Dissecting the Forces that Dominate Dimerization of the Nucleotide Binding Domains of ABCB1

P-glycoprotein, also known as multidrug resistance protein 1 or ABCB1, can export a wide range of chemically unrelated compounds, including chemotherapeutic drugs. ABCB1 consists of two transmembrane domains that form the substrate binding and translocation domain, and of two cytoplasmic nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) that energize substrate transport by ATP binding and hydrolysis. ATP binding triggers dimerization of the NBDs, which switches the transporter from an inward facing to an outward facing transmembrane domain conformation. We performed MD simulations to study the dynamic behavior of the NBD dimer in the presence or absence of nucleotides. In the apo configuration, the NBDs were overall attractive to each other as shown in the potential of mean force profile, but the energy well was shallow and broad. In contrast, a sharp and deep energy minimum (～?42 kJ/mol) was found in the presence of ATP, leading to a well-defined conformation. Motif interaction network analyses revealed that ATP stabilizes the NBD dimer by serving as the central hub for interdomain connections. Simulations showed that forces promoting dimerization are multilayered, dominated by electrostatic interactions between the nucleotide and conserved amino acids of the signature sequence and the Walker A motif. In addition, direct and water-bridged hydrogen bonds between NBDs provided conformation-defining interactions. Importantly, we characterized a largely unrecognized but essential contribution from hydrophobic interactions between the adenine moiety of the nucleotides and a hydrophobic surface of the X-loop to the stabilization of the nucleotide-bound NBD dimer. These hydrophobic interactions lead to a sharp energy minimum, thereby conformationally restricting the nucleotide-bound state.     

Conformational changes in MetNI: steered molecular dynamic studies of the methionine ABC transporter with and without substrates

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters are integral membrane proteins that utilised energy from ATP hydrolysis to translocate substrates across the membrane. In addition to the common nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) and transmembrane domains (TMDs), the methionine ABC transporter has C-terminal regulatory domains (C2 domains) that belong to ACT protein family. When the amount of methionine in the cell is high, the transport stops. This phenomenon is called trans-inhibition. To understand how a trans-inhibited protein returns to an uninhibited, resting state, we performed steered molecular dynamic simulations with and without the substrates. From the simulations, we observed some important conformational changes in the whole ABC transporter, including the constriction in the translocation pathway in the TMDs and approach of the NBDs. However, the C2 domains behaved differently in two types of the simulations. These findings might help to explain the relationship of the conformational changes of the C2 domains with the rearrangements of the NBDs or TMDs, and provide a way to understand the trans-inhibition from an opposite direction.     

Conformational coupling of the nucleotide-binding and the transmembrane domains in ABC transporters

Basic architecture of ABC transporters includes two transmembrane domains (TMDs) and two nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs). Although the transport process takes place in the TMDs, which provide the substrate translocation pathway across the cell membrane and control its accessibility between the two sides of the membrane, the energy required for the process is provided by conformational changes induced in the NBDs by binding and hydrolysis of ATP. Nucleotide-dependent conformational changes in the NBDs, therefore, need to be coupled to structural changes in the TMDs. Using molecular dynamics simulations, we have investigated the structural elements involved in the conformational coupling between the NBDs and the TMDs in the Escherichia coli maltose transporter, an ABC importer for which an intact structure is available both in inward-facing and outward-facing conformations. The prevailing model of coupling is primarily based on a single structural motif, known as the coupling helices, as the main structural element for the NBD-TMD coupling. Surprisingly, we find that in the absence of the NBDs the coupling helices can be conformationally decoupled from the rest of the TMDs, despite their covalent connection. That is, the structural integrity of the coupling helices and their tight coupling to the core of the TMDs rely on the contacts provided by the NBDs. Based on the conformational and dynamical analysis of the simulation trajectories, we propose that the core coupling elements in the maltose transporter involve contributions from several structural motifs located at the NBD-TMD interface, namely, the EAA loops from the TMDs, and the Q-loop and the ENI motifs from the NBDs. These three structural motifs in small ABC importers show a high degree of correlation in motion and mediate the necessary conformational coupling between the core of TMDs and the helical subdomains of NBDs. A comprehensive analysis of the structurally known ABC transporters shows a high degree of conservation of the identified 3-motif coupling elements only in the subfamily of small ABC importers, suggesting a distinct mode of NBD-TMD coupling from the other two major ABC transporter folds, namely large ABC importers and ABC exporters.     

