The post‐release process of establishing stable home ranges and diel movement patterns of hatchery‐reared black‐spot tuskfish Choerodon schoenleinii

Post‐release change of home ranges and diel movement patterns of hatchery‐reared black‐spot tuskfish Choerodon schoenleinii were examined using ultrasonic telemetry. Nine hatchery‐reared C. schoenleinii were released in Urasoko Bay, Ishigaki Island, Okinawa, Japan and monitored using ultrasonic telemetry. The fish gradually increased home ranges for c. 3 months before establishing stable home ranges. This pattern of home‐range change might have been associated with the learning process of natural environments and intraspecific and interspecific competition. The fish also showed strong diurnal movement patterns: moving horizontally and vertically during the day and staying in the same place at night. The behaviour observed in this study is highly valuable to determine when, where and how to release the fish as well as how to increase the fitness of the fish before releasing.     

Radio‐telemetry shows differences in the behaviour of wild and hatchery‐reared European grayling Thymallus thymallus in response to environmental variables

Juvenile wild and hatchery‐reared European grayling Thymallus thymallus were tagged with radio‐transmitters and tracked in the Blanice River, River Elbe catchment, Czech Republic, to study their behavioural response to stocking and environmental variation. Both wild and hatchery‐reared T. thymallus increased their diel movements and home range with increasing light intensity, flow, temperature and turbidity, but the characteristics of their responses differed. Environmental variables influenced the movement of wild T. thymallus up to a specific threshold, whereas no such threshold was observed in hatchery‐reared T. thymallus. Hatchery‐reared fish displayed greater total migration distance over the study period (total migration) than did wild fish, which was caused mainly by their dispersal in the downstream direction.     

Effects of hatchery rearing on Florida largemouth bass Micropterus floridanus resource allocation and performance under semi‐natural conditions

This study examined the growth, activity, metabolism and post‐release survival of three groups of Florida largemouth bass Micropterus floridanus: wild‐caught fish, hatchery fish reared according to standard practice (hatchery standard) and hatchery fish reared under reduced and unpredictable food provisioning (hatchery manipulated). Hatchery‐standard fish differed from wild‐caught fish in all measured variables, including survival in semi‐natural ponds. Hatchery‐standard and hatchery‐manipulated fish showed higher activity levels, faster growth and lower standard metabolic rates than wild‐caught fish in the hatchery. Fish reared under the manipulated feeding regime showed increased metabolic rates and increased post‐release growth, similar to wild‐caught fish. Their activity levels and post‐release survival, however, remained similar to those of hatchery‐standard fish. Activity was negatively correlated with post‐release survival and failure of the feed manipulation to reduce activity may have contributed to its failure to improve post‐release survival. Activity and post‐release survival may be influenced by characteristics of the rearing environment other than the feeding regime, such as stock density or water flow rates.     

Post‐release growth and dispersal of pond and hatchery‐reared European grayling Thymallus thymallus compared with their wild conspecifics in a small stream

The growth, and dispersal of stocked European grayling Thymallus thymallus, reared in a hatchery (fed dry food pellets) or in a pond (fed natural food), compared with their wild conspecifics was assessed from the recapture of individually tagged fish 168 days after their release into the Blanice River, Czech Republic. Recapture rates and site fidelity were higher for wild T. thymallus than for artificially reared fish. Specific growth rate and upstream or downstream dispersal did not significantly differ between any of the groups of fish. An influence of rearing conditions (pond v. hatchery) on the overall performance of stocked fish was not demonstrated. Initially, lower condition factors of reared T. thymallus were equal to wild fish after recapture, suggesting adaptation of artificially reared fish that remained in the sections studied.     

