Control of the endonuclease activity of type I restriction-modification systems is required to maintain chromosome integrity following homologous recombination

A type I restriction-modification enzyme will bind to an unmethylated target sequence in DNA and, while still bound to the target, translocate DNA through the protein complex in both directions. DNA breakage occurs when two translocating complexes collide. However, if type I restriction-modification systems bind to unmodified target sequences within the resident bacterial chromosome, as opposed to incoming 'foreign' DNA, their activity is curtailed; a process known as restriction alleviation (RA). We have identified two genes in Escherichia coli, rnhA and recG, mutations in which lead to the alleviation of restriction. Induction of RA in response to these mutations is consistent with the production of unmodified target sequences following DNA synthesis associated with both homologous recombination and R-loop formation. This implies that a normal function of RA is to protect the bacterial chromosome when recombination generates unmodified products. For EcoKI, our experiments demonstrate the contribution of two pathways that serve to protect unmodified DNA in the bacterial chromosome: the primary pathway in which ClpXP degrades the restriction endonuclease and a mechanism dependent on the lar gene within Rac, a resident, defective prophage of E. coli K-12. Previously, the potential of the second pathway has only been demonstrated when expression of lar has been elevated. Our data identify the effect of lar from the repressed prophage.     

A DNA methyltransferase can protect the genome from postdisturbance attack by a restriction-modification gene complex

In prokaryotic genomes, some DNA methyltransferases form a restriction-modification gene complex, but some others are present by themselves. Dcm gene product, one of these orphan methyltransferases found in Escherichia coli and related bacteria, methylates DNA to generate 5'-C(m)CWGG just as some of its eukaryotic homologues do. Vsr mismatch repair function of an adjacent gene prevents C-to-T mutagenesis enhanced by this methylation but promotes other types of mutation and likely has affected genome evolution. The reason for the existence of the dcm-vsr gene pair has been unclear. Earlier we found that several restriction-modification gene complexes behave selfishly in that their loss from a cell leads to cell killing through restriction attack on the genome. There is also increasing evidence for their potential mobility. EcoRII restriction-modification gene complex recognizes the same sequence as Dcm, and its methyltransferase is phylogenetically related to Dcm. In the present work, we found that stabilization of maintenance of a plasmid by linkage of EcoRII gene complex, likely through postsegregational cell killing, is diminished by dcm function. Disturbance of EcoRII restriction-modification gene complex led to extensive chromosome degradation and severe loss of cell viability. This cell killing was partially suppressed by chromosomal dcm and completely abolished by dcm expressed from a plasmid. Dcm, therefore, can play the role of a "molecular vaccine" by defending the genome against parasitism by a restriction-modification gene complex.     

Comparison between Pyrococcus horikoshii and Pyrococcus abyssi genome sequences reveals linkage of restriction-modification genes with large genome polymorphisms

Recent work suggests that restriction-modification gene complexes are mobile genetic elements that insert themselves into the genome and cause various genome rearrangements. In the present work, the complete genome sequences of Pyrococcus horikoshii and Pyrococcus abyssi, two species in a genus of hyperthermophilic archaeon (archaebacterium), were compared to detect large genome polymorphisms linked with restriction-modification gene homologs. Sequence alignments, GC content analysis, and codon usage analysis demonstrated the diversity of these homologs and revealed a possible case of relatively recent acquisition (horizontal transfer). In two cases out of the six large polymorphisms identified, there was insertion of a DNA segment with a modification gene homolog, accompanied by target deletion (simple substitution). In two other cases, homologous DNA segments carrying a modification gene homolog were present at different locations in the two genomes (transposition). In both cases, substitution (insertion/deletion) in one of the two loci was accompanied by inversion of adjacent chromosomal segment. In the fifth case, substitution by a DNA segment carrying type I restriction, modification, and specificity gene homologs was likewise accompanied by adjacent inversion. In the last case, two homologous DNA segments, were found at different loci in the two genomes (transposition), but only one of them had insertion of a modification homolog and an unknown ORF. The possible relationship of these polymorphisms to attack by restriction enzymes on the chromosome will be discussed.     