The first nucleotide binding domain of the sulfonylurea receptor 2A contains regulatory elements and is folded and functions as an independent module

The sulfonylurea receptor 2A (SUR2A) is an ATP-binding cassette (ABC) protein that forms the regulatory subunit of ATP-sensitive potassium (K(ATP)) channels in the heart. ATP binding and hydrolysis at the SUR2A nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) control gating of K(ATP) channels, and mutations in the NBDs that affect ATP hydrolysis and cellular trafficking cause cardiovascular disorders. To date, there is limited information on the SUR2A NBDs and the effects of disease-causing mutations on their structure and interactions. Structural and biophysical studies of NBDs, especially from eukaryotic ABC proteins like SUR2A, have been hindered by low solubility of the isolated domains. We hypothesized that the solubility of heterologously expressed SUR2A NBDs depends on the precise definition of the domain boundaries. Putative boundaries of SUR2A NBD1 were identified by structure-based sequence alignments and subsequently tested by exploring the solubility of SUR2A NBD1 constructs with different N and C termini. We have determined boundaries of SUR2A NBD1 that allow for soluble heterologous expression of the protein, producing a folded domain with ATP binding activity. Surprisingly, our alignment and screening data indicate that SUR2A NBD1 contains two putative, previously unidentified, regulatory elements: a large insert within the β-sheet subdomain and a C-terminal extension. Our approach, which combines the use of structure-based sequence alignments and predictions of disordered regions combined with biochemical and biophysical studies, may be applied as a general method for developing suitable constructs of other NBDs of ABC proteins.     

ABC transporter architecture and regulatory roles of accessory domains

We present an overview of the architecture of ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters and dissect the systems in core and accessory domains. The ABC transporter core is formed by the transmembrane domains (TMDs) and the nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) that constitute the actual translocator. The accessory domains include the substrate-binding proteins, that function as high affinity receptors in ABC type uptake systems, and regulatory or catalytic domains that can be fused to either the TMDs or NBDs. The regulatory domains add unique functions to the transporters allowing the systems to act as channel conductance regulators, osmosensors/regulators, and assemble into macromolecular complexes with specific properties.     

Cysteine-scanning mutagenesis provides no evidence for the extracellular accessibility of the nucleotide-binding domains of the multidrug resistance transporter P-glycoprotein

Multidrug resistance of cancer cells is, at least in part, conferred by overexpression of P-glycoprotein (P-gp), a member of the ATP-binding cassette (ABC) superfamily of active transporters. P-gp actively extrudes chemotherapeutic drugs from cells, thus reducing their efficacy. As a typical ABC transporter, P-gp has four domains: two transmembrane domains, which form a pathway through the membrane through which substrates are transported, and two hydrophilic nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs), located on the cytoplasmic side of the membrane, which couple the energy of ATP hydrolysis to substrate translocation. It has been proposed that the NBDs of ABC transporters, including the histidine permease of Salmonella typhimurium and the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator, are accessible from the extracellular surface of the cell, spanning the membrane directly or potentially contributing to the transmembrane pore. Such organization would have significant implications for the transport mechanism. We determined to establish whether the NBDs of P-gp are exposed extracellularly and which amino acids are accessible, using cysteine-scanning mutagenesis and limited proteolysis. In contrast to other transporters, the data provided no evidence that the P-gp NBDs are exposed to the cell surface. The implications for the structure and mechanism of P-gp and other ABC transporters are discussed.     