Maladaptation and phenotypic mismatch in hatchery‐reared Atlantic salmon Salmo salar released in the wild

Changes in body shape, fluctuating asymmetry (FA) and crypsis were compared among Atlantic salmon Salmo salar fry kept as controls in captivity and those released and subsequently recaptured in the wild according to a before‐after‐control‐impact (BACI) design. Hatchery fish that survived in the wild became more cryptic and displayed a much lower incidence of fin erosion and of asymmetric individuals than control fish kept in captivity. Significant differences in body shape were also apparent, and survivors had longer heads, thicker caudal peduncles and a more streamlined body shape than hatchery controls as early as 20 days following stocking, most likely as a result of phenotypic plasticity and non‐random, selective mortality of maladapted phenotypes. Hatchery‐reared fish typically perform poorly in the wild and the results of this study indicate that this may be due to phenotypic mismatch, i.e. because hatcheries generate fish that are phenotypically mismatched to the natural environment.     

Behavioural Interactions and Hormones in Naturally and Hatchery‐Spawned Chinook Salmon

Artificial breeding programmes commonly lead to domestication, which is associated with many behavioural differences that can reduce the success of animals released into natural environments. To better understand the factors contributing to domestication, we used a captive population of Chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) to partition hormonal and behavioural differences to effects of the breeding method and rearing environment. We compared 9‐mo‐old juveniles from three lines that shared a common genetic background: (1) the Channel line produced by natural spawning and reared in a low‐density environment with a natural substrate for approx. 6 mo before being transferred to the hatchery; (2) the Hatchery line produced by artificial spawning; and (3) the Transfer line produced by natural spawning but reared in the hatchery from the eyed‐egg stage. Plasma concentrations of 11‐ketotestosterone (11‐KT) and cortisol were measured in groups of 150 fish and again after 4 d of social interactions in groups of six fish. There was no difference in 11‐KT among lines in large groups, but in small groups, Transfer fish had lower 11‐KT concentrations and were significantly less aggressive than both Channel and Hatchery fish. Regardless of group size, concentrations of the stress hormone cortisol were nearly twofold higher in Channel fish than in Hatchery and Transfer fish. Furthermore, the elevated cortisol concentrations in Channel fish were associated with 35% lower feeding rates than in the other two lines. Our study details complex behavioural and hormonal responses to breeding method and rearing environment in juvenile salmon.     

Validation of daily increment formation in otoliths for Gymnocypris selincuoensis in the Tibetan Plateau,China

Daily increment validation in fish otolith is fundamental to studies on fish otolith microstructure, age determination and life history traits, and thus is critical for species conservation and fishery management. However, it has never been done for Schizothoracine fish, which is the dominant component of fish fauna in the Tibetan Plateau. This study validated the daily increment formation of Gymnocypris selincuoensis, as a representative of Schizothoracine fish, by monitoring the growth of hatchery‐reared larvae group and wild‐caught post‐yolk‐sac larvae group under controlled experiments. The results from monitoring the hatchery‐reared larvae group showed that sagittae and lapilli were found in yolk‐sac larvae, and formed 5–7 days before hatching, but asterisci were not found until 11 days post‐hatching. The first increment in sagittae and lapilli was formed in the first day after hatching. The daily periodicity of increment formation was examined and confirmed in sagittae and lapilli of both larvae groups. However, sagittae were better for age determination than lapilli for larvae at earlier days. For larval G. selincuoensis older than 50 days, lapilli were the only otolith pair suitable for larvae daily age determination. This study validated the daily increment formation in Schizothoracine fish for the first time has primary implications to other fishes from this subfamily.     

Updated assessment of hatchery‐reared pallid sturgeon (Forbes & Richardson, 1905) survival in the lower Missouri River

