Modeling the repair of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks

A problem often overlooked in the study of the repair of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breads (DSBs) is the question of what the status of a regular site is in the DNA duplex immediately after a radiation treatment. Here, we suggest a mixed repair mechanism which consists of a gradual process and an instantaneous process. A comparison of the present kinetic model with those which have appeared in the literature shows that the former is a generalization of the latter. We have shown that different repair mechanisms may lead to equivalent mathematical representations. Therefore, care must be taken in interpreting the repair mechanism on the basis of the experimentally observed transient number of DSBs.     

A kinetic analysis of the repair of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks

The repair of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) is analyzed kinetically. It is assumed that a fraction of the damaged sites in the DNA duplex are irreparable. The kinetic model takes the effect of radiation dose into account. The analysis of the available experimental data reveals that, although the number of irreparable DSBs is a quadratic function of radiation dose, the normalized number of irreparable DSBs correlates linearly with this variable.     

A stochastic analysis of the repair of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks

A three-state stochastic model is described for the repair of radiation-induced double-strand breaks (DSBs) in DNA. If irradiated, a site or region in DNA is assumed to be in a potentially damaged state; this site may either become permanently damaged or be repaired after a certain period of time. The result of the analysis of the available experimental data reveals that the present two-parameter model is capable of interpreting the rapid decrease in the number of DSBs in the initial period, which cannot be predicted by previously proposed models. The stochastic analysis yields not only the temporal variation of the mean of the number of DSBs but also its variance, and therefore is a generalization of the conventional deterministic models.     

Decreased repair of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks with cellular differentiation.

Although the majority of mammalian cells in situ are terminally differentiated, most DNA repair studies have used proliferating cells. In an attempt to understand better the relationship between differentiation and DNA repair, we have used the murine 3T3-T proadipocyte cell line. In this model system, proliferating (stem) cells undergo growth arrest (GD cells) and subsequently terminally differentiate into adipocytes when exposed to media containing platelet-depleted human plasma. Pulsed-field gel electrophoresis was used to evaluate the induction and repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) after ionizing radiation. The levels of radiation-induced DSBs in GD and terminally differentiated cells were similar, but in both cases greater than those found in stem cells at each radiation dose tested (0 to 40 Gy); these differences appear to be due to growth arrest in G1 phase. DNA DSBs were repaired with biphasic kinetics for each cell type. For terminally differentiated cells 25% of DNA DSBs remained unrejoined compared with < 10% for GD and stem cells after a repair time of 4 h. These data indicate that terminal differentiation of 3T3-T cells is associated with a reduction in the repair of ionizing radiation-induced DNA DSBs.     

Measurement of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks by pulsed-field gel electrophoresis

We have examined the use of pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) to measure DNA double-strand breaks induced in CHO cells by ionizing radiation. The PFGE assay provides a simple method for the measurement of DNA double-strand breaks for doses as low as 3-4 Gy ionizing radiation, and appears applicable for the measurement of damage produced by any agent producing double-strand breaks. The conditions of transverse alternating field electrophoresis determined both the sensitivity of the assay and the ability to resolve DNA fragments with different sizes. For example, with 0.8% agarose and a 1-min pulse time at 250 V for 18 h of electrophoresis, 0.39% of the DNA per gray migrated into the gel, and only molecules less than 1500 kb could be resolved. With 0.56% agarose and a 60-min pulse time at 40 V for 6 days of electrophoresis, 0.55-0.90% of the DNA per gray migrated into the gel, and molecules between 1500 and 7000 kb could be resolved.     

Cohesin promotes the repair of ionizing radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks in replicated chromatin

The cohesin protein complex holds sister chromatids together after synthesis until mitosis. It also contributes to post-replicative DNA repair in yeast and higher eukaryotes and accumulates at sites of laser-induced damage in human cells. Our goal was to determine whether the cohesin subunits SMC1 and Rad21 contribute to DNA double-strand break repair in X-irradiated human cells in the G2 phase of the cell cycle. RNA interference-mediated depletion of SMC1 sensitized HeLa cells to X-rays. Repair of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks, measured by γH2AX/53BP1 foci analysis, was slower in SMC1- or Rad21-depleted cells than in controls in G2 but not in G1. Inhibition of the DNA damage kinase DNA-PK, but not ATM, further inhibited foci loss in cohesin-depleted cells in G2. SMC1 depletion had no effect on DNA single-strand break repair in either G1 or late S/G2. Rad21 and SMC1 were recruited to sites of X-ray-induced DNA damage in G2-phase cells, but not in G1, and only when DNA damage was concentrated in subnuclear stripes, generated by partially shielded ultrasoft X-rays. Our results suggest that the cohesin complex contributes to cell survival by promoting the repair of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks in G2-phase cells in an ATM-dependent pathway.     