Functionally important interactions between the nucleotide-binding domains of an antigenic peptide transporter

The transporter associated with antigen processing (TAP), an ABC transporter, pumps cytosolic peptides into the endoplasmic reticulum, where the peptides are loaded onto class I MHC molecules for presentation to the immune system. Transport is fueled by the binding of ATP to two cytosolic nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) and ATP hydrolysis. We demonstrate biochemically that there are two electrostatic interactions across the interface between the two TAP NBDs and that these interactions are important for peptide transport. Notably, disrupting these interactions by mutagenesis does not greatly alter the ATP hydrolysis rate in an isolated NBD model system, suggesting that the interactions function at alternative stages in the transport cycle. The data support the general model for ABC transporters in which the NBDs form a tight, closed conformation during transport. Our results are discussed in relation to other ABC transporters that do or do not conserve potential interacting residues of opposite charges at the homologous positions.     

The W232R suppressor mutation promotes maturation of a truncation mutant lacking both nucleotide-binding domains and restores interdomain assembly and activity of P-glycoprotein processing mutants

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) proteins contain two nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) and two transmembrane (TM) domains (TMDs). Interdomain interactions and packing of the TM segments are critical for function, and disruption by genetic mutations contributes to disease. P-glycoprotein (P-gp) is a useful model to identify mechanisms that repair processing defects because numerous arginine suppressor mutations have been identified in the TM segments. Here, we tested the prediction that a mechanism of arginine rescue was to promote intradomain interactions between TM segments and restore interdomain assembly. We found that suppressor W232R(TM4/TMD1) rescued mutants with processing mutations in any domain and restored defective NBD1-NBD2, NBD1-TMD2, and TMD1-TMD2 interactions. W232R also promoted packing of the TM segments because it rescued a truncation mutant lacking both NBDs. The mechanism of W232R rescue likely involved intradomain hydrogen bond interactions with Asn296(TM5) since only N296A abolished rescue by W232R and rescue was only observed when Trp232 was replaced with hydrogen-bonding residues. In TMD2, suppressor T945R(TM11) also promoted packing of the TM segments because it rescued the truncation mutant lacking the NBDs and suppressed formation of alternative topologies. We propose that T945R rescue was mediated by interactions with Glu875(TM10) since T945E/E875R promoted maturation while T945R/E875A did not.     

Structural consequences of ATP hydrolysis on the ABC transporter NBD dimer: molecular dynamics studies of HlyB

ABC transporters are a large and important family of membrane proteins involved in substrate transport across the membrane. The transported substrates are quite diverse, ranging from monatomic ions to large biomolecules. Consequently, some ABC transporters are involved in biomedically relevant situations, from genetic diseases to multidrug resistance. The most conserved domains in ABC transporters are the nucleotide binding domains (NBDs), which form a dimer responsible for the binding and hydrolysis of ATP, concomitantly with substrate translocation. To elucidate how ATP hydrolysis structurally affects the NBD dimer, and consequently the transporter, we performed a molecular dynamics study on the NBD dimer of the HlyB ABC exporter. We have observed a change in the contact surface between the monomers after hydrolysis, even though we have not seen dimer opening in any of the five 100 ns simulations. We have also identified specific regions that respond to ATP hydrolysis, in particular the X-loop motif of ABC exporters, which has been shown to be in contact with the coupling helices of the transmembrane domains (TMDs). We propose that this motif is an important part of the NBD-TMD communication in ABC exporters. Through nonequilibrium analysis, we have also identified gradual conformational changes within a short time scale after ATP hydrolysis.     