As pallid sturgeon, Scaphirhynchus albus (Forbes & Richardson, 1905), natural reproduction and recruitment remains very minimal in the lower Missouri River from Gavins Point Dam (river kilometer [rkm] 1305.2) to the confluence with the Mississippi River (rkm 0.0), hatchery supplementation and river‐wide monitoring efforts have continued. Annual survival estimates of hatchery‐reared pallid sturgeon stocked in the lower Missouri River were previously estimated during 1994–2008. Low recapture rates prior to 2006 limited the data available to estimate survival, which resulted in considerable uncertainty for the estimate of annual survival of age‐1 fish. Therefore, the objective was to provide more precise estimates of annual survival of pallid sturgeon using five additional years of stocking and sampling. The Cormack‐Jolly‐Seber model structure provided in program MARK was used to estimate the age‐specific survival estimates. Over 135 000 hatchery‐reared pallid sturgeon were released during 1994–2011 and recaptured at a rate of 1.9%, whereby estimates for the annual survival of age‐0 (Ø = 0.048) and >age‐1 (Ø = 0.931) were similar to those previously reported, but the age‐1 (Ø = 0.403) survival estimate was 52% lower. Post hoc analysis using time‐specific survival estimates indicated lower survival for age‐1 fish post‐2003 year classes, relative to the pre‐2002 year classes. An analysis confirms that hatchery‐reared pallid sturgeon continue to survive in the wild. However, low survival during the first 2 years of life is a management concern as efforts are aimed at maximizing genetic diversity and population growth. A follow‐up analysis also demonstrated the variability of capture rates and survival over time, which reinforces the need to continue to monitor and evaluate mark‐recapture data. The mark‐recapture efforts have provided demographic parameter estimates that remain a critical component for species recovery as these data are incorporated into population models.     

Impact of live food on survival and growth of hatchery‐reared sea trout (Salmo trutta trutta L.) parr in the wild

Survival rates and growth parameters of hatchery‐reared sea trout (Salmo trutta trutta L.) fry were determined after stocking in the wild. The larvae were hatchery‐reared for 12 weeks in two groups: fry were fed either on live zooplankton and live chironomidae larvae (LFG), or fed a pellet diet (PFG). The survival rate and specific growth rates were higher in the LFG than in the PFG group. Most effective for hatchery‐reared fish intended for stocking was the natural, live feed. The mean number of chironomid larvae found in the stomachs of fish that were initially captured in the wild was significantly higher in the LFG than in the PFG group. The live diet supplied in the rearing period had a positive impact on the foraging skills of the sea trout fry and their survival in the wild after their release on 24 April 2010.     

Ontogeny of the feeding apparatus of hatchery‐reared white margined sole,Dagetichthys marginatus (Soleidae): implications for cultivation

The aim of this study was to describe the ontogeny of the feeding apparatus of hatchery‐reared Dagetichthys marginatus and to discuss development in relation to generalized early development in (flat)fish and the potential influence of reproduction and/or rearing practices used. Fertilized eggs were obtained from hormone‐induced wild females of the white margined sole, D. marginatus. Subsequent larvae were reared until shortly after metamorphosis between 35 and 45 dah (days‐after‐hatching) when mortalities occurred. At 4 dah a small maxilla and two paired branchial arches appeared. Metamorphosis was completed at 22 dah while the left/migrating eye still remained in its initial position at 31 dah. Based on the likely disadvantages for survival it is assumed that the observed development indicates underdevelopment rather than an evolutionary adaptation. The influence of reproduction and rearing practices used on development and mortalities are discussed.     

Improving anti‐predator responses of hatchery reared salmonids by social learning

Predation shortly after release is the main source of mortality among hatchery‐reared fish used to restore or enhance endangered salmonid populations. We found, that hatchery‐reared salmonid young originating from endangered stocks have weak innate responses to their natural fish predators. The ability to avoid predation in fish can be improved through social learning from experienced to naïve individuals. Huge benefits would be achieved, if social learning processes could be successfully applied on a large scale to enhance viability of hatchery fish prior to release into the wild. By using model predators together with chemical cues from real predators we tested if social learning could be used to train hatchery‐reared salmonid young to avoid fish predators. As there are clear differences in social behaviour among the salmonid species, we first examined whether these differences affect the probability and efficiency of learning anti‐predator skills from trained demonstrators. We compared anti‐predator responses of observers (fish trained by using experienced fish as demonstrators) with those of control fish, which had been ‘trained’ by untrained naïve conspecifics. We also examined how the efficiency of social learning depends on the ratio of experienced to naïve fish involved in social transmission trials. The results of these experiments will give guidelines how social learning could be utilized in developing hatchery scale training protocols.     

Recapture rate and growth of hatchery‐reared brown trout (Salmo trutta v. fario,L.) in Blanice River and the effect of stocking on wild brown trout and grayling (Thymallus thymallus,L.)