RNA-directed repair of DNA double-strand breaks

DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) are among the most deleterious DNA lesions, which if unrepaired or repaired incorrectly can cause cell death or genome instability that may lead to cancer. To counteract these adverse consequences, eukaryotes have evolved a highly orchestrated mechanism to repair DSBs, namely DNA-damage-response (DDR). DDR, as defined specifically in relation to DSBs, consists of multi-layered regulatory modes including DNA damage sensors, transducers and effectors, through which DSBs are sensed and then repaired via DNAprotein interactions. Unexpectedly, recent studies have revealed a direct role of RNA in the repair of DSBs, including DSB-induced small RNA (diRNA)-directed and RNA-templated DNA repair. Here, we summarize the recent discoveries of RNA-mediated regulation of DSB repair and discuss the potential impact of these novel RNA components of the DSB repair pathway on genomic stability and plasticity.     

Induction and repair of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks in human fibroblasts are not affected by terminal differentiation

It was studied for human skin fibroblasts, whether the induction or repair of DNA double-strand breaks (dsb) depend on the differentiation status. These studies were performed (a) with a fibroblast strain (HSF1) kept in progenitor state (mitotic fibroblasts, MF) or triggered to premature terminal differentiation (postmitotic fibrocytes, PMF) by exposure to mitomycin C or (b) with 20 fibroblast strains differing intrinsically in their differentiation status. The differentiation status was quantified by determining the fraction of postmitotic fibrocytes by light microscopy. DNA dsb were measured by constant-field gel electrophoresis, and the fraction of apoptotic cells by comet assay. MF and PMF cultures of HSF1 cells were irradiated with X-ray doses up to 160 Gy, and dsb were measured either immediately after irradiation or after a repair incubation of 4 or 24 h. There were a difference neither in the number of initial nor residual dsb. PMF cultures, however, showed a slightly higher number of dsb already present in non-irradiated cells, which was measured to result from a small fraction of 5% apoptotic cells. The 20 analysed fibroblast strains showed a substantial variation in the fraction of postmitotic fibrocytes (9-51%) as well as in the number of dsb remaining at 24 h after irradiation (1.9-4.9%), but there was no correlation between these two parameters. These data demonstrate that for fibroblasts the terminal differentiation has an effect neither on the induction nor the repair of radiation-induced dsb. This result indicates that the variation in dsb-repair capacity previously observed for fibroblast strains and which was considered to be the main cause for the variation in the cellular radiosensitivity, cannot be ascribed to differences in the differentiation status.     

Chromatin remodeling and repair of DNA double-strand breaks

Eukaryotic cells have developed conserved mechanisms to efficiently sense and repair DNA damage that results from constant chromosomal lesions. DNA repair has to proceed in the context of chromatin, and both histone-modifiers and ATP-dependent chromatin remodelers have been implicated in this process. Here, we review the current understanding and new hypotheses on how different chromatin-modifying activities function in DNA repair in yeast and metazoan cells.     

DNA双链断裂修复与重症联合免疫缺陷

DNA双链断裂(double-strand breaks, DSBs)是细胞DNA损伤的主要类型,它的修复通过同源重组(HR)和非同源末端连接(NHEJ)两种机制实现.NHEJ是人和哺乳动物细胞DSBs修复的重要通路,主要由DNA依赖性蛋白激酶(DNA-PK)、X射线修复交叉互补蛋白4(XRCC4)、DNA连接酶Ⅳ、Artemis、XLF/Cernunnos和其它DNA损伤修复辅助因子组成.本文重点介绍了NHEJ机制主要成分的特性及其功能,以及这些组分的基因发生突变或缺失所引起的DSBs修复缺陷与辐射敏感性重症联合免疫缺陷(radiosensitive severe combined immunodeficiencies, RS-SCIDs).     

A model for repair of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks in the extreme radiophile Deinococcus radiodurans

The bacterium Deinococcus (formerly Micrococcus) radiodurans and other members of the eubacterial family Deinococaceae are extremely resistant to ionizing radiation and many other agents that damage DNA. Stationary phase D. radiodurans exposed to 1.0-1.5 Mrad γ-irradiation sustains >120 DNA double-strand breaks (dsbs) per chromosome; these dsbs are mended over a period of hours with 100% survival and virtually no mutagenesis. This contrasts with nearly all other organisms in which just a few ionizing radiation induced-dsbs per chromosome are lethal. In this article we present an hypothesis that resistance of D. radiodurans to ionizing radiation and its ability to mend radiation-induced dsbs are due to a special form of redundancy wherein chromosomes exist in pairs, linked to each other by thousands of four-stranded (Holliday) junctions. Thus, a dsb is not a lethal event because the identical undamaged duplex is nearby, providing an accurate repair template. As addressed in this article, much of what is known about D. radiodurans suggests that it is particularly suited for this proposed novel form of DNA repair.     