Nucleotide-binding domains of cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator, an ABC transporter, catalyze adenylate kinase activity but not ATP hydrolysis

The cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) is an anion channel in the ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter family. CFTR consists of two transmembrane domains, two nucleotide-binding domains (NBD1 and NBD2), and a regulatory domain. Previous biochemical reports suggest NBD1 is a site of stable nucleotide interaction with low ATPase activity, whereas NBD2 is the site of active ATP hydrolysis. It has also been reported that NBD2 additionally possessed adenylate kinase (AK) activity. Knowledge about the intrinsic biochemical activities of the NBDs is essential to understanding the Cl(-) ion gating mechanism. We find that purified mouse NBD1, human NBD1, and human NBD2 function as adenylate kinases but not as ATPases. AK activity is strictly dependent on the addition of the adenosine monophosphate (AMP) substrate. No liberation of [(33)P]phosphate is observed from the gamma-(33)P-labeled ATP substrate in the presence or absence of AMP. AK activity is intrinsic to both human NBDs, as the Walker A box lysine mutations abolish this activity. At low protein concentration, the NBDs display an initial slower nonlinear phase in AK activity, suggesting that the activity results from homodimerization. Interestingly, the G551D gating mutation has an exaggerated nonlinear phase compared with the wild type and may indicate this mutation affects the ability of NBD1 to dimerize. hNBD1 and hNBD2 mixing experiments resulted in an 8-57-fold synergistic enhancement in AK activity suggesting heterodimer formation, which supports a common theme in ABC transporter models. A CFTR gating mechanism model based on adenylate kinase activity is proposed.     

The nucleotide-binding domains of P-glycoprotein. Functional symmetry in the isolated domain demonstrated by N-ethylmaleimide labelling.

The two nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) of a number of ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters have been shown to be functionally dissimilar, playing different roles in the transport process. A high degree of co-operativity has been determined for the NBDs of the human multidrug transporter, P-glycoprotein. However, the issue of functional symmetry in P-glycoprotein remains contentious. To address this, the NBDs of P-glycoprotein were expressed and purified to 95% homogeneity, as fusions to maltose-binding protein. The NBDs were engineered to contain a single cysteine residue in the Walker-A homology motif. Reactivity of this cysteine residue was demonstrated by specific, time-dependent, covalent labelling with N-ethylmaleimide. No differences in the rates of labelling of the two NBDs were observed. The relative affinity of binding to each NBD was determined for a number of nucleotides by measuring their ability to effect a reduction in N-ethylmaleimide labelling. In general, nucleotides bound identically to the two NBDs, suggesting that there is little asymmetry in the initial step of the transport cycle, namely the recognition and binding of nucleotide. Any observed functional asymmetry in the intact transporter presumably reflects different rates of hydrolysis at the two NBDs or interdomain communications.     

The mechanism of nucleotide‐binding domain dimerization in the intact maltose transporter as studied by all‐atom molecular dynamics simulations

The Escherichia coli maltose transporter MalFGK₂‐E belongs to the protein superfamily of ATP‐binding cassette (ABC) transporters. This protein is composed of heterodimeric transmembrane domains (TMDs) MalF and MalG, and the homodimeric nucleotide‐binding domains (NBDs) MalK₂. In addition to the TMDs and NBDs, the periplasmic maltose binding protein MalE captures maltose and shuttle it to the transporter. In this study, we performed all‐atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations on the maltose transporter and found that both the binding of MalE to the periplasmic side of the TMDs and binding of ATP to the MalK₂ are necessary to facilitate the conformational change from the inward‐facing state to the occluded state, in which MalK₂ is completely dimerized. MalE binding suppressed the fluctuation of the TMDs and MalF periplasmic region (MalF‐P2), and thus prevented the incorrect arrangement of the MalF C‐terminal (TM8) helix. Without MalE binding, the MalF TM8 helix showed a tendency to intrude into the substrate translocation pathway, hindering the closure of the MalK₂. This observation is consistent with previous mutagenesis experimental results on MalF and provides a new point of view regarding the understanding of the substrate translocation mechanism of the maltose transporter.     

