Segregation of type I collagen homo- and heterotrimers in fibrils

Normal type I collagen is a heterotrimer of two α1(I) and one α2(I) chains, but various genetic and environmental factors result in synthesis of homotrimers that consist of three α1(I) chains. The homotrimers completely replace the heterotrimers only in rare recessive disorders. In the general population, they may compose just a small fraction of type I collagen. Nevertheless, they may play a significant role in pathology; for example, synthesis of 10-15% homotrimers due to a polymorphism in the α1(I) gene may contribute to osteoporosis. Homotrimer triple helices have different stability and less efficient fibrillogenesis than heterotrimers. Their fibrils have different mechanical properties. However, very little is known about their molecular interactions and fibrillogenesis in mixtures with normal heterotrimers. Here we studied the kinetics and thermodynamics of fibril formation in such mixtures by combining traditional approaches with 3D confocal imaging of fibrils, in which homo- and heterotrimers were labeled with different fluorescent colors. In a mixture, following a temperature jump from 4 to 32 °C, we observed a rapid increase in turbidity most likely caused by formation of homotrimer aggregates. The aggregates promoted nucleation of homotrimer fibrils that served as seeds for mixed and heterotrimer fibrils. The separation of colors in confocal images indicated segregation of homo- and heterotrimers at a subfibrillar level throughout the process. The fibril color patterns continued to change slowly after the fibrillogenesis appeared to be complete, due to dissociation and reassociation of the pepsin-treated homo- and heterotrimers, but this remixing did not significantly reduce the segregation even after several days. Independent homo- and heterotrimer solubility measurements in mixtures confirmed that the subfibrillar segregation was an equilibrium property of intermolecular interactions and not just a kinetic phenomenon. We argue that the subfibrillar segregation may exacerbate effects of a small fraction of α1(I) homotrimers on formation, properties, and remodeling of collagen fibers.     

Changes in thermal stability and microunfolding pattern of collagen helix resulting from the loss of alpha2(I) chain in osteogenesis imperfecta murine

Homozygous mutations resulting in formation of alpha1(I)(3) homotrimers instead of normal type I collagen cause mild to severe osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) in humans and mice. Limited studies of changes in thermal stability of type I homotrimers were reported previously, but the results were not fully consistent. We revisited this question in more detail using purified tendon collagen from wild-type (alpha1(I)(2)alpha2(I) heterotrimers) and oim (alpha1(I)(3)) mice as well as artificial alpha1(I)(3) homotrimers obtained by refolding of rat-tail-tendon collagen. We found that at the same heating rate oim homotrimers completely denature at approximately 2.5deg.C higher temperature than wild-type heterotrimers, as determined by differential scanning calorimetry. At the same, constant temperature, homotrimers denature approximately 100 times slower than heterotrimers, as determined by circular dichroism. Detailed analysis of proteolytic cleavage at different temperatures revealed that microunfolding of oim homotrimers and wild-type heterotrimers occurs at similar rate but within a number of different sites. In particular, the weakest spot on the oim triple helix is located approximately 100 amino acid residues from the C-terminal end within the cyanogen bromide peptide CB6. The same microunfolding site is also present in wild-type collagen, but the weakest spot of the latter is located close to the N-terminal end of CB8. Amino acid analysis and differential gel electrophoresis showed virtually no posttranslational overmodification of oim mouse tendon collagen. Moreover, thermal stability and microunfolding of artificial rat-tail-tendon homotrimers were similar to oim homotrimers. Thus, the observed changes are associated with difference in the amino acid composition of alpha1(I) and alpha2(I) chains rather than posttranslational overmodification.     

Deletion of the pro-alpha 1(I) N-propeptide affects secretion of type I collagen in Chinese hamster lung cells but not in Mov-13 mouse cells.