Hatchery‐reared adult brown trout, Salmo trutta v. fario L., [215–335 mm standard length (L_S), n = 82] were individually tagged and released into three sections of the Blanice River in May 2007. Wild populations of brown trout and grayling, Thymallus thymallus, L., in these sections and three non‐stocked control sections were also tagged. The recapture rate of hatchery‐reared adult brown trout after 6 months (18%, n = 15) was comparable to that of wild adult brown trout in stocked (15%, n = 14) and control (14%, n = 11) sections. The recapture rates of wild brown trout and grayling after 6 months were higher in control sections than in stocked sections, but the differences were not significant. The movement of recaptured large juvenile wild brown trout from stocked sections was significantly higher (36%) than from control sections (9%). Wild brown trout growth and grayling growth were unaffected by stocking with adult hatchery‐reared brown trout.     

Effect of hatchery environment on cranial morphology and developmental stability of Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar L.) from North‐West Russia

The study addresses the effect of hatchery rearing on morphological variation and developmental stability of Atlantic salmon parr from North‐West Russia. Totally, we collected nine samples. Four wild samples were collected from each of the rivers Kola, Umba, Keret’ and Shuia. Five samples of hatchery‐reared parr were the first‐generation progeny of wild adults from these rivers reared separately at the four hatcheries (one hatchery was represented by two samples). Ten meristic and 48 morphometric cranial characters were analysed. We studied the morphological divergence between wild and hatchery fishes of the same river of origin. To analyze developmental stability we used fluctuating asymmetry (random deviations from perfect bilateral symmetry). It was found that hatchery‐reared parr significantly differ from wild parr in both meristic characters and the shape of cranial bones. Different hatcheries caused similar effect on morphological variation in all populations. Fluctuating asymmetry in morphometric characters was significantly higher in hatchery fish than in wild from the Shuia River, indicating a higher level of developmental instability. However, wild parr from the Keret’ River had significantly higher fluctuating asymmetry than cultivated parr of the same origin, possible due to a high infection pressure of the parasite Gyrodactylus salaris Malmberg which has led to significant decline of the wild salmon population in this river, or from genetic changes caused by cultivation. The obtained results indicate a notable effect of hatchery environment on Atlantic salmon’s phenotype.     

Population characteristics of pallid sturgeon (Scaphirhynchus albus (Forbes & Richardson, )) in the Lower Missouri River

Population characteristics of pallid sturgeon Scaphirhynchus albus in the lower Missouri River are relatively unknown. Therefore, data collected from the Nebraska Game and Parks Commission Pallid Sturgeon Population Assessment Program was synthesized to (i) document the population structure of pallid sturgeon by origin (hatchery‐reared or wild), gender, and reproductive readiness, (ii) document the minimum size and age‐at‐maturity by gender, and (iii) document the fecundity rates of the fish that were successfully spawned in the hatchery. During this 4‐year study (2008–2011), relative abundance for wild and hatchery‐reared pallid sturgeon collected with gill nets did not significantly change whereas relative abundance for wild fish using trot lines declined significantly. The proportion of hatchery‐reared pallid sturgeon increased annually, with the population being composed primarily of hatchery‐reared fish. The proportion of reproductively ready females to non‐reproductively ready females was 1 : 2.0, compared to male ratios at 1 : 0.9. Minimum fork length‐at‐maturity was estimated for females at 788 mm and for males at 798 mm. Minimum age‐at‐maturity for hatchery‐reared released fish was age‐9 for females and age‐7 for males. Highest relative fecundity, based on the ovosomatic index, was 10% with an overall mean of 7%. The number of eggs per ml (egg size) was not correlated with fork length (P = 0.0615) or weight (P = 0.0957). Relative condition factor (Kn) for females was significantly different by reproductive condition (P = 0.0014) and Kn for males did not differ between reproductive conditions (P = 0.2634). Detecting shifts in population characteristics are essential not only to understand population dynamics since hatchery inputs and natural perturbations continue to change the population structure but also to assess species recovery efforts to ensure long‐term species sustainability.     