Multiplication of a restriction-modification gene complex

Previous works have suggested that some gene complexes encoding a restriction (R) enzyme and a cognate modification (M) enzyme may behave as selfish mobile genetic elements. RM gene complexes, which destroy 'non-self' elements marked by the absence of proper methylation, are often associated with mobile genetic elements and are involved in various genome rearrangements. Here, we found amplification of a restriction-modification gene complex. BamHI gene complex inserted into the Bacillus chromosome showed resistance to replacement by a homologous stretch of DNA. Some cells became transformed with the donor without losing BamHI. In most of these transformants, multiple copies of BamHI and the donor allele were arranged as tandem repeats. When a clone carrying one copy of each allele was propagated, extensive amplification of BamHI and the donor unit was observed in a manner dependent on restriction enzyme gene. This suggests that restriction cutting of the genome participates in the amplification. Visualization by fluorescent in situ hybridization revealed that the amplification occurred in single cells in a burst-like fashion that is reminiscent of induction of provirus replication. The multiplication ability in a bacterium with natural capacity for DNA release, uptake and transformation will be discussed in relation to spreading of RM gene -complexes.     

Behavior of restriction-modification systems as selfish mobile elements and their impact on genome evolution

Restriction–modification (RM) systems are composed of genes that encode a restriction enzyme and a modification methylase. RM systems sometimes behave as discrete units of life, like viruses and transposons. RM complexes attack invading DNA that has not been properly modified and thus may serve as a tool of defense for bacterial cells. However, any threat to their maintenance, such as a challenge by a competing genetic element (an incompatible plasmid or an allelic homologous stretch of DNA, for example) can lead to cell death through restriction breakage in the genome. This post-segregational or post-disturbance cell killing may provide the RM complexes (and any DNA linked with them) with a competitive advantage. There is evidence that they have undergone extensive horizontal transfer between genomes, as inferred from their sequence homology, codon usage bias and GC content difference. They are often linked with mobile genetic elements such as plasmids, viruses, transposons and integrons. The comparison of closely related bacterial genomes also suggests that, at times, RM genes themselves behave as mobile elements and cause genome rearrangements. Indeed some bacterial genomes that survived post-disturbance attack by an RM gene complex in the laboratory have experienced genome rearrangements. The avoidance of some restriction sites by bacterial genomes may result from selection by past restriction attacks. Both bacteriophages and bacteria also appear to use homologous recombination to cope with the selfish behavior of RM systems. RM systems compete with each other in several ways. One is competition for recognition sequences in post-segregational killing. Another is super-infection exclusion, that is, the killing of the cell carrying an RM system when it is infected with another RM system of the same regulatory specificity but of a different sequence specificity. The capacity of RM systems to act as selfish, mobile genetic elements may underlie the structure and function of RM enzymes.     

Genomic changes following host restriction in bacteria

Many genomic sequences have been recently published for bacteria that can replicate only within eukaryotic hosts. Comparisons of genomic features with those of closely related bacteria retaining free-living stages indicate that rapid evolutionary change often occurs immediately after host restriction. Typical changes include a large increase in the frequency of mobile elements in the genome, chromosomal rearrangements mediated by recombination among these elements, pseudogene formation, and deletions of varying size. In anciently host-restricted lineages, the frequency of insertion sequence elements decreases as genomes become extremely small and strictly clonal. These changes represent a general syndrome of genome evolution, which is observed repeatedly in host-restricted lineages from numerous phylogenetic groups. Considerable variation also exists, however, in part reflecting unstudied aspects of the population structure and ecology of host-restricted bacterial lineages.     