Interaction of asymmetric ABCC9-encoded nucleotide binding domains determines KATP channel SUR2A catalytic activity

Nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) secure ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter function. Distinct from traditional ABC transporters, ABCC9-encoded sulfonylurea receptors (SUR2A) form, with Kir6.2 potassium channels, ATP-sensitive K+ (K ATP) channel complexes. SUR2A contains ATPase activity harbored within NBD2 and, to a lesser degree, NBD1, with catalytically driven conformations exerting determinate linkage on the Kir6.2 channel pore. While homodomain interactions typify NBDs of conventional ABC transporters, heterodomain NBD interactions and their functional consequence have not been resolved for the atypical SUR2A protein. Here, nanoscale protein topography mapped assembly of monodisperse purified recombinant SUR2A NBD1/NBD2 domains, precharacterized by dynamic light scattering. Heterodomain interaction produced conformational rearrangements inferred by secondary structural change in circular dichroism, and validated by atomic force and transmission electron microscopy. Physical engagement of NBD1 with NBD2 translated into enhanced intrinsic ATPase activity. Molecular modeling delineated a complemental asymmetry of NBD1/NBD2 ATP-binding sites. Mutation in the predicted catalytic base residue, D834E of NBD1, altered NBD1 ATPase activity disrupting potentiation of catalytic behavior in the NBD1/NBD2 interactome. Thus, NBD1/NBD2 assembly, resolved by a panel of proteomic approaches, provides a molecular substrate that determines the optimal catalytic activity in SUR2A, establishing a paradigm for the structure-function relationship within the K ATP channel complex.     

The Nucleotide-Free State of the Multidrug Resistance ABC Transporter LmrA: Sulfhydryl Cross-Linking Supports a Constant Contact,Head-to-Tail Configuration of the Nucleotide-Binding Domains

ABC transporters are integral membrane pumps that are responsible for the import or export of a diverse range of molecules across cell membranes. ABC transporters have been implicated in many phenomena of medical importance, including cystic fibrosis and multidrug resistance in humans. The molecular architecture of ABC transporters comprises two transmembrane domains and two ATP-binding cassettes, or nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs), which are highly conserved and contain motifs that are crucial to ATP binding and hydrolysis. Despite the improved clarity of recent structural, biophysical, and biochemical data, the seemingly simple process of ATP binding and hydrolysis remains controversial, with a major unresolved issue being whether the NBD protomers separate during the catalytic cycle. Here chemical cross-linking data is presented for the bacterial ABC multidrug resistance (MDR) transporter LmrA. These indicate that in the absence of nucleotide or substrate, the NBDs come into contact to a significant extent, even at 4°C, where ATPase activity is abrogated. The data are clearly not in accord with an inward-closed conformation akin to that observed in a crystal structure of V. cholerae MsbA. Rather, they suggest a head-to-tail configuration ‘sandwich’ dimer similar to that observed in crystal structures of nucleotide-bound ABC NBDs. We argue the data are more readily reconciled with the notion that the NBDs are in proximity while undergoing intra-domain motions, than with an NBD ‘Switch’ mechanism in which the NBD monomers separate in between ATP hydrolysis cycles.     

ATP binding cassette systems: structures, mechanisms, and functions

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) systems are found in all three domains of life and in some giant viruses and form one of the largest protein superfamilies. Most family members are transport proteins that couple the free energy of ATP hydrolysis to the translocation of solutes across a biological membrane. The energizing module is also used to drive non-transport processes associated, e.g., with DNA repair and protein translation. Many ABC proteins are of considerable medical importance. In humans, dysfunction of at least eighteen out of 49 ABC transporters is associated with disease, such as cystic fibrosis, Tangier disease, adrenoleukodystrophy or Stargardt’s macular degeneration. In prokaryotes, ABC proteins confer resistance to antibiotics, secrete virulence factors and envelope components, or mediate the uptake of a large variety of nutrients. Canonical ABC transporters share a common structural organization comprising two transmembrane domains (TMDs) that form the translocation pore and two nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) that bind and hydrolyze ATP. In this Mini-Review, we summarize recent structural and biochemical data obtained from both prokaryotic and eukaryotic model systems.     

Functional asymmetry of the ATP-binding-cassettes of the ABC transporter TAP is determined by intrinsic properties of the nucleotide binding domains.