Daily age estimation reveals rapid growth of age‐0 alligator gar in the wild

We estimated the daily age and growth of wild age‐0 alligator gar (Atractosteus spatula) from Choke Canyon Reservoir and the Guadalupe and Trinity rivers, Texas, USA. Growth rates of wild age‐0 alligator gar were compared across systems, as well as to alligator gar reared in a Texas hatchery. Estimated ages of alligator gar ranged from 7 to 80 days in Choke Canyon Reservoir (n = 140), 11–73 days in the Guadalupe River (n = 16), and 4–115 days in the Trinity River samples (n = 245). Alligator gar growth was faster in the Trinity and Guadalupe rivers than growth in Choke Canyon Reservoir. Growth of alligator gar in Choke Canyon Reservoir (3.60 ± 0.08 mm/day), the Guadalupe River (4.76 ± 0.35 mm/day), and the Trinity River (5.13 ± 0.07 mm/day) was faster than growth of hatchery reared fish (3.41 ± 0.08 mm/day). This study represents the first account of early growth of age‐0 alligator gar in the wild, and documents some of the fastest growth of age‐0 fish among freshwater fishes. We attribute the rapid growth of wild alligator gar to their quick transition to piscivory at early stages, and their effective use of habitat and resources on inundated floodplains during flood pulses. Future studies should explore the effects of environmental factors on the hatching success, growth, and survival of age‐0 alligator gar.     

Passing a seawater challenge test is not indicative of hatchery‐reared Atlantic salmon Salmo salar smolts performing as well at sea as their naturally produced conspecifics

Despite satisfactory reactions to seawater challenge tests indicative of appropriate physiological state, hatchery‐reared Atlantic salmon Salmo salar smolts stocked in the Eira River in Norway between 2001 and 2011 performed less well at sea in terms of growth, age at maturity and survival than smolts of natural origin. The mean rates of return to the river for hatchery‐reared and naturally produced S. salar were 0·98 and 2·35%. In the Eira River, c. 50 000 hatchery‐reared S. salar smolts of local origin were stocked annually to compensate for reduced natural smolt production following regulation for hydroelectric purposes, while a mean of 17 262 smolts were produced naturally in the river. This study demonstrates that, although captive S. salar perform well in seawater challenge tests, hatchery‐reared smolts are not necessarily as adaptable to marine life as their naturally produced counterparts. These findings suggest that production of hatchery‐reared smolts more similar to naturally produced individuals in morphology, physiology and behaviour will be necessary to improve success of hatchery releases. Where possible, supplementary or alternative measures, including habitat restoration, could be implemented to ensure the long‐term viability of wild stocks.     

The role of social learning in conservation and fisheries reintroductions

The plight of the world fish stocks is all too well documented. As part of an ongoing attempt to bolster fish stocks for both commercial and conservation purposes, many fish are reared in captivity and released into the wild. It is well known that hatchery‐reared fish have low post‐release survival compared with wild fish of similar age. Part of the reason for this high mortality is that hatchery fish show deficits in virtually all aspects of their behaviour, including prey selection and predator avoidance. Much behaviour requires repeated experience so that it may become fine‐tuned to prevailing circumstances via learning during development. It has been suggested that inappropriate behaviour is encouraged when fish are reared in the unnatural surroundings of the hatchery. However, hatchery fish can be taught to recognise live, novel prey items and predators and the rate of learning is increased in the presence of a more knowledgeable conspecifics. Here we present data showing how social learning protocols can be used to dramatically increase foraging success in juvenile Atlantic salmon. We also outline related aspects of our ongoing research and discuss some of the possibilities for altering hatchery practices to maximize post‐release survival.     

