the formation of cholesterol crystallites, suggesting that not all of the cholesterol recruited to this domain is bound to the peptide. NMR studies show that the peptides insert somewhat more deeply into membranes when cholesterol is present, but their strongest interaction takes place with the interfacial region of the membrane. We conclude that the peptides we studied containing CRAC sequences are more effective in promoting the formation of cholesterol-rich domains than are shorter peptides of this region of caveolin, which although they contain several aromatic amino acids, they have no CRAC motif. The presence or absence of a CRAC motif, however, is not a sufficient criterion to determine the extent to which a protein will promote the segregation of cholesterol in membranes.     

Sphingomyelin-cholesterol domains in phospholipid membranes: atomistic simulation

We have carried out an atomic-level molecular dynamics simulation of a system of nanoscopic size containing a domain of 18:0 sphingomyelin and cholesterol embedded in a fully hydrated dioleylposphatidylcholine (DOPC) bilayer. To analyze the interaction between the domain and the surrounding phospholipid, we calculate order parameters and area per molecule as a function of molecule type and proximity to the domain. We propose an algorithm based on Voronoi tessellation for the calculation of the area per molecule of various constituents in this ternary mixture. The calculated areas per sphingomyelin and cholesterol are in agreement with previous simulations. The simulation reveals that the presence of the liquid-ordered domain changes the packing properties of DOPC bilayer at a distance as large as approximately 8 nm. We calculate electron density profiles and also calculate the difference in the thickness between the domain and the surrounding DOPC bilayer. The calculated difference in thickness is consistent with data obtained in atomic force microscopy experiments.     

Stable and unstable lipid domains in ceramide-containing membranes

We applied x-ray diffraction, calorimetry, and infrared spectroscopy to lipid mixtures of palmitoyl-oleoyl phosphatidylcholine, sphingomyelin, and ceramide. This combination of experimental techniques allowed us to probe the stability and structural properties of coexisting lipid domains without resorting to any molecular probes. In particular, we found unstable microscopic domains (compositional/phase fluctuations) in the absence of ceramide, and macroscopically separated fluid and gel phases upon addition of ceramide. We also observed phase fluctuations in the presence of ceramide within the broad phase transition regions. We compare our results with fluorescence spectroscopy data and complement the previously reported phase diagram. We also obtained electron paramagnetic resonance data to assess the possible limitations of techniques employing a single label. Our study demonstrates the necessity of applying a combination of experimental techniques to probe local/global structural and fast/slow motional properties in complex lipid mixtures.     

Regional influences on the physical properties of T cell membranes

Differences in the composition of membrane lipids are well documented between cells from distinct tissues. These differences may be manifested by changes in the motional freedom or fluidity of lipid molecules within plasma membranes and may predispose to alterations in cellular function. Regional influences on immune function have been implied by the finding that thymic-derived cells from murine spleen and lymph nodes are differentially responsive to antigen priming. The possibility that microenvironment also shapes the physical properties of T lymphocyte membranes has not been explored and is the focus of this study. Using mice as the experimental model, differences were found in fluidity and in the resting level of intracellular free-ionized Ca2+ between splenic and lymph node T cells from immunologically normal mice and from autoimmune-prone MRL-lpr/lpr mice. The results indicate that T cells are more heterogeneous than previously recognized and suggest a potential role for microenvironment in determining immune responsiveness.     

The organization of biological membranes

A nomenclature for the organization of biological membranes is proposed. The terms primary (composition), secondary (transverse and lateral distribution), tertiary (membrane stacking/unstacking), and quaternary (membrane-membrane, cell-cell interactions) levels of organization are used by analogy with protein structure, but at each level the membrane organization is more complex and dynamic than protein structure.     

Lateral organization of biological membranes

The lateral organization of biological membranes is of great importance in many biological processes, both for the formation of specific structures such as super-complexes and for function as observed in signal transduction systems. Over the last years, AFM studies, particularly of bacterial photosynthetic membranes, have revealed that certain proteins are able to segregate into functional domains with a specific organization. Furthermore, the extended non-random nature of the organization has been suggested to be important for the energy and redox transport properties of these specialized membranes. In the work reported here, using a coarse-grained Monte Carlo approach, we have investigated the nature of interaction potentials able to drive the formation and segregation of specialized membrane domains from the rest of the membrane and furthermore how the internal organization of the segregated domains can be modulated by the interaction potentials. These simulations show that long-range interactions are necessary to allow formation of membrane domains of realistic structure. We suggest that such possibly non-specific interactions may be of great importance in the lateral organization of biological membranes in general and in photosynthetic systems in particular. Finally, we consider the possible molecular origins of such interactions and suggest a fundamental role for lipid-mediated interactions in driving the formation of specialized photosynthetic membrane domains. We call these lipid-mediated interactions a ‘lipophobic effect.’