The ATP-binding-cassette (ABC) transporter associated with antigen processing (TAP) delivers peptides into the ER. TAP consists of two polypeptides (TAP1 and TAP2) each with an N-terminal transmembrane (TMD) and a C-terminal nucleotide binding domain (NBD). The two highly homologous NBDs of TAP show different nucleotide binding specificites, and identical mutations in the domains can have different effects on peptide transport. We asked whether this functional asymmetry of the NBDs is an intrinsic property or is imposed by the TMDs to which they are linked. To investigate the functional interdependence of the TAP domains, we created various TAP variants in which TMDs and/or NBDs were exchanged. All TAP variants except those with two TMDs of TAP1 could assemble. The TMDs did not affect the different nucleotide binding properties of the NBDs. The TAP variant with switched NBDs showed active peptide transport while the variants with pairs of identical NBDs or TMDs were inactive. Although both types of TMDs and NBDs have to be present for peptide transport they do not have to be assorted as in wild-type TAP. Thus, TAP domains seem to preserve functional autonomy despite their fusion into single polypeptide chains. We propose that the two NBDs act as nonequivalent 'modules' that directly determine the functional asymmetry of the included ATP-binding-cassettes. This provides a new insight into the function of NBDs and opens up new possibilities to investigate the molecular mechanism of the 'NBD engine' in ABC transporters.     

Definition of the domain boundaries is critical to the expression of the nucleotide-binding domains of P-glycoprotein

Heterologous expression of domains of eukaryotic proteins is frequently associated with formation of inclusion bodies, consisting of aggregated mis-folded protein. This phenomenon has proved a significant barrier to the characterization of domains of eukaryotic ATP binding cassette (ABC) transporters. We hypothesized that the solubility of heterologously expressed nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) of ABC transporters is dependent on the definition of the domain boundaries. In this paper we have defined a core NBD, and tested the effect of extensions to and deletions of this core domain on protein expression. Of 10 NBDs constructed, only one was expressed as a soluble protein in Escherichia coli, with expression of the remaining NBDs being associated with inclusion body formation. The soluble NBD protein we have obtained corresponds to residues 386-632 of P-glycoprotein and represents an optimally defined domain. The NBD has been isolated and purified to 95% homogeneity by a two-step purification protocol, involving affinity chromatography and gel filtration. Although showing no detectable ATP hydrolysis, the protein retains specific ATP binding and has a secondary structure compatible with X-ray crystallographic data on bacterial NBDs. We have interpreted our results in terms of homology models, which suggest that the N-terminal NBD of P-glycoprotein can be produced as a stable, correctly folded, isolate domain with judicious design of the expression construct.     

Perspectives on the structure-function of ABC transporters: The Switch and Constant Contact Models

ABC transporters constitute one of the largest protein families across the kingdoms of archaea, eubacteria and eukarya. They couple ATP hydrolysis to vectorial translocation of diverse substrates across membranes. The ABC transporter architecture comprises two transmembrane domains and two cytosolic ATP-binding cassettes. During 2002-2012, nine prokaryotic ABC transporter structures and two eukaryotic structures have been solved to medium resolution. Despite a wealth of biochemical, biophysical, and structural data, fundamental questions remain regarding the coupling of ATP hydrolysis to unidirectional substrate translocation, and the mechanistic suite of steps involved. The mechanics of the ATP cassette dimer is defined most popularly by the 'Switch Model', which proposes that hydrolysis in each protomer is sequential, and that as the sites are freed of nucleotide, the protomers lose contact across a large solvent-filled gap of 20-30??; as captured in several X-ray solved structures. Our 'Constant Contact' model for the operational mechanics of ATP binding and hydrolysis in the ATP-binding cassettes is derived from the 'alternating sites' model, proposed in 1995, and which requires an intrinsic asymmetry in the ATP sites, but does not require the partner protomers to lose contact. Thus one of the most debated issues regarding the function of ABC transporters is whether the cooperative mechanics of ATP hydrolysis requires the ATP cassettes to separate or remain in constant contact and this dilemma is discussed at length in this review.