Repair of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks is dependent upon radiation quality and the structural complexity of double-strand breaks

Mammalian cells primarily repair DSBs by nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ). To assess the ability of human cells to mediate end joining of complex DSBs such as those produced by chemicals, oxidative events, or high- and low-LET radiation, we employed an in vitro double-strand break repair assay using plasmid DNA linearized by these various agents. We found that human HeLa cell extracts support end joining of complex DSBs and form multimeric plasmid products from substrates produced by the radiomimetic drug bleomycin, 60Co gamma rays, and the effects of 125I decay in DNA. End joining was found to be dependent on the type of DSB-damaging agent, and it decreased as the cytotoxicity of the DSB-inducing agent increased. In addition to the inhibitory effects of DSB end-group structures on repair, NHEJ was found to be strongly inhibited by lesions proximal to DSB ends. The initial repair rate for complex non-ligatable bleomycin-induced DSBs was sixfold less than that of similarly configured (blunt-ended) but less complex (ligatable) restriction enzyme-induced DSBs. Repair of DSBs produced by gamma rays was 15-fold less efficient than repair of restriction enzyme-induced DSBs. Repair of the DSBs produced by 125I was near the lower limit of detection in our assay and was at least twofold lower than that of gamma-ray-induced DSBs. In addition, DSB ends produced by 125I were shown to be blocked by 3'-nucleotide fragments: the removal of these by E. coli endonuclease IV permitted ligation.     

Mathematical models of the generation of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks

The double-strand break (dsb) is one of the most critical lesions leading to a variety of radiobiological effects. In this paper, we reconsider the previously constructed and generally accepted mathematical models for dsb generation, and give a concrete mathematical basis for the generation of dsbs and the calculation of the number of induced dsbs, under the assumption of randomness in the break location in DNA and in the number of breaks. Using these models based on the Poisson distribution and the binomial distribution, we calculate the dose dependence of dsb generation. We deduced from our models that the dose dependence of the number of dsbs is described approximately as a quadratic form in both distribution models where dsb generation is accounted for by two ssbs. Previously reported experimental data on the dsb generation in phage DNA was found to be in good agreement with our models. Though the widely used model, the linear quadratic (LQ) model or the molecular theory of dsb formation based on the Poisson distribution, also gives the quadratic term, in spite of rough estimates or some mathematical incompleteness, a marked feature of our formulation is the absence of a parameter like the $\beta $ in the quadratic term that requires experimental data to determine. Thus in this study we provide mathematical validity to the generally accepted models of the number of dsb.     

Efficient rejoining of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks in centromeric DNA of human cells

Although major efforts in elucidating different DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair pathways and their contribution to accurate repair or misrepair have been made, little is known about the influence of chromatin structure on the fidelity of DSB repair. Here, the repair of ionizing radiation-induced DSBs was investigated in heterochromatic centromeric regions of human cells in comparison with other genomic locations. A hybridization assay was applied that allows the quantification of correct DSB rejoining events in specific genomic regions by measuring reconstitution of large restriction fragments. We show for two primary fibroblast lines (MRC-5 and 180BR) and an epithelial tumor cell line that restriction fragment reconstitution is considerably more efficient in the centromere than in average genomic locations. Importantly, however, DNA ligase IV-deficient 180BR cells show, compared with repair-proficient MRC-5 cells, impaired restriction fragment reconstitution both in average DNA and in the centromere. Thus, the efficient repair of DSBs in centromeric DNA is dependent on functional non-homologous end joining. It is proposed that the condensed chromatin state in the centromere limits the mobility of break ends and leads to enhanced restriction fragment reconstitution by increasing the probability for rejoining correct break ends.     