Insertion with long target duplication: a mechanism for gene mobility suggested from comparison of two related bacterial genomes

The complete genome sequences of two closely related organisms--two Helicobacter pylori strains--have recently become available. Comparison of these genomes at single base pair level has suggested the presence of a mechanism for bacterial gene mobility--insertion with long target duplications. This mechanism is formally similar to classical transposon insertion, but the duplication is much longer, often in the range of 100bp. Restriction and/or modification enzyme genes are often within or adjacent to the insertion. A similar process may have mediated insertion of the cag(+) pathogenicity island in H. pylori. A similar structure was identified in comparisons between Neisseria meningitidis and Neisseria gonorrhoeae genomes. We hypothesize that this mechanism, as well as two other types of polymorphism linked with restriction-modification genes (insertion accompanied by target deletion and a tripartite structure composed of substitution/inversion/deletion), have resulted from attack by restriction enzymes on the chromosome.     

Regulation of the HpyII restriction–modification system of Helicobacter pylori by gene deletion and horizontal reconstitution

Helicobacter pylori, Gram-negative, curved bacteria colonizing the human stomach, possess strain-specific complements of functional restriction-modification (R-M) systems. Restriction-modification systems have been identified in most bacterial species studied and are believed to have evolved to protect the host genome from invasion by foreign DNA. The large number of R-Ms homologous to those in other bacterial species and their strain-specificity suggest that H. pylori may have horizontally acquired these genes. A type IIs restriction-modification system, hpyIIRM, was active in two out of the six H. pylori strains studied. We demonstrate now that in most strains lacking M.HpyII function, there is complete absence of the R-M system. Direct DNA repeats of 80 bp flanking the hpyIIRM system allow its deletion, resulting in an "empty-site" genotype. We show that strains possessing this empty-site genotype and strains with a full but inactive hpyIIRM can reacquire the hpyIIRM cassette and functional activity through natural transformation by DNA from the parental R-M+ strain. Identical isolates divergent for the presence of an active HpyII R-M pose different restriction barriers to transformation by foreign DNA. That H. pylori can lose HpyII R-M function through deletion or mutation, and can horizontally reacquire the hpyIIRM cassette, is, in composite, a novel mechanism for R-M regulation, supporting the general hypothesis that H. pylori populations use mutation and transformation to regulate gene function.     

Restriction-modification system in bacteriophage MB78

Restriction-modification system is present in bacteria to protect the cells against phage infection. Interestingly, the bacteriophage MB78, a virulent phage of Salmonella typhimurium possesses restriction-modification system. Permissive host transformed with plasmid having the genomic fragment of MB78 carrying the putative restriction-modification genes severely restrict the growth of the phage 9NA. Growth of phage MB78 is also restricted to some extent. However, the temperate phage P22 is not restricted at all. Cloning of the the putative restriction-modification genes has been done in both orientations in different vectors. The clones carrying the genes in the same orientation as that of the lacZ in pUC19 are mostly unstable. However, those are stable when cloned in opposite orientation. Viability of the transformants is strain-, orientation-, and medium-dependent. The two genes have also been cloned individually/separately. Hosts carrying only the modification gene do not restrict growth of phages while the hosts carrying only the restriction gene do. The former produces stable transformants while the latter produces very unstable transformants which were viable only upto 36 h or so. The colonies carrying modification gene were normal looking while those carrying the restriction gene were tiny, flat, and looked distressed resembling very much the clones carrying bacterial restriction-modification system. Amplification of the genes and subsequent cloning in expression vector will be carried out for characterization of the enzymes.     

The minimal genome concept

Complete genome sequences are becoming available for a large number of diverse species. Quantification of gene content, of gene family expansion, of orthologous gene conservation, as well as their displacement, are now possible - laying the ground for the estimation of the minimal set of proteins sufficient for cellular life. The consensus of computational results suggests a set close to 300 genes. These predictions will be evaluated by engineering of small bacterial genomes.     