Development of natural growth regimes for hatchery-reared steelhead to reduce residualism, fitness loss, and negative ecological interactions

Wild steelhead (Oncorhynchus mykiss) typically spend two or more years in freshwater before migrating to sea, but hatchery steelhead are almost ubiquitously released as yearlings. Their large size at release coupled with life history pathways that include both male and female maturation in freshwater present ecological risks different from those posed by hatchery populations of Pacific salmon. Yearling hatchery reared steelhead that fail to attain minimum thresholds for smoltification or exceed thresholds for male maturation tend to ‘residualize’ (i.e., remain in freshwater). Residuals pose ecological risks including size-biased interference competition and predation on juvenile salmon and trout. Three hatchery populations of steelhead in Hood Canal, WA were reared under growth regimes designed to produce a more natural age at smoltification (age-2) to aid in rebuilding their respective natural populations. Mean smolt sizes and size variability at age-2 were within the range of wild smolts for two of the three populations. The third population reared at a different facility under similar temperatures exhibited high growth rate variability and high male maturation rates (20% of all released fish). Experimentally comparing age-1 and age-2 smolt programs will help identify optimal rearing strategies to reduce the genetic risk of domestication selection and reduce residualism rates and associated negative ecological effects on natural populations. Investigations of Winthrop National Fish Hatchery summer-run steelhead will measure a) selection on correlated behavioral traits (‘behavioral syndromes’), b) degree of smoltification, c) changes in hormones that regulate gonad growth at key developmental stages, and d) conduct extensive post-release monitoring of fish reared under each growth regime.     

Maternal effects in vulnerability to eye‐parasites and correlations between behavior and parasitism in juvenile Arctic charr

Hatchery‐reared fish show high mortalities after release to the wild environment. Explanations for this include potentially predetermined genetics, behavioral, and physiological acclimation to fish farm environments, and increased vulnerability to predation and parasitism in the wild. We studied vulnerability to Diplostomum spp. parasites (load of eye flukes in the lenses), immune defense (relative spleen size) and antipredator behaviors (approaches toward predator odor, freezing, and swimming activity) in hatchery‐reared juvenile Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus) using a nested mating design. Fish were exposed to eye‐fluke larvae via the incoming water at the hatchery. Fish size was positively associated with parasite load, but we did not find any relationship between relative spleen size and parasitism. The offspring of different females showed significant variation in their parasite load within sires, implying a dam effect in the vulnerability to parasites. However, the family background did not have any effect on spleen size. In the mean sire level over dams, the fish from the bolder (actively swimming) families in the predator trials suffered higher loads of eye flukes than those from more cautiously behaving families. Thus, the results indicate potentially maternally inherited differences in vulnerability to eye‐fluke parasites, and that the vulnerability to parasites and behavioral activity are positively associated with each other at the sire level. This could lead to artificial and unintentional selection for increased vulnerability to both parasitism and predation if these traits are favored in fish farm environments.     

Supportive breeding boosts natural population abundance with minimal negative impacts on fitness of a wild population of Chinook salmon

While supportive breeding programmes strive to minimize negative genetic impacts to populations, case studies have found evidence for reduced fitness of artificially produced individuals when they reproduce in the wild. Pedigrees of two complete generations were tracked with molecular markers to investigate differences in reproductive success (RS) of wild and hatchery‐reared Chinook salmon spawning in the natural environment to address questions regarding the demographic and genetic impacts of supplementation to a natural population. Results show a demographic boost to the population from supplementation. On average, fish taken into the hatchery produced 4.7 times more adult offspring, and 1.3 times more adult grand‐offspring than naturally reproducing fish. Of the wild and hatchery fish that successfully reproduced, we found no significant differences in RS between any comparisons, but hatchery‐reared males typically had lower RS values than wild males. Mean relative reproductive success (RRS) for hatchery F₁ females and males was 1.11 (P = 0.84) and 0.89 (P = 0.56), respectively. RRS of hatchery‐reared fish (H) that mated in the wild with either hatchery or wild‐origin (W) fish was generally equivalent to W × W matings. Mean RRS of H × W and H × H matings was 1.07 (P = 0.92) and 0.94 (P = 0.95), respectively. We conclude that fish chosen for hatchery rearing did not have a detectable negative impact on the fitness of wild fish by mating with them for a single generation. Results suggest that supplementation following similar management practices (e.g. 100% local, wild‐origin brood stock) can successfully boost population size with minimal impacts on the fitness of salmon in the wild.