Proteasome involvement in the repair of DNA double-strand breaks

Affinity purification of the yeast 19S proteasome revealed the presence of Sem1 as a subunit. Its human homolog, DSS1, was found likewise to copurify with the human 19S proteasome. DSS1 is known to associate with the tumor suppressor protein BRCA2 involved in repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). We demonstrate that Sem1 is required for efficient repair of an HO-generated yeast DSB using both homologous recombination (HR) and nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) pathways. Deletion of SEM1 or genes encoding other nonessential 19S or 20S proteasome subunits also results in synthetic growth defects and hypersensitivity to genotoxins when combined with mutations in well-established DNA DSB repair genes. Chromatin immunoprecipitation showed that Sem1 is recruited along with the 19S and 20S proteasomes to a DSB in vivo, and this recruitment is dependent on components of both the HR and NHEJ repair pathways, suggesting a direct role of the proteasome in DSB repair.     

Analysis of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks misrepair is not compromized by broken DNA in human fibroblasts

It has been suggested that the technique for measuring repair fidelity of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) using Southern blotting and hybridization to defined regions of the genome could be compromised by broken or poorly-digested DNA. Since misrepair of DNA DSBs is an important aspect of radiation-induced chromosome aberrations, mutations, and cell killing, we checked for such a supposition in non-transformed human fibroblasts. DSB misrepair was assessed in a NotI-cleavable DNA fragment of 3.2 Mbp located on the long arm of chromosome 21 and detected by D21S1 probe. We hypothesized that the suggested DNA degradation, whether spurious in nature or the results of irradiation-induced phenomena such as apoptosis and/or necrosis, should be detectable with or without NotI restriction enzyme treatment. When the DNA embedded in agarose plugs was separated by electrophoresis without prior NotI restriction, no significant difference was observed in the relative amount of migrating DNA between the control (no irradiation) and 24 h of repair following 80 Gy irradiation. Furthermore, only about 10% of the total signal was located below the 3.2 Mbp band. This suggests that the amount of DNA fragmentation due to biological (apoptosis or necrosis) or technical processes was negligible. The Tunel assay supported these results, as there was little to no apoptosis detectable in these fibroblasts up to 24 h after irradiation. We conclude that in primary human fibroblasts, the NotI method for measuring radiation-induced misrepair is not compromised by DNA degradation.     

Enhancement of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks and micronuclei in human colon carcinoma cells by N-methylformamide

The differentiation-inducing agent N-methylformamide (NMF) enhances the sensitivity of some cell lines to ionizing radiation. To elucidate the mechanism of NMF-mediated radiosensitization, we examined the effects of this agent on gamma-ray-induced DNA double-strand breaks and micronuclei in two cell lines, clone A (human colon carcinoma) and HCA-1 (murine hepatocarcinoma). Both cell lines form a better differentiated phenotype upon exposure to NMF, yet only clone A is radiosensitized. The neutral (pH 9.6) elution assay was used to evaluate the effects of this maturational agent on radiation-induced double-strand breaks in these cell lines. Exposure of HCA-1 cells to NMF had no effect on the level of DNA double-strand breaks induced by gamma rays. In clone A cells, however, exposure to NMF enhanced the initial formation of gamma-ray-induced double-strand breaks at each dose tested. The repair of double-strand breaks in both cell lines was not influenced by NMF. As a measure of chromosome fragmentation after irradiation, we evaluated micronuclei using the cytokinesis block method. Exposure to NMF had no effect on radiation-induced micronuclei formation in HCA-1 cells yet significantly enhanced the frequency of micronuclei induced by radiation in clone A cells. In clone A cells, the increases in radiation-induced double-strand breaks and micronuclei as a function of NMF exposure time reached maximums by approximately 72 h. These data suggest that NMF-mediated radiosensitization is the result of an increase in the initial level of radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks.     

Recombinational repair of radiation-induced double-strand breaks occurs in the absence of extensive resection

Recombinational repair provides accurate chromosomal restitution after double-strand break (DSB) induction. While all DSB recombination repair models include 5′-3′ resection, there are no studies that directly assess the resection needed for repair between sister chromatids in G-2 arrested cells of random, radiation-induced ‘dirty’ DSBs. Using our Pulse Field Gel Electrophoresis-shift approach, we determined resection at IR-DSBs in WT and mutants lacking exonuclease1 or Sgs1 helicase. Lack of either reduced resection length by half, without decreased DSB repair or survival. In the exo1Δ sgs1Δ double mutant, resection was barely detectable, yet it only took an additional hour to achieve a level of repair comparable to WT and there was only a 2-fold dose-modifying effect on survival. Results with a Dnl4 deletion strain showed that remaining repair was not due to endjoining. Thus, similar to what has been shown for a single, clean HO-induced DSB, a severe reduction in resection tract length has only a modest effect on repair of multiple, dirty DSBs in G2-arrested cells. Significantly, this study provides the first opportunity to directly relate resection length at DSBs to the capability for global recombination repair between sister chromatids.