Mobility of a restriction-modification system revealed by its genetic contexts in three hosts

The flow of genes among prokaryotes plays a fundamental role in shaping bacterial evolution, and restriction-modification systems can modulate this flow. However, relatively little is known about the distribution and movement of restriction-modification systems themselves. We have isolated and characterized the genes for restriction-modification systems from two species of Salmonella, S. enterica serovar Paratyphi A and S. enterica serovar Bareilly. Both systems are closely related to the PvuII restriction-modification system and share its target specificity. In the case of S. enterica serovar Paratyphi A, the restriction endonuclease is inactive, apparently due to a mutation in the subunit interface region. Unlike the chromosomally located Salmonella systems, the PvuII system is plasmid borne. We have completed the sequence characterization of the PvuII plasmid pPvu1, originally from Proteus vulgaris, making this the first completely sequenced plasmid from the genus Proteus. Despite the pronounced similarity of the three restriction-modification systems, the flanking sequences in Proteus and Salmonella are completely different. The SptAI and SbaI genes lie between an equivalent pair of bacteriophage P4-related open reading frames, one of which is a putative integrase gene, while the PvuII genes are adjacent to a mob operon and a XerCD recombination (cer) site.     

Avoidance of DNA methylation. A virus-encoded methylase inhibitor and evidence for counterselection of methylase recognition sites in viral genomes

The ocr+ gene of bacterial virus T7 codes for the first protein recognized to inhibit a specific group of DNA methylases. The recognition sequences of several other DNA methylases, not susceptible to Ocr inhibition, are significantly suppressed in the virus genome. The bacterial virus T3 encodes an Ado-Met hydrolase, destroying the methyl donor and causing T3 DNA to be totally unmethylated. These observations could stimulate analogous investigations into the regulation of DNA methylation patterns of eukaryotic viruses and cells. For instance, an underrepresentation of methylation sites (5'-CG) is also true for animal DNA viruses. Moreover, we were able to disclose some novel properties of DNA restriction-modification enzymes concerning the protection of DNA recognition sequences in which only one strand can be methylated (e.g., type III enzyme EcoP15) and the primary resistance of (unmethylated) DNA recognition sites towards type II restriction endonuclease EcoRII.     

Discovery of a new type of restriction and modification in a group of intestinal bacteria]

The adsorption of 23 new lambdoid bacteriophages to 547 strains which isolated from natural population of Enterobacteriaceae was studied. The frequency of positive combinations of phage-bacterium with adsorption is not more than 2%. A study of possible causes of limited growth of lambdoid phages in the bacterial strains revealed that neither homoimmune prophage nor prophage P2 are single factors of the growth limitation. It is found that in natural populations a selection of bacterial strains with the least limitation of phage takes place. Three cases of killing bacteria after infection with high multiplicity are found. The reason of the killing effect is manifestation of some functions by infecting phages. A new restriction-modification system is found which differs from restriction-modification system A, B, K, 15, P1, EcoRI, EcoRII. The most of strains, which adsorb phages but do not support their growth, are supposed to possess several mechanisms of restriction. Thus, the search of new restriction system in Escherichia coli is worthwhile.     

Prokaryotic genomes: the emerging paradigm of genome-based microbiology

Comparative analysis of the complete sequences of seven bacterial and three archaeal genomes leads to the first generalizations of emerging genome-based microbiology. Protein sequences are, generally, highly conserved, with ∼70% of the gene products in bacteria and archaea containing ancient conserved regions. In contrast, there is little conservation of genome organization, except for a few essential operons. The most striking conclusions derived by comparison of multiple genomes from phylogenetically distant species are that the number of universally conserved gene families is very small and that multiple events of horizontal gene transfer and genome fusion are major forces in evolution.     

Plastid-to-nucleus signalling

The function of the eukaryotic cell depends on the reciprocal interaction between its different compartments. Plastids emit signals that regulate nuclear gene expression to ensure the stoichiometric assembly of plastid protein complexes and to initiate macromolecular reorganisation in response to environmental cues. It is now clear that several different plastid processes produce signals that influence the expression of photosynthetic genes in the nucleus. The genome uncoupled (gun) mutants recently revealed one of the plastid signals, the chlorophyll intermediate Mg-protoporphyrinIX.     