We have introduced two mutations into a full-length human pro-alpha 1(I) cDNA that delete 114 amino acids or the entire 139 amino acids of the N-propeptide domain. Wild-type and mutated versions of the cDNA were introduced into cultured Chinese hamster lung (CHL) cells, which do not produce endogenous type I collagen, and into Mov-13 mouse cells, which produce endogenous pro-alpha 2(I) chains but not pro-alpha 1(I) chains. As judged by resistance to proteases, neither mutation impaired intracellular triple helical assembly of human alpha 1(I) homotrimers in CHL cells, or of chimeric type I collagen comprised of human alpha 1(I) and mouse alpha 2(I) chains in Mov-13 cells. Thus, the N-propeptide is not necessary for intracellular assembly of the main helical collagen domain of type I collagen. In CHL cells the rate of secretion of the mutant homotrimers was greatly reduced as compared to wild type homotrimers, and by immunofluorescence and immunoelectron microscopy, the mutant chains were shown to be accumulated in large vesicular expansions of the rough endoplasmic reticulum. When such cells were retransfected with cDNA encoding wild-type human alpha 2(I) chains, mutant alpha 1(I) chains were not rescued and heterotrimers containing the mutant chains were also retained in the intracellular vesicles. By contrast, deletion of the N-propeptide did not affect secretion of heterotrimers containing mutant chains from Mov-13 cells. Thus, an intact N-propeptide appears necessary for efficient secretion of type I collagen from some but not all cell types.     

Characterization of recombinant human type IX collagen. Association of alpha chains into homotrimeric and heterotrimeric molecules.

As type IX collagen is a minor cartilage component, it is difficult to purify sufficient amounts of it from tissues or cultured cells to study its structure and function. Also, the conventional pepsin digestion used for fibrillar collagens cannot be utilized for purifying type IX collagen, because it contains several interruptions in its collagenous triple helix. A baculovirus expression system was used here to produce recombinant human type IX collagen by coinfecting insect cells with three viruses containing full-length cDNAs for the alpha1(IX), alpha2(IX), and alpha3(IX) collagen chains together with a double promoter virus for the alpha and beta subunits of human prolyl 4-hydroxylase. Correctly folded recombinant type IX collagen was secreted, consisting of the three alpha chains in a 1:1:1 ratio and showing the expected biphasic thermal melting profile. When the individual alpha chains were expressed, disulfide-bonded homotrimers and homodimers of the alpha chains were observed. When the cells were coinfected with the viruses for all three alpha chains, heterotrimers of alpha1(IX), alpha2(IX), and alpha3(IX) were detected in cell culture medium, and the other possible combinations were less prominent. When any two of the alpha chains were co-expressed, in addition to the homodimers and homotrimers, only alpha1(IX) and alpha3(IX) chains were disulfide-bonded. The results thus suggest that the most favored molecular species is an alpha1(IX)alpha2(IX)alpha3(IX) heterotrimer, but the chains are also able to form disulfide-bonded heterotrimers of alpha1(IX) and alpha3(IX) chains and (alpha1(IX))(3), (alpha2(IX))(3), and (alpha3(IX))(3) homotrimers.     

Stable expression of chicken type-VI collagen alpha 1, alpha 2 and alpha 3 cDNAs in murine NIH/3T3 cells.

As a component of an extensive network of microfibrils interwoven with large collagen fibers and in close contact with cell surfaces, type VI collagen plays an important role in cell-matrix interactions. To investigate the behaviour of chicken type VI collagen chains in heterologous host cells as a means to understanding the pattern of assembly of this collagen, we transfected murine NIH/3T3 cells with cDNAs encoding chicken alpha 1(VI), alpha 2(VI) and alpha 3(VI) chains. Cell lines that constitutively expressed the individual chains were analyzed by metabolic labeling and immunoprecipitation with specific antibodies. No self-association was observed for either alpha 1(VI) or alpha 2(VI) chains which were secreted as monomeric polypeptides. Furthermore, neither the chicken alpha 1(VI) nor alpha 2(VI) chains associated with the endogenous murine chains to form chimeric chicken/murine heterotrimers. In contrast, chimeric chicken/murine heterotrimers were detected in cell lines transfected with chicken alpha 3(VI) cDNA. These chimeric forms appeared to be properly aligned since their triple helices were stable to pepsin digestion. In addition, the chimeric heterotrimers coassembled and gave rise to disulfide-linked type VI collagen molecules.     

Assembly of stable human type I and III collagen molecules from hydroxylated recombinant chains in the yeast Pichia pastoris. Effect of an engineered C-terminal oligomerization domain foldon

The C-propeptides of the pro alpha chains of type I and type III procollagens are believed to be essential for correct chain recognition and chain assembly in these molecules. We studied here whether the 30-kDa C-propeptides of the human pC alpha 1(I), pC alpha 2(I), and pC alpha 1(III) chains, i.e. pro alpha chains lacking their N-propeptides, can be replaced by foldon, a 29-amino acid sequence normally located at the C terminus of the polypeptide chains in the bacteriophage T4 fibritin. The alpha foldon chains were expressed in Pichia pastoris cells that also expressed the two types of subunit of human prolyl 4-hydroxylase; the foldon domain was subsequently removed by pepsin treatment, which also digests non-triple helical collagen chains, whereas triple helical collagen molecules are resistant to it. The foldon domain was found to be very effective in chain assembly, as expression of the alpha 1(I)foldon or alpha 1(III)foldon chains gave about 2.5-3-fold the amount of pepsin-resistant type I or type III collagen homotrimers relative to those obtained using the authentic C-propeptides. In contrast, expression of chains with no oligomerization domain led to very low levels of pepsin-resistant molecules. Expression of alpha 2(I)foldon chains gave no pepsin-resistant molecules at all, indicating that in addition to control at the level of the C-propeptide other restrictions at the level of the collagen domain exist that prevent the formation of stable [alpha 2(I)]3 molecules. Co-expression of alpha 1(I)foldon and alpha 2(I)foldon chains led to an efficient assembly of heterotrimeric molecules, their amounts being about 2-fold those obtained with the authentic C-propeptides and the alpha 1(I) to alpha 2(I) ratio being 1.91 +/- 0.31 (S.D.). As the foldon sequence contains no information for chain recognition, our data indicate that chain assembly is influenced not only by the C-terminal oligomerization domain but also by determinants present in the alpha chain domains.     

Jellyfish mesogloea collagen. Characterization of molecules as alpha 1 alpha 2 alpha 3 heterotrimers

The mesogloea collagen of a primitive animal, the jellyfish Stomolophus nomurai, belonging to the class Scyphozoa in the Coelenterata, was studied with respect to its chain structure. Most of the mesogloea collagen was solubilized by limited digestion with pepsin and isolated by selective precipitation at 0.9 m NaCl in 0.5 M acetic acid. Upon denaturation, the pepsin-solubilized collagen produced three distinct alpha chains, alpha 1, alpha 2, and alpha 3, in comparable amounts which were separable by CM-cellulose chromatography. The nonidentity of these alpha chains was confirmed by amino acid and carbohydrate analyses and peptide mapping. Furthermore, the introduction of intramolecular cross-links into native molecules by formaldehyde yielded a large proportion of gamma 123 chain with chain structure alpha 1 alpha 2 alpha 3, as judged by chromatographic behavior and peptide maps. We concluded that mesogloea collagen is comprised of alpha 1 alpha 2 alpha 3 heterotrimers and is chemically like vertebrate Type V collagen. On the other hand, sea anemone mesogloea collagen from the class Anthozoa was previously reported to comprise (alpha)3 homotrimers (Katzman, R. L., and Kang, A. H. (1972) J. Biol. Chem. 247, 5486-5489). On the basis of these findings, we assume that alpha 1 alpha 2 alpha 3 heterotrimers arose in evolution with the divergence of Scyphozoa and Anthozoa.     

Defective C-propeptides of the proalpha2(I) chain of type I procollagen impede molecular assembly and result in osteogenesis imperfecta

Type I procollagen is a heterotrimer composed of two proalpha1(I) chains and one proalpha2(I) chain, encoded by the COL1A1 and COL1A2 genes, respectively. Mutations in these genes usually lead to dominantly inherited forms of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) by altering the triple helical domains, but a few affect sequences in the proalpha1(I) C-terminal propeptide (C-propeptide), and one, which has a phenotype only in homozygotes, alters the proalpha2(I) C-propeptide. Here we describe four dominant mutations in the COL1A2 gene that alter sequences of the proalpha2(I) C-propeptide in individuals with clinical features of a milder form of the disease, OI type IV. Three of the four appear to interfere with disulfide bonds that stabilize the C-propeptide conformation and its interaction with other chains in the trimer. Cultured cells synthesized proalpha2(I) chains that were slow to assemble with proalpha1(I) chains to form heterotrimers and that were retained intracellularly. Some alterations led to the uncharacteristic formation of proalpha1(I) homotrimers. These findings show that the C-propeptide of proalpha2(I), like that of the proalpha1(I) C-propeptide, is essential for efficient assembly of type I procollagen heterotrimers. The milder OI phenotypes likely reflect a diminished amount of normal type I procollagen, small populations of overmodified heterotrimers, and proalpha1(I) homotrimers that are compatible with normal skeletal growth.     

Transfer of proalpha2(I) cDNA into cells of a murine model of human Osteogenesis Imperfecta restores synthesis of type I collagen comprised of alpha1(I) and alpha2(I) heterotrimers in vitro and in vivo

The oim mouse is a model of human Osteogenesis Imperfecta (OI) that has deficient synthesis of proalpha2(I) chains. Cells isolated from oim mice synthesize alpha1(I) collagen homotrimers that accumulate in tissues. To explore the feasibility of gene therapy for OI, a murine proalpha2(I) cDNA was inserted into an adenovirus vector and transferred into bone marrow stromal cells isolated from oim mice femurs. The murine cDNA under the control of the cytomegalovirus early promoter was expressed by the transduced cells. Analysis of the collagens synthesized by the transduced cells demonstrated that the cells synthesized stable type I collagen comprised of alpha1(I) and alpha2(I) heterotrimers in the correct ratio of 2:1. The collagen was efficiently secreted and also the cells retained the osteogenic potential as indicated by the expression of alkaline phosphatase activity when the transduced cells were treated with recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein 2. Injection of the virus carrying the murine proalpha2(I) cDNA into oim skin demonstrated synthesis of type I collagen comprised of alpha1 and alpha2 chains at the injection site. These preliminary data demonstrate that collagen genes can be transferred into bone marrow stromal cells as well as fibroblasts in vivo and that the genes are efficiently expressed. These data encourage further studies in gene replacement for some forms of OI and use of bone marrow stromal cells as vehicles to deliver therapeutic genes to bone.     

Template‐tethered collagen mimetic peptides for studying heterotrimeric triple‐helical interactions

Collagen mimetic peptides (CMPs) have been used to elucidate the structure and stability of the triple helical conformation of collagen molecules. Although CMP homotrimers have been widely studied, very little work has been reported regarding CMP heterotrimers because of synthetic difficulties. Here, we present the synthesis and characterization of homotrimers and ABB type heterotrimers comprising natural and synthetic CMP sequences that are covalently tethered to a template, a tris(2‐aminoethyl) amine (TREN) succinic acid derivative. Various tethered heterotrimers comprising synthetic CMPs [(ProHypGly)₆, (ProProGly)₆] and CMPs representing specific domains of type I collagen were synthesized and characterized in terms of triple helical structure, thermal melting behavior, and refolding kinetics. The results indicated that CMPs derived from natural type I collagen sequence can form stable heterotrimeric helical complexes with artificial CMPs and that the thermal stability and the folding rate increase with the increasing number of helical stabilizing amino acids (e.g. Hyp) in the peptide chains. Covalent tethering enhanced the thermal stability and refolding kinetics of all CMPs; however, their relative values were not affected suggesting that the tethered system can be used for comparative study of heterotrimeric CMP's folding behavior in regards to chain composition and for characterization of thermally unstable CMPs. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Biopolymers 95: 94–104, 2011.     

Type VIII collagen: heterotrimeric chain association

Two chains, alpha1(VIII) and alpha2(VIII), have been described for type VIII collagen. Early work suggested that these chains were present in a 2:1 ratio, although recent work has shown that homotrimers can form and predominate in some tissues. In order to address the question of whether the alpha1(VIII) and alpha2(VIII) chains could co-polymerise we made a shortened alpha1(VIII) chain and expressed this with full length alpha2(VIII) chain in an in vitro translation system supplemented with semi-permeabilised cells. Heterotrimers containing either two or one alpha2(VIII) were evident. Interestingly, a point mutation in the NC1 domain of the alpha1(VIII) chain abrogated trimer formation. In addition we were able to demonstrate chain association of the alpha1(X) chain of type X collagen with the shortened alpha1(VIII) chain. Variations in chain association were seen when altered ratios of message were used. These results demonstrate the importance of the NC1 domain in chain association and suggest that gene expression regulates the composition and function of type VIII collagen by varying chain composition.     

Collagen XXIV,a vertebrate fibrillar collagen with structural features of invertebrate collagens: selective expression in developing cornea and bone

Tissue-specific assembly of fibers composed of the major collagen types I and II depends in part on the formation of heterotypic fibrils, using the quantitatively minor collagens V and XI. Here we report the identification of a new fibrillar-like collagen chain that is related to the fibrillar alpha1(V), alpha1(XI), and alpha2(XI) collagen polypeptides and which is coexpressed with type I collagen in the developing bone and eye. The new collagen was designated the alpha1(XXIV) chain and consists of a long triple helical domain flanked by typical propeptide-like sequences. The carboxyl propeptide is classic, with 8 conserved cysteine residues. The amino-terminal peptide contains a thrombospodin-N-terminal-like (TSP) motif and a highly charged segment interspersed with several tyrosine residues, like the fibril diameter-regulating collagen chains alpha1(V) and alpha1(XI). However, a short imperfection in the triple helix makes alpha1(XXIV) unique from other chains of the vertebrate fibrillar collagen family. The triple helical interruption and additional select features in both terminal peptides are common to the fibrillar chains of invertebrate organisms. Based on these data, we propose that collagen XXIV is an ancient molecule that may contribute to the regulation of type I collagen fibrillogenesis at specific anatomical locations during fetal development.     

Identification of the molecular recognition sequence which determines the type-specific assembly of procollagen.

A key question relating to procollagen biosynthesis is the way in which closely related procollagen chains discriminate between each other to assemble in a type-specific manner. Intracellular assembly of procollagen occurs via an initial interaction between the C-propeptides followed by vectorial propagation of the triple-helical domain in the C to N direction. Recognition signals within the C-propeptides must, therefore, determine the selective association of individual procollagen chains. We have used the pro alpha1 chain of type III procollagen [pro alpha1(III)] and the pro alpha2 chain of type I procollagen [pro alpha2(I)] as examples of procollagen chains that are either capable or incapable of self-assembly. When we exchanged the C-propeptides of the pro alpha1(III) chain and the pro alpha(I) chain we demonstrated that this domain is both necessary and sufficient to direct the assembly of homotrimers with correctly aligned triple-helices. To identify the sequences within this domain that determine selective association we constructed a series of chimeric procollagen chains in which we exchanged specific sequences from the pro alpha1(III) C-propeptide with the corresponding region within the pro alpha2(I) C-propeptide (and vice versa) and assayed for the ability of these molecules to form homotrimers. Using this approach we have identified a discontinuous sequence of 15 amino acids which directs procollagen self-association. By exchanging this sequence between different procollagen chains we can direct chain association and, potentially, assemble molecules with defined chain compositions.     

Identification of the cartilage alpha 1(XI) chain in type V collagen from bovine bone

Type V collagen prepared from bovine bone was resolved into three distinct alpha-chains by high performance liquid chromatography and gel electrophoresis. Peptide mapping established two chains as alpha 1(V) and alpha 2(V) as expected and the third as the cartilage alpha 1(XI) chain (previously thought to be unique to cartilage). In adult bone, the type V collagen fraction was richer in alpha 1(XI) chains than in fetal bone (about 1/3 of the chains in the adult). How these polypeptides are organized into native molecules is not yet clear, though the stoichiometry suggests cross-type heterotrimers between the type V and XI chains.     

Changes in the types of collagen synthesized during chondrogenesis of the mouse otic capsule

We have investigated the temporal relationship between the morphological differentiation of the mouse otic capsule and the pattern of collagen synthesis by mouse otocyst-mesenchyme complexes labeled in vitro. In 10.5- to 12-day embryos the mesenchyme surrounding the otocyst was loosely organized except for a few lateroventral condensations; explants from these embryos synthesized only small amounts of collagen. Collagen synthesis by whole explants increased by more than 50% between 12 and 13 days concomitant with metachromatic staining of the lateral periotic mesenchyme. Cartilage specific type II collagen was the predominant collagen synthesized by these explants as confirmed by SDS-PAGE, densitometry, CNBr cleavage, and V8 protease digestion. This biochemical expression of the cartilage phenotype preceded morphologic recognition of otic capsular cartilage by almost 2 days. Type II collagen synthesis continued to increase and predominate through Day 16 of gestation by which time the otic labyrinth was surrounded by mature cartilage. The minor cartilage collagen chains, 1 alpha, 2 alpha, and 3 alpha, first appeared on different days of gestation. The 1 alpha, and 3 alpha chains were synthesized by explants from 11-day embryos while the 2 alpha chain appeared during Day 13, just before overt differentiation of mature cartilage. These results suggested that the 1 alpha, 2 alpha, and 3 alpha chains may not form heterotrimers containing all three chains and that synthesis of the 2 alpha chain may be associated with stabilization of the cartilaginous matrix. Comparison of these data with the patterns of collagen production by mutant, diseased, or experimentally manipulated inner ear tissues may provide insights into the molecular basis of chondrogenic tissue interactions.     

Separation of the alpha chains of type I and III collagens by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis.

A method for the separation of type III collagen from type I collagen by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis has been developed. This is based on the observation that the presence of 3-4 M urea decreases the mobility of the alpha 1 [III] chain to a greater extent than those of the alpha 1[I] and alpha 2 chains, although the alpha 1[I] and alpha 1[III] chains move at the same rate in the absence of urea. An attempt to separate the alpha 1[II] chain of type II collagen from the alpha 1[I] chain was unsuccessful under the experimental conditions employed.     

Changes in the synthesis of minor cartilage collagens after growth of chick chondrocytes in 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine or to senescence

Analyses were made of the minor collagens synthesized by cultures of chondrocytes derived from 14-day chick embryo sterna. Comparisons were made between control cultures, cultures grown for 9 days in 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdU) and clones of chondrocytes grown to senescence. Separation of minor collagens from interstitial collagens was achieved by differential salt precipitation in the presence of carrier collagens in acid conditions. The precipitate at 0.9 M NaCl 0.5 M acetic acid from control cultures was shown by CNBr peptide analysis to contain only the alpha 1(II) chain of type II collagen, whereas after BrdU treatment or growth to senescence synthesis of only alpha 1(I) and alpha 2(I) chains occurred. The synthesis of type III collagen was not detected. Analysis of the precipitate at 2.0 M NaCl, 0.5 M HAc from control cultures demonstrated the synthesis of 1 alpha, 2 alpha and 3 alpha chains together with the synthesis of short chain (SC) collagen of Mr 43000 after pepsin digestion. After BrdU treatment or growth to senescence alpha chains were isolated which possessed the migration positions on polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE), or the elution positions on CM-cellulose chromatography, of the alpha 1(V) and alpha 2(V) chains of type V collagen. In addition, for BrdU-treated but not for control cultures, intracellular immunofluorescent staining was observed with a monoclonal antibody which specifically recognizes an epitope present in the triple helix of type V collagen. Synthesis of short chain (SC) collagen was not detected after BrdU treatment or growth to senescence. These results suggest that chick chondrocytes grown in conditions known to cause switching of collagen synthesis from type II to type I collagen also undergo a switch from the synthesis of 1 alpha, 2 alpha and 3 alpha chains to the synthesis of the alpha 1(V) and alpha 2(V) chains of type V collagen. It appears that there are several cartilage-specific collagens which together undergo a regulatory control to the synthesis of collagens typical of other connective tissues.     

Collagen X chains harboring Schmid metaphyseal chondrodysplasia NC1 domain mutations are selectively retained and degraded in stably transfected cells.

Collagen X is a short chain, homotrimeric collagen expressed specifically by hypertrophic chondrocytes during endochondral bone formation and growth. Although the exact role of collagen X remains unresolved, mutations in the COL10A1 gene disrupt growth plate function and result in Schmid metaphyseal chondrodysplasia (SMCD). With the exception of two mutations that impair signal peptide cleavage during alpha1(X) chain biosynthesis, SMCD mutations are clustered within the carboxyl-terminal NC1 domain. The formation of stable NC1 domain trimers is a critical stage in collagen X assembly, suggesting that mutations within this domain may result in subunit mis-folding or reduce trimer stability. When expressed in transiently transfected cells, alpha1(X) chains containing SMCD mutations were unstable and presumed to be degraded intracellularly. More recently, in vitro studies have shown that certain missense mutations may exert a dominant negative effect on alpha1(X) chain assembly by formation of mutant homotrimers and normal-mutant heterotrimers. In contrast, analysis of cartilage tissue from two SMCD patients revealed that the truncated mutant message was fully degraded, resulting in 50% reduction of functional collagen X within the growth plate. Therefore, in the absence of data that conclusively demonstrates the full cellular response to mutant collagen X chains, the molecular mechanisms underlying SMCD remain controversial. To address this, we closely examined the effect of two NC1 domain mutations, one frameshift mutation (1963del10) and one missense mutation (Y598D), using both semi-permeabilized cell and stable cell transfection expression systems. Although able to assemble to a limited extent in both systems, we show that, in intact cells, collagen X chains harboring both SMCD mutations did not evade quality control mechanisms within the secretory pathway and were degraded intracellularly. Furthermore, co-expression of wild-type and mutant chains in stable transfected cells demonstrated that, although wild-type chains were secreted, mutant chains were largely excluded from hetero-trimer formation. Our data indicate, therefore, that the predominant effect of the NC1 mutations Y598D and 1963del10 is a reduction in the amount of functional collagen X within the growth cartilage extracellular matrix.