Genome DNA Sequence Variation, Evolution, and Function in Bacteria and Archaea

Comparative genomics has revealed that variations in bacterial and archaeal genome DNA sequences cannot be explained by only neutral mutations. Virus resistance and plasmid distribution systems have resulted in changes in bacterial and archaeal genome sequences during evolution. The restriction-modification system, a virus resistance system, leads to avoidance of palindromic DNA sequences in genomes. Clustered, regularly interspaced, short palindromic repeats (CRISPRs) found in genomes represent yet another virus resistance system. Comparative genomics has shown that bacteria and archaea have failed to gain any DNA with GC content higher than the GC content of their chromosomes. Thus, horizontally transferred DNA regions have lower GC content than the host chromosomal DNA does. Some nucleoid-associated proteins bind DNA regions with low GC content and inhibit the expression of genes contained in those regions. This form of gene repression is another type of virus resistance system. On the other hand, bacteria and archaea have used plasmids to gain additional genes. Virus resistance systems influence plasmid distribution. Interestingly, the restriction-modification system and nucleoid-associated protein genes have been distributed via plasmids. Thus, GC content and genomic signatures do not reflect bacterial and archaeal evolutionary relationships.     

Antirestriction activity of the IncI1 transmissive plasmid R64 ArdA protein

The transmissive plasmid IncI1 R64 contains the ardA gene encoding the ArdA antirestriction protein. The R64 ardA gene locating in the leading region of plasmid R64 has been cloned and their sequence has been determined. Antirestriction proteins belonging to the Ard family are specific inhibitors of type I restriction-modification enzymes. The IncI1 ColIb-P9 and R64 are closely related plasmids, and the latter specifies an ArdA homologue that is predicted to be 97.6% (162 residues from 166) identical at the amino acid sequence level with the ColIb = P9 equivalent. However, the R64 ArdA selectively inhibits the restriction activity of EcoKi enzyme leaving significant levels of modification activity under conditions in which restriction was almost completely prevented. The ColIb-P9 ArdA inhibits restriction endonuclease and methyltransferase activities simultaneously. It is hypothesized that the ArdA protein forms two complexes with the type I restriction-modification enzyme (R2M2S): (1) with a specific region in the S subunit involved in contact with the sK site in DNA; and (2) with nonspecific region in the R subunit involved in DNA translocation and degradation by restriction endonuclease. The association of the ColIb-P9 ArdA with the specific region inhibits restriction endonuclease and methyltransferase activities simultaneously, whereas the association of the R64 ArdA with a nonspecific region inhibits only restriction endonuclease activity of the R2M2S enzyme.     

Experimental genome evolution: large-scale genome rearrangements associated with resistance to replacement of a chromosomal restriction-modification gene complex

Type II restriction enzymes are paired with modification enzymes that protect type II restriction sites from cleavage by methylating them. A plasmid carrying a type II restriction-modification gene complex is not easily replaced by an incompatible plasmid because loss of the former leads to cell death through chromosome cleavage. In the present work, we looked to see whether a chromosomally located restriction-modification gene complex could be replaced by a homologous stretch of DNA. We tried to replace the PaeR7I gene complex on the Escherichia coli chromosome by transducing a homologous stretch of PaeR7I-modified DNA. The replacement efficiency of the restriction-modification complex was lower than expected. Some of the resulting recombinant clones retained the recipient restriction-modification gene complex as well as the homologous DNA (donor allele), and slowly lost the donor allele in the absence of selection. Analysis of their genome-wide rearrangements by Southern hybridization, inverse polymerase chain reaction (iPCR) and sequence determination demonstrated the occurrence of unequal homologous recombination between copies of the transposon IS3. It was strongly suggested that multiple rounds of unequal IS3-IS3 recombination caused large-scale duplication and inversion of the chromosome, and that only one of the duplicated copies of the recipient PaeR7I